1 DEAD, another hospitalized after Fort Pierce PLANE CRASH!

Подписаться 15 тыс.

Просмотров 131 тыс.

50% 1

A Piper PA-44-180 Seminole, crashed during a go around at Treasure Coast International Airport (FPR/KFPR), Fort Pierce, Florida.
The aircraft, using callsign WCP643 "Whitecap 643", was operating on a training flight out of KFPR. The flight radioed Fort Pierce Tower that they wanted to do an ILS missed approach to runway 10R.
One occupant perished and the other suffered serious injuries and the aircraft was destroyed on March 30, 2024.
📌Details: aviation-safety.net/wikibase/...
📌Video: • Plane crash leaves one...
00:00 Intro
00:04 Description of the situation
00:24 Inbound for ILS approach and missed approach
01:52 "Traffic pattern went wrong"
02:06 Declaring an emergency
Join this channel to get access to the perks:
/ @the_flight_records
#aviation #realatc #avgeek
____________________________
IMPORTANT:
This video is all about education. It's designed to give aspiring pilots and air traffic controllers a taste of real-world situations through example scenarios and helpful info. But that's not all! Current pilots and controllers can also benefit by listening to real radio communications from around the globe. This helps them stay sharp and think about how they might handle similar situations in the future.
To create these videos, I keep my ear to the ground on major aviation news and events. I check the dates and time zones to see if I can find recordings of the radio conversations. Then, I become a bit of a broken record myself, listening to them repeatedly to create subtitles and identify key moments. Finally, I whip up some animations (or grab them from ADS-B websites) and pull it all together into a neat package.
____________________________
► e-mail: theflightrecords@gmail.com
Radio conversations: www.liveatc.net/
Map: www.google.com/maps/

Опубликовано:

19 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 499

@GFSwinger1693 2 месяца назад

22 year-old Maria Valentina Guillen was the person who perished. RIP young lady.

@pixamite1 2 месяца назад

🙏🏼

@marcomm7828 2 месяца назад

From what I've learned, she was a certified flight instructor, but sounded more like student here. I've been around aviation for quite some time, but never heard of anyone being an instructor at age like this. I know it doesn't take much to become one, but this accident just proves the requirements should be way higher. Still feel bad for the young lady. May she rest in peace and the student recovers well.

@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 2 месяца назад

@@marcomm7828I was an instructor at 21. It’s perfectly fine and it’s how the majority of pilots in the USA started their flying career. The requirements are fine and age has zero to do with it.

@johnh5358 2 месяца назад

My instructor is 21... a few years younger than me. @@marcomm7828

@marcomm7828 2 месяца назад

yeah, I've known a few at around 25, but did prefer the experienced ones personally. It just appears to me, she kinda panicked in this distress situation, but who knows. I don't wanna play smart here, it's just how I feel about it..

@ddddd1168 2 месяца назад

Valentina was my instructor for my discovery flight back in December of 2022. She created an unforgettable experience and I have so much admiration in my heart for her. She was the sweetest woman and made sure I was comfortable while still having a fun time. Thoughts and prayers to all of her loved ones and those affected. Rest in peace pretty girl

@V1AbortV2 2 месяца назад

You’re a cuck, ya know that?!

@tywingfield6953 Месяц назад

Well said.

@anthonycarr6732 2 месяца назад

April 11, 2011. My Navajo went down at KRIC. I survived with 65% burns, 2 amputated fingers, numerous broken bones, a completely destroyed and rebuilt nose, and 68 total surgeries (so far) for skin grafts, tissue reconstruction, and laser scar revision. I was on a fentanyl drip in a medically induced coma for over a month. NEVER take any day for granted. Each day we have is a gift. God bless.

@someotherdude 2 месяца назад

Small airplanes are just a dance with death. A very interesting pursuit, but ultimately not worth it for about 99% of us.

@anthonycarr6732 2 месяца назад

I completely agree with you. It’s so sad how many people are killed in small aircraft.

@andyburk4825 2 месяца назад

Here's hoping you're well along in your recovery . Why did you pull back both throttles ?

@emergencylowmaneuvering7350 2 месяца назад

TOO HIGH AOA. STALLED A strong airplane hard to stall. Panic Pull?

@user-ej9jq2zf1y 2 месяца назад

Wow! Sounds like it was a miracle you survived period!!!

@carloseperezmontes2462 2 месяца назад

I was a MEI with more than 250 hours of FT in a Seminole. If the engine dies on final, the plane is landing, period. That machine doesn't safely fly with one engine. Go around isn't an option.

@CanardBoulevard 2 месяца назад

Yup. I did all my multi rating in a Seminole. On my multi commercial checkride (which incorporated a multi instrument ride as well), I had to do a DME arc with one engine shut down (not just feathered). I could not for the life of me get it started again, I knew landing on one engine was a "you get one chance" deal - no going around. On the way back to the airport, which took about ten minutes, I did everything to get that engine going again, and finally got it to kick over and start, not long before I arrived in the pattern. Big sigh of relief!

@Willaev 2 месяца назад

It depends on when/where on final that the engine dies.

@Aonexia 2 месяца назад

Interesting... Do you think it is the shorter wingspan, coupled with the heavy dated engines?

@VLove-CFII 2 месяца назад

Oh great! I got my Commercial MEL rating in a Seminole.

@jarrettleto 2 месяца назад

I fly a baron and yeah priority is to land it at all cost, if I'm truly out of runway you need to know that before youre too low and if im going around though it's going to be straight out for like 10 miles so I can get some altitude before I turn back.

@eddylauterback1312 2 месяца назад

When she reported souls on board before declaring an emergency or mayday or something, it was SAD. You knew they were in trouble

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

I'm trying to understand why she mentioned souls on board so soon instead of focussing on flying the plane. Is doing so part of that flight school's training?

@PostcardsfromAlaska 2 месяца назад

Communicate comes after aviate. When you have an emergency, you’re in the drivers seat. You don’t ask. Just do.

@just_another_brick_in_the_wall 2 месяца назад

Devil is in the details.

@chrisvickers1262 2 месяца назад

Actually it comes after navigate as well.

@kidlat9545 2 месяца назад

Aviate, Navigate, Communicate

@mark1015 2 месяца назад

She sounded so unsure and overwhelmed. :(

@Dhanushaglitter 2 месяца назад

She didn’t sound overwhelmed

@MartianSolarbuddy 2 месяца назад

She sounded “resigned,” one of the five danger-attitudes.

@hillarynicole5089 2 месяца назад

How would you sound in the air during an emergency?

@V1AbortV2 2 месяца назад

…like every single other FEMALE PILOT in aviation!

@Chriscutfries7 2 месяца назад

@@V1AbortV2How dare you, you nasty ignorant sexist, racist shuck

@jimosborne2 2 месяца назад

That went bad extremely quickly. As a former instructor, I have difficulty understanding how the plane couldn’t land safely- on either runway or anywhere on the airport- from a position on short final. Was she too high or was the instructor confused by something the controller said? Was the student switched from a go around mode to a landing mode at last second? In any event, fly the airplane first. and stop talking to ATC until the aircraft is stable.Very sad scenario. RIP.

