A Perfect Circle - Judith (REACTION!!!) 

A little context: Maynard’s mother, Judith Marie, suffered a stroke and as a result, was wheelchair-bound for the rest of her life. But despite that, she continued to hold strong to her Christian faith. As the lyrics to this song make clear, Maynard does not share that faith. Although, his feelings for his mother’s continued belief evolved. When she passed away, he wrote the lyrics to “Wings for Marie” and “10,000 Days” for the Tool album 10,000 Days. Lyrics that helped me with my own mother’s death. I recommend that you give those songs a listen some day so you can fully appreciate the difference from the vitriol shown in “Judith”.

Maynard’s mother Judith suffered a stroke that left her paralyzed, but she never gave up on her faith.

You two interpret the lyrics exactly as he meant them. I really appreciate that about you two. Not just this song or this genre but every song you two listen to. Ty. Truly unbiased opinions. 👍👏

Judith was Maynard James Keenan's mother's name. She was a very religious person. One day she had a stroke that left her in a wheelchair partially paralyzed. This stroke only strengthened her belief in God - something that Maynard found to be pretty ironic. The lyrics in this song reflect how he felt about the whole situation.

A perfect circle - Orestes This underrated song happens to be their most beautiful. There is only one like it.

Dear God, you’ve reviewed my favorite song ever. So hyped

Maynard carried that last lyric for like 20 seconds at full throttle.

10:44 - *Maynard's voice surges through Ryan's body* 10:54 - *Enlightenment begins*

Holy crap thank you guys i have been requesting this for a year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you so much Third eye By tool!!!!!!!! The remedy by Puscifer!!!!

The difference between Tool and APC is that APC is usually simpler, softer, has shorter songs, and are more alternative rock than progressive metal / hard rock. I slightly prefer Tool to APC but APC is still incredible. They still display the fantastic musicianship that Tool does, but their songs are more straightforward with a standard structure. Oh also this song leans on the heavier side for them. Definitely do "The Outsider" for your next APC pick though! It's the "Judith" of their second album; guaranteed you'll both love it!

the noose is one of the most beautiful songs you'll ever hear in your life

This song represents true artistic expression/emotion, the way it should be. 'Mer de Noms' is a phenomenal album.

The Noose is my favorite APC song. 3 Libras and Pet are great as well.

Steven Wilson - the raven that refused to sing Porcupine tree - the sound of Muzak Dream theater - Blind Faith

Don't know if anyone has mentioned that F**k your god! is the only instance on the entire album where he swears. He saved it for that one sentiment.

A Perfect Circle is about as much Billy Howerdel's band as it is Maynard's, he's the one who got it going in the first place after all. In terms of comparison to Tool, thematically there are a lot of overlaps but they're explored in slightly different, more "radio friendly" ways, and in terms of the music Tool are a progressive metal band, A Perfect Circle are an alternative rock band, so the two don't muscle in on each other too much. I absolutely love all of Maynard's work, Puscifer are absolutely sick as well. Uneven Structure - Frost/Hail

Tool=Mind A Perfect Circle=Heart Puscifer=Spirit

Maynard is a special person in music. PERIOD

RAW EMOTION masterfully expressed through vibration. Gotta love the passion and anger of Maynard in this song. So haunting and horrifying yet so real. Head banging the whole way through 🤘🏽

God damn, it always puts a massive smile on my face when you guys do reactions to songs I love, and you clearly love it too. Really uplifting content guys. Fire! ;-)

9:55 LIV: He's still holding that note. 10:45 Maynard: Hold my Beer

Would? - Alice in Chains is a song for you guys!

Recently came across you guys and love love love your REAL non biased reactions and recognition for passionate music!!! Keep on keepin on. Much respect. Subscribed 😎

Haha I love you guys, I've been watching a lot of reaction videos lately, and you guys give such good, honest, fair reactions. Very cool. ❤

Maynard to me is such an anomaly. I haven't really resonated with any other vocalist like Maynard. You can FEEL his emotions when he belts out. His range is amazing, and I REALLY enjoy his gruff, pissed off vocal delivery. To top it off, his lyrics are also something that has helped me and been somewhat therapeutic to me in life. That may sound corny and Maynard probably wouldn't give 2 fucks either, but I still stand that way lmao

Angry Maynard is straight fire, end of story. Outsider is a great song too.

