Тёмный

Battle of the Little Bighorn - Custer's Last Stand | History | 

History Radar
Подписаться 20 тыс.
Просмотров 1,3 млн
50% 1

The Battle of the Little Bighorn will go down in history as one of the most famous battles of the American Indian Wars. This is the story.
------------------------------
* Edit: Custer was a Lt. Colonel not Lt. General at the time of the battle.
* Edit: The quote of Custer's final message to Benteen should say big village not valley which is corrected with the onscreen quotation*
------------------------------
Video clips from:
Son of the Morning Star (1991)
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED. All rights belong to their respective owners.
------------------------------
If you enjoyed the video please like and subscribe to the channel.
------------------------------
#usa #america #history #AmericanIndianWars #Custer #CrazyHorse #SittingBull #LittleBighorn

Опубликовано:

 

2 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,9 тыс.   
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
My apologies for the two errors that slipped through editing but here's the correct edits - * Edit: Custer was a Lt. Colonel not Lt. General at the time of the battle. * Edit: The quote of Custer's final message to Benteen should say big village not valley which is corrected with the onscreen quotation. Thanks again
@robertbishop5357
@robertbishop5357 3 года назад
Noted and Custer was not a well respected leader.
@jameslongstreet9259
@jameslongstreet9259 3 года назад
Custer was as you noted a Lt. colonel in the regular US Army during the battle, but as he had been a major general of volunteers during the civil war it was customary to call him general Custer. The book "Crazy Horse and Custer" by Stephen E. Ambrose is a highly recommendable book about the life and death of these two great American warriors :o)
@nealfairbanks5340
@nealfairbanks5340 3 года назад
@@robertbishop5357 he was good at what he did as a part of a larger, being the brash and daring cavalry. Great gor disrupting formation and plans then quickly retiring while more heavily armed and equipped soldiers would take advantage of the confusion and hold the ground taken. Cavalry, even if their just basically mounted infantry like dragoons, generally don't have the numbers and supplies to hold out against a determined and numerous opponent. If cavalry isn't out scouting or in raids and attacks away from their logistical support their really not doing their job, unfortunately the horses quickly tire and ammo runs out after a short while. Standing your ground is not an option.
@paultyson4389
@paultyson4389 3 года назад
Yes, but there obviously was some confusion as to his rank perhaps because of his larger than life public image. I am sure I can remember an article from the time about him and it referred to him as a "general".
@perkinsvalentine
@perkinsvalentine 3 года назад
Custer was great...at self promotion, which he taught to Lilly. He knew how to use the Fox news outlets of the time, and almost made himself President. It sure helped him get pardoned for his screw-ups, except of course by the Sioux/Cheyenne, who sent Custer to the "Happy hunting grounds" where they could whup him again.
@scottlouis1064
@scottlouis1064 Год назад
The site of the last stand is a VERY spooky place. We visited there some years ago, it was mid July and the temperature was right at 100 degrees. Once you got away from the visitor's center and got on the "path" that talked about the battle, I mean it got DEAD quiet. No animals moving, just the wind whooshing through the prairie grass, very eerie.
@yungbackshots
@yungbackshots 6 месяцев назад
This makes me want to go visit it won't even lie
@bone3594
@bone3594 Месяц назад
The spirit of those fallen warriors and soldiers are still there.
@kowalski3769
@kowalski3769 16 дней назад
Yeah, felt the same when I visited there around the same time of year you did. There's definitely some odd vibe there. You see those markers well away from the other ones and you have to wonder what was going thru that man's mind? Out in the middle of nowhere, with a bunch of people hunting you who you know are going to make you suffer in your death. Doesn't matter which side you were on, it had to be terrifying.
@DeclanAethelwulfPryce
@DeclanAethelwulfPryce 13 часов назад
It’s such a huge area. That’s what surprised me. And when you get away from Last Stand Hill and see the white and maroon markers, with how quiet it is can be chilling.
@colwilliamnoydb4134
@colwilliamnoydb4134 Год назад
Another point is that of the weapons they used. Custer's men used single shot Springfield rifles and 45 pistols. The Indian's used Winchester and Henry and Spencer repeating rifles. 14 shot rifles in a .44 caliber more effective than a single shot rifle. They were outgunned from the beginning.
@colwilliamnoydb4134
@colwilliamnoydb4134 2 года назад
As a member of the Sioux, I listened to my great grand father tell me about this. He was just 14, but a warrior.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
If I was alive then as an American, I would have thrown in with the Sioux tribes, their courageous response to the thievery was glorious- even though very short lived...
@Junkman2008
@Junkman2008 2 года назад
@@petersonlafollette3521 Amen.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
@@Junkman2008 Except Sioux would not have us- the Crow and Shoshone were their mortal enemies probably because those tribes were too docile with white invasion.
@Junkman2008
@Junkman2008 2 года назад
@@petersonlafollette3521 And in all honesty, I don't blame them. Nothing good has come from trusting the European settlers.
@TheBatugan77
@TheBatugan77 2 года назад
Custer should have Siouxed.
@formerparatrooper
@formerparatrooper 2 года назад
During a road trip on our Harley Davidson back in 1975, we visited the site of Custer's demise. It was quite eerie as it was in July very close to the 25th. We spoke with several visitors but we did not meet any rangers on the field. I had not studied the campaign much before then but in the years since I have looked into it. This particular history offering is well done.
@thegadflygang5381
@thegadflygang5381 2 года назад
that is great, as I imagine 40 years ago the access was much greater. I too enjoy battlefield walks, very eerie as you mention but I like to pay respect to my heroic ancestors. Usually only Gettysburg and Civil War fields of battle where I say a prayer for all my Johnny Rebs and the poor Union lads conscripted to fight. Going to Gallipoli and seeing the final resting place of the 7th Cavalry is definitely on my bucket list
@bobmarchinetti9808
@bobmarchinetti9808 2 года назад
"Hellbent on furthering his reputation Custer departed from his orders and decided to attack without the aid of the Terry/Gibbon column." That comment omits significant details. On the morning of June 25 Custer ordered the men to camp for the day and attack the following day on June 26, which was the earliest day the Terry/Gibbon column would be in position. But after resting several hours it was discovered that some supplies had fallen from the pack mules and troopers who went back to retrieve them saw Indians carrying off the supplies. Everyone connected with the planning of the campaign (Sherman, Sheridan, Terry) was of the opinion that the Indians would scatter across the plains in countless smaller groups, which would defeat the purpose of the campaign to capture them when they were all together. When Custer was informed that Indians now knew of his proximity to the village he decided he could not wait until the following day to attack, fearing the Indians would use that time to scatter. So even if he was "hellbent on furthering his reputation" he initially gave orders to attack in coordination with Terry/Gibbon and only decided to attack without their participation when he reasoned that waiting another day was no longer practical.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
That was both a ludicrous and historically inept military strategy.
@davidjohnson8793
@davidjohnson8793 2 года назад
This is truth. Custer had discretionary orders. Terry, Sheridan, and Sherman covered this up to place all the blame on Custer. Custer was always supposed to be the striking force and the Terry-Gibbon force was a blocking force. it is the reason for Terry's offer of Brisbane's companies. Besides, Terry was late anyway, not arriving in position until the 27th.
@sirridesalot6652
@sirridesalot6652 3 года назад
Country singer Johnny Cash had a song Custer with this line in it: "Custer split his men. Well he won't do that again". Another line is: "It's not called an Indian victory but a bloody massacree. There might have been more enthusin' if us Indians had been losing".
