Battle of the Quilting Subscription Boxes -TILDA CREATING MEMORIES and TILDA CLUB BOX - October 2024 

I love the bag you made sooo cute! On the boxes I give 4 and 5 on both. Love seeing your sweet baby dandelion

Loved the boxes! Tilda is also one of my favorites. Love your pouch, so adorable. Thanks for sharing.

Awesome all the way around. I think the button package says Winter reds and greens. Love the bag, those raw edges don't bother me one little bit. Thanks again Holly for a great video. You made my day. Still waiting for that little ghost project. Have a wonderful Fall weekend. I'm heading North in a couple weeks for a short vacation. Leaves are so beautiful up there, but they don't last long enough. Thanks again, Holly.

Love both boxes! Both are a 4.5. Very cool!

Love the bag you made. Fabric a big huge 5/5 and the box I give 3/5. I love love the buttons.

Love the pouch you made. Love the colors of Tilda. Give this box a 5. As for the Tilda Club box, I love it!!! I give this box a 5+

Hi Holly 💜 I really like the bag, you did great! The boxes are nice, I would say a 4 for each. And Dandelion, you are so good and giving high fives, cool! 😎

Oh definitely a 5/5 on the Colours of Tilda box! And another 5/5 for the other box. Just lovely.

5 for both of these. Tilda is my favorite also. Hi Dandelion! Yes, that is great idea for the embroidered pieces.......

Ohh, what a smart Miss Dandelion ❤! Love your cute bag and it looks fine without the binding. Love the blue and burgundy headband! I vote a 3 on the box and bag of fabric, just not my favorite colors.

Your bag is adorable!!!!

Holly, your pouch is so so cute! Like the fabric and love the buttons… dandelion is looking good too. enjoy your weekend.

Totally 💯 love this box I’m definitely a Tilda fan now ❤ great seeing you miss Holly you bring joy to my life thank you ❤❤

Love the pouch. Tilda colors 5, Tilda club 5.

5 on both boxes - fabric combo was great in box - would be a great holiday table topper

❤❤❤ I loved the pouch. 5 on the fabrics and the box. Loved the colors of the fabric.

Love your box, Holly! Very cute. 😍 Like the Tilda fabric selection. 4/5 The buttons are really cute, but I don’t know what I’d do with them. Both boxes are great. 4/5

Cute pouch. I really like the fabric for it. The Colors of Tilda gets a 4.5. The Tilda club box gets a 4.

Cute pouch! Colors of Tilda - cute buttons and lovely fabric. Also not my usual style, but Tilda does this so well. The mix of fabrics in the box is interesting. It’s a 4 for me. Tilda Club - fun notions to work with. It’s a 4 from me also. Great to see Dandelion happy and healthy!

I would say 4 & 4. I have a friend who loves to make banners. I LOVE the opening video. The fall stream is beautiful. In Vegas, we don’t get to see those beautiful scenes. So I love watching the opening. Great job on the Sewers Club bag. I don’t know how you find the time.

Good morning, Holly! Your pouch is beautiful. With of these boxes are also awesome. I vote five out of five for them both! Sweet Dandelion, what a good girl.

Ohhh my 👏👏👏 Both boxes-5!!! Dandelion-just to excited!! ❤️😀

Love love love your pouch!!! And the Tilda, OMG!! Big 5+ for both. Happy Friday sweet lady. Hope your weekend is Fabulous ❤

Hi Holly! You did an awesome job on the pouch! I give the 5s. Dandelion is such a goodlookingdog! Have an awesome weekend!

Also 5 from me. I am with you Holly….i love Tilda but opposite to everything I usually love in fabric! Not sure why, but it is the only line of dainty prints I crave.

Thank you sharing Dandelion today. I truly enjoy your complete shows but Dandelion is my favorite part. True animal lover here. I personally am not a big fan of Tilda. Would give the fabric a 4 and the notion box a 3. The bias binding tool is great. Have an entire set of them. Hope your day is great.

Thanks for showing us the pouch…it’s lovely! Unfortunately, I’m not really in to either of these boxes…just not my thing so a 3 from me.

Hi Holly. Colors box is a 5*5. The notions box is a 4*4. Thanks for sharing!

Winter Reds and Greens.

