Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
You could have easily ended the discussion by explaining to him only small heretics groups of sufis who do and not all of them and on top of that majority of Muslims are not sufis nor do majority mainstream Muslims consider sufi sects to be Muslim The prophet pbuh also prophesied alot of other sects will appear and enter hellfire
How do you perceive shari'ah banning and riba states in Muslim lands? When we apply the fundamental believe that we must ajtanibu min attaghut, how do we reconcile that with ppl indulging themselves with state affairs or are agents themselves of the state apparatus committing blatant shirk by staying loyal to post colonial dogma's and systems? They're even members of the VN which has a staff of Musa as logo including the seal of Suleiman as. Signs everywhere of the Day approaching. I'm sure you don't want to be like ahlu Sabbath who where silent.
Does the Salafi Sect consider Ashari people (majority of muslims) and their scholars (Majority of the Scholars) Moshrekeen ? I know for a fact that you will not answer this because you are taught from your Sheiokh to avoid answering ( the modren Khawareg Taqia)
@@hasisahi1784 😂😂😂 Salafies are sunnies This shows that you dont even know what you talking about 😂😂😂😂 Poor Christians when they try to use their brain hahah
So Bob, the non Arabic speaker, who thinks like a Sikh that every religion is true, who has not studied the Qur'an entirely thinks he knows more than 2 billion people on earth just by talking to people?? 😂😂
One of my goals is to be like him, if every Muslim who feels the danger that he and his brothers and sisters are in gains knowledge and work on himself so that he can share it and be like this man, the people of wrong are many and they are working hard and proudly to share the wrong they are upon, so if we the people of right go in clash with them intellectually , thats it gg
The level of his knowledge and logical mental capacity is mashallah. For his age. But once I remember him saying “I liked learning about all aspects of Islam since early age. He was ahead from beginning.
i spotted a very nice thing about brother Muhammad's dawah,he always goes for the EXACT definition of the word,and the exact number.He basically leaves no ground for atheists and other clowns to mock our religion and twist and rearrange their own words after being caught
He said more than billion, why? Because the definition of muslim is the one who submit their will to god…. It didn’t specify God here is Allah, so there are many people who submit their will to other God, by definition can be muslim too but they are doing shirk according to Allah
@@insanityfreedom2953 Seriously ?! We believe in One God, we don't believe there is many Gods, god with small g is different. and by the way in Arabic we don't use the word God/god at all we use instead the words "Ilah" and "Allah"' we say there is no Ilah(God) but Allah. that's the definition of the word "Muslim" in the broad sence which include all the prophets. The specific definition is the one follows and believe in prophet Muhammed PBUH.
This video was very bad. You seem to defend sufi grave worshippers and at the same time make it look as if Islam teaches belief in magic. Magic is the religion of the pagans taught to them by shayateen (jinn devils) to worship them which is shirk. And many sufis are involved in all kinds of polytheistic misguidance.
We believe there's magic, but we know practicing magic 'sihr' is take you out of islam. We pray that Allah will save us from evil, sihr, and any practice of syirk
exactly. We believe in the existance of magic. But believe does note equate to practicing magic, which is haram. Just as Muslim have to believe in angels, the prophets, the books of revelation, etc. That does not mean we worship angels/prophets/holy books. Just as muslim believe Jinns and devils exist, but somehow the non-muslims take it as if muslims worship the devils.
@elgaecp5738 Exactly this is how i wanted ali to respond to bob ..he just told that we muslim believe in magic he should have answered it ,the way you answered here ..even i have heard many muslims who are doing shirk .. there are many muslims in south india who does shirk which i have seen so this is what bob wanted to know like what does islam say about shirk and ali should have clarified him here correctly.
He's not even a Muslim, why does he care? It's like a Muslim telling Catholics they're not true Christians because Protestants say so. I don't understand his angle.
The obsession to disprove something that cannot be disproven; a challenge that will never be met hoping that it might one day. That's why everyone who isn't a Muslim is obsessed with Islam. We need to learn a thing or two from 'em!