@MuadDab
@MuadDab 2 года назад
“How the battle unfolded” is actually not a current debate. All of Custer’s men died, but plenty of Natives lived to pass the story on. The “secrecy” stemmed, for a very long time, from an unwillingness to accept Native accounts of the battle.
@TheIblis2u
@TheIblis2u Год назад
That is true. When I was younger, I met Chief Joe Medicine Crow, Joe's grandfather was the famous Custer scout and Crow war chief, Medicine Crow. Custer actually told his Crow Scouts to leave after they stripped down to their own clothing and sang their death songs. It infuriated Custer, and he dismissed them. Curley was the Scout who stayed with Custer. The Crow feared and respected the Lakota, and all were ferocious riders, courageous fighters.
@natecrosman9506
@natecrosman9506 Год назад
The American Gov't has completely ignored the accounts of the first people's. Every thing we were taught about this is a lie. Custer was shot in Medicine Coolie and drug up to "last stand hill." It's been passed orally and is known.
@DSPHistoricalSociety
@DSPHistoricalSociety Год назад
None of the good guys survived
@uncleray3354
@uncleray3354 3 года назад
It was NOT a massacre, it was self defense. Wounded Knee was a massacre
@0johnirving162
@0johnirving162 3 года назад
Very true...it was purely self defense from the white's aggression.
@SH__69
@SH__69 3 года назад
100% correct!!
@TheLAGopher
@TheLAGopher 3 года назад
While the Indians were defending themselves, they didn't take prisoners. It was a massacre.
@SH__69
@SH__69 3 года назад
@@TheLAGopher Thanks for your contribution. Made me think about the battle again and I realise you are partly right. The killing by Reno and his men of children, men and women was indeed a massacre. To bad Reno didn't get what he deserved that day.
@laurencefox5884
@laurencefox5884 3 года назад
@@TheLAGopher Those were the rules of war at that time. No prisoners were ever taken. A massacre however, is when defenceless civilians were murdered without provocation. Wounded Knee.
@154rjr
@154rjr 2 года назад
Custer was a fearless warrior. But he was also reckless and foolhardy. He never should have attacked. His scouts told him how many Indians were there, but his massive ego would not allow him to consider the fact that he could be defeated.
@samcolt1079
@samcolt1079 2 года назад
You got it. He should have thought this out better. He had no chance. Just about the only win for the Indians. By this time there were millions of indians dead. All over America.
@bone3594
@bone3594 Месяц назад
Never underestimate the enemy, Custer did just that; also made many strategic mistakes and the natives capitalize on that.
@cjrudd
@cjrudd 2 месяца назад
Great video! I really appreciate how you edited the scenes from Son of the Morning Star together to make it enjoyable to watch while also representing what was being portrayed on the screen.
@fearlessfosdick160
@fearlessfosdick160 3 года назад
Knowing that the camp was about to start moving, Custer went against his own better judgment and ordered an immediate attack. That is a very perceptive way to put it. It was arguably tragic, but the story of the American Indian was never going to end any other way.
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
That is so true. It is always a sad, tragic story to what happened to the American Indians. They were caught up in our 'Manifest Destiny' with a young, explosive country that wanted everything in its reach - and got it!! I have a small part of the Cherokee group in my background, as do a lot of people from the North Central part of Texas which was a hugh Cherokee tribal area long ago.
@johnzeszut3170
@johnzeszut3170 2 года назад
Yes I have read that Custer was alarmed that the camp might break and than elude detection and capture. It was amazing that Native Americans could seemingly vanish into the country side.
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
I KNEW U DIDNT LOVE ME
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
And this part of that story ended in poetic justice. Plus the U.S. could never live down their defeats from their own typical greed and stupidity.
@bone3594
@bone3594 Месяц назад
The Natives had nothing to lose anymore.
@karlheinzvonkroemann2217
@karlheinzvonkroemann2217 2 года назад
Custer was never a Lieutenant General. He was a Brevet (temporary) Major General in the Civil War and commanded a Cavalry Division under Philip Sheridan. After the war he, like countless other US officers, reverted to their regular army rank of Lieutenant Colonel. That was his post war rank although he was often called General by his men, many of whom had been with him in the Civil War.
@michaelewert8310
@michaelewert8310 Год назад
His post war rank was captain. Only when the 7th was organized was he made second in command as Lt. Colonel.
@stephenburke5967
@stephenburke5967 Год назад
Incorrect.For Custer to revert to his initial army rank he would have reverted to 2nd Lieutenant but Sheridan put in place before wars end the rank of Captain.Custer became Lieutenant Colonel of the newly formed 7th cavalry at Fort Reilly,Kansas.
@michaelewert8310
@michaelewert8310 Год назад
@Stephen Burke June 2nd, 1862 promoted by Gen. McClellan as aid de camp with regular rank of Captain. April 9th, 1865 at wars end assumed his regular rank of Captain before accepting assignment to newly formed 7th at Fort Riley, KS.
@bradleymiles671
@bradleymiles671 6 месяцев назад
No he wasn't a general he was a lieutenant colonel at the Battle of the Little Big Horn
@ronaldherrington2832
@ronaldherrington2832 4 месяца назад
Actually Custer's permanent rank was Captain. After the war he was appointed a Lt Col and given command of the 7th Cavalry Regiment.
@radrook2153
@radrook2153 2 года назад
He refused to take along sabers, Gatling Guns or cannon because he said that they would slow him down.
@Timelord2001
@Timelord2001 2 года назад
Very true...and very foolish on his part.
@BigBri550
@BigBri550 2 года назад
Custer was used to making surprise mounted attacks on unprepared villages whose hapless inhabitants would scatter and run. Custer, Reno, and Benteen weren't anticipating such large scale resistance at Greasy Grass.
@oldhippiejon
@oldhippiejon Год назад
Perhaps the biggest regret was not taking along the extra companies from the other cavalry unit who knows what an extra 100 rifles would have done.
@martinalarcon3108
@martinalarcon3108 Год назад
He could had use Apache helicopters 😮
@Thunderchild-gz4gc
@Thunderchild-gz4gc Год назад
The Black Hills were used by the Sioux for hunting game and the trees were useful for housing and whatnot. They had practical reasons to want to keep them.
@tflynn2400
@tflynn2400 3 года назад
When you make a treaty, stick by it. If you don't value your word, nobody else will either. No amount of gold is worth your integrity.
@Nocturnal808
@Nocturnal808 3 года назад
I bet you’re integrity will be compromised if a gold worth 50 million is offered to you
@tflynn2400
@tflynn2400 3 года назад
@@Nocturnal808 You would lose that bet.
@youngking2503
@youngking2503 3 года назад
@@Nocturnal808 The Sioux still have over 1 billion dollars sitting in a account waiting for them to access it. They haven't touched it
@rogeeeferrari
@rogeeeferrari 3 года назад
What you say is true, but we're talking about the US Government which has never had an ounce of integrity...
@OttoMattak
@OttoMattak 3 года назад
@@youngking2503 And they won't unless the United States relinquishes control of the Black Hills. It's a matter of principle.
@billalumni7760
@billalumni7760 3 года назад
Who else thought Custer was being played by Ben Stiller when he looked like White Goodman in 'Dodgeball'?
