No video :(

American Presidential Tyranny (feat. The Exploration with Will Fox)

Подписаться 297 тыс.

Просмотров 300 тыс.

50% 1

This was written 6 months ago, and the conclusion was not added later. Any semblance of topical subjects is purely coincidental, and was not built into this by myself, no matter how prescient it may sound given six months prior writing.
We wanted to talk about how representative-democracy can be subverted or turned into tyranny - a pretty apt subject at any time. It is always a pressing matter. Here in the United States, we have a very clear way of defining tyranny within our government, yet it is somehow vague as well. Since our constitution was created in 1787, usurping that constitution has been the easiest way to proclaim someone as a tyrant.
Check out The Exploration's episode on the rise of tyranny in Germany:
• The Rise of the Third ...
------------------------------------------------------------
references:
Richter, Daniel. Facing East from Indian Country: A Native History of Early America (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2003). amzn.to/2MVhWJ4
Ross Kennedy eds, A Companion to Woodrow Wilson (NY: John Wiley & Sons, 2013).
amzn.to/2KXhGc1
Greg Robinson, A Tragedy of Democracy: Japanese Confinement in North America (NY: Columbia University Press, 2009).
amzn.to/2MY3kZz
Eds. Paul Boyer, Oxford Companion to American History (UK: Oxford University Press, 2001), 26, 367-68, 379-79, 831, 834.
amzn.to/2KRpTl8
Eds. Eric Foner and John Garraty, The Reader’s Companion to American History (Boston, Mass.: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1991) 26-27, 215, 558, 565, 588-89, 1081, 1172.
amzn.to/2MUYR9M
www.loc.gov/rr/...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS:
www.youtube.com...
Support the channel through Patreon:
/ cynicalhistorian
or pick up some merchandise at SpreadShirt:
shop.spreadshi...
LET'S CONNECT:
/ cynicalcypher88
/ cynical_history
------------------------------------------------------------
Hashtags: #history #tyranny #presidents #tyrants #Adams #Jackson #Lincoln #Wilson #FDR

Опубликовано:

22 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 939

@KVirello 6 лет назад

I heard he was called Woodrow "literally Hitler" Wilson in college. That's especially bad when you realise that was before Hitler was even born.

@redjirachi1 6 лет назад

Andrew Jackson is the most "literally Hitler" president given the Trail of Tears

@a_can_of_soda 6 лет назад

The Crimson Fucker Hitler hated socialism. The word "privatization" was literally coined in the 1930s to describe how far to the right the Nazis were.

@a_can_of_soda 6 лет назад

Richard Wilson If the Nazis were socialist because they called themselves "National Socialists", *then East Germany was a democracy because they called themselves the "German Democratic Republic".*

@johnnygreenface4195 6 лет назад

SodaBoy628 but weither be liked it or not, he enacted socialist policies.

@weerribben47 6 лет назад

SodaBoy628 Hey the Democrat People's Republic of Korea is totally a democracy right?!

@Googledeservestodie 6 лет назад

You forgot to mention a major point about Japanese internment; Japanese American properties (homes, business, etc) were ordered to be sold quick or be seized by the government. Farms were auctioned, stores shuttered, bank accounts froze, leaving them with no money or ownership. This left all the prisoners without livelihoods and income after the war, which was the real lasting damage to Japanese American communities.

@dbojangles1597 6 лет назад

+SBBwasaight Vuong Pretty cruel to be sure. That's the mess you have to deal with when trying to run a multicultural nation in war time. It's hard to know where the loyalty of your citizens lie when you go to war with their ancestral nation. We have always had a problem with spies for that reason.

@Googledeservestodie 6 лет назад

D Bojangles that's the thinking that creates internment camps yes. A symptom of an overarching xenophobia created by the fear you're describing. From what I can tell it creates more disdain for the US within the community than it prevents. 20 years later we had Japanese Americans who lived in the camps joining groups like the Black Panther Party, see Richard Aoki, creating another problem for the US that is arguably more damaging. It's an overarching theme of modern American history that nearly all our problems at home or abroad have roots in previous administrations taking drastic (often dictatoral) measures.

@j.2512 6 лет назад

so leftist cry because the japanese got their property seized and were sent to internment camps? strange, because the left believes in the state seizing all means of production and everyone on the middle and upper class sent to reeducation or labour camps to create the proletariat dictatorship. Ummm is almost like cognitive dissonance here. how is this cruel but massive expropiation and nationalization of private property isnt?

@dbojangles1597 6 лет назад

+SBBwasaight Vuong Yes that type of thinking creates internment camps. That type of thinking is also the truth of the situation. It seems to me that in the case of Aoki his growing up in a black ghetto had a lot more to do with his joining the panthers than internment as a child. A country that contains a multitude of radically different ethnic cultures is a recipe for internal strife no matter what the government does.

@idavisband 6 лет назад

SBBwasaight Vuong

@platonically 6 лет назад

*exhales* WILSONNNNNNN ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@jakubpociecha8819 3 года назад

*SEYMOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUURRRRR!!!*

@hermannkarol9370 3 года назад

SHIZAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

@iammrbeat 6 лет назад

Holy crap, did not know that about Francis Scott Key's grandson...woahness

@JackClockerinos 5 лет назад

Learned about him last year in school.

@michaelloedel750 5 лет назад

Hey Mr. Beat! Love your channel!

@callmecharlie37 3 года назад

@Creator De Coatrack lol stfu

@LopezArts 3 года назад

AYYYYY

@elliottowens8913 3 года назад

Mr beat give me money

@Lolpy. 4 года назад

Funnily, when Wilson went out of office he actually thought he was a failure, and did a poor job at presidency. Soar the least he was a humble fella.