Bro don’t be double standard, indeed many muslim actually goes to catholic or protestant and said to them “the other denominations sees you as non Christian” This isn’t rocket science, they and us doing that to show the religion can be fault, because even in the one religion itself they are calling each other kufr, so nobody knows who is right who is wrong!
Bob comes with no evidence, makes ridiculous claims, mentions studies though cannot cite peer reviewed sources, makes up numbers and tries to present his position as rational. Poor Bob.
Truth is evident and simple. Islam teaches strict monotheism, instills the best way of life for an individual, offers the best reorganization of society and state as a whole, and provides answers to existential questions. Religion that calls you to submit to The Almighty, commands you to live a clean life, and tells you to enjoin good and eradicate evil - such religion cannot be false. This is why Islam is the truth.
@@callumward7503 Allah ﷻ says that Islam is the only true religion and He won’t accept any other religion : «Whoever seeks a way other than Islam - it will never be accepted from them, and in the Hereafter they will be among the losers.» (Quran 3:85) «Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is only Islam.» (Quran 3:19)
Masha'Allah Tabarak'Allah Jazzak Allahu Khair for the great work you do for the ummah. You're not only educating non muslims but you are also educating Muslims on their deen.
You knew that it will not be a sincere and serious conversation when brother Muhammad asked him about his name and he responded "Traditional cutarfjascation society" Anyways, we reached 151K. Alhamdulillah. May Allah reward brother Muhammad and grant him guidance and knowledge, and reward each brother and sister who's doing his/her best to spread this content. Let's keep up the good work ❤☝
Believers should not take disbelievers as guardians instead of the believers-and whoever does so will have nothing to hope for from Allah-unless it is a precaution against their tyranny. And Allah warns you about Himself. And to Allah is the final return. Surah Ali 'Imran 3 : 28
Thank you brother because you are not giving those ignorant people a chance to waste your time and our time. And this is very important to show respect to your sincere viewers. Again thank you brother.
these people come in many different forms - perennialism, atheism, 'ex-muslims', tikka masala, basmati rice, etc. they come with tricks and games up their sleeves but these brothers doing da'wah are always smashing them at their own games. mr.Basmasti Bob here failed miserably to set up brother Muhammad against muslims of different opinions. they are always trying to cause a discord amongst us. CLASS!
BarakAllah fiq brother Muhammad. You saw his game a mile off and showed the wisdom and discretion necessary. He wanted you to make blanket takfir on Muslim communities but you saw right through that.
that is the furthest from the truth my dear sister. I have made hijrah to Indonesia. I teach islam and english to the children here in a madrassa. I recently askt them. what is worse. drinking alcohol, zina or shirk. 50% said alcohol and 50% said zina. non of the children knew what shirk was. ages between 7 and 14. they have many here who are hafiz of the quran, but when i ask them what this or that verse spoke of, they dop not know. they only learn the Quran by rezitation and not by meaning of the words. This is also true in many other places. I do agree that IT SHOULD be basic knowledge in our religion and be taught in every school in all levels. BUT it is not. The reason it is not is simple ! because if all people know what shirk really is, then there would be no people voting inb the man made Shirk elections of those who make laws other than the shariah of Allah !. just like Surah AL-Maidah 5:44 where Allah says: So do not fear the people; fear Me! Nor trade my revelations for a fleeting gain. And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed those are ˹truly˺ the disbelievers. So even though this person in the video spome of things he did not understand, we cannot say he is wrong. I dont have the full number, but ask yourself, how many people are there who claim Islam and in the same time vote for other than Allah. We know that Allah says "I forgive all sins ACCEPT Kufr and Shirk" and voting in democracy is clear shirk. as domocracy means by defenition "by the people for the people" Not By Allah for the people. So democracy is actually the opposite of Islam !. So how many commit shirk when there is an election . Unless they are new in the religion or make taubah with full sincerety, all those left islam by this action. So instead of hiding from the truth and talking about this deply sadening truth and reality, the question gets blown away as a joke. And this is also a part of Tawheed, to know and understand what the meaning of the shahadah really is. what it means to say I bear witness that there is no god but Allah....it is not just words, as a muslim must accompany his words by his action and toungh and heart. not just speaking these words and then do the opposite by voting for the opposite of islam...democracy.
