Myleah Kushin I don't think you understand what I meant. I was implying that while they can sing her parts, no one can do it exactly like her, mannerisms and voice wise. So therefore, they can't. Have a nice day, sorry not sorry.
the way Jessica sings, definitely stand out in the music. yes that other members are good too, but the fact that no one has the same vocal / pronunciation as her already proven her existence & vocal in snsd can never be replaced. still gonna choose Jessica.
Maksim Li ohh plzz the other members sang it really well most of her parts except for highnotes was just covered by snsd dance line . So it wasn't really that difficult . But i agree with some high notes they should have given sunny
Well Only one can accept to replace her part is Taeyeon in Highnote/Highpart, because Taeyeon&Jessica level like 1st&2nd place in SNSD. It's like Wendy RedVelvet & Yuju GFriend, the other just like Seulgi RedVelvet strong but can't beat them.
Agree! I think every sone want to see the OT9 complete "DIVINE" and "indestructible"live performances not the MV version. It's my opinion. Jessica's high notes in this song always makes me cry . And I also want to see the Catch Me If You can" Jessica's version.All the Jessica"s version in the Internet is not complete QQ.
taeyeon and Jessica is the top 2 of snsd vocalist. Taeyeon high notes is more powerful while jessica have high pitch and soft high notes. Tiffany just cant reach those powerful or high pitch high notes like taeyeon and jessica. also, tiffany's voice is unstable too unlike seohyun.
Yoona- Too soft. Yuri - Too throaty. Sooyoung - Too blcoky. Hyoyeon - Lack articulation. Tiffany - Lacks technique. Seohyun - Can't reach that high. But because she has great technique, it sounds pleasantly decent. Taeyeon - Too powerful. Too strong. Parts that needs a decrescendo (softer parts) she can't do well. And so it loses it's original magic. Sunny - Too much vibrato. The closest to me would be Taeyeon, Sunny & Seohyun. *But this just proves Jessica's voice is so prominent in SNSD's songs. Unrivaled and unmatched.*
i would say yuri sound nasally, tiffany got technique, but totally different with jess style... taeyeon got almost same power same strength with jess, except jess got higher tone voice and thinner sound, while taeyeons voice is fuller and lower tone... but from the clip yuri suprise me the most in mr taxi(its yuri not sooyoung singing jess part) yuri change the vibe of that particular part, for me that part suit her more edit: for mr taxi part its sooyoung not yuri, my mistake..
@@jojo-js8mvI agree with Yuri too nasal but she’s too heady while Tiffany is too throaty. I feel like it would be best if they can sing a bit more relaxed when reaching higher high notes. I feel like Seohyun does a great job but then again she can’t reach the high notes as her timbre is the most neutral but when doing Jessica high notes she adds a bit of a husk in the notes. Sunny suits as well but I find Sunny having too much vibratos like you said but also Sunny doesn’t have the Clear(?} in Her voice. Yoona and Sooyoung does well but Yoona is too airy/soft and lacks technique while Sooyoung just doesn’t have the clear(?} in her voice and lacks dynamics in showing herself off, she does a great job covering tho. Taeyeon is very similar to Jessica but she lacks the higher range. I find Taeyeon voice a bit deep for covering Jessica parts but she does a great job. Hyoyeon is just too Husky and stylistic. So overall I would put it best 1. Taeyeon 2.Sunny 3.Seohyun 4. Tiffany 5.Sooyoung 6.Yoona 7.Yuri 8.Hyoyeon 5-7 is hard. Yuri cover her lines quite well like in Blue Jeans,ITNW,Mr Mr There are sometimes she’s too heady(Kissing You) Yoona does a great job but she lacks power like in IGAB Sooyoung does a great job but lacks Dynamics such as Vibrato and agility. So i say 5-7 is interchangeable. Maybe (4-7)
+A Brand actually i can buy her clothes and all of her shitty collection ;) but i wont because my money is for music and better clothes than that ugly line. I have entire Girls' Generation collection of Cds and stuff so dont even try it Lol
am i too biased or can no one replace sica's stage presence? she seems to be a lot better at connecting with the audience and just taking over the stage. she lets the music take over her, even the little movements she does during her singing parts can't be easily recreated by the others.
