Тёмный

‘With No-First Use Doctrine India’s Redlines In Nuclear Domain Are Very Clear’ 

StratNewsGlobal
Подписаться 276 тыс.
Просмотров 19 тыс.
50% 1

There is no need for India to revise its policy of no first use policy insofar as nuclear weapons are concerned since the country’s deterrence redlines are fairly well established for any of the adversaries to take chances, two of India’s well-known analysts in this specialised field, Dr Manpreet Sethi of Centre for Air Power Studies and Dr Roshan Khanijo of United Services Institution feel. They are in conversation with StratNewsGlobal Editor-in-Chief Nitin A. Gokhale in the final episode of the limited edition series Strategic Insight jointly done with USI, India’s oldest military think-tank.
#Indian #Nuclear #China

Опубликовано:

 

27 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 114   
@carryon2197
@carryon2197 4 года назад
One of the most phenomenal talk on strat news global till date. 1. The signalling! Two women form India enlightening about NUCLEAR weapons doctrine. No majors, no generals, no diplomats. Two incredible women. Beyond words. Nitin Gokhale sir you pulled off a thing whose true implications are enormous. The signalling! 2. What pragmatic views by both experts. No need for any other opinion on nuclear doctrine needed. Ps: 1.Madam Dr Roshan Khanijo, have become fan of your voice. 2. People remember India developed Nuclear weapon in response to chinese development in 1960's. So fear not. Our focus of nuclear development is with respect to China & not the macchar Pakistan
@CaptAnandKrSingh
@CaptAnandKrSingh 4 года назад
Very relevant topics discussed with in-depth knowledge. Your channel is a class apart.....
@tristanjohn2626
@tristanjohn2626 3 года назад
sorry to be so offtopic but does someone know of a tool to get back into an instagram account..? I was stupid lost my password. I would appreciate any help you can give me
@bradleycase4129
@bradleycase4129 3 года назад
@Tristan John instablaster ;)
@tristanjohn2626
@tristanjohn2626 3 года назад
@Bradley Case Thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site through google and I'm waiting for the hacking stuff now. Takes quite some time so I will get back to you later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
@tristanjohn2626
@tristanjohn2626 3 года назад
@Bradley Case It did the trick and I actually got access to my account again. I'm so happy! Thank you so much you saved my account !
@bradleycase4129
@bradleycase4129 3 года назад
@Tristan John Happy to help =)
@therunouschronicles5282
@therunouschronicles5282 4 года назад
We have to focus on China and by doing that Pakistan will be covered automatically
@udayviruppal3730
@udayviruppal3730 4 года назад
Pak is a separate story altogether
@sabdulnasir1
@sabdulnasir1 4 года назад
"You know we can handle Pakistan" 😊 but anyone who watched this talk, can see that you're looking fully obsessed with Pakistan. Why..? We aren't that much dangerous really..! 😊
@sabdulnasir1
@sabdulnasir1 4 года назад
Dear Indians..! Pakistan isn't that much dangerous... You are a much larger country..! Pakistan can only stop you going across Himaliya and make you spend Billion of dollar... Nothing other than this.! Have courage and be confident 💪
@anirbanghosh1984
@anirbanghosh1984 4 года назад
@@sabdulnasir1 First spell properly, then do the talking!!!
@raxona1
@raxona1 4 года назад
So genuinely pure discussion. I am in love with this channel
@hmanjunathaprabhu907
@hmanjunathaprabhu907 4 года назад
Both the distinguished panelist were knowledgeable, informative and a pleasure to listen to. Thanks Nitin and panelists!
@sanjchopra
@sanjchopra 4 года назад
One doesn’t come across this subject in public domain especially in India. Good insights by the experts
@gathamore
@gathamore 4 года назад
I totally agree with Dr Roshan! It is my belief that the next race for dominance wld be in space and deep space research, without an infrastructure which works fully on AI this would be impossible! Slightly offtopic but thats where my mind went when Dr Roshan spoke of AI.. thankyou guys this was an amazing engrossing discussion from 2 very well informed experts!🙏
@jkvel421
@jkvel421 4 года назад
Crystal clear points from two ladies.. absolutely phenomenal. Mr Kolale a thumbs up from my side...
