Тёмный

‘If Ladakh Stalemate Continues, A Two Front Scenario Is Possible’ 

StratNewsGlobal
Подписаться 231 тыс.
Просмотров 64 тыс.
50% 1

Pakistan may be tempted to join good friend China in opening another front against India if the current military stalemate in Ladakh persists, feel former military officers Maj Gen BK Sharma (Retd), Director of USI and Lt Gen GS Katoch (Retd), member of India’s oldest military think tank in this episode of Strategic Insight hosted by StratNews Global Editor-in-Chief Nitin A. Gokhale
#India #China #ChinaIndiaFaceOff

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2020

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 372   
@pankajkaushal5602
@pankajkaushal5602 3 года назад
Getting addicted to this high class journalism . Far better than Print 👍
@chillerbp85
@chillerbp85 3 года назад
I think when it comes to Strategic news and military tactics, deployments and doctrines etc Stratnews Global is Numero Uno, there is no doubt about it. No other news outlet has such in-depth analysis and knowledge about military affairs and military tactics than Stratnews Global. But when it comes to Foreign Affairs, Global Powerplay and Global Politics, The Print has Shekhar Gupta and I think he is the czar of Politics in Indian journalism right now. Global Power play, reading between the lines about statements from Ministry of Foreign Affairs of other countries, about signalling done by other countries etc. To understand what is happening on India's borders and, basically everything related to defense, you have to watch Stratnews Global. But to understand what is happening in the region and maybe around the World also, you have to watch ThePrint especially CTC by Shekhar Gupta. Congratulations to both Stratnews Global and ThePrint.
@suryanarayansingh1219
@suryanarayansingh1219 3 года назад
@@chillerbp85 right CTC and Stratnewsglobal especially with USI is very good.
@nishant17285
@nishant17285 3 года назад
Print is lund
@sagivinayaka6509
@sagivinayaka6509 3 года назад
@@nishant17285 well said
@amazedguy
@amazedguy 3 года назад
This is one of the best moderators: He very adroitly shifts from one panelist to the other, while maintaining the continuity of the discussion. He does not shout, does not interrupt, does not even put anyone down.
@MyPlanetMyDuty
@MyPlanetMyDuty 3 года назад
This channel is better than Print ..
@syamchandrnair8517
@syamchandrnair8517 3 года назад
Nop
@vve2059
@vve2059 3 года назад
Also checkout wion
@rushikeshpawar614
@rushikeshpawar614 3 года назад
Print guys are full of agenda
@aneeshsoorya
@aneeshsoorya 3 года назад
Print is always biased
@suhasbagale5025
@suhasbagale5025 3 года назад
Print is a lot biased!!!
@suryakantapradhan6087
@suryakantapradhan6087 3 года назад
After following PLA and IA in Ladakh for 5 months.. i can express this whole situation like this😀 1)Winter is coming(coming harsh winter) 2)North will remember(Galwan,Ladakh) 3)The two Army(IA vs PLA) 4) PLA(white walkers from north) 5)The wall(Himalayas) &🤭 6)Weapons(PLA spears, stones, machetes & wire stick) #Humour
@gandharthanekar8648
@gandharthanekar8648 3 года назад
We have to deal our enemy first and then think of economic repercussion. If we are overrun by our enemies , then economic consequences afterward will be much more. So we have to fight with our full strength .
@VK-no5kj
@VK-no5kj 3 года назад
Yes. In WW2 Russia had severe losses but fought fanatically and ultimately prevailed. For own land we should not hesitate for permanent solution otherwise we can never safely develop
@adventurehub4825
@adventurehub4825 3 года назад
Right said bro. China and Pakistan are cancers. We have to cut them off
@gautamgunjan8471
@gautamgunjan8471 3 года назад
This Channel has a long journey to charter..Excellent content..Excellent people
@siddharthkrishnan7564
@siddharthkrishnan7564 3 года назад
Pak wants a reluctant China to attack India & then see how it goes before opening second front. Meanwhile China wants Pak to carry out some terror attack to divert India's focus westwards. But Pak is wary too (zero US/Arab support, FATF, weak economy, weak internal situation). Both doesn't have confidence [to go all out]. And both are trying to see if internal disturbance is possible.
