The girls are clearly not 'dumb' to see that they are being isolated and the future of their careers are at a risk at hybe rn, so i think their concerns are totally valid. I mean most of the higher ups of ADOR are being replaced with belift staff and bsh's henchmen (a woman too ig) who have clearly shown they don't have the best interests of the girls in mind (ref to that horrific disaster of belift's 27 min video) . Obviously i don't like mhj, and i do find it sad that the girls seem very reliant on her when she is an egotistical manic at best. HOWEVER considering how the girls have literally been with her since 2021 at the earliest when they were in fact ALL minors, what can you really expect? They are obviously going to stand with the person who seems to be most concerned about 'you' and your career even if that concern is not actually coming from a place of true sincerity. Anyways i'll always stand with the girls as i have a fully developed brain and can understand that they are the victims here, not 'evil minions' not 'bratty' not 'devils' just young girls who have been failed by the adults around them.
Why would HR pursue a complaint that can’t be backed by evidence? It would be insane to do this. They checked CC TV. NJ acted with extreme disrespect in the way they spoke to and about the new CEO. Definitely not a good look.
Am i crazy for thinking that its..not that bad? Like they look like they actually got the vision, the execution is just not quite there yet. I wish they would fully commit to the rich kids vibe they are going for and make the mv very edgy and crazy. Also love their vocal tones SO PLEASE LET THESE GIRLS SING
This is a very bad decision. They've been failed by the adults around them. This is why kids need to be properly educated and socialized. So sad. The real world isn't what they think it's like and their parents should've guided them better.
NGL, but yeah I am attracted to pretty girls, and a big part of what girl groups I follow most is partly due to how cute they are. I also know not every group can be on the level of Red Velvet vocally, so as long as they can carry a tune I'm OK as long as the songs are good. What I can't stand is lazy songwriting - bland average beats, formulaic lyrics, and generic choruses, or just repeating the same nonsense over and over. I also can't stand people bragging about how much money they have or how badass they are, especially if they are a rookie group. I had not heard of the group prior to seeing the member teasers which were pretty good, and yeah Ella is super hot so of course I was interested. I think when I saw the teaser with bigfoot I had a bad feeling that it was going to be cheesy. It was even worse than I had feared. I feel no need to ever hear it again,
It’s also there FIRST TIME in this industry, with how these companies isolate them I don’t blame them or shame them for still trusting and respecting Min Heejin. I feel like they take their relationship with her like a parent. At times we hated or hate our parents because we overheard them talking shit about you to another family member. Sometimes some of the closest people we love we also share a hate for something they do or say, they wouldn’t be here without her and they feel they owe their unwavering loyalty to her so maybe I’m clueless but why are people hating them for expressing their opinions. They knew what they were risking by speaking up so I support them speaking their mind.
The thing is the girls will keep feeling mistreated no matter what because MHJ is not coming back. In reality Min can’t plan a company take down for literal years and cause massive hate trains against other idols in the company and get rewarded by getting back her CEO position. But sadly the girls and kpop Stan’s don’t understand that. The NJ members are always gonna hate anyone who went against their “mother”. I mean Min has proved she is not mentally stable or mature enough for that kind of power. And those poor girls are gonna crawl through broken glass for a woman that’s shaman could have told her she sees the devil in them and then Min would have cut them from the group for it. It’s actually crazy and sad. I want the girls to be happy but Min has done so much damage she just can’t come back.
Just because NewJeans is capable of making their own decisions doesn’t mean MHJ and HYBE allow them to do so. They learned about MHJ stepping down as CEO from a news report like I highly doubt that any of the girls are taking part in whatever decision making is going on.
