Тёмный

ANCESTRY DNA VS. MY HERITAGE: OUR NEW DNA RESULTS 

Ida & Silvia
Подписаться 15 тыс.
Просмотров 46 тыс.
50% 1

We had our dna analysed by two different companies and here are the results!
Music by Silvia
-Ida
/ iiidajosefine
Snapchat: iiidajosefine
Personal channel: / idaastrand
-Silvia
/ figsilvia
Snapchat: silviafigueroa

Опубликовано:

 

16 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 294   
@sergiosierra6849
@sergiosierra6849 5 лет назад
both are 100% pretty, like i needed a test to know it
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
That's so sweet thank you for commenting 🤗🤗 /silvia
@AlbertoAKernz
@AlbertoAKernz 3 года назад
Very nice video! Thank you for sharing your results with us.
@christianlimpert1706
@christianlimpert1706 3 года назад
Simp
@septalcannon6850
@septalcannon6850 3 года назад
@@christianlimpert1706 Hes not simping. He’s just saying they’re just pretty. That’s it. He’s not actually looking for them as a relationship
@amandaravello
@amandaravello 4 года назад
When I tested my dna on ancestry I got 2% Nigerian while on myheritage I got 54.9% Nigerian. That is a HUGE difference so I am so confused now.
@beanem.3989
@beanem.3989 4 года назад
What?! That‘s really confusing 😒😒😒
@keyboardwarrior0082
@keyboardwarrior0082 4 года назад
@o o Many Germans and France have a simillar DNA. Its because ethnics are very mixed here. For example most English People come from North Germany(Angelsachsen) so many North Germans have the same DNA as the english.
@discogoth
@discogoth 4 года назад
I’ve had this happen. I’ve done three different DNA testing companies and have received dramatically different results from each. I think people sometimes forget that these are science entertainment, and the science isn’t completely reliable. But they can get pretty close for the most part.
@discogoth
@discogoth 4 года назад
o o yes, hence, “these are science entertainment and the science isn’t completely reliable”.
@aubs965
@aubs965 4 года назад
I FEEL YOU ON THAT. I originally tested on myheritage and got 34% italian, then on ancestrydna i got ZERO. The thing is i know my dad is italian lol so its true but maybe somewhere in between zero and 34 lol. Maybe its the same for you, somewhere in between those numbers
@tsalon5864
@tsalon5864 5 лет назад
MyHeritage is the worst for Latin Americans. Why? The Central American group does not mean Native American. They used mixed people for this category instead of indigenous Americans, so the Central American is always larger than what it would be if it had been just indigenous Americans. Two Mexican friends showed up 60% Central American when they were about 30% Native American on every other site.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
interesting! /Ida
@ntl5983
@ntl5983 5 лет назад
MyHeritage is the worst.. period.
@danilovelennon8283
@danilovelennon8283 4 года назад
I agree, my heritage DNA sucks, I got my results and I so disappointed with that... I'll try my ancestry or 23 and me ...
@DarkGoddess99
@DarkGoddess99 3 года назад
So my heritage puts central like Hispanic and indigenous as one catogory🤔
@commendedzuez0944
@commendedzuez0944 3 года назад
Do you have a source?
@tvurk
@tvurk 5 лет назад
Most importantly, humans share 50% of their DNA with bananas
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
I love that 🍌 /Silvia
@JackoBanon1
@JackoBanon1 5 лет назад
That's because all life on Earth has the same origin.
@radination2018
@radination2018 5 лет назад
60%
@Miningfox
@Miningfox 5 лет назад
... and at least 99.9% with all other humans.
@John-pu5kz
@John-pu5kz 5 лет назад
We all came from Adam and Eve at the end of the day.
@clarestclair8771
@clarestclair8771 5 лет назад
You guys are just two beautiful human beings no matter what any Dna results says you guys are awesome people and I think that's all that matters.
@char08fal
@char08fal 5 лет назад
For the African heritage I think Ancestry is a little bit more accurate and can pinpoint smaller regions due to the larger database. But overall they are still the same regions if you look at the shaded areas.
@melaninqueen2413
@melaninqueen2413 3 года назад
Not really. I don't see Sierra Leonean on there, which I descend from and they're saying that I'm 86% African while Myheritage DNA is saying that I'm 78.7%. I don't know which one to believe.
@fordhouse8b
@fordhouse8b 10 месяцев назад
@@melaninqueen2413 Because some gene sequences (in fact the great majority of them) are shared by all human beings, and even with other primates. It isn that one company is finding less African genes in your sample, it is that based on the data they have available, some of that DNA is not interpreted as being exclusively associated with people of African.descent.
@djBLOOMchalGA
@djBLOOMchalGA 5 лет назад
If you read into the American ethnicity description, MyHeritage says that their native American ancestry is mestizo (half/half native/European)....so I would trust Ancestry over heritage if your Latino.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
yes! that's why we did the ancestry test to begin with since silvia had read that it was the most accurate one for latinos ^^ /Ida
@ntl5983
@ntl5983 5 лет назад
You mean "central american"... that is how they call the native american-european mix.. they have another region called native america but that only covers the U.S..
@ntl5983
@ntl5983 5 лет назад
@@mararanian9573 So?... that didn't create another race called "central America"
@lil_weasel219
@lil_weasel219 4 года назад
No. Their CENTRAL AMERICAN is mestizo.
