If you enjoy Second Wind, consider supporting us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/SecondWindGroup Even $1 a month goes a long way to helping make sure we're sustainable.
I'm glad others do appreciate hearing a cynical take on a beloved game. Of course, I binge both you and Yahtzee so it makes a not all that surprising amount of sense that you're a fan too.
Wait... What were you doing for the four years Yahtzee was doing this before that? Or for the four years prior to that since the game came out!? Are you... one of them!?
The guards were the pinnacle of work-to-rule. "The intruder is still in the building but _they're not in MY section of the building_ so I don't give a shit, nor will I let any of my coworkers know about her."
My favorite part of stealth games is how long people care about the conspicuous intruder. MGS3 is funny returning to a spot you just alerted being about as normal as you first enter implying the Soviets go 'that supremely trained international spy infiltrating our base must've pissed off back to America or died in the jungle after cocking up' mere minutes after leaving lol
@@dillonmoore9810 I've always liked to think that all the normal soldiers in metal gear are just like "I don't get paid enough to do anything but the bare minimum against this guy, cause if I make him mad I'm absolutely fucked, and there'll be nothing I can do about it."
Did NOT expect this game to pop up here One of the few precious gaming memories I share with my dad (he's perfectly fine, just hasn't touched a video game in over a decade)
Fair. Still love the game though. Replayed it many times. Perhaps it helps that the Dutch dub is absolutely hilarious. But yeah, any possible sequel can pretty much only disappoint at this point. Probably best to move on.
The only thing I remember about this game is playing it over a friends house. I was at the racing mini-game when the announcer insulted people who did knitting. I remember this because I then looked over to see my friends mom knitting something and now glaring at me.
I remember getting a few hours into this game and thinking "wow this has been such a good little game, I can't wait to see what happens after it opens up in the next... oh, it's the finale."
I remember playing the game with my gf and wondering when we'd get to go to all the other planets that show uo on the radar. Clearly we must be doing that now that we have a spaceship. Boss fight with a big eldritch dude? Must be an end of act 1 boss fight and now the game's gonna open up.....WHAT DO YOU MEAN "ROLL CREDITS"?????
"Maybe they keep flaking on the sequel because expectations only get higher" As someone who just finished Half Life 2 Episode 2, I've heard that story before.
@@generalrubbish9513 It's weird that peopel tend to forget the existence of Half-Life: Alyx. But yeah, while it's a really good game, and while I liked a lot as a person who didn't nostalgia blinded to old Half-Life games 'cos I didn't had chance to play when it was released in first place, people had a chance to play HL1/2 and Episodes back in the day, seems bit disappointed for Alyx. expecting for more.
@@deadruins I've played Alyx and I agree it's pretty good, especially for a VR game (as in, it feels like an actual GAME and not a 20 minute proof of concept), but given the massive entry cost of building a VR-capable rig and buying a VR headset, I just can't bring myself to consider Alyx a mainline entry in the series. VR would have to get a lot more accessible first, and Valve isn't really helping that with their $1000 Index headset. I would be delighted if they instead tried to develop a cheap entry-level headset like the Quest and made games for that.
Mildly interesting anecdote regarding BG&E, 2 in particular During my college course (2020) one of my lecturers (who was, like most of us in that class, a gamer) apparently worked on BG&E 2 - I think he said it was sound. As we were discussing it he said something that really stuck out to me - that he was STILL waiting to be paid for it I think he'll be waiting for a *long* for that money
I'm gonna bet that Ubisoft releases an obvious prototype of Beyond Good & Evil 2 after a long wait. At least the really long wait explains the constant teases for that game. I wonder if Ubisoft's keeping it as a 'hail Mary', like that FF7 remake was for Squenix?
@@Code7Unltd Ubisoft drops another trailer for BG&E2 strategically so they do not lose the trademark. Nothing more. Smoke and mirrors. That's why we get one every ten years.
That commercial at the end does have me curious if Fully Ramblomatic will occasionally do episodes dedicated to laughing at an industry that never learns anything tee hee hee, but with a newer and jazzier theme song, perhaps? Also tossing this out there now, very excited for Yahtzee to play Persona 3 Reload in a few weeks. It's not P6, it'll still be a mostly new experience for him.
He’s said on a few streams that he feels the Stuff of Legends/Chronicles(?) from Frost has taken the place of Let’s all laugh so it seems..unlikely? :/
He’s gonna hate persona 3. Because it had terrible pacing, characters, story and themes. People like it because it harkens back to their angsty youth. But ultimately it’s the only bad modern persona game.
One of my all time favourites. Back then I felt like the world was a bit too small, cause it was the time of GTA3, but replaying it some 15 years later, I think it made it better, more focused. Of course I've been waiting for the sequel for 20 years... and I still do, i won't give up.
I remember Steph Sterling making the case that Yakuza has a better open world than most games because the small size makes it more intimate and familiar. Stuff around every corner, not a 5 minute drive away.