@marcospark2803 2 месяца назад

Too many questions, we need to wait for the investigation report

@jimosborne2 2 месяца назад

@@marcospark2803 hopefully whoever survived can be interviewed because there’s no other way to know what happened in the cockpit

@JOSHL50 2 месяца назад

that is a lot of quarterbacking for a crash that just occurred a couple of days ago. let the investigators do their job. rip to the person who died and get well to the person who is in hospital.

@jimosborne2 2 месяца назад

@@JOSHL50asking questions isn’t the same as quarterbacking in my book.

@sesvid 2 месяца назад

My guess will be that the instructor took the controls at some point and flew the aircraft first. She then decided by herself to continue to communicate. Also it could be possible they started first the go around but decided to lad instead, but being too high. This could explain the request for another runway. We will have to wait for the final report. But it already shows how fast this can go south.

@erickborling1302 2 месяца назад

With a proprietary FAA-approved callsign, they're clearly a training operation. They must have been doing the one-engine-inoperative ILS approach for the pilot's Comm'l Multi-engine rating. Training in twins requires a high degree of safety awareness and risk-management, and a highly skilled instructor. Terrible sad mishap. Terrible. I expect a blancolirio brief on this accident soon.

@christianforero. 2 месяца назад

Valentina was an incredible instructor, about to become a 4 bar instructor and I’m 100% sure she would’ve landed the aircraft if the scenario presented here was accurate but it isn’t, the comms are delayed and she was actually way closer to the middle of the runway when she lost the right engine. Everybody no matter how good u think you are has a shock moment (around 10 secs) in unexpected scenarios like this one, she chose to turn right and I’m sure she had a reason for it unfortunately 1 mistake is enough for everything to go south and that turn in combination with a slight pitch caused the spin. It’s easy to judge when you are not the one in her position but let’s have some respect for the family.

@gabrielakukolkaraoke4862 2 месяца назад

Soy tía de Valentina, prime hermana de su mamá, estamos todos destrozados😢

@yungrichnbroke5199 2 месяца назад

It seemed obvious to me that they must’ve been too high to make the runway. Losing the engine halfway down the runway while at 500 feet and moving fast isn’t a good situation. Lose it at minimums sure go straight ahead. In the climb after a possibly early missed? Your options aren’t so clear cut anymore.

@christianforero. 2 месяца назад

@@gabrielakukolkaraoke4862 Mi más sentido pésame, siempre recordaré a Vale como la increíble y linda persona que fue, yo era su roommate desde que llegue hace más de 1 año y solo tengo buenos recuerdos con ella, a los meses de llegar nos fuimos al downtown de fort pierce y me mostró el centro de la ciudad, tomamos fotos (me mostró su escultura favorita de la cual tengo fotos de ese día) y me contó que su papa a penas llegó ella por acá, le dibujo un mapa de como movilizarse dentro de fort pierce, nos reímos y le dije que eso no lo hace cualquier papa, ayer me vi con los familiares en la casa pero lamentablemente no supe como decirles cuanto lamentaba su perdida, les mando un fuerte abrazo a todos y sepan que Vale era muy querida por aquí y no será olvidada, cuídense mucho.

@christianforero. 2 месяца назад

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

No disrespect to Valentina, but a multi instructor (as any multi pilot) has to expect an engine failure at any time. It shouldn't take ten seconds to start to take action.

@cageordie 2 месяца назад

I tried this in a simulator. The best I could do was accelerate and dive to get cleaned up and then limp along. If I tried anything more aggressive I just spun towards the dead engine. I fear that the simulations these days are much more accurate than they used to be. So their only chance really was to power off the good engine and land straight ahead. At least crash upright. But I don't know what altitude they were at. Hopefully Blancolirio will analyze this crash.

@08turboSS 2 месяца назад

First two things, full pwr good engine, opposite rudder to counter, push yoke forward get nose down and DO NOT clean up the plane if you have any flaps and gear out, your asking for a stall spin and thats exactly what flight path lopks like along with rapid loas of speed combined with possibly the student (female) on controls witj cfi at same time, not good in any way.

@cageordie 2 месяца назад

@08turboSS And you killed them. Because you jammed in full power before accelerating above Vmc. So you didn't have the rudder authority, and you yawed due to asymmetric thrust, spun from low altitude, and crashed before you could even get the power off and try to recover from your error.

@CFITOMAHAWK 2 месяца назад

@@08turboSS LOL.. DO NOT CLEAN UP THE AIRPLANE? How the hell will you not go down with all that drag of flaps and gear? Dont bullshit us. YOU HAVE TO CLEAN FLAPS AND GEAR TOO OR WONT CLIMB.

@TheSoaringChannel 2 месяца назад

In any twin - that becomes single - it really is a glider. A really crap glider. If you lose an engine, your hands are on the throttles for a freaking reason. Close them both, pick a spot, and pray you survive. Crashing right side up is a whole lot better than crashing nose down inverted.

@TheSoaringChannel 2 месяца назад

@@cageordiewhen you do practice approaches - you always fly it above VYSE and the Seminole VMC is above stall speed so what are you even on about? Do you think they're flying an Aerostar or something? I have a lot of hours in Piper twins, including the Seminole. That's hogwash what you just asserted. It might apply in a 310, Baron, whatever. But certainly not if you fly approaches properly. All aircraft you fly the approach above VMC or at VYSE in case of a failure, so you can make it to the ground on the one remaining. In some light twins, you do a go around --- highly unusual to be able to do so. We had a Seneca with a Robertson STOL kit that was an exception to the single engine = crashing soon rule. That's the only light twin I've flown that would legitimately fly on one. And it was because (yes, in the STC as well) of the STOL kit. I loved that plane. If I could still have it today, I would. So easy to fly well! You always clean up the airplane AS you smoothly apply power. If possible, keep the descent going until it's clean so it cleans up even faster. If it won't do a go around - full flaps, idle, and dive for whatever runway or field is ahead. I don't care. That's more survivable than stalling on one engine.

@CFITOMAHAWK 2 месяца назад

Former ME CFI. That looked like a miss approach single engine actual. She tried to land on runway 14 but overshot it. Then on the single engine go around she let it VMC roll and down it went.

@kathrynslye471 2 месяца назад

This is so very sad. A terrible place to lose an engine in an aircraft that simply doesn’t fly on one. Two lessons/reminders for the rest of us to possibly take away from this tragedy are: 1) to remember that in an emergency all surfaces are now “runways”; grass, taxiways, and open areas are all to be considered as viable landing areas so don’t fixate on the actual runway, 2) and do whatever it takes to NOT stall spin; always fly through the crash as controlled and level as possible.