@nuttus7839 3 года назад

He gets 3 redeeming points for understanding that he almost made usa an authoritan dictatorship

@ktheterkuceder6825 2 года назад

@@nuttus7839 3? Too kind. 1 is generous enough.

@B4llingKitten43 2 года назад

he was angry that he didn't accomplish all of his evil plans

@johnecoapollo7 2 года назад

"GODDAMMIT, I DIDN'T GET TO MAKE THE KKK INTO AN OFFICIAL PART OF THE US GOVERNMENT. I AM A FAILURE" -Woodrow Wilson, most likely

@lovecraftscat2420 Год назад

He had a stroke while in office and his wife often acted on his behalf

@someyoungguy4949 6 лет назад

Wilson downvoted this 31 times.

@sportsgamer8524 4 года назад

Lorenzo Nivellini these goddamn Plebeians

@lordkarasu2263 2 года назад

No way to tell now, rip dislike count

@Alex-yy5wo 2 года назад

@@lordkarasu2263 Wilson’s cabinet arrested the dislike button

@acasualcactus5878 2 года назад

The dislike button was arrested under the sedition act.

@alexwest2573 2 года назад

@@acasualcactus5878 😂🤣😂 that’s funny asf.

@williamcfox 6 лет назад

To anyone lucky enough to be a subscriber or Patron of Cypher: you've made a great choice with your time and support. This guy is seriously dedicated to his crafts of videomaking and history. Cypher , thanks for a great collab. And thanks for your patience while I worked out my half. Looking forward to hearing about vidcon

@TheKalihiMan 6 лет назад

I appreciate you mentioning the internment of people of Japanese descent. My grandfather lived in Hawaiʻi at the time, so was not interned, but my grandmother and her family lived in San Bernardino, and were sent to the Poston War Relocation Center on the eastern bank of the Colorado River. Being only 13 at the time, the sudden upheaval and treatment as a hostile outsider in the country of her birth had a lasting impression, and even to this day she hesitates to speak the Japanese language, as she feared it would cast more suspicion on her and her family than there already was. The effects of the past are still felt today, and in my case, I was cut off from the language of my ancestors through no fault of my own.

@videogamebomer 6 лет назад

TheKalihiMan Rings ture of what's happening today with kids in cages

@dillonblair6491 4 года назад

@@videogamebomer Except they aren't Americans and none of their rights are being infringed. And you leave your foreign language and culture at the border. Be American or go home.

@indy_go_blue6048 4 года назад

@@videogamebomer Shame that Obama started those cages right. Especially when it turns out that a majority of those kids WEREN'T (and still aren't) with a parent or known relative. Now what might they be doing with those kids when they get them into the states?

@DEVILSBELONGINHADES. 4 года назад

Get over it

@bluespaceman7937 4 года назад

@@dillonblair6491 Actually, several of them have been mistreated. That's violating their rights, not as Americans but as human beings. You don't automatically get to treat people of other nationalities poorly.

@timothymclean 6 лет назад

"How do you get re-elected from a _jail cell?"_ It's more common than you'd think. A lot of the long-running scandal-heavy political careers that are absolutely _hilarious_ a couple decades down the line have at least one election cycle where the politician was in jail (or at least in the middle of a criminal case) during the election.

@jliller 5 лет назад

Did Eugene Debs run for president more than once from a jail cell?

@spaceman081447 3 года назад

@@jliller RE: "Did Eugene Debs run for president more than once from a jail cell?" [Eugene V.] Debs was the Socialist Party of America candidate for president in 1904, 1908, 1912 and 1920 (the final time from prison). Reference: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs

@hawkeyeten2450 2 года назад

There was a federal judge who was impeached and removed by Congress...then BECAME a Congressman himself! Alcee Hastings.

@andrewsutherland133 4 года назад

"Adam's happily signed it into law" Actually Adam's signed it into law reluctantly and under pressure for a short time. Literally everyone admits that law was a mistake, but Adams himself never even enforced it

@chico305SIGMA 4 года назад

Is it true what you say? Pinky swear.

@neo-filthyfrank1347 3 года назад

doesn't matter, he still did it and that alone makes him a bad president, and the only bad founding father president

@andrewsutherland133 3 года назад

@@neo-filthyfrank1347 you can argue that he was a bad president, but at least be true to his character.

@neo-filthyfrank1347 3 года назад

@@andrewsutherland133 him signing it in despite not wanting to IS a mark on his character

@andrewsutherland133 3 года назад

@@neo-filthyfrank1347 but the video exaggerates his intentions

@nerdrocker89 6 лет назад

I live in Oklahoma and we totally screwed them (the native americans) over again with the land run.

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

It was even worse, because the Indian Territory was originally the Preeminent Indian Frontier, running all the way to Minnesota. That wasn't kept very well

@HoneyBadger--sl6wi 4 года назад

@@CynicalHistorian i mean hell all my ppl got was free healthcare and casinos

@nerdrocker89 4 года назад

@Saint RedPill We still screwed them. Plus I doubt that was the reason and more the excuse. Although the tribes are taking all our money now with the casinos lol guess we deserve it too right?

@thenintenbro7154 4 года назад

Martin Jones eh it’s because we utilize too broad a term

@beautifulblobfish3590 4 года назад

@@darthbigred22 one of reasons they joined the csa in the first place is they hoped that if the csa won their land would stop being taken

@ethanfleisher1910 4 года назад

Love that you guys are treating these hugely important subjects with clarity and maturity... it's so refreshing to see an apolitical, educational video exploring authoritarianism. I've been horrified in the last few years at how tyranny has become increasingly misunderstood and caricatured, to a point that I'm starting to think the younger generations would actually support a despot, so long as he told them what they wanted to hear...

@engiethefriendlyengineer 4 года назад

Yeah that's every county. You tell them what they want to hear and people will vote for you. That's what hitler did.

