Тёмный

ATHEIST Scientist ASKS Tough QUESTION on God in the Bible-BRILLIANT Response by William Lane Craig 

Naga Seminarian
Подписаться 73 тыс.
Просмотров 5 тыс.
50% 1

#debate #williamlanecraig #atheist
Here’s an engaging section of debate between Atheist Dr. Krauss and William Lane Craig. Do the atheists like Dr. Krauss have any objective moral value judgment to condemn any issues on morality?
About William Lane Craig
William Lane Craig (born August 23, 1949) is an American analytic philosopher, Christian apologist, author, and Wesleyan theologian. He is currently a Professor of Philosophy at Houston Christian University and a Research Professor of Philosophy at Biola University's Talbot School of Theology. Dr. Craig has updated and defended the Kalam cosmological argument for the existence of God. He has also published work where he argues in favor of the historical plausibility of the resurrection of Jesus (wikipedia)
About Dr. Krauss
Lawrence Maxwell Krauss (born May 27, 1954) is a Canadian-American theoretical physicist and cosmologist who taught at Arizona State University (ASU), Yale University, and Case Western Reserve University. He founded ASU's Origins Project in 2008 to investigate fundamental questions about the universe and served as the project's director.
Krauss is an advocate for public understanding of science, public policy based on sound empirical data, scientific skepticism, and science education. An anti-theist, Krauss seeks to reduce the influence of what he regards as superstition and religious dogma in popular culture.[2] Krauss is the author of several bestselling books, including The Physics of Star Trek (1995) and A Universe from Nothing (2012), and chaired the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists Board of Sponsors.

Опубликовано:

 

31 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 186   
@bitofwizdomb7266
@bitofwizdomb7266 22 дня назад
With or without religion , Good people will do good things and evil people will do evil things . But for good people to do evil things it takes religion . Flying planes into building or wiping out nations bc they happen to be in the way of the “promised “ land are of one and the same . Morality is doing the right thing regardless of what you are told . Obedience/religious dogma is doing what you’re told regardless what is right.
@arthurdevrome8925
@arthurdevrome8925 25 дней назад
Amazing how that kind of people don't have a problem with abortion.
@TotalAnalyst2
@TotalAnalyst2 25 дней назад
Because saying killing a fetus is like killing a baby is like saying killing a chicken egg is the same as killing a chicken
@Theo_Skeptomai
@Theo_Skeptomai 25 дней назад
What _kind_ of people?
@arthurdevrome8925
@arthurdevrome8925 25 дней назад
@@Theo_Skeptomai The people with the power.
@Theo_Skeptomai
@Theo_Skeptomai 25 дней назад
@@arthurdevrome8925 "the power"?
@arthurdevrome8925
@arthurdevrome8925 25 дней назад
@@Theo_Skeptomai The power of voodoo
@MarkH-cu9zi
@MarkH-cu9zi 25 дней назад
The argument that 'god has the right to murder...because he's god' is a terrible argument. It's just an assertion, a problematic one. It doesn't really explain the immoral actions of the god of the bible, it's really just thumping the desk and declaring that we have to ignore it when god did bad stuff. Not a brilliant response at all.
@edwardelliott5756
@edwardelliott5756 25 дней назад
Are claiming to be the arbiter of all truth?
@MarkH-cu9zi
@MarkH-cu9zi 25 дней назад
@@edwardelliott5756 What?
@NunYaaBizz
@NunYaaBizz 24 дня назад
@@MarkH-cu9zi shut ur face
@vladtheemailer3223
@vladtheemailer3223 23 дня назад
In a way, it does explain the bible. It all becomes ethical subjectivism.
@MarkH-cu9zi
@MarkH-cu9zi 23 дня назад
@@vladtheemailer3223 Explain.
@cygnusustus
@cygnusustus 22 дня назад
Craig's answer was truly disgusting.
@YizzyRoger
@YizzyRoger 11 дней назад
You must be an atheist
@willievanstraaten1960
@willievanstraaten1960 26 дней назад
William Lane Craig: ‘0:30 didn't explain that explains how this is consistent with an all-loving god” It does not make sense to call a malevolent, malicious, cruel and evil god loving. He never proved love in the OT.
@NRay-bt2kj
@NRay-bt2kj 26 дней назад
What is the just punishment for people who sacrifice their children on a burning altar to a false god? What is justice for a muderous empire that skinned prisoners alive or impaled them on a pole? These things and more are mankind's history. It isn't God who is malevolent, malicious and cruel. It's mankind. God will not let their evil go unpunished, but will judge justly. That is to bring back on their own heads what they have done. God is loving in that he gave his Son to pay the penalty for man, but we must accept His gift. Those who reject will receive justice. It's up to you - mercy or justice?