@mussunny
@mussunny 3 года назад
lol, yes because that's all Pakistan and China think about right??? how about considering the fact that your hindu hard line government has successfully turned india into a communal state, has very incompetently managed the corona issue and the cherry on top is it's economic performance and now the only card it's got left to play is to start a war and blame all of india's woes on it's neighbors, kinda reminds me of a german fellow we read about in history....
@Unknown-sh8kw
@Unknown-sh8kw 3 года назад
Chinese r not stupid. China won’t go to war it will use Pakistan to start war
@mussunny
@mussunny 3 года назад
@Vijay Jha sure, I'm sure that's how RSS recruits your sort on the streets of delhi
@manofsan
@manofsan 3 года назад
Pak is not independent actor here - China is their master. It's always possible that China could tell Pak to heat up LOC on its side.
@chillerbp85
@chillerbp85 3 года назад
@@mussunny What did you expect? March to May 2020 we had a complete lockdown. That means a GDP growth rate of -23.5% in the 1st quarter of this year, which is the GDP growth rate y-o-y for March to May 2020 will obviously be negative, because those 3 months we had a lockdown. Only essential services were allowed to open. Because of one of the strictest lock-downs in the world, the World Bank predicts that India's GDP will contract for the Annual full year rate of 4.5% this year, that means -4.5%. And next year we are expected to grow at around 8% to 9%, some predictions are giving at 9.9% growth rate next year (2021 to 2022). Don't worry Pakistan is not growing even without a lock-down.
@sarpedonzeus1874
@sarpedonzeus1874 3 года назад
Impressed with the quality of the interviews, the panel and the points being discussed. Well done.
@indianmilitary
@indianmilitary 3 года назад
Crap. Which BJP leader said that Chinese are not a threat? In fact, Chinese are pissed because of fast infrastructure build up at finger 4 and other indo-china border areas since 2014.
@sarpedonzeus1874
@sarpedonzeus1874 3 года назад
@chan pal Thanks for the excellent reply and it's much appreciated that you were kind enough to point out my low standards 😁. Compared to some of the other discussions these are on point and clear n for a simpleton like me perfect.
@sarpedonzeus1874
@sarpedonzeus1874 3 года назад
@chan pal Agree with your points with regards to China. Successive Indian govt have been 100% negligent in not viewing the CCP as a real threat. The CCPs actions in the SCS should have rung alarm bells in India's govt and military and begin to prepare for today's scenario. Instead of being proactive and reacting to the substantial CCP military build over 20yrs the politicians stuck their heads in the sand. The incidents in Ladakh were going to happen just as the world was going to be hit with an unknown virus (Covid-19). Further, Modi denying the PLA's land grab was shameful as well. Personally, I'd recognize Taiwan and HH Dalai Lama + Tibetan govt in exile and then ban Huawei & Co from any infrastructure projects immediately. The One China policy needs to go the way of the dodo ...it's meaningless when dealing with a dictatorship like the CCP.
@satishiyer1452
@satishiyer1452 3 года назад
Very good programme and excellent informative discussion between knowledgeable experts. Keep it up !
@uddhavpradhan3480
@uddhavpradhan3480 3 года назад
Strategic insight is a very apt title for this show. Indeed very insightful ❤️🙂
@rajdeeprawal597
@rajdeeprawal597 3 года назад
Quality of video, audio and graphics deserve compliments. Content and quality of discussion is also great.
@orangelays5084
@orangelays5084 3 года назад
A wonderful programme
@ramanghuman4691
@ramanghuman4691 3 года назад
A very crisp and to the point discussion by Gen BK Sharma.
@IndroneelMukerji
@IndroneelMukerji 3 года назад
My points : 1. India has to have plans - integrating all five commands (army, navy, airforce, cyber, nuclear) ready for a two front war, even if the enemy attacks are in Kashmir, Ladakh, Sikkim or Arunachal Pradesh. Our airforce, navy should be ready for retaliatory measures on any areas of control of the two enemy countries. Similarly our missiles should be at the ready for making conventional attacks. Diplomacy and economic measures should be listed to cause the maximum possible impact to the CCP especially. The Quad has to be strengthened by formalising SOPs to neutralise CCP’s coercive military aggression- with counter strikes basis severity of their aggression. India should enter into military alliances with Vietnam, Taiwan, Singapore and perhaps Oman to stifle PLAN’s IOR plans.
