She has a daytime Emmy but as someone said they are reluctant to give them to sci-fi/supernatural shows. The only Emmy's the show got was back in S2 for make up and soundtrack. Sarah did deserve more recognition but at the time i'm sure the show was seen as a cult rather than mainstream so it didn't get as much attention. She was also nominated for a GG in 02 but didn't get that either.
@@erin_3569 my brother killed himself in February 2019. The feelings Buffy talks about are so true. Your emotional metor gets tapped out sometimes and your just at a loss of what to feel.
Exactly so true, I lost a friend to Suicide this year and I practically overloaded myself with work, going out, drinking, just to distract myself from what happened
I've always loved how they switch mentalities in this scene. Buffy knows the danger of trying to bring someone back, and also isn't acknowledging her feelings about Joyce. But as she finally lets it out, she can admit that she's scared of life without her and wants her mother back no matter the cost. Meanwhile, Dawn wanting Joyce back is rooted in her loneliness, but once she realizes she's not alone and that she and Buffy are in it together, she can finally let Joyce go and is the one to end the spell. This is just an amazing scene.
@@mineonlyedwardcullen Whatever was walking towards that house was definitely not the real Joyce. Have you ever heard of _Pet Sematary_ 👀? Besides, we know that, in this show, natural human deaths cannot be successfully reversed. Joyce died from normal, human, medical complications. Dawn would not have been able to resurrect her properly.
Ricky Moran Jr Compared to Buffy, Vampire Diaries is Twilight. Buffy was way ahead of its time. TVD was just another Supernatural teen drama with no heart. Sure it had good moments, but none as good as Buffy
I always liked how they never showed Joyce here. It makes it more creepier not seeing her or knowing if she was normal or not. I think it's safe to say that she wasn't.
VultureClone I also think that Buffy would have trouble dealing with Joyce, a disastrous violent fight would take place with one ending up dead. Kind of like "The Body" scene with the naked vampire in the hospital.
It's based off a story called The Monkey's Paw. There are many similarities between the two, including the fact that they never reveal the resurrected person. Rather, they leave it up to the reader/viewer's imagination. It left a much stronger impact that way. Worked for the book, works for this episode.
I wish that they had changed it so stupid Dawn didn't "destroy" the picture"::@ :'((U) I want to see how Joyce looked like!And why didn't she say something?!She just knocked on the door!:O:'((U). 2
oh the voice cracks...sarah michelle gellar is quite literally amazing....the way she says "whos gonna take care of us" it tears me apart cus she just plays buffy so broken and defeated and shows that even a strong warrior like buffy is vulnerable and in pain
Ava Rodriguez i didn't say all men either. But Buffy is a powerful heroine and Wolverine powerful antihero, not to compare them but they are both strong
Reasonable! It's one of the few times she was reasonable. I think one reason Buffy didn't break down earlier is because Dawn had the market on being melodramatic covered. It can be hard to show your emotions over a death when someone else is wailing the way Dawn does.
To this day i can't still understand such harsh criticism to Dawn. I really love her, even when she's "being melodramatic". She's super real to me, and has had a very difficult existence, not only because she's just energy xD (And that is a huuuuuge one - identity crisis elevated to the highest level). She's a teenager with her problems, has always been compaired to her sister (who has superpowers) and of course keeps so many secrets from her, their father left them when she was just a child, etc. I really get her. I love Michelle portrait as well, she plays Dawn delightfully. And of course i really love Buffy and Dawn relationship, it melts my heart, and this particular scene is so touching.
I do agree that she had it tough but I always felt like she was letting her frustration out on Buffy. If she could have at least tried to get along with her and talk to her I would have been okay with it. Even as a teen with huge problems one should be able to emphasize with others and see that everyone has problems while with Dawn I felt that she was always stuck in her own little world. I mean, for example, why would she steal from the magic shop? It's not like she never had anyone who'd listen to her; she was friends with Willow and Tara and Xander but singled herself out quite often. So while her life is hard she is in no way innocent that some things went wrong and that her relationship with Buffy wasn't the best. Buffy's done so much for her (even though she also made mistakes and was sometimes too harsh due to her being overwhelmed by everything) that I would have at least wanted her to try to understand Buffy a little better.
I love how Buffy not crying when her mom died and at the funeral was addressed. She bottled everything up because she wanted to be strong for everyone and then it exploded right here. Most shows would have the characters cry and move on by the next episode. To me this felt more realistic this way.