Yeah Sica's voice is unique and she can hit high notes really well but I think Soshi managed to cover her parts well except for some of Fany's high notes. Yeah it doesn't sound the same cause we're used to hearing Sica's voice. Every member has a different vocal colour so maybe it's not as perfect as Jessica's but they did well enough in my humble opinion. Hope to see Sica release a solo album soon. I miss her voice. And people .. pls stop comparing Snsd and Jessica .. cause I don't think it's right. Things happened but still she was part of the group and in fans hearts she still is .. Let's stay united and support both sides. Jessica started as a Snsd member and built her confidence and developed her talent. Who knows if she would've become a singer if SM didn'y cast her .. who knows how her life would've turned out. The same goes for the other memers too. Stop making up stories how now Snsd is trash cause Sica is not there or how Sica is nothing now that she's not in SNSD. It's ugly .. and painful. SNSD is what it is because of every single member efforts. It's a group , a team .. not solo. So the fact Sica is not there anymore is painful .. but no that won't end SNSD as long as there are fans supporting them and as long as SNSD have passion for music. So I think Jessica will gain a lot of new things as a solo artist , see new things .. experience them from a diff point of view. SNSD will also grow up even more and develop as people and artists. So the most important is that both Jess and SNSD stay healthy and happy.
+kpopbg 100% Totally absolutely definitely agree with you :) If all the people have the same thought as you that's really good...Let's support soshi as sone and Jessica as maomaos.
+kpopbg This was so well written! lol had to say it :P I don't think they replaced her part as good as hers but they were sort of able to do it good enough to fit the song! I 100% do prefere Jessica's parts tho! :P the songs sound a bit colorless and empty :(
I am not really a kpop fan but youtube brought me here. After watching this, i found out it was a pity to kick Jessica out of the group since she played an important role in most of the songs in past. Nowadays SNSD's new releases are just as common as other girl's groups. I can't hear the special anymore lol.
so what about taeyeon? are we just gonna ignore the fact that snsd still has one of the most powerful female vocalists in kpop and the fact that she still is and always has been a far better vocalist than jessica and the rest of snsd.
+darci lowery Jessica left becuse she dont have time for being a CEO and an Idol, she miss some dance practice and she wanted to take and hiatus thats why the CMIYC is versión whit 9 they recorded when Jessica still in the group and she decided to take an hiatus so the member have to record CMIYC again covering Jessica, S.M and the member do it for the best of GG maybe they are not longer what they were but now member like Yuri and Hyo have the chance to sing and demostrate they are perfect singers too.
its not like they had a choice, we dont know the story yet but recently koreaboo posted about why jessica was "kicked out" that might have been somewhat accurate. so what they say happened was that jessica was planning on going on hiatus and then leaving the group, SM agreed and and in the tokyo dome concert that would be like jessica's goodbye concert thats why they recorded divine and cmiyc to be released at the concert but jessica then said "lol jk i dont want to leave now" but everything was already planned and they considered jessica wasnt taking the group seriously so SM didnt let her back in the group. this might not be true but it makes sense
It's not only that Jessica's voice was so distinctive but that she has the highest voice of all nine (including Taeyeon and Sunny) so anyone covering her higher parts is just not going to sound as effortless.
kicking Jessica out of SNSD/GG was the biggest mistake SM could make! The choreography is off and Jessica brought a unique tone to the group! Her voice made her a stand out in the group and since her departure, the group hasn't been the same and has been failing!
@@balakajan151 ??? Holiday night sales is more than Mr. Mr despite stock issues and SM messed up their promotion due to snsd's contract renewal. Lion Heart era has the most win on music shows, just after Gee. Holiday is their most watched MV in 1st day as full group too. Losing Jessica is surely affect them, but not till they're failing cause losing 1 member 🤭 whoever that 1 member is. Get your fact straight.
@@timmychristian8 lion heart wins the most because of the song itselft but honey the consistency isn't there. See you mentioned lots of comeback already just to justify it. Sorry hun, they really changed. If taeyeon and yoona wasn't there they would fall.
Yoona did a good job. Feel proud. Snsd did well too especially Taeyeon. For me, some Jessica's parts are not easy to cover bcause her voice n tone are different than others.