@jimmiphaze5785 2 месяца назад

I'm sorry to hear that

@xxhockeymaster03xx 2 месяца назад

This flight school seriously needs investigated.. two fatal crashes in 6month span WITH CFIs onboard… Why on earth would you attempt to go around single engine in a Semiole??????????? At ATP we taught if you lose an engine in the PA44, you LAND at all costs straight ahead! No turning!! Its literally safer to bust minimuns and attempt to land than it is to go around single engine in a seminole… RIP😔

@xheralt 2 месяца назад

"Landing at all costs" is precisely what was attempted here, and is precisely WHY the crash. While counterintuitive, clawing for altitude gain and doing the full go-around would have been a better idea. If _simulated_ single engine failure at the moment equals go-round, _so does a real failure._ Unless the GOOD engine failed, and they were now gliding?

@xxhockeymaster03xx 2 месяца назад

@@xheralt what are you talking about? Low to to the ground in a seminole, land straight ahead. What went wrong is she tried to turn low to the ground (PROBABLY into the bad engine making things even worse) on a single engine and land on 14 when she was already lined up with 10R! Should have landed on 10R.. even if it meant land long. I really hope an actual failure happened and this wasnt all apart of a simulated failure…

@johnbasiglone1219 2 месяца назад

@@xxhockeymaster03xx I agree 100% and I am sick of all these phony virtue signalers who feign wringing their hands and gnashing their teeth when these people make hideous decisions and auger-in; they know nothing of the A/Cs performance and have next to no REAL WORLD flying experience. This is glaring to me, just as it was to you. People are flying today and being by trained by people who do not have the requisite body of knowledge to be at the controls of and aircraft and especially should not be instructing people on learning to fly an aircraft. Just look at the pilots in the RU-vid wonderland, that speaks for itself. Also, the only mishap debrief I am inclined to listen to, is Dan Gryder. Like his personality or not, he is not going to sugarcoat it, nor be afraid to speculate on the cause of the mishap for fear of offending the snowflakes in the audience. This is the court of public opinion, not a court of law. We are entitled to share our opinion, especially when we may have a little more real world experience flying the world than many of these content creators or virtue signaler.

@V1AbortV2 2 месяца назад

That’s what happens when these FL flight schools cater to female and MINORITY foreigners! You’re going to have a high accident rate!

@steven2145 2 месяца назад

@@xxhockeymaster03xx This....put it down even if you end up on the grass past the end of the runway, wheels up and even hitting the fence after skidding. If she was at Vref on final and had enough power to make that turn, she could have slammed it in on 10R. She may have had it in her mind to save the airplane and land it.

@JohnChuprun 2 месяца назад

Really confused how a flight with an instructor could crash a small twin when right over top of an airport with runways in every direction. All power off, put it down wherever an open space exists, grass, pavement, doesn't matter. Don't stall and spin at 100 feet. Sad to see.

@jadewickenheiser6776 2 месяца назад

We had the Chief flight instructor and a student gear up a Seminole because they forgot to put the landing gear down.

@Jimmer-tr6bi 2 месяца назад

As an instructors with barely any hours, becoming instructors to build time, is that what you’re referring to :-)

@Dhanushaglitter 2 месяца назад

Don’t talk if you don’t know what happened

@hillarynicole5089 2 месяца назад

She declared the emergency before the go around. She used the memory items we are taught at my school and the ACS. “Gear up, flaps up, full prop, power, mixture, etc” and when you’re this low, she should have idled the engines and landed straight in but she already lost directional control banking towards the inop engine (on the right) which is why she made an attempt to land on 14

@JohnChuprun 2 месяца назад

@@hillarynicole5089 Spent too much time worrying about communicating, trying to declare an emergency, worrying about souls on board and how much fuel left... worst stuff to be focusing on during a high stress and immediate situation. There was no presence of mind about what to do during an emergency before beginning the approach, something that should always be briefed or already thought of in the past. There must be some training about how marginal a PA44 is on single engine, especially in a go-around? it's not a 737.

@gumbyshrimp2606 2 месяца назад

Florida general aviation having a rough time recently

@Aonexia 2 месяца назад

Sure thing, by so many aviation accidents in the past year. I'm in Kissimmee, Florida near the home of "Crazy Horse- P-51 Mustang." It's been a heartbreaking 2 years in general aviation for this state.

@gumbyshrimp2606 2 месяца назад

@@Aonexia guessing it’s just because the weather down there is warm so people are flying.

@Aonexia 2 месяца назад

@@gumbyshrimp2606 I guess...

@freakfly23 2 месяца назад

Atc and pilot here. Lot's of training mixed with a lot of established ga, with a lot of commercial traffic. Flying cross country is like space invaders.

@Aonexia 2 месяца назад

@@freakfly23 True... Thanks for the reply. I so get the "Space Invaders" analogy. Haaa... I love you guy's!

@bct_planespotter5598 2 месяца назад

I only have 13 hours of multi time but form I learned that if you have a dead engine in the landing configuration that thing is not climbing, you have no othe option but to put it on the ground. My guess is that they lost their right engine, tried to climb, got too slow, and entered a Vmc roll at a very low altitude. Rest in peace to the pilot who passed away

@MiguelAlejandro1969 2 месяца назад

Con tren abajo y un motor muerto es imposible si pierdes la mínima velocidad de control poder ir al aire,girar y ascender. Simplemente sigue recto sin potencia y aterriza adelante donde sea. Es así?

@Taino505 2 месяца назад

Si.

@robertwaldo 2 месяца назад

Most twins are disasters on one engine close to the ground and dirty. VMC is the speed just before the crash. Pilots still use it and they still die.

@bct_planespotter5598 2 месяца назад

Yep, got below Vmc and lost control, that's how they flipped

@EllieM_Travels 2 месяца назад

This is so sad to hear. I lived in Vero S just north of Fort Pierce, and I knew of several pilots who flew to and from both air fields. My heart goes out to those involved and their families.

@zaynewyo8424 2 месяца назад

🙏

@Taino505 2 месяца назад

There must be security cameras footage of the last few seconds of this accident. I’m surprised that nothing additional has been published in two weeks. Also waiting to hear the accounts as related by the survivor student.

@RegularItemShow 2 месяца назад

Rip. Looking forward to ntsb report.

@backandforthupanddow 2 месяца назад

Very sad. Breaks my heart.

@firemedic5100 2 месяца назад

Well, I wasn't flying in that pattern, and I was confused

@gravesclayton3604 2 месяца назад

Same thing, same day, in Truckee Nevada, only, there they had snow, ice, 1/2 mile visibility, and mountains, and a non-precision localizer missed approach. Both in NV perished.

@xxhockeymaster03xx 2 месяца назад

Non-precision ILS? What? Theres no such thing.

@michaelhoffmann2891 2 месяца назад

@@xxhockeymaster03xx Unless my charts are hopelessly out of date, KTRK has 3 RNAVs, no LOC/ILS at all. 14.5deg offset, ouch. Certainly non-precision at least.

@xxhockeymaster03xx 2 месяца назад

@@michaelhoffmann2891 he said non-precision ILS approach initially but corrected it to localizer.

