All Star Roster WINS And FAKES 

Doing the Lord's work

I actually had to look up how many Jane Smith's were in the US just the other day.. Over 3K if anyone cares..

@@iTalkStudios pin this mans comment

Fr bro

Agreed 🤝

It’s a joke honestly what more does he have to do good bat and one the best 1st baseman in the league

@@aarong2114it’s only because the Mets needed someone

@@Mrshyguy-edits Ik it’s just dumb

Valid

Same

Same bru

Based

I like the legacy pick but not every year, it was only good for miggy and albert

Real

Who cares

Giants are mid and boring 😂😂😂 He will fall off and never make an All Star Team again

Jarren Duran

You're making the case for an NL player to be an AL all star.

no he isnt, hes trash also

For real, and right when Alonso is going into a slump, for the Mets it should’ve been Lindor or Nimmo

@@ToxicMilitant oh Mimi should have represented them

lindor isnt an all star..

Should’ve been weaver

Absolutely agree

I get it. Kwan has only played 62 games to Duran's 90 but Kwan is equal or better in every possible stat except stolen bases. So yeah, I got to go with Kwan

@@wingracer1614not even vlose

@@unclejuan2274 What's not even close?

@@wingracer1614 duran is having a better year this year than kwan specially defensively wise to and him playing every single game he should get the nod

Same with Logan Webb. His record would look better if he got more run support, which you could say about any pitcher really. But he’s an under the radar star

@@ericemler8151 He's this decade's Matt Cain

Marco Luciano also got shafted big time by the Giants front office. He was batting .393 with a 1.027 OPS when he got sent back down to AAA because he made some defensive errors. Farhan Zaidi has no clue how to run a baseball team.

@@jonnyt16 Schmitt or Luciano should be starting at SS, not Nick Ahmed. I like Chapman he’s starting to come around and he seems like a good leader for the clubhouse. Farhan technically did what fans have wanted him to do this year which was bring in good free agents, they’re just taking a long time to get into their grooves, but I still agree Farhan needs to go at some point

Agreed. Too much focus on big market shit means small markets get ignored, even when in first place. I bet dude barely knows who Turang is

Agreed

100% deserves a all star spot

@@darkstar7555 I do kinda understand with the Brewers having 2 starting position players, but Arraez isn't even a 2nd baseman

@@tbraun1705 I do kinda understand with the Brewers having 2 starting position players, but Arraez isn't even a 2nd baseman

Mets bias

Because they sucked for most of the year. One hot streak doesn't cut it unless you're Paul Skenes

But the whole season has been a hot streak for skenes

@@williamanderson6006 AAA doesn't count

@@wingracer1614 5-0 2.12 ERA do you even watch baseball

Damn

Jesus Christ hahaha

Lmao

Sadly to say it’s looking like wander gonna be be back within 2 years

adley >>>

Yeah Adley and salvy deserve it

it was kinda a snub but ASG dosnt typically carry 3 catchers. other 2 are good also

The Grimace snub is indeed puzzling…highest WAR of the entire Mets roster

What. Lindor has been super good since he got out his slump. Alvarez has not played nearly enough games. And the Mets have been the hottest team since June. Are you reallya Mets fan or just a casual?

fr

Lindor definitely should be there too, at least to make up for the fact that he definitely deserved to make it the past 2 years and easily should have made it last year. 2022 is debatable, Trea and Dansby were better but he should've been there over William Contreras if he wasn't even gonna catch, but no way should he have not made it in 2023. Made the second phase of fan voting, and definitely should've won. Swanson was a reserve over him, which was fine, but for some reason Geraldo Perdomo, a platoon player, made it over him. Pete probably made it so they can fill a HR derby spot, and the other shortstops are/were some teams' only representative, but if he doesn't get Mookie's spot then it's actually ridiculous. He's far and away been the best player in the NL not in

this is the problem with the all star game, it doesn’t matter how great you have been for the past 8 years it matters how you do in 2024. Yes he has been great and deserves the spot but you can’t just give someone an all star nod because of what they have done in years prior.

Devers is definitely beasting out. always has! But he's like a tick behind Jose I think most baseball fans know he is the better overall player. Devers is a monster at the plate, but a defensive liability and a bit less of a threat on the bases.