After Jessica quitting gg I found their new songs weren't as impressive as than the old song. In my opinion, girls generation without Jessica is just ordinary
You Need To accept The Fact! I'm an Exo-l and the 3members Left! When You're a True Sone Don't Just Stan Jessica Stan SNSD! No matter What Happened to the Group! It will make Your Relationship stronger! All you can Do is Just Accept the Fact That She's Not In the MV to Appear! And If you're a True sone In your Eyes They are 8 but In your Heart they are 9 and If your a True Sone You always See them ExtraOrdinary (poor English)
the only one who covered jessica's parts flawlessly is only taeyeon, the rest flop. this is why jessica is the second main vocalist and you can't replace jessica's part with someone else and think that it'll still be flawless
You can really see now that Jessica was the backbone of SNSD she made the songs pop out especially with her adlibs. The way she pronounces the words and sings is so different from any of the members except Taeyeon ( they basically sing the same ).
you cant speak english well so shut up, Tiffany is a very great vocalist and i dont think you can criticice because you are not in worlwide famous girl group😂😂😉
+souna mira Jessica doesn't lipsync pls she sings her live naturally n perfectly, especially her high notes. she can do them easily n rly high without trying. 😉😉 in case udk, snsd doesn't really lipsync
sorry i'm not a hater but idk when tiffany sang jessica's part in divine i just don't like it. no one could replace jessica in that song, she was too perfect and tiffany just meh -_- she is tooooooo louuudd
They have diff. Voice range. Tiff's voice is very powerful and kinda husky. Yes her voice is powerful and jyp agreed on thid one while sica's voive is sweet and kinda soft.
Jessica's presence and voice is as valuable as any other member. No matter how well a member does while doing Jessica's part, it's irreplaceable, simply because it's originally not their part.
Also jessica's voice really adds this character that is really essential to the OT9 SNSD. You can literally hear her voice in every SNSDs unison (when all of them sings). it just never sounds the same without her (lion heart chorus, holiday chorus,)
ugh....like I wish Sicca would just like release a mini album and TOTALLY sing her heart out....because honestly her voice is just so beautiful. I remember when I first heard her sing I immediately assumed she was the leader because I thought her voice was just that good.
Yoona's "we can be divine" really moves me, i don't know why- she has a really sweet voice. That part always made me emotional when Jess sang it and I think Yoona showed that emotion really well. Can't wait for Jessica's solo debut song, I miss her ❤️
These comments are either about A) Tiffany sucks at Jessica's part B) taeyeon and Jessica or C) angered fans thinking they know what really happened between snsd and Jessica I mean at least tiffany tried, it's not like you can do them perfectly either. And stop blaming taeyeon please.
IKR?! Like, of course they won't be able to perfectly cover her lines, not unless they magically get her voice and vocal range. Some people just really need to learn to appreciate the effort the other girls our putting in. They're doing their best and they don't really have a choice considering that Sica's not here anymore. People need to accept that and live with it. And this coming from a huge Sica stan.
Chan Ally Her voice is way too different from Jessica's which make her sound weird when she sing her parts. Also, Jessica's high notes are very smooth while Tiffany struggles to sing the high note properly. It'd be better if they just give it to Sunny.
Obviously Jessica will sound better for most of these because they were assigned to her because they suited her. However if I personally were to rank who did better for each part it'd go like this (sorry this is long but this interests me) Jessica vs Yoona = Tie (they sound similar) Jessica vs Yuri = Jessica Jessica vs Hyoyeon = Tie Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica Jessica vs Tiffany = Jessica Jessica vs Sooyoung = Jessica Jessica vs Seohyun = Seohyun Jessica vs Taeyeon = Taeyeon Jessica vs Taeyeon = Taeyeon Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica Jessica vs Sooyoung = Jessica Jessica vs Tiffany = Jessica Jessica vs Yoona = Jessica Jessica vs Tiffany = Jessica (by far tbh) Jessica vs Yuri = Jessica (but Yuri did fine because she sings the other part like that anyways) Jessica vs Sunny = Tie I guess Jessica vs Sooyoung = Jessica Jessica vs Yoona = Yoona Jessica vs Seohyun = Jessica (Seo had no power there) Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica (Tae did great but it's signature for Sica) Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica Jessica vs Tiffany = Tie Jessica vs Sooyoung = Jessica but Soo is really close Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica Jessica vs Tiffany = Jessica hands down but to be fair Fany is crying Jessica vs Yoona = Jessica but almost Yoona Jessica vs Sunny = Sunny Jessica vs Sunny = Jessica Jessica vs Yoona = Jessica (Yoona's so surprisingly good at her parts though) Jessica vs Yoona = Jessica Jessica vs Seohyun = Jessica Jessica vs Sooyoung = Jessica Jessica vs Seohyun = Seohyun I guess Jessica vs Hyo/Yoon = Jessica just by the fact that they need two girls to hold each other up Jessica vs Yoona = Jessica Jessica vs Taeyeon = Jessica by a little bit
+Him Gookye If she can't do the high note, then why did the writers gave Jessica's line to Tiffany? Why not give it to Taeyeon? If you're the one on stage, you'll be nervous right? Use your brain.
they are all fake people .... I wasn't expecting that from Yuri, Hyo and Seo... I thought they were good people :( Despite Tae is one of my favorites, she is a fucking cold greedy bitch
The thing is that, I'm a sone since 2010.. and I knew Tae when she was a good person... I still love her singing and her talent but she is just not the same... I remeber the TaeSic times... they were really good friends.. but Tae decided to ignore Sica and then everything started..