@davidbeattie1366 Месяц назад

@@xxhockeymaster03xx Localizer approach uses same beam. You can be cleared for an ILS approach “Glide slope inop”.

@xxhockeymaster03xx Месяц назад

@@davidbeattie1366 thats not the point. He initially said “non-precision ILS”. He corrected it to say “non-precision localizer” after i pointed that mistake out. There is no such thing as a “non precision ILS”.

@briancooney9952 2 месяца назад

These other pilots need to listen to what's going on before keying up their mics! Talk about complete lack of situational awareness. 1. When someone declares an emergency, you open your ears and don't step on them! 2. When you're approaching an airspace, don't just dial up the freq and blab. Listen for a bit first!

@FlyingNDriving 2 месяца назад

Problem is not a single mayday call, atc basically had to declare the emergency

@briancooney9952 2 месяца назад

@@FlyingNDriving Exactly!

@redbaron6805 Месяц назад

@@FlyingNDriving She was cleared for the Option, meaning she was cleared to land already. The problem was trying to return to the pattern. The Seminole with the gear down will not climb on a single engine, so she needed to use the remaining runway of 10R, and just use the grass, the fence and the vegetation ahead. Fortunately at that airport, there are no buildings after the fence...

@davidbolinsky1750 2 месяца назад

@igclapp It's really hard to say what she should have done in that case without knowing what the chain of events that preceeded the crash. You could say landing in the grass is better then what appeared to be them spinning into the ground. I think she was trying to fix the problem. That is the worse case scenario for an engine failure. Approach speed, flaps out, and gear down. And listening to the video, it looked like she had around 70 seconds from engine failure to the end. I use to go to Aviator. I even was an instructor there. This is all just really sad.

@essel23fly 2 месяца назад

So the engine failed after they went around?

@MeerkatADV 2 месяца назад

Guessing at this point, but maybe lost the right engine. Then stalled the right wing when they tried to turn to 14. Whatever they did was obviously too abrupt for the aircraft and they came down uncontrolled.

@richwilde4908 2 месяца назад

You don’t ever turn into the dead engine.

@BlueSkyUp_EU 2 месяца назад

I think you may be on to something. There's a panicked "635" comm at about 02:32 that I was trying to make sense of. I think it happens just as 643 turns right, so what we hear might be his reaction to seeing the plane flipping around after the wing stall. It might also explain why the plane crashed with the gear side up.

@user-lm2ix1xd4c 2 месяца назад

@@richwilde4908 right but the plane crashed, so they may have attempted to, leading to the crash is what is being said, obviously

@richwilde4908 2 месяца назад

@@user-lm2ix1xd4c that’s why you don’t turn into the dead engine.

@user-lm2ix1xd4c 2 месяца назад

@@richwilde4908 well no shit lol

@BeakerSteve 2 месяца назад

Prayers to all those impacted by the incident.

@zaynewyo8424 2 месяца назад

🙏

@V1AbortV2 2 месяца назад

You’re a cuck, ya know that?

@jamesa5720 2 месяца назад

Many of the comments have been about immigrants and language and some people showing their colors. But the issue is not about accents and immigrants, it is about the need and requirement for clear and concise language between pilots and Controllers...and that is not negotiable. Demanding that in no way is discriminatory against any citizen's origin, it is about safety in a complex three-dimensional world that is getting more and more crowded. Come on people!

@user-lm2ix1xd4c 2 месяца назад

agree its not about accents or immigrants whatsoever. too many racist sheep these days, not enough self-initiated thought - racist groupthink. if problems ARE being caused by communication breakdowns between english-first and non-english-first speakers, then the problem lies with the regulations, standards, and efficacy of the safety protocols that must be in place to curb those potential communication barriers. fucking obviously. the problem certainly does not lie in non-english-language speakers simply existing as pilots. i cannot with people.

@kewkabe 2 месяца назад

You can't have clear and concise communication if someone has an undecipherable accent and poor English language skills. By the way most these foreign students are here on student/work visas, not immigrant visas.

@JackIanLin 2 месяца назад

I’m was immigrant child and used to be a school teacher in a predominantly immigrant school as a a grown up. One of the stupidest things I keep seeing is monolingual Americans thinking that shouting the same words louder will help someone understand. They’re just ignorant and xenophobic.

@JackIanLin 2 месяца назад

@@kewkabe aviation English is a highly specialized version of English that is designed to specifically mitigate differences in accents and dialect. Everyone one these highly motivated individuals has to pass ICAO English proficiency tests. You don’t have to have a beer with them but you also don’t have to be a nationalistic prick.

@cdncitizen4700 2 месяца назад

@@kewkabe The unclear communications seems to mirror the lack of flying capabilities. Given they declared an emergency, they sure weren't flying like one.

@douglasthompson2740 2 месяца назад

I sometimes wonder if the ATCs are conducting a contest on how fast and how garbled they can communicate vital information. You would think clarity would come first. On some of these recordings you get a concise and easily understandable radio call and on a lot you get what sounds like a burst of static. Are they trying to confuse?

@andremichau2455 2 месяца назад

The single biggest complaint I have about communication between pilots and ATC is the unnecessarily hurried speed of speech.

@markcardwell 2 месяца назад

RIP

@kehreazerith3016 2 месяца назад

I think there are bots in the comments because they're all screaming about the pilot's English accent, her speaking was clear and concise.

@AndrewGrey22 2 месяца назад

Yeah, her thinking and preparedness, not so much.

@blair7473 2 месяца назад

@@AndrewGrey22it’s called panic go play MSFS you non pilot 😊

@davidbeattie1366 Месяц назад

Sad that aviation in the USA attracts racist, misogynist xenophobes who believe that only WHITE, MALE Americans can fly airplanes. They are proven wrong thousands of times a day when foreign pilots safely aviate around the world. As far as accents are concerned, I hope these twits don’t ever fly overseas where everyone has an accent. Their head may just burst at the challenge.

@jaredjones6292 2 месяца назад

Question: Did 635 step on top of 643 radio call while she was talking to the tower after declaring an emergency?

@johnpatrick1588 2 месяца назад

Another sad story. It is really frustrating when there is an "instructor" involved in an accident. Other things I noticed were the poor radio communications skills all around except for the controller.

@a_goblue2023 2 месяца назад

The controller confused 2 different planes, he confused them just as much

@BlueSkyUp_EU 2 месяца назад

I think we shouldn't jump to conclusions about the instructor just based on what we know at this point. There could have been something terribly wrong with the plane. Or the student might have gotten scared and pulled up all of a sudden causing a stall.

@cfm1337 2 месяца назад

@@a_goblue2023 this was after he witnessed the plane crash. Would love to see how calm you stay in a situation like this.

@a_goblue2023 2 месяца назад

@@cfm1337 your job as a controller is to stay calm in situations like this, if you can handle it don’t become a controller, errors like that in a big airport could cause major issues

@GOOBENsticks 2 месяца назад

@@a_goblue2023 You can stay calm and still slip up by saying the wrong number for two very similar names. Especially when one of them is so in your mind due to a crash. And communication works two ways, you're simultaneously calling the pilots incompetent if they did not realize the controller's MINOR error and correct it. Everyone involved worked through this slip up seamlessly, and you're here calling for them to be robots.

