Are Warsaw's reforms too little, too late? | Conflict Zone

Подписаться 5 млн

Просмотров 17 тыс.

50% 1

Last year Poland bucked the trend in Europe and ousted the far-right Law and Justice Party that had been in power for eight years. But just how divided does the country remain? And how worried is the government that a far-right party emerged in the European elections as the most popular among young people? Our guest this week in Warsaw is the Justice Minister Adam Bodnar. Few countries have watched the war in Ukraine more closely than Poland, which warned time and again that Putin would march beyond his borders - only no one listened.
What warnings does the government have for Europe these days?
00:00 Intro
00:24 Polish Justice Minister on young voters, liberal values & Europe
01:15 Getting back on democratic track
02:30 State of reforms in Poland
03:15 Presidential pardons
05:15 Dismantling Law & Justice entanglements
07:10 Removing judges could cause chaos?
08:25 Judicial independence vs. Legal stability in Poland
09:35 How divided is Poland?
11:25 Support for abortion and same-sex marriage in Poland?
12:55 Polish youth vote for far right?
15:02 Warsaw’s veto of EU migration pact
16:25 Illegal Polish pushbacks of refugees?
19:00 Sabotage and espionage
20:00 GRU infiltration of alleged arson attackers
20:45 Defection of Polish judge to Belarus
21:20 Ukraine’s chances of victory?
21:46 Kremlin’s hybrid war in Poland
24:00 Polish committee committee investigating Russian activities
Subscribe: ru-vid.com...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Poland #Reforms #FarRight

Опубликовано:

26 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 83

@everypitchcounts4875 6 дней назад

Illegal push back? Keep your sovereignty Poland

@1mnyenaphar727 3 дня назад

How foolish it is to assume those who have fled the war as a threat to the country's sovereignty.🙄

@adamski2931 6 дней назад

Embarassing interview. The interviewer is trying to push the narrative in more primitive fashion than the interviewee.

@eldiablomatadore8580 6 дней назад

19:43 Art.264 point 3 ( who helps cross border illegaly risks imprisoment up to 8 years) ... This international group doesnt act with accordance to law. If u want to cross border LEGALY u go through crossings and file documents. Distributing documents through border is clearly criminal.

@Piotrek_J 4 дня назад

They help after the illegal crossing, so it's not criminalized.

@MegaMementoMori 4 дня назад

@@Piotrek_J People crossing illegally can know that on the other side there are people who will aid them, which is often necessary for a successful operation. A driver who helps bank robbers get away with the loot is just as culpable for assistance as anyone else.

@Piotrek_J 4 дня назад

@@MegaMementoMoriOk, so you have to prove that they contacted each other and jointly organized the procedure, which is very unlikely.

@MegaMementoMori 3 дня назад

@@Piotrek_J No. If there is a plague of bank robbers and you wait with your car, hoping to let one of them escape, you still go to jail for helping bank robbers. The same is true for illegal crossings - you may not know who is doing that, but you are willingly helping criminals.

@Piotrek_J 3 дня назад

@@MegaMementoMori In your example, such a person who goes somewhere because he hears about it from TV does not organize these bank robberies. You manipulated a bit. Art.264 pt.3 "Whoever organizes others to cross the border of the Republic of Poland in violation of the provisions of the law, shall be punished by imprisonment from 6 months to 8 years." The regluation is clear, it says "organizes", activists do not organize illegal crossings, they assist in obtaining asylum and medical care after that.

@jboycaceres2871 7 дней назад

What kind of interview is that? The Polish minister is like reporting to his school principal about his assignments.

@emteiks 7 дней назад

a minister, president or whatever politician is just an officer to serve the public, it is not a saint cow to declare his truths like criminal Putin

@totus7891 6 дней назад

The willingness to submit to challenging interviews is a hallmark of healthy democracies. If ever politicians feel comfortable with their interviewer, then we will have what we had with the previous nationalist and communist governments.

@wilg9400 4 дня назад

People can only learn appreciation after suffering, and the grass is always greener on the other side, lastly social class is somehow fixed lack of dynamics

@Itsmrajhful 7 дней назад

nice interview. regardless of the truth its really apparent the interviewer is outright telling him what to say.

@Eureka2003 7 дней назад

This person has been putting words in people's mouths who are considered far right and people in general for a bit now. I don't know them too much, but they seem very aggressive to any right leaning shift.

@samsadeniz 6 дней назад

Poland is very divided

@jajajaja2606 6 дней назад

It's not at all

@Blanka1100 5 дней назад

@@jajajaja2606 It is. Split in two. Western and Eastern Poland are two different planets on so many levels.

@baassiia 5 дней назад

@@Blanka1100you know saying 'nie sra się do własnego gniazda'. Warsaw, Krakow, so two most important cities are on East side and there is reason for that - those are historically lands that Poles originates from. There is no point of spreading things that divides more. Maybe we can talk about how we are one nation?

@VicharB 7 дней назад

Tim - you don't know half of the topics you Hardtalk a.k.a. Conflict Zone a.k.a. Let Me Babble, on, for what?

@jajajaja2606 6 дней назад

Conflict zone? I knew Germany doesn't like Poland, but didn't realize they started to call it a 'conflict zone' in the German tv

@baassiia 5 дней назад

😂

@CieplinskiPawel 4 дня назад

Never heard about Germany disliking Poland. Chancellor Khöl played a significant role in 1989/90 events and sign _border confirmation_ treaty after German Unification. Germany was *huge* advocate of our EU accession. Thanks to Chancellor Merkel's support Donald Tusk was _President of EU,_ later chairman of the biggest party in EU Parliament, Ms. Merkel's a member of. And that's just a few major examples.