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
​@@NRay-bt2kjIf God is all knowing then God knew why they became those kinds of people. It's obvious they were following a false religion, one that taught child sacrifice. Could not God have given them a miraculous experience and guide them to change their ways? Wouldn't God know what to do?
@romano3771
@romano3771 25 дней назад
@@JohnCamacho He gave us free will.
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
@@romano3771 God has intervened in many different stories. Did Jesus not appear to Saul? Did God not stop people from continuing to build the tower of babel? There are other stories too.
@NRay-bt2kj
@NRay-bt2kj 25 дней назад
@@JohnCamacho It's true, we have free will and God will not violate that to make us robots. What God does is send messengers, Prophets, preachers, whatever it takes to turn us from evil. He even sent his only Son, Jesus, to demonstrate His love for us and pay for our sins. But if anyone rejects His love and mercy, he will face justice. There's a story in the Old Testament, the Hebrew Bible, of the Assyrian capital city of Nineveh. God sent his prophet Jonah to warn them to turn from their sin. Jonah didn't want to go because the Assyrians were brutal enemies of Jonah's people. God made him go. The people of Nineveh "believed God" and Jesus later said in Matthew 12:41 - "The men of Nineveh will stand up at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and now something greater than Jonah is here." Today something greater than Jonah has come to us, the loving message of Jesus. We must believe his message as the Ninevites believed Jonah. God will not change our hearts unless we want him to.
@BobCalNor
@BobCalNor 25 дней назад
Unless these children somehow embraced the gospel of Jesus before they died, they wouldn't spend eternity in heaven - but hell, This is not the action of a loving god!
@iBishopEsquire
@iBishopEsquire 23 дня назад
It's called the doctrine of Baptismal Ignorance, those children don't go to he'll. Clearly you don't ever look up what Christians themselves say
@Rocketninja200
@Rocketninja200 14 дней назад
You're partially right. After the fall of man everyone went to hell when they died. This was satan undoing God's plan. Then mentioned all the way back in Genesis it mentions the coming of the Messiah to fix this. When Jesus was crucified he went to hell for three days. (See Apostles Creed and Nicen Creed) He saved all those people and took them with him.
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
The idea that God has anything to do with love is a false rhetoric to encourage worship. If God truly loved us, he would communicate with us as that's the only way to grow a relationship with him
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
Maybe he does but you choose to ignore him because deep down inside you don't want him to exist.
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
@@blusheep2 oooh looks like I touched a nerve. Poor liddle booboo
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
@@JohnCamacho You can mock me if you want, but what I said is still true.
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
@@blusheep2 you don't have a clue about me
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
@@JohnCamacho Um... ok. Could that why I said, "maybe?"
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
Do you believe a God exists?
@user-hr8dx9qw4n
@user-hr8dx9qw4n 25 дней назад
This world is far away from being a divine design: Animal suffering and struggle for survive every single day. Of course thats not because of human sin: Animals existed millions of years before humans came up. And then: Some Christians say god takes the animals immediately into heaven when they die after suffering, other Christians say : animals have only “kind of a soul” nothing that can go to heaven. LOL, what a lousy show.
@iBishopEsquire
@iBishopEsquire 23 дня назад
It's called the Problem of Evil and Catholics have a ton of literature on it.
@user-hr8dx9qw4n
@user-hr8dx9qw4n 23 дня назад
@@iBishopEsquire You didnt get it my friend: animals existed long (millions of years) before humans. They also existed long befire humans invented "sin" and "morals". Or in your invented narrative: they existed long before humans even had the chance to make an "original sin". So forget about your tons of catholic literature about it.
@iBishopEsquire
@iBishopEsquire 23 дня назад
@@user-hr8dx9qw4n "This world is far away from being a divine design: Animal suffering and struggle for survive every single day." --- That is indeed the "Problem of Evil" and Catholicism has a lot to say about it. In short creating a world with free will and without evil might be a contradiction in terms, therefore, evil exists in a world created by a benevolent God.
@user-hr8dx9qw4n
@user-hr8dx9qw4n 22 дня назад
@@iBishopEsquire Once again: animals exist since around 3.7 billion years and since that time animal suffer exist. We humans exist since 300 k years. So we cant be the reason for that suffering. Where should the "evil" come from, that causes this suffering? From the devil or demons, lol? Then god is evil as he allowed that to happen, has nothing to do with human free will. I hope I explained myself now.
