When Rihanna came out with her make up line or Beyoncé with her perfume line, I didn’t see all of this craziness aimed at them at the time. People either purchased the products or they didn’t. The same should be done with the haircare lines.
This is true, but i think with Fenty makeup it really was for ALL people, whereas with the hair care lines, it's not giving that same energy even though it's marketed that way.
that's cuz hair is different. Hair takes time to achieve a certain result. Makeup and body smell is instant, so of course there was no issue. IF Rhianna showed up a year from now with different results, bigger fro, fuller hair, bald patches filled in and consistent pattern root to tip, THEN THIS, would be what people would buy the product for. I mean we can also look at it like this, she's making the product accessible to all of us while she's growing her hair out and healthier. ...in real time, so in a year's time people can see, wow! this product works!
There is a lot of mental pathology around hair. This is why hair products ( especially those being sold by celebrities) are such an issue for people. It should be embarrassing or at least a reason to get professional help in those who find value in skewering the celebrities in such personal and vicious ways. There is something more than "I dont care for the products" going on here.
@@Ebizzill But where does it say this is a hair growth product? None of the others stuff that people buy, Olaplex, Kerastase, Pattern, etc claim to grow hair. Hair growth is determined by lots of things, diest, hormones, etc. This line is for grooming and styling. And we need to stop pushing the idea that the only hair worth admiring is long and flowing. We need to drop that stereotype.
It's fair for me to support the females who build the natural hair care movement. Not those who are now lined up to enjoy the benefits. This is how I choose to think about important subjects like this.
I can understand that perspective! I don't think any of those lines are specifically designed for us naturals but I get what you're saying. Thanks for watching!
@preciousfro I wouldn't even bother to try them. They don't care about us, let alone our hair. Thanks for trying them out and providing us with content.
I agree wholeheartedly. To add to that, I just resonate more with individuals who have more first hand experience with their own hair than their personal stylists do.
Exactly! And short hair shouldn’t be viewed as an indication of hair health. Damaged hair is a problem not short hair. Halle Berry wore her hair short for many years and it was beautiful.
Rihanna also had length in the beginning and has worn it at some point during her pregnancies. She's cut her hair, doesn't mean it can't grow or is in poor health. Some women also have postpartum shedding.
Having short hair and selling products shouldn’t be an issue imho. Some of us are so obsessed with length meanwhile hair health is more important. Her hair looks healthy to me and that’s what matters. Personally, I can think of at least 3 women in my circle of friends/family friends who purposely wear their hair short and they are beautiful hair. One wears her type 4 hair in a tapered natural cut with it longer on the top. Another one has a relaxed pixie for like the last 30 years (my mom friend) and it’s so thick and shiny that it looks like a 27 piece quick weave.
Thank you for taking the time to make this video! I was disappointed by some of the bashing that I saw, especially the “billionaire” comments as if we haven’t contributed to every other multi-billion dollar corporation-Walmart, Loreal, Pantene, etc. Instead of celebrating the success of our people, some choose to scrutinize, degrade, bash, bully… it’s so sad. It made me think of Gabby Douglas, Serena, Venus, Simone, and so many others who have been bashed by our own when they have worked incredibly hard to excel and are doing the dang thing-representing us all! They were down right bullied about their hair- they broke all kinds of records and some of our people were more concerned about their edges. 🤦🏾♀️ I know that constructive criticism can be helpful, especially when you are building a business but demanding our own to show their hair and then overly scrutinize it is so crazy because we don't demand anyone else to do anything and we have been making everybody else rich- no questions ever asked. There was a huge price paid by our ancestors so that we can participate in commerce so when one of us wins, it’s a win for all. If we can not be happy for those of us who have attained success and wealth, we can at least be inspired by it-and see what’s possible. I am so thankful that there are billionaires who look like us! I pray that there will be even more billionaires that look like us! I don't think I have ever written a comment this long but it's long overdue. I have been disgusted with how some of us have treated our own for awhile. I have often wondered how we will ever get the respect that we deserve (consistently) if we blatantly disrespect each other. We need to get it together. Just because someone is a “celebrity” or “influencer” doesn’t mean they don’t have feelings. Thanks again for taking the time to speak up! 💕
I absolutely agree that constructive criticism is helpful and warranted. its when it turns into personal insults that i start to cringe. we can def. do better with how we treat one another. thanks for watching!