@RWebster325
@RWebster325 4 года назад
@laina Your statement is not fully accurate or factual. It does not matter which company does the test, they can only compare it to what they have in their database. The next thing is how accurate or inaccurate are the 'family trees' created by the individuals (or researchers) that participate with that company? The more accurate the background 'family trees,' the more accurate the results for 'ethnicity' AND race become. An additional factor that is rarely addressed in videos such as this are the haplogroup results since most of these are based on the autosomal test which does not include haplogroup information.
@zezemh5462
@zezemh5462 5 лет назад
Happy seeing you back girls 💖
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
I hope you liked the video 💕 /Ida
@socrates5135
@socrates5135 5 лет назад
I agree with earlier comments that Ancestry DNA is most likely more accurate for multiple reasons (more reference data, better algorithm, etc.) The final definitive result is obvious...Two 100% Lovely Ladies!
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
yeah i like that they keep updating the results too ^^ /Ida
@Jay-cy4js
@Jay-cy4js 4 года назад
Ancestry changes a million times and delayed so many regions and adds random new regions you’ve never heard of .
@albinajeta8882
@albinajeta8882 4 года назад
@@Jay-cy4js true. Ancestry gave me 30% eastern European dna and my heritage 0 ,I think my heritage is more accurate.
@hanng1242
@hanng1242 5 лет назад
The way these sort of DNA tests work is that they compare your genetic profile to the genetic profile of a sample population. The population's profile is created by aggregating the the genetic profiles of the population sample such that they can say something like, "X% of people living in Y country have Z allele." Then, they use statistical analysis to match up your individual profile to those of various populations to return a result. One limitation to this, though is the manner in which the "population" is defined for purposes of establishing the baseline. For example, if we were to create a population profile for the United States, it would be different from a population profile generated for Americans who check of "black" on their last census form. Thus, the difference in the results between the two companies could be the result either of different methods of statistical analysis, or it could be that their population baselines were different. The "population" is the population at the time of compilation. But this could be tweaked over time, it could be tweaked by limiting the population by sociological factors (for example, maybe they could exclude from a country's population" any DNA taken from an individual whose family has residency in country of less than five generations, as proven by birth certificates), or they could possibly supplement data using DNA taken from old remains. Anyway, I am not surprised by Ida's British and Baltic results. I suspect that it is not that she has British/Irish or Baltic ancestors, but rather that the vikings invaded the British Isles, leaving mark on the pre-existing population, and that the Baltic population also has viking roots - either from before the unification of Russia, or because of the Teutonic Knights and their state in the Baltics after the general conversion of the northmen to Christianity. As for Sylvia, I'm not sure, but it seems that about 15% of the Swedish population is foreign born. Depending on what Swedish population was used to establish the population profile, it could be that some of the folks included in that profile were from places (Southern Europe, Middle East) whose population left their DNA in areas where Sylvia knows here ancestors are from. Or it could be that some Swede traveled widely back in the day, and may have left his DNA in a place that produced somebody who left his DNA in Colombia.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yes ^^ we mentioned this briefly in the video but I cut most of the discussion out cause it went on for too long haha I don't remember exactly how much I kept in there but I think I mention the Viking thing like you did too in the video ^^ and we also said that's why silvias African side is so fussy cause it's most likely based on Americans and not "actual" Africans still living in their native countries :) hence why the european results seem more accurate cause many people still living in Europe has provided their dna already so you have a more accurate way of guessing :) and that's why it's great that ancestry keeps updating your results as more information is collected ^^ for that reason only I'd probably recommend ancestry over my heritage :) /Ida
@davidd3063
@davidd3063 5 лет назад
i love both your smiles! thank you
@davidd3063
@davidd3063 5 лет назад
you can do 23 and me
@stargazer1804
@stargazer1804 5 лет назад
You both are incredibly beautiful, I just uploaded my raw DNA data to my heritage, I’m excited. 😅
@lpragaiova
@lpragaiova 4 года назад
How did it go? :)
@LovelySunshine17
@LovelySunshine17 5 лет назад
Awesome! My results on ancestry changed quite a bit after the update too ~~ my Cameroon/ Congo used to be around 20%. Now its up to almost 40%. I also had Finland/nw Russia lol. But its Norway now... I'll check again in a few months to see if it changes again.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yeah I hope it gets more and more accurate with time 😁 /silvia
@OpinionatedChicken59
@OpinionatedChicken59 5 лет назад
I'm glad I watched this I didn't know myheritage did it for free I uploaded my ancestry.com raw data as soon as I watched this video and got my results back today they are pretty much the same just wildly different in percentages but still interesting myheritage seems a lot more in depth in the relatives area though I found a lot of new relatives much more easily than on ancestry that actually helped me build my family tree!
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
that's great! the family part just depends on what company those people used to do the test though, and different tests might be more common in different countries ^^ now you're in both data bases so you have an even higher chance of finding relatives! good luck! ^^ /Ida
@saharasky2
@saharasky2 5 лет назад
My daughter who has Cree ancestry comes up as Inuit through myheritage as well. I believe they just have that migratory group classified as one thing when it really encompasses many different peoples. Also she comes up with 0 % Native American through ancestry.
@hailandplaice
@hailandplaice 5 лет назад
MyHeritage is the least accurate of the testing companies as they have the smallest database by some margin. But even ancestry and 23andme confuse certain German (north west), Dutch (north) and Danish (south) genes with British/English as that is where the English originated from. Even the Scots, Irish and Welsh will have quite a lot of English DNA.
@johnpatrick5307
@johnpatrick5307 2 года назад
The "English" are mostly Britons - and half of them are Middle Eastern farmers.