@randyripley7356
@randyripley7356 3 года назад
ME ! ... lol ... :'D
@davefnewell
@davefnewell 3 года назад
Me Too! That’s why I almost didn’t watch. I thought it would be some sort of parody.
@bigbillivlogs6589
@bigbillivlogs6589 3 года назад
I was thinking the exact same thing!
@user-wn8rm6rb2i
@user-wn8rm6rb2i 2 года назад
Spot on!!!!
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
WE DIDNT KNOW WHO WHO WAS HE
@loisbell6517
@loisbell6517 3 года назад
My late husband and his horse were part of the 7th cavalry reenactors who were filmed in those scenes near Billings, MT..
@reuterromain1054
@reuterromain1054 3 года назад
Great, the authentic battle-site is very close to Billings. I went there in 1997.
@talicatinai2637
@talicatinai2637 3 года назад
A wonderful commentary spoken clearly and concisely . Thank you so much .
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@killerbee3794
@killerbee3794 3 года назад
Custer died for your sins! Hoka Hey! Hehanni waniyetu opawinge wanje wikcemna zaptan sam zaptan ehantanhan Lakota oyate kin hena Shahiela oyate kin Pehin Hanska akicita sica kilena wichaktepti yelo! He lila wakan yelo! By the way only four Arapaho warirors were present at the Battle of the Little Bighorn and they were kept apart under surveillance for a while because the Lakota thought they were spies. Anyway when the battle started and Custer troops tried to storm the northern end of the village where the Cheyenne camp was located these Arapaho warriors fought alongside the Lakota and their Cheyenne relatives. To this day there is an oral tradition that says that probably the first of two shots that killed General Custer was shot by one of this Arapaho warriors. This video is an excellent researched historical document.
@riazhassan6570
@riazhassan6570 3 года назад
What language was that in the beginning of your comment? Did it have a writing script of its own? Is the pronunciation of words rendered properly in the Latin script?
@ejcheli
@ejcheli 3 года назад
@Don2615 Hahaha! You got me in the first half... XD
@emadbagheri
@emadbagheri 2 года назад
Custer 's hair was not long on this day, in fact both the Indians and the Cavalry had difficulty identifying him because they were looking for the one with the "long hair"
@andygossard4293
@andygossard4293 3 года назад
Gary Cole as Custer. If you Indians could just line up over here, that would be terrrrrrrific. Mkayyy?
@tannerghost5136
@tannerghost5136 3 года назад
History teaches a lot
@JoeyArmstrong2800
@JoeyArmstrong2800 3 года назад
Son of the morning star
@johnzeszut3170
@johnzeszut3170 2 года назад
Thank you - the presentation simplified what sometimes turns into a confusing battle.
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
gOD WELL AT LEAST U CONFESSED
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
COULDNT JUST DRAW STRAWS
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
THEY MUST HAVE ALL LOVED KILLING EACH OR THEY WOULDNT BE ALL DEAD
@billmasters385
@billmasters385 3 года назад
One of the clearest explanations ever for what happened on that fateful day.
@-Isaac-
@-Isaac- 2 года назад
Fateful? That was a Victorious day 😂
@brucewayne3602
@brucewayne3602 2 года назад
@@-Isaac- absolutely !!!
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 Год назад
"General, you go down there...There are thousands of Indians...and when they get done with you, there won't be nothing left but a grease-spot.This ain't the Washita River, General, and them ain't helpless women and children waiting for you. They're Cheyenne braves, and Sioux. You go down there, General, if you've got the nerve." (Little Big Man)
@darrylg7600
@darrylg7600 3 года назад
I walked the battlefield two years ago. It truly is a solemn place. It is also a lot larger than I thought it was.
@ThunderHaus
@ThunderHaus 3 года назад
It also has era photo's on site that look the same now as they did in 1876.
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
THE WHO WERE COMING
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
WHO?
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
RUN WAR SUCKS
@johnadams5489
@johnadams5489 2 года назад
This is the best explanation of the battle of the Little Big Horn. Great Video.
@phili676
@phili676 2 года назад
IV just subscribed.. Loving your content, war history is one of my favourite subjects
@markknivila8383
@markknivila8383 3 года назад
I really liked how you used film clips from "Son Of The Morning Star." Over all, I thought it was a very entertaining video! Thank you!
@aledakivett9255
@aledakivett9255 3 года назад
Mark Thought I saw some from Little Bighorn Man too. One of my favorite movies.
@HB-forensics
@HB-forensics 3 года назад
Definitely read "Son of the Morning Star" by Evan S. Connell. Exquisite writing and well researched.
@HB-forensics
@HB-forensics 3 года назад
@paul Provenzano excellent book!
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
i ALL SAID WAS GOD WE TOLD YOU NOT TO
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
THATS WHERE IT ALLSTARTED AGAIN
@reality-cheque
@reality-cheque 2 года назад
Thanks for the video - excellent graphics showing what happened. We British had a similar experience three years later at Isandlwana when some 1200 troops were all but wiped out by over 15,000 Zulus. Chelmsford made the same mistake as Custer - under-estimating his enemy, not knowing where his enemy were and splitting his command - in hostile territory!
@brucewayne3602
@brucewayne3602 2 года назад
absolutely ... Custer lived with his belief of being infallible the cost of which was disaster !!!
@williamfreeman9356
@williamfreeman9356 6 месяцев назад
Sad so many native Americans had to die In this battle. Troops trying to exterminate the native population were evil in the future I hope they learn the difference.
@johnrogan9420
@johnrogan9420 3 года назад
Custer was a hero at Gettsburg in 1863 when he stopped Jeb Stewart's cavalry attack on day 2 of the battle...a decisive move that allowed the North to prevail!
@eXcommunicate1979
@eXcommunicate1979 3 года назад
The battle would have been super interesting if the Confederate cavalry maneuver had rolled up behind the Federal lines, opening another front for Meade to deal with.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
Your point? Custer should have left that glory there- not paraded it into eternity..
@MrChickennugget360
@MrChickennugget360 2 года назад
@@petersonlafollette3521 point is that most people don't know anything about Custer other than the Battle of the Little Big Horn.
@DSPHistoricalSociety
@DSPHistoricalSociety Год назад
​@@petersonlafollette3521 You sound like a whiny loser.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 Год назад
@@DSPHistoricalSociety Why is that Sunshine- because many here are not a Custer apologist like you? Why do you think the tribes gathered, joined forces and struck like a cornered snake never releasing it's jaws? Read REAL history...
@texhaines9957
@texhaines9957 3 года назад
I lived in this area for 2 years. The Native American "camp" was over 6 miles in length. Interested parties might want to read their version, "Save The Last Bullet for Yourself" More information came after wild fires revealed more relics on the battle field.
@hoffert17
@hoffert17 3 года назад
It was not "6 miles in length" that is such a common misnomer. The village stretched for approximately 3 miles, probably in concentric tribal circles as was customary. The village actually moved further north the afternoon of the 25th and that's why it's size has been greatly overstated. "Save the Last Bullet" is a joke of a citation to use as it's source material is far out there in terms of reality that it should be listed in the fiction section. Lakota Noon by Greg Michno is by and far the best resource for the Lakota and Cheyenne accounts of the battle
@texhaines9957
@texhaines9957 3 года назад
@@hoffert17 thank you for the clarifications. Yes, that is a better reference book.