@spaceman081447 3 года назад

@Ethan Fleisher RE: ". . . to a point that I'm starting to think the younger generations would actually support a despot, . . ." It wouldn't just be the younger generations. I remember a poll that was taken decades ago. People were asked to read a copy of the Bill of Rights (the first 10 amendments to the constitution) and asked what they thought of it. A majority of the people surveyed rejected it as being a "commie" document.

@ethanfleisher1910 3 года назад

@@spaceman081447 But this is actually kind of in line with my point. Younger generations are far more likely to trust "polls", "statistics", and "studies" than their own gut instinct. In fact, when I look at people my age, I'm not so certain many of them have gut instinct left anymore. Hitler once taunted the parents of Nazi youth who were horrified by the change they saw in their children. His words still make sick because of how true they were. He basically said he didn't care about parents who resisted, because he had the school systems on his side, and that when the parents were either destroyed or died in time, the children would know nothing aside from Nazi ideology, having only been taught one way of seeing the world. I see this already in young people and kids. They can't fathom that people would disagree with the orthodoxy of "republicans are bad" or "all white people are racist" or any of these things that are not at all truth but a consensus. This is what scares me. Historically, when we look at Mao, Hitler, or Stalin, or any of these tyrants, they pitted the youth against the traditions of the time. Hitler is typically cast a traditional character, but he was actually a hardline socialist up until joining the brown shirts. He despised the "bourgeoise" and the traditional protestant German culture. The danger begins when tyrants or tyrannical regimes can spin their oppressive and divisive material as "revolutionary", or "liberating" that they gain that unstoppable momentum.

@macha3191 2 года назад

@@ethanfleisher1910 I'm not sure we want to trade legitimate studies for gut instincts. I would argue it's more important for folks to learn to discern which studies are legitimate.

@toddstroger9505 Год назад

Sounds like President Trump, the only one who can save us.

@js8281 6 лет назад

There's a reason why they don't talk about the tenth amendment in school: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people." Nearly every function of the federal government is outside the guidelines of the Constitution but people are too busy bickering about what bathrooms .01% of the population can use.

@RachaelMarieNewport 4 года назад

Watch HipHughes History he talks about the 10 th amendment a lot.

@emc448 4 года назад

Usually the Implied Powers of the Constitution are used to justify federal decisions that would otherwise not be supported by the document.

@yotubeification 4 года назад

They do talk about it in schools. And while many of the powers are delegated to the states the states, through passing federal law, have effectively delegated it back to the federal government.

@dmnemaine 4 года назад

What you're omitting here is that while the states do have power not delegated to the federal government, the states' powers are still constrained by the Constitution. For example, a state can make whatever traffic laws it desires, but those laws can't violate equal protection or due process, such as basing who can have a driver's license on race or ethnicity

@rustym.shackelford5546 3 года назад

Or some other Culture War crap. Ugh. 😒

@conorkelly8851 4 года назад

If I am not mistaken, Lincoln's second suspension of Habeas Corpus was conducted with congressional approval, albeit it later in 1863.

@3ou1man 3 года назад

That is correct yes

@meatman2203 5 лет назад

Jefferson during Marbury vs Madison: 👏👏 JUDICIAL REVIEW 👏👏 JUDICIAL REVIEW

@zacharytaylor3178 3 года назад

Update: we now have 6 tyrannical presidents, not 5

@ronaldomontero3624 Год назад

Trump Washington Roosevelt Lincoln Nixon Bush

@johnnyviking8152 Год назад

@@ronaldomontero3624two Roosevelts

@gh0s7-704 6 лет назад

As a non-American, I do find this really interesting...

@walterbrunswick 4 года назад

As a non-American, I am happy to be non-American.

@aryanbhuta3382 4 года назад

@@walterbrunswick Happy to be a citizen of your country, or happy you are not American?

@ALEXIUSTHEGENERAL 3 года назад

@@aryanbhuta3382 not American

@SNB_1985 3 года назад

Walter's Playground unfortunate. Where are you from?

@walterbrunswick 3 года назад

@@aryanbhuta3382 That's an interesting way to put it. Actually I would even say both in my case.

@crypticmrchimes 6 лет назад

Wow. I’m impressed you took notice of the Aleut camps. Not too many people outside of Alaska are even aware of them and I was genuinely surprised to see you give them a mention.

@MerlijnDingemanse 6 лет назад

8:04 "Lincoln was a QUEER protecting his BLACK QUEERS" Mate pls

@BradyPostma 4 года назад

Ridiculous claims. But even if true, it would still have been preferable to the pro-slavery side.

@iscrewy 6 лет назад

1. Adams didn't actively support the A&S act. Congress passed it. 2. No one was deported under the acts. 3. The common law at the time was much stricter than the Sedition Act.

@BradyPostma 4 года назад

I glanced at McCollough's book about Adams. It discusses the passage and signing of the Alien & Sedition Acts on pages 404-406. It says the acts were "an improvement" over common law, which used the truth of the claims as a positive defense (meaning that once it was proved that the defendent said the thing, they were guilty unless they could prove it was true). But "improvement" doesn't seem to suggest it was less a violation of freedom of speech. It seems more like it was "improved" because it was better at silencing libelous anti-administration newspapers. I'm not claiming certainty, but it seems like muddy waters at best and blatently anti-speech at worst. And I say that as a real fan of John Adams.

@Steven_Edwards 3 года назад

He signed it...he may have had his reservations about it, and while it is common for a President to sign almost anything Congress gives them, but his signature meant he agreed with it more than he disagreed with it.

@thesladesterb3vt3co7h 3 года назад

@@Steven_Edwards True that!

@paulbrandel5980 Год назад

@@thesladesterb3vt3co7h That doesn't make Adams a tyrant! Now old hickory Jackson another matter.