You guys are by far the best non rock/metal-head reactors on RU-vid. I love how you understand the appeal of all those songs although it's not your personal taste in music.

Without knowing any of Maynard’s history, these guys were able to pick up the meaning or significance of the song.

Maynard also has a THIRD! group called Puscifer. They have a song called "Horizons" that is a must-hear. It's about his mother, Judith. He has a lot of songs about her spread across his 3 groups.

Now I'm just waiting for Albatross - Corrosion of Conformity!

watching people react to something you have known is amazing, for a long time, is fun.

Hard to believe this song is 18 years old. I can remember the first time this was played on Triple J all those years back, still one of my favourite songs and albums.

Tool Stinkfist. That is a banger

If you liked the drumming at the end, you should check out their song "The Noose" which has an awesome drum groove. APC's drummer on their first two albums, Josh Freese, is different than Tool's Danny Carey, but still a top tier drummer and one of the most versatile in the entire business. He's great. As for the difference between APC and Tool, the former is a bit less progressive metal and more alternative rock/metal. Generally they have shorter songs, that are also generally not as complex and with more typical song structures and time signatures, but they are still very creative and definitely morso than most modern alt rock, I'd say. The drumming is definitely different, but both bands have two of the best rock drummers active. While Tool uses their bass and guitar about equally for rhythm and melody, I would say APC, while still having good bass work (especially on some particular songs) the guitar is a bit more prominent as a lead instrument with short solos and cool lead lines/licks and they make more consistent use of a rhythm guitarist in their grooves unlike Tool who only has one guitar player. This is very likely due to lead guitarist Billy Howerdel actually being the co-founder and writer of most of the instrumental melodies for A Perfect Circle. But generally, APC isn't quite as complex or intricate and is a bit more straight forward alternative/art rock, but that is by no means a negative. I would say they are more accessible, but that their songs are also a bit more varied in sound (even if most aren't as complex as most Tool songs) due to not being as focused on the progressive or metal elements. But they still have some killer riffs, leads, drumming and, of course, singing and lyrics courtesy of Maynard James Keenan. The two bands are both distinct, but both equally brilliant. Some people may prefer one over the other and that is understandable and cool, but APC is super talented just like Tool, just a slightly different flavor. That's how I would put it anyway. Cheers, love the reactions and like the polls, but I would say still choose at random from the suggestions too since sometimes the most popular song requests aren't the best. Judith is a great song though and I definitely look forward to seeing you guys react to more APC!

The way this relates to me is: my grandfather 95 yrs old, served to the church since he was 60. Cooked four times a week, distributed food for the homeless in Cuba, matanzas. And then after serving all those years for a cause, his house hit broken into and he was beat to death. That has changed my ways to see religion, to see this song, to see all the things that are important. Not sure what to believe in anymore heartbroken

Do Wings for Marie Parts 1 & 2. It is the answer to this song and it is the greatest piece of music I've ever heard.

The whole album 'Mer de Noms' is one of the best rock albums of all time. So many good tunes on that!

So glad you liked „Judith“ 😍. I recommend „Momma sed“ by Puscifer to enhance the Maynard world.

Wow. I've never heard of you guys or seen any of your videos but instantly im subscribed. You guys have some seriously spot on takes and comments on this song. The takes you took from the lyrics on your first listen really impressed me. Went at it with an open mind and gave some honest on point commentary. Keep up the good work fellas.

I know I’m getting to these videos late- but man. You guys have no idea how much joy I felt watching you guys bop to deftones, make faces to Tool, and George- you manage to talk yourself through song meanings so quickly that it blows my mind. I’ll be subscribing on Patreon. You just made a fan

Deftones - My Own Summer

45 seconds in to one APC song and you love everything about it? Well than you'll be blown away when you sit down and listen to the whole album. It's phenomenal.

y'alls appreciation for music PERIODT despite any disagreement of personal beliefs is so refreshing! And your willingness to dive into the meaning and the understanding of differing points of view... Y'all goated for this. Glad i found y'alls channel.

