Тёмный

Bad History Takes - Al-Andalus: Conquest, Convivencia, Legacy 

New History of Spain
Подписаться 259
Просмотров 127
50% 1

In this Bad History Takes I will respond to some of the most ridiculous and dumb comments about al-Andalus, Muslim Iberia, especially regarding the Muslim conquest, its legacy, and the Christians under Islamic rule.
SUPPORT NEW HISTORY OF SPAIN:
Patreon: / newhistoryspain
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/newhistoryspain
PayPal: paypal.me/lahistoriaespana
Bitcoin donation: bc1q64qs58s5c5kp5amhw5hn7vp9fvtekeq96sf4au
Ethereum donation: 0xE3C423625953eCDAA8e57D34f5Ce027dd1902374
Join the DISCORD: / discord
Or follow the show for updates on Twitter/X: x.com/newhistoryspain
OTHER SERVICES:
My English to Spanish translation service: www.fiverr.com/s/Ke8yP4b
Join my course to learn how to use AI in your academic research and writing: www.udemy.com/course/ai-for-s...
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 Hook
00:30 Christianity is Peace, Islam is Violence
01:03 Influencer Says Granada’s Conquest Expelled Evil
01:54 Erase the Dark Muslim past
03:08 There Was No Native Collaboration in the Muslim Conquest
04:30 Galicians Are Celts, There Were No Muslims in Galicia
06:15 Denial of the Muslim conquest
07:05 Denial of historical knowledge if you weren't there
08:22 The Romans civilized, the Muslims brought nothing
11:53 The Arabs didn't bring much culture because Arabic isn't spoken in Spain
13:02 Muslims Didn’t Allow Catholic Churches and Forced Conversions
14:37 Christians Were Enslaved in al-Andalus
15:11 The Few Christians Left Fled North
16:02 I Prefer to Be Roman Than Moor, Islam Doesn’t Make Women Free
16:52 Arab Imperialist Comments
18:44 Interfaith Marriages in al-Andalus
19:44 The Myth of al-Andalus and the Three Cultures
23:03 Al-Andalus, an Invention of the Separatists
23:29 Outro

Опубликовано:

 

1 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 19   
@AliSyed711
@AliSyed711 Месяц назад
It’s interesting. I literally just found your channel yesterday and was disappointed that you had stopped uploading and then I see the video about the new channel a day later.
@newhistoryspain
@newhistoryspain Месяц назад
Hahaha glad you are here for the comeback, perfect timing
@AliSyed711
@AliSyed711 Месяц назад
I’m your third subscriber on this new channel.
@HamidGulsher
@HamidGulsher Месяц назад
Interesting video. Personally, I see al-Andalus as closer to what a state should look like than modern liberal democracies. The reason is that minorities knew that they were minorities but they were given rights, hence the state was functional. In modern Europe, ideological minorities such as ideological Muslims, ideological Christians and nationalists are told that their beliefs are liberalism when they are not. This results in dysfunctional societies such as in the U.K. the Christians and Jews in al-Andalus knew that they couldn’t publicly oppose the state ideology, yet they were given rights and could practise their religion (apart from the Almuwahid era)
@TariqofAlifaqsh
@TariqofAlifaqsh Месяц назад
I’m your 5th subscriber and my name is Tariq. Will I attempt to take over your podcast?🤔
@newhistoryspain
@newhistoryspain Месяц назад
I hope no hahaa
@Yakaru1
@Yakaru1 Месяц назад
Very interesting and thorough debunking. I guess I should be glad that Spain also has its fair share of lunatic history buffs. (I added a link to this video in the comment section of a blogpost I did debunking Fernadez-Morera's atrocious right wing Catholic attack the history of al-Andalus. Much of his argument sounds like some of your commenters!)
@newhistoryspain
@newhistoryspain Месяц назад
Yeah, sadly I think in every country there are a lot of bad history takes, mostly because of nationalistic narratives.
@ericmoore6769
@ericmoore6769 Месяц назад
Very well done.
@newhistoryspain
@newhistoryspain Месяц назад
Thanks!
@KhalidibnAli-ut5zb
@KhalidibnAli-ut5zb Месяц назад
Good video and you speak English well.
@newhistoryspain
@newhistoryspain Месяц назад
Thanks Khalid
@chiefinstaffgeneralofapost7253
@chiefinstaffgeneralofapost7253 Месяц назад
Eh seems biased. Why are you being so academic as a Spaniard? You should tell our side about how we were enslaved for so many centuries and won our freedom despite huge odds. Why are you sympathising with invader? They’re legit the villain of the story
Далее
Best exercises to lose weight ! 😱
00:19
Просмотров 12 млн
Rise of the Abbasids: Islam's Mightiest Dynasty
23:29
The Abbasids: Islam's Golden Age (All Parts)
47:21
Просмотров 1,4 млн
What happened with the Muslim Majority of Spain?
10:34
I Left Islam for Judaism
1:13:07
Просмотров 54 тыс.