@harshalgore
@harshalgore 3 года назад
Excellent discussion Nitin sir.. thank you for the insights.
@vikthought
@vikthought 3 года назад
For the Two front war scenerio we should pronounce abrogation of the "no first use" against Pakistan in our nuclear doctrine... QUAD will not fight your war in himalayas.. A stated first use policy in a two front scenerio will draw the globe to this conflict...
@mandalindranil
@mandalindranil 3 года назад
Brilliant discussion ...many new things to learn
@keysman27
@keysman27 3 года назад
We hv 3lac CRPF,CISF,SSB.....which are well equipped and hv seen action....as a good 2nd line back up
@mrvattoli1858
@mrvattoli1858 3 года назад
Do you think 1billion common people will allow some strangers come near to our backyard.. This is not 19th 18th century. We are one nation when it comes to question our country. I dont have any doubt in that
@Unknown-sh8kw
@Unknown-sh8kw 3 года назад
We need need new DUN “ United Nation of Democracy”
@vishnukumar-lj9kt
@vishnukumar-lj9kt 3 года назад
Very good analisis of our capacity and capabilities. Very much re assuring.
@JajaborManas
@JajaborManas 3 года назад
One of the finest channel 👌👌👌
@subhashchandrasingh5528
@subhashchandrasingh5528 3 года назад
One of best channel on security affairs
@umakanthkarthik
@umakanthkarthik 3 года назад
Very thought provoking and very knowledgeable panel and host
@sourabhbhattacharya3411
@sourabhbhattacharya3411 3 года назад
Thank God, this kind of discourses is happening and experts are engaging. God bless you gentlemen.
@surendrabarsode8959
@surendrabarsode8959 3 года назад
Excellent discussion! My views are 1. We should treat as if we have one enemy (China) and treat western to northern to eastern as one single border to defend. This will make planning for taking on both of these countries easier. 2. We must have some pact with any one of -USA, France or Israel or Russia on the lines of 1971 treaty with USSR. That will give us required comfort as a backup 3. We should in fact look to settle the issues. Pakistan may finally bear the heavy cost of supporting China!!
@rajkshitij6348
@rajkshitij6348 3 года назад
Wonderful discussion, very pragmatic and realistic 🙏
@rajiblochanpanigrahi2198
@rajiblochanpanigrahi2198 3 года назад
Very knowledgefull sir..keep it up
@shyamk4257
@shyamk4257 3 года назад
Thanks for sharing
@prabhaskumarmohanty5910
@prabhaskumarmohanty5910 3 года назад
Quality discussion
@sanjeevathreya
@sanjeevathreya 3 года назад
Extremely insightful. Great panel. Thank you.
@2010anilshukla
@2010anilshukla 3 года назад
Brilliant as ever. Thanks for bringing it to us.
@sujataganguly4529
@sujataganguly4529 3 года назад
Great episode! Thank you!
@apurbokale7165
@apurbokale7165 3 года назад
Excellent insight Stratnews Global. Thank You. We get to hear from the best minds on this subject..
@subratasarkar5174
@subratasarkar5174 3 года назад
Sir, there is a third front playing inside India which plays a vital role in this conflict. That front is known as the breaking India force. Their mental set up has directly or indirectly started sayiing " Now face the music". Israel is surrounded by its enemies , but they dare to go into any conflict with Israel due to the absence of any breaking Israel force.
@mukeshsinghmaher2378
@mukeshsinghmaher2378 3 года назад
Excellent discussion
@kiransahni100
@kiransahni100 3 года назад
Amazing discussion by Nitin,learned a lot from the wise guests,really wish prime time TV would also be sensible
@prernabhadwal4439
@prernabhadwal4439 3 года назад
Very eloquent, impressive and informative.
@virajzanzane8330
@virajzanzane8330 3 года назад
Best defence strategic Think tank 💯💯💯💯💯
@buvaneswaranpadmanabhan3254
@buvaneswaranpadmanabhan3254 3 года назад
wonderful episode
@virendrapalsingh2846
@virendrapalsingh2846 3 года назад
Hi Gen Sharma and Katoch, nice to see both of you together at the same forum. Good talk. Hope you remember me, HAWS!