@panorzech 6 дней назад

Scores of russian bots in comment section of this particular interview, color me surprised…

@adrianrudak 6 дней назад

Tim Sebastian understands democracy very well. I wish Polish voters will understand independence and freedom because only then we can talk about democracy in Poland.

@CieplinskiPawel 4 дня назад

Yyyyy... we *did voted out* authoritarian government. Again.

@pwamibamawetunga7695 7 дней назад

I really love Mr Sebastian interviews 😍 I hope he never goes on retirement

@edmatos2897 7 дней назад

Gorbachev looking ahh

@civiltrialatty 7 дней назад

yo GERMAN INTEL: u saw IT. I SEE u saw IT.

@vipecrx 7 дней назад

how to talk about europe in poland? Simple, just show them how much they get and the difference with what they pay in instead of going on about how their economy is the best and biggest.

@Mr.Parker95 7 дней назад

Considering the amount of EU funding that bigger european countries waste every year, I would say that the fact that Poland is capable to use that funding is rather commendable. And don’t be jealous of polish economy: maybe you’ll be going there soon to find your next job

@Exxperiment626 7 дней назад

@@Mr.Parker95 It would br easy to find a job in Poland, since half of its population are living in Western Europe these days 😂

@xena2559 6 дней назад

They only get idiotic EU directives of immigration pact and green deal.

@Blanka1100 6 дней назад

@@Exxperiment626 Wrong. Poland 2004 was like that. Poland 2024 is a different planet.

@everypitchcounts4875 6 дней назад

Keep standing up for your self little European Texas

@cenationofjnu 7 дней назад

Poland should not fear russia.. Russia has no plan of attacking the Poland.. However, Poland should not depend on anyone for their defence. They should create a strong army.

@piotrwojdelko1150 7 дней назад

This minister Adam Bodnar was a famous ombudsman who was a last resort for many in previous semi democratic/illiberal system

@butryk22 6 дней назад

They are doing just that

@andriibakhtiozin4477 6 дней назад

In 2022 Russia claimed that they have no plans to attack Ukraine either, but here we are.if ur neighbor is Russia u have to be always prepared

@cenationofjnu 6 дней назад

@@andriibakhtiozin4477 russia wouldn't attack Poland because Poland is a member of nato. Russia wants Ukraine because Ukraine could be another nato member and by conquering Ukraine , there would be one less nato member at their border. Besides, Russia wants to create a buffer zone between nato and Moscow.. It's unfortunate that Ukraine is in the middle.

@Blanka1100 5 дней назад

@@cenationofjnu Nato is an excuse, not a reason. Putin wants Ukraine and if Ukraine had been in Nato, Putin would have never started this war. He can invade non Nato Ukraine only. He invaded because he could and wanted to. Putin did not care about Finland which has the biggest land border with Russia. He wants Ukraine. It is about his legacy. Nato is an excuse. Ukraine had no chance to join anyway.

@Aga-um5te 4 дня назад

I'm Polish, what Adam Bodnar says is nonsense, he is in the Civic Coalition party and in order to regain government in Poland, they went so far as to say in Europe that there is no democracy in Poland. there was and is democracy in Poland. please understand that the bipartisan coalition party was not allowed to govern for 8 years because people did not want to elect them, they did not vote for them because they did a lot of bad things in Poland, e.g. they closed mines and industries, people had to leave Poland for a living, the poverty zone was larger. Since law and justice began to govern poverty, there was less work in Poland, so people voted for law and justice. Please take my word for it, Poland was and is a democracy. The citizens' coalition is saying this specifically to put Europe at odds with Poland. If they don't govern, no one should govern, and they exert influence by spreading nonsense. I used to travel a lot around the world, my English is not that good. I wanted to make the rest aware that what Bondar is saying is nonsense, he just wants to gain money and let the citizens' coalition rule again, and if they don't rule, they say there is no democracy and they have been using emotional blackmail for many years.

@Blanka1100 4 дня назад

keep crying.

@1mnyenaphar727 3 дня назад

The fact that Poland is not a democracy does not need to be endorsed by the Civic Coalition or others. The Liberal Democracy Index (LDI) shows this well in the last ten years.

@eac.6808 6 дней назад

how to say sth without saying anything? Listen to Bodnar.

@voyd1507 7 дней назад

Better be Far Right then Far Wrong (which your German government is)

@samlatooni 6 дней назад

Yes, and they are also very rich, which you are NOT !😅😅😅😅😅... "Better be wrong and rich than "right", poor and begging for EU charity"!!!!. Don't take our taxes as charity if U think you are so right!

@grizzlybeaver528 6 дней назад

Far Right = Far Wrong

@voyd1507 6 дней назад

@@samlatooni Do not repeat false slogans purposely fed by left media. What Germany does is nothing short of robbing economically all poorer countries of EU. Goal to start hot war is economy. As history tells us, 2 previous attempts of dominating Europe with brutal force didn't end well for Germany. Who needs enemies having Germany for a "friend"?

@karo2090 4 дня назад

@@grizzlybeaver528 you've never learnt logic, have you? 😂

@gwynbleidd1917 3 дня назад

@karo2090 right-wingers shouldn't talk about logic.😂 unless you're very wealthy, right-wing policy are literally harmful to you. You just like the bigotry they entail. Which is why everyone associates right-wingers with bigotry.