2023 Honda Pilot VS 2023 Toyota Highlander || Which Reliable 3 Row SUV Is Best? 

Hey guys! I watched many many videos over and over again and always came back to the Honda Pilot. I guess I've always been a Honda girl. I had a 1992 Honda Accord and loved it. As my family grew from 2 to 4, we went for the 2007 Honda CRV and have kept it because of its reliability and good condition after all these years (over 200,000 miles). There is wear on tear on the leather but hey, kids and almost 16 years will do that to any vehicle. We needed a vehicle that would haul our kids and their cousins and friends. So we went for the 2023 Honda Pilot Touring with added AWD and haven't regretted it one bit. We have had it since March and drove it almost 6,000 miles. I love everything but here are the things I absolutely love. The enormous interior size of the vehicle is so roomy. Adults and kids alike feel very comfortable sitting in any row; the 9" infotainment system works great. I have an android phone and it is so amazingly convenient. Our previous car did not have one so having one now is such a luxury. No need for a huge one when this one provides me with the information I need. My favorite parts of the front seats are the comfortable seats, wireless charging, everything on the steering wheel, multiple cup holders and wireless commands like text, call, weather and directions. Remember, I am coming from a 2007 Honda CRV so these features are HUGE for me. My kids are in love with the backseat and so am I. They have temperature controls and vents back there, which we did not have in CRV. Plenty of cup holders and compartments for all their toys, gizmos, etc. Love that they can each charge their iphone and tablet without having to use ours up front. The seats are wicked comfortable and huge with lots of leg room. We appreciate the ability to take the middle seat out of the 2nd row but have needed that precious space for a butt for sure. Pano moonroof gives the interior a nice airiness and lots of light. Cargo is smaller than my old CRV but it is more than enough for my family and our travels. I love the hands free and the walk away feature for the trunk. The drive itself is smooth and refined, just like you said. And I love that the steering wheel is light, considering how much driving I do. It handles beautifully. I'm glad to know that I can depend on this car to care of my family for many many years.

You’re a great example of “keep your eyes on the road”!! 👍

I'm in more awe about the removable and storable middle seat in the Pilot than I should be.

I bought a brand new 2023 Honda Pilot Sport three weeks ago. It is bigger and looks better than previous generations. It's gas mileage is average, performance is OKish, nothing impressive. The brake is not responsive, you have to push the brake harder to get it stopped. But, The second day, the check engine light on. Here is the message:"Emissions system problem. Power may be reduced. See dealer". I immediately drove it to the dealership Service Dept. But, that Service Advisor said I did not make an appointment and has a kind of "do not care" attitude. It took me lots of efforts and almost 5 trips, eventually, they said it a sensor issues which is in some kind of value of the gas tank areas.They put order to replace the value and sensor. But, it has been over 15 days and no ETA from the supplier! Plus, the driver side wiper blade simply flew away the first time I turned it on in the heavy rain. It took three phone calls and two appointments to get the new wiper blade installed because it need to be "ordered" also. On the left side of back window, the bottom trim is not glued well and can easily peel off and has not fixed by the Service Dept yet. Since 1996,I used two Honda Accord which were very reliable. and a Honda Odysessy van which had transmission issues after 6 years. After that, I bought new Acura MDX and drove it for over 15 years and very reliable. That is the reasons I come back to bought this 2023 Honda Pilot. But, looks like Honda's build quality dramatically degraded. If I have choice now, I will NEVER buy Honda cars again. First, the manufacturing quality is very bad from my experience with the brand new Pilot, secondly, the experience with the Service dept is very bad also. Especially with the ordering of parts, it take over 15 days , no ETA ! what's hectic ! From the Honda manufacturer to the Service, the Honda is degrading big time. I will not recommand anybody to buy the 2023 Pilot.

The Pilot with the Toyota hybrid engine would be great.

I just picked up my Honda Pilot trail sport the other day and I was like holy shit it's so spacious and it looks more rugged than the old Pilot, it's fun to drive not disappointed at all.

I really like your to-the-point analysis. Thank you

Pilot is sucha great suv for what it offers but spending 55k+ on a base model with 7 inch touch screen???!! That feels like a slap on your face lol

Picking up my Highlander Hybrid later this morning 😁

I have Pilote 2022 EXL and I will never regret having it

Just picked up 2023 honda pilot trailsport absolutely love it and we're toyota loyal.

Hi can you please give me your review to new Chevrolet Groove 2023? Is it good SUV to buy? thanks in advance….

If you really do your homework on the Highlander you’d find there’s not a big enough difference in gas mileage to justify the additional cost for the hybrid. Both the Honda and Toyota are great vehicles

The 3rd row in the highlander is not as practical as the pilot's 3rd row.

I’m a Toyota fan boy but I’m a little disappointed about the 4 cylinder turbo instead of the v6, I also love the way the Pilot looks and I have a feeling the reliability will be slightly better.

Have you thought about comparing these two with the Subaru Ascent?

We have the Highlander Hybrid. Excellent vehicle, and super great fuel economy.

Hondas timing belt and direct injection are the turning point to a Toyota dealership…Looks a lot better than the highlander

Honda is just better built regarding fit, finish with comfortable seating and smooth ride quality. You can tell a lot of thought and work went into the overall quality of the vehicle and rider experience. Which is why typically Honda’s are more expensive than Toyota’s.

I was checking the Honda pilot,dodge Durango and Toyota highlander which won do you think is better.

The Honda Pilot is very smooth and spacious, but I got the Highlander. You cannot go wrong either way.