It's Indians...

@@nickr3441 you’re a Canadian, why do you care what the team in a different country is called? Boomer cry baby.

@@GrantIsrael638 but he’s having a better year

kimbrel sucks

@@benblake7720 Your mom sucks! LOL! 🤣🤣🤣

He'd choke bro. as a die hard red sox fan..... if you watched him in the 2018 playoffs you would have been pulling your hair out. Phillies fans can say that abt him for the 23 playoffs also.

ASG isn't about what you did last year, so why are you bringing up skenes? he's dominated since april 1.

@@cococock2418 Skenes debuted on May 11. That’s only 2 months in the majors. Your facts are off.

This comment means a lot. It makes me happy to know I'm at least giving you and your brother some joy, thank you so much for both of your support. I really appreciate it

Basically

how are we sure wander franco isn’t subscribed?

@@seamusthenerdmaniTalk is too old. And male

that escalated quick

@@rich7787 LMAO

Not even slander it’s just facts that he’s not been playing at an all star level. There were already four other shortstops for the nl and he’s not Better than them as of right now

He isn't an injured pitcher. He's been a DH since game 1 of 2024, and he's been the best DH in baseball. you cant be this dumb?

Over Contreras? Yeah no

@@jacoballenn_ Yeah yes, Contreras only has better counting stats

Every year - 2021 Lindor has been deserving and a top 3 shortstop but gets snubbed

If he played as many games, yes

@@iTalkStudios The thing is, Kwan is nearly equal or even better in most counting stats despite playing about 30 less games..

@@wingracer1614 Thats what happens when you play LESS games.

@@iTalkStudios The event is All Star, not MVP. Why are you considering “valuable”?

​@@wingracer1614but nonetheless maintaining rate stats over a longer period of time is more valuable, there's a reason that Kwan beats Duran in almost every counting stat yet Duran has more WAR, volume matters

Thank you!

@@iTalkStudios no problem keep up the good work!

I don’t think you realize how OPS works.

@@jacoballenn_ yeah, on base plus slugging: this year he's slightly above average at getting on base and has no power. If you're a guy who's only good at hitting for contact, you have to be really good at hitting for contact to be an all-star, like hitting above .340, his .312 average this year isn't good enough

@@vitalymaliarov696 312 is still good regardless.

The goat

He doesn't deserve a second chance

not if hes in prison for 20 years...... kinda hard to start again at 50

Thank you for the support! Preciate u👊

seager fell off

Either Munez or Kimbrel should have made it

@@micawells4608 yeah

he said it a milliion times. no one cares.

@@cococock2418 what is bros username

Jose Miranda isn't even close to an all star... 12 hits in a row doesnt make an all star

He told me as he was getting arrested

@@iTalkStudios lolol😆

It's a stacked year for AL outfielders. As good as he has been, he is nowhere near the top for AL OF. Judge, Soto, Duran, Kwan and many others all having better years.

@@wingracer1614 judge Soto and Duran all understandable but kwan really he was partly injuried

Because the AL outfield is stacked. he's not better than yordan,judge,soto, or kwan. Kwan only missed 20 games. The guy is batting .370. he's way better than shitander

Because it's awesome, what other reason would it be?

Blud Ohtani on skenes team lol

I agree but the problem is all the other NL SS have pretty much sucked. Arcia can't hit, Swanson has also been hurt and sucked, Lindor sucked until very recently, there's just no one else to take the spot. Mookie could but he's hurt. That really just leaves Elly and I guess Cruz..

@wingracer1614 Yeah, no argument there. It is what it is guy! As always though. Another ass National League whooping taken from the American League because most of the best players are in the American league

@@jlawhonestmusic6565 Ohtani, Ozuna, Sale, ReyLo, Mookie, Freeman, Shota, Teoscar, Profar, etc all beg to differ. We shall see

@@wingracer1614Don’t forget Masyn Winn. He’s been consistent at the plate all season and fun to watch on defense. If you’re talking about SS’s who deserve to be an All-Star; he should be in the conversation

amazing? hes mid.

O'Hoppe?