There are so many beautiful touching moments in this romantic movie. I love how she turned down his ride. How she signaled him not to go to the car. The quiet looks they shared. Beautiful movie.
*Without a doubt, it is the best movie I have ever seen, congratulations to the actors and the director. - Sin duda, es la mejor película que he visto en mi vida, enhorabuena a los actores y al director.*
It is a beautiful, but sad movie. All the actors are very good, the actor that plays Werner is a beautiful man, inside and outside. Wish there would be a sequel.
There was a sequel planned, but the French public opinion were still very much lodged in the negative towards any human portrayal of the enemy soldier. The collective psyche was not ready for a reunion of this new interpretation of an old Resistance propaganda book. This film had lots of back lash when it came out in 2004 (60th anniversary of DDay). We are now in 2024, 80th coming this summer, I hope the incredible team that put this film together would give us another film that further deprogram the collective psyche not just of the French, but the world beyond, god knows, we need to have our eyes and hearts opened up. We need disclosure as for who really created these wars that caused such unspeakable suffering on such mass scale, if this was not human sacrifice, I don't know what is. When Young people can not love each other because they were supposedly enemies, we are in very deep trouble.
I agree and the voice modulation when he talks to them. I am surprised that he didn't win any award. Also the movie should have been in the category of top french movies but it isn't. Its a beautiful movie.
@@padmacrao2158 There are still many in the French public hate the German occupation, and the women who consorted with the German soldiers. This movie met lots of backlash when it came out in 2004. That is why they shelved the sequel when Werner found his way back to Jeanne. Today if you go on some of the short documentary about French women being shaved and tormented on the streets in post war France, you will see the vehemence and hatred some the comments are towards these women. It is generational indoctrination. These are younger people who know how to use the internet but never lived through the war. Yet they hold tremendous negative emotions... So you can see, no matter how good Thomas Jouannet's performance was, he can not be give a prize, the ordinary audience in France will not receive that well, they can not distinguish the actor and his craft vs. the character the German Soldier, it is too raw. I am surprised by how the trauma of the war are still so deeply baked in the collective psyche of the French...It was the 60th anniversary of D Day when this film came out (2004), this year is 80th, I wonder if more commemorative movies will come out for WWII. Time to heal France, and Germany. Time to acknowledge the war caused suffering on all sides, and we the people had been and still are manipulated to kill each other so some can harvest the pain, because they live off our suffering (this is a truth most of us do not know).
This film is really well done. Simply told, outstanding acting. I have 2 questions. What was Werner going to tell Jeanne until grandpa interrupted them? And why was he at the pier?
@@parasharshikha7 Thank you for the explanation! The mystery behind what Warner was going to tell Jeanne makes more sense now, also why he was at the pier!
Also with the Vietnamese women who had children with American soldiers during the Vietnam War. They were humiliated and discriminated against by their own people.
This guy is so annoying.He tried to make a pass at her.She rebuked his advances.This time he assaulted her.As an Officer and a Gentleman,Werner just controlled his anger instead of giving him a jab in his jaw.
@Unsung Songs if he had done something, he would have put Jeanne at risk. As it is, Pascal already thought the two were having an affair. And for a French woman to have an affair with a German at that time, meant she was basically a collaborator and would be punished as such.
@@oskyperez4989the writer of The silence of the sea was Jean Bruller, he wrote during the war under the pseudonym of Vercors, died in París in 1991. The jew writer was Irène Némirovsky, who died in a concentration camp, she wrote a very similar novel, French Suite, which was found unfinished by her daughters, there were also some notes about the end she was thinking, the film was made in 2014. Both are very similar, but French Suite was first published in 2004
Elle fait de la résistance à la place de sa voisine fusillee.et lorsqu'elle mais un géranium c'est comme ça quelle signalé quelle est avec des résistants en train de discuter.