@@preciousfroIt makes me so very sad when black women tear each other down. These celebrity women are trying to build businesses. We should applaud them not tear them down. 😢
The hate is real!!! We criticize natural hair,weaves, wigs, braids, twists out, dreads, straight hair, EVERYTHING!!! Black women appear to have a lot of NEGATIVE OPINIONS, especially of other black women. Self hatred cannot be far behind. 🙏🏽🙏🏽
In my opinion, i personally think what it all boils down to is that we are the harshest critics of our own people. I'm not suggesting that people buy products blindly simply because its from our community. But ive never seen anyone go this hard for products like Cantu....which has never been BLK Owned. Or like someone else mentioned, Olaplex, Pantene etc. We dont even know what the owners look like but we know most of these brands dont have us as the target audience (with the exception of Cantu). Yet our people will gladly spend their coins on it, While judging our own people.... celebrity or influencer for attempting to trying to fill in the gaps on areas where they are few and far between. I see some reviews of women with 4c hair rave about some or all of the products from both Beyonce and Rihanna's lines. At the same time i see women say neither brand is for 4c hair.... ignoring the fact that nobody's hair will act identical to the next no matter what hair type they have. And both brands are inclusive to ALL hair types. Maybe thats what people are really mad at.
Interesting perspective. As someone who has mixed feelings about both hair lines efficacy on my 4c hair i feel that it’s fair to critique a hair line that promotes that outs for ALL hair types. It’s impossible to me to have two conditioners in each line that will make all people happy. I wish they didn’t try to target everyone like that. But when the criticism starts to become personal attacks on them instead of reviewing the products, that’s when I feel like that’s our own ugliness coming out on full display.
Exactly!! Everyone should be able to own a business and no matter who they are and if they have on a wig or not. No knows who owns Olaplex. We don’t see their hair. So sick of our community and the antics online. These business woman can’t even enjoy their launch, which I am sure was exciting. Tracee Ellis Ross, Beyonce, Taraji, And Rhianna, as the three continuously promoting their brand, seem very passionate about beauty and hair. So for them personally, why not? I so far have supported Taraji, Pattern, and now Fenty: two are in stores and consistently available, and I am a Fenty consumer, so why not. They all work wonderfully if they want to dawn a wig every now and again. We need to zip it.
I mean I'd say the difference between these celebrity hair care products and the common household brand haircare products is that the latter is much more affordable. And even with the brands that are more on the expensive said, it comes with the understanding that it is more professional, it is higher quality (whether this is true or not is a completely different debate) whereas Beyonce's expensive line is doing what any other pharmacy shop brand is doing. Additionally, I don't think this general dislike of celebrities coming out with some sort of product is locked only to black female celebrities. All over, when there's another announcement of a celebrity coming out with a makeup brand or a skincare brand, its not entirely met with positivity. People are tired of being sold to
@@clare769 Cecred is being marketed as a professional brand, hence the patented formulas. It’s not a common household brand. That’s why she partnered up with salons and hair stylists.
Rihanna said her pregnancy caused her hair to fall out. That happens to a lot of women. You can't control hormonal balance/imbalance. I think she would go through it all over again for her kids. She still have hair to grow back but in the meantime she's rocking thick beautiful short hair and weaves and wigs when she wants to. Shampoo and conditioner don't discriminate, people do. Short hair also needs love, products and people to represent them. No one is being forced to use her products which is made not to grow butt length hair to clean and style hair.
I was born n the 60s and there very little black hair care products to choose from like soft sheen, crème of nature, ultra sheen lol, I don’t have a problem with celebrities creating hair products, at least we have choices, because I remember when….🤔
I think it's fair to judge since celebrity hair lines come with a price tag. If I'm going to pay $30 for 1/4 of the product, then there has to be an added value somewhere that doesn't come from having more of the product. However, the LANGUAGE used in the black community regarding hair is very toxic, PERIOD. And, as always, your hair looks great!
This is exactly what I'm saying! People can be skeptical and want more with a higher price tag (beyond quantity) but the way people are vocalising this skepticism is way past wrong.
I think we’re being unfair. Celebrities can creates as many hair care lines & skin care lines as they wish. I wouldn’t buy them because they’re expensive (celebrity price tag). I prefer to use hair care products based on ingredients that my hair loves which tend to be cheaper & natural ❤ Great video 👍🏽
I agree that they up-charge a lot of these products Simply because of the name which is unfortunate, I wonder if they were pierced more affordable what the reception would be like. Thanks for watching as always!❤️
I’m so confused by this statement. A celebrity is more than just a celebrity. They have passions and other things to other than being a singer or an actor. Just like an human being. lol you are allowed to make a business outside of your normal job so why can’t they? It’s hypocritical to me for y’all to keep saying celebrity brands. As of right now, anybody can release products without research but because Rihanna and Beyoncé have the financial means they do have people who are experts helping them. These products took years and I doubt they would release products that would look badly for their brand.
Nothing wrong with playing the field but they shouldn't expect mere peasants to buy their products when it's not financially attainable.. celebrity products are usually overrated anyways @@jjw1920
Excellent points! Thank you. I don't trust celebrity hair care products marketed to us because I cannot be confident they put in the work to develop them vs simply agreeing to put their name on the outside. I am focused on what is on the inside of the bottles and jars. I also try to but Black and support small business when it comes to my hair. I feel I spent years buying products from people who do not look like me and know nothing about my hair. Now, can we talk about your hair? 😍 Can we get a style tutorial for all that greatness on display? 😍 (I could barely concentrate on the video, I was so takes with your hair.)