I have that Jen Kingwell bunting tool, and I LOVE LOVE LOVE it! One of my absolute favorite specialty rulers/templates.

Colors of Tilda I give a 4. The second one I give a 4 also. I am called the Gadget Girl with my Guild. I loved the bag.

Your bag has me wanting to sign up for that box for the 3rd time in a couple of months! That bag is such a nice shape and size, very practical. It would be nice if there is time to get this one. The Tilda fabric is cozy and comforting, and the banner is the same. Perfect for a child feeling safe and loved at granny's house. There would be potato soup simmering on the stove!

Hello Holly, looking lovely as always. You are rocking the flower headpiece! Your little pouch is adorable, I might need the pattern for that. The Interpid Threads boxes are ok, I do not care for the fabric, I give it a 3, the notions box is a 5, great items, love the buttons. Aww Dandelion is so beautiful. Thank you for sharing, until next time.....

Colors of Tilda is 3.5. The intrepid thread box is a 4. I love your pouch! I survived raising 4 daughters through teen years. 😮 It was rough 😅❤. The reward was 4 lovely adult women🥰

I would give them both a 4. The fabric not really my jam and things in the other box I wouldn’t use. Have a great day. Xoxo

5 on both! I loved them both♥Dearly love Tilda's delicate florals and matching buttons♥In love with Dandelion....She makes me smile♥

Yay!! Dandelion, I've been missing her too. 5 for the boxes. Clever viewer who suggested framing the cross- stitch panels, the puckering on them had me worried.

I haven't made the Sewers Club project yet but I'm excited to get it done. I give the box a 4. Nice box but I'd probably only be using the buttons.

Hi Holly, I give the Tilda Box a 4 and the bag with fabric a 5. Have a wonderful weekend. XOXO Carol from down the road

Hey Holly, it's nice to see you. I love teenagers too. They hold so much promise and most aren't aware of their abilities. I love Tilda fabrics and goodies. I can't afford it but the fabric speaks to my heart. 5 across the board for both of the boxes.❤I love you dear friend. Be blessed and

Very cool boxes. I'd give it a 4.5. Have a great weekend.

I love my creating memories package that I get every month from Julie. She is so sweet and the cost isn’t prohibitive. Always a 5! I haven’t pulled the trigger yet on the project box. The value is definitely there, but…. 4.

Pouch turned out cute! Much bigger than it sounded. Didn't like the fabrics much, 3. 2nd box with all the notions a 2 because I have those except for the bias maker. But I always use jelly rolls 😊

Colors of Tilda gets a 3 from me.Tilda Club box gets a 5. See you next video. Love to see Dandelion!

She is the sweetest good girl!❤

Good morning and happy Friday to all. Holly, that bag is beautiful! You did a great job keeping the bottom color level all the way around, and your quilting on it is neat as a pin. No one is going to see the inside, and it's not like you can't go back & bind or zig-zag it later if the raw edges start to bother you. Tilda isn't my favorite line of fabrics, and I would never ever use the bunting pattern/templates, so I wouldn't really want either box. On the positive side, the buttons are *divine* (that first packet is called "Winter Reds & Greens" - I wasn't sure of the first word, either, so I googled it). It's a pity they don't have a Tilda button subscription; they're always awesome. The non-floral fabrics are really nice, and looking at them with an unbiased eye, the florals are too even if they aren't my style. Both boxes are reasonably priced for what you receive, so from me it's *4 out of 5* on both of them.

I'm really bad. I give it a 4 because I want fabric too.😊

The pouch looks great! The boxes are just OK for me - I’m more of a bright colors girl, but I do love polka dots, so that particular one was nice. I’d give the box a 3 but 4 for value. I think I’m spoiled because I always shop sales, so seeing the prices for some of these boxes is hard to swallow. The notions box was a nice assortment, but not much that I would use, so that one is also a 3 from me. I’d rather have fabric for the money. I hope they get your fence up and running again soon. I have a Berner and a Swissy who absolutely love running in our fenced yard and imagine we would all be extremely unhappy if it were down. Dandelion looks so sweet - just the kind of temperament I would expect from your dog. She matches your vibe.

5s all around! I adore all things Tilda!❤

5 for both boxes. Absolutely love the buttons.

Good Day Holly! I think the button card is winter reds and greens. Love the video!