@hailandplaice
@hailandplaice 2 года назад
@@johnpatrick5307 ANF (Aegean Neolithic farmers) were actually mainly I1s and I2s in Britain, probably represented a slave class who originally learnt farming from the peoples who brought farming from the Aegean to what is now Iberia, France and Germany. These ANF peoples were the first to create the stone/wooden circles, but in western europe were almost completely wiped out by a migration of R1b steppe beaker peoples migrating from what is now Ukraine c. 3000-2500BC. The vast majority of males in western europe are now R1b.
@johnpatrick5307
@johnpatrick5307 2 года назад
@@hailandplaice But recent studies have shown that they survived in parts of France - and went on to re-colonise much of Britain.
@hailandplaice
@hailandplaice 2 года назад
@@johnpatrick5307 The peoples that came from France to Britain 1300-800BC were all Bell Beaker R1b descended peoples. The only place where male lines of ANF peoples survived in western Europe was in Corsica and Sardinia (protected because they were islands), and possible to a smaller extent in the Basque region (protection from mountains).
@johnpatrick5307
@johnpatrick5307 2 года назад
@@hailandplaice Well, the findings were that "Middle Eastern farmers" re-colonised Britain, so that can't be the case..
@mystery1745
@mystery1745 5 лет назад
I'd say Ancestry is more accurate. It's a bigger company (more samples) as well. Interesting results from both!
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yeah and it's interesting how they offer free updates when they have enough new information! So it should get more and more accurate with time ^^ /Ida
@Jay-cy4js
@Jay-cy4js 4 года назад
No my heritage
@ramakrishnashalom9004
@ramakrishnashalom9004 5 лет назад
Silvia, you are a unicorn. It's very rare for a person of Spanish descent from the Americas to have that much African DNA. That high percentage is usually only found in people of Spanish descent in the Caribbean and Brazil.
@tsalon5864
@tsalon5864 5 лет назад
Ramakrishna Shalom Not true. 90% of the African slave trade went to Latin America. There are many in countries outside of what you said where people have significant African ancestry, especially Venezuela and Colombia...but many other countries as well.
@agfromdai.e3806
@agfromdai.e3806 3 года назад
It is NOT rare lmfao.
@IMR27
@IMR27 5 лет назад
Nooo I am from Spain and I totally understood what you were saying and didn’t get offended ❤️
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
I'm glad you did! Thanks for watching
@jaimedegonzaga9722
@jaimedegonzaga9722 5 лет назад
Por qué nos iba a ofender? Sería suerte para ella que tuviera sangre española. España dominó el mundo por 300 años mientras ellos vivían sin ninguna importancia.
@vm2602
@vm2602 2 года назад
Por qué nos iba a ofender ? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WfmjPKwW9ko.html
@taewoonglee457
@taewoonglee457 5 лет назад
Hello ida & silvia,hope you guys are doing great,always keep doing what you love,keep being awesome & have a blast of fun everyday 😊😊😊
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Thank you :) /Ida
@taewoonglee457
@taewoonglee457 5 лет назад
@@DaebakOfficial your very welcome ida,sorry I've been busy on bigo live but still,i'll always be supporting you & your friends. Stay awesome 😊❤
@Spinelicker5
@Spinelicker5 5 лет назад
I just got my Ancestry DNA test today! I'm excited to find out.. so far I think I'm %50 Scandinavian and then %20 Native american %10 Scottish and %10 English and then the last %10... I have no Idea mostly probably from Middle East or Africa because that's a huge Migration pattern. Great Vid you all!!!!
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Fun! I hope you get your results fast! 😁 /Ida
@BimRen246
@BimRen246 5 лет назад
I just did this with my Ancestry raw data to My Heritage and was left a bit confused as well. I liked the dramatic music part as I opened My Heritage to get my results... lol
@azaliarastin5025
@azaliarastin5025 5 лет назад
bimboyren from which part of ancestors DNA we can get Raw data of our genetic please ?
@BimRen246
@BimRen246 5 лет назад
@@azaliarastin5025 Ancestry Sign in to your Ancestry account. Click the DNA tab and select Your DNA Results Summary. Click SETTINGS on the right side of the page. Click DOWNLOAD RAW DNA DATA on the right side of the page. Enter your password and click CONFIRM. ... Open the email and click Confirm Data Download. Click DOWNLOAD DNA RAW DATA.
@flexingingodspeace7774
@flexingingodspeace7774 5 лет назад
Bomboyren so which one will you believe?
@vocalist1961
@vocalist1961 2 года назад
Interesting video. I tested with MyheritageDNA, recently, and these were my results: Mesoamerican & Andean 81.4% Irish, Scottish, and Welsh 15.6% Middle Eastern 3% I will definitely test with Ancestry DNA next to compare
@barbaraobach
@barbaraobach Год назад
My Heritage lumps together 'Native American and Southern European' and calls it Native or 'Meso American' which can be misleading, so if your results says 81.4 % MesoAmerican, you're not 81% Native American , you're from that portion, aprox 35%Native Smerican and 45%+ S European
@dushessr5272
@dushessr5272 5 лет назад
Maybe I can explain the cameroon/congo + bantu vs kenyan Largest ethnic group in kenya is the bantu and they generally come originally from congo/cameroon region... Hence results may overlap from that..
@tallthinwavy3
@tallthinwavy3 5 лет назад
Funny video. I had the same problem when I used DNALand and others. Finnish popped up and few other nationalities like Spain but not in Ancestry. Do make more videos on this topic. Thanks.