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
@@hoffert17 Hey, Chris! What are your best estimate of the size of the warriors that were in the camp? I've seen so many different. I've kinda settled on 2,500 to 3,500. Whatever number we come up, it was still too vast a number for a group of exhausted troupers to overcome. When they went into a pitiful defensive position with what they had to fight with, that was the beginning of the end.
@hoffert17
@hoffert17 3 года назад
@@johnjohnson8812 based on Greg Michno’s studies, which are probably the best to date, 1,800-2,000 Warriors. TBH, the “exhausted” troops claim is a bit over stated, usually by people who have never experienced combat. Adrenaline alone is enough to carry a human being forward for several hours regardless of fatigue-firsthand experience on that one. Ultimately it boils down to terrain. The terrain Custer found himself on played to the Native strengths, albeit the Achilles Heel of gullies was not known until too late.
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
@@hoffert17 Interesting, Chris. Still a formidable gathering. The 'exhausted' comes from Indian eye-witness accounts later. Custer drove them hard to be the first to fight - and die!
@stephenyoung2742
@stephenyoung2742 3 года назад
Most of the warriors were asleep in camp due to a late night celebration of the battle of the Rosebud and were a number swore to die in battle and this is the group who made a suicide attack that broke in among Custers men before remanants were forced to last stand hill almost since Crazy Horse showed up behind them. It was thought that braves were off on a buffalo hunt by Custer also.
@rogerross6583
@rogerross6583 3 года назад
This is the best movie portraying Custer’s Last Stand! For once Hollywood comes real close To getting it right.
@wezab
@wezab 3 года назад
What was the movie? Because the clips I saw in the presentation were not so accurate. The Indians had traded for years and they acquired Winchester rifles for hunting. The rounds were heavy and took down game with the advantage of a quick rate of fire. For a light cavalry this was an ideal weapon and much superior to the single shot Springfield rifles used by the 7th. There was a lot of detail left out of the presentation but it was a very good overview.
@rustillthere.5024
@rustillthere.5024 2 года назад
Thank you for video.
@cliffmays442
@cliffmays442 2 года назад
Custer had been demoted and was not a general at the time of the battle. Also Sitting Bull had another part of his vision. He warned Crazyhorse not to mutilate the bodies after the battle. Crazyhorse did not listen.
@johnkersey2365
@johnkersey2365 2 года назад
He was a Lt. Colonel his promotion to General was temporary, he got just what he deserved, and as it turns out there was no big gold strike so all the inhumanity inflicted on the original American's was for nothing by those so alleged good Christians.
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 Год назад
Custer was awarded the rank of MGen in the Civil War - Brevet Rank. That mean the rank was only for a temporary assignment for particular tasks. When those were completed he reverts back to the rank he held prior.
@halibut1249
@halibut1249 2 года назад
Hollywood Custer. Not a smudge or drop of sweat on his face. Perfectly coiffed hair, shampooed and blown dry. Clean hat and uniform. Must have taken a stagecoach while his men rode horses.
@wespenn7243
@wespenn7243 2 года назад
15:29 I would argue there was many survivors. The Native Americans that wiped them out could have and did give 1st hand recollections. Like it or not, they were victorious and can write that portion of history as they saw it!
@tomjones2202
@tomjones2202 2 года назад
You are absolutely right! There were MANY survivors! The US just didn't want to recognize the surviving Native Americans who fought that day who could very well tell them EXATCLY what happened! And in later years they did start saying, well ,, maybe they do know what happened,,, Curly knew! just ask him ,, or Two Moons,,, or any other warrior who fought valiantly that day! Thank goodness there are surviving records from those great warriors who fought that day to protect themselves and their families.!
@wespenn7243
@wespenn7243 2 года назад
@@tomjones2202 You are probably right. Sad event all the way around!
@patriciarouse2801
@patriciarouse2801 2 года назад
Actually forensic achiologists excavation of the site confirmed the evidence supports the accounts of Lakota survivors.
@benclanton6392
@benclanton6392 2 года назад
That's not the point he was making. There were no survivors from Custer's formation. You could ask anyone in the battle what happened and you will get different details that add up to a bigger picture. Sadly, without the details from inside Custer's ranks, the perspective from the US troops will never be revealed. Was it a state of confusion, despair, or just grim resolve? We'll never know first hand.
@tomjones2202
@tomjones2202 2 года назад
@@benclanton6392 I think the perspective was pretty obvious by ALL accounts even the troopers that tried to get to Custer,, The perspective from them would be " we're all about to die!" and they did. What other perspective could they possibly give? Compare it to Reno... what was their perspective,, they were in the same boat! Reno chose to get to higher ground and survive and tell about it. He said he felt if he stayed where he was he and all his men would be killed so he moved to the safety of the high ground. So, yeah, the perspective was really there.
@josephmulvihill3353
@josephmulvihill3353 2 года назад
Impressive research. That was very good work. My hat is off to you.
@wes326
@wes326 Год назад
Custer's tactics worked until they didn't. Thanks for sharing. Excellent presentation.
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 Год назад
You mean cowardly tactics- twice previously he attacked woman and children, killed and taken hostage which was his strategy- to leverage. Read up...
@wes326
@wes326 Год назад
@@petersonlafollette3521 I wouldn't say using the women and children as hostages to end the fight is cowardly but probably morally wrong. War crimes from our present day standards were pretty prevalent.
@bone3594
@bone3594 Месяц назад
Custer's luck just ran out.
@AbrahamLincoln4
@AbrahamLincoln4 3 года назад
This channel is so underrated!
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Thank you Mr President!
@patrickdaniel4050
@patrickdaniel4050 3 года назад
@@historyradar9654 lol, nice work. Thanks
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
@@patrickdaniel4050 XD
@wwolfe1478
@wwolfe1478 3 года назад
Your layout of the battle was sublime. Good job! Subbed!
@jamesstuart3346
@jamesstuart3346 2 года назад
Very well done. Liked and subscribed.
@doctorgarbonzo2525
@doctorgarbonzo2525 2 года назад
One of the better editorials of this Historic piece of History
@trumpsmessage7777
@trumpsmessage7777 2 года назад
I've been tracing old wagon trail ruts between Dodge City Kansas and Oklahoma which Custer used to attack the Cheyenne in the Battle of the Washita. They also cut off SW into the Texas Panhandle where the Red River War of 1874 was fought.
@devonmccallum7130
@devonmccallum7130 2 года назад
You may enjoy this book. I have nothing to do with it, but thoroughly enjoyed seeing the difference between the Custer Expedition's photographs and modern day ones.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 4 месяца назад
I also did that in the very early 2000s!!! I was at Fort Larned National Historic Site in Larned, KS, I was taking a college class about the American West, and we had to do a term paper about a battle from the Plains Indians War, so I chose the Washita Battle. While at Fort Larned, I was talking with one of the park rangers about what I was doing. He was gracious enough to show all kinds of artifacts that were supposedly from the Washita battle site - something that regular visitors do not really get to see unless on display. He also showed me an actual map that one of the officers from 7th Cavalry used - he was kind enough to give me a facsimile copy of it. Afterwards, I went down to Fort Dodge, KS, (east of Dodge City) and picked up the trail from there. By using that facsimile map and an actual modern-day map, I was pretty much able to follow the path that the 7th Cav took to Washita (was also surprised how accurate that facsimile map was). Yes - did have to make a few detours because of modern-day farms and roads and such, but those detours were not as bad as expected and was able to require the trail rather quickly and lots of those roads were gravel, dirt, or quite questionable. Do remember crossing into Oklahoma and making it to Fort Supply. From Fort Supply to the battlefield, it was more or less a direct drive south. Was a great experience being able see what the troopers may have seen back then (minus all the modern houses, roads, signs, snow, etc,). Also, on a visit to the battlefield last year, as I was driving home north along US HWY 283 north of Cheyenne, OK, and came to an intersection with a sign for a cemetery out in the middle of nowhere. Followed that sign and turns out that cemetery was where Custer had Major Elliott and his command buried - more of just finding an acceptable spot and dumping the bodies there. The cemetery popped up for regular use later if I remember the historical signs properly. At the cemetery entrance there are historical markers explaining the immediate area, the battle, and such. You will have to walk roughly 1/4-mile south of the entrance gate to get to the actual cemetery - it is on private property, but the landowner allows visits. Once there, you will find a historical marker for each of the soldiers that were killed in Maj. Elliott's command - thought that was an awesome touch. I planned to visit the cemetery and spend about 10-minutes there but ended up staying about 2-hours!! A few of those signs had blown over and I was trying to restore them as best as possible. Think the cemetery had about a dozen or so other graves there as well of the local people.
