20+ BALANCES CHANGE Wish List to the 10 Best & Worst Brawlers 

I think Melodie shouldn’t be able to gain notes by hitting the Heist safe. It just makes her too brainless in Heist, especially considering she already has no issues travelling to the safe. The only other brawler who has a mechanic that gives some sort of power up upon hitting an enemy (Bea) only has it activate when hitting a brawler, so I don’t see why Melodie doesn’t have that restriction Edit: Ash also doesn’t gain rage from non-brawlers

New buff for Spen: he oils up every time he takes damage

1:50 Nah bro, the safe got violated 💀

Bro hates Angelo 💀💀

I just think that supercell shouldn't nerf the base stats of a brawler when the HC is broken. Like, Lou and Maisie weren't that good without HC. The HC was amazing. But rather than nerfing the HC, they just nerf the brawler so now, a brawler who is weak or average without HC becomes bad.

Mentally stable Janet main here. 9:04 I still think the easiest way to buff Janet is simply to buff her main attack damage a little bit. From the time she was meta, a lot of new brawlers that counter her have been released as well as hypercharges which makes her struggle a lot since she lacks damages so a small buff in damage will certainly not make her as broken as she was before, just viable hopefully. On the other hand, she still has a problem with her Star Powers, but the problem isn’t that the first one is bad, it is that the second one is essential to make Janet at least playable; so just make her second Star Power base kit and then add a new Star Power. It could be a lot of things as well: - Super’s bombs leave fire behind - Double damage to non-brawler - 10% progressive damage ramp-up the more you charge your attack (if you don’t buff base damage) - healing in her Super - Janet attacks doesn’t take shields into account (Pokemon ref since she has sound based attacks) - etc… A lot of those ideas seem broken but you can for sure balance some of them and you have to remember her first Star Power is really good, it’s just that Janet is unplayable without Vocal warm up.

Honestly it would be cool if they slowed him to normal movement speed while drawing his shot. Many other games have this mechanic and it feels really cheesy that he can chase people down and easily dodge while holding a 4.4k damage shot

Maise went from S tier to the D tier with only 1 nerf Charlie received 10 nerfs but she's still S tier 💀

I don't think belle needs a nerf at all, is a good brawler not really broken and is easy to counter, if that wasn't the case I can understand a nerf

1:51 balanced fucking gameplay soupcell.

I think if Angelo holds his arrow too long that his animation should make bow string snap like how hanks bubble pops to reset

Buff Wishlist for spen. Spen now has a new trait called oil and milk.

They shouldn't nerf the new hypercharges yet they need to give them a little bit of time to shine

SAM NEEDS A CHANGE!!! My balance concepts: - Sam's super now heals him baseline; Hearty Recovery now heals Sam for 700 for each enemy his super hits. - Sam's super recharges itself in 8 seconds after throwing his knuckle busters away - Remote recharge is completely reworked: Sam can retract his knuckle busters after 4 seconds (instead of the normal 8) - Pulse repellent is reworked completely; Upon activation, his next super doesn't stay on the ground, and instead returns to him like a boomerang, pulling enemies along with it (similar to Gray's walking cane) - Sam's attack Damage, super damage and HP are increased by 5% (so that he's useful without HC) - Mythic Gear: Reinforced Magnets: knuckle buster pickup range is increased by 100% - Hypercharge: Iron fists: Sam's Super now slows down enemies and leaves a burning trail which sets enemies on fire, dealing ticks of 500 damage for 5 seconds Many people think Sam is a healthy, balanced brawler with his uses in the meta, but that's clearly not the case. His kit feels awkward, and without Magnetic field + Hearty recovery, he's completely useless. If Spen sees this, then please, consider implementing this :). My boy Sam has been garbage for way too long.

The thing with Frank that makes me think that he won't get a rework or buff is cuz his HC was teased in brawl talk

i think buffing hanks super charge rate and as you said revert the nerf would be pretty good, but i think you could buff his damage to 4400 to make him on par with angelo

A good Melodie nerf regarding her insane utlity in brawl ball, is that she would be unable to use her ammo whilst one super or more out of the three has been used. The damage reduction is literally negligible due to her poor attack output, so it wouldn't detriment her too much. Obviously she needs further nerfs, but this is good to prevent brawl ball cheese.

Darryl definitely needs some love, he has always been one of my favorite brawlers from a fun aspect. He’s a super fun brawler to play, but in his current state it’s not fun at all. Lol. I think they should give him a slight attack range increase and buff his shield star power to 3 seconds.

Maisie needs more justice. Yes she's my main. Yes i dropped from 1350 to 1150. But what made her good was her consistent super. Nerfing her hypercharge rate: fair enough. But her super rate was too much. I reckon she'd be B-Tier or A-Tier if her super charge rate was reverted, but leaving the hypercharge rate, which is the ideal spot for her. But idk.