@@kieramcgregor I guess we’ll agree to disagree. This felt natural to me and it was nice to see the emotions of Joyce’s death carry on for several episodes.
Well that's because Buffy don't want to show everybody her weakness since her mom died, so that's why she's not crying and all she's only showing a brave face or she's telling herself that, she's not going to cry, she's not going to cry something like that. But Dawn notice and think maybe Buffy don't care at all that their mom died and then she's not showing anything any feelings towards it. But deep inside Buffy it's killing her so that's why she keeps doing something just like her mom doing. And that's the one Dawn don't get it but Sarah's acting here is really one of a kind she's amazing and all. Her emotions and all it's so natural her crying wow!! She's the best ever I love Buffy ever that 😍😍😍💕💕💕💕
When my mom died, I broke down at her bedside. Then for the next 7 to 10 days straight through arrangements and the funeral service I basically did the same thing. It's a weird stage of grief where it's not real so you can actually focus on everything and everyone else. When they all went away and the service was over, it started setting in and that's the hardest of all
I lost my mom when I was 15. When I was told that my mother died I acted similar to Buffy. An hour later after I learnt the news I sat at my table to do my homework. My aunt who came at that time said she was shocked to see me not crying but just sitting there working. After I finished homework I wanted to go to the art school I was attending and the only thing that stopped me was that i was afraid I would faint somewhere on the street. I continued going to school and took a day off only for the funeral. Everyone thought I was being too stoic but in fact I just thought that if I had stopped, just lied on my bed and cried, I'd have gone crazy. Because if you're busy then you don't have the time to think about your grief. So it makes it easier.
I'm sorry for your loss.😔 Everyone deals with their grief in their own way, and sometimes, we act so strange because we still don't know how to process the loss of a loved one. It's just...so hard to get through with it.💔
It always pisses me off when people act like that. Like people don't always burst into tears on the spot, if there's one thing I've learned from experience it's that the stages of grief aren't really a step by step thing but a random cycle, you can be numb one moment and angry the next, it always takes time.
Sarah again just proving no-one can do a better emotional breakdown than she can. It's absolutely heartbreaking to see Buffy so broken. Sarah is unbelievable. When she asks Dawn "Who's going to take care of us?" is honestly one of the hardest things you have to watch in the entire series.
People hating on Dawn, you know Buffy's character wouldn't have such in depth emotional connection if it wasn't because of her little sister. We've seen her being a tough young slayer but it's amazing to also see her transforming gracefully into adulthood and somewhat motherhood as well. Both ladies are such amazing actresses and this scene has to be the best, strongest and most emotional ever. There's no way they could just read the script and act it out. They're natural talent!
Buffy had depth and emotional connection the whole series. It's what made her such an iconic character. She's always been a thoroughly explored multifaceted person.
The courage Dawn showed in the end ripping up the picture to save Buffy, at the same moment accepting her mom was really gone after all she had done to try and get her back - it was the bravest and most unselfish act in the whole series. I CANNOT understand how anyone hates Dawn; she was an incredibly strong character and VERY mature for her age and circumstances. As a secondary school teacher, I would much rather have had Dawn in my class than Buffy.
They frequently wrote Dawn as a much younger character, almost infantilizing her at times. Not Michelle Trachtenberg's fault but some people can confuse the actor with the character.
@tmage23 I akways took the childishness to be a sign that no matter what magic was used in creating her, she was emotionally much younger than her appearance.
Ill admit. As a fan i ddnt like dawns character on the show at all. HOWEVER, i LOVED how buffys character developed as a result of dawns presence on the show. It gave buffys more depth bc now you got to see her go from teen vampire slayer concerned abt boys to more of a motherly figure. And season 5 is def my second fav season after season 3.
that was why they brought her. They knew that they were going to have joyce die (and giles leave) at some point and needed something to tie her to the "real " world.
what the HELL DO YOU THINK IS "GOOD" WITH THAT?!:@ THIS DESTROYED THE WHOLE EPISODE!I WANT TO SEE HOW JOYCE LOOKED LIKE!:'(AND I WANT TO KNOW WHY SHE SAID NOTHING,WHY SHE JUST KNOCKED!
I love the writing too, but I don't get Dawn's perspective. Simply because I can't relate to such an immature, self-absorbed, self-loving and egoistical person. Anyone with eyes would have seen Buffy was really hurting, only a person I described above wouldn't have.