@davidkinsey8657
@davidkinsey8657 Год назад
I hate it when people say we don't know how Custer's Last Stand played out because there were no survivors. There were over 1,000 survivors but they were all Native American. The accounts of the Battle of the Greasy Grass handed down in their oral traditions are consistent with modern battlefield archeology.
@jonathanhill9453
@jonathanhill9453 2 года назад
15:58 another correction, they were clipping south. Sorry if I’m wrong. Fascinating video. Loved the way they chased those jerks back to their fort.
@dmprdctns
@dmprdctns Год назад
Well done... Thanks... Excellent map work!
@lukejs3182
@lukejs3182 Год назад
Thank you very much for this detailed video!
@stratsteveo106
@stratsteveo106 2 года назад
I am a Custer. My great grandfather changed it from Custer to Kuster and married a native American. Ironic isn't it? You wont read that in your history books. His blood runs through my veins yet i also have native American blood too. Think about it. General Custer is my great great uncle. My brother and uncle look identical to him.
@clevelandwilliams5922
@clevelandwilliams5922 Год назад
That is great Irony my mentor Cleveland “The Big Cat” Williams was of African & Cherokee Indian descent. To why he was a great warrior and boxer.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 3 года назад
Great video!!! Have had the opportunity to visit Little Bighorn Battlefield numerous times. Have been there BEFORE the Native American markers were put into place AND BEFORE the Native American memorial was built. Also have been there numerous times AFTER everything was emplaced - way better experience and interpretation of the events that happened. It is roughly a 5-mile distance from Last Stand Hill to Reno Hill and have ridden my bicycle that route a few times, as well as, driven. Always learn/see something new. Unfortunately, cannot visit the location where Reno's command crossed the river and started the battle, for that is private property. However, once you enter battlefield-proper, you can drive to an overlook and get a good glimpse of the area. Also, have followed Gen Crook's route north out of Fort Fetterman to the Rosebud Battlefield (Battle Where the Sister Saved Her Brother). That battle was a NEAR DISASTER for the Army, because the army was caught by surprise. Indian scouts detected/intercepted the Indian attack and engaged the enemy long enough for the Army to re-act.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
That sounds amazing, it’s definitely on my list of battlefields I want to visit. Thanks for sharing ☺️
@jebangelacox9279
@jebangelacox9279 3 года назад
Your knowledge of the battle is superb. I recently read Steven Ambrose's book on Crazy Horse and Custer really good.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 3 года назад
@@jebangelacox9279 THANKS!! Have read that book as well. Another excellent book to read that came out a few years ago, "A Terrible Glory" by James Donovan is a good source. Goes in depth of the entire campaign and aftermath.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 3 года назад
@@jebangelacox9279 If you have not already seen them, look on You Tube for custerapollo. This guy does an EXCELLENT 36 video series about the battle. Also, he will walk the actual battleground and point out areas of interest, movements of combatants, orientate you to the battlefield, and other stuff. Just an awesome series. He also has maps that will show the battle as well.
@jameswilliams3241
@jameswilliams3241 2 года назад
Yes Buffalo Road Calf Woman who rode back to save her brother when his horse was shot from under him, many of the people say she was the one who killed Custer
@coredfu8488
@coredfu8488 2 года назад
I never knew I needed a documentary about Custer's last stand starring Ben Stiller until I saw this thumbnail. "Nobody makes me bleed my own blood...other than the Lakota..."
@reekhavoc2932
@reekhavoc2932 Год назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@wolfsden3812
@wolfsden3812 3 года назад
Probably the best description of the battle I've ever watched
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Thank you, glad you liked it.
@wolfsden3812
@wolfsden3812 3 года назад
@@historyradar9654 I'll go as far as saying a must watch 2x's. FYI I was suprised to find out Custer was a hero a Gettysburg...who knew
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
@@wolfsden3812 Thank you so much! I was also surprised to find out that his brother Thomas received the Medal of Honor twice twice for his actions during the Civil War.
@user-wp4zh6po3k
@user-wp4zh6po3k 2 года назад
You 'conveniently' left out, that custer raided villages of women and children WHEN THE WARRIORS WERE AWAY ... custer received righteous retribution.
@renokauweloa9607
@renokauweloa9607 2 года назад
Yes, the history books make Custard out as a hero and the victim to this blunder. What they dont teach people, is that he tried to kidnap the women and children to make the men surrender.
@hailtodachimp2950
@hailtodachimp2950 2 года назад
Zased custer
@orion6251979
@orion6251979 3 года назад
I was on the Pine Ridge Indian reservation on June 25th, 2004. The Lakota tribe still celebrates this victory to this day.
@michaelotten2724
@michaelotten2724 3 года назад
Came at a great price
@martinkirby3100
@martinkirby3100 3 года назад
And so they should celebrate it it was the end of a mass murderer ie G A C he was no hero heroes don't kill woman and children
@kjboulard
@kjboulard 2 года назад
@@martinkirby3100 Nits make lice.
@Jason-hg1pc
@Jason-hg1pc 2 года назад
😱
@Jason-hg1pc
@Jason-hg1pc 2 года назад
I'm not Lakota, but I AM Native, so I was ambiguous when I read about it while enrolled in public school school, but I have definitely celebrated it independently, and I have learned to assess a minor but crucial element of peoples' psyche from their perceptions of that day, their descriptions of the people involved, and the amount of time and effort spent describing it.🏹🤠⚰️
@larry1824
@larry1824 Год назад
A battle that went south almost as soon as it began..
@razorshark9320
@razorshark9320 3 года назад
I went to the Little Big Horn when I was about eighteen. I made a life study of this Battle when I was fourteen and still learning more about it. This battle needs to be on film again.
@Taiko-THC349
@Taiko-THC349 3 года назад
Can you recommend some good books?
@razorshark9320
@razorshark9320 3 года назад
Crazy Horse and Custer, Custer's Last campaign, and A Terrible Glory.
@Taiko-THC349
@Taiko-THC349 3 года назад
@@razorshark9320 Thankyou.
@numbnumbjuice3375
@numbnumbjuice3375 3 года назад
@@Taiko-THC349 read black elk speaks , black elk was at the Little Bighorn battle when he was twelve and talks about it as well as a couple others in the book
@Taiko-THC349
@Taiko-THC349 3 года назад
@@numbnumbjuice3375 I will. My thanks.