@thesladesterb3vt3co7h Год назад

@@paulbrandel5980 True. It still doesn't exempt John Adams from the blame for the act. He still sign it and gave it the "okay".

@LibertarianUSA1982 3 года назад

Best presidents 1. Washington 2. Jefferson 3. Lincoln 4. Coolidge 5. Reagan Worst presidents 1. Van Buren 2 Woodrow Wilson 3. FDR 4. Carter 5. Obama

@gogomonow 3 года назад

@@WyattPriceTV I'd put Teddy above Lincoln.

@sebastianchavez2668 2 года назад

1. Washington 2. Teddy Roosevelt 3. Lincoln 4. Coolidge 5. JFK And worst are 1. Woodrow Wilson 2. James Buchanan 3. Andrew Johnson 4. Richard Nixon 5. Andrew Jackson

@99wins31 Год назад

I'd also throw Bush Jr in here because of some of the laws enacted following 9/11 like the Patriot Act

@aidanflaherty6183 4 года назад

"How do you get elected from a jail cell?" James Michael Curley: OBSERVE

@iustinianusspeedruns 3 года назад

Sadly, Eugene Debs didn't

@kzonedd7718 6 лет назад

You SAY you wrote this 6 months ago, but admit it; this is about Woodrow Wilson, isn't it? :-P

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

I wrote the Wilson episodes months before they were finished too

@kzonedd7718 6 лет назад

I would never get anything done. By the time of making the video I'd have had too many new ideas, learned new things or simply second-guessed myself too much. I need to work against a tight and rapidly approaching deadline or projects would exist in a perpetual state of 'technically done, after I just do this little thing...'

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

Hank Green (of VlogBrothers fame) once said, "I try to get them at least 80% perfect." I was talking to him last week, and he was even more conciliatory than that about mistakes. Sometimes you can't sweat the details too much, or you'll get lost in the weeds

@rykleygalinsky8366 4 года назад

I like how you begin the video by saying the Supreme Court is tyrannical because it gave itself power, but then immediately follow with claiming Jackson is tyrannical because he didn’t obey that power

@BlaBla-sd4is 4 года назад

Right after you said a president who’s tyranny was a mainstay of this administration a trump ad came on.

@CynicalHistorian 4 года назад

Now that's funny

@Jenacide 3 года назад

@The Cynical Historian And that tells me everything I need to know about this channel

@awkwardguy8238 3 года назад

@@Jenacide Cmon that’s funny

@leviticus2001 3 года назад

@@Jenacide You must be really smart.

@golds3882 Год назад

The line "how do you get reelected from a jail cell?" hits different here in 2023...

@WrestlingMoM-gr6it 3 года назад

Honest Abe also liked to jail journalist that were against the war as well as busting in and taking guns from anyone he chose. It was terrible......

@BigNut762 6 лет назад

Pretty cool vid, a little surprised you didn't give much reference to FDR's court packing scheme. (or if you did, I didn't catch it)

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

It didn't go through, so not the purview of tyranny. Ideas only count if they take place

@BigNut762 6 лет назад

The Cynical Historian Ah, okay, makes sense then. I'd say you did a pretty good job of what actually went through, then

@kingofflamingos4344 4 года назад

FDR also put Germans and Italians in internment camps as well.

@dmnemaine 4 года назад

Not nearly to the extent that Japanese were. And what difference does that make?

@dmnemaine 4 года назад

@@darthbigred22 "The common sense side of internment" says all I need to know about you. No American citizens should have been put into internment camps regardless of their ethnicity. There was nothing "common sense" about denying American citizens their constitutional rights.

@anemu3819 3 года назад

@Nick Arjomand how were the internment camps genocide

@kayvan671 3 года назад

Really? How does it come that the commanding general in Europe was a German American? (Dwight D. Eisenhower) Did Frank Sinatra also spend time in these prisons? No he didn't. And we all know the reason why German- and Italian Americans were not put in these prisons.

@spaceman081447 3 года назад

@fabRic_jAck RE: "Internment camps =/= Concentration camps" Oh? And why not?

@rars0n 5 лет назад

I find that, time and time again, when Thomas Jefferson is against something, he's usually correct. And I know that he wasn't a great person, but goddamn did he have some great ideas.

@yotubeification 4 года назад

I mean. Judicial review is one thing he opposed that I think is good. Also the federal government itself as well. As State governments have proven time and time again to pass discriminatory and tyranical laws that need to be smashed from above as it is harder to smash from below a boot. A collective consciousness is harder to corrupt even if the institutions it functions through still are.

@unrealivandd8415 6 месяцев назад

“How do you get re-elected from a jail cell?” That sounds familiar

@57WillysCJ 6 лет назад

It wasn't just Jackson's removal of the Eastern tribes, it was how the process was accomplished that makes Old Hickory look bad. The military had a pretty humane process set up for their removal using the army. Jackson didn't like it. He wanted them out faster and the people who taking their land provide local militia to do the job, thus the trail of tears. If I remember correctly General Winfield Scott had made the arrangements for proper transport with regulars that didn't arrive. The sad part he played in the end is the one many soldiers did in following orders of being merciless in the end. Scott could have resigned in protest but it would have changed nothing.

@WaterLemon147 3 года назад

Wilson is the worst thing to happen to this country

@wyattmcgee1 3 года назад

Agreed.

@ronaldomontero3624 Год назад

Donald Trump

@AbrahamLincoln4 4 года назад

I a tyrant? Absurd.

@whafflete6721 4 года назад

How was the play? I heard it's mind blowing

@big_guy_of_leiden5688 4 года назад

I’d never call you a tyrant sir!