@iBishopEsquire
@iBishopEsquire 22 дня назад
@@user-hr8dx9qw4n Yeah, you explained yourself. But the "Free Will Defense", which is what I think its called, addresses that. Creating a world without Evil and with Free Will might be contradictory so suffering is a part of the world. It doesn't matter what specific example you use: cancer, struggle for survival, the animal kingdom - the Free Will Defense covers it.
@willievanstraaten1960
@willievanstraaten1960 26 дней назад
William Lane Craig: 1:13: “God has the right to give and take life as he sees fit.” How stupid. God according to Craig has the right to punish his people with cannibalising and eating the flesh of their own children. This is sadistic, sick and monstrous. How the hell can you superstitious people justify these barbaric deeds by your god?
@AwakenTheEarth
@AwakenTheEarth 26 дней назад
Well said!!!
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
How about you read the Bible before you criticize it? This cannibalism is tik tok B.S. The part of the Bible that speaks about mothers eating her children is a description of what was happening in a city at the hands of its own people. Not something God ordered to be done, condoned, or institutionalized. If your picture is you then you are old enough to not make these kinds of blatant mistakes.
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
@@AwakenTheEarth stupidly said.
@AwakenTheEarth
@AwakenTheEarth 25 дней назад
@@blusheep2 - thanks for your valuable time on this earth 😂
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
@@AwakenTheEarth Your welcome. :)
@neildillon837
@neildillon837 16 дней назад
Afraid to post any of Krauss' responses? Oh yeah, that common sense stuff ruins the narrative.
@Obeytheroadrules
@Obeytheroadrules 26 дней назад
WLC , the master of special pleading, word salad, ignorance
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 25 дней назад
How does he special plead?
@Obeytheroadrules
@Obeytheroadrules 25 дней назад
@@blusheep2 If god wanted to eliminate the Caanites , why did he need the Israelites to do it with swords and clubs , god could have just made the caanites disappear if he’s all powerful, remembering this is a god that’s loves us LOL. Craig can’t accept his god is immoral, Craig thinks it’s ok for his god to be a cruel , but still claims god gives good morals, but fails dismally to accept you can’t get good morals from an immoral source.
@vladtheemailer3223
@vladtheemailer3223 23 дня назад
​@@blusheep2The Kalam argument.
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 23 дня назад
@@vladtheemailer3223 Ok. Tell me what special pleading is and tell me when something that appears to special plead doesn't actually special plead. Then tell me how the Kalaam special pleads. I think your about to demonstrate to everyone how little you know about the Kalaam.
@blusheep2
@blusheep2 23 дня назад
@@Obeytheroadrules Where is the special pleading in this? You may not like his reasoning but why is it special pleading? Why does Craig say that both "cruelty" and good morals can coexist?
@jackalsgate1146
@jackalsgate1146 22 дня назад
You - William Lane Craig gave an excellent response. Will Lane Craig - God gave life and he can take it away. Response - Lmfao . . . you mean the same pathetic excuse we've been hearing from chrstns in order to keep the lie of a fictional god in a good light.? Keep the lie alive, for all he is not worth.
@BobOort
@BobOort 19 дней назад
I'm afraid that with all prevailing religious mass psychosis indoctrinated dogma and the insistence to remain ignorant of the obvious non existence of an all mighty God leave alone an all loving God, a world where people will ever live in Peace will never be possible.
@user-mb8xf2dm7w
@user-mb8xf2dm7w 14 дней назад
18,000 different gods and holy idols since the beginning of civilization,what makes this god the right one? Is it because he had a demigod for a son because if having a demigod for a son was the deciding factor well the Greeks and Romans and Egyptians and many others also had one. For example Hercules...if it was a contest of demigods well Hercules was a lot stronger than Jesus....it is time to leave old world superstition behind..it is the twenty first century people..we no longer live in mud huts inventing reasons to explain away thunder and lightning
@SmashinAdams
@SmashinAdams 26 дней назад
The wicked will always your "free-will" until Judgment comes & brings CONSEQUENCES for their actions. Sin brings death. Old sins can be revisited to 3 & 4 generations later. WE are not God. God is Sovereign. Some asinine private interpretation doesn't come near the Lord's Sovereignty. Begin here: John 3:16.❤
@AwakenTheEarth
@AwakenTheEarth 26 дней назад
Begin here...actually LISTEN to the argument and not have your religious blinders on
@rickyanthony
@rickyanthony 25 дней назад
GOD STARTED ALL OF THIS MESS 😂
12 дней назад
The thing Is, if the Christian god does not exists, this Is awful, if he does, then Is not (because life Is his and when he takes it, they go with him, if they chooses or they don't)... I don't get why atheist can't understand this. Christians believe that god exist, they really do, don't you get it? Christians are able to understand atheists, but atheist usually can't understand christians...