Daaaamnnn, you guys GOT it. Been enjoying your reaction vids for a little while, but this won my subscribe

The emotion in this song is beautiful. I love MJK!

Jeff Buckley-Grace Jeff Buckley-Grace Jeff Buckley-Grace

Stank face AND headbanging??? It was a stellar day for Lost in Vegas! Beautiful song, stunning lyrics. Great video guys! 💗💗💗

Nailed the reaction... again! You knew exactly what maynard's motives were immediately, I love how you have a good eye or rather ear for music and you really break down songs like this! Much respect, I love your channel!

Great video for a great song. The poll thing on patreon is a great idea and I was excited to get notifications that a new poll was put up. Keep it going!

YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!! YES - ROUNDABOUT!!!

"You never thought to question why." "Shout out to the free thinkers."

Loved this video! Love A Perfect Circle, being a massive Tool and Maynard fan since their first EP, so this was a no-brainer. Loving your open minds just as much. Brings a whole new appreciation to music I already loved!!

This is one of their more Tool sounding songs. They have a few songs similar to this but they have a lot more mellow and melodic stuff as well. And while Tool songs often feel very meticulously put together I feel like these guys kind of go with the flow a bit more. Also the polls were great, I'm definitely on board if you guys keep doing them.

fun fact: Josh Freese recorded the drums in 1 take

Really like what you guys do. You are appreciated!!

Love what you guys do but also love that you remind me about classics!

I have been watching youtube almost every day since 2009 and your my first subscription. I find both your perspectives intuitive, insightful, and UNBIASED glad your doing what your doing. Keep up the good work.

A Perfect Circle - The Outsider A Perfect Circle - Brena A Perfect Circle - 3 Libras

Much love to you guys.....keeping it real. Always get into your insightful opinions

I love how you guys really go outside of your normal musical tastes. Welcome to the world of metal heads lol

That whole album mer de noms was a masterpiece. Even when it came out all them years ago i remember the double takes people had with the band. Definitely one of those pieces of work that once you're aware of it, it makes its way to the collection. Good reaction fellas.

Tool - The Grudge!!

I just started watching your videos. First you guys get it, love that you had know idea about what this song was about and you guys got it. Yes it’s his mom he was talking about. Look forward to checking out more of your videos. 😊👍🏼

I love the open way in which you approach all these different kinds of songs. One of the best corners of the internets here.

Gotta check out Rise Against "Savior" and other songs by them. Keep up the good work!

I have been waiting for this since I found you two!!!🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

***George & Ryan, you guys are the best!!*** this is the first video I watched from your channel and ever since, I’ve been a subscriber and rang that bell for notifications on all the videos you post. I’ve spent whole weekends just trying to catch up on all the interesting and smart reactions to some of my favorite songs that you’ve featured here. Being a huge fan of Tool, 46 & 2 and Lateralus were two of my favs. You guys were on the right path about 46 & 2 right from the beginning. Better than I did at my first listen. I did some research to find the meaning behind the song and that’s the best when a song might require some homework if you’re not quite sure what the lyrics mean at first listen. When you learn something new from your favorite music, that’s awesome. You guys are smart, funny and so entertaining, and pretty easy on the eyes I might add. Two handsome, smart men with a lovey outlook who happen to be free thinkers, who could ask for more?! You guys are the best! Keep doing what you do, I’m in it for the long haul. 👍🏼😉

There is something so satisfying about watching these videos. Thank you 🙏

Maynard has come out saying that he writes with two different minds with these bands, - he writes for Tool with a very masculine mindset and he writes for APC with a feminine mindset. He also describes it as left of the brain for Tool (the functional, directional, thinking side) and the right side for APC (the linguistic, emotional, reasoning side)... - His words, not mine, - but he definitely thinks there's a difference, either way. The other guys for the two bands are also very different musicians and write in different ways, - you'll need a few more songs of each to nail down how you think they play.

Good one guys! Corrosion of Conformity - Albatross or Clean My Wounds

Love how you guys firstly enjoyed and secondly picked this apart.

Love it again guys, keep them coming!