That makes sense, I don’t expect that Beyoncé or Rihanna were in the lab whipping up formulations lol but I’m equally untrusting of all brands in general even some small owned businesses so I like to try everything at least once lol. Thank you so much for the compliment! That was just a shrunken old twist out!!
I’m so confused by this statement. A celebrity is more than just a celebrity. They have passions and other things to other than being a singer or an actor. Just like an human being. lol you are allowed to make a business outside of your normal job so why can’t they? It’s hypocritical to me for y’all to keep saying celebrity brands. As of right now, anybody can release products without research but because Rihanna and Beyoncé have the financial means they do have people who are experts helping them. These products took years and I doubt they would release products that would look badly for their brand.
100% ...in the end reviews are just giving personal opinions. The consumer should just spend their coins as they want without any judgment..live and let live.❤
I’m GenX and we mostly used Pantene and Amyway shampoos. I’m thrilled to see all of the different hair care lines. As long as the creator and hair Chemists, are doing the right thing and testing the products properly before they are released to market, I’m all for it! 🥳📚🔥🔥🔥🔥
You can’t please Black women🤷🏽♀️ Says me, a Black woman. We tear each other down ALL the time. We complain about not supporting Black owned companies and not having hair care targeted to us. Then Black owned lines come out and we make fun of someone’s hair for not being long enough or make a stupid comment about an entertainer wearing wigs. You can’t win with us. Too much jealousy and too much self-hate. I can’t wait to try both of the hair care lines😊
😮 but her curls are georgus they look so cute. Also a lot of people with long hair have very damaged hair. Her hair looks how I would want mine to. I think people just like to be nasty, they are jealous. THAT IS ALL! Jealousy is so so ugly...
I’m from NYC. There’s black vendors everywhere selling their own lotions, oils, hair care products, accessories, everything. You BEST BELIEVE I’m checking out their skin, hair, nails, etc when I’m considering buying the product. So if Beyoncé and Rhianna have hair care products, I’m checking out their hair too. I wouldn’t have ever purchased Fenty Beauty or Skin if Rhianna’s makeup and skin looked a mess. That face looks stunning everywhere she goes. Therefore I’m a believer, imma cop that. Now as for the hair, imma stick to Pattern Beauty.
It’s bs, you don’t know what the person who makes Ogx, L’Oréal, etc. .. Everything you step in WalMart , you are making that billionaires Walton family richer. The black on black hate is real.
I don't buy expensive hair products in general because they always seems to be missing things I need like silicones and don't work better than cheap or mid-priced ones. I buy what works for me but if celebrities make a line hey good for them.
I like Rihanna, her hair is always pretty. But... the market is already over populated with black hair care products. How many more products do we need? Gabby Union, Beyonce, Rihanna, Taraji P, and Trace Ellis Ross... I think Taraji P Henson has the best line, but it is usually the cheap ones that are the best like Auntie Jackie. The best is the original Miss Jessie's which is still expensive 20 years later👌🏾✌🏾
I don't think we are being unfair with some of the questions being asked about Beyonce and Rihanna hair products. Some questions are extreme but, most are not. Both of these ladies are the face of their products unlike a a corporation that has models for their products. I wasn't that excited for Beyonce products as nothing about her brand speaks hair care and Rihanna wore a 26 piece to sell products. Just no, no's in my opinion. Wishing both ladies the best of luck on their hair care brands.
It’s true that corporations use models for their products, once I transfer that a lot of times those women are also wearing hair extensions I gave up on looking to any corporation or brand as honest unfortunately, I guess that’s capitalism. Thanks for sharing!
I'm too cheap to give anybody my hard earned money. Vo5 shampoo, Crisco shortening Dove conditioner, Extreme wetline. THATS IT. For me its more about technique than product. BTW I ❤ your Channel.
I'm SO happy you made this video, we do need to talk about this... our reactions just felt so unloving to me that last week I just had to make a video along the same line... even tho I'm brand new to this YT thing, it was on my heart. So Bless you for addressing it on your platform 🌟💞
The thing is, (apart from Cantù) all those brands you mentioned that are no longer black owned-they were diy formulations that the creators used on their own hair or their relatives. There may have been tweaks here and there for mass production and long-term preservation purposes, but that’s the reality of what those products are. *The ORIGINAL product lines for SM, Mielle and CD are diy products created by women living and rediscovering natural hair.* I understand your point, I just think it applies more to other brands that have always been white owned, that several naturals have and still use. I.e. Aussie, tresseme, garnier, crème of nature, aunt Jackie’s, ORS, AsIAm (Pakistani owned) proclaim, etc. etc.
