Тёмный

A Budget Full of Trickery: Kapil Sibal Asks 3 Economists How to Make Sense of it 

Dil se with Kapil Sibal
Подписаться 145 тыс.
Просмотров 22 тыс.
50% 1

In this Episode of @DilsewithKapilSibal Ten years since Narendra Modi came to power, the economy has undergone no significant improvement. After 2016, the decision of demonetization destroyed the MSME sector. In 2019, the government tried to give benefits to the corporate sector by reducing tax rates. The corporate sector did not deliver, they just cleaned up their balance sheets. The agriculture sector is stuttering.
The Narendra Modi government has now got a fillip in the form of Rs 2.1 lakh crores of dividends from the Reserve Bank of India.
Sibal is joined by three experts who try to answer what's good and bad about the budget. One of these is more difficult to answer than the other.
Jayati Ghosh has taught for 35 years at JNU and has a PhD in economics from Cambridge University. She has written about globalization, international trade, macroeconomic politics and more. She is consulted by the UNDP and ILO.
Arun Kumar is part-physicist (with a degree from Princeton) and part-economist. He has done enormous work in developmental economics and written extensively on black economics.
Himanshu is also a JNU developmental economist. He has been advising the government in several capacities.

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 212   
@MahiChaurasiya-m6v
@MahiChaurasiya-m6v Месяц назад
You're only last hope for Reneet 2024 🙏🙏
@bloomsberg7008
@bloomsberg7008 Месяц назад
Sir please do something for neet 2024 scam itna inflation ho rakha h ki hum bas dumbstruck h Plzz 🙏
@nippubaba4098
@nippubaba4098 Месяц назад
I humbly request to you that all the episodes should be provided in all measure reginal languages so that common people of our country can take advantage of it
@ShazamaEramazmi
@ShazamaEramazmi Месяц назад
Sir you are the last hope for this neet scam
@illusionuchiha6947
@illusionuchiha6947 Месяц назад
Nobody is listening to Neet now but i hope u will...sir
@SEVENTEENCARAT-zd4yc
@SEVENTEENCARAT-zd4yc Месяц назад
SIR PLEASE GIVE JUSTICE TO NEET ASPIRANTS, PLEASE WE WANT RENEET #RENEET
@yournameyt2
@yournameyt2 Месяц назад
#kabil sibbal we wants justice we want reneet
@ASHOK-dn4st
@ASHOK-dn4st Месяц назад
As long as Modi is the PM my country will not prosper....
@phoenix007ism
@phoenix007ism Месяц назад
So how well did the country prosper before him?
@satvikhegde325
@satvikhegde325 Месяц назад
​@@phoenix007ism we were strong growing nation
@manujohn99
@manujohn99 Месяц назад
No, no it will be very prosperous for BJP only 😂😂🤣
@hulklogan4751
@hulklogan4751 Месяц назад
Strong growing nation that collapsed in 1962 1991 2008 ahh thank u congress​@@satvikhegde325
@ishankotru7652
@ishankotru7652 Месяц назад
​@@hulklogan4751 in 2008 world collapsed India did very well. In 1991 it was coalition govt supported by bjp.
@user-bx3qf1by6t
@user-bx3qf1by6t Месяц назад
@Dil se with kapil sibal....sir pls help us we want justice. .we want reneet
@kshitijkumar1118
@kshitijkumar1118 Месяц назад
Please sir reneet का केस हम बच्चों की तरफ से ladiye आप हमारी आखिरी उम्मीद है प्लीज प्लीज प्लीज प्लीज
@pbghosh5305
@pbghosh5305 Месяц назад
It's a serious issue, indeed.
@AyushRoy-bu4ef
@AyushRoy-bu4ef Месяц назад
Kapil sir justice for NEET 2024 STUDENTS...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@PodCaster901
@PodCaster901 Месяц назад
#reneet please kapil sir..