@surfingpenguin2279 6 лет назад

Im glad you're still posting, very informative stuff here. As long as itnis practical i hope you continue to do this

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

Building enough of a reserve to last to at least winter break

@zeroclout6306 6 лет назад

Can you go into more detail about the red scare and what is and isn't protected speech as well as the relationship of the popular political language of speech vs actually existing history/law of speech? Any fraction of these subjects would be hella interesting. Thanks for being my favorite history teacher on RU-vid!

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

As you can probably tell, protected speech has been arbitrarily defined for the last century. You would think any kind of political speech would warrant protection under the 1st amendment, but that keeps being proven wrong

@jeddafakee91 6 лет назад

That guy Adams used biracial as an insult wow ... Well slavery days I guess

@roberthsa9475 6 лет назад

i know was like... wow... just wow.

@TheRealReVeLaTioN 5 лет назад

It's sad that this country feels apologetic for what they've done to everyone else except for what they've done and continue doing to Blacks in this country.

@AeneasGemini 5 лет назад

I mean the fact that this surprises and offends you is kinda silly. History is full of things which are pretty different from our own values, and judging history by modern standards is fairly foolish. There's literally no country in any period of history that had values which were truly synonimous with modern western nations. If you get stuck in being offended by the past then you'll spend too much time on what upsets you and miss out on the other historical cool stuff

@jimbaily734 5 лет назад

It was a pretty sick burn though, from that gender-bending hermaphrodite though. In all seriousness and in retrospect, it does in ways point to truth behind the saying of "the more we change the more we remain the same" American history is fascinating

@hawkeyeten2450 2 года назад

@@TheRealReVeLaTioN LOL, when do we EVER care about Native American reservations or people in this country? African Americans get hours of media and politicians' attention, while they continue to have their community needs ignored and their history kept buried.

@anthonyminimum Год назад

I was in both Congress Hall and Old City Hall when I visited Philadelphia to see Independence Hall, the doors on those buildings are heavy and kinda hard to open

@CynicalHistorian Год назад

That's a very apt metaphor

@TheHoagie13 4 года назад

I don't know WHY it made me chuckle, seeing the quarrel between Adams/Jefferson with Mortal Kombat aback, but goddamn, *it SURE DID!!*

@pmcmanus420 6 лет назад

"The first casualty of war is not truth... but reason." -- George W. Bush

@gijoe5372 5 лет назад

Fuck Bush!

@macduece2112 4 года назад

Fuck Churchill too:-)

@Journey_to_who_knows 4 года назад

“ I am the decider I decide what is necessary”

@dougnapier6441 4 года назад

We had German internment camps in World War one kind of a forgotten Wilson moment. The man was prefacist eugenicist.

@kayvan671 3 года назад

Thats funny considering that german Americans are the largest ethnical group in the states.

@JRJohnson1701 3 года назад

Lincoln: arrested people who opposed his war policies including Francis Scott Key's grandson; deported a congressman, Clement Vallandigham; shut down and destroyed newspapers ; allowed and likely encouraged generals to target Civilians and civilian property for destruction ; invaded states he claimed were in the Union without permission of the legal government ; Created a state. West Virginia, without consent of Virginia, which he claimed was in the Union, blockaded ports, and act of war, without a declaration of war ;called up Militia to invade states without declaration of war ; plotted to have the south fire first to incite the war, and tried to deport black people from the US

@oldfan1963 3 года назад

Thanks very much for this lesson. This is what the internet should be -- a place where Americans can (if they want) learn and have many sources of information from which they can -- one can only hope -- form their own opinions.

@barrontrump3943 2 года назад

Who cares!

@joshdepaola4002 4 года назад

“I hope it hit Adams in the arsce” I mean if I said that I would just take the fine it was worth the epic burn 😎

@justafaniv1097 6 лет назад

The Korematsu decision came up again just a couple days ago. In Trump v. Hawaii (the travel ban opinion), the court once again denounced Korematsu. Though it is technically still good law, since thankfully the conditions necessary to overturn it have not arisen again, and hopefully never will.

@sanecosine505-8 6 лет назад

I've been waiting for a video like this for what seems like forever!! Finally.

@Danogil 4 года назад

Please answer When did our Representative Republic become a Democracy?

@GuyOnAChair 5 лет назад

11:42 Yes Will is a well known Tyrant. :)

@laurelrunlaurelrun 6 лет назад

FDR also tried to pack the Supreme Court with more Justices friendly to his legislation. He had to be stopped by members of his own party in congress. Done legally, but with tyrannical intent. Further, we should remember that he was elected to 4 terms, effectively serving a life term as president. He did a lot of good, but wanted his way no matter how he had to get it.

@hawkeyeten2450 2 года назад

FDR was the closest thing to a dictator this country has ever had, and what's terrifying is how powerful his cult of personality was. Even to this day, some older liberals think he was the greatest president the United States ever had, above Teddy Roosevelt, Kennedy, Lincoln and even Washington. Not quite on Mao or Stalin's level, but very alarming none the less.

@jackr1360 6 лет назад

I really enjoyed the subject matter of this one. Great vid!

@PremierCCGuyMMXVI 2 года назад

Even the greatest presidents in history did horrific things (Lincoln and Roosevelt, although what they did, especially Roosevelt, was very messed up) Although Wilson sucked on all sides lol

@henryolsen6248 6 лет назад

FDR also had Supreme Court packing, gold prohibition, and NRA.

@crimfan 6 лет назад

Nice video, and important things to recall. There are numerous other examples, of course. What I think is less usual is that the current... unpleasantness is not taking place during wartime or with anything really substantial happening on the border, although it is during the aftermath of two notable wars and a massive financial panic, so that's the kind of thing that does happen. Still. Comparison to the 1920s is apropos.

@kennethdelicata283 2 года назад

Wilson is his best line.. in fact he was not able to conduct all of his policies because of stroke makes you wonder what else would have happened

@BotheredBoy 3 года назад

Boy, this video is hitting hard in early 2021...