I get what you're saying. But oftentimes when those companies were/are purchased by the bigger corporations they end up changing the formulations to ingredients that are more cost effective and easier for them to mass produce. That to me loses the integrity of what the original product was. Also, if you were purchasing those products because you were excited to be supporting a small black owned business you're now no longer doing that. But, everyone has their own motivations/reasons for why they purchase products so I can understand that not mattering to someone.
@@preciousfro They have, which is why I highlighted the original formulas. The reason why I still think they apply in this conversation is because those were the formulas the public had access to at the line’s launch. This is also a discussion that always comes when a celebrity launches a line. So, to me, that’s the fairer comparison. Also you have to consider that several people moved on when those lines were bought out. Some came back (SM) and some didn’t (Mane Choice). It really does depend on how valuable that product is, regardless of the tweaks and ownership. I personally think it more so boils down to which formulation design/motivation you lean towards. Modern or old school? SM and Mielle, despite their ownership is not modern. They might be dipping a toe or two in that direction, but as a company, they are not. Next to none of these celebrity lines are old school. They’re modern on modern on modern.
"Where does the hate come from?" It starts from home. The females in my family were hateful when I was growing up. My aunts, grandmother, sisters, mother, and cousins were sometimes jealous of other women. They would say ugly things to people. I have one female cousin who is younger than me and thank God we have a good relationship. I went through terrible things done to my hair for years by females and it made me fearful of trusting a hairstylist over the years. But I'm grateful for the faithful few who did do my hair right. Adults need to watch what they teach the younger generation about what beauty is. Now that I am an adult, I realize the females in my family had problems and insecurities with themselves. But I am excited to try Rihanna's new hair care line. I'm hoping it will be money well spent.
I have seen reviews of Rihanna's products and after using the the conditioner gel, some say it didn't work for them. For me if I wash and condition I use an oil or grease my roots and use a leave in to properly finish up. So I wonder if others normally do same.
I like your comments about hair length. Unfortunately we have fallen for the banana in the tailpipe and assume that long hair means healthy hair. We need to heal ourselves from these white standards of beauty because we're looking stupid out here.
I feel that we are in fact being unfair because all these Black celebrity women are being asked to be vulnerable in ways we never ask other brands to be just to sell products to a segment of people that may not even buy the products in the end. And it's clear those people won't buy these brands because when have we ever asked the leaders of Olaplex, Shea Moisture, Mielle etc., to show us their scalps or whats underneath their braids? The only problem I do have with Cecred is that this brand should've really been marketed as Tina's brand and not Beyonce's since she's the hairstylist. We know that Beyonce's true passion is the art of music and probably even film making and photography. But, hair? She's never mentioned it and this project feels more as if it was done to appease her mother than as her own passion products and this can be seen by the fact Tina is the one who's now making the rounds for the project while Beyonce is doing what she loves marketing Cowboy Carter. So, that one bit of transparency is where I feel like Cecred fell short.
I could not agree more! We give a lot of slack to these major corporations and yet investigate the celebrities with a magnifying glass. I wonder if it was mainly her moms brand but they did it somewhat together at a mother daughter project? I guess we’ll never really know.
I love you for speaking out on this issue. For the longest Black women have been obsessed with getting their natural hair to look like mixed women’s natural textures. From the hair on their heads to the constant upgrading of weaves and wigs, the silent group think has been to have hair similar to mixed women. The hypocrisy in the responses to Beyonce’s natural textured hair was illuminating… and embarrassing. Rihanna, being the culture watcher she is, decides to work with her short natural hair and again, responses have been enlightening… and embarrassing. I’m confused why these women were shunned when Tracee Ross Ellis was embraced to the nth degree. TRE doesn’t have Bey or Rihanna’s hair texture. TRE’s is a true high type 3 almost type 2. In other words, her hair definitely is goals for those women wanting a mixed woman’s hair texture. Her products have been met with open arms. But BW are now embracing a variety of other brands touting diversity but who have nonblack owners and always have. Many of the formerly black owned companies are now owned by white organizations. Period. 🤷🏻♀️
I couldn't agree with any of this anymore. I have not tried pattern beauty but I am equally surprised by how much people love it based off of tracee's hair type. I just figured that her hair type was so far from my own that her stuff wouldn't work for me. But , i think it has to do with people actually liking tracee as a more relatable person to them than how they perceive beyonce and rihanna to be.
tracee hair isn't close to type 2 at all, and she wore her hair during her prime acting years when no one else was wearing their curly hair, Rihanna wore her damaged hair out for a couple days to promote her products, also Beyonce doesn't have type 4 hair , she has the same hair texture that many mixed woman have
Briefly considered buying melanin hair care and pattern beauty, but honestly these celebrity hair lines have celebrity price tags. I can get 3 products at the cost of the one celebrity product. People have been saying beyonce and riri line was disappointing. I’ve tried Japanese products that women with 4c hair have liked, but I didn’t get the same results. Import costs made them pricey. I can’t fork out that much cash for another let down no matter who is selling it. I already have something that works for less, so to make another mistake like that would be the equivalent of cheating on a good man. I can’t be bothered.