@shreyahalder1018
@shreyahalder1018 Месяц назад
Plzz kapil sir hum neet aspirants ki help kijiye all india paper leak hone k bad bhi supreme court localised leak bol dia or galat decision dia ab aap hi nyay dila sakte ho sir🙏
@shreyahalder1018
@shreyahalder1018 Месяц назад
Plzz sir reneet for all kara dijiye hum hardworking poor aspirants bahot muskil me hai 🙏
@shahrukhali2105
@shahrukhali2105 Месяц назад
Please speak for #reneet @kapilsibbal sir..please.. We students between 655-620 are very very much affected by this year #Neetresult.. Please sir please..🤲🙏🤲🙏
@ssshhhhb
@ssshhhhb Месяц назад
#reneet #reneet #reneet #reneet Pls😢
@Shrishtiiii239
@Shrishtiiii239 Месяц назад
Please support us for Re neet ! #justice
@pbghosh5305
@pbghosh5305 Месяц назад
We all support re-NEET WHOLE HEARTEDLY. ✋️💯✋️
@shoaibaftab8915
@shoaibaftab8915 Месяц назад
Sir please 🙏🏼 re neet Ur the last hope of many students sir please 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
@Aditya-e6j-s3h
@Aditya-e6j-s3h Месяц назад
Tweet kro bhai
@funv.k.18
@funv.k.18 Месяц назад
BJP trying to pull IND down. it's explicit now
@Kajalkumari-ne3ty
@Kajalkumari-ne3ty Месяц назад
Sir plz help NEET UG 2024 students u r our last hope . Plz help in review petition we have so many points . Plz listen those ones .plz help.
@user-xy4zy2or3l
@user-xy4zy2or3l Месяц назад
The govt is not listening, nor interested in listening, they think what they are doing is right, therefore, no need to listen to anybody. All instructions come from PMO and all others have to just listen. The other day it was said in Parliament that only 6 people run this govt, therefore, there is no need for all the other 140 crore to do anything or worry about anything except to just relax and listen to what they are being told. Afterall this is govt of hard workers and not Harvard people. Anyway, thank you for speaking your minds and let us not worry if somebody is listening or not listening.
@jacobcherian9270
@jacobcherian9270 Месяц назад
😊l
@anjanamalhotra7593
@anjanamalhotra7593 Месяц назад
“Denial of Unemployment Numbers by the BJP has today created a huge Problem and leave the Government with No Road Map of how to tackle this problem” Jayati Ghosh A core problem that the youth face today is Unemployment.
@AryanSingh-he5pw
@AryanSingh-he5pw Месяц назад
Extremely meaningful conversation with an unbiased agenda. Kudos to Mr. Sibbal for this initiative
@Zaraki-f7k
@Zaraki-f7k Месяц назад
Sir please help NEET UG students! You are our last hope
@Aditya-e6j-s3h
@Aditya-e6j-s3h Месяц назад
Tweet kro
@agangmaringmei2529
@agangmaringmei2529 Месяц назад
Sir, always love your discussion with the intellectual. We have the solution in farm sector, but the present ruling dispensation is not acting on it.
@user-wp9mb2xv8i
@user-wp9mb2xv8i Месяц назад
जुमलेंद्र जी झोला लो और निकल पड़ो। Desh ko Loot Daalo British ki trah aur Phir Desh ko Adani Ambani ka Gulaam bana do.
@Aditya-e6j-s3h
@Aditya-e6j-s3h Месяц назад
" students, who were unfairly impacted by the paper leak and systemic failure, *deserve a fair chance to demonstrate their abilities.* #reneet
@srikanthkantha8706
@srikanthkantha8706 Месяц назад
Kapil Sir very good information..I learnt a lot....from small town in Karnataka ❤❤❤
@jenithjohn3248
@jenithjohn3248 Месяц назад
Himanshu summed it perfectly. Companies are looking to reduce spending and calling it skill issue Companies want experienced candidates but not willing to pay as they don't want to pay for training
@HimanshuAggarwal-qj1kw
@HimanshuAggarwal-qj1kw Месяц назад
#reneet sir
@mohammedmudassirali1174
@mohammedmudassirali1174 Месяц назад
this is what we call a discussion but adding upto it we need equivalent minds and brains to understanding such great conversations.
@aarbee96
@aarbee96 Месяц назад
Very informative. Amazing to see the father of evolutionary biology discuss the Indian budget.