Because the word muslim by definition is the one who submit their will to God, they can be Christian too so they worshipped tomb of saint whatever so they indeed doing shirk according to Allah
@@insanityfreedom2953 Shirk is basically to associate anyone , anything beside or equal to Allah in Islamic terms ! Christians basically have 3 versions of god Jesus Christ , Father and the Holy spirit , Islam doesn't have 3 versions of God Islam only has one and one alone Allah ! No son , No father , No spirit ! What christians do is shirk under Islamic terms and If a muslim does shirk starts to associate deities with Allah he is no muslim any more he is out of Islam because the main and only thing that makes you a muslim or allows yo to enter Islam and becoming a muslim is accepting oneness of Allah Almighty then accepting the prophet hood of Muhammad PBUH if you are not accepting oneness of Allah then you are doing shirk and neither you are a muslim nor should be called a muslim ! If there are people who are going to these saint tombs praying in front of the dead guys or saints for themselves or associating them or expecting tomb saint can grant you some wish of course they are doing shirk but I wanna remind you that not majiority of muslims go to tombs ! Even if some or minority muslims go to tombs we surely dont know either they went to ask dead saint for something , wish or we can assume they went and prayed for forgiveness of the dead guy or saint that is permissible ! You can pray for a departed soul !
@@insanityfreedom2953If they dont associate partners and obey/worship only and only Allah they are Muslim. This is the first commandment, to not worship anyone or anything accept Allah
ASLM ....Alhamdulillah thumma Alhamdulillah...Brother Muhammad...may Allah SWT protect you and grant you goodness in this world and hereafter Aameen...
Allahumabarek Lak So knowledgeable and witty mashallah, may Allah keep you steadfast and continue using you to further the deen Allah yi Khalik la ahlak wu ye7mik
He's clearly ignorant of Tasawwuf. Yes, some Sufis do goofy stuff, especially ones from Pakistan and India, but they are a vocal minority. The majority of Sufis adhere to the Shari'ah, and, at worst, may follow certain bid'a/innovations but still remain in the fold of Islam.
@@haydertahir8556 Salah addin being ashari means asharism is true? Asharis were non existent till the 4th century of islam, and their aqeedah (quran being created, Allah is nowhere, Allah is not above his throne, Allah does not speak) is kufr by consensus.
Well I can speak for subcontinent and which holds around 500 million Muslims I can safely assure that people who do similar things/ or who dont do but thing that it's not shirk are around 400 million to say the least and i repeat this is the least. And i have heard same about chechnya and turkey too. Only saudi etc is saved
@@Wedowhatwedo123| very careful in your statement, if you understood the severity of mass accusation of Muslims, it is amongst the more st gravest acts against a fellow Muslim. For you to identify a person’s beliefs you would need to ask them in order to make a claim of shirk about them, if the religion is safe only in Saudi then Shia a permitted to make Hajj and Umrah, if they are according to your principle kuffaar then they are not permitted?
Wow… Bob - The assumption making snake made a complete tool out of himself. He was clearly a troll who kept smirking throughout the conversation. Guy needs his meds. Glad Muhammed Ali demolished his ludicrous claims and didn’t let him continue with his nonsense.
Remember to keep our brothers in Dawah in your prayers my siblings. May Allah give us the strength and intellect to combat such accusations. تقبل الله صالح أعمالكم.
I love brother Ali for the sake of Allah. Bro Ali is Straight forward, clear and concise in his explanation. Trolls like Bob are surving us and motivate us to learn more and more. They can only humiliate and expose themselves. May Allah bless you.
Bob, my humble advice to you is : make your priority, First of all is focusing in your salvation in front God Almighty in hereafter life - being a Muslim the only true religion in the earth - and then read and slowly slowly comprehend Quran and authentic hadist - implementing them in your daily life as much as you can - by doing that, you'll find the clear answers for your questions - rather than searching un-important subject like that. Hope you'll find the truth and happiness
@@hasisahi1784 What are you talking about? Are you saying Bukhari wrote hadiths or what? Go and do your research before talking this nonsense. If the prophet described camel urine and camel milk as medicine for Ascites for these people, and the medicine works to remedy Ascites, who are you to talk about that? People in the past and today extract medicine from a lot of things. If you don't know what you are talking about, then mind your own business.
