All I ask of you 

Eternelspotlessmind ugh me too i love him so much 💕

I'm a girl btw I just use a fake name 😄

Gerard sang it in a way that was more like he was talking to someone he loved, with such care and tenderness.

right! AND HE DIDN'T EVEN HAVE VOCAL TRAINING

AND HE'S DEAF IN ONE EAR! O_o

Anna Baker really wow he's good

Soul0Stealer no way, Patrick sang it way better than Gerard. Gerard ruined that song.

Yeah but there is a difference, Ramin is awful

i respect your opinion, but Ramin is a better Phantom than Gerard

@@michaelcastanaga5839 In all honesty, though Ramin has a clearer voice and probably a better range (Gerard can go falsetto, and so can Ramin), Gerard's persona and presence, plus older-sounding voice and acting, have me personally favoring him. Of course, Michael Crawford is my all time favorite.

But he was the best looking and sexiest Phantom I've ever seen.

@@Mira_Dunia r u all serious? Comparing a theatre and film actor with each other? Wtf

Juliette Veronica I knew he won a Tony award for Oklahoma and the full Monty

Juliette Veronica no clue

the best version I swear lol

Perfect.

Child of Music and Dreams yeah, it could have been cast much worse **cough** Russell Crowe **cough, cough**

Dude,Gerard's voice is alright but its NOT phantom material....Gerard just wouldnt make it in the broadway show

@@ironfire98 We're not saying he would make it in the stage musical, dude.

Melissa Roskos So we should just settle for gerard?

@@ironfire98 No, just that we all have our favorites. If other people say their favorite is Gerry, respect that.

She did not play Christine to be known as fiona🤦🏽‍♀️

@@NessWrldd, but she did a great job with both characters.

She will always be "Christine Daae" to me..

I remember watching POTO in 2004, then when I started watching Shameless I did a double take lol.

@@eyb0sswelcometothericefiel752 Poto significa trasero en Latinoamérica xD

It’s sick how much I’ve watched this movie. Best version ever

Same here~~~

yup and insidious

and watchmen

Radiohead yup I knew lol

yesss he is i love him

Radiohead yes....didn't know he could sing

YES AMEN

What's crazy about Gerard singing all his parts is that he's not a trained singer. Phantom was the first film he did when he sang his parts, but being from Scotland he has this natural kind of rock tone in his voice as he sings that he used very well in the film

@PopKing It's a good idea to say "I think Gerard was the worst Phantom singing wise." Whether he was bad or good are people's opinions.

No, he wasn't the best. I thought he was still good, though.

I also find it very rude that you wrote lmao.

Please don't try to change my opinion. He wasn't the best, but I loved him as the Phantom singing and all. If you're comparing him to the guys who play that role on stage, don't. It's not fair to group him with professional singers. Also, stage and film are two different mediums. Even you're a professional singer, you're going to have people you like and don't like. The Phantom was not a professionally trained singer in the book. He taught himself. Good and bad singing is relative and therefore everyone has their own idea of good and bad singing.

THANK YOU!

SAMEEEE THO!!! 😂😂

Same my aunt pointed it out me cuz I started binge watching it and then she did and I still couldn’t believe it at first she was 16 in phantom of the opera tho so she was young but still

Bailey Smith sameeeee

yes! gosh ALW is amazing

NANI !?!? So you're saying Patrick Wilson didn't do the song justice? Because to me he sounds just about perfect

@@itburns5756 I never said or implied anything about Patrick Wilson. I simply said that I think Gerard Butler has an amazing voice. Many people have an issue with the fact isn't a professional singer, but one does not have to be a professional singer to have a good voice.

@@NANI-eu3eo Yes, I agree with you about not necessarily having to be a professional singer to have a good voice.

Thank you so much. That is my point exactly.