@praveshbist
@praveshbist Месяц назад
Mr Sibal hats off to your discussions, I am a naval veteran officer and have seen the country evolving through 4 decades and believe you me ,your ideas and discussions gives me hope for my daughter that all is not lost. Keep up the good work. Truly a fan of your court proceedings and Dil se conversations. Highest regards
@AJverse-2.0
@AJverse-2.0 Месяц назад
Pls reneet sir🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏you are our last hope❤❤❤❤
@PodCaster901
@PodCaster901 Месяц назад
Sir our one whole year would be wasted because of those fraud people who bought the question paper... please help sir!! 🙏
@_ShubhamSharma_
@_ShubhamSharma_ Месяц назад
for the nth time, sir there is an ECHO in your room which distorts the quality of the sound of podcast, please tell this to someone from his team
Месяц назад
Respected Kapil Ji, with what ever seriousness I appreciate the color of your shirt today, with same seriousness I appreciate this "Dil se" discussion episode ... while find you don't allow the #Cheap (2/- Bhakts Status) Economist Sanjeev Sanyal at all on your platform. Rest Rahul and Nirmala (with her face-palm) playing #Ankhmicholi in Parliament. But the most successful #Elected Clean-Politics Man, so sound in Economic matter is put to jail by Chauthi-Pass-Raja !! 🤦‍♂
Месяц назад
The best #Demand and #Supplies issues are discussed ... while MSP Guarantee from a "Govt. Law" is an absolute hot topic, for present Govt. for last 10 years and even before 2014 with #GhandhjiFamily "remote control hindrances affairs" it was hot potato indeed. Has put the entire FARMERS sect. in huge bad debts. With immediate inflow of moolah by way of "MSP Guarantee" will activate the Mahajan (in Modi's term BICHOULI) gang recover old debt. So a Govt. regulation has to come forth simultaneously, with stricter implementation through #CorruptFree agency. Only AK has capacity to do that. Rests are hapless !! 🙄
@VividhKothari-rd5ll
@VividhKothari-rd5ll Месяц назад
why are #you adding hashtags to random words?
@kaivalytolbande8787
@kaivalytolbande8787 Месяц назад
This ideology of savarkar is very dangerous in long term
@shoyabahmad6688
@shoyabahmad6688 Месяц назад
Last hope of all neet aspirants 🙏
@arhturlegend007
@arhturlegend007 Месяц назад
Very informational, thank you sir.
@smitchaudhari9783
@smitchaudhari9783 Месяц назад
We should abolish personal income tax below 20lakhs. That will also increase demand by formal sector workers.
@sandhiyakardam9596
@sandhiyakardam9596 Месяц назад
We want justice reneet please sir hmara case handle kro hum baccho ki last hope ho ap please sir
@Humanity_only
@Humanity_only Месяц назад
Sir, विनती 🙏के साथ कहना है की कृपया आप ऐसे किसी केस में मत पड़िएगा जहां नीट सीट डिजर्विंग aspirants की कुछ लोग सीट छीन कर re chance of exam चाहते हैं। सर हमने तीन चार साल की रात दिन की कड़ी मेहनत के बाद 655+ नंबर लाए हैं, अगर सर कोई पेपर 10ए10.30 बजे पटना /हजारीबाग में लीक हुआं तो हम MP, Delhi, Rajasthan, tamilnadu Kerala etc की क्या गलती है। हमने तो अपना बेस्ट दिया है। क्या गारंटी है को re-exam हो और हम बॉर्डर लाइन बच्चों के फिर से 660 नंबर आजाएं! आप प्लीज़ re-neet का केस मत लड़िएगा कौरवों की तरफ से। आपसे विनती है 🙏🙏
@KARINA.379
@KARINA.379 Месяц назад
SIR PLEASE GIVE JUSTICE TO DESERVING NEET ASPIRANT, WE WANT RENEET
@Jafrinsiddika456
@Jafrinsiddika456 Месяц назад
# plzhelpkapilsir# u r last hope plz help neet student
@mohammedmurtaza3257
@mohammedmurtaza3257 Месяц назад
Corruption, casteism, and communalism are significant issues. All successive governments, as well as the people, are responsible. People should question these problems, but due to a lack of education, they often do not question, reason, or rationalize.
@KARINA.379
@KARINA.379 Месяц назад
Sir please give justice to deserving students, please sir RENEET
@sena3941
@sena3941 Месяц назад
Tax avoidance by corporates is barely talked about. Glad that is being talked about. We should be examining transfer prices and debt shifting within company arms and subsidiaries to see whether they are genuine or just masking profit shifting and base erosion. Capital taxation is tricky with the base of financial wealth being outside. Even if one has information on it, bilateral tax treaties make it difficult to tax them at ideal rates. It is important to give incentive and also impose penalties on certain type of base shifting.
@PratikDas-vu1bs
@PratikDas-vu1bs Месяц назад
FM minister should watch this as cuz her qualifications doesn't addressing how the 2024 budget had been placed. Somewhere people were expecting more but now it's seems to be not enough capable to handle the countries economic of India.