@jamesa5720 2 месяца назад

I am a former glider pilot, so not as cued into communication protocol as many commenting might be, but I wonder if they could have declared an emergency sooner so the Tower could have handled things differently? And also the nature of the problem. But it is unclear to me when the emergency surfaced.

@cageordie 2 месяца назад

They could, but they'd have been better landing and worrying about telling people why later.

@BlueSkyUp_EU 2 месяца назад

Truth is that is little ATC can do other than clearing up the airspace around you and maybe providing clearances for approach and landing. It's up to the pilot to fly the plane and make a safe landing. In extreme emergencies you don't even have to waste time and energy with comms. You just focus on landing the plane and do the explaining later. In this particular case they were so close to the runaway that is extremely shocking and sad to see how it all ended...

@cageordie 2 месяца назад

@@BlueSkyUp_EU Once you have called MAYDAY it's all up to you, ATC can give you help, but you don't need clearance to do anything. Even a military airfield will allow you to land once you say the three magic words. Very few pilots get that in the US. Listen to the Thompson 757 MAYDAY at Manchester, the pilot doesn't ask for directions he tells ATC what he's doing, because that was an ex RAF pilot and he knows how this works. UK ATC are very accommodating too. I've only ever heard one airport try to turn away an emergency and that controller chose the wrong person. That was Scott Purdue in a B-25 at Las Vegas McCarran. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-F8fj9VoH5SA.html

@michaeljuster67 2 месяца назад

Great post Christian. So sorry for what happened 😪 Eng fail right when you add power to do a missed app, is THE worst thing in a low powered twin. May Valentina rest in peace 😪 And to the keyboard warriors - 2000 hours as a MEI..and another 16k in easy overpowered airplanes .

@Daishi0861 2 месяца назад

Not sure what ATC could've handled differently, to be honest. The announcement of the emergency wasn't really the issue so much as handling the aircraft. Flying one-engine in a light twin like the semi at low speed is a pretty critical situation and regardless of how soon the ATC was made aware of the emergency, the pilot can land and discuss it later.

@Bren39 2 месяца назад

Usually on these instructional flights.. The instructor does the radios.. So i think she was the instructor. Sounds like they were doing simulated engine out... Either the student stomped on the wrong pedal or they had a real engine out. Even though generally going around single engine on these light twins is not a good idea.. Changing runways while low and maybe unstable was definitely not a good one.

@Leo-fk9ch 2 месяца назад

MEII here. Absolutely never, ever intentionally idle or shut down an engine that low at that speed. Never. This must be part of the training pre flight rule from instructor to student.

@briancooney9952 2 месяца назад

Watch again and listen. they were doing practice instrument approaches. By the time a student is in instrument training, their radio work needs to be WAY better than this.

@user-lm2ix1xd4c 2 месяца назад

@@briancooney9952 but that's not the student on the radio is what the first person is saying.

@dakotaconners107 2 месяца назад

@@user-lm2ix1xd4c could be the first person is guessing because she was the student.

@kennyr5906 2 месяца назад

They were probably doing a single engine instrument approach (as req for the exam), but under no circumstance you should be doing single engine go arounds. Either shut down the engine and do a full stop taxi back (pretty stupid if you ask me) or idle one and throttle both back up upon touch down for the go around.

@sultankaplan8015 2 месяца назад

RIP 🙏🏻

@vfx7t 2 месяца назад

Rip !

@Taino505 2 месяца назад

I've replayed this flight over twenty times on Flightradar24.. She was at 50ft crossing the threshold of RW14, at 68kts heading east. She then gradually turned south, holding altitude at 25ft. Then quickly descended towards RW14 but crossed it at a right angle and heading towards some structures. One appears to be a restaurant. Now she's showing zero altitude but at 60kts and turning sharply right (north) and avoiding buildings but barely slowing down until the plane apparently flipped. The pictures show the landing gear lowered. I believe that if they hadn't flipped we'd be telling a different story.

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

I believe you need to add 250 feet to those altitude figures due to the altimeter setting of 30.17.

@Taino505 2 месяца назад

@@igclapp so you’re saying she was at 300ft over the runway?

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

@@Taino505 Yes, between 250 and 325 feet MSL, which is about 225 to 300 feet above the runway.

@mikeramsey9747 2 месяца назад

Definitely some confusion on the controllers part, I don't understand why the incident aircraft appeared to attempt to circle vs, just landing on the crossing runway, I'm not hearing anyone else in the tower to help the controller (sounds like he is in the tower by himself).

@RetreadPhoto 2 месяца назад

Holiday weekend. Maybe trying to trim it out and keep wings level?

@bradmarcum2927 2 месяца назад

She was cleared any runway. She indicated single engine. VMC rollover.

@Iseeyoulurking12 2 месяца назад

My guess is she was too high to land on 10R and attempted to bleed off altitude by landing on 14L but doing so turned to sharply and stalled

@betacam22 2 месяца назад

It's sad. So young Girl.

@Benis650 2 месяца назад

RIP....I got so many question about this incident, :/

@RaspySquares 2 месяца назад

Which number AQP scenario is this?

@outwiththem 2 месяца назад

Single Engine Go Around and VMC Roll?

@Jreaddy 2 месяца назад

There was a crash in FL yesterday, seems like it’s once a week now, really wanna see what when wrong.

@Jimmer-tr6bi 2 месяца назад

Get used to it! All these undertrained yo-yos are heading to the airlines

@geoffsummitt6703 2 месяца назад

Why did the controller get 643 and 635 confused, don't answer it's rhetorical? Looks like an engine failure on short final and the confusion in the call-signs is a problem. I freaking hate the flight schools with their BS call-signs and not the most English proficient pilots. Use your N number and keep this clean for everyone. Two Seminoles in the same pattern with a 600 ish call-signs and tower clears the wrong one to land any runway. If this ends up being a messed of go-around due to confusion as to a landing clearance when they could have cut power and landed that thing on either runway, well that's just sad..........

@Airpaycheck 2 месяца назад

Airlines use call signs instead of tail numbers. I'm just sayin.................

@lancomedic 2 месяца назад

@@Airpaycheck Part of that is advertising and part of that is so that at busy airports ground controllers can say “follow company” or “let Southwest pass in front”. No reason that flight schools need to do that.

@jimarcher5255 2 месяца назад

Count me in on the bs call signs. Home field currently has 6 different flight schools and it’s confusing as hell.

@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 2 месяца назад

@@lancomedicadvertising? Come on man. 🙄. And no, it’s not so that ground can say: “follow company”. The call sign is the flight number. This way, airlines can swap airplanes, but still have the flight plan filed.

@lancomedic 2 месяца назад

@@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 Okay

@user-ej9jq2zf1y 2 месяца назад

So tragic and sad!