@NRay-bt2kj
@NRay-bt2kj 26 дней назад
God has a purpose for the temporal world He created. God sets the time and place in which each of us lives. He chose Israel to be the nation through which the savior of the world would come. Through that Savior, all nations on earth can be reconciled to God. The problem unbelievers have is that they are on the wrong side of what God is accomplishing. So what is their purpose here? Well, you're not going to like it, but: "What if God, although choosing to show his wrath and make his power known, bore with great patience the objects of his wrath-prepared for destruction? What if he did this to make the riches of his glory known to the objects of his mercy, whom he prepared in advance for glory-" No one has to be the object of His wrath. Just believe in Jesus.
@AwakenTheEarth
@AwakenTheEarth 26 дней назад
Either you're right and have all the answers or you're flat out wrong. I feel like religion is sick
@jeffhatfield9220
@jeffhatfield9220 26 дней назад
Rel​@@AwakenTheEarthreligion is Salvation is not. Big difference. The God of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not, lest they come to the glorious light of Jesus Christ. When you search for him with your whole heart he will be found of you. And no one will have to tell you. Then you will want to tell the whole world I HAVE SALVATION.
@AwakenTheEarth
@AwakenTheEarth 26 дней назад
@@jeffhatfield9220 - Even if I had salvation I wouldn't want to tell the world. Maybe this being drilled into your head as a child helped you "find" jesus??
@JohnCamacho
@JohnCamacho 25 дней назад
Or maybe there's no God at all
@jeffhatfield9220
@jeffhatfield9220 25 дней назад
@@AwakenTheEarth I was never taken to church as a child. I was in my forties when Jesus Christ himself spoke to my heart when I was broken and contrite spirit and had no were to turn. Atheist say they don't believe why fight so hard against something you don't believe in. John 12-32 Jesus said if I be lifted from the earth I will draw all men unto me. When he draws you, you will know who is talking to you. Then you have a choice to make you either accept him or reject him. God Bless you all.
@joshd3502
@joshd3502 16 дней назад
Saying Islam and Christianity are the same takes an amazing level of ignorance.
@therick363
@therick363 16 дней назад
Kind of like when someone says atheism is a religion-ignorance.
@mzubuki
@mzubuki 25 дней назад
If you read Daniel 3 and want to go by the story you'll know that three people were thrown into the fire and came out unharmed and without even the smell of Fire but if you also read Daniel 3 you would assume that death doesn't have to hurt so what you call Murder, God might call movement, that you can see two Hilltop God can see over the hilltop. I believe some things are just warning shots I think back to the book of Job he went through such a trial and i think back to the book of Genesis when i read the book of Job because it says we were made in god's image. god is a mind, he has thoughts, and he has a will there's a direction he wants to go and he has emotions. He feels things. So sometimes i just want you to know how bad things can get, but the new testament said that the great lake of fire wasn't meant to come into fruition until after the great white throne judgment. Not that there isn't a bad place that you can get. In the old testament hell as we know it is in no place only in Isaiah 66 does it say until the New Testament speaks and will tell you when and where Lakes of eternal Fire and parasitic carnivourous worms that never die are going to drop in and be in play. Testament when you look at its definition is another word for agreement so by context old Testament must mean old agreement so that there's somethings in the old that does not apply in the new. But if you had never been burned you would not know how bad it felt But faith is a weird thing in a relationship and God is a relational being cuz without faith or hope for things you cannot see mankind will ooze pessimism negativity and endless suspicion always
@timothywilliams4089
@timothywilliams4089 8 дней назад
Legends and fables,.....Craig said it....I don't think that he actually believes this stuff.
@user-ye2em3fn4o
@user-ye2em3fn4o 25 дней назад
Firstly, why is Krauss arguing Biblical Theology with anyone on a debate stage? WLC is stooping below his weight class on this one.
@bitofwizdomb7266
@bitofwizdomb7266 22 дня назад
WLC is delusional go watch his interview with Alex O’Connor . Delusional and dangerous . Morality is doing what is right regardless of what you are told. Obedience/religious dogma (and also political dogma ) is doing what is told regardless of what is right. With or without religion , good people will do good things and bad people will do bad things . But for good people to do evil things , it takes religion.
@user-ye2em3fn4o
@user-ye2em3fn4o 22 дня назад
@@bitofwizdomb7266 please make a claim that includes an example or something concrete.