@chhandaghosh9651
@chhandaghosh9651 Месяц назад
Sir plz as students who earnestly earn the seat
@arjunlahiri8317
@arjunlahiri8317 Месяц назад
Do you'll think that the India Alliance would ever be able to bring the funds percolating into the PM Care Fund and also the cash rich BCCI, under the purview of the Auditor General of India???
@ranjanasharma1331
@ranjanasharma1331 Месяц назад
Please sir reneet
@astralrajdhan
@astralrajdhan 9 дней назад
Good discussion
@nikhilvarma5197
@nikhilvarma5197 Месяц назад
The IT sector is yet to on-board students since 2022.
@KARINA.379
@KARINA.379 Месяц назад
SIR THE MAXIMUM STUDENTS WHO ARE SUPPORTING "NO RENEET" CLEARED THE EXAM BY DOING SCAM, THEY BOUGHT OR GOT THE NEET QUESTION PAPER BEFORE THE NEET EXAM
@HimanshiYadav-w2h
@HimanshiYadav-w2h Месяц назад
How do you claim do you have any proof
@KARINA.379
@KARINA.379 Месяц назад
@@HimanshiYadav-w2h and how is it even possible that a girl who failed in her 12th boards scoring 705 in neet and now she failed in her supplementary too, i know she will not get admission this year but something fishy nta has done by which she scored 705 in neet
@HimanshiYadav-w2h
@HimanshiYadav-w2h Месяц назад
Yar I am tired...pls I honestly scored 680 this year Last year it was 605 and 95 percent in boards.. Whats my mistake ....I am experiencing extreme mental trauma due to all this re neet drama Cbi is investigating.. please let us live too I am honest
@KARINA.379
@KARINA.379 Месяц назад
@@HimanshiYadav-w2h you are thinking about yourself and those who want Reneet thinking about themselves so both the groups are in the same line and if you are getting disturbed by this things so don't search this topic or stay away from your mobile
@srinivasrao369
@srinivasrao369 Месяц назад
Middle class has been cheated
@SadguruPrernaTrust
@SadguruPrernaTrust 25 дней назад
It is ZERO LOSS budget ! Sibal !!!
@rashmirajsonal8971
@rashmirajsonal8971 23 дня назад
Just love this show
@pranshugupta7201
@pranshugupta7201 Месяц назад
Bhai ne end me to bilkul pointed baat hi bol di You start the revolution, and we'll make it revolutionary😄
@sahi67
@sahi67 Месяц назад
Kapil sir. Please look into "Fair work commission" of Australia.
@brijbhushanpandey7682
@brijbhushanpandey7682 Месяц назад
Re neet sir please help us .
@jaggis4914
@jaggis4914 Месяц назад
Please more of these discussions Mr. Sibal!
@abumohammedsajidbasha5741
@abumohammedsajidbasha5741 Месяц назад
Very helpful discussion, hats off to the learned minds
@sristijain6230
@sristijain6230 Месяц назад
Personal income tax is already more than corporate tax
@EZNOMICS-RohitVajpeyi
@EZNOMICS-RohitVajpeyi Месяц назад
very informative. thanks
@ManOfSteel1
@ManOfSteel1 Месяц назад
34:00 this guy has done his research well!
@wjtiz45
@wjtiz45 Месяц назад
Can pre election and post allocation distribution state-wise be compared? Similarly comparison with previous year would show the distortion in favor of Bihar and A.P. Conclusively!
@deeptisingh_1828
@deeptisingh_1828 Месяц назад
Respected @kapilsibal sir plz take our repetition case Reneet for 13lakhs qualified candidates 🙏😭
@kanwalburmi7342
@kanwalburmi7342 Месяц назад
@SEVENTEENCARAT-zd4yc
@SEVENTEENCARAT-zd4yc Месяц назад
PLEASE SIR RENEET
@ganeshganesh-cf4fz
@ganeshganesh-cf4fz Месяц назад
Every discussion must go through towards solutions not criticising each other then only india prosper .
@Millions0fDreams
@Millions0fDreams Месяц назад
Happy Birthday sir 🙏
@SuperRAJORSHI
@SuperRAJORSHI Месяц назад
THE FAMOUS LAST WORDS --- " I HOPE THE GOVERNMENT WILL LISTEN TO THIS......." EVEN I HAD SOME IDEAS FOR MY COUNTRY LISTENING TO THESE KIND OF CONSTRUCTIVE RU-vid SEMINARS...!!!
@Shrishtiiii239
@Shrishtiiii239 Месяц назад
Please help for re neet sir Cheaters are posting for no re neet Our 1 year will be waste
@ajayadvani678
@ajayadvani678 Месяц назад
Excellent discussion.