@alberteinsteinthejew
@alberteinsteinthejew Год назад
Omg Ida is an angel
@pugrad2011
@pugrad2011 5 лет назад
Both so very pretty ladies :)
@KewpieGirl
@KewpieGirl 3 года назад
I dare you, girls, to try CRI Genetic for updated results for this YEAR and see other comparisons from your of 2 DNA companies. Im gonna try MyHeritage, I heard that company was the number #1, Ancestry is in 2nd place, and also beat 23&Me the lowest place. Be proud of your own skin!
@moncadamedia
@moncadamedia 5 лет назад
I think MyHeritage DNA is nuts!!
@sadgirlporvida92
@sadgirlporvida92 4 года назад
it is the same my heritage just breaks down where exactly you come from, like on ancestry I got 33 percentage of Germanic Europe but it doesn't say where at but on my heritage it tells me where I come from in Germanic Europe
@goodaimshield1115
@goodaimshield1115 5 лет назад
Try Gedmatch. Also, ancestry dna is way better than MyHeritage, though they do weird things too, like separating Basque Spanish and Portuguese into different categories.
@randycostenbader9800
@randycostenbader9800 5 лет назад
goodaim shield, but Basque, Spanish, and Portuguese are different from each other, why wouldn’t they separate it?
@ChrisM-vz4pe
@ChrisM-vz4pe 5 лет назад
Randy C_21 Actually, in a way they are the same in terms of DNA. In fact, if anything it’s just a minor small differences between each other. I have a friend who works as a genealogist for 23andme. What my friend told me is that they are basically the same. I do remember him telling me that the difference is 0.05 when comparing and examining both DNA. I don't remember everything he told me and this was about two months ago. For Instance, Irish and Scottish are the same in terms of DNA. In time Ancestry’s DNA database will get substantial solid and sufficiently accurate with people’s DNA results.
@randycostenbader9800
@randycostenbader9800 5 лет назад
Chris M, the amount of dna that they actually examine for your overall genetic results is about that same percentage you mentioned, which makes sense. However, a small percentage makes a big difference with their genetics and their appearance. While it’s very similar, it’s still different and should be separated if they are different. Irish and Scottish are also like this. They have very similar dna, but are still different. From personal experience, I’ve been able to see differences in appearance between all of these similar ethnicities. Plus, without differences within their dna, there’s no way ancestry could separate them like they have.
@Irllyneed2pee
@Irllyneed2pee 4 года назад
goodaim shield 23 and me is better than both.
@conormcguire2376
@conormcguire2376 4 года назад
Ancestry told me I was Scottish, Irish, English and Welsh and myheritage said I’m Irish, Scottish and Welsh and Baltic
@An-by2rk
@An-by2rk 5 лет назад
Ida Can you make a makeup Tutorial please? 😊
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
many have asked me to, but i don't really do make up 😅i only put on bb cream as a concealer, mascara, fill in the hole in my left brow (lol), fill in my lips with any available lip pen that matches my natural lips and i use the same brown eyeshadow for cutting the crease and contouring my face 😅when I'm not filming I don't do any make up at all, i'm too lazy haha but i could definitely make a video about what products i use and how i apply them! (spoiler alert they're pretty much all from etude house haha) /Ida
@TempleDrivePluto
@TempleDrivePluto 4 года назад
its pretty much the same its just not broken down
@ChrisM-vz4pe
@ChrisM-vz4pe 5 лет назад
@Silvia Honestly, you're so cute and beautiful. Moreover, you also have gorgeous skin complexion. 😍
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Aw thank you that's so sweet 😁🌸/silvia
@A-Dubs398
@A-Dubs398 5 лет назад
Ida has a great beautiful glowing complexion too.
@vaneshoska
@vaneshoska 4 года назад
The results are depending of the data each Company have already in their system... Non of them are wrong... They just complement each other... That's it!!! One company have more data for certain areas and same with the others companies ....
@macinhorstemeyer1961
@macinhorstemeyer1961 5 лет назад
With AncestryDNA, I got 68% Eastern European and 32% Baltic .
@anuheakamahana8719
@anuheakamahana8719 5 лет назад
Aloha! You both should do 23&me and compare. And it is on sale right now 😀
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
hahaha maybe.. I don't feel like it would be worth my money though, pretty sure I'd just be confirmed Swedish once again haha maybe they accept raw dna files too like my heritage so we could get it for free though ^^/Ida
@John-pu5kz
@John-pu5kz 5 лет назад
@@DaebakOfficial LOL!
@idamillaenberg1571
@idamillaenberg1571 5 лет назад
New video yaaay
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
thanks for watching
@vanessa12342able
@vanessa12342able 5 лет назад
For a minute I thought she also Asian. Thanks. For sharing your dna results.
@Dumsvensk
@Dumsvensk 5 лет назад
I also had 1.3 Eskimo/Inuit! *Cyber* *High* *Five!*
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yay! ✋🏼
@theresacolosimo5589
@theresacolosimo5589 4 года назад
When you transfer results from one company to another, it's like playing wheel of fortune. Not as good as actually taking a test with each company. Bits and pieces not the same.Also, each company looks at different parts of the genome which is huge.I don't think you are supposed to be adding up each result with another, they are separate for a reason.
@irtap404
@irtap404 5 лет назад
Ladies, did Ancestry DNA send you the update for free or do you pay the monthly fee?