Lastly, I don’t think celebrity brands would get near as much negative attention and push back, were it not for the price point. When products cost more, people naturally expect a ‘wow factor’ and for more than just a handful of people. When it’s not there, it doesn’t seem worth the time to try over more affordable products. I respect the business women in these ladies, but that’s the market they’ve gambled into. Gotta put up or shut up to be frank. Because the $10-15 gems are putting out and out performing. That’s just business.
I agree that both brands are expensive, hair care in general especially products that are targeted towards black women have been drastically increasing over the past few years
@@preciousfro They’re seeing that 1) we’re not automatically broke and 2) even the ones are technically broke are still spending whole car payments on their heads. They can’t erase what they’ve seen 🤷🏽♀️
We talk the talk but we tear down other black women. People need to buy products for the ingredients work with the type of hair you have. You gave a great point when you mentioned how we don’t have a problem making Revlon richer. I have tried several products from celebrities like Taranji P Henton, the Brat, etc. I have been disappointed with all but for Traci Ellis Ross. I am referring specifically to the Pattern hair pick. If you have a lot of hair or a TWA it does wonders!! The truth is celebrities have the money to have a GLAM SQUAD. They don’t do their own hair. I think if Solange had put out the product line it would have been more successful because she wears her natural hair. i
Beyonce has always had long hair it wasn't cecred that got it long i knew from the jump i wasn't gonna buy it, Rihanna's haircare line i think is/should be focused on styling cause her hair is always laid. I think if these ladies had documented them using their products as far as 5 years ago and us being able to see the growth and thickness over the years that would've had so many people sold.
That’s an interesting point, if you have hair as short as Rihanna‘s, do you think it still would’ve benefited her to show a hair growth journey over the years if we don’t see her grow her hair long?
@@preciousfroit’s not a hair growing serum. It’s about healthy hair isn’t it? I think a lot of black women are insecure and typically look for things that make them more white adjacent, will it lay my edges and not leave it curly, will it grow my hair to my buttocks, will it help with bleached hair. The question of will it help my hair be healthy or my curls springy is usually at the bottom of the list. It’s kind of sad. There’s nothing wrong with wanting long blonde hair with layed edges , but the fact that this is the ultimate goal when our hair usually does the opposite. Even when it’s long most 4c hair girls have hair that grows upward not down on backs. All of this is sad. That said, buy these brands if you want. If you don’t want to don’t buy them. Simple as that. It’s your money.
I think it’s about reputation. A lot has been said about both of these ladies regarding their beliefs. Some even believe they dabble in the “craft”. Although that’s a rumor, the lyrics in their songs (especially Beyonce) don’t help. To your point, we don’t know the beliefs of these other companies either. However people are more likely to trust nameless/faceless. Is it always fair, no, but we can’t all expect “success” in everything we do. Shes an entertainer (for some) but when it comes to haircare, people are not obligated to trust and support you! 🤷🏽♀️
Very interesting, I have heard some of the rumors about witchcraft. But I don’t really know what the real truth is, nor do I really go down those rabbit holes because it would be difficult for me to ever really find out what is real. I do think that if she and all the other celebrities are into some weird stuff, then all of the other nameless faceless brands are into that weird stuff right along with them. I think that it’s just something that can be present when we start looking at the Rich and famous in general.
That’s definitely my issue with “sacred” and listing the hair regimen as “rituals” is weird. And I almost threw away my Fenty products after seeing Rihanna do that demonic photo shoot. I’m not supporting either one. I don’t listen to secular music or follow celebrities. I pray that they give their life to Christ, first and foremost.🙏🏾 We may not know who the major brand ceo’s worship but ignorance is bliss. I’ll stick to what I’ve been buying🤷🏽♀️
With all of this said though, my friends said they buy my products because they see my hair… so I think where your consumers know you, the legitimacy of what you’re telling them lies in what they see with your own hair
What an interesting take! I loved the commentary. I will say that I didn’t understand the Beyoncé hate since she’s always showed her natural hair to some extent… but Rihanna clearly doesn’t take care of her hair and is selling a hair care line
@@preciousfroit’s fried and damaged. I think maybe she just did a big a chop or something to promote the line… I would say someone like Tracy Ellis Ross didn’t receive “hate” on her hair care line because she’s been a long time natural and it makes sense for her. I think most naturals have spent hours on their hair and grow a connection to it and a sense of pride to it, so it’s a bit disingenuous of Rihanna to promote a hair care line. Maybe if her campaign was about starting a natural hair journey that would have felt genuine. Just my opinion
I think there’s a bit of unfair hate and ridiculousness. I’m a person who has always been identified by my long hair, but at points, like now, I’ve opted to cut and color it, people do that. More to the point, some black women with long aren’t so precious about their hair that they won’t cut it. There’s so much heat styling in entertainment without regard for health, that I get people protecting their hair with a wig. I experienced it once and I couldn’t imagine having any hair left if I had the same person doing my hair for a year. That considered, celebrities selling stuff endorse the thing and without being tried and tested, it’s their celebrity that co-signs the legitimacy of their product so it’s understandable that people would like them to be using their products.