What about making charlie dmg scale a bit depending on the range so that she deals more damage from long range. This way you need to caculate if the faster reload speed is better than the extra dmg and deciding if you shouls keep a distance or push

I think that good nerf to melodie could be that when she uses her gadget (the shield one) all the notes that did the shield will disappeare (lets say you have 2 notes and you use the gadget so the two notes will disappeare and form the shield

i think brawlers like Byron and Nita who havent been meta in a long time need to stay like #6-9 in the meta but Nita HC does charge so incredibly fast

Instead of removing the slow on auto aimer can we have the knockback removed Instead?? Even without the slow its still just gonna give her more ammo with snappy sniping, and allow her to deal more damage through her damage scaling. Keeping ony the slow still allows her to deter brawlers like bull or jacky who try to run up on her, without doing the same to assassins. She already has an insanely strong disengage and wall break in her super, she doesnt need more. Just my two cents.

Buff Hank milk 🙏🙏😫😫

New buff: Spen oils up so much that every time he gets hit he gains 1000 hp

I honestly dont mind gene and max being meta (except for maxs uber long super) cause they actually require some game knowledge,haven’t been meta in a while, and are less toxic than many other brawlers- looking @ u charlie >:(

Even though lily is kinda decent right now I think she needs a rework. I think her first starpower should be baseline since she's terrible without it. I came up with a starpower idea that let's her next attack after her super heal her. Also rework her shadow realm gadget. It's too easy to escape with it. I think she should only be able to use it when she's above 50% health. Also she kinda needs a small range buff

Easy way to nerf Charlie is by making her attack piercing... By doing this she can't unload so fast

Melodie's shield gadget is pretty much Ash's healing but 10x better, she doesn't even lose her notes which aren't as hard to gain as full rage bar with Ash

I have built a list of Chester buffs and reworks on a Note. Like, a general buff to his Supers, turning the Bell o' Mania SP a baseline, and replacing it by _Lots o' Jokes_ , which enhances all of it's Supers in different ways. Not forget to replace Sneak Peek Star Power, for _Peekin' Out_ which Chester reveals the enemy brawlers, Supercharge and the Gadget the brawler is using.

Maybe a good way to buff Doug is to add the tank trait to him, every time he takes damage, charge some super, in a brawler that respawns with the super, this could be very good

I think they should put vocal warm up in Janet’s base kit and give her a new star power, and then probably replace the 2nd star power cause it’s just not good, there’s gadgets that can do the same thing

for charlie spider speed needs to be cut in half the super shouldnt make it so you drop gems and allow healing inside the super

Something that just came to mind was increasing Penny's turret attack rate. This will make her better at what she's good at: Annoying and the enemy with her mortar and map control with the fire trail. And to make it even more punishing, maybe increasing the fire's damage by an extra 3%.

Angelo nerf could be that as he charges his shot his movement speed is reduced

For me personally on how would I buff doug is just like what you said buff the healing to 1800 hp, but at the same time adds a super charge area that's the same like buster that requires teammates to be in there to charge it, since both of them are support tanks, so it would makes sense for doug to have that charging area as well. I don't know if it would make him too op or not but this is just my opinion.

With Angelo I’d like to see a range nerf before a movement speed nerf. Making him very fast gives him a nice distinction from other sharpshooters, but he shouldn’t have that and the same range as Piper, Belle, and other normal movement speed sharpshooters. His movement speed technically makes the range longer, too, because he can outrun his targets and close the gap. Basically I’d prefer for him to be mobile but not have the area of effect he has now.

Those brawlers that need their first super to get going should get a new trait or mythic gear that charges their super like halfway when the match starts. This way some of the trash brawlers that rely on their super could get a lot stronger. This will also increase their skill level, for you need to chain supers in order for these brawlers to be good.

I like your idea of ​​balance but I think another brawler to buff is Lily and these are the changes that Let them do it:shot cooldown buff or more damage and a rework on his super where he can now pass through walls

They have to make Angelo fire his shot after a certain duration, otherwise he’ll just receive damage nerfs until he is useless. 1 idea for Melodie is to make is so she doesn’t get notes from pets so there are actual ways to counter her in ranked. But she’d still be overpowered in ranked, especially brawlball.

They need to give doug a speed trait that activates when he doesn't get hit.