Valerie Winter Because she was in pain too ? When you loose someone or you are in extrem pain, it's not easy to understand such obvious things. Remember when Buffy couldn't speak with Joyce's doctor and answear to his easy questions ? That was the same for Dawn who couldn't understand why Buffy didn't cried.
That episode, and all those about Joyce's death, rang so true. I know... I lost my mother when I was 29. And I so relate to Buffy and Dawn, I always break down in tears watching this. I have rarely seen my personal grief and heartache so well portrayed... The way Buffy says "Mommy" when she hears the knock on the door.... So heartbreakingly true...
Frick, that gets me everytime when Buffy goes mommy and rushes to the door, and dawn rip the picture just to find Buffy to open the door and see nobody there so heartbreaking! 💔 I know a lot of people found Dawn to be annoying and a brat.. I will admit I even couldn't stand her but i realize now that Dawn was just a teenager than.. And as she grew up she mature into a strong woman like Buffy! These two wow this was absolutely a chilling moment! Loved every moment of it!
I wish they could have let us seen how it would go if they Did so Joyce was Alive again😢😭💔 Stupid Dawn who broke something so it was "over'!:@ 😢 😭 💔 Stupid director!It could have been a so great episode!
The entire death of Joyce arc was the biggest gut-punch in all of BTVS. Not to diminish others, like say Tara's death, but... there was someone to blame. Someone to kill. Some reason for it (like Angel's death) or a noble sacrifice (Spike's death... and Anya's for that matter). Or just someone to hate over it (Fred's death). Joyce? We had nothing. Grief. Mom's dead. For no real reason other than life is freaking cruel. The writing, the acting, all reflected that so damned perfectly. Right down to that cold, strong front of the person that feels they have to be the adult, to be the rock for everyone... while they are dying on the inside.
I relate so much to Buffy in this scene its unreal "Who's going to take care of us" 2 years ago I lost by best friend, my role model, my anchor, My father After acting as his support and back up nurse when my mum was busy, he passed away from his long-term battle with Cancer. The day it happened I felt like I was broken inside, like I had lost a part of myself. Not just a parent. I miss him so much sometimes I feel like I'm broken and a part of me will never be fixed. But then I look at my sister and my mum, then I remember what my dad said "Work together, be a team". My mum is a single parent, aside from having her boyfriend now. She's lost the love of her life and father of her kids. Her soulmate. She broken inside and though the pain gets easier, she will never stop missing my dad. My sister is good at hiding her feelings much like myself. The only times she truly cries or shows how she feels is when she is under the influence. Her depression not helping much with that either. She's 20 now and the loss of dad never helped either of us, sometimes telling me how much she misses him. I'm the eldest but I've always been resilient, coming out of things stronger and learning from my mistakes. I never show how much I'm hurting. Willing to put the need of others before myself, because the most important thing to me is those I care about. My loved ones. Be they friends or family So I keep protecting my sister and mum, my friends and my family. They are my rock, my anchor. Without them I would be lost. At my worst and weakest moments they have been there for me. and I don't know what I would do without them
You are not alone! I experienced nearly exact the same what you are writing. Except... i had a totally mental breakdown last year (8 years after the death of my mother) at that moment my head was realising that "everyone is okay" - meaning my dad and my brother are stable, and can continue without the urgent need of my help. At that exact moment I was falling so deep and it was a huge pain with therapy and stuff to come out of that. What I want to say: Take care of yourself, don't forget to think about you also. You are strong! Much Love! ♥
Wow. Shout-out to every one who has lost their mom.. I can't imagine the pain you have been in.. I'm so sorry. This scene shows the real life burdens older siblings must constantly bear when they become orphans. Reguardless of age.
I watched this show years ago. I didn't realize how great of a show it was till now. This scene alone, alone with Anya crying over Joyce, are such accurate representations of grief. How it effects everyone differently. Buffy is trying to keep it together, Dawn doesn't understand why she's emotionally cold. Anya not understanding how someone can be here one minute and gone the next. Very powerful scenes and superb acting.
SMG is one of the most underrated and (outside of Buffy) underused actresses. This scene was incredible, hope we get to see her in some good roles in the future
I love this scene it's my favorite Dawn moment because Buffy is always there for her taking care of her and always being strong but this time it's the other way around Dawn sees Buffy break down and realizes she's not alone in this and comforts Buffy like Buffy always did with her I love how Dawn and Buffy are holding each other at the end and Dawn is saying it's okay this time Dawn was the big sister for Buffy Sarah and Michelle are amazing in this scene
it’s always so powerful when they show buffy being emotional. in every second of her life she has always been the protector. never allowing herself to be human. so when she finally breaks it makes the scene that much greater and you can only imagine how much emotion she has built up.