@friendxyz2919
@friendxyz2919 3 года назад
Very impressive and apt...
@krackjack6021
@krackjack6021 3 года назад
Great discussion with lots of insights provided by the two distinguished guests. This channel is becoming great source of authentic and patriotic information. Well done Mr Nitin Gokhale.
@balasubramanyakn6466
@balasubramanyakn6466 3 года назад
Salutations to you sir. Keep doing your great work.
@EraserofGoodHandwriting
@EraserofGoodHandwriting 3 года назад
About nukes as Modi had said "Humne kya Diwali ke liye rakhe hue hain kya?"
@EraserofGoodHandwriting
@EraserofGoodHandwriting 3 года назад
@rabatha 273 ye nukes wali dhamki tumhari hoti hai Poxtani, tumhare toh nyaayaab nukes Hain.. aadha kilo ke, paav bhar ke, ek kilo ke, bas Hindu ke liye.. Hindu India? Arey jaheelon jab kisi non Poxtani se baat karo toh thodi taleem le liya karo!! India Mai Hindu,Sikh,Muslims, Christians, Buddhists,Parsi, Yahudi sab rehte hain aur sab tumhe thokte Hain!! Sahi kahan hai ye poori kaum he jaahil hai
@ameyabakre4609
@ameyabakre4609 3 года назад
Keep in mind how Israelai forces dealt with 7 arab nations all at once...
@kisansolanki1324
@kisansolanki1324 3 года назад
Nicely analysis... Great.
@ramdas_naville
@ramdas_naville 3 года назад
Please take this two front scenario as normal position in confronting the nexus. Common factor is the CPEC and POK .
@sadhnanair2488
@sadhnanair2488 3 года назад
The experts seemed to be overly sanguine about our ability to handle the 'nightmare' scenario. Much needs to be done to shore up our capabilities.
@doncorleone3901
@doncorleone3901 3 года назад
Let American + Taiwanese + Japanese companies set up chip manufacturing facilities in Ladakh. Needs lot of water which is available in Himalayas
@wokeymcwokeface1974
@wokeymcwokeface1974 3 года назад
Lady Anon what’s up with your porn name?
@wokeymcwokeface1974
@wokeymcwokeface1974 3 года назад
Ladakh is mostly pristine and beautiful! Let Ladakh stay that way with managed tourism. There are plenty of places for doing business!
@jasha9sandhu
@jasha9sandhu 3 года назад
Logistical cost would be too much for economic viability in the global supply chain. Port infrastructure in the vicinity is must for all export economies
@vedprakashsrivastava2516
@vedprakashsrivastava2516 3 года назад
Kudos to Gokhle Sir 🙏 We needed this channel very badly to get an in depth analysis rather than rheoterics of main stream media and propoganda driven youtube channels. Thanks a lot 🙏
@Kanthavel.KV.Chennai.Bharat
@Kanthavel.KV.Chennai.Bharat 3 года назад
The media these days analyses everything so deeply, that sometimes it's scary... It's better that forums like this should stick very strictly to the current situation & should take care not to speculate about things that are not necessary to be spoken in public. Bharat should prepare for such a scenario but very silently.
@shapnilhaldar4530
@shapnilhaldar4530 3 года назад
@@chillerbp85 Ironically that's Sun Tzu talking. If he was around, he would have retracted from Ladakh, accepted defeat and come back stronger. But today's China is different from what it was, China now is ruled by a man who likes to be appeased so there is no room for real concern at the top.
@shreepanicker
@shreepanicker 3 года назад
Lt Gen Katoch adroitly stepped around revealing anything much about exactly how a two front scenario would be tackled, saying sagely "I'm sure there are plans for that". The sterling quality about Strat News Global, apart from their top notch moderators (esp Nitin Gokhale), are the highly experienced domain experts whom they manage to rope in. It gives these discussions the aura of being conducted within a Think Tank, with the viewers being flies on the wall!