@leox1876 3 года назад

imagine

@A_mando1911 3 года назад

Actually Lincoln only did habeas corpus at the start it was for the rail lines to d.c so Congress could get there and when he did in 1863 it was made with full congressional Approval

@otakuevolution2131 6 лет назад

FDR is probably my favorite President, but... yeah. You don't want to praise him around George Takei. That whole internment camp fiasco was a black mark on that administration.

@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong 6 лет назад

+Logan Waltz The economy was horrible anyway. FDR just eased the suffering and gave the American people hope. A great president is not just someone who was in office while the stock market is doing well.

@darkcoeficient 6 лет назад

Captain Sum Ting Wong I think you just threw Obama under the bus.

@j.r.mocksly5996 6 лет назад

FDR is my least favorite president, because he was a bitter, angry cripple that pushed the boundary of the presidency too far. He was the original 'red scare' guy, and few recognize he was really the first big politician to start becoming paranoid about and monitoring communists. He was probably right in that though. He stayed in office 4 consecutive terms, instituted japanese internment camps, and opened pandora's box on the welfare state that has plagued our country ever since. The only reason people think he was good was because he was a war-time leader, and people think he was the only one who could've done it. He did a good job, but he was NOT the only man for the job & he blatantly disrespected george washington and our entire national tradition by refusing to step down after his 2nd term. Pearl harbor was gonna happen anyways, and our support to the allied powers was gonna happen anyways, frankly I don't think he did anything unique during WW2 except for giving a good speech and being very paranoid about people with foreign backgrounds.

@j.r.mocksly5996 6 лет назад

Noah go read up on it. He did make statements during and perhaps before WW2 indicating he was paranoid about communists. He was certainly paranoid about the Japanese as well

@fratersol 5 лет назад

Fdr was a dam communist. He bankrupted america and re organized us into a.debt based socialist country and is the root of much of whats wrong today.

@johnkilmartin5101 6 лет назад

Just as a minor point, the Canadian internment camps were not on the other side of the Rockies. The initial camp was at Hope the eastern end of the Lower Mainland. Subsequent camps were in the Slocan Valley of the West Kootenay. Later in the war as labour became scarce there was recruiting for workers on the sugar beet farms of southern Alberta where workers were in the same accommodation as the previous workers. That being said it is also true that the entire fleet of the Canadian Fisherman Volunteer Reserve came from the largest vessels of the fishing fleet of interned Japanese.

@kapatidtomas 3 года назад

I like on how you really put rock music in the intro, every single video.

@dicktracy3787 4 года назад

Lincoln tyranny: 1) passes income tax without any constitutional basis, 2) Legal tender laws - see the hilarious and depressing history on point, 3) conscription in a war to end slavery - talk about irony

@Nonsense010688 6 лет назад

2:30 "and Adam happily sighing it into law" but but the TV series, you can find here on youtube, paints him REAALLLLLY struggling and actually not wanting it and ONLY because Congress wanted it and and... ;)

@BradyPostma 4 года назад

*signing

@BradyPostma 4 года назад

Technically, it should have been "... signing THEM into law." There were multiple Alien Acts, and the Sedition Act was also a separate bill separately passed.

@joyjones8231 5 лет назад

its finally the weekend and i can binge watch you.

@bobcunningham9590 Год назад

"How do you get reelected from a jail cell lol?" 🤥

@Gixwing 5 лет назад

3:25 I would like to introduce you to my country of Brasil. We have legislator in jail so often it's not even funny.

@axriim7251 6 лет назад

this question might be controversial but did you think that president andrew johnson and his subsequent failure to halt the southern states from implementing jim crow laws is tyranny or just plain old dbag?

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

You'll find a lot of folks saying the resulting Radical Reconstruction was equally tyrannical. Considering constitutional amendments were part of both Presidential Reconstruction and Radical, the unconstitutionality of either seems suspect

@dbojangles1597 6 лет назад

+Communist Patrick I'm going to have to agree with the Historian on this. What you basically had was states violating amendments that the north pushed through without any of the former confederate states being allowed to vote. And I don't know why you would say Johnson would be tyrannical for not using the military to once again bend the south to his will. Kind of the opposite really.

@axriim7251 6 лет назад

my logic is a bit weird while all of the presidents that mentioned did something that would consider a tyranny i think about what president that didn't do anything even though he had the power to consider him a tyranny

@indy_go_blue6048 6 лет назад

Actually the Southern states did vote on them... under compulsion. Ratify or you can't rejoin the Union. At any rate, Lincoln fought against the Radicals the entirety of his first term. AJ simply didn't have the capacity to keep them in line and they rode roughshod over him. When he attempted to stand up by firing one of his cabinet they impeached and damn near convicted him, and the US would've been governed by the Speaker of the House.

@ColonizerChan 6 лет назад

Communist Patrick Well if i look at this from another way, California, New York, Massachusetts, and New Jersey among many more implemented bans on certain types of weapons to where the New York AR is an abomination. In clear violation or the second amendment to us gun owners, are we to say to other states how to run their state? I feel the same towards jim crow. Sure, it’s shitty and is a violation, but nothing exactly prevented things like segregation or voter literacy tests in the same way as there isn’t something specific to say a gun must meet retarded specs or you have to go through a waiting period (the one from Yankee Marshall where they waited more than a month in Washington over a traffic incident in Georgia from years ago that wasn’t even her fault is a funny one). I’m playing devil’s advocate here and trying to make modern parallels. However, the constitution is violated/twisted to meet a certain end for given states. If the Feds were to enforce it equally across the board, then this further limits the state power that has been slowly dwindling since the civil war to where the only differences might be traffic laws or commerce related. So yes, it would be tyrannical, even if you think you’re doing the right thing. Also, I’m from dixie, VA. I’m just saying a friendly warning to y’all to never go 80 mph or above in the state. It is a major fine and cops love getting that ticket M O N E Y for that violation. Just a heads up.