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
there's a monthly fee? haha I've never heard of that 😅the update is a free update that everyone who's taken the test gets :) they update all results when they have enough new information ^^ if you've used the service you get an email saying updates are out and to log in if you want to see what changed :) /Ida
@irtap404
@irtap404 5 лет назад
​@@DaebakOfficial Thank you! I think the monthly fee is for people interested in researching their family tree. Good to know, I think I know which one to go for now! It's kinda annoying to see now that no company will show "the truth", after seeing how Silvia got such different results... (Inuit? wtf). But maybe with the years it gets better!
@gugoop6918
@gugoop6918 5 лет назад
Mine totally did a 180 from the previous
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
So confusing 😅 /silvia
@robgau2501
@robgau2501 3 года назад
Myheritage says I'm 45% Scandinavian and 44% British but AncestryDNA has no Scandinavian and mostly British. So.. .Definitely what to believe? You're both gorgeous btw
@GersonBulldog
@GersonBulldog 3 года назад
Hola. Me pasó muy similar a Silvia. My Heritage con 19% escandinavia y en 1% Ancestry Al igual que En los otros porcentajes muy distintos. Saludos
@alexlestrange8662
@alexlestrange8662 3 года назад
Silvia looks so much like a friend of mine but we live half the world away lol
@teneleven2818
@teneleven2818 5 лет назад
This test might be more accurate than the other test
@jaimedegonzaga9722
@jaimedegonzaga9722 5 лет назад
I am from Dsdfpweegejvmlsre (Mars) and I got: 37% Mars, 24% Pluton, 21% Saturno, and some other places around there.
@SxVaNm345
@SxVaNm345 Год назад
Dude, I'm also from Dsdfpweegejvmlsre (Mars) and I received similar results!
@waynepierce6495
@waynepierce6495 3 года назад
You both are beautiful
@judyguillen7317
@judyguillen7317 4 года назад
Silvia and I share almost similar DNA and we look a little bit alike. LOL
@yourlocalstudent5855
@yourlocalstudent5855 5 лет назад
Awww Silvia😂😂😂 you guys should do it in a few years who knows😂
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
yeah maybe technology will advance haha /Ida
@tsalon5864
@tsalon5864 5 лет назад
The tests are good at a continent level, but are less accurate at a country level within the continent because there has been so much mixing within the continents for generations. MyHeritage has a special problem with this weird Central American category. They should have used indigenous Americans for this category instead of Native/Euro/Afro mixes. Also, if your ancestry has a history of the African slave trade you’ll end up with many African countries.
@madfugu9852
@madfugu9852 5 лет назад
I was not surprised by my test - by My Heritage. I am brazilian and all the names in my family from 1863 on are portuguese, so 74% iberian was expected. My wife, however, she got pretty much everything estern europe could offer and her familly is from a small town in inner Brazil. I really doubt finns and greeks would have ventured there in the past...
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Well they could have met in Europe and then their kids went to Brazil maybe! ^^ /Ida
@Adrian-ju7cm
@Adrian-ju7cm 4 месяца назад
Have you tried Gedmatch?
@latoyayoung6783
@latoyayoung6783 5 лет назад
In my imagination different is not wrong. Ancestry is only looking at the background of your mother's mother's mother line etc. Myheritage looks at each line mat/ paternal and might give an overall percentage.The 2 lines are unrelated. Their migration might be similiar or different due to circumstances. Or maybe 1 test reflects what was happening farther back than the other. -Sierra Leone, Ivory Coast, Ghana, Togo, Benin, Nigeria, Cameroon are not all over Africa; they are in a "small" area. I imagine depending on local issues people might migrate around that area easily to avoid fighting, attain /or avoid becoming a resource smh for example. Say your mother's mother line stayed in 1 of those areas for sometime but your father's father f settled and had to move then his son settled and had to move. Your myheritage percent would look diff from ancestrydna maternal results. - They could have moved from Africa to Spain to find something new or because Spain used some laborers/slaves since Greek Phoenician times. - your mother's mother's m line might have stronger roots in Spain- Your father's father f line might have been settled on the border of Spain and France and mixed with a french person. - maybe your paternal line moved to Scandinivania area for sometime. Let's say your maternal line never settled there. So on Ancestry it would not include that area. Your lines may come to North America crossing over as some did from Russia or from Scandinivanians/ vikings travelling to North America or from Spain trying discover North America. -In our minds we might see Native Americans as unrelated to native central Americans and South Americans but maybe they are people who came over to North America and broke off, settled areas, or kept travelling farther down. My long point is just that your history is not math but a story with situations influencing movement. -
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Very interesting, thank you for commenting! /Silvia
@RWebster325
@RWebster325 4 года назад
Did either of you create a 5 generation family tree and map/compare the results? And Silvia, for you the Ancestry results are a lot more accurate than the My Heritage results. Another reason about the accuracy - IF there is not an actual 'family tree' to compare the results, then accuracy is actually a SWAG which most of the companies admit. So for accuracy insure that you do a family tree for comparison with the DNA results.
@Jay-cy4js
@Jay-cy4js 4 года назад
RWebster325 Ancestry changes a million times and delayed so many regions and adds random new regions you’ve never heard of .
@RWebster325
@RWebster325 4 года назад
@@Jay-cy4js Did you read and comprehend what I wrote? Have you yourself ever done a properly researched family tree? Your reply suggest that you did not and have not. And by the way, I subscribe to and use Ancestry.com and have been a customer of theirs off and on for 20 years.
@user-lz9kz7hu2w
@user-lz9kz7hu2w 5 лет назад
This is cool . Btw you look tanner in this vid, was the other video filtered?