Maybe make it so that when Frank attacks, he also damages a small area around him so brawlers cant dodge him so easily

I genuinely think nerfing the cannon but making it so you can do split shots on it would be really fun. Maybe would have to nerf her damage a bit too

The Angelo nerf also should come with a new mechanic for him and hank Being that even if you die the attacks should be released At least for Hank it makes sense the bubble literally pops so if he gets defeated it popping too would just make sense It wouldn't be significant but at least interesting to see

I think they can kind of rework Charlie’s main attack. Her main attack will be dependent on range: min. 650 dmg, max. 1500 (yes, damage nerf 1600->1500) and bringing back her unload speed how it was on her release. It won’t make her very dominant in close range but you can just rush her because she can spam attacks again

Penny needs a buff to her reload speed, her attack is awful in a 1 and 1 fight and the fact that it takes so long to get more ammo makes it even worse.

maisie is actually criminally underrated if you know how to play her for example not auto aim at any ranges if the opponent is going sideways and good positioning on the hypercharge

Nerf/ borderline rework idea: the longer Angelo charges his arrow, the slower he gets

i think very fast movement speed on a marskman is special which no other marksman really has

Chester is broken at low level and awful at a high level so I think a reload speed or range buff might be good for him

I feel like for melody instead of getting 3 supers she could only get one, but you charge to get a 2nd and 3rd super if you hit shots

The problem with Spen's takes is that he seems to forget that most "broken" brawlers he mentioned in 1 event are trash in another (couple of exceptions) so by nerfing what makes them worth anything, you make them non-playable in anything.

Instead of rework, I think you should say adding it to basekit, for bellomania and vocal warmup. As a Mandy main I think in my sights also deserves the basekit treatment like incendiary and balls of fire 😍

janet and penny have been crying for buffs now lol but i like the idea of buffing their starpowers and penny's turret delay between attacks

Just make Angelo’s charge up time longer

the best way to nerf piper is to just nerf that stupid snappy sniping star power, thats what hyper counters assassins or tanks, piper goes from sniper to machine gun whenever a tank gets near them

I think Darryl needs full kit rework that Penny had, changing his base kit a little bit (like super charge rate or it's length, main atack having less projectiles, bur each deal more damage so his atack is not useless in mid range) and reworking all of his star powers and gadgets

i personally use chesters title and let me tell you it is not fun to push it bc you get the same awful super like 3 times in a row (the like ground circle rock thing)

about autoaimer gadget: i think it gotta take 1 ammo and it should not work with snappy sniping starpower, cos piper now has 5 ammo instead of 3 upclose with this build, and she deals more dmg than belle within 5 tiles or further. thats just not fair

Make melodie shots not charge super, only notes?

Bro still hates Angelo and Charlie

Imo they need to fix/rework/buff many Star Powers and Gadgets, before touching the Brawler itself. There are so many brawlers that HAVE to use one Gadget or one Star Power :(

If they make Angelo's arrow pop like milky hank he would be unusable💀😭 like come on he not as strong as larry and lawrie on release, just nerf his super

I think they need to nerf dynamkes gadget and damage Main Damage 3000 to 1000 Stunt gadget 1.5 seconds to 0.5 seconds To make dynamkie fair also reduce his HP TO 4800 And super damage 7000 to just 2500 THATS THE NERF THAT DESERVES Also Delete melodie she is absolutely garbage so delete her

Who authorized the amount of brainrot here😭😭

i havent seen a darryl player in so long that i forgot he was in the game

5:22 Charlie needs her supercharge rate nerfed from 7 hits to 12 hits Her super is already fundamentally broken, nerfing her super hard would make you think when to use her super. Of course if it was just that nerf she would easily be F tier so to compensate she would need her hypercharge rate buffed from 1.66 supers to 1.25 supers, her range is increased by half a tile, and her projectile speed is slightly buffed. I think that would make charlie much more balanced.

I think they should rework some hypercharges. Brock’s makes his super worse and sprout’s doesn’t do anything unless ur in heist and primos doesn’t really help him out that much in terms of super cuz it’s really the same amount of knock back and in some cases is actually bad for you.

Frank buff suggestions: Next attack on second gadget is no longer cancellable Frank super always hits enemies mid-air 1st gadget now has 3x duration, but cannot hold the ball in brawlball during this time.

Max and gene finally get back in the meta and they need a nerf? The max nerf is reasonable with the time duration but they shouldn’t touch her outside of that. Gene needs a buff to his hyper charge, but should be nerfed elsewhere

As a mentally unhealthy Frank main, I just hope that his upcoming Hypercharge makes him viable again, but in a balanced way although not as trash as Sprouts HC. Hope Adrian cook some good shi with my hammer boi

I am a big fan of Angelo, and I actually really like your ideas for nerfs. Making his super take longer to get (3 fully charged arrows) sounds quite reasonable, as well as his arrow charge being cancelled if he holds it for too long. I think the very fast movement speed is fine, as long as they nerf the things you mentioned. He'll still be fun, just not as oppressive.

Make melodie not charge her notes off of pets like Mr.p porters or the safe.