Back in the day I watched "The Body" episode over and over again, and in 2012 I lost my Mom in the exact same way Found her on the couch at night Since then I can't bring myself to watch that episode again
I hope you are doing okay nowadays. That must've been terrible to not only lose her but to have it linked in your mind to a thing you previously enjoyed immersing yourself in for a bit of enjoyable escapism. I wish you wellness and healing.
This scene is so damn good. Like Dawn finally realises that Buffy has been shouldering all of this in part to take care of her, and then when Buffy turns and says "Mommy" she's the one who needs someone to take care of her and that makes Dawn step up and do the right thing. I love it
I think Joyce's death was truly the most heartbreaking and difficult moment in Buffy history. What was so heartbreaking about all of this, is that Dawn thought and felt she was the only one suffering and that needed her mother back. She assumed Buffy's emotional strength was as strong as her slayer/physical strength. Once Buffy has confessed that she's been working to maintain their home, lives and from dealing with the loss of their mother, its Buffy's first moment to really open up fully and allow herself to mourn. This is where Dawn realises that she misunderstood her sister, that in-fact she is not alone with her emotions and doesn't need to go to these extreme and problematic lengths, as Buffy really is here, both emotionally and physically. This is where Dawn's overwhelming emotions are replaced with logic and she reverts the spell out of kindness towards her sister, saving her from seeing what most likely... would have been horrific to both see and experience. This is the part that's so heartbreaking, she puts her sister through everything Dawn went though in a coarse of days, in just a matter of minutes... leaving Buffy to lose her all over again at her doorstep. Understandably, we see Buffy collapse and give into the overwhelming emotions she had been suppressing and let them spill into their house and into Dawn's arms, something Buffy was trying and working so hard to avoid, only to protect Dawn and be strong for her. Ultimately, what Dawn did was cruel, but also kind. She created a scary and emotional predicament for her sister, but in doing so, she forced her to mourn her mother (something she needed to do) and then took her mother away from her again. In my opinion, this is where the show changed forever. The Buffyverse was tipped upside down when Joyce died, which makes perfect sense. When your parents are gone, your world, life and reality is never the same. You're filled with fear, uncertainty, doubt and anxiety. Buffy showed huge character development from this episode onwards. Buffy the Vampire Slayer was no longer a show about defeating monsters and demons, it was a show on defeating and surviving the fears and worries of adulthood without your parents, taking care of what they left behind for you and your siblings. Ensuring you keep yourself and the rest of your loved ones happy and alive. Something we all can relate to now, or hopefully... much, much later.
This and many other Amazingly POWERFUL scenes with that always perfect and amazing music, incredible acting, scripting, directing is why this is listed as one of the top ten TV series in TV history and one of my personal top 3.. maybe even number one as I think about it. No show has had as many powerful moments, teaching moment that warns you about the dangers of dealing in witchcraft and the occult unlike books and movies like Harry Potter which does just the opposite.. especially season six where Willow goes off the deep and turns into Darth Willow showing how dangerous the dark side really is. This show has SO many teaching moments without being preachy and many have said in various comments how this show helped them get through many hard times in their lives because of the Deep lessons contained within it.. just fantastic. This show should be in syndication and on every day, I don't know why it's not.. have to look into it I think.
She was a GREAT actress. I don't actually like Buffy's character at all, but Sarah's acting skills were worth watching even when I couldn't stand the power-hungry message she was promoting by Season 7.
SMG was pulling up some truly deep emotions from somewhere real. Acting or not, she crossed the line into that eerie, uncanny valley, where you can't tell if it's acting or real.....even for a moment. Something only a few actors in the world can pull off. Yeah, I said it. Also, it is known that when she said "I FELT YOUR HEARTBEAT...." and looked up at Angel, in that amazing crossover episode of his show (where he becomes human again, for a day), her acting was so authentic that she really started crying and David accidently said "Sarah...." to comfort her, instead of Buffy. And they kept it in. Amazing.