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
The other video was filmed before summer right in front of a window, I got really tan this summer and it still hasn't really faded haha /silvia
@user-lz9kz7hu2w
@user-lz9kz7hu2w 5 лет назад
Daebak Aww I assume you tan easily! Haha so that makes two of us ;p Korea must be hot as heck in the summer , yes?
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yeees super easy! Korea is crazy hot in summer but lately Sweden is too🤯
@liv5953
@liv5953 5 лет назад
I tested my DNA in 23andMe and got: 78% British & Irish 5% French & German 3% Scandinavian 13% North Western But I uploaded my data to MyHeritage and got: 40% Scandinavian 38% English 22% Irish
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
interesting haha what did you expect to get before taking the test? /Ida
@robertmance1744
@robertmance1744 5 лет назад
I seriously don't know what is up with MyHeritage and Scandinavia. I'm from Croatia and we are pretty mixed in general since we were under different empires, mostly Austria-Hungary and Venice, so I did expect that I probably would have some German, maybe Hungarian, Italian but mostly it should be Balkans/South Europe. The results were: 40% North & West Europe (Germany, Benelux countries, France), 28% Central and Eastern Europe - Slavic countries, 16% South Europe, where Croatia is included in the map, then get this...12% Scandinavia and 4% Scotland/Ireland/Wales. Lol!! No way! Scandinavia 12% is just too baffling, not to mention Scotland, ha ha! At any rate, yeah...I must do Ancestry, from what people have been saying they're the most accurate. MyHeritage has this weird obsession with Scandinavia lol!! Note: I really don't have absolutely anything against Scandinavia, don't get me wrong. :)
@user-mf5gz2yw9f
@user-mf5gz2yw9f 5 лет назад
Im ethnicly very mixed russian and ukrainian. I have a roots from West and North Russia, Syberia, North and East Ukraine. And I took test in My Heritage. East European - 46% Baltic - 26% Finnish - 14% Balkan - 8% Central Asian - 4% Greek - 2%
@robertmance1744
@robertmance1744 5 лет назад
@@user-mf5gz2yw9f Hey my Slavic balkan bro! You've got half of my balkan percentage, lol! I asked my family about this and now it kind of makes sense, maybe...I don't know. Anyhow, they said that our last name probably isn't Slavic, they just aren't sure if it is French or German, depending on what it was originally spelled like and they don't know exactly If it was Mantze, Manze, Manzee, or Manche, lol! But on my mother's side the last name is in fact Croatian - Malnar.
@user-mf5gz2yw9f
@user-mf5gz2yw9f 5 лет назад
That actually normal, because Croatia a catholic country and, historically, have a connection with Italy and Germany. What's your full heritage?
@marcinspace
@marcinspace 3 года назад
I did my ancestry and heritage as well and got different results for both.. somewhat similar but different.. huh? Which one do i believe?!!@
@ulrictotenheim7998
@ulrictotenheim7998 5 лет назад
Wow the blondie makes some serious effects when looking thé camera
@rodneyscales195
@rodneyscales195 5 лет назад
Some of these tribes moved around between countries!
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yeah that's why It's even harder to know how reliable these tests are 😅 /Silvia
@SideWalkAstronomyNetherlands
@SideWalkAstronomyNetherlands 3 года назад
My heritage is the best actually..
@NCXitlali
@NCXitlali 5 лет назад
I think I should make a video explaining this. Should I make a video reply?
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
If you want to lol, we would gladly watch it! /silvia
@StephGrobler1
@StephGrobler1 5 лет назад
It's my dream to receive a DNA result like the Scandinavian girl 😂 I love Nordic genes . I'm doing my test soon but I know I am a mix mash of : Danish , German , Dutch , Portuguese , French , Jew So I'm a mix breed 😂
@Bill-1370
@Bill-1370 5 лет назад
My first results were about 30% British/Irish/Scottish, 30% Scandinavian, and 30% Iberian Penn., 5% Cameroon and other misc...….Now with the forth update I am 75% British, 10% German, Still 5% Cameroon, 4% Norway and the rest Misc. Notice how the 30% Iberian Penn has just disappeared. Wonder what it will be in two yrs from now.
@Elif-jg9mk
@Elif-jg9mk 5 лет назад
💗💗💗
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
thanks for watching
@tomaslarrosa6918
@tomaslarrosa6918 3 года назад
Latina🇨🇴💪🏽,both of you are beautiful and awesome,what part of colombia is your family from? Silvia's indigenous south american features looks very wayuu from la guajira or embera from chocó🤩
@michaeltaylor8501
@michaeltaylor8501 9 месяцев назад
Silvia's 2 tests weren't too different, except for the 9% Swedish on the MyHeritage which has a stronger European database than Ancestry (which has the stronger American database). Each company uses different evaluation criteria, snips of DNA, & databases to "guestimate" ethnicity. One used "Cameroon & Congo" while the other used "Nigerian" combined with "West African" - these are quite similar: it's merely a reflection on the differing databases & terms of the 2 different companies (remember that today's national borders didn't always exist & weren't always strictly guarded; so, DNA matches & various peoples won't be strictly confined to our currently set borders). Also, one can get some differing results from the same company when re-tested; &, companies improve & re-evaluate as their databases expand. Note that sometimes very small groups within a database are used to calculate guestimations for various countries/areas: there's more room for error when a group in a database is quite limited in number than when there's many from a group in a database. Unfortunately these companies don't pool their databases & co-opperate on guestimating.