I am absolutely in love with Sunny's part in MR MR!! I think she does wonderful and adds just a different flavor to the part! I of course like Jessica but I loved that part for Sunny!
+Bella Rose Shes just pathetic! Not every sone is like that. Dont let her stop u from being in the fandom. She cant accept that Jessica is better then Tiffany in vocals and that everyone has their own opnions.. She should get a life! So dont let her bother u
+Bella Rose tiffanys cover in divine was great and how could your ears die if duh u just just have said your deaf duh..... why are many people complaining about tiffany u know she can really sing most of us people cant do that lets stop being rude or mean to her or whatever and everyday and everytime i will always love tiffany
then your are definitely deaf or biased either of the two, cuz tiffany definitely outstand and outperformed every high notes not just jessicas part, sorry but bitterness and jealousy has no cure,.
Hyoyeon is better than jessica in dancing Taeyeon is better than jessica in singing Tiffany is better than jessica in english and fashion Seohyun is better than jessica in musicals Yuri is hotter than jessica anytime Sooyoung is better than jessica in dramas Yoona is better than jessica in beauty and political issues Sunny is better than jessica hosting shows and interviewing So there yo go,
+Kawaii Sone Excuse me, Jessica has left SNSD, can you just shut up, why do you always complain about Jessica? Every mean comment about Jessica has you in it! You didn't even think about that Jessica had sacrifice for SNSD in almost 10 years! If you don't care anything about her, then just SHUT UP! If you don't like her and you still like to talk about her, WOAH, just admit that you're a fan! 너 찐자 미쳤어
+GloriaR Gloria but youroverrated queen is not better than SNSD. Everyone knows that so please dont even try it again or i will send a lot hate against you! :)
Ahmm Tiffany can sing Jessica's part, but please when it comes to highnote please just give it to Taeyeon or Seohyun just please... Yoona and sunny can cover better tho
My goodness those comments, smh. -____- You know, if you don't want to hear someone covering Jessica, might as well QUIT stanning/listening to GG from now on. Cause whatever shit you fuss about Tiffany's singing, Taeyeon's range, Yoo&Soo's singing ability, they will be SINGING sica's part from now on cause they can't leave it blank. I hope you realized that they are singing Jessica's part not because they wanted to prove that they are better singer than her but because THEY CAN'T LEAVE IT BLANK! Get that in your freaking head! Now, if you can't take listening to OLD GG SONGS, bitch please. No one is pushing you to like it. Just leave and keep your "so called opinion" in your ass.
thats because jessica's voice has a higher pitch than taeyeon but however, taeyeon's high notes are more stable than jessica despite the fact that jessica has a wider range. in terms of quality, taeyeon is much better in singing high notes. needless to say that taeyeon covering jessica parts were the best
+BlackJ VIP Actually if you weren't so biased and listened hard you would see tiffany version was better...and this is from someone who is not a sone but likes to listen to other groups and their songs.
They tried to cover her parts but did not give justice..only Jessica can give it's original vibes and lively feel...no one can replace her ♡ she's the best in her part..ONLY JESSICA
Well duh, of course. Its her part so ofcourse its gonna sound better on her because we're already used to her voice on the audio. Also, its not like other members did bad on her part too. They did quite well.
I think sunny would do good covering her parts cause Jessica and Sunny both have squeaky voices(not in a bad way) so it would be okay if sunny does her parts.
+SM9Angels SM and Taeyeon should've thought about that before they agreed to KICK her out. I don't trust the group now....they seem fake to me now. Since they haven't shed their side of the story and continue to remain silent...then I will continue to not like them like I used to. Jessica to this day hasn't forgiven the girls for what they did to her. The longer the group remains silent the more I just don't believe that Soshiville ever existed....total fakeness. They were fake then and they're fake now.
+SM9Angels I love OT9 but I don't think it's bad that Jessica left. Because Sica is gone, the girls are working harder, they have to train like they were on their trainee days and they're pushed to do better. therefore, they're getting better than they were. the members who used to have less lines before, now have more lines and is therefore more recognized. the other members now get more screen time as well.