@specialed1444 6 лет назад

Was I the only one that screamed Wilson at the top of my lungs when i near he was coming up?

@LukeMcGuireoides 2 года назад

Your channel rocks. Howard Zinn would proudly approve.

@johnnyviking8152 Год назад

Zinn would add a few more to the list, probably start with Teddy Roosevelt.

@BasedPeter 6 лет назад

I've been searching for the music in the beginning for ages. Please, m'lord sauce?

@CynicalHistorian 6 лет назад

handel - sarabande

@michaelloedel750 5 лет назад

9:49 “you know who’s next” goes to add, and shows Elon Musk! The tyrannical leader of Tesla Elon Musk! (Thunder snaps) 😂😂😂

@rateeightx Год назад

1:34 Reminds me of an article I saw from the Onion, "Supreme Court rules that the supreme court rules."

@PrivateSi 3 года назад

The difference between Europe and America during WW2 is telling... In America and Canada they segregated enemy nationals away from the general population, in Europe every person that had friends or family in the countryside sent their kids to live there... millions of British kids segregated.

@holdenvanetten3106 6 лет назад

Hey dude, I think you should do a video on the film “The Siege Of Jadotville”

@theshenpartei 6 лет назад

Can you do based on a true story of Steve Spielberg’s Lincoln?

@ColonizerChan 6 лет назад

Zachary Cutter Us southrons would really stir the pot...go for it, even though I’m not a huge fan of Lincoln the president. Comments would probably be underwhelming though tbh. You’d need good bait

@neilpemberton5523 4 года назад

There's more evidence in favor of that film's portrayal than against it, unless you are a lost causer with conformation bias.

@comesahorseman Год назад

John Adams was a fine patriot before and during the American Revolution. As president, the Alien and Sedition Act knocked him down several notches in my eyes.

@SNB_1985 3 года назад

Thanks Wilson

@johnlogan2732 6 лет назад

Definitely not Wilson.... wait what?

@wanderinghistorian 4 года назад

@Cynical Historian You showed a clip of Star Wars and said that "Order 66" from SWRotS was directly inspired by Executive Order 9066, but a simple Google Search showed absolutely no evidence of this. In fact, the only thing I found was a fan theory from someone speculating it might be the case. Now to err is human, but what upsets me as a historian about this blunder is that in order to make it you had to have heard this urban legend hearsay from someone, then posted it into a video without a primary source. You could've said it was a theory, or speculation, but instead presented it as fact when you knew you didn't have the proof in hand. That is academically dishonest, and it casts a long shadow of doubt for me over all the rest of your content.

@backtothefutureman1 3 года назад

That Star Wars reference was funny.

@LamLawIndy 6 лет назад

Both the FDR (Exec. Order 6102) and Nixon (via Treasury Sec'y Connally) Administrations suspended the convertability of notes into gold. While not blatantly a "taking" in the sense of govt taking private land, their actions drove down the value of notes held by the public and/or foreign nations.

@TheParadoxGamer1 6 лет назад

The Andrew Jackson thing, always bothers me, as someone from Oklahoma I know and am infuriated by the actions against them especially in the years of Oklahoma becoming a state.

@barrontrump3943 2 года назад

Go to another state then

@donnydew6207 5 лет назад

FDR also took control of economy

@michaelbledsoe9296 5 лет назад

Cheesehead87Gamez Good.

@steveempire4625 3 года назад

While certain practices of tyranny are useful to study, I would argue that tyranny can be as simple as the power granted to the executive. The more a nation's government spends as a percentage of their GDP, the more power the executive has to enforce Congress' laws and the agencies funded. Under that criteria, the most authoritarian presidents are Lincoln, Wilson, FDR, and every single president after FDR to the present. This we can statistically measure.

@lookbovine 2 года назад

Political power and government money spent are not 1:1, as in they are not the same thing. So that is not a measure of “tyranny”, as if political power was equivalent to tyranny either. Keep studying.

@steveempire4625 2 года назад

@@lookbovine Your argument is essentially "not-uh" with a less than witty retort at the end.

@TheModernPioneer Год назад

I want literally just one major wartime President that doesn’t violate the First Amendment. Just one.

@CynicalHistorian Год назад

but it's traditional

@iustinianusspeedruns 3 года назад

WILSOOOOON!

@sanguisbumb6138 6 лет назад

14:49 nice John Oliver reference

@fuzzydunlop7928 6 лет назад

I like his show, but I will never respect the man after that episode they did the week of the 2016 election slandering Jill Stein in order to get people to vote for Hillary. They even called her an 'anti-vaxxer' erroneously. It was under-handed and obviously partisan-motivated and it really made me lose my respect for the man and lose my trust in the show - but god is it good when it's on point.

@willemdafoe9811 3 года назад

@@fuzzydunlop7928 his foreign policy stuff is kinda weird. His thing with amlo being like a "mexican trump" was odd to say the least. So much actually interesting political topics around amlo's presidency and that is what they went with.

@redjirachi1 6 лет назад

Just as Linkara traces everything bad back to Countdown, you trace everything bad back to Woodrow Wilson

@TheVredeHunter 5 лет назад

People need to seriously stop comparing trump to hitler. It’s insulting to people who actually lived in that hell. Trump, is a loose cannon, not a dictator monster.

@fovlsbane 6 лет назад

Why is it foolish to hate Lincoln for being racist and denying states to leave the union?