Agree 5 and 5

I give both Tilda boxes a 5 each. Nice boxes

I love Tilda and Liberty fabrics!

Loved both boxes. They are both 5 for me!

Both boxes were nice. I give them both a 4. ❤

Dandelion is the best she gets a 10. The first bag I give a 4 just not a linen person. The second box a 5. Would love a Christmas liberty box but too steep for me but bet it is lovely!

Bag looks good. 4,5 4,5

Wonderful box!! I say 5! ❤

Dandelion is so cute!!❤

Hi Holly. The Intrepid Thread Christmas Box link appears to be broken. I went ahead and ordered one and mentioned you in the comments. I am looking forward to receiving it. Thank you for being a part of my morning. Have a wonderful weekend

5 on both. Loved the buttons! 😊

I give both a 5.

WINTER Reds and Greens

Big 5 for this!

My Vote - Creating Memories: 5 and 5 (Love the fabrics and buttons.) My Vote - Tilda Club Box: 3 and 5 (Buttons and charm are cute, cleaning tools are useful, but the rest - meh. Either already have them or wouldn't use them - I'm just not a bunting person.)

I have so many notions…..3/5

Hi Holly, your bag turned out beautifully! It's very pretty. I give the colors box a 5. Definitely a good value and the buttons s are so cute. The Tilda club box isn't for me. I have a lot of notions that I really don't use. So, I'd give this box a 1.

I give these boxes a 4. I’m not a big Tilda fan but these were nice.

Hi Holly, your pouch turned out very well. I didn't much care for the Tilda Creating Memories fabrics, but the buttons are cute. I give this box a 4. Cute items in the box, but I wouldn't use most of the items except for maybe the buttons. It's always a special day to see Dandelion. See you next time.

Boxes are good give them both a 4

I give a 5 to both

I give these boxes a 5

LOL Holly, If you don’t mind sharing is what were you singing. I’m guessing…HMNN somewhere between Ball and Chain and Puff the Magic Dragon. :) I love singing. Pouch is lovely! TY Holly

Colors of Tilda - intrepid Threads 5/5 Tilda Club- 2/4

I get the liberty version of this and have enough now to make the quilt in Alice's Wonderland by Alice Caroline.

Colors of %tilda is a 5. Nice group of fabrics that would go together. I liked the buttons. Did not like the box at all. Would not use at all...3. You did a nice job on the pouch. Thanks for the visit.

I’m the rain cloud for these boxes. While I think the buttons are so pretty, I rarely use buttons. Not a fan of Tilda fabrics. Those binding or bias keepers are enormous?! Your pouch is really cute. I’ve made a few of similar boxy bags, but I don’t like that they don’t stay open. 🤷🏻‍♀️ 3 and 3

The colors of Tilda are ok. Just not a fan of those colors, but they do go together nicely. 3/5 The Tilda club box is a nice group of notions. I give this box a 4/4.

The tilda club box I thought wasn’t a bad value. 4 The creating memories is a no for me. 2 They replace or fix your dog fence!

4/4-box one 5/5- box 2

I’m doing the colors of Tilda too. It’s a great way to collect these. 5 from me for the fabric. The Tilda club is ok. But I’m not thrilled with the banner. I too got this box too. I didn’t think it was necessarily Tilda though. I think it would be better if the pattern was a Tilda pattern. The price is a really great deal for what you get. But since the project wasn’t my cup of tea, I give it a 4.

The link to the Christmas box in the description says 404 page not found 💔

Your pouch turned out great. Intrepid thread: Tilda not my style this time , cute buttons3/5 Tilda club: cute box, ok notions 3/4

I give both these boxes 4.5 and dandelion sleeping is a wonderful zen! ❤ some dogs limp just for attention 😂 but it could also just be bruised and doesn’t heal because she has to walk on it 🤷🏻‍♀️or she pulled something and the same thing, it can’t heal because she has to use it??

❤❤❤❤❤ : ❤❤❤❤❤

Creating Memories 4-4. It’s pretty, not sure I’d want it, not really interested in wovens or chambray. $4/FQ is pretty steep to me, too, sweet buttons notwithstanding. Same for the box. Nice things, good enough value, but I wouldn’t use most of it. 4-4.

Not my fave fabric 2/ the box was a 3