0614 Rei They'll never be better w/o Jessica. And who cares about lines? Everyone had their role before and everyone had at least one line in most of their songs. What really changed is the realization that there were a couple of personalities that just didn't jive. It's not bad that Jessica left...but it is VERY bad on HOW she left. A member was kicked out of the group and many fans just don't like them as much as before. They still can sing good songs but that trust and devotion to them is not the same. All it would take is for the girls to explain their side...and they chose not to. They took the path that complete silence would make fans forget what happened. Some fans will never forget.
This is my opinion ok: For me, seeing that Jessica has some of the harder parts in songs, and some of them are given to sub-vocals, it makes me proud of them. But it just isn't the same. Jessica has this soft voice that no one can replace but I'm glad the other members can cover her parts
Jessica's parts are perfect for her voice. No one can replace that she has that unique soft, angelic, pure, innocent voice that draws you in once you hear it you can never get enough. Not many of the members have that kind of charisma. They are all great in their own way but Jessica's parts are especially meant for her. No other can change that fact. While, Tiffany's a great singer her voice just doesn't relate to Jessica's if you pay attention closely it sounds like she's shouting/screaming/struggling when she goes to those high notes. While, Jessica cruises through it smoothly. Yoona has similar voice to her but she can't really do that high notes. Taeyon's voice is like the opposite of Jessica's it's too strong, too rough which can easily reach those high notes well but the toughness just isn't doing it.The others are good too but it's never going to be the same.
+Kawaii Sone Umm if ure a true sone u wouldnt say that. I know people are upset that Jessica is no more a part of snsd, but hey, ure being a bit rude here. If youre a true sone, you would respect all of them, including Jessica. They have their own ways.
for me Jessica is really gooood singer she will prove to everyone the she can stand alone when her album is out ....Jessica will always be fine .... i just hope you the one who are not going to be lazy to listen to her songs 😌
Is it wrong to say I feel really anger at them for covering her parts right now . I just do it just does not feel right for them to do that in my opinion I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one who feels like this
What do you want them to do then? Just awkwardly stand there when the person who is no longer in the groups is singing in the back? Lip sync to her parts? What can they do other than cover her parts? Literally this is the most stupid shit I have ever read!! Do they just stop performing their classics and hits?!? Hell nah
So your saying I have no right to be anger their are other people who are also not happy about it . If your find with it fine that's good for you but don't be mad at me for what I feel .
+roxas namine I understand u... I'm not angry, instead I'm rly sad... As for covering her parts, they have no choice but to do it. If its her voice on the background while one of them lip syncs her parts, I think GG would be sad if the heard her but she's not there anymore. It's also not possible if they don't sing those old songs like starting fresh.... I can understand ur anger becuz Jess was my bias and the person I watch the most whenever they show up and I'm sad that she's left but there's no other option
People saying when Tiffany is covering Jessica parts she's off key ? Wtf ? If any of you guys know anything about music 😂 each member has THEIR own voice pitch ( High or low ) XD Tiffany is on the right key for HER VOICE 😩 her voice is not the same as Jessica so the key won't be the same 🤔 and Jessica. Voice is naturally higher than Tiffany so OBVIOUSLY when Tiffany is covering her notes won't be higher XD
Tbh when a member of a certain group left, there's literally no one can replace the left member's position. I personally find it kinda weird hearing other soshi member's voice replacing sica's even tho its taeyeon the main vocal. BUT the only good thing is I can hear the dancers line's voice more now especially yoona's :)
Speaking as a professional from the states, one thing this vid makes obvious is how much Jessica carried the group live. The clips with her are SO much cleaner on the bottom end, without her the sound crew is boosting the bass hard. This is a common trick in sound reinforcement when the top end is weak, over play the bottom end, it muddies things up and covers a lot of what would be obvious flaws otherwise. I don't know this group or situation at all to speak of, but Jessica was def the principle vocal talent, her voice is dynamic and has a timber that's exceptional, quite angelic. Shame it went the way it did, but welcome to the music business...it's a cutthroat world and jealousy has wrecked a LOT of acts, trust me.
Taeyeon > Seohyun > Tiffany > Sunny> Jessica ! (jessica is last because she cant sing live like the rest does, "with energy", when jessica sings/or playback the most of times, she dont put energy she sings like a cat whos dying.)
For me ,my girls sound perfect in every line they sing , i will love them for ever no matter what other people can think about it. SNSD FIGHTING! JESSICA JUNG FIGHTING! SONES FIGHTING! EVERYBODY FIGHTING!
![제시카 정_Jessica VS Girls' Generation_소녀시대 [Singing parts comparisons]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