May Allah swt continue to grant you the wisdom and foresight to suss out these mischief makers, who are often enough fellow Muslims, who wish to debunk and embarrass the Truthful who only wish to spread dawah inshaAllah
Masha'allah only people who are involved in Dawah and has dealt with their good share of people will appreciate the smart approach of brother Mohammad dealing with this guys tactics, Masha'allah
Its a fair question he had. Shame he came with such an accusatiey mindset, especially with reading things from someone feeding him information and not accepting the answers he received
Here around me many people using flowers and burning incese during voluntarily congressional prayer Visiting graves of islamic figures to ask them to pray to Allah so they can have better yields Learning what they call as islamic ilm of being able to immune to weapon attacks and many more Using talisman in a form such as rings or paper with arabic writings that they perceive as quranic verses in their bodies or being put on top of their door or buried somewhere in the vicinity. Make offerings so their works would be easier and free from any disruption. Bathing in a certain river at a certain time and chanting certain verses. Please don't ask me for details like names, addresses, evidences like confiscated talismans, ritual videos, photos of perpetrators. It's here and it's real. These people said to me that those are islamic teaching and I don't buy them. Maybe he was addressing the same issue.
My brother, I think you have the highest Ratio from VIEWS to LIKES. Alhamdullah. As this time, you have 6.7K views and 1k Likes, which is very high, meaning people are enjoying your videos and they must be learning, or being entertained by your knowledge, mashallah!
Subhan Allah that was hilarious especially that last part how Bob just started laughing because he knows he got caught 😂. May Allah guide him and us. May Allah bless your efforts and your family M.A. and reward you on behalf of the Ummah.
I’m senegalese and there’s a large amount of sufis here (a majority I would say) and I swear they are almost all doing shirk, they pray to their Cheikh’s tomb, they even put him before Allah. They can literally say to you that he is better than Allah 🤦🏾♂️
@tencent9 « Senegalese Muslims are almost all members of a Sufi brotherhood, who are four in number in Senegal. The two main ones are the Tijaniyya (60% of Senegalese according to the 2002 census) and the Mourid brotherhood (28%) »
No I like the lantern guy normally but on this occasion Bob had a good point but Ali was being super defensive! IT’s correct that you are not allowed to go to graves and tombs to pray etc! Why did Ali not address this? 🤷♀️
In case you still don't get it, Bob's goal is not asking what is right or what is wrong, rather he want to drive a wedge between the muslims ummah. He says he is christian, not interested in becoming muslim, but then pretend to be deeply concerned about detailed muslim practice. If he is indeed sincere then brother M. A will answer it differently. The Muslim Lantern saw his aim from miles away and thus shows us how to deal with insincere person.
He’s trying mocking the wrong person, shame he think this world and Islam is a game, he will regret everything later when he keep like this As always great job dealing with people like this brother, may Allah blessed you
Morocco, among many other Muslim countries, is drowned in all kinds of practices and beliefs which are totally opposed to the teachings of Islam and which clearly fall into the major Shirk which makes a person a disbeliever. The unfortunate thing in this is that very few Muslims denounce these acts of Shirks which have now become accepted customs in the everyday life of Moroccans. They go there to ask the saints for different things; the sick seek relief or healing, women a good husband, professional or educational success, offspring or anything else. They ask these things from the dead rather than asking Allah the Living, the One who does not die! The Gnawas also practice Koufr ceremonies in which they enter into a trance and evoke the Jinns. They sacrifice animals for the Jinns and seek their help to cure an illness or to make a man marry a woman etc. They mix this with drum beats and music and colored clothing specific to each Jinn.