Please make video on Sienna vs Highlander and Pilot vs Odyssey. I understand that one is SUV another is Van but when people buy 3 row vehicle they generally compare Van with SUV.

Highlander

I will go with Honda pilot❤😊

Timing belt change after 160K 😮 that's crazy Honda on these days 😧 , HIgh lander might be a good choice but people who are six feet🐾 tall ,driver seat leg space is not enough , you can't stretch your legs inside when you drive

I'm sorry but no 4-cyl engine for me, especially on an SUV. I think Toyota is going to regret it. Many still want the V6 feel and power. Getting a used 2021 or 2022 model.

What are your views on the VCM system in the 3.5L Pilot engine? Many problems have been reported. My wife and I were ready to purchase the Pilot until I learned about the VCM system.

I use Toyota and Honda for but I always love the Honda over a Toyota anytime any day because it has a better engine and More fun to drive than a Toyota that's my opinion

what is the cost difference? projected reliability?

Pls compare mazda cx90 vs bonda pilot

I will keep my 2020 Highlander with the 3.5. Turbos have issues or cause other issues.

My wife drives a Highlander with the V6, looking to upgrade but will not go with the I4 Turbo or the hybrid. Guess it is time to look for another car brand/model

pilot 23 or wait for 24 grand highlander hybrid? I'm on waitlist for both ...

Compare it with latest grand highlander

I bought a pilot over the Toyota mostly because the Toyota was boring to drive. At least the pilot had a "sporty" funness for a large suv. But that's what it came down too.

Boths vehicle are good but V6 is better which Honda vs4 cylinder turbo

I was checking out Skoda Kodiaq recently and it's practicality seemed amazing but this Honda Pilot did impress me just as much. Choosing which one to buy will come down to price I guess...

Highlanders are bulletproof. My 2007 Limited towed boats, had amazing visibility, and was pretty good on gas. Replaced the serp belt once and a wheel bearing. Traded it in at 300k miles still got $4500 for it

Good comparison... I think overall I like the Honda Pilot better... mainly because of the naturally aspirated 6cyl... but also because, since I don't need a 3-row vehicle, Honda offers a 2-row version of the Pilot... the Passport... which I would buy instead... If Toyota did the same with the Highlander I would certainly be open to it, especially if it offered a hybrid option... sadly, it does not.

Unfortunately in Australia we don`t have access to Honda Pilot/Passport/Ridgeline or any Acura. I hate that so much! BTW Blue Pilot Trail sport would be amazing to get =(

Toyota makes fantastic but V6 engine is much better less wear on engine not a good buy. I’d go Honda Pilot V 6 285 horsepower and tons of space no doubt.

you know when I think about which one to buy, for me it is extremely easy to decide what to do ...cuz I got no money

Timing belt is a big NO!

Love the Red interior, but Hate the dark depressing headliner. Looks like something Dracula would love.

Pilot is the best 👌👍ever

i used to like the toyota, specially the toyota sienna but i kinda notice this highlander body style and the sienna body has a similar style, i’m going for honda pilot this time, sorry toyota

At this time, it's Grand Highlander for me, but let's see once they come out, what they are all about. If the new Sequoia got better MPG and have about 12-15 more cubes of space, it would already be in my door yard, as I really like the looks of that model

Pilot

Grangma vs Grandpa Very old style

ALL vehicles should have tow hooks both front and rear..... get stuck sometime and you'll find out why.

You can go with the Hybrid Hylander all day long but if you can't get one from one to two years what's the point? I was told not to hold my breath for a hybrid until Q2 2025 based on Toyota allocations and waiting lists. Screw Toyota, going Honda all day long, besides Turbo gas engines suck, lots of issues as they age. V6 any day of the week.

Pilot is the perfect car if it has a gear shift stick. No push buttons please.

I miss V8s

I'm not happy that the new Honda V6 only has direct injection and not port injection as well - and as you also pointed out, the inclusion of a timing belt in a new engine design is a real head scratcher. Having to pay close to $2,000 every 100,000 miles to replace the belt (and might as well replace the water pump while you're there, so increase that price) is a big deal for us since we keep our vehicles for 10-20 years.

Timing belt!!! Says it all. Garbage. Will never buy. Very expensive to replace. Can actually break at any time.

Toyota just killed Highlander by releasing the Grand Highlander

Highlander was my choice but now it is honda.

Just test drove the Pilot and the interior just seemed cheap to me. Space was nice and surprised me compared to other suvs. I still think the Grand highlander is the one to beat.

Wait until you have to replace that battery $$$ lol

toyotas are the best 1. better on gas 2. no turbos on some models 3. cheap on maintence 4. hybrid system is way better 5. more reliable

Highlander. Now get off my lawn.

I hate the Highlander 😡😡😡😡

Toyota reliability all the way! To this day, Honda interiors are basic looking..the turbo 4 is amazingly fast!

Come on Honda 1600.00 for timing belt. Nice money grab. I will pass.

Always toyota is better 😂😂😂

I have owned both Toyotas and Hondas and by far Toyotas are much more reliable and ages gracefully. Honda made a mistake with direct injection and using a timing belt. It adds repair cost long term. There is no way a Honda Pilot worth over 50K! What a waste of money. The Toyota Highlander is bargain.

Toyota is boring and reliable.honda os fun and reliable ❤

why does he sound like computer generated speech? very mono-tone

Honda's still uses stupid timing belt. Why? Honda's need to put Timing chain. i am not buying Honda. i will buy Toyota instead.

Pathfinder v6 engine is better than these Japanese rivals.

turbo engine no thanks

Highlander