@GeminiMoon1994
@GeminiMoon1994 4 года назад
Why did you correct "British" with "Irish, Scottish, Welsh*"? Sure, the Republic of Ireland isn't British (though it is part of the British Isles), Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales are in fact British. You had it right the first time.
@nathantisdale2013
@nathantisdale2013 5 лет назад
I did mine I'm 56.3% English. 40.1% Irish Scottish and Welsh. 3.6% Nigerian. ( the Nigerian bit was a huge shocker)
@shelbywu445
@shelbywu445 5 лет назад
Nathan Tisdale Why was it a shocker ? My black friend got only 16 percent Irish and she wasn’t shocked.
@jamiew6438
@jamiew6438 5 лет назад
Hi Nathan , did you test with My Heritage ?
@nickns4577
@nickns4577 5 лет назад
@@shelbywu445 If your friend is nearly 20% non-black he is rather of mixed race and not actually black.
@valamerkozlowski7915
@valamerkozlowski7915 2 года назад
The ethnicity breakdown is only as accurate as the DNA companies "reference sampling" from a particular region. The " reference sample" is traced back to maximum of five generations i.e. 125 years back. This obviously is not taking into account migrations which happened before that period (earlier than 125 years ago).
@barbaraobach
@barbaraobach Год назад
My heritage doubles it's Native American, lumps it with Southern European (South Spainn, South Italy, SGreece) and calls it 'Meso American ', which means mixed American,,or Native American' Euro w/Native
@magnoliaplumeria8208
@magnoliaplumeria8208 5 лет назад
My changed as well, before i had some brittish, west European and little Iberian. After the change I got only Swedish and Norwegian 😂
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
I feel you hahaha /Ida
@bellalover200
@bellalover200 5 лет назад
Ida reminds me of my mother when she was younger. I am of mostly Norwegian and distantly Swedish descent to.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Cool! Hahaha maybe we're related 😂 /Ida
@lisaa6099
@lisaa6099 5 лет назад
IDA is beautiful
@shelbywu445
@shelbywu445 5 лет назад
9.2 isn’t a lot. My black friends have at least 16-25 percent white . That’s here in America though . Also, Africans and whites do take the test more often than anyone due to the Slave trade.
@jaimedegonzaga9722
@jaimedegonzaga9722 5 лет назад
So, you blacks....genocided 1/4 of the white population of the USA.... LOL.
@alonewolfhowling
@alonewolfhowling 4 года назад
It is strange that there are marked differences in the results. Probably how they do the test and what technology is applied also causes deviation. I remember finding a very large DNA base, but don't remember the details. Also don't know who accesses the information. Stay cute.
@ljsmooth69
@ljsmooth69 3 года назад
Edortic. That's how you say it for Viking. Nordic. There I think it says it right now
@dasaniwaterb
@dasaniwaterb 5 лет назад
I took 23andme and got 40% British Irish 20% French german 10% Iberien and a bunch of other places with small percentage. But the second I did other tests like gedmatch and genotation I got 40% French /German, 30% West asia/ near eastern 15% Iberian, etc. 23andme, myheritage, and ancestry were completely off for me.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Interesting 🤔 /Ida
@raptagon2303
@raptagon2303 3 года назад
The ethnicity is determined through the father only.
@workoutwarriorzone
@workoutwarriorzone 6 месяцев назад
Why did y'all vanish
@Bolshoytsheburek
@Bolshoytsheburek 5 лет назад
Ida! you look like a valkyrie😍
@cloud-YNrEmailCloud
@cloud-YNrEmailCloud 4 года назад
Creep
@sadgirlporvida92
@sadgirlporvida92 4 года назад
my hearitage breaks down all the ethnicitys that you are ancestry dna DOES NOT DO THAT
@fendibondie2545
@fendibondie2545 2 года назад
I think my heritage is on good for European countries and west Asian countries
@vitocorleone1462
@vitocorleone1462 5 лет назад
Don't worry you'll get comments like that all the time. Don't let them bother you. The comment that said "the girl on the left is hitler's wet dream'" is hilarioous tho, it's just a joke. I love your videos btw
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
yeah hahaha it's fascinating how some people go full stupid when they think they're being anonymous :) thank you! /Ida
@duniacohen409
@duniacohen409 7 месяцев назад
My DNA test results from Ancestry vs Myheritage are almost completely different can anyone explain please I sent my own dna swab Ancestry says 94% North African 2%senegal 2% Arab pensuila 1% Benin and Togo 1% Nigeria My heritage 89% North African 9.3% Iberian ( which southern Europe ) 1.9% Nigerian I am confused even though myheritage makes more sense to me because of the way I look also I am Moroccan do we are super close to Spain
@bluebell3720
@bluebell3720 3 месяца назад
The moores - Europeans called muslims Conquered Iberia now spain / portugal Unclear what ethnic group the moors in that area were Prodiminatly Arab/ N Africa / admixture?
@duniacohen409
@duniacohen409 3 месяца назад
@@bluebell3720interesting analysis thank you for sharing
@stargazer1804
@stargazer1804 5 лет назад
I have Native American DNA but I don’t really hate Spain or the spanish, I still don’t like and absolutely believe that what they did back then was barbaric and horrendous but the spanish of then aren’t the spanish of now, you can’t hold people in contempt like this. Best thing to do is to forgive and not forget, build bridges and share cultures, I don’t wish to see humanity befall unto such barbarism, tribalism etc. I hope for humanity to evolve beyond this and finally everyone to be one and set ahead goals together, that way we can advance and progress faster and beyond.