Free market, buy the best product in one’s budget. Another concern of mine is what are the ingredients? I don’t want to use a product that has items that can possibly cause harm later.
The brand value of established brands lies in the capital investment in research and development. The value of celebrity products is the celebrity who, it is worth noting, NEVER disclose the time and capital investment into research and development. Celebrity products are mostly money grabs, imo. Its Redkin for me, whose r and d has been established for decades.
That's interesting, I personally don't really ever dive deep on how much time or money was invested into making products so I wouldn't have anything to compare that to
Suave is my price point, I'm blessed that I can use OTC products as an African-American Woman. I have naturally curly so its easy for me to switch up like that when needed.
Great points made. It has always been unfair the criticism towards celeb BW entering the haircare space. It’s just now that’s it’s Rihanna people want to act brand new and be reflective. It was all giggles when Beyonce , Gabrielle Union, Taraji, Tia were getting dragged for launching brands and their hair. BW was leading the charge on tiktok with the insults. Now they are upset about criticism towards hair. So everyone needs to keep the same energy for all and not just for one.
Idc who creates the product, I want it to be stellar, especially when I pay top prices. If Bey and Rih price higher that Design Essentials, As I Am, and SheyMoisture, their products should be better and they aren’t. They created two minimalistic, generic lines that can be used across all hair types to maximize profit. I also don’t want more established brands to get any ideas, like if they’ll pay for $60 for Cecred and it works so-so, we can raise our prices, too!
That's a good point about the companies copying each other and raising prices. I think inflation and overall economy changes is influencing this as well
Sis I agree with you. We can be our worst enemy. I usually make my own DIY products and I have my own business Zundrasluxury selling organic natural products.
I don’t mind buying hair products from a celebrity. I use kaleidoscope it’s very good for my hair. My hair has responded well with it as well. I’ve been using it for a whole year. The BRAT and her wife made Kaleidoscope. The prices are very reasonable as well. Beyoncé and Rihanna have very unreasonable prices. I know they’re trying to keep a millionaire, billionaire status, but regular people cannot afford their products. So I know a lot of celebrities right now is going through a money phase. Money is not “moneying” like it used to. So yes, they gonna do what sales the best thing going right now: make up, skin products and natural products.
Some women get triggered when people show their natural left whether that is very short hair or long hair. When it's natural, there's a problem with it. Now, I dont think I will buy those products cause we already have so many companies who cared about making good products when we didn't have any. It was surprising to me when Beyonce came out with hair products cause I could honestly picture her more with a perfume and stuff.. she was never involved in the natural hair community. HOWEVER, Beyonce's hair is obviously hers.. her mom is a hairstylist and she takes good care of her hair. I thinks us curly ladies should focus on the women who REALLY CARE about making CLEAN, NATURAL hair products.. such as the Kinky curly curling custard, Mielle, Shea moisture and the brands that lean towards the natural side. Many people are giving these celebrities too much hype just because they are fans.. like sure, hype their makeup, music, etc...but hair products is something I would not trust from them.
For me, its the fact that their lines don't have anything groundbreaking enough with proper studies to prove their claims like something like k18 or olaplex does. Idc if they're black (and they're obviously not... k18 was clearly not made with black people in mind lol) but they actually created groundbreaking products. Fenty beauty and Cecred aren't cheap but also didn't put anything out that is interesting (only thing I'm interested in is the cecred protein treatment) so I think that is why people care more about the people who made it's hair because their hair would be selling the product. YT people felt the same way about that yt influencer who wears wigs but promotes hair gummies. It just makes sense to prove that it works. And since these are brand new lines with nothing to really back it up (rihannas study is really bad. 30 people for 2 weeks. literally the bare minimum) her hair wouldve been proof or a marketing strategy cause as of right now, it's uninteresting. Also both cecred ans fenty hair are market towards all hair types yet people with straight, wavy, and curly hair (as opposed to coily) don't seem to care as much. they seem very indifferent despite beyonce and fenty wanting hair care lines for ALL only one group didn't have products for them not too long ago so the others don't really give a damn cause they have a plethora of well established brands + new groundbreaking brands (like the aforementioned k18 and olaplex) that cater to them. That's just my opinion though. I don't even live in a country with access to either of those lines and black people are like less than 1 percent of the population.
I think those are all valid points, but I also think that when people see a photo of their hair and jump straight to attacking how it looks, that doesn't have anything to do with them being dissatisfied with the studies or ingredients, that seems to be a mean girl type of mob mentality.
"Are we being fair?"...We? Don't put me in this😂... However, you are right, that most negative comments regarding what us blk women do with our hair comes from most of our own ppl and it needs to stop.