@Kanthavel.KV.Chennai.Bharat
@Kanthavel.KV.Chennai.Bharat 3 года назад
@@chillerbp85 Hide your strength, bide your time,
@vikau950
@vikau950 3 года назад
Good discussion
@shailendrakhapli3580
@shailendrakhapli3580 3 года назад
Mr. Nitin , you have discussed America, Japan and Australia. But what about Russian effect. Our defense supply is depend upon Russia. All forces are having atleast 60 to 70% armaments from Russia. Will you please discuss Russian roll in this senerio??
@SachinSingh-ej2zy
@SachinSingh-ej2zy 3 года назад
It's worth watching u always
@abhishekdas9281
@abhishekdas9281 3 года назад
India needs to take QUAD more seriously as Australia and USA both are very much ready for it. Japan also is looking to revise it's no attack policies and ready to push China back. Also, no point in acknowledging 'One China' policy. Formal ties need to be established with Taiwan, HK and Tibet. How funny is the fact that we still don't acknowledge Tibet govt even though it's office is in Dharmasala.
@sivaramansrinivasan285
@sivaramansrinivasan285 3 года назад
Excellent one. Discussing on all possible scenario and India's capability to handle such scenario was well covered. One thing that was missed out was that Chinese assets are there going through PoK. It is extremely vulnerable if Pakistan start opens another front. India is waiting to break it completely. Then China would try for a truce. Then India will become a key strategic partner of China. Pakistan is also vulnerable as a country as each Pakistani province wants to break away from Pakistani Punjab.
@PradeepKumar-yj6wj
@PradeepKumar-yj6wj 3 года назад
It's journalism is better quality. Keep it up dear Nitin.All the best.Thanks
@sanjaysoi
@sanjaysoi 3 года назад
Excellent analysis
@nayanbuch4075
@nayanbuch4075 3 года назад
Your discussion on the current situation is quite informative and useful to understand what exactly is going on and what lies ahead. Two fronts confrontation is really tough situation and eventhiugh we come out of it but the end results wiil be very painful for a longtime in economic and other fronts .No doubt we can not afford to leave this situation as it is under fear because it has it's own problems. Let's hope for the best.
@AKS-qq1fw
@AKS-qq1fw 3 года назад
This channel is best for strategic affairs.
@suresh.bbhadraiah9571
@suresh.bbhadraiah9571 3 года назад
High quality discussion
@CaptAnandKrSingh
@CaptAnandKrSingh 3 года назад
An in-depth analysis of the situation. This channel has it's own class.
@joegeorge7868
@joegeorge7868 2 года назад
Hats off. Brilliant analysis from General Sharma. While this analysis is still note worthy and relevant in 2022, it would be important to note that Russia is a spent force and will not assist India. Their true strategic partner will be China. India must urgently seek a new alliance with the West. Very long over due.
@MrSunilal
@MrSunilal 3 года назад
Higher than mountains Deeper than ocean Sweeter than honey Cheeper than China 😀.
@prabirray1329
@prabirray1329 3 года назад
Sanctimonious Iike Chaina Sanctuary like India
@rajendrasinghbutola9217
@rajendrasinghbutola9217 3 года назад
We must cement Quad
@janardanchoudhury431
@janardanchoudhury431 3 года назад
Either we sign a pact with USA or QUAD or Russia . Pakistan and China are cooking plans for two front war against India .
@javedsiddique2012
@javedsiddique2012 3 года назад
Quad is an unnatural alliance.
@anshul9462
@anshul9462 3 года назад
What If Quad decides to attack Russia (keep Nato in mind). We will be forced to attack Russia. That will be like stabbing a frnd. We must look at Quad without USA. Replace USA by South Korean then it makes sense for India to join.
@RK-xo6gi
@RK-xo6gi 3 года назад
very impressed
@D.LexT14
@D.LexT14 3 года назад
I really enjoyed every min of this video. Would be nice if it was under 20 min.
@PunjabHP
@PunjabHP 3 года назад
good info
@naveensharma6882
@naveensharma6882 3 года назад
Nitin sir very late to subscribe u and congrats u being a clear view of neutrality, vision, aim, importance, common sense( sorry to say but missing in all others) But most important s in patriotism, and is define by TRUTH and acceptance of opposite views I believe u hold both What a wonderful insights u all given, thank u
@ahmedakhan1
@ahmedakhan1 3 года назад
naveen sharma This was total BS! If you want quality analysis you should check out Praveen Sawhney's videos. He is probably the best Indian defence analyst on RU-vid!