@aledakivett9255
@aledakivett9255 3 года назад
Custer ordered a forced March before the battle. His men and horses had little rest or food for over 24 hours. The weather was very hot for June. They were exhausted going into the fight. I had the pleasure of visiting the Little Bighorn Battlefield last summer. The topography is much rougher and steeper than depicted. There are small markers where soldiers and Indian bodies were originally found. Army horses were interned around the base of the monument . The ... I'm going to call it a monument... for the Native Americans was so moving I litterly staggered as I entered its circle and would have likely fallen if its wall hadn't caught me. Wish I could post photos here.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
I definitely need to visit the battlefield one day
@snowblind9065
@snowblind9065 3 года назад
been there a few times my self what i was astounded by is that the battlefield is about 6miles long and the coulees and ravines are deep and overgrown,I was their a second time in may and the temperature was hot,hot.Glad there was a motel and casino across the street after spending half a day on the battle grounds
@gerthie
@gerthie 3 года назад
What was Custer thinking
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
Aleda, correct! Some Indian eye witnesses later said that when the troopers got off their horses to fire their carbines, their legs were trembling. They were exhausted! Custer had to be first! He was and paid for it with his life and his men!
@aledakivett9255
@aledakivett9255 3 года назад
@@gerthie He needed a big win. He hated Ulysses Grant and had plans to run in the next election.
@explosiverex5023
@explosiverex5023 3 года назад
Really good take on this using the footage and using maps,couldn't even imagine the panic them men went through,but to be fair to the natives they were backed up in a corner like a wounded animal and fighting for there way of life and seen many atrocities before it was pure blood lust for them,just hope they are all at peace!
@TheRounder1980
@TheRounder1980 2 года назад
I see the NA like bees or Hornets. Custer attacked the nest when they were awake and came out like hell to protect there queen and kids. One hornet might not do much but if they stay together 100 of them can. The NA stayed together and fought for each other. Whites didn’t period and had too. Custer Benteen and Reno should all get blame
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
AN ORGHY WOULD HAVE BEEN OUT OF THE QUESTION THEN
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
THATSOK JUST SO YOU DONT LOVR RCHJ OTHER THATWOULD HAVEBEEN A LITTLE BETTER OFA TIME
@petersonlafollette3521
@petersonlafollette3521 2 года назад
There were smoldering memories of Washita not very many years before- customary slaughtering of women and children
@rastapete100
@rastapete100 2 года назад
@@davidcardone2141 What the fuck?
@adrianbay1496
@adrianbay1496 Год назад
Excellent job ! :)
@BattalionCommanderMK
@BattalionCommanderMK 2 года назад
Nice vid man.
@geoluc2357
@geoluc2357 3 года назад
Excellent documentary! Greetings from France 🇨🇵
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@billy1858
@billy1858 2 года назад
crazy horse ,a true warrior!
@DSPHistoricalSociety
@DSPHistoricalSociety Год назад
Not really, he lost.
@martinalarcon3108
@martinalarcon3108 Год назад
Crazy horse a great warrior 😮and what does he get ? A malt licor alcoholic drink named after 😮
@trumpsmessage7777
@trumpsmessage7777 2 года назад
Visited Custer battlefield in early August 1969. I can remember looking for bullets or shell casings in that area for fun!
@mikefournier2601
@mikefournier2601 3 года назад
That was the best last stand movie out son of the morning was well done closed to true life good 0ne
@blackholeentry3489
@blackholeentry3489 3 года назад
As Johnny Cash sang...."Custer split his men....He won't do THAT again!"
@31terikennedy
@31terikennedy 3 года назад
You divide and maneuver on offence when you have the initiative and concentrate on defense when you don't.
@juliorosenberg2222
@juliorosenberg2222 3 года назад
Hitler made the same mistake in Russia and I believe the Mexican general who took the Alomo also split his Army and lost to Houston
@Mike12522
@Mike12522 3 года назад
Custer's _own Indian scouts_ ( Crow and Arikara ) told him they had sighted *" the biggest and most populated Indian camps they had ever seen in their lifetimes, "* , some 6,000 to 7,000+ persons. These camps stretched for MILES. 2,000+ of the people there were warriors. The scout's advice to wait was ignored by him. Custer decided to attack without re-inforcements. But then again, the scouts were telling this to someone who had graduated *LAST* in his class at West Point. Custer's worst subject was ' cavalry tactics '. Custer attacked a minimum of 2,000 warriors with 210 men. That's right. They were outnumbered ten to one. I can only imagine that Custer stupidly thought they would all immediately surrender, not fight, and follow his orders. Sadly, at least 6 of Custer's Indian scouts were killed during the battle. ( An estimated half of the Indians were equiped with a large variety of repeating rifles and handguns. They had much earlier traded for them with ......... white men. )
@davidtuttle7556
@davidtuttle7556 3 года назад
Second to last. Pickett bested him for those honors I believe.
@Mike12522
@Mike12522 3 года назад
@@davidtuttle7556 - Strange how your sole opinion differs from the rest of the entire Internet. Pickett finished last in his class of 59 in 1846. Custer was last in his class of 34 in 1861.
@davidtuttle7556
@davidtuttle7556 3 года назад
@@Mike12522 i stand corrected.
@Mike12522
@Mike12522 3 года назад
@@davidtuttle7556 - I will take the time to congratulate you. I make mistakes, too. It takes a BIG man like you to admit he's wrong, or sorry, or even cry. Ask your wife about that. I think she'll agree.
@reallyhappenings5597
@reallyhappenings5597 3 года назад
Always the racial angle from youtube historians like you
@outthere9370
@outthere9370 8 месяцев назад
I think this is the best video I've I've seen yet. Some video's r so confusing with 2 much info thrown at once. This is well done with the current facts acknowledged in a structured way! Thanks. P.S. except for the the trooper depicted with a repeater! 🙄. Regarless of what actually happened on that fateful day be assured Custer & his men got their arses well & truly kicked! 😱
@turbotj
@turbotj Год назад
This is very well done. Thank you for creating this explanation of this battle and the history behind it. Though I should point out that you didn't include the aftermath of the Native Nations and the subsequent treatment of the people after the battle.
@bad74maverick1
@bad74maverick1 2 года назад
Son of the Morning Star is a great movie. A lot of it is a bit historically incorrect but it got a lot of smaller details right on. I still enjoy watching it with my father. We nit pick it a bit, but that's part of the fun sometimes.
@bondoly66
@bondoly66 Год назад
Happy you can watch it with your father.
@bad74maverick1
@bad74maverick1 Год назад
@@bondoly66 Oh yes, it's something almost a family tradition!
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 4 месяца назад
Always kind of imagined what was going through Custer's mind as portrayed by Richard Mulligan in that movie "Little Big Man".
@bad74maverick1
@bad74maverick1 4 месяца назад
@@jamesbednar8625 Oh man that movie!.... Still not the worst portrayal of Custer. That title goes to Robert Shaw and Custer of the West.
@icefoxline9361
@icefoxline9361 2 года назад
I just got done visiting the battle and to be honest it gave me the creeps because almost all of the soldiers are buried in a mass grave right on top of last stand hill. And seeing where they were found ( White markers that said U.S. soldiers fell here June 25-26 1876)and how the 95-degree heat made the soldiers untraceable made me feel sick.