@MarcPagan 2 месяца назад

RIP. As an MEI, I don't understand how the instructor let this happen. Aviate, navigate, communicate. Looks like the MEI forgot that, and that he was PIC. Who was flying, and why after the engine issue? Letting a student fly in emergency is fine - given the student, his experience, and circumstances. Real life CRM. They were perfectly lined up to land when the call was made about the engine, so why the go around? More often than not, a single-engine go-around is impossible due to weight, DA, and the low HP engine.

@marcomm7828 2 месяца назад

how do you know, SHE wasn't the PI here? She of course might have been in process of upgrading her license, but I really can't imagine a reasonable PI wouldn't have taken the charge.

@MarcPagan 2 месяца назад

@@marcomm7828 I'll wager you're correct, she was upgrading, and far enough along in training to handle everything - flying, instrument flying, and comms. The unknown MEI could have been a he or she of course. Statistically, a he. As 90% of pilots are men, plus or minus a bit. Of course again, the female might have been the MEI, handling comms whist giving the student a specific task or tasks. I did the same during a real engine out. But my student was a wizzo Air Force Lt. Col. working on his commercial twin, and rock solid on his VFR flying by then. I gave him the task to aviate - "You have the aircraft. Keep it straight and level, maintain heading 270. I have the comms and checklist".

@marcomm7828 2 месяца назад

@MarcPagan I'm guessing the engine didn't fail on short final in your case, so to let the student hand fly the plane gives perfect sense. In this particular case, the time frame was apparently very narrow, and things went south rather quickly. Can't wait what the investigation report reveals..

@SeamusOR 2 месяца назад

Rest in peace🥺

@Primhachinsky 2 месяца назад

Sadly this incident happened to a person whom I know. He's the one who survived this crash and I'm also sorry for the loss of the instructor

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

Sorry to hear that. How is he doing? Is he able to provide any information about what happened?

@kenwhitfield219 2 месяца назад

What happened??

@bruceabrahamsen221 2 месяца назад

It appears the right engine either failed or was shut down. Twin training is dangerous business. Why they didn't just land straight ahead is something the survivor of this accident probably knows.

@leroycharles9751 2 месяца назад

I don't think MOST pilots even think about an engine quitting. The ones that do always have a plan, instructing or not.

@slates010 2 месяца назад

Second crash from this flight school in 6 months

@rclarkcarpenter 2 месяца назад

I had to land a duchess single engine (pretty much the same airplane) back in the early 2000s. Ironically it was runway 10R in Fort Pierce when I was doing time building with Ari Ben Aviator.

@bobwilson758 2 месяца назад

Probably like Daytona - pulled the mixture - engine quit completely no restart - stall / spin

@igclapp Месяц назад

This was an avgas piston plane. The engine can restart fairly quickly when you move the mixture back to normal.

@BlueSkyUp_EU 2 месяца назад

So sad. I wonder why they didn't go for 10R. It's the longest and also required least manoeuvering from their position. Could the panicked "635" we hear at 02:32 / 02:33 be in fact the instructor from 643? If it was indeed 635, he regain composure quite quickly. And the women pilot speaking at around same timestamp, was she in the crashed accident? If so, her calmness is shocking.

@johnrobertson7583 2 месяца назад

Sad that this comment section has devolved by people who think their ancestors lived here 400 years ago and anyone with an “accent” isnt allowed to be here.

@dhardy6654 2 месяца назад

We are fed up with diversity and you are commenting about the blow back.

@lebojay 2 месяца назад

For some, hatred is an obsession and everything they see is an opportunity to apply their confirmation bias.

@jamesa5720 2 месяца назад

Do you not think it is a fair question to determine if language was an issue in this accident cause it sounded like it? What does that have to do with hating anyone?

@pgnandt 2 месяца назад

Well if you're a hammer everything looks like a nail. I couldn't understand her either.

@user-lm2ix1xd4c 2 месяца назад

@@jamesa5720 yeah, it's a fair question for the INVESTIGATORS to ask, not for bozos in youtube comment sections with about 15% of the total information needed in order to assess potential causes. obviously! there is no evidence***** here that her "accent" caused this crash. therefore it's fucking weird for so many people to be making hostile comments about an accent

@user-lq7hf1ww3k 2 месяца назад

Looks like engine sim failed, failed for real with gear and flaps down. She needed to land it, but VMC roll or stalled instead.

@paulking8318 Месяц назад

Despite the incident still a safe way to travel rip lost soul

@markairman8041 2 месяца назад

Very sad. RIP instructor. You sounded very professional all the way. I wish you would have just landed instead of going around. But you tried your best.

@jayde3046 2 месяца назад

Rip;-;

@detteiu00 2 месяца назад

One engine inoperative landing is not very challenging. However, the worst and best decision they made was "go-aroud". It was max (go-around) power, sea-level, windmilling prop and landing speed which is very close to stall speed as well as Vmc. There are many people saying "why they did not put it on the ground?" But their survival instinct for the problem was go-around which is correct and works very well for most landing problems but not this time. That was just unfortunate. I guess I might take the same action...maybe...idk

@yungrichnbroke5199 2 месяца назад

“Why wouldn’t you have tried to go around instead you crashed a plane with a perfectly good engine” they didn’t have any great options so naturally people want to pick the one that feels most normal.

@josephroberts6865 2 месяца назад

The question[s] that arise after hearing that is 1) was the engine failure an actual one or simulated by the instructor?; 2) if the engine failure was actual did the instructor take flight controls and if not, why not?; 3) if simulated, why didn’t the instructor recover the simulation rather than let a bad situation become worse? 4) why was tower so deliberate about closing the airfield?; why did the instructor overload the student?; and 5) why did’t the instructor simply land the aircraft on Rwy 10R? The most import single action that a pilot can take in the event of a serious emergency (engine failure qualifies) is to land the aircraft safely.

@ericlarabell2177 2 месяца назад

Your questions are very Valid except for number 4. The tower called the airport deliberately closed so the fire truck from across the field could get to the crash site which the tower could see from the tower, The fire truck needed taxiways and runways. The big help came from the fuel service truck, they put out any prospective fire from one of the smoking engines as there was fuel spilling out of the wings. A sad note to the story, students from the academy showed up to take pictures with their phones.

@josephroberts6865 2 месяца назад

@@ericlarabell2177 agree with all. It seemed to me that A couple of minutes went by before Tower closed the airfield after seeing the crash. Maybe it was due to air traffic in the pattern, I don’t know, but seemed to be a bit longer than we normally see.

@Exiles800 2 месяца назад

Total guess but they probably lost an engine and being so close to the airport were distracted by landing, forgot to feather, and stalled...Twin engine engine failure training kills more people than it saves...Just go ahead and say it..."Airport closed we've had a bad crash"...

@user-nx6qr1mt6f 2 месяца назад

These frequent incidents are why many mechs prefer staying on the ground A&P/IA

@jugheadjones5458 2 месяца назад

Other planes either just switched to tower or weren't listening. At least 2 asked for full stop right after ATC declared field shutdown. Then one pilot asked if he could land on another runway. Really?