When my... ex, formerly my fiancé, passed away, I felt helpless. I started doing a bunch of stuff, gathering pictures of her, trying to find old online accounts of her, old videos. I started talking to people, seeing if I could in some way help them with that sort of stuff. I felt incredibly useless, but I did so regardless. Talked to her mom, her sister, her (our) friends. For a couple of days, nonstop thinking about anything that she could have used during the nearly 10 years I knew her. It wasn't until later it kicked in; I did it because once I'd stop finding "old things" or finish finding them, I would never, ever find something new of her ever again, because she was gone. Thats when reality kicked in. As long as you're busy doing something, anything, after someone passes, it's like they're not really out of your life just yet. This episode was so immensely strong and powerful, and both actresses here nailed it in ways a lot of actors and actresses can only dream of.
Never finding anything new again... That is a really accurate nutshell-description of a terribly sad circumstance. I'm sorry you went throught that. For me, it was remembering things my grandma regularly said / did and her support of me, that she would never do again, never offer to me again. I had to put the memories (and physical momentos) away, and still I rarely unpack them. It's like a star in the sky burned out. Sure, there are others, but *that one star* that you always looked to, that was a constant presence even when you weren't looking at it, is gone and never coming back. The sky may look the same to others, but there's a particular blank space in it that you know with certainty was once filled with light but is no longer.
god sarah michelle gellar is outstanding at emotional scenes. Every moment in this show that made me cry was from her acting making you feel it all too
I admit that Dawn is not my favourite character. I do not love her as much as the rest of her cast. There are far too many times where she is annoying, angsty and spiteful, acting too much like, well, a teenage girl. I know that is meant to be her character, doesn't mean I have to like it. Even though I'm in my early twenties, I have a bit of a "Get off my lawn!" mentality when it comes to teenagers. But I let that slide in this episode, because Dawn actually learns something. She grows and sees the consequences of her actions and words. She sees her sister break down when the full reality of the situation hits her. She sees Buffy crush under the weight of her responsibilities and her loss. Dawn realises that not everything is about her, that she is not the only one whose suffering. Dawn instead chooses her sister over her reanimated mother. (Or whatever that was. I like to think that it's something dark possessing her body, brought to life to bring pain to the living. Because the episode paints it as something sinister, and if the girls give into temptation and let it in then something terrible will happen). I still don't like Dawn. But in the context of the episode, I truly felt some respect for her.
I love Dawn. As a secondary school teacher, I don't just deal with teenagers: I have learned to love and respect them as individuals. Dawn was my favourite character after Spike. She was really like a student I might have had. I was completely on her side every time, because no one EVER sticks up for the teenagers. Whenever I tell people I prefer teaching teenagers, they say, 'Oh, I couldn't handle THEM!' Like they are some kind of alien species. And then we wonder that they cause drama. Makes my heart ache, personally.
i love how buffy after her rant, ran for mommy and dawn had the strength to tear the photo and make her zombie disappear. such a wonderful, emotional episodes (joyce death and funeral)
Then having to deal with a break up, a demon god trying to kill her sister, having to quit school in order to raise her family. Like damn and her friends never once paid fucking rent when they lived in her house and didn't help with bills and why couldn't willow fix the damn pipes with magic for her.
It's supposed to show real life at it's darkest, this show. Many more people live like that and deal with their own 'demons' every day than we can imagine. Even more so in past generations and less privileged parts of the world. Buffy is not alone.
I could only watch The Body once. My mother died young like Joyce and I was Buffy's age. That episode destroyed me reopening an extremely dark time in my life. My younger Brother was 17 Damn this scene, way too heavy 😟
:( I'm really sorry to hear that. If it's hard for a person that hasn't lived something that similar i can't even imagine someone that has. Hope you and your brother are better now. Take good care!
I find it surprising how many viewers mention how Dawn never shut up and listened, but no one ever points out that Buffy herself also never shut up and listened to anyone else if she didn't want to either. Spike was the only one who would call her out on her self-centredness, and she abused him for it. Is she supposed to be above normal human rules and civility and empathy just because she's a superhero? I don't like that about this show.
This scene is for me the most sad of the show..for so many reasons. The music....the ambience in the house so dark...buffy and dawn are alone and broken....and we realize that Joyce....a Mother is really dead and will never come back....😔
Seriously this show is a MASTERPIECE and SMG is just incredible- No other supernatural show will ever come close to being as good as this!! Apart from the original charmed 👏🏼
I will always admire this show for how it doesn't pull any punches showing what true grief looks like. It's never just a few gentle tears and over. When terrible, painful things like this happen to people, it emotionally scars them for life. It never goes away, you just learn to live with it.
