10 Most OVERRATED Quarterbacks In The NFL Today (2024 EDITION) 

Man this is just ragebait level video

It’s not possible to be overrated if you were drafted last in the draft 😂

The weapons for Purdy isn’t an excuse 💀 Trey Lance couldn’t do shit with the 9ers

Purdy is far from overrated, this channel is on CRACK.

I'm not even a niners fan. What the heck does Purdy have to do to earn the respect he deserves. Game manager is hilarious😂

Kyler also has had the worst supporting cast, coaching and front office of anyone on this list lol

You don't finish second in MVP voting and put up record high numbers in a SB performance and deserve to be called OVERRATED.

Don’t get injured or you’ll make this list.

😂😂 Derek Carr with an elite offensive line?? What team are you watching??😂😂

The Jalen Hurts agenda is wild, dude was the sole reason the team was 10-1 this year and not 3-8. How can you watch any Eagles game this year and not even mention just how bad the defense was? Also you fail to mention AJ brown's career took off since coming to the Eagles and Hurts is the one throwing to him. Hurts is overhated more than anything

Purdy is a great QB. The way he moves in the pocket is next level

Brock Purdy is a top 5 QB in the league right now. Guy has come in and made the team so much better.

Jalen hurts is not overrated- first of all he was a 2nd round pick who managed to scrape together a crazy 13-4 season no one saw coming. Second - yeah no shit his two playoff wins were against OK quarterbacks - but he blew them out by 20+ points Third - he only played 4 total playoff games because this guy is YOUNG Actually tps I love ur channel but sometimes u guys just yap like crazy. Am I really wrong?!?! Many times tps contradicts the complete opposite they state in another video

Why does every qb gets nitpicked for having weapons besides burrow ? Burrow been working with two numbers and a number two with a top five running back his entire career in the nfl

In 2 years, Brock Purdy has made a Super Bowl and NFC championship. He's been one the youngest qbs to ever make a Super Bowl. Also, you can't blame the loss on Brock cause when he stepped up, the defense wouldn't and they would go to choke the game. Not to mention, he was THE LAST PICK so his chances to even play a snap were extremely unlikely. What more can you ask of the guy?

Heres a video idea: WRs had legendary talent but wasted it on bad teams

Trevor Lawrence will never ever be what Peyton Manning was in his prime straight up

Dak needs to wake up in the post season.

Brock Purdy being the last overall pick impossible to be overrated.,and maybe some of the people on thus list he got right but thats only because teams and team builders don't understand how to use people to accentuate their skills

Hurts literally balled out in the superbowl loss. Carried the elite offense you talked about…..

Justin Hurbert should be on this list

This dude don't know what he talking about. Come on man He don't know football

How is Jalen hurts overrated? He’s in year 4 and has been to the playoffs twice and one of them was a Super Bowl

Bro people don’t understand it wasn’t hurts fault it was the coaching and the pressure from the coaching that was on him

The fact that Herbert amd Allen arent on here but Hurts is is just astounding

Brock is not overrated

How is Purdy overrated? He doesn’t even get recognition for being a top 10 QB in the league. Gets hated on all the time.

Top 2 all time qb performance in Super Bowl history yet Hurts is overrated😂

Trevor Lawrence is the most overrated player in nfl history

Jalen hurts was the reason they went to the Super Bowl he was literally the mvp favorite before his injury in the bears game

Saying Dak has an All star cast around him is such BS. Ya he has Ceedee but the rest of his weapons have been old or injured. And they talk about him having a great Oline? That was in 2016 the last 3 seasons the Oline pass blocking rank has been 25th or worst

Purdy is underrated as a QB he’s the future GOAT he’s not overrated he broke the 49ers passing yards record in his first year as a QB 4,278 passing yards and a completion record of 77.4% in the NFL and threw the 2nd or 3rd most TDs in year 1 as starter in the league for the 49ers it’s because of him that we were the first team with 4 players over 1k+ receiving yards and 1k+ rushing yards so Purdy is underrated not overrated I think u don’t know what you are talking about sir with all do respect u Don’t know football 🏈

justin herbert?

Mahomes should be here

And for another video you left Lamar Jackson out of the conversation. C’Mon he’s overrated as fuck, of course, he can put mvp seasons like but when matter most in the playoffs he folded, not to mention he only have 2 playoff wins: one against a mediocre Titans and another to a rookie team Houston Texans. Please, stop defending him and start seeing as he is, an overrated QB

Who says Carr is an above average QB? I'm honestly not sure how he's been a starter all these years.

Herbert better be on here

Half of these guys aren't even overrated 🤦‍♂️

How is Kyler Murray overrated when he's basically the sole reason that team has ever been competitive even with a subpar GM and coach for most of his career. And besides DHop, what elite weapons has he had? An aging Fitz? Also, he gets ton of hate, which goes against the very definition of being "overrated". He definitely has a lot to prove in these next few years with a new coaching staff and slightly elevated roster. And yeah, Brock Purdy being overrated? That's just a wildly bad take.