Господи, какой же красавец! Отдельные слова и фразы понимаю, а как хотелось весь фильм посмотреть Благодарю вас за предоставленое удовольствие. С уважением 👍👍👍🌹🌹🌹♥️♥️♥️
Quella sera dopo essere stato preso in giro dagli amici facendoli capire che era solo un sognatore quando si domanda "cosa posso fare ecco questa era una domanda a se stesso o una richiesta di aiuto. Perché continuano mantenere il silenzio di fronte alla sua evidente disperazione e dopo aver sperimentato per 3 mesi la sua scelta di non umiliare i vinti e di non voler fare del male. Non avrebbero dovuto e sopratutto lei avvicinarlo parlargli consigliarlo a continuare nel suo modo di essere che avrebbe aiutato e non osteggiato i "vinti". Questo lo avrebbe aiutato. Il silenzio lo ha fatto sentire un perdente e non un giusto. Mentre i perdenti erano i suoi amici amanti del potere per esercitare ad ogni costo. Anche Jeanne si dimostra dura e perdente. Di fronte all"uomo che ama esercita la parte dell*eroina e solo quando tutto è perduto piange disperata e pronuncia la sua sola parola. Adieu
Jailda, pronto pode assistir o filme inteirinho. Eu já vi umas 5 vezes e cada vez que vejo tem algum detalhe que não tinha visto antes. Depois que vc assistir responda aqui o que vc acha que ele ia dizer pra ela quando foi interrompido pelo avô dela ta
Фильм великолепный Жанна и капитан великолепно сыграли да он интересный и она красивая девушка они друг друга любили, Жанна немогла вести по другому и он тоже он был настоящий культурный мужчина, во время войны немцы были наглые и ничтожные русских. уничтожали и сравнивали с землей Я запад ненавижу они Россию хотят постовить на колени но им неудасться Россия была и будет стоять. За все ответит Запад. Бог любит Россию.
La propagande est puissante en Russie !!! A vrai dire, la Russie n'intéresse pas l'occident. Elle n'aurait eu un intérêt que si elle avait intégré l'Europe. ... malheureusement, elle a des dirigeants qui ne s'intéressent qu'à leur propre intérêt..... du reste, puisque vous nous menacez de votre bombe, sachez que nous en possédons d'excellentes aussi.
Russia may have to lead the movement of Disclosure---the truth of our reality that had been kept from humanity. России, возможно, придется возглавить движение Раскрытия - правды о нашей реальности, которая была скрыта от человечества.
Не пишите всякую бредятину и вранье. Никто россию никуда не ставит. Это она пытается ставить на колени всех кто не хочет жить как она в нищете и грязи. Они орки какие зверства совершают в Украине!
That's really chilling - romanticizing the German occupant in WW2 is rather sick. It could be felt only by someone who've never come close to an experience of dealing with the German army and the horror they spread...
Abbi I German occupant were people too. Most were forced to followed the society. If they were going against the nazi or didn’t join they were ostracized by their peers. You act like you deal with nazis before and I know 100% that not true.
Well - never said they were not people. But does it justify occupying someone's house and murdering millions of people? If you're curious of myself - I'm third generation descendant of their victims and also I have to deal with the trauma transmitted from my grandparents and parents - in third generation (!) I also don't think it is fair, but - well - that's life, right? Also - answering the previous comment - I never said one shouldn't talk about WW2, on the contrary - I personally think talking and remembering is the only way to prevent this horror repeating ever again. My problem with this particular rendition of history is that it's subversively justifying and blurring responsibility of the German soldier for what was happening back then. Yes - it was certainly difficult to stand back to his peers, family, neighbors, SS, Gestapo and the whole system, although there were people who were brave enough to do so and paid the highest price also in those hellish days...
The movie is based in a book written by a French resistance writer. His nickname is Vercors. I read the book and understood the movie much better. The title is the same “ Le silence de la mer”. The translation in English is “The silence of the sea”.