@bruceabrahamsen221 2 месяца назад

Appears to be a vmc stall spin.

@scapilot1980 2 месяца назад

I'm really confused why they didn't just land on Rwy 10? Were they too high?

@rinleez 2 месяца назад

What the hell happened here? Changed runways at last minute, missed it, turned too tight and stalled?

@alfredbelcher1369 2 месяца назад

What the Heck!

@dakotaconners107 2 месяца назад

My guess is she plainly lost control of the plane and it could be she was also new flying a twin engine. My reasoning is you basically don't start your IFR training in a TWIN and especially if you have low hours on flying the Twin. They don't say what kind of training was being done on this flight. Twin engine training or IFR training. It also; sounds like she was put on a fast track to obtain her commercial license by building twin engine time and getting her IFR rating at the same time.

@kennyr5906 2 месяца назад

Twin engine training requires a single engine instrument approach for the checkride though.

@dakotaconners107 2 месяца назад

@@kennyr5906 True however; I believe that that is required for a commercial rating but not required for your twin engine only rating. In general you get your IFR rating and Twin rate endorsement separate. If check ride is for getting your CFII or commercial with a twin then it may require a one engine approach

@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 2 месяца назад

@@dakotaconners107 I’ve seen your comments elsewhere, which have been incorrect. She was the instructor, not the student. Also, you have no idea what part of the training the student was in.

@dakotaconners107 2 месяца назад

@@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 Since there was no mention as to her status i made my comment based on her communication skills and the events leading up to the crash. Nice that you know for a fact she was the instructor. I didn't say what part of training was being done and neither did the video. The video only mentioned doing an IFR approach and go around then someone commented that they were doing it with one engine out. The only time, unless they changed the format in the last 30 years, that an examiner might require an engine out IFR approach in a check ride is for a commercial pilot rating. The IFR approach was not done if you were going for just a Twin Engine rating. Been There Done It and i have had my license for almost 40 years.

@yungrichnbroke5199 2 месяца назад

Seems obvious they were too high and far down the runway to easily land ahead with remaining runway.

@maxtanicfilms 2 месяца назад

Human factors are always such a big question in aviation accidents. At what point does a pilots trained decision making deteriorate into poor decision making? We had two C310's and a Baron. Fly straight ahead, (IVFS) pitch for blue line if not there, clean up the airplane and prepare to put the airplane down under control if blue line is unattainable. Messing with VMC/A is lethal, once that airplane starts to roll over you have no chance. See this interesting video. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CkAxdRGGeZY.html Don't mess with being a test pilot, fly straight out. Then and only then do you give your brain a chance to apply proper single engine twin training. Tragic, RIP young lady. Interested to see what additional details come out about this accident.

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

Doesn't Vmca decrease with increasing density altitude and increasing weight?

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

@@maxtanicfilms No, Vmca decreases with increasing density altitude because maximum engine power is reduced and there is less yawing tendency from the operating engine. Therefore less indicated airspeed is required for the rudder to provide adequate counter-yaw.

@clarazegarelli5861 2 месяца назад

from the communication stand point. it doesnt seem efficient to have callsign such as those, where more than 50% of the call sign represent no valuable information, since Whitecap is the same for many aircrafts. it lends itself to confusion, takes airtime etc.

@chuckgottschall3747 2 месяца назад

Thank you God for blessing my family and protecting us from the evils in this world. I love you. ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏

@speedomars3869 2 месяца назад

She was lined up on the runway and could have landed in that emergency. Instead chose to fly away from the runway and it appears attempt a tight turn to the crossing runway, stalling and crash the plane.

@tomthebomb9474 2 месяца назад

Seen a lot of Seminole training wrecks in the last few months, MEI training is definitely lacking.

@lebojay 2 месяца назад

If your first instinct after watching this is to complain about immigration, there is something wrong with you.

@Whateva67 2 месяца назад

Why? Fuq em

@kevingraham2733 2 месяца назад

Never even come to mind, only yours it seems

@lebojay 2 месяца назад

@@kevingraham2733 my post was a reaction to comments I read here. It didn’t occur to me either. Like you, I was surprised that it occurred to others.

@MmmmJuicy 2 месяца назад

@@kevingraham2733 I was scrolling through the comments and noticed a surprising number of borderline racist comments. Like I know it's Florida, but that's really no excuse.

@lebojay 2 месяца назад

@@MmmmJuicy that’s what I’m saying Since my first post, a good number of misogynist screeds have come up to join the racist ones It’s like some people are obsessed with hate, and everything they see is an opportunity for them to apply their confirmation bias

@emdude1784 2 месяца назад

Very sad. Barely a student, teaching a student. Puppy-mill training is all well and good, until an emergency happens. Seeing too many inexperienced instructors snd their students getting killed recently. Actually Way too many GA accidents. Whats going on?

@michaelspunich7273 2 месяца назад

The US GA accident rate has been coming down for years. A itnd is way below the average so far this year. Your impression that there ae tons more accidents is just incorrect.

@tymatt4555 2 месяца назад

Lots of training going on. I agree accident rates aren’t unusually high. And teaching in the twin is a very unforgiving. I was an instructor at aviator in 95. Started at 300hr and didn’t move on until I had 900hr of duel given in the twin. Even very experienced instructors have messed up teaching or giving checks in the light twins. Very unforgiving.

@someotherdude 2 месяца назад

@@michaelspunich7273 I find that very hard to believe, that the GA accident(fatality?)rate has been declining for years.... and I want this to be true. Can you post the specific stat? Flying requires an excellence and focus in people that our culture doesn't create any more. Basically, we don't have what it takes as a society, even as GA grasps ever more people to sustain itself, while putting forth the lie that GA is 'safe'. It isn't.

@michaelspunich7273 2 месяца назад

@@someotherdude Overall accident rates decreased from 4.69 to per 100,000 flight hours to 4.28 and the fatal accident rate decreased from 0.84 to 0.77 from 2020 to 2021, respectively.” Non-commercial airplane accident rates fell slightly, with the fatal accident rate declining to 0.86 and the accident rate decreasing to 4.87. The YT channel, Probable Cause, with host Dan Gryder goes over every single GA fatal accident that occurs in the US. You should check it out.

@jiyushugi1085 2 месяца назад

FAA should mandate glider time before allowing the step up to power training. Far too many fatals caused by the inability to perform basic maneuvers. It can end up saving the pilot money because many glider hours can be used for Private and Commercial ratings.

@JackIanLin 2 месяца назад

Who is doing these captions? 2:58 “extend your upwind” not ARFF1.

@the_flight_records 2 месяца назад

How a crashed plane can extend its upwind? 643 is disabled aircraft and it's on the ground. Controller said he'll send the ARFF (Aircraft Rescue and Fire Fighting) vehicle.