It's Mostert not mastert!! And how is Tua overrated?! Explain that!!

Bro this channel loves the afc quarterbacks with their whole heart, but as soon as Jalen Dak or Brock or heck, even kirk or kyler, has a bad season, or fails to have a sb despite having weapons, they are "uncomparable" to the afc "powerhouses". Hey buddy, remember the regular season? Yeah, Jalen hurts beat the chiefs and bills, so according to your crappy logic, he's better due to wins.

Dak Prescott being called “Overrated” after coming off a Top 4 season is crazy.

Trevor Lawrence on this list is pretty unfair!

Come on! Hurts is underrated and given no respect!

Some of these Qb’s are way overhated which is why people give them more credit

Ok if nobody is coming to Brock’s defense then I will I would say Brock purdy is over rated you may remember is Brock purdy first ever game as a starter he beats a 7 time Super Bowl champion yes the niners do have the best weapons but so does joe burrow in Cincinnati I’m my opinion burrow and Brock purdy are on the same level the right teams with great weapons a good to great offensive line and a ferocious defense Brock and joe have both taken their respective teams to the super home and two back to back championship games so Brock purdy is not overrated he’s perfectly rated

😂 the fact that you put Purdy on here is wild man

Did they just say New Orleans had an elite offensive line?

Josh Allen

The Hurts hate is real! Josh Allen performed well against Mahomes 1 time in the playoffs and he is the greatest thing! Hurts does the same thing in the Super Bowl and he is overhyped?? Whatever you say TPS..

Jalen Hurts does not belong on this list.

Everyone hating Purdy solely because of where he was drafted. You put his same numbers on Lawrence and Lawrence is “something special”. Tom Brady needed a team around him to become something special. Joe Montana needed the West Coast offense to be created to be something special… Mahomes needed Kelce and Reid to be something special… yet it’s a knock that Purdy has talent around him to be something special?

TPS taking an L. Color me shocked

What is the guys yapping bout? T-law is not overrated. Like blud gets everything wrong. Everyone used to say that he was a generational talent, now they are saying he is a bust. T-law is underrated.

Kyler Murray won't be overrated this year but now that he's gotten a new Wide Receiver in Marvin Harrison Jr in this years draft they is gonna be a excellent QB/WR Combo but as long as Murray doesn't do anything dumb or ridiculous then he'll be all right but will see in the meantime 6:44

Naw brock is fire i gotta disagree

If anyone is overrated it is Caleb Williams, everyone is saying how is already as good as Patrick Mahomes and stuff… Dude hasn’t played a single snap in the NFL and we’re already calling him a superstar

That’s crazy tho paying somebody 230 million dollars to a QB that’s never won a playoff game

Remember when Peyton Manning struggled for a while before turning into a superstar let’s give Lawrence a chance because you could say manning was overrated

Justin Herbert not on the list. List not valid. Jalen Hurts, overrated??? Loooooooooooollll….what a load of 💩

Can we get the most underrated quarterbacks

NO Justin or Josh. I see the Agenda. Why didn’t you ask for a playoff victory from blondie Herbert?

Collin Kaepernick- doesn’t play but every year I have to listen to some talking head say this team should sign this BUM

As a dolphins fan… I knew right away Tua was gonna appear on this video. I’ll admit his stats are carried by his receivers, but he’s at the very least competent as QB. He’s got a lot of work to do, but he’s at least competent

Justin Herbert he has the same problem as Prescott and Cousins.

Patrick mahomes is way overrated and hopefully they miss the playoffs this upcoming season

How can Jalen hurts be overrated when even now he has so many doubters, even Philly media underestimates him & thinks he isn’t the guy? you do understand what overrated means right?

Lols 😂 love this upload! Agree with ya on this list bro 👍🏼

You are very wrong about Purdy and Tua. Purdy is great because he's accurate and makes smart decisions and is surprisingly mobile. Yes, he has Kyle Shanahan and some great weapons. Trey Lance had that too and he didn't develop. Jimmy G was okay but he never produced like Purdy has. And outside of Trent Williams, the 49ers' offensive line is no good. Yet, Purdy had one of the best QB ratings in the NFL. Give him some credit. As for Tua, he led the NFL in passing yards and in completion percentage. Why? Mostly because he is insanely accurate. Teddy Bridgewater and the 3rd stringer also had Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle to throw to and what did they accomplish? Tua's accuracy, touch, underrated arm strength, and trust in his receivers are what make him so good. Otherwise, this video is spot on

The Eagles hate is strong with this channel.

THANK YOU for listing Purdy. Niner fans think his overrated ahh is literally God

It’s Patrick Mahomes. He was benched as a starter in 2017. He lost to Burrow in the playoffs as well as against a 6th round draft pick who is 18 years older than him. Last year he failed to win in 7 games. And he eats too much ketchup.