Be careful who watches your children (though the parents probably are more in it for the money). The channel and live stream they did was an easy move to get their contract terminated. There is a good chance MHJ has skewed the members' reality. I hope the member's will see that. If for some unimaginable reason MHJ is CEO again (assuming obviously with less power) I hope those who know her toxicity keep record with it and all MHJ's actions is transparently given to the girls so they can truly see MHJ decisions so they can make a better judgment for themselves. I am sure there are people in Adore who know the true factors and are too afraid to say anything based on the power of MHJ and probably culture. The girls' are just her chess pieces for her to get her way. SM dodged a bullet with her. She is clearly too messy to deal with. It is better for her to start her own company, but I bet she lacks the capability to handle it. She is probably very controlling and has an unhealthy narcissistic obsession of recognition whether it was her doing or not. The other sad part is that HYBE is also probably just as bad, but I would take a crappy company that I could leave than stay with an individual like MHJ because it most likely entered their personal life as well.
at the end of the day, NJ are responsible and only NJ are responsible for own careers. HYBE does not care nor should it, NJ is cog in the HYBE money making machine. If the cog is broken, you try to fix it (remove MHJ) and if it is still broken, throw it out and replace with a new cog. At this point it does not matter if the are the victims or the architect of this whole mess, they must live with the consequences of their actions
illit is the new cog and it feels kind of weird how they are trying to make illit seem like natural friends how newjeans members are with each other when it just feels so forced imo.
saw a tiktok from a korean women who makes this a feminist movement like i get it MHJ is impressive! she's able to climb up the corporate world full of men! in korea! but you cannot be serious supporting NJ's demand. MHJ is a women yes BUT with a criminal record! wait until NJ isn't desirable or young enough for MHJ i don't think that woman would bother protecting her creations anymore
Tell me one K-pop group that isn’t groomed by their agency. Kids literally start training at the age of 10 in South Korea. I don’t know why you are blind to the HYBE media manipulation. The whole situation seems to me like an outsider telling a fully grown child that everything their parents tell them is a lie and that they have been groomed. We can only hope to know half of the things these idols go through. Now, an idol group is voicing their thoughts and opinions on what’s been going on. Instead of giving them a listening ear and hearing what they actually have to say, people are out here saying they are sabotaging their careers and that they are groomed. You all advocate for speaking up, yet when they speak, you don’t listen. If you listened to this live stream at all, the very first thing they said was that no one was aware of it. And lastly, if you think the kids are too young to understand, what about their parents? Do you really think they don’t know what’s going on? Do you think any parent will leave their minors in the hands of someone who doesn’t want the best for them? Or would you say the parents are groomed by MHJ as well? I’m sorry, you all have been played and manipulated by HYBE so badly it’s clouding your judgments.
The toxic fandom BUNNIES are also to blame. NJ members were brainwashed and led to believe they are NOTHING without MHJ, and idols without confidence and positive attitude=trash.
How I see the whole situation Twenty one was a cool group that is why they got popular Then yg decided to get a new girl group after twenty one, hoping for same succes Blackpink got even popular After they kinda separated Yg kinda saw how there was one popular girl group and than another so dicided to pop in another one for them to get popular too But babymonster didn't get that popular Yg panics and makes a new girl group But that flops again
bye at this point i just feel hella sorry for everything they went through I'm not a fan I'm a casual listener and i check the news sometimes but this one. bruh. that's messy.
Well for me I Don’t they went live secretly without anyone knowing and demanding their old ceo back they been manipulated by mhj groomed and Used they basically destroyed their career that’s not how company works you don’t demand to get what you want they just entitled brats
Imagine yourself being accused of bullying someone because your brother, sister, bestie, friends, or anyone related to you in some way didn't say hello or didn't show them respect the way they see fit, and everyone is applauding the accuser for "standing up" against you for bullying them when they themselves misinterpreted the situations more often than not. For them to address the new CEO in such a disrespectful manner and for them to make absurd and childish demands should tell you a lot about their attitudes, and perhaps they are being shunned at work is because of their bad attitudes. Why would HYPE mistreat their artists when their artists are the source of their financial gain? Not to mention they investing so much $$$$ into training, marketing, travel expenses, paying people as their managers? People need to remember there are always two sides to a story.