@WaltzRitzi
@WaltzRitzi 8 месяцев назад
As an American through and through, this was a fair fight. Custer had an Army that was armed moving through the Indians land. The Indians got together and won a battle. They should’ve done this wayyy before and kept doing it. But instead they stopped fighting and just accepted defeat. You can be an American but still have sympathy for these people and what their ancestors went through.
@jorv1971
@jorv1971 2 года назад
Thank you for this well orated narrative of native history.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 2 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@cashstore1
@cashstore1 3 года назад
I have run into many young adults now that have never heard of this. Had no idea what I was talking about. Never heard of Custer. One of them never heard of Pearl Harbor.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 3 года назад
Yep - running into that as well. Really want to STUMP someone, regardless of age???? Ask them what was the worst DEFEAT that the US Army ever suffered from fighting the Native Americans - St Clair's Defeat in 1791 (Battle of the Wabash) in western Ohio. Catastrophic defeat where 5 times more casualties suffered from the Army than at Little Bighorn/rosebud combined. Took about 3 years to rebuild/train the army where it finally defeated the Native Americans at the Battle of Fallen Timbers.
@geoluc2357
@geoluc2357 3 года назад
Sad, I'm french and I know the story of little big horn and Custer last stand!
@cashstore1
@cashstore1 3 года назад
@@geoluc2357 You have better schools in France.
@BMac-qb8xo
@BMac-qb8xo 3 года назад
that is what we get for letting them teach gender studies
@bencovington1121
@bencovington1121 3 года назад
The real sad part is that when you demonstrate how little they know they don’t care
@derektan8792
@derektan8792 3 года назад
Good excellent detailed commentary
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Glad you liked it!
@mlbowen6476
@mlbowen6476 2 года назад
Bit of trivia. Gary Cole is the actor who played Custer. Cole was supposed to have been given the role of Crockett in Miami Vice, but he turned it down and Don Johnson got it. And as they say, the rest is history.
@zyxmyk
@zyxmyk Год назад
this was excellent. very rational super well researched. custer did have some good intelligence, his scouts, especially mitch bouyer--who was the army's number one scout and who had never worked with Custer before-- warned him of the size and ferocity of the village but he apparently didn't trust their opinion very much. this was great.
@allanpennington
@allanpennington 3 года назад
It would be useful to have a North point and a Scale on the maps so we can judge the distances involved.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Thanks for the suggestion, I'll see what I can do with future videos :)
@stephenyoung2742
@stephenyoung2742 3 года назад
Custer turned down the gatling guns and another cavalry detachment of more than 200 men
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
Yes, Indeed! He also did not arm his men with their sabers. They were left behind. The Indians had a healthy respect for the cavalry men armed with sabers.
@premierhoner614
@premierhoner614 3 месяца назад
WOW, you guys have a rich history.. Treasure it for the years to come.. From Capetown South Africa...
@Norwegian733
@Norwegian733 2 года назад
I`m always worried about the horses when they fight like that 😄
@artistaprimus7080
@artistaprimus7080 3 года назад
Custer kept compounding his errors in judgment. After surviving all those reckless charges during the civil war, his luck finally ran out.
@goober208
@goober208 3 года назад
Those reckless charges prevented JEB Stewart from attacking Meades flank. Saving the day
@artistaprimus7080
@artistaprimus7080 3 года назад
@@goober208 An impressive record during the civil war, no doubt about it.
@johnwhitworth9074
@johnwhitworth9074 3 года назад
His Brother Tom Custer won the Medal of Honor Twice..and of course George was a hero at Gettysberg...so the whole thing is an utter tragedy ..
@arctodussimus6198
@arctodussimus6198 2 года назад
The real battle of the Washita River is far different than what you may read in the history books. The Cheyenne warriors had separated themselves from the old men, women, and children, to protect them from battle. They were camped two miles away. Custer attacked the women and children, killing about half of them and taking the other half as prisoners. They left the area before the Indian warriors could get there. The Cheyenne called him “Woman Killer” He was an arrogant ass, with one of the highest desertion rates of any military outfit. You won’t hear this story in history books because the people in the east wouldn’t have stood for it after hearing about the battle of Sand Creek, almost exactly one year earlier.
@gocatoon4591
@gocatoon4591 2 года назад
bullshit
@randyscott9720
@randyscott9720 2 года назад
Interesting, little known fact is Custers 1st Stand at the Pig War in San Juan Islands WA. I lived there for awhile and participated in the reenactments. As a new Lieutenant Custers 1st command was a small outpost on north part of Island. There was a British post on south part. Friction over a boundary line occurred with soldiers on each side when a shot rang out followed by several more. A pig had run between the 2 sides triggering some shots. Only casualty was the poor pig. Look it up, its true
@buddyrupp6235
@buddyrupp6235 3 года назад
Excellent, bravo!
@ralphgeigner9545
@ralphgeigner9545 3 года назад
We did a family vacation out that way, was interesting to walk the battle site, it also was the same time as the Sturgis bike event, we were there the year after Dances with Wolves came out and that was big deal out there, getting to a few movie sites. And some Indian War era forts and battle sites.
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
GOOD WALL A HORSE
@davidcardone2141
@davidcardone2141 2 года назад
COULDNT ALL GET AWAY OH WELL LIVE THAT WAY DIE THAT WAY IS THAT U COULD DO FOR ME
@farnorthhomested844
@farnorthhomested844 2 года назад
it looks like the indian on this video is wind in his hair from dances with wolves.
@jamesbednar8625
@jamesbednar8625 3 года назад
There is an AWESOME 36-part series by a You Tuber called "CusterApollo". He explains the battle in great detail and also walks the battlefield, pointing out the terrain, significant events, etc. He also has animated maps of the battle as well. Highly recommended.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Thanks that sounds amazing I will check it out 👍🏻
@danielwilburn1148
@danielwilburn1148 Год назад
11:28am
@danielwilburn1148
@danielwilburn1148 Год назад
I'm ashamed to hear this last stand information, terrible results.
@outthere9370
@outthere9370 8 месяцев назад
Thanks for the heads up!
@ballygeale1
@ballygeale1 Год назад
That was a very good video
@davidlard8490
@davidlard8490 2 года назад
A really interesting depiction of the battle and quite true from what I have read. Kenny Rogers should have been there and " know when to hold em ', know when to fold em' .
@marcellino1956
@marcellino1956 3 года назад
This was well done thank you
@chasemurraychristopherdola7108
@chasemurraychristopherdola7108 3 года назад
I would love to see something like this but on the battle of Gettysburg because that battle really interests me and the reasons that the battle of Gettysburg interests me are I had ancestors that fought in it and they were 2 of my 4x great uncles the first one is William Henry Weikert who fought in a skirmish on June 26th and the other one is George E Kitzmiller who served valiantly in the ranks of Company K first Pennsylvania reserves infantry regiment and on June 22nd 1867 aged 27 6 years before he passed away the war department issued him a brevet promotion to captain to date March 13th 1865 for gallant and meritorious service in the wilderness campaign another reason I am interested in the battle of Gettysburg is that my ancestors lived through it so my ancestor William Henry Weikerts Dad And George E Kitzmillers Father in law my 4x great grandfather Jacob weikert had a house and barn that was used as a Union field hospital for the 5th corps army of the Potomac and during the fighting on the second day of the battle of Gettysburg his saw the famous famous bayonet charge of the 20th Maine infantry regiment against the 15th Alabama infantry regiment and i know that my ancestors house and barn was used as a field hospital because a famous union soldier/ general died there but at my ancestors house was a young girl named Matilda Jane Tillie pierce Alleman and she wrote the only civilian account of the battle of Gettysburg called what a young girl saw and heard of the battle of Gettysburg and I would highly recommend people who are interested in the civilian experience during the battle of Gettysburg to read the book and its on the Pennsylvania state university library’s website and in the book Mrs pierce remembers a promise that she made and she says I hastened down to the little basement room, and as I entered, the soldier lay there dead. His faithful attendant was still at his side. I had kept my promise, but he was not there to greet me. I hope he greeted nearer and dearer faces than that of the unknown little girl on the battlefield of Gettysburg. As I stood there gazing in sadness at the prostrate form, the attendant looked up to me and asked;” do you know who this is?” I replied;” No sir.” He said;” This is the body of General Weed a New York man” And I also know that my ancestors house and barn was used as a field hospital because located within the museum at the Gettysburg national military park visitor center is a table but it’s not just any ordinary table it’s my ancestors kitchen table and if you look 👀 closely you see something that looks like a blood stain but that’s not just any ordinary Blood Stain it’s the blood of union and confederate soldiers who were amputated and treated on the table.