@naveensharma6882
@naveensharma6882 3 года назад
@@ahmedakhan1 i 9 what u want to say, katwey, gadhar
@whatwhyhow1855
@whatwhyhow1855 3 года назад
Sir your articals too helpful
@spacelion6318
@spacelion6318 3 года назад
Asymmetrical warstrategies need to be used
@rahul0526
@rahul0526 3 года назад
Gokhale Sir: Please conduct a discussion on Need of formalisation and modernising military doctrine of India. Modern militaries are more of Air power dominant and also more focussed on Air/Maritime/Space domain. We currently are still Land dominant force. If India were to become a superpower, it cannot limit itself to being a soft power.
@srinivasmorey4229
@srinivasmorey4229 3 года назад
Some Very Good Incisive Insights From The Former Military Generals
@iangerahty3422
@iangerahty3422 3 года назад
Very much enjoy the appreciations made by these retired defence officers in your series. The CCP/PLA seem to lack a comparable level of intellectual analysis as the Indian Defence Forces which leadership clearly has operational experience at junior to senior command and staff level.
@seetaramdantu3190
@seetaramdantu3190 3 года назад
It's best channel for deffence
@sweettruth8039
@sweettruth8039 3 года назад
Best defense channel.
@dharamewada6922
@dharamewada6922 3 года назад
Thankfully, the Generals are mature enough not to discuss beyond a point. The Generals are slightly off the mark in undermining the capability of Pakisthan. The Force level of Pakisthan is quite impressive and that needs to recognized. Two front war is a reality and it is foolish to think that we are still planning.
@PromodhSridhar
@PromodhSridhar 3 года назад
Hell not scared of China or Pakistan 😉 We are called Proud Indians 🇮🇳
@rohitagarwal5293
@rohitagarwal5293 3 года назад
👌👌👌
@ninadk30
@ninadk30 3 года назад
With a two front conflict being a real possibility, India needs to have a very strong anti-access area denial capabilities. We need to make it extremely costly for either of the two neighbours to make any drastic move. With India commanding the crucial heights, the only vulnerability is the air. We need surface to air and surface to surface capabilities urgently. The 10 year hollowing out of the air assets during the UPA is stinging us.
@krishnanchari2001
@krishnanchari2001 3 года назад
Dear Nitin Sir, the analysis of the options available in different scenarios, in case of a 2 front war, is good from a discussion point of view. Also, the tri armed forces as seen in the discussion would be confident and committed to defending the country to the last man. The people of India have complete trust in the Armed forces. However, the uncertainty lies in the political fabric of the country which cannot be trusted for their capability to take decisive actions and also to give a free hand to the tri armed forces to defend the country against external aggression. As can be seen from the past the political leadership has always been soft, indecisive in all the wars that we have faced, and more important from a strategic perspective, the political leadership of India never finishes a war with an advantage. History is clear on how we squandered our strategic advantages despite the good advice from our armed forces. The blunders committed by various political leaders have exposed our people and nation to a complex network of strategic threats the annual costs of which is very high and burdens our economic development through the generations. Unfortunately right from Nehru to Modi there has been repeated complacency in taking firm decisions regarding national security. Indian political leadership has only existed for vote banks and power and has always failed to respond effectively. How can we assure ourselves that our political leaders will commit themselves to take effective decisions at times of security threats such as these? What are the options that political leadership has in its mind? There needs to be a discussion such as this also with political leaders to know their minds and their perceptions. A comparison of their thought process with the discussion that we have with armed forces professionals can at least enable us to understand the our true capability to defend against external aggression bet it one front or two front. Wars cannot be won only with the commitment of armed forces, it also needs the political commitment and patriotism which I honestly doubt of our political leaders.
@bimal2011
@bimal2011 3 года назад
Chari G is right.We can't trust the sleeper cells planted all over India.
@blowemall
@blowemall 3 года назад
It is already a 2-front war anyways since Galwan valley incident. With India making its intention of getting Gilgit, Baltistan and PoK back, future of Karakoram highway and CPEC were in peril. China has jumped in to help its ally by opening a front in Ladakh.