A Perfect Circle - Passive

Judith is actually the name of Maynard's mother, she was paralyzed for quiet some time, I'm not sure what illness she had, I think it might've been cancer, but this song was written while she was still alive I believe, so this his feelings towards how he felt about his mother keeping her faith strong while she was going through this illness. The Tool album '10,000 Days' is a reference to how long she suffered before she died (some 27+ years) the song of the same name is in memory of her and is the polar opposite of the anti-god lyrics in Judith, that one is more paying homage to how great she was to him. Edit: It was actually a stroke, I believe this happened when Maynard was 11 years old; referenced in the Tool song "Jimmy"

Puscifer “The Humbling River” shows how spiritually complex Maynard’s music is.

I would have loved to see your reaction when you found out it was his mother! Loving these metal videos guys, you have such open minds and a great vibe. Thanks! Nice to see metal being appreciated by others.

3 Libras another great one. The build up on Judith to the end, amazing

Jeff Buckley - Grace

Damn you guys are really good at analyzing lyrics good vid keep it up ;)

This is the emotional reason I left the faith. My mom has been paralyzed and unable to speak for seven years. I have many other reasons but this song is the visceral feeling that was the seed for my apostasy. When you change your moms diapers and the Christians in your life are more concerned with "saving her soul" than helping their sibling, you see the hypocracy so clearly it makes you ill. Edited to say you guys do an EXCELLENT job. Well done!!

3 Libras, Orestes, The Hallow, Pet, The Outsider, Blue, and Gravity are also REALLY good songs by APC. Any and all are worth checking out

Love this reaction. Seen APC 6 times live and they are absolutely amazing

Thanks for the compliment. You two are contagious with your persistence with reaction videos. I plan on having both of you do a show with me. Because im the 10,000 song song writer

It's a testament to these guys for being able to pull out a pretty spot on meaning from this song on the first listen but it's also a testament to the writing and the force of the music to make it not only accessible, but thought provoking and compelling.

Wow I really enjoyed that you guys loved this so much. The polls are awesome. I’ve been requesting the band Chevelle for some time now and I think there are some definite crossover characteristics between APC and them that you would enjoy. Chevelle is alternative metal like APC and had some big hits around the same time and are still making music. I would love to see a poll for Chevelle.

The best music leaves you exhausted. This song always, ALWAYS, leaves me spent...

i applaud anyone who branches out to experience new music Maynard is a genius when it comes to music. love the time signature changes, syncopated beats, and deep lyrics makes him (in my humble opinion) a magnificent musician. Bravo, gentlemen for helping spread good music to a new genre of ppl. big ups!

Love you guys! Not cuz you love on this song. Cuz you are so onnit! Y'all are so f'n fun! Cheers!

Am i the only guy that thinks 3 libras is the best song ever. i enjoy most APC but....3 libras is so perfectly imperfect

A Perfect Circle - Pet, I really recommend that one in regard to vibe and lyrics.

Once again you guys are awesome! Spot on interpretation of this song

Love how y’all clearly FEEL the heavy 90s rock 🤘🏼 I dunno how anyone can NOT feel it. 💕

You guys are awesome, so much better than any other reaction videos

Dude I love this song and I enjoyed watching it with y'all,glad y'all liked it,yall have open minds when it comes to music,i appreciate y'all's opinions👍👍

Great song! Glad you liked it! You guys were on pint with your thoughts before even knowing the real story. Well done and thank you!

I found you reacting to kamikaze. I stumbled on your reaction to 46 + 2 and Judith. (Disclaimer APC is my fav band, enough that it’s inked on my arm). I love that 2 guys who didn’t know Maynard, JC or BH were straight enjoying and rocking out. You analysis was unbiased and awesome to hear. Honestly it might have been more on point than me who has listened to tool/apc/puscifer (mjk’s 3rd musical project) for almost 20 years. You guys respect music and appreciate all forms. Job well done.

Porcupine Tree - Arriving Somewhere But Not Here

A Perfect Circle Halo, The Package, Blue, Three Libras... ALL play list worthy. Headphones, alone, eyes closed. Experience. 🎶🎼😎🎼🎶

I can’t tell the two of you how much you two appreciate this song as much as I do 🙌🏻🤘

Love this reaction guys!! You have to do The Outsider for the next one. You’ll want to put that on your playlist too 😉