@milymathew
@milymathew Месяц назад
Did they just say that income tax percentage should be increased??
@rmodak90
@rmodak90 Месяц назад
31st july remember the date..democracy lost... we are in danger..sir pls don't do that
@manujohn99
@manujohn99 Месяц назад
BUDGET-2024 IS THE WORST OF THE WORST BUDGET PRESENTED IN ALL OF BJP'S TENURE😡😡🤬🤬🤬
@aniketsinghkirar6714
@aniketsinghkirar6714 Месяц назад
What’s your view on taxing the big farmers? Because you guys talked about taxing everybody. Please tell me
@BoraiahNataraju
@BoraiahNataraju Месяц назад
Read golwalkar.
@binylk
@binylk Месяц назад
Excellent ,insightful
@shoyabahmad6688
@shoyabahmad6688 Месяц назад
Sir please help poor neet aspirants 🙏
@ManOfSteel1
@ManOfSteel1 Месяц назад
you should have individual interview with Blue shirt guy. his 10mins were worth more then the whole interview itself.
@chandrakantlahare146
@chandrakantlahare146 Месяц назад
This conversation should be translated in HINDI.
@ExperimentRider
@ExperimentRider Месяц назад
Mobilise/mobility of people like sending them through a dedicated company for menial jobs to developed countries as they face shortage in working population. Bring changes in UNO for this.
@BoraiahNataraju
@BoraiahNataraju Месяц назад
They don’t want to create jobs and increase the middle class, They are achieving the goal of Goldwater of having only two classes, rich and poor. Only masters and slaves so they can practice and perpetuate masters and slaves ideal of many smrithi aka Sana than dharma.From bjp perspective they are achieving their goals so they don’t even have pretence of an apology. They are gleeful away from the wider gaze. They have to go if jobs have to come.
@ManOfSteel1
@ManOfSteel1 Месяц назад
6:10 she sounds like she's about to cry 😂
@AbhyudayTripathi-zm9fq
@AbhyudayTripathi-zm9fq Месяц назад
Happy
@mitheshpatel6806
@mitheshpatel6806 Месяц назад
Well kapil ji....instead of an ex tempore interview....u can hand over the questions before hand...and rotate the turns....feels jayathi madam has too much to say , its kind of interrupting the flow of other two gentlemen
@user-db5bc3tv6z
@user-db5bc3tv6z Месяц назад
Very good sir
@ShubhamGupta-iq8ow
@ShubhamGupta-iq8ow Месяц назад
Insightful
@AnimeshKumar-bx6ye
@AnimeshKumar-bx6ye Месяц назад
Ek baar Congress ka budget padh ke aane ko bolo sabko, yeh budget ke fan ho jayenge sbkoi
@manmeetsingh5541
@manmeetsingh5541 Месяц назад
Nirmala Sitharam should take advice from her Economist husband before making the budget.
@AnandSingh-kt3qx
@AnandSingh-kt3qx Месяц назад
Please sir help neet students We want reneet🙏
@pbghosh5305
@pbghosh5305 Месяц назад
Unemployment, unemploxment, Unemployment.
@veneetreddy6607
@veneetreddy6607 Месяц назад
You guys talk about increasing demand and in the same breath talk about increasing income taxes. You should be taxing ultra rich agriculturalists and not the middle class.
@abcdefghy-h6
@abcdefghy-h6 Месяц назад
No reneet sir as now already 3.5 months are gone🙏
@kamleshkumarsaini723
@kamleshkumarsaini723 Месяц назад
The person who just sits in AC rooms does not know anything about India's poverty. please don't fool people by just wearing costly costumes and sitting in mahals or just talking in English
@locationsmumbai3411
@locationsmumbai3411 Месяц назад
😅😅😅
@AbhyudayTripathi-zm9fq
@AbhyudayTripathi-zm9fq Месяц назад
Sir
Далее
УДОЧКА ЗА 1$ VS 10$ VS 100$!
22:41
Просмотров 280 тыс.
Эконом такси в твоем городе 😂
00:59
Standoff 2 is a true horror! #standoff #horror #meme
00:13
BeastMasters Hawk just had enough #ti13
00:30
Просмотров 358 тыс.
Inside Dr. Shashi Tharoor’s Home  | Brut Sauce
13:44
УДОЧКА ЗА 1$ VS 10$ VS 100$!
22:41
Просмотров 280 тыс.