@johntong4453
@johntong4453 3 года назад
a two front war is the best scenario for India. How can you be sure that countries like Nepal, Bangladesh, even Sri Lanka will not join the feast? And, how abt those separatists from Assam to Panjab?
@vasanthakumarporumamilla6722
@vasanthakumarporumamilla6722 11 месяцев назад
Good information. I have a suggestion on the alliance with the three democracies namely U.S.A, Australia and Japan to make India as alternative hub for manufacturing other than defence understanding. This would help for better overall mutual support. Can there be a discussion on this also please ?
@therunouschronicles5282
@therunouschronicles5282 3 года назад
What will be the economic cost of fighting China as we are already in trouble from economic point of view?
@jayakrishnanm2975
@jayakrishnanm2975 3 года назад
well go bankrupt as china already has a 3 trillion dollar surplus and we dont have any surplus
@jayakrishnanm2975
@jayakrishnanm2975 3 года назад
@Kambojas Kambo MY FRIEND that is your view if we go to war it may not affect china due to its 3 trillion surplus but our poor peaple will go hungry
@kundanchaudhari3951
@kundanchaudhari3951 3 года назад
@@jayakrishnanm2975 3 trillion surplus? Their total exports amounted to 2.50 trillion worldwide last year.
@reddisathya
@reddisathya 3 года назад
U r parents should think about economy while u r birth ..🔥🔥🔥..
@Ck-yp7re
@Ck-yp7re 3 года назад
Jayakrishnan M Yes they have 3 trillions reserves but more than 4 trillions external depths Thati have to calculate
@lazyarrogance
@lazyarrogance 3 года назад
It's the only " news channel" in india as of now.
@shika-fm
@shika-fm 3 года назад
Is it possible to open India Vietnam economic corridor which can connect Indian Ocean with Pacific Ocean and passing it through Arunachal Pradesh and making international colation. And joing it with other disputes of China like Vietnam Japan and taiwan as all country will benefit from it.And highly militarilising strait of Malacca.As well as placing missile and takes near cpec which can target in future for creating logistical problem for China.
@revanthreddy175
@revanthreddy175 3 года назад
Don’t you think you are giving away all the military planing details?
@noelcastelino6790
@noelcastelino6790 3 года назад
In these matters, it is perhaps best to avoid self-fulfilling prophecies.
@asitdesai7728
@asitdesai7728 3 года назад
Is there a site that has access to our neighbours strategic thinking - so that it informs viewers of the possible state of play - as both of them would not one hopes be embarking on any action/s on the spur of the moment.
@aochubaao9138
@aochubaao9138 3 года назад
This panel members are crazy. Why such strategies be disclosed?
@mohan4114
@mohan4114 3 года назад
India should not go to war with anyone and develop India economy. India is a big country with big population and good potential. The Colonial had trick India many times into war that made India poor & weak,. for example , India & Pakistan has war, disagreement & etc, all this made India & Pakistan Poor & weak. It is easy to start trouble between Pakistan & India and both country go on emotional roller coaster. When Modi visit Sharif, peace almost appeared in horizon, but foreign power topple him and put someone they can manage. Image if India & Pakistan have good relationship most of the defense budget can go to education & poverty eradication.
@nilanshah63
@nilanshah63 3 года назад
My blessing to India and China to start war with half of Delhi in rubbles with Tyagis suffering the most. I bless Noida side of Delhi in rubbles with Sandeep Tyagi adulterous and his family suffering the most. GOD this has become my daily prayers.
@daljiba
@daljiba 3 года назад
It is the first time I have come cross Army generals talking so sensibly
@bimal2011
@bimal2011 3 года назад
Gokhale G, It seems to me that You three are on the Russian vaccine trial of covid-19,bindaas no mask. Aur aai shapath, bolte dono bhaau jhakaas. 😁
@humayunbawkher5372
@humayunbawkher5372 3 года назад
As a two front war risk was always possible, why is it that China's mid June was a surprise for India? Looks like this risk was always overlooked or felt it cou,d be ignored as China was not felt to be a real threat. This seeming disconnect needs to be examined & explained.