Don't have the gold to get hypercharges so it's a little annoying when a brawler's hc makes them top tier/broken, resulting in nerfs that don't just hit their hc.

I think a great Maisie Buff would be to revert back her super charge nerf from 4 hits (current) to 3. And instead, nerf her super *REcharge* rate from 3 to 4. Therefore when hitting 1 brawler with her super, you'd still need 3 ammos to get it back thus nerfing her super cycling while giving back her defensive playstyle.

Angelos movement speed while aiming should be nerfed and projectile speed should be slowed to make him slow but deadly and have more of a skill cap

I need my main willow to be buffed she’s been mediocre since she released and has never been even remotely close to being the best thrower

My Star Power Reworks for Kit: Power Hungry gets replaced with Cartoony Superstar, which gives Kit an additional 125% power per kill, so that it can be used in 3v3. (This is a more skillfull SP) Overly Attached gets added to the base kit and gets replaced by Purrsonal, which reduces the damage that Kit takes by 75% when on an enemy.

I think Melodie just needs a second cd or 2 seconds between dashes, or she gets her super in 2 hits but she needs an in between damage tick like Stu, prolly too similar

I believe the brawlers on the nerf list are OP because of their play style, not their stats. You can't really nerf their playstyle because that ruins the brawler, so you have to nerf the stats to make the playstyle less rewarding. For example, a gene dmg nerf wouldn't remove the resourcefulness of his split shot and team heal. Also for Piper, it's just annoying facing a sniper who can distance brawlers from herself, when getting close to her is the only way to fight back, but that's the whole point of Piper, so you can't nerf that.

i think they should give frank very fast movement speed that will help him catch up to other brawlers and dodge more frequintely

Angelo seems balanced,neft 8bit movement speed

Kit also needs a Nerf right now he bullies tanks, sharpshooters and throwers with the damage A good way probably would be to Nerf damage slightly and rework his invis gadget to a 50 % shield for 3 seconds because why would a support brawler need to go invis .

only thing i agree w is angelo. make it so as you charge your distance slowly increases

They NEED to fix melodies notes spawning in her when she gets one. It almost makes her unkillable in close range

Melodie could just lose the ability to get notes from hitting non-brawlers. It would allow brawlers with pets or turrets to counter her and she won't be able to melt the safe as easily as she will need to keep her notes up. A small dash range nerf as well won't hurt

Make El Primo oneshot tanks

Melodie shouldn't charge notes with non-brawlers

I think Gene is completely fine right now, his hypercharge could get a slight buff even

last time you want supercell nerf Maisie and they did, now u want them buff Maisie ???

You sneaky sneaky man, I so the notification and I thought that we were actually getting balance changes

Melodie doesnt need her notes from things like a heist safe

I really want melodie to get one simple nerf that may ruin her in heist , obv, they cant gain notes from non enemies

When is milk hank cosplay 🥵😩🤞🙌

Dyna needs a nerf as well. I'd nerf super damage/radius + stun gadget

I think Maisie’s super should charge 40% per hit and her base attack 30% this way if you hit 1 person with the super it takes another 2 hits and not 3

my nerf ideas (angelo should be deleted not nerfed(: angelo: damage nerf to 3500 and scr to 3 arrows and a half melodie: she can super the ball with 3 supers only and fix her supers issue when she die and she take 6 hits for a super gene: idk belle: super charge rate nerf and star power nerf to 13%shield nita: hypercharge charges with 3.5supers and sandy is same as nita byron is damge/heal nerf to 680 charlie: hypercharge nerfs and damge nerf to1500 piper: damge nerf to 3000 and her bushes star power +a nerf to her gadget

I think Melodie should still have 3 dashes, but the distance they travel is reduced. She's so similar to Stu with the dashes so she should have her own traits that are different with pros and cons compared to him Also I want Barley to get buffed because Larry & Lawrie outclass him in every way. Barley's attacks should do 3 ticks of damage each so they would stay out longer, that way he's better at being a control brawler than a damage dealer, which is a benefit over the twins

My idea for maisie is to give her the surge treatment. Make it so that she charges her super in 3 shots, but her super recharge rate is 1/6. So she needs 3 shots for her 1st super. If she hits 1 brawler with her super, she still needs 3 shots, but if she hits 2 brawlers with her super, she can recharge her super in 2 shots. This prevents very easy super chains. Also, maybe nerf her hypercharge rate if necessary.

piper autoaimer gadget guarantees a knockback and a piper shot onto the enemy which is making her too cheesy and noobie. They should just nerf the projectile speed of the autoaimer gadget so its really difficult to hit in the first place at a 2 tile distance or remove the “auto” part of it and allow her to aim it on the enemy by herself by giving her one extra ammo, so it prolongs the duration thats required by the player to go havoc with the gadget and spam shots