@mackenzieblair8135
@mackenzieblair8135 Год назад
That’s crazy that he witnessed the 20th Maine’s charge when the Weikert Farm is nowhere close to that action and the family left their farm during the battle. It’s almost like you’re making stuff up.
@edwardschmitt5710
@edwardschmitt5710 2 года назад
Nice job.
@iralee1180
@iralee1180 2 года назад
Custer wasn’t a general (brevet only). He was a colonel and graduated last in his class at West Point.
@paultyson4389
@paultyson4389 3 года назад
What a great presentation. As I understand it, the trooper Reno sent with a message to Benteen to join him could barely speak English.
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Thank you. Yes you are correct the trooper (Giovanni Martino) was of Italian heritage and had poor English skills.
@mariocisneros911
@mariocisneros911 3 года назад
And he was sent by Custer's to Bentteen
@clintmatthews2714
@clintmatthews2714 3 года назад
excellent
@historyradar9654
@historyradar9654 3 года назад
Many many thanks
@Thumper770
@Thumper770 2 года назад
I just can't sit here a listen to a guy who isn't American tell me about American History.
@jedimike1020
@jedimike1020 2 года назад
Not going to lie, seriously thought that was Ben Stiller in the thumbnail there for a sec lol
@tomservo5347
@tomservo5347 3 года назад
Shout out to John Gibbon, a hero of the Civil War and a man who recognized the Native Americans' plight. He didn't like fighting against them but the Army was his career and he later became an agent for them as the Natives learned when he gave his word it was good, regardless of any career repercussions that might happen. To Benteen's credit, he'd seen plenty of horrific combat during the Civil War and IMHO he knew they were in way over their heads. For a hardened combat commander to order his men to dig in it means he knew things looked grim. He also knew from experience just how nearly impenetrable dug in rifle pits were to attackers. He didn't lose his cool-he just knew trying to rescue Custer would have left him completely exposed and probably would have led to his command getting cut to ribbons. He knew Custer's ego would eventually be his undoing. In an odd twist, the Natives had better rifles in the form of 1873 Winchesters while the troopers still used single shot breech loaders thanks to the penny pinching War Department.
@snowblind4009
@snowblind4009 3 года назад
you are wrong about the rifles. In the following 2 days of battle after the little bighorn fight,200 Calvary troopers held of more than 1000 natives with their single shot 45-70 rifles, which was much easier loading and more accurate than the Unreliable and more expensive Winchester.I suggest you read about the about the battle of Roark,s drift in which the British army with single shot rifles defeated a vastly superior Zulu force. The Decision of US army to army its soldier with the Springfield had more to do with tactics than with economics. Also Custer ego had nothing to do with his defeat he was following the tactics of the day by splitting his command to prevent the natives from scattering.
@johnjohnson8812
@johnjohnson8812 3 года назад
@@snowblind4009 The army rifle at the time was the 1883 Springfield carbine for the cavalry in .45 caliber. Supposedly accurate up to 600 - 800 yards (depending on the source you read) in the hands of a skilled rifleman. Custer's men were not even close to being skilled in anything. The carbine had a tendency to jam if overheated at times, and the soldier had to pry out the jammed cartridge with a knife. Tough! You are correct about the Battle of Rorke's Drift in Jan., 1879 in Natal, South Africa. 140 regular British troops fought off a Zula force of 3,000 to 4,000 natives. Two British regular army Lieutenants were in command. The troops were regular British army troops and had served the empire all over the world. Rifle used was the single shot Martini-Henry .454 caliber. A superb weapon of the time. 17 British soldiers were killed, and 11 Victoria Crosses (equivalent to our Medal of Honor) were awarded. This battle is still studied today, as it shows what good leadership, well-trained troops, and good tactics can do in the face of an overwhelming, determined enemy.
@Jason-hg1pc
@Jason-hg1pc 2 года назад
I ask you please share your knowledge of rifles with another commenter on this named "Ed"
@oldhippiejon
@oldhippiejon Год назад
@@johnjohnson8812 And 1000 odd men were wiped out earlier in the day ay Isandlwana using the same weapons, the truth is one battle was fought from behind mealy bags and biscuit boxes the other open plain, the effect of the rifle did kill and injure many Zulu but could not turn the battle the 24ths way in such exposed conditions being attacked by a fast moving enemy.
@wes326
@wes326 2 месяца назад
Benteen and Reno held off the Indians with Springfields. The Springfields had a longer range and were more powerful in order to stop a calvary charge. They could also be shot from a prone position. The lever actions were less powerful but did fire faster until they had to be reloaded, which could be done behind cover. Both had advantages and disadvantages.
@nicodemusblackbird5617
@nicodemusblackbird5617 3 года назад
The day our people lost a way of life that lasted thousands of years,the fight continues to this day.
@watchmanschannelofdespair
@watchmanschannelofdespair 3 года назад
Yet, they didn't have horses for all those "thousands of years", you can thank the Europeans (i.e. Spanish) for that, so give credit where credit is due, and take the good with the bad.
@antjack2602
@antjack2602 2 года назад
Cry some more. Losers
@normanacree1635
@normanacree1635 2 года назад
@@antjack2602 I can't believe the depth of you ignorance.
@richardpluim4426
@richardpluim4426 2 года назад
@@antjack2602 Your nation is falling apart as you speak, By 2030, the US will give up Hawaii and parts of Alaska. Your street signs will be in Chinese very soon.
@crappiehookking387
@crappiehookking387 2 года назад
Its pretty cool to know history.
@hughgrection4205
@hughgrection4205 2 года назад
Congratulations, a very nice presentation
Далее
ЮТУБ ТОЧНО ВСЕ!
11:23
Просмотров 863 тыс.
Hiroshima - the unknown images
52:01
Просмотров 7 млн
Did Custer Commit Suicide?
24:19
Просмотров 472 тыс.
Battle of Rorke's Drift | History | Zulu Wars |
10:05
Просмотров 451 тыс.
Battle of Isandlwana | History | Zulu Wars |
11:34
Просмотров 596 тыс.
What's up with Custer Survivors?
10:43
Просмотров 1 млн
Custer's Little Bighorn Failures Revealed
14:29
Просмотров 153 тыс.
ЮТУБ ТОЧНО ВСЕ!
11:23
Просмотров 863 тыс.