@praveenagarkar
@praveenagarkar 4 года назад
Very informative but very scary outlook at how we lack ability ... thanks for such a quality program....
@vishnukumar-lj9kt
@vishnukumar-lj9kt 4 года назад
Very well explained, I think everyone in this country knows the problem we are facing except the govt. Govt should start teaching these things in schools and colleges, so that younger generation start working on these things like the Americans and Russians.
@gautamgunjan8471
@gautamgunjan8471 4 года назад
What a remarkable discussion..Hatsoff
@surendrabarsode8959
@surendrabarsode8959 4 года назад
Excellent discussion on a relevant topic. I would go with Dr. Roshni on her suggestion of developing specific technologies like we have recently tested HSDTV. It would have been a bonus if Nitin could have discussed specific scenarios Dr. Sethi had simulated to give us a peek into the exercise.
@prakashairavat8635
@prakashairavat8635 4 года назад
Felt very good to see woman in this field . With such knownledge. India is Rising.
@dilipdesai5392
@dilipdesai5392 4 года назад
With war tensions high what a pleasure to listen to two such informed and articulate experts at ease in their area of expertise keeping us updated on such a relevant topic. A quality presentation and congratulations are due to StratNews and Nitin Gokhale.
@arvindr25
@arvindr25 4 года назад
Excellent discussion and very knowledgeable panelists. Thanks for making this Nitin bhai.
@vivekmohanta2363
@vivekmohanta2363 4 года назад
A very relevant and much needed discussion! Thanks for bringing it up
@sudhanshusharan5720
@sudhanshusharan5720 4 года назад
Great program and great analysis. Big Congratulations to the Experts and you Nitin ji.
@MsJaihind
@MsJaihind 4 года назад
Look at women so knowledge able and clear on subject.
@maitreya.jamkar
@maitreya.jamkar 4 года назад
A discussion on Scientific Research is very very Important for India right now.
@2960kg
@2960kg 4 года назад
Both the experts were very impressive..I am very encouraged that India has such experts who drive such policy discussions
@couponscyber
@couponscyber 4 года назад
Nari Sakthi, really proud of those two women. Indian is in great environment.
@Gyan_Pyasi
@Gyan_Pyasi 4 года назад
Very informative discussion from truly knowledgeable experts. My cobwebs on the principle of NFU and credible deterrence were cleared by the clarity with which the points were dealt with. Thank you Nitin for bringing up such enlightening subjects discussed by such brilliant minds🙏
@kiransahni100
@kiransahni100 4 года назад
Always very well explained discussions and analysis
@roshanpund2203
@roshanpund2203 4 года назад
Such well articulated debate🙏
@mannu9934
@mannu9934 4 года назад
Woooo🔥🔥🔥🔥 I enjoyed it. Respect women 🙏!!
@umardharini2011
@umardharini2011 4 года назад
Thank you so much Mr.NITIN !! for Taking up Very Important topics for discussion ~ BTW Our RESPECT to the Great WOMEN , who are REAL Experts in their own field !! ~ I doubt PAKISTAN doesn't have single fellow in their entire country , with at least 10% of the wisdom & knowledge of these TWO Proud Indian Mothers about National security Subjects !! # JaiHind
@amantri2710
@amantri2710 4 года назад
Great discussion
@saiecorp5646
@saiecorp5646 4 года назад
SratNews Global, you are doing great job and service to nation by bringing such important topics on forefront.
@sagar7757
@sagar7757 4 года назад
I have become fan of both the ladies. Please bring them often in your shows!
@vishnumohan1133
@vishnumohan1133 4 года назад
Nice discussion.good content nithin sir👍
@2010anilshukla
@2010anilshukla 4 года назад
Great to hear the well informed and articulate ladies- double thanks for the show. PS Wonder why people still waste time on TV news?
@Olive_Chap
@Olive_Chap 4 года назад
these things must be displayed in OTA or IAS academies.. hats off to the ladies & obv nitin sir
@ramvaiyacheri3820
@ramvaiyacheri3820 4 года назад
Informative.I am glad for these well informed and artculate ladies both of whom presented their point of view in a way that could be understood by a common man.