This dude really talked out of his own shenanigans with zero evidences to his claims. While there are indeed very very very few muslims that do actions that can be considered shirk (generally the ones involve in weird mysticism), it is outrageous to say "billions of billions of people" committed shirk. You don't need to be an expert to say that's a lot of bollocks.
This is how you treat any person who claims nonsense in order to cause mayhem and inserts doubts, complete shut down and hold them accountable. You can't BS your way in this religion.
but why not actually answer his question? that those who worship graves as a general statement is an act of shirk and kufr. however, that you cannot make takfir of someone as an individual or blanket statement a whole people until the truth (proof's and evidences) have been made clear to them. so generally speaking that act is an act of disbelief, but perhaps they have been misguided and do not know that what the are doing is wrong. rather then pretending to not know what or which sufi's do these acts. which is well known that there are sufi's that do. Akhi, this was something that i think was abit like hiding from the question, you know full well exactly what he was talking about. these sorts of things you can find on youtube, now he was wrong in saying the vast majority of muslims do it, which is incorrect. perhaps he was really a troll, but trolls can be stopped in their tracks when you give them an answer to a question they think they have some sort of upper hand in. as this could have been an opportunity to teach the people watching the video, that may fall into making takfeer of others and take it lightly to do so. Any person can find videos and websites of sufi's deobandis saying and giving fatwas about calling upon the awliya of allah in times of hardship and difficulty or even during times of ease to ask Allah on our behalf to help us. or fatwas issued to men trying to get their wives back by toasting 7 black pepper corns and reciting something over it 1000 times to get her back. subhanAllah. or even those who claim to heal and work with jinn and say they are Ulama. they may be stories, but what does islam say about them, if someone is asking why not answer. i get you are experienced with these people, but i think it is still a valid question. and this video could have been made shorter, or perhaps longer due to the man seeing that he was not speaking to salafis that had a good grasp of salafiyyah Allah knows best. Somone's facial expressions or how they sound and when they smile may not be a tell tale sign that they are insincere. perhaps he just a socially awkward person or has autistic tendencies and to some people it seems like odd behaviour. the conversation with him was cut off quite unfairly. Allahu a'lam perhaps also you had been dealing with trolls all night and its hard to differentiate also, may Allah make it easy for us aameen.
Honestly I couldn’t decide if Bob was just playing games or genuinely ignorant, but then when he said that believing in magic is Shirk I understood that he was definitely at least ignorant if not also playing games and being insincere. Either way, may Allah guide us all.
With all due to respect brother MA just dodging question to not create "fitnah". Brother don't be afraid just tell your position not, pleasing other muslim.
As-salamu alaykum brother amazing the sabr you always have in your videos, it helps me a lot to improve myself. May Allah reward you for all the good you do and the knowledge you share.Jazaak Allahu Khayran
Ah its hurting my neck seeing bob the builder sit like that! Anyway this weirdo used to go to Br Hamzas stream and with these same questions and just imagine how br Hamza smacked him lol
Bob reading from another screen what others are typing for him. Definition of having no clue of what’s he is talking about but just reading others comments 😂
He is not wrong, I'm a Muslim and in my country Muslim people do that, they go to grave of a good person or we call it (Ziarat) and they pray to them to take thier words to God, I thought it was stupid from childhood but I really wanted to hear what islam said about it.
A lot of misguided people. Specially in Asian communities. Lot of influence from Lindoo culture. As Muhammed said, best thing to do is read the Quran and Sunnah. Where you don’t find these practices, leave them, but I bet the brainwashed people won’t.
@@albertohysham4030 well they don't really pray to them rather they do things that resembles praying but it isn't praying , like asking for needs while believing they do dua to Allah and Allah is real helper. I am speaking about continent. And to the replier you are taking 400 million Muslims out of Islam
I think its called tawassul i.e. using intermediary. There is some different of opinion between salafi and ashaari/maturidi on the issues of shirk with regards to certain types of tawassul.
Bob: "There is strong evidence to say that billions of muslims are committing shirk" "where is the evidence?" Bob:"Its strong evidence" "where is it? Give link?" Bob:"Its super duper strong evidence!" Classic debate with atheists lol. Always skipping out the details
