A’Salaamu Alikum You’d agree with me that there has been a great deal of disagreement among the leading scholars on the term abrogation, its extent, the number of abrogated verses and its determination! Imam Jalal-ud-Din Suyuti (ra) has said that the number of abrogated verses are 19 which were later reduced by Hazrat Shah Waliullah Sahib Dehlavi (ra) to only five verses. And a few current scholars consider their number not more than three! It is worth noting that if the verses of the Qur'an were abrogated, would not the Prophet (PBUH) himself have pointed them out? And if he (PBUH) did, then the disagreement among scholars on it (according to Abu Muslim Isfahani) is a proof that “no part of the Qur'an is abrogated and all the verses are obligatory. Assuming that the number of abrogated verses is nineteen (according to Imam Jalal-ud-Din Suyuti) or so, then reducing their number is a great crime which is attributed to Hazrat Shah Waliullah Sahib Dehlavi (ra)! Allah SWT says about the glorious Qur’an, “Don't these people meditate on the Qur'an? Had it been from other than Allah, they would have found in it many differences” [4-82].
Asslam O Alekum video time @24:11 speaker said that understanding of these things for Ulema. My respected speaker Quran has been revealed for Humans and we are fully allowed to understand by itself. Why I should understand Glorious Quran through someone else.
The Quran also said if you don't know anything ask the Ahlul ilim people of knowledge same for understanding... If you want to understand that part you have to ask the scholars u can understand the Quran no doubt it is clear but according this ayah of quran you have to ask ahlul ilim bcuz quran says that... That's y tafaseers are written ....
@abdulwaheed7211 Assalamu Alaikum, It is good to have differences(ikhtilafat)as it is beneficial for the ummah, but creating sects is not right. However, sects will be formed as Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) had already said... But imamas aren't reason behind the sects may be some but not the majority
Kaf Ha Ya Ain Shod (19:1)= Katabna Hiya Yaritsuha Ibadiyas Sholihun.(2:124)+(21:105): God has determined that this earth Will be in herited by our pious servants= Mahdi,as/The Last Heir of the earth.!
Are you trying to say that you understand the verse “Kaf Ha Ya ‘ain Saud”???? Because that is CLEARLY pointed out in the video of being knowledge only Allah has. For someone to say they know what the meanings are would be saying Allah is lying which is MAJOR KUFR and that person would not be a Muslim. I’m not saying this is what you are doing because I don’t really understand what you are saying but just in case, be careful. Is that what you are saying? That you know the meaning/knowledge behind those verse ???