People scream about treating idols like humans, then harass some girls for experiencing real-life human struggles. The girls have not had a responsible adult to look after them since the beginning of their careers when they were all minors, and even if they weren't, adults can still be manipulated and tricked. These girls were put in the middle of a fight they shouldn't be in at all by both the woman who claims she "cares about them" and a greedy, soulless company. I just hope this ends with them getting the REAL help they need, MHJ blacklisted from the industry, and HYBE ending once and for all, of course, not leaving their artists without careers, but their greed and hunger to take over kpop needs to be stopped
MHJ kept dragging NewJeans into the drama on every media platform. Now.... the group will learn what breech of contract means. Companies replace CEO all the time (look at all the american music companies) New management is typical business. Without HYPE, these girls would have never been known internationally.
Where is the orientation from the parents? Maaaan. My mom would love smack me right upside my head 😂if I were weirdly idolizing another adult this way.
Now they’re doing too much What an act?? They want everything name, fame, dorms, luxury given by company but don't want company. that's not gonna work girls. Either leave hybe and pay penalty or leave with min hee jin. There's no other choice They know actually everyone know that without HYBE & BTS they will never ever be this far Stop acting like this such a drama queens If you don't like HYBE then leave It is high time to Disband Bye bye New Jeans No more drama that's all we want
Somebody sayd something that really put things is perspective. NJs says in the live they found out about MHJ not being the CEO anymore through an article which really hurt them because the company didn't say it directly to them first. The thing is miss girly MHJ knew she'd lost her position and didn't bother to tell the girls she sees as her own children?! The women knew this would hurt the girls, you can't convince me she didn't want them to be angry and hurt about this
어처구니 없는 댓글들이 많아 한마디 남깁니다 민희진과 뉴진스의 관계는 여러분이 알고 계시는 것과 완전히 다릅니다 민희진씨가 뉴진스 멤버들의 엄마로 불리는 것은 친밀감의 표현 일 뿐이고 진실은 서로 믿고 의지하며 미래의 계획들을 함께 이루어 나가는 동지, 동료의 관계 입니다 일부 하이브의 주장과 언론 플레이에 현혹 되어 민희진씨를 부정적으로 인식하는 분들(일부 아미로 보이는)이 아무리 왜곡된 정보를 퍼트려도 진실은 숨길 수 없고 언젠간 누가 옳았는지 알게 될겁니다
I am wondering what your opinion is on the financial troubles over at YG, and how they are liquidating so many assets, because of the 2.5 billion in bad debt they have because of the Black Pink Tour? It appears that all those rumors of the company having to give away tickets, to make it look like the concerts were sold out were not rumors after all.
These girls are so audacious to believe that they have the right, or power to make demands or place an ultimatum on the head of Hybe. I do not believe that they did this on their own, this reeks of MHJ . These girls need to learn appreciation and humility. They also need to learn why they are so disliked by everyone at Hybe, and this little stunt will only make it worse on them. I am sure they just ended any chance of a major career. No other company is going to want to deal with them or MHJ. And MHJ will never spend the money on them like Hybe did, even if she had it- which she does not.
Now this. Plenty of fans, supporters and those who side with MHJ, need to hear this truth. Maybe, hopefully, even the girls themselves need to hear it.
There is no such incidents or problem before new jeans or ador come into hybe this is why hybe didn't debut lots of girl groups then hybe was peaceful until new jeans debut. The girls dig their own grave
Stop to say that newjeans are manipulated,newjeans are not stupid,the mhj ador was the best label in the kpop,so different and cool,newjeans represent the best Korea,now with hybe it's not my newjeans,from happy group to bad mood, give my newjeans back plz,love you newjeans, a forever a bunnie ❤❤
Real artists are suffering actual mistreatment like no pay, poor working environment, and CEO making them do favors. Lost the last respect I had for them.
Why are people in this comment section so fucking scary and lack empathy to these girls, what the fuck.. these girls thought long and hard and decided to do a live, knowing the risk of losing everything they’ve worked so hard for this past years. Please just provide them support if you love them, instead of immediately jumping to conclusion that, “they destroyed their career.” Please be nice…