@bitofwizdomb7266
@bitofwizdomb7266 22 дня назад
@@user-ye2em3fn4o go watch his interview with Alex O’Connor . It’s mind boggling the thing WLC believes in and how he justifies it
@bitofwizdomb7266
@bitofwizdomb7266 22 дня назад
@@user-ye2em3fn4o go watch his interview with Alex O’Connor . Delusional and dangerous . Morality is doing what is right regardless of what you are told. Obedience/religious dogma (and also political dogma ) is doing what is told regardless of what is right. With or without religion , good people will do good things and bad people will do bad things . But for good people to do evil things , it takes religion.
@Egyptian_moslem_1
@Egyptian_moslem_1 13 дней назад
الحمد لله على نعمة الإسلام اللهم لك الحمد والشكر على كل نعمة أنعمت بها علينا Why Trinity are God
@byrgudin1964
@byrgudin1964 14 дней назад
God said I Am that I Am. In agreement I say it is what it is. God ended the lives of all but 8 humans with the flood, mankind had chosen corruption and God is Holy. Don't make excuses for God. FEAR HIM AND LOVE HIM ABOVE ALL if you wish to live. The fear of GOD is the beginning of wisdom.
@JandroD.04
@JandroD.04 25 дней назад
I actually understood Craig, thank you.
@pat6289
@pat6289 25 дней назад
I can hear the idiots laughing !
@shortyshorts3471
@shortyshorts3471 26 дней назад
The Lord gives and the Lord takes it away. He is the potter and we are the clay.
@user-hr8dx9qw4n
@user-hr8dx9qw4n 25 дней назад
Nonsense. This world is far away from being a divine design: Animal suffering and struggle for survive every single day. Of course thats not because of human sin: Animals existed millions of years before humans came up. And then: Some Christians say god takes the animals immediately into heaven when they die after suffering, other Christians say : animals have only “kind of a soul” nothing that can go to heaven. LOL, what a lousy show.
@epicofgilgamesh9964
@epicofgilgamesh9964 25 дней назад
Spoken like a true slave.
@mannyfabin1850
@mannyfabin1850 15 дней назад
All the atheists crying a river over a response by Dr Craig to an entity that they don't believe exists.
@markh1011
@markh1011 14 дней назад
You're missing the problem.... any claims of Yahweh being an omniscient, omnipotent and omnibenevolent being become untenable when he's so immoral.
@mannyfabin1850
@mannyfabin1850 14 дней назад
@markh1011 no you're missing the point. If you're adopting the view that God exists then God has to be the standard of morality for his creation. Not his creation deciding what the standard of morality is for its creator. That's nonsensical. If he doesn't exist then atheists should relax live their lives and stop complaining about a non existent entity.
@markh1011
@markh1011 14 дней назад
@@mannyfabin1850 _"If you're adopting the view that God exists "_ ...and with this you're showing that *you're still missing the point.* Atheists are not adopting that view. 🤦‍♂
@mannyfabin1850
@mannyfabin1850 14 дней назад
@markh1011 so atheists are not adopting the view God exists but are still upset about the morality of a being they don't believe exist...honestly the mental disconnect is next level. You relax and enjoy your life... if this is the mental gymnastics you put yourself through.
@markh1011
@markh1011 14 дней назад
@@mannyfabin1850 _"so atheists are not adopting the view God exists but are still upset about the morality of a being they don't believe exist"_ It's like you can't understand basic concepts. 🤦‍♂🤦‍♂ The point is to show that the theists position is illogical. How is this too complicated for you?
@paulmarcil6221
@paulmarcil6221 23 дня назад
Craig has a bizarre view of the world. He has no morals, he is quite accepting of evil if he determines that it is god's will. And of course, it is god's will when it suits him in order to justify his belief in a god.
@stephensonpawan1158
@stephensonpawan1158 7 дней назад
😂😂 wow soo disgraceful.
@matthewanderson1262
@matthewanderson1262 23 дня назад
They both lost the argument. If the children went straight to "heaven" then is this the best thing that can happen to any child? Something that can not be backed up by the bible
@boltrooktwo
@boltrooktwo 15 дней назад
This is the same atheist that says his study in science shows reality is an illusion, there is nothing consistent in what he says.
@edwardelliott5756
@edwardelliott5756 25 дней назад
The Atheists anger is a tell that he knows down inside that he is guilty before an all powerful, all loving God.
@markh1011
@markh1011 14 дней назад
🤦‍♂
Далее
EPIC Q&A: Atheist Student Begins to Change His Mind!
10:48
Smug Atheist Scientist DESTROYED by William Lane Craig
4:56