@vm2602
@vm2602 2 года назад
As a Spanish individual thank you but nobody has to forgive us, Spanish exported the best of us to South America, education, religion, language, etc, South Americans DNA are mixed, our goal wasn't killing Indigenous people, you can compare US white citizens DNA, try to find Indigenous DNA on them. Mexico was quite big plenty of Indigenous people, Texas, California etc... We, the Spanish people are not sorry about anything that the " Black Legend" ( Propaganda) acuse to us. Thank you Star Gazer for your words, it's great you trying to help but I just want to let you know that it is " The Black Spanish History Leyend". About the video, great video ☺
@polly09871
@polly09871 5 лет назад
My 23&Me results are 98.1 European Irish & British 53.7% ( mostly likely match United Kingdom) French and German 22% ( couldn’t calculate) Scandinavian 5.8% ( couldn’t calculate) Italian 0.3% Broadly Northwestern European 13% Broadly Southern European (probably more Italian) 2.5% Broadly Eroupean 0.3% Sub-Saharan African 1.1% Senegambian &Guinean .7% Congolese .2% Broadly North East African .1% Broadly Sub Saharan African .1% East Asian and Native American 0.8% ( they calculated more but it’s not listed ) Native American .5% Indonesian, Thai, Mayanma and Khmer .2%
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
That's really cool! Interesting mix, maybe we're related hahaha ^^ /Ida
@polly09871
@polly09871 5 лет назад
Daebak We probably are hahaha 😆
@pedrothompson7870
@pedrothompson7870 5 лет назад
Ida look like Kate Winslet
@shelbywu445
@shelbywu445 5 лет назад
Pedro Thompson Far from it.
@keyboardwarrior0082
@keyboardwarrior0082 4 года назад
Germanic isn´t the same as German it also could mean Netherlands, Denmark or British.
@CindyMarie4211
@CindyMarie4211 4 года назад
Here’s mine and I’m confused 🤷🏼‍♀️ AncestryDNA 61% England, Wales, NW Europe 33% Ireland & Scotland 6% Germanic Europe MyHeritage 69.3% Irish, Scottish, Welsh 24.2% English 6.5% Scandinavian
@tvtalkwithavi
@tvtalkwithavi 4 года назад
New title alert! : 2 gorgeous women take a DNA test.
@tvtalkwithavi
@tvtalkwithavi 3 года назад
@@Abeuniversal I'm from Haifa stupid. 🤦🏾‍♂️יש לי כיפה בתמונה.
@Biobele
@Biobele 5 лет назад
Yes but they benefited and still benefit from what their ancestors did 100 years ago.
@felipe.fecandido
@felipe.fecandido 4 года назад
MyHeritage is was less specific. Specially for us, south americans. Their database is not update. Go ahead and trust Ancestry, Silvia. 😃
@kameel68
@kameel68 5 лет назад
I tested my DNA with MyHeritage and 23AndMe. Both had quite different results. MyHeritage said 54% Scandinavian, 43% English. 23AndMe said 53% French/German,Dutch, 22,5% English, 9.7% Scandinavian and 14% Broadly Northwestern European.
@flexingingodspeace7774
@flexingingodspeace7774 5 лет назад
Harold Gerrsen so which one do you believe?
@teofilol2666
@teofilol2666 3 года назад
MyHeritage is definitely more accurate
@Paracelsuskey
@Paracelsuskey 5 лет назад
You guys should've done 23andme instead of Ancestry, it's more accurate.
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
We did ancestry cause they're the most accurate for native Americans :) for Europeans however all companies have large sample groups so it doesn't really matter as much which one you choose ^^ your results will turn out more or less the same no matter the company if you're like me, as shown in this video :) /ida
@MelbaToast7117
@MelbaToast7117 4 года назад
We might be related!
@bryanwolfe6975
@bryanwolfe6975 5 лет назад
AncestryDNA.com is the most accurate test👍🏻 so if I were you I would go with ancestry 👌🏻
@DaebakOfficial
@DaebakOfficial 5 лет назад
Yeah I think it "sounds" more accurate 😂 /Ida
@aspieatheist6040
@aspieatheist6040 3 года назад
What you have to understand is that ethnicity composites are only guesses. There's no such thing as a an Asian gene or an African gene. Every last gene out there can be gotten from more than one place in the world. The best way to find out about your ethnicity is to document your biological family's history back to their old countries. That's the only way to know for sure.
Далее
ANCESTRY DNA: OUR SURPRISING RESULTS!
12:46
Просмотров 739 тыс.
Just try to use a cool gadget 😍
00:33
Просмотров 61 млн
Аварийный выход
00:38
Просмотров 752 тыс.
SHOCKED BY OUR DNA RESULTS! | MyHeritage DNA Kit
15:00
Просмотров 395 тыс.
TWINS COMPARE THEIR DNA RESULTS 💞| 23andme
12:10
Просмотров 78 тыс.
SHOCKING DNA TEST
10:45
Просмотров 474 тыс.
CRAZY ADOPTEE DNA RESULTS(& We found her Parents!)
6:35
HOW I BECAME A MODEL IN KOREA | The K-pod ep. 80
12:03
My DNA Results REVEALED! 23andMe || Mayim Bialik
8:54
Prince William: DNA Test Proves Indian Heritage
3:53
Просмотров 494 тыс.
Irish People Take A DNA Test
4:56
Просмотров 2,3 млн