Not sure if we can fairly discuss the negative comments on Beyonce and Rihanna using only a black woman's lens. At their level of popularity the negativity is just part of the package, you know? There's definitely a good number of black women spewing self-hatred, but I'm sure that the sources of jealousy are as diverse as the market that the two haircare lines are targeting. And that's why I'm personally not going to buy either one's hair products: they're not made for me. I'd rather spend my coin on black women-owner haircare lines made for my hair in mind.
I don’t mind Rihanna having short hair and selling product. I don’t like the weird occultic vibes of Beyoncé’s product because it is against my religion but I’m cool with trying celeb products if I feel they relate to me but I am so supportive of the natural hair gurus who were the originals like Melanin by Whitney and Green Channel
Concuerdo al 100%, soy afro-latina y me gustaría probar los productos para el cabello de Bey y RiRi, pero la cantidad de comentarios negativos sobre sus marcas es abrumador y de gente que ni siquiera los ha probado. No entiendo porque tanto odio de los afroamericanos con ellas, ¡que importa si usan pelucas o extensiones!, ojalá tuviéramos acceso en America Latina a todos estos productos ❤… gracias por el video.
I find this all very interesting . I feel like we’ve come so far in natural hair products . We’re use to seeing videos of pple using the products on their hair and asking them questions .We’re learning so much now about ingredients and techniques that pple can’t just sell us anything. Times are hard now and with everything going up some pple cannot afford luxury brands. But if the product is good and it will work for that person and they wanna support their favorite celebrities y not . I know for me when I started being natural I didn’t buy black owned. Now that I’ve been natural for a little bit I prefer black owned . And if you ask me if I would buy melanin hair care products or Miche products over cecred and fenty . I’ma choose Miche and melanin 😂 . And it’s no shade to Beyoncé or Rihanna I’m sure their products will work for some pple . And they are very talented women . But ima stick with what works for me .
Thanks for your response! It’s interesting because when I think of Cecred, I definitely think of it as a luxury brand, but Fenty I just think of it as a regular mid priced hair brand, because if you look at the deep conditioner from Fenty versus melanin hair care For example, Rihanna‘s deep conditioner is actually cheaper than melanin hair care unless melanin hair care is also considered a luxury brand these days? All I know is that all hair care products in general seem to have gotten a lot more expensive than when I was a kid. lol But I agree everyone should just use whatever works for them
@@preciousfro yeah I didn’t even think of that . I know Melanin containers r bigger but they’ve also have changed and then it’s a small black business . I’m not sure if I would call Melanin a luxury care brand but the owner is Whitney also known as natural85.But your right hair products in general r more expensive then they use to be even the ones that are more affordable have gone up in prices .
All I know is that the images that Beyonce and Rihanna put out with the straight wigs made it that much harder to go natural *especially among black people.* Buuut I also know the same people criticizing Beyonce and Rihanna right now were the same types back in the mid 00s ridiculing me w/ the Miss Celies, Macy Grays, and a "slave" jibes (none of those comparisons insult me now but as a teenaged girl I couldn't see there was nothing in those examples to be ashamed of). Rihanna and Beyonce did nothing for it so they'll get nothing from it, at least on my part. They let other bw do the dirty work and now want to swoop in. I'm only a little easier on Beyonce because of Lemonade and Blue Ivy a true natural hair icon 😂
lol Blue really is a natural hair icon. I agree they didn't usher in or help to usher in the natural hair movement, but i give them some grace on that b/c despite the fame and money i think at the end of the day they're still just women that struggle with hair insecurities and wanting to look more "Eurocentric".
All the hair products I like and get used to, get sold to yt companies who then adulterate the formulations to spoil afro hair. I'm going to have make my own again.
I'm not buying their products, because I have a lot of products I love from brands that have focused on making products for my hair type by people with my hair your for years. Oyin handmade, Qhemet Biologics. I'm not focused on how their hair looks, my main concern is that a setback from a substandard product could set me back years. I'll happily buy a lipstick, but I have to be more careful with my hair.
@@preciousfro A point I would also add is that there are videos of Beyonce even as kid with super long hair. Anyone saying her hair is fake was just too lazy to do their research.
If SOME Black women spent as much time worrying about and nurturing what's growing INSIDE their heads, as they do what's growing on the outside, their lives may be so much better.
*Peace be unto those who understand science of hair, ingredients, tools, climate, etc and how to use all these in achieving their aim without being in debt and wth flourishing hair, account and peace of mind.* *I'm from a country classified as 3rd world and this isn't the least of my problems. If I add these products and exchange them into my currency, it will be my salaries worth for 2 months or more.* *So, I stick with my staples which are, Kinky Curly Come Clean, Aphogee 2min Reconstructor, Camille Rose Aloe Butter Gel and Wetline Xtreme*
I'd rather give my money to my folk any day over L'oreal or Revlon. Finally, we are capturing meaningful market share. It reminds me of urban wear in the 90s. It was a come-up. Why not. Hopefully, they are employing the folk as well.