Call me crazy, but I think my quarterback Jordan Love is overrated. Is he good? Yes. Is he going to become the third straight Packers legendary QB? Eh, I'm not so sure. As we saw, Jordan Love THRIVES in the underdog role. The Packers won each of their road division games and the playoff game in Dallas in blowout fashion, putting up 4 of their 5 highest point totals in those games, despite being heavy underdogs in each one. The Bears talked a lot of s*** last offseason and thought they would finally break through and beat the Pack now that Aaron Rodgers was gone. The Lions thought they were finally kings of the north and could win their first Thanksgiving game since 2016. The Vikes thought they could eliminate us from the playoffs in their own building despite Kirk Cousins' injury. And the Cowboys hadn't lost at home in two years, and no 7 seed had ever beaten a 2 seed in the NFL playoffs. All four were very wrong. And even though we lost in San Francisco, we controlled the game for the most part and could have won or at least gone to overtime if we had a kicker. However, when the Packers were favored this season, they didn't do so hot. Sure, we were underdogs against the Chiefs and we beat them, but we didn't look that great doing it. We should have beaten the Giants for sure, but we were terrible. We should have at least put up a fight against the Bucs, but instead Baker Mayfield left Lambeau with a perfect passer rating. Even though we beat the Panthers, it took a walk-off field goal to do so. And when we beat the Bears at home, our defense did most of the heavy lifting. Plus, this league has plenty of one-hit wonders -- just look at RGIII. Jordan Love could be one of them. I hope not, but he could be. So that's why I'm not ready to crown Jordan Love as the next Bart Starr / Brett Favre / Aaron Rodgers just yet. Give him a season as the favorite and see how he does.

Trevor Lawrence isn't overrated, he's been playing with trash Talent, HE made them dudes. Put him on Buffalo, Cincy, Detroit, even the Rams and give him 2 years. Zay Jones trash, Kirk trash, Engram decent, no TE, and Ridley just came back. When Trevor throws the ball it's as if he walked up to you and gave you the ball. This is an unfair question because every QB can't have Cincy, Buffalo, and SF offense.

Now I don’t disagree Watson hasn’t been worth the money, but I don’t think the results brissett and flacco had were to prove that he was bad either. Flacco was on pace for 30 int if he played a full season. That isn’t good.

How is tua overrated? The media hates on him regularly for no reason

vikings paid cousins all that money to not build an actual defense until his last year in minnesota

Hurts is on a well-managed team with a lot of weapons, and that’s a mark AGAINST his abilities? Okay, here’s a thought experiment for that theory. If you replace Jalen Hurts with Zach Wilson but keep the exact same offensive cast, do the Eagles get better, worse, or stay the same?

Y’all need to stop acting like Purdy was drafted 1st overall

Josh Allen not being on this list is crazy, how is Jalen Hurts on this list when he was injured the whole season, as well as Brock Purdy being on here when Purdy has at least been to a Super Bowl, but Allen isn’t, like make this list make sense

How is Jalen Hurts OVERRATED?

Dak is over hated but not overrated. The media spends 80% of cowboy discussions calling him horrible.

POV you don't do any research and just say the same shit as a 12 year old Patriots fan

The Texans won that trade getting rid of Watson....

Your Hurts slander doesn’t make sense. By logic Mahomes sucks cuz he has Kelce and Andy Reid. Tom Brady sucked cuz he had Gronk and Bill. Hurts haters are desperate for anything.

Other than Niner haters wanting to see Brock fail, how is he overrated? What other reason than that would people want him to fail? I thought people loved a good underdog story?

hurts had 15 interceptions this last year, even geno smith only had 4 less touchdowns with 6 less inteceptions

I can see all the purdy fans pulling their hair out from this one 😂😂😂

If they’ve only played for 1 team or have been on one contract, it needs to be proved. Brock Purdy is a question mark still.

Yall gonna stop hating on my qb Jalen Hurts. All he does is win

What about Josh Allen? Hmm

25 tDs and 8 interceptions Carr doesn’t look that bad but it’s been time when he looked inefficient out there and appear to be struggling in the biggest moment in certain games plus he kept getting injured.

I mean, yeahBrock Purdy did have better weapons than most. But, he also has numbers than Garpallo and Lance ever had.

9ers everywhere know there is a big difference between Jimmy G and Brock Purdy. Plus Brock is young and has time to develop into an even better player.

This was sooooooooo accurate bro Purdy is actually booty but he's not a game manager

As soon i heard Purdy was on this list it’s was irrelevant. You must not watch him play

I love watching Dak Prescott in the postseason. Especially this year, when my Packers DESTROYED him.

Adding Kirk Cousins in this list is EXACTLY why the Falcons drafted Michael Penix Jr.

As a jags fan, is Trevor overrated? Yes, very much so. Did the chargers hand them that game? No. They struggled to move the ball in the first half and only scored because of interception field position. We were just the better all around team, and if anything we handed them that big lead, then just played football and won. That’s why the jags beat them by 28 in the regular season that year

Dak is properly rated. He has arguably more detractors than supporters. No one rates him THAT highly anymore. No way Kirk is overrated. The dude is arguably the biggest punchline in the NFL. Who rates him that highly 😂