@JackIanLin 2 месяца назад

@@the_flight_recordswrong. The controller mistook WCP635 on the departure/upwind leg was WCP543. At 3:45 the controller refers to WCP635 flying runway heading as WCP543. You even highlighted the wrong callsign in red. 😏

@BlueSkyUp_EU 2 месяца назад

@@JackIanLin Auto translate says "I'll send you up one". That's what I also hear, but it doesn't makes sense. "I'll send you RF 1" on the other hand makes total sense given the circumstances.

@MagnumOpusSRT 2 месяца назад

Gear was down? Why Go around power Go around flaps Positive rate gear up. Rudder into good engine Or power to idle… just land straight ahead Either way. Poor ADM

@CanardBoulevard 2 месяца назад

It's a Seminole. There is no realistic "positive rate" on one engine. If you lose an engine, you are landing. Going around is suicide kissing Vmc.

@TechnikMeister2 2 месяца назад

Whats going on with General Aviation in the USA? It seems there is a serious accident every day. There can only be two reasons. Aircraft maintenance and pilot incompetence. Looking at NSTB data the latter is the main cause. In many cases it private pilots with minimal skills and experience trying to get home facing approaching darkness of bad weather, or simoply bad decisions. Looking at licensing, the max hours I could find to get an IFR in the USA is 40 hours. Some will do it in a day. In Australia its an 8 week full time course with 220hrs flight time. Thats just IFR. This is in addition to the minimum 150 hours for your pilots license. The minimum hours to get an airline pilots job here is 1500 hours including 500 multi engine.

@stevefisher2553 2 месяца назад

My guess is new money

@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 2 месяца назад

None of what you said is correct. A private pilots license in the USA requires 40 hours. Same in Australia. (Certain schools in the USA and Australia can bring that to 35 hrs) Instrument rating is next. Takes an additional 40 hours in the USA. Roughly the same in Australia. A commercial license in the USA takes 250 hours of flight time. It takes 200 hours in Australia. ATP license is 1500 for both the USA and Australia.

@michaelspunich7273 2 месяца назад

The US GA accident rate has been coming down for years. ANd it is way below the average so far this year. Your words are all false.

@stevefisher2553 2 месяца назад

@@michaelspunich7273 watch the news, daily carnage.

@igclapp 2 месяца назад

Private aviation has never been safer. There were literally four or five fatal crashes per day decades ago.

@FollowTheJohn 2 месяца назад

Whitecap 635 heard there was an accident and still wanted to do a full stop landing! OMFG!

@comcfi 2 месяца назад

Settle down blasphemer

@FollowTheJohn 2 месяца назад

@@comcfi okay tool!

@Dyson_Cyberdynesystems 2 месяца назад

Interesting, a flight school that seems to lean heavily on EASA Flight Training. Not that it should matter for standards but does explain the foreign students.

@MeaHeaR 2 месяца назад

did the engun propelor stop spinns

@flyman1185 2 месяца назад

The controller got the two Seminole Aircraft call signs confused. Definitely part of the problem and creating confusion in the entire scenario. He’s got one job and failed miserably when he was needed most.

@andremichau2455 2 месяца назад

He seemed to become flustered, yes, but I cannot see how the ATC caused or contributed to the incident.

@robs.4146 2 месяца назад

Indecision at the wrong time and little to no experience (both pilots). A fatal combination that rarely works out well. I've had more simulated engine failures during part 135 check rides than I can count. Always with real airplanes (LR25/35, C310R & E110) and experienced check airmen. Better do everything right immediately and without hesitation. These incidents are becoming disturbingly common. We play for keeps in this profession...

@WWPlaysHoldem 2 месяца назад

Took the controller long enough to stop airport operations.

@kewkabe 2 месяца назад

That's an airport manager decision, not controller.

@yenxid 2 месяца назад

It's not the controller's responsibility 😂

@johnbasiglone1219 2 месяца назад

I landed at night on a taxiway at the controllers request when a V-Tail Bonanza landed gear up on the one runway. Why should the other runway have been shut down. It was not a factor. It was well clear of the mishap. In my opinion the arriving flights should have been able to continue to land and at least taxi to a specified location. When I was coming into Fox Field, I was number two following the Bonanza. The tower advised me of the Bonanza gear up on the runway and gave me the option to take the taxiway. I said I could do it and loved it. AND THIS WAS AT NIGHT. After I landed I went out to the runway and was talking to the Bonanza owner and his son who were bringing the plane back from the East Coast as they just bought it a couple days before. The owner said it was a long trip across the United States and was excited to get home and forgot to drop the gear.

@alan_davis 2 месяца назад

@johnbasiglone1219 aren't you a legend... pity you understand f-all about airfield ops.

@confuseatronica 2 месяца назад

looks like another attempt at the "impossible turn" back to the runway

@lebojay 2 месяца назад

Weren’t they already on final?

@confuseatronica 2 месяца назад

@@lebojayI thought so too but there's that hook at the ned of the track, I don't get it either. Maybe they just dropped a wing stalling and pulled out the other way before crashing?

@SierraBravo7970 2 месяца назад

Looks like it doesn’t it. However that’s not what happened here. They VMC’d the aircraft. Got to slow and rolled on her back. So so sad. There have been so so so many VMC accidents recently

@fdafdsafdsafdsa5655 2 месяца назад

Your training is complete.

@Taino505 2 месяца назад

Si..we speak many languages. You?

@jbl7092 2 месяца назад

Until flight instruction becomes a true profession with rigorous qualifications and a curriculum that meets airline standards with real life scenarios, this crap will continue. Amazing that so many "pilots" have no knowledge of what keeps an airplane in the air. Disgusting!

@Richard-iu9sf 2 месяца назад

Agreed

@rtbrtb_dutchy4183 2 месяца назад

Majority of pilots in the USA started their careers as an instructor. It has worked fine for over 50 years. Do accidents happen? Sadly yes, but that doesn’t mean the system is broken.

@hillarynicole5089 2 месяца назад

The school pays $15/hr… hard to have a true profession when there’s no incentive. You also don’t have the facts, so to immediately put the blame on pilot error is incredibly insensitive.

@jennypeters4012 2 месяца назад

Ummm you have NO idea what happened...

@PeterStaniforth 2 месяца назад

As a former X-15 jockey, Shuttle commander, and Concorde captain, I completely agree with the guys comments below.

@MKwan82 2 месяца назад

Actually land on 10R taxi way would be the way to go. She’s already sidestepped due to the engine at low altitude. Could have went idled and land on the taxiway instead.

@user-rt8jc5lh2t 2 месяца назад

Unless the instructor is doing this out of love for instructing, its a time builder for many.

@billpugh58 2 месяца назад

Is that an accusation?

@gordo1163 2 месяца назад

Its a foreign pilot mil.

@johnbasiglone1219 2 месяца назад

@@billpugh58 It is most likely the truth. They either love instructing or building time to move on to get an airline gig. Generally, most instructors do not like instructing. It gets old very quickly and is more frustrating than teaching a teenager to drive by magnitudes of the nth degree.

@user-rt8jc5lh2t 2 месяца назад

@@billpugh58 no...an accurate observation