@AjeetYadav-xt1tz
@AjeetYadav-xt1tz 4 года назад
India should need to focus on China centric issues and how to counter chinese military..especially space war and in cyber war...
@ramabadranbabu5863
@ramabadranbabu5863 4 года назад
Both the panelists are more resourceful and they gave us a deep insight into the facts of nuclear arsenal and the delivery systems.
@ashokulu
@ashokulu 4 года назад
Wah two empowered charming lady
@pathfinder9547
@pathfinder9547 4 года назад
Sir please do more videos with Manpreet sethi ma'am, she seems to have domain expertise on areas nobody talks about.
@lajwantishahani1225
@lajwantishahani1225 4 года назад
A pertinent discussion with experts without any chest-beating jingoism is exactly what we need in today's political scenario. Good to know where we stand vis-a-vis Pakistan and China. It's not about gender but as a woman, I'm pleased to see women with such expertise leading the national debate in such matters. Also, I've begun to look for your content for an educated presentation on our current defense situation.
@mssrinivas2146
@mssrinivas2146 4 года назад
Nitin ji, please make a video on tactical nuclear weapons and dirty bombs
@mavrik61
@mavrik61 4 года назад
Good work, keep it up
@anuragbari9535
@anuragbari9535 4 года назад
Best Chanel
@rahulsharma-lz2du
@rahulsharma-lz2du 4 года назад
Nitin can be seen smiling a lot in this episode. :-)
@ka3898
@ka3898 4 года назад
😜, it's first or probably one of very few times he hosted ladies, that too 2 at the same time.
@sridharannarasimhan4916
@sridharannarasimhan4916 4 года назад
No-First use will keep our collective conscience clear. Let's keep our heads high and walk tall. We need to save this world for the future generations.
@rakadus
@rakadus 4 года назад
Keep our head high! Fine. Will the head be attached to the body?
@indianmilitary
@indianmilitary 4 года назад
@@rakadus hehe true. Dr Manpreet is talking like a typical lutyens bureaucrat
@jkvel421
@jkvel421 4 года назад
On one side army has the nation, on the other side, a party has the nation... any way in both cases....they are not for their people,...in fact they are here just for the sake of existence....
@alecmisra4964
@alecmisra4964 4 года назад
China's doctrine depends on circumstances, notably what they think they can get away with.
@aashish9100
@aashish9100 4 года назад
A reiteration of the present nuclear policy word by word in the Parliament by Modi himself is enough to open up the jammed ears on both fronts!
@rajprakash1340
@rajprakash1340 4 года назад
Love this channel
@flaminmongrel6955
@flaminmongrel6955 4 года назад
China should remain the centre of all discussions its demise will automatically bear fruits for Indian growth.
@AjeetYadav-xt1tz
@AjeetYadav-xt1tz 4 года назад
Surveillance of Pakistan nuclear programme is easy in all form..than what is the credibility of Pakistan nuke?????even Pakistan nuke can be destroyed in short time by army or airforce.???plz explain.. Is China trying to engage india with Pakistan???
@numanali1997
@numanali1997 4 года назад
Nice joke keep dreaming
@sabdulnasir1
@sabdulnasir1 4 года назад
When are you going to make a video on losing 38,000 KM ? I have subscribed your channel to get notified. Oh. Yes... I pressed the bell icon as well.. 😊
@sabdulnasir1
@sabdulnasir1 4 года назад
"You know we can handle Pakistan" 😊 but anyone who watched this talk, can see that you're looking fully obsessed with Pakistan. Why..? We aren't that much dangerous really..! 😊
@anirbanghosh1984
@anirbanghosh1984 4 года назад
How can Pakistan develop triad if they don't operate the SSBN or SSN whatsoever!!! It is high time for our government to get the US & Russia both on-board regarding the China issue!!
@bharatdhakhada460
@bharatdhakhada460 4 года назад
...US and others are not fools, one cannot have best of both the worlds...
@anirbanghosh1984
@anirbanghosh1984 4 года назад
@@bharatdhakhada460 But regarding Chinese expansionism both the US & Russia especially Russia is very very skeptical with Vladivostok issue!!