I’m it against all celebrity brands but it does seem like a lot of them are doing it and it feels like money grab. For Beyonce it makes sense to me because of her growing up in a hair salon and her mom being a hairstylist with her own salon and having that knowledge. Plus Beyoncé care about legacy. I don’t think she cares about money like that i think it’s really mama Tina’s passion project and they’re collaborating on it. Other brands, 4ubytia, gab unions brand, Taraji, it all feels misplaced. Pattern made since for Tracee Ellis Ross. And it seems like everyone shows their natural hair, minus Beyonce, only when these products are rolling out. So i get the hesitation but not necessarily the disrespect.
I honestly did know people were criticizing their hair . I thought Rihanna looked beautiful and showed different styles. Regarding Beyoncé , I assumed it was because no one really knows her
I was baffled by two things. The “not making a billionaire richer” took me by surprise. The other was the bullying (IMO) of saying I’m not buying because I haven’t seen your hair from some who don’t even know the owners of most products they use, let alone what their hair looks like. At the end of the day, spend your money where you want but there’s no need to bash someone if their product is not for you. With regards to Rih, I will say as the face of her own line, length is not an issue but to me, the hair does not look healthy. I would’ve expected to at least have healthy hair (not long, healthy). But I also get that this is a business.
when people are relying on their likeness and image to sell products of course fans are going to expect that person to. represent what the brands stands for. just like renowed chemist create beauty products, they make sure to list their qualifications (board-certs etc.) to legitimize their products....bey and rich aren't chemist obviously ppl expect to see results as "qualification"
When I saw Rhianna's hair it felt "real" She just had 2 babies back-to-back and had some postpartum shedding. This happens to alot of us so it felt normal and natural. I was very saddened by the personal comments. You can tell she really worked hard on the hair care line and as with all of her products, either people will buy them or opt out. But there is no reason to bring our own people down. I admire her drive, guts, creativity and willingness to try new things.
I support hair care companies owed my US, especially if the product is cost make sense and is effective and most important what’s in it? That’s my focus. YT companies have been pimping and deceiving US forever! Now, we want be judgement. I don’t care how Beyoncé’s hair looks, or Rihanna. I’ m at cost, quantity and quality
We are being fair, because it’s our money. We buy what we want. No one wants to buy over priced Beyounce’ products . I might buy Fenty because the products are priced more appropriately. But I’m not interested in trying anything right now.
I'm mad they're calling her bald headed. So hypocritical. What is wrong with short hair? She probably takes better care of her short hair than I take of mine.
I wouldn’t spend the money just to “try” a celeb product unless its targeting an issue I have. So it’s not about getting the rich -richer for me per say. I do wonder if they do their own hair regularly enough to be an expert in a hair care line. Alicia Keys has a skin care line that is priced reasonable as a dept store or Neutrogena but she had flawless skin even as a teenager.
I can understand not wanting to buy products just to buy them. Personally I enjoy time new products so I’m happy when hear a as new one is out. I thought alicia had talked about battling acne her whole life?
@@preciousfro thanks for asking/responding. I dont recall Alicia mentioning acne but her pics of her younger her skin looks flawless. I looked them up when I heard of her skin care line which doesn't mention or target acne like Proactiv . I know Vanessa Williams and Diddy (forgive me) have/had cystic acne and did promote Proactiv for years and I did buy it because of black people promoting and I had the same issue.
@@jonest1627Alicia Keys was a spokes person for Proactive so she’s had problematic skin in the past. Getting older can help clear up a lot of things. As for whether the celebrity has to be an “expert “ and do their own hair, I would imagine their products are made in the same laboratories as all the other commercially sold products. The cosmetic chemists are the “experts”.
Not me I support real black owned hair care products- Karen body beautiful stay black! My hair only likes organic products anyway so beyonce or rhianna products have enough phaletes and toxic chemicals that would make my hair rough, cause breakage overtime, excessive dryness. I totally agree with it, if you are not tracee Ellis Ross who wears their hair naturally, I’m not buying your product. Black women have been bamboozled by the hair care industry for years . Companies hiring actors who don’t even put relaxers in their own hair yet black women were wearing toxic relaxers that caused fibroids and cancers in our bodies. So black women should be more conscious and not be so ignorant again at the expense of our health.
until she comes out and says that, i don't want to say that, for all i know she could have been keeping her hair short under the wigs/extensions this who time
What you are saying is absolutely correct! We are so critical of one another. Just having natural hair brings criticism from our own. "She's not this, and her hair is not that," It's all so crazy and vindictive. Why can't we just be happy for each other. Also, recognize that Rihanna and Beyonce are business women. In business, you always have to find ways to reinvent yourself to keep money coming in. We need to stop beating each other in the ground! Encourage folks❤