@tobyblack9535 6 лет назад

Fovlsbane well, those states 1) wanted to go against the federal nature of the US, which went against the constitution , and 2) did so to preserve the morally abhorrent institution of slavery. It's rare that people who defend "states rights" don't do so to perform a form of confederate apologism.

@fovlsbane 6 лет назад

Whether something is constitutional or not doesnt really matter, the implication being that only by following the constitution of the US can you not be a fool, atleast I dont think that. Im not american, so Im not defending state rights, Im however defending people to be self determined if they so wish, whether its legal at the time or not. Also, I see people defend state rights for all sorts of reasons not to do with the south, maybe you follow different things from me. Im not a historian, so probably ignorant to many things. Potentially ignorant, I dont know that secession rights were ironed out before the civil war.

@backyardboosters9128 6 лет назад

Toby Black wait wait wait. The Confederates by law would have been upholding federal nature (federation). The union would have been defending a nationalist nature unknown to the constitution. The conflict is not simple. The North by and large had very little problem with the institution of slavery, hence it continued to exist in border atates, Lincoln supported the Corwin ammendmeny. The main concern was it's spread westward were there were fewer than 20 slaves...... this had to do with representation to both sides and much less to do with slavery. The ugly truth is the South was free trade, the North were very much protectionist. Lincoln was a very huge fan of Henry Clay amongst other whigs. The free soilers had a very racist motivation for the defense of free states westward, they over and over again including Lincoln stated that they wanted to keep western lands for the white man...... republicans and former whigs believed blacks would die out without slavery, this is why Lincoln in 1865 stated "former slaves would root hog or die" which was him basically saying they would be gone in know time, he remained a member of the Illinois colonization program to his dying day, and supported Illinois blacl code laws...... It's not some simple "Southerners are monsters" story it's a very odd and strange thing. Read time on the cross very interesting read from a northerner none the less.

@backyardboosters9128 6 лет назад

Fovlsbane Virginia amongst a few other states implicitly stated when ratifying the constitution that they reserved the right to leave the Union. This was unchallenged.

@fuzzydunlop7928 6 лет назад

Can I see some sources for what you're saying here?

@moneyadams3751 6 лет назад

Why the hell is there a dislike on this video?

@Synthprayer 6 лет назад

Money Adams woodrow wilson did it

@GanjaEnthusiast322 6 лет назад

WIIIIIIIILLLLLLLLLSSSSOOOOOOONNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!

@Kabutoes 4 года назад

Order 66 wasn’t mentioned as inspired by 9066 from Lucas anywhere I have found, but the parallels between Emperor Palpatine and FDR are alarming from the fact that both were viewed as heroes to the republic and wanting to make it so they have lasting power (FDR with the 4 terms, one being 1944, a year before his death). FDR was on a roll, why should he voluntarily stop running? Same reason why Palpatine didn’t back down from his ascendency.

@deoglemnaco7025 3 года назад

Wilson was a very fair cribbage player. Nobody ever mentions that. Always focusing on the bad stuff. Sheeesh

@EUSA1776 6 лет назад

Although Lincoln might have done some things which we would regard as usurpatious, it is undeniable that without him we would not have a country . The suspension of Habeus Corpus was wrong , but it was preferable to losing the border states and losing the war. Ulysses S. Grant would suspend Habeus Corpus when fighting the KKK and no one complains about that . The constitution gives the president war powers, and nothing Lincoln did was meant to extend past the end of the war. He wanted the South to rejoin the Union without punishment, without vengeance . Jefferson Davis even said that the worst day of the confederacy was when Lincoln was assassinated. Was he racist ? In his youth, most likely, as he got older , and especially during his presidency his views changed , and he developed a great respect for colored troops. He called for black voting rights 100 years before the civil rights act , and John Wilkes Booth put a bullet in his head for it . These are minor faults in the grand scheme of things. Lincoln lead the country through its greatest crucible, and he did an outstanding job , he is our greatest president . Flawed yes, such as we all are, but it takes a very arrogant person to say they could’ve done it any better. Lincoln deserves his place in our national memory, and our gratitude . Long live the Union 🇺🇸.

@EUSA1776 6 лет назад

MR.Chickennuget 360 Absolutely right . Some blacks even held public office in the years after war, though Grant still had to hold martial law to prohibit the KKK and other groups from acts of violence . Civil rights did nothing but force the government to uphold the promises of a century prior .

@DracosTheGladiator 6 лет назад

We're a Constitutional Representative Republic. Not a democracy.

@BrendanGeormer 6 лет назад

Don't forget the time FDR tried to flood the Supreme Court.

@charliem6467 4 года назад

Wilson isn’t even comparable to hitler. I get what you mean but they just aren’t comparable

@pestilenceplague4765 6 лет назад

We are not a democracy, we are a representative republic!

@BobbyBlockable 6 лет назад

Not that big of a difference, they aren't clearly defined

@pestilenceplague4765 6 лет назад

Bobby Block if we were a democracy then Hillary Clinton would have won the last election.

@MaxterandKiwiKing 6 лет назад

Thats still a democracy, just not a *direct* democracy

@pestilenceplague4765 6 лет назад

MaxterandKiwiKing it's a representative republic

@tobyblack9535 6 лет назад

Nah, still a democracy. Just because the electoral college is a thing doesn't make America a non-democracy. Government and legislative power, authority, influence and legitimacy still comes from the people.

@marbanak 6 лет назад

Hate to complain about otherwise excellent work. I support the Japanese internment but ==>not the way it was done

@NewGuy2534 3 года назад

I think it comes out to whether or not Tyrany is an evil that should be shunt or a necessary evil that should be used sparingly. In the end, evil remains.

@tigerstyle4505 4 года назад

I'm not sure if the real irony isn't that Francis Scott Key wrote that most famous of songs about freedom and included a now omitted stanza in glowing support of slavery and those who violently enforced the institution. Just sayin.