@numanali1997
@numanali1997 4 года назад
@@anirbanghosh1984 pakistan already complete nuclear traid babur 3 cruise mesiles from agosta 90 b
@bharatdhakhada460
@bharatdhakhada460 4 года назад
.....its our lack of foresight and resultant prolongation vis-a-vis military procurements preparedness in acquiring new planes platforms due to bofors jinx.....that leaves us with no choice but to approach USSR.....
@bharatdhakhada460
@bharatdhakhada460 4 года назад
@@anirbanghosh1984 bofors jinx weakened or delayed our military preparedness....
@kedarisgreat
@kedarisgreat 4 года назад
Both ladies are articulate and experts in their fields. I was very reassured that such calm and intelligent women are their to guide India. Pleasure to listen them. India’s future is Safe.
@saiecorp5646
@saiecorp5646 4 года назад
Absolutely true.
@jmarj1038
@jmarj1038 4 года назад
Yes we have seen with corona. Had India did not have no first use doctrine which is outdated and to be relegated to Mahabharata today we would not have had China with Tibet,or even Pakistan as a Saguni character. We will be sitting ducks to get more bio wars unleashed and more have lockouts.
@rajatshukla9968
@rajatshukla9968 4 года назад
It was very educational and intelligent podcast and I must say women's r much more subtle and calm in making and taking decisions we need more females like them in our system .. cause I beleive that females could handle pressure to some extent more than a man.. this video made me happy.
@sanketkumar8040
@sanketkumar8040 4 года назад
I agree with roshan mam that with advancement of technology second strike capability can be dodged hence observation is must and indigenous development of new technology is must.this is the reason Russia developed death hand.
@navneethshashank8854
@navneethshashank8854 4 года назад
This is probably my goto channel now for any strategic credible information on security! Thanks Nitin Gokhale and team for your commendable job in making this thought accessible to the broader audience interested in India's security.
@saugatalahiri7287
@saugatalahiri7287 4 года назад
Why hasn’t India gone more public on what Dr. Kanijo mentions that India caught the Chinese ship on missile plorification
@Umpt
@Umpt 4 года назад
Excellent discussion and great to have two female experts which I found more balanced in their views
@upendrashukla1441
@upendrashukla1441 4 года назад
Earlier Chinese had outsourced troubling India to Pak but China has to directly handle India. Things will get estabilised that's for sure.
@mithunghosh6380
@mithunghosh6380 4 года назад
This is called real journalism if u want to get real picture follow Nitin Gokkhle not Arnab Goswami..
@humayunbawkher5372
@humayunbawkher5372 4 года назад
A very relevant discussion (that interesting,y has not been discussed in Indian media). Pakistan reportedly has an abundance of Chinese tactical nuclear missiles & it should not be trusted to be reactive in using them if its borders are threatened in any way. Just hope there is no border escalation.
@noelcastelino6790
@noelcastelino6790 4 года назад
A very calm and rational discussion between inmates in a lunatic asylum. May at least the whales survive.
@sap268
@sap268 4 года назад
Another great discussion. Thank you ladies
@vigisbigtm
@vigisbigtm 3 года назад
Erudite speakers, need to invited more often to discussions.
@abdulsalamarifvkarif7288
@abdulsalamarifvkarif7288 4 года назад
Very informative session about deterrence and latest direction on high tech warfare . Tnx
@gurusastropalmistry2214
@gurusastropalmistry2214 4 года назад
'Should there be a collusion?' Are we dreaming??
@mj1979
@mj1979 4 года назад
Dr. Manpreet was too good in her clarity of thought and articulation
@vishnus5977
@vishnus5977 4 года назад
Excellent Discussion👌
@prashantshukla8545
@prashantshukla8545 4 года назад
Excellent discussion
@s.baskar4319
@s.baskar4319 4 года назад
very good info sir
@AR-os2uw
@AR-os2uw 4 года назад
Nitin, you are fucking Savage. Thank you for this channel and informed discussions !!!!!!! Call me old school sir , but I would rather see males in defence matters.
Далее
Главное рыба есть, а воды нет..
00:54
Meni yerga urdingda
00:20
Просмотров 360 тыс.
11 ming dollarlik uzum
00:43
Просмотров 279 тыс.
The Big Picture: India's Nuclear Doctrine
28:21
Просмотров 37 тыс.
Planning Of Article 370 Removal
43:06
Просмотров 9 млн