@jasha9sandhu
@jasha9sandhu 3 года назад
No war is feasible in this day and age. However recent Chinese aggression would only sharpen Indian defences , in a way good for India. Atleast a 30 year perspective is must for India to neutralise it's adversary permanently. Prepare for a 2 & half front war and war won't happen. However if you are weak enough, you entice your enemy to engage u in a kinetic duel
@udayakumarp1981
@udayakumarp1981 3 года назад
What will happen on a fourth scenario China move thier 3 out of 4 theatre command to Indian border , Pakistan opened one or two fronts and India do not get real material or intelligence support from others and the arrival of real winter in the himalaya is delayed by 2or 3 weeks( nature in their support) In this scenario can we hold our positions? Can we liberate Aksai chin?
@shawnawasthi
@shawnawasthi 3 года назад
We are playing chess with Chinese rite now,war still looks like a far-fetched Idea.
@Unknown-sh8kw
@Unknown-sh8kw 3 года назад
If we want Aksai Chin, Gilgit-Baltistan we have to go war sometime in future or forget about them.
@shivamsrivastava9296
@shivamsrivastava9296 3 года назад
Should be beware bcoz Chinese play checkers, which has a different mindset ( enchroch until win )
@shawnawasthi
@shawnawasthi 3 года назад
@@Unknown-sh8kw if we will be able to push our GDP in 2 digits then yes,in future.
@shivamsrivastava9296
@shivamsrivastava9296 3 года назад
@@shawnawasthi GDP is important but savagery is even more so.
@3oranges4
@3oranges4 3 года назад
Pls do talk the realities....May be in the winter there will be a serious clash between india vs china and pakisthan together....May be the pakisthan will open up war fronts in kashmir....ladakh...Indian western borders and simultaneously china will join war fronts joining pakisthan against india in ladakh,himachal...Uttarakhand...Extending up to north east states...May be they will try to break the chicken neck of india in north east and isolate north east states...With the help of nepal or with out permission from nepal... It can be a difficult task for India to defend a three front war ...From the west...Gujarath....Rajasthan ...Punjab....,from north from kashmir,ladakh....himachal and uttarakhand....From nepal side and Bhutan side....Through siliguri pass....Dokhlam...area....Nathula........The chicken neck of india.... May be we will fight for our dooms day against them.... May the Americans,israel,France,Vietnam,korea,Australia,Indonesia and japan will come to help India...if india gets external help.....We will make a decisive win over these forces...And get the aksai chin and some part of pakisthan occupied kashmir and Pakisthan punjab can be annexed back to India... And Baluchistan and sindh will get independence...from pakisthan. . A mild chance of Tibetan independence if india makes a landslide win against the chinese...It will End one belt one road...AND china pakisthan economic corridor......But if there is no military help from outside for us,and if russia betrays in military equipment supply,if the Gurkha's in indian army denies to fight for india and if they try to fightback against us as a military coup......Then it it can be a disastrous defeat for us...And we r going to loose ladakh,kashmir and eight north eastern states......Some part of uttarakhand and himachal and some part in gujarath...Punjab and rajasthan.... If we r pushed hard towards a defeat....May be it will end up in a nuclear war...And india will use all its nukes against china and pakisthan...And destroy all our enemies before we die ultimately.. Pls don't underestimate my statements....bcse the Chinese r very cruel and cunning...I think they r waiting for the winter...To start the fight....Until then they will make all the preparations...And they r waiting for indian winter and covid cases goes to its peak... anyway troublesome days forward for Indian subcontinent and the Chinese....
@ajitashenoy2018
@ajitashenoy2018 3 года назад
First we have to understand what are the intentions of Chinese PLA. Are they worried about India interfering in their CPAC project? Or are they worried that QUAD is going to be a danger for China?
@shivamsrivastava9296
@shivamsrivastava9296 3 года назад
Pakistan has a huge Human Intelligence (HUMINT) inside India which should not be taken lightly, and they will pass it to their new masters. India should also leverage Taiwan for HUMINT and SIGN INT into China.
Далее
‘Mountains Favour The Defender’
27:55
Просмотров 43 тыс.
1967, Nathu La: When India Gave China A Bloody Nose
15:07
Sumdorong Chu: When India Got The Better Of China
14:07
телега - hahalivars
0:54
Просмотров 1,3 млн
ЭКСПРЕСС разбор стиралки
0:39