Honestly, I pray it never gets a sequel. I'd rather have an interesting game that didn't stick the landing and remains an eternal what if than let the slimy tentacles of AAA publishers tarnish its legacy with endless mediocre sequels and spinoffs.
Well that's a massive coincidence! I just decided to boot this game up like 3 days ago on a whim. It clearly shows its age, but I still enjoy the charm of the characters and the world. I think you hit the nail on the head with your guess of why people were yearning so much for a sequel, I always liked to imagine what lied beyond the borders of the map and see what more stories could be told in the world.
Oh man the soundtrack for this game is gold. The atmosphere of this game hold up really well and I think that alone sets it apart form many modern high budget games.
"Incredible ambitions towned down by lack of time and budget ending up with the second half/last third of the game being super rushed" is basically the summary of 90% of french videogames that aren't AAA.
@@silak33 Well way back in the long ago there was trailers for a sequel. Then way back in just the way back we got a trailer for a prequel. It's all vaporware. Neither Ubisoft or Ancel give a fuck so much so that even Ancel fuckedoff from his own creation more than once. I used to really be interested in whatever Ancel created but now I realize he's just a hack that accidentally created some good games early on. Plus the creative director for BGaE2 died last year. I don't think this quel will ever release, whether it's pre or se.
@@justintucker331 "Some good games early on"?? Almost every Rayman game, BG&E and King Kong makes for 18 years working on well received games! And BG&E2 is one of the only two projects he worked on afterwards, after having pushed for it more than once at Ubisoft. Yeah, it's a shame he saved the project from preproduction hell at Ubisoft just to drive it back into preproduction hell at his own studio, but his other project had the same fate so it was a deeper problem than "fucking off his own creation". Also, you can't seriously blame the man for retiring from gamedev after 30 years and nothing to show for the last 6.
@@rikamayhem Yes, early on. He directed only 5 games and a bulk of them were earlier on and the most well known ones are Rayman 2, Beyond Good And Evil, and King Kong. I really enjoyed them quite a bit for what they were and I still have my GameCube (which is next to my phonograph and time machine) copies of BGaE and King Kong. I know he directed 2 more Rayman games later but they were in middle of the vaporware pre/sequel "development" and didn't get anywhere near as much attention (despite both of them being great from what I heard) as his 2 passion projects both of which he abandoned. Neither Wild or Beyond Good And Evil 2 or whatever they're calling it now will ever exist as far as I will believe. I've tried having faith in this guy for literal decades and now I'm glad he's gone from the industry so I never have to listen to him saying all the things he has in mind, just for them to never materialize. He was good for the time he was in but the industry advanced and he couldn't with it. Basically he has an endless amount of great ideas but has no ability to know when to stop and stick with a few ideas that can work. Yahtzee makes very good points in this video about how even this game has a bunch of ideas that never seem to go anywhere. This is why I feel he's just not that good. He just couldn't keep up yet publicly projected himself as someone who was. And personally, I don't think he retired from video game development so much as knew that he was about to be outed as a verbally and socially abusive boss and just left. As far as I can tell, there was never any follow up from either him, Liberation, or his accusers in the last 4ish years so take that with a grain of salt.
I feel like these 'not deciding on what genre it wants to be' games are the truest form of the "Adventure Game" genre tag. If you're not at least 3 games combined into one then you're not an Adventure Game no matter how many times you put it in your game's tags!
Makes me think of Kya: Dark Lineage for PS2. 3D Rayman-like art direction with standard platforming and light stealth and puzzle solving, but also wind gliding, sky diving, animal riding and board sliding as WELL as combat like a fairly in-depth mini-tekken. It all flows quite quickly into one another too! The combat has suff like different grabs depending on your position in relation to the enemy, a launcher or two, a stun in the form of a groin kick, at least five different kicks depending on the position of the left analog stick while pressing the kick button and more... also jumping onto and over enemies to ride them into their enemies or grab them by the tail to use as meat shield or big flail. Game is a bit janky on the technical front and has potential for more than it was in the final product, but by ODIN is it a very solid and fun hard-to-define PS2 exclusive gem. I hope that one day, like Beyond Good and Evil, it gets a proper new chance on continuing its story, at the hands of good and skilled people who can take it in a good further direction.
Boy howdy, wait 'til you see the rest of the PS2 catalog! The eternal paradox of the reboot is that the games that get retro-remade are always the ones that were good, not the slightly dodgy ones that people forgot about entirely.
@@CatonatorYeah, that's applicable to movies as well where it's pretty much always the bigger and more popular movies that get remade rather than the flops that still had potential. It's all about banking on brand name recognition though, which becomes even more transparently clear given how many of said remakes are ironically end up being flops themselves.
@@Catonator If we're talking about the PS2 in particular, most good games have hardly been touched afterwards. Still waiting for the Jak & Daxter and Ace combat remakes. Then again, modern day naughty dog would butcher everything good about the previous Jak games... Probably for the best if it stays gone.
The amount of pearls per item in the Mammago garage is gated so that you never acquire things out of sequence: you could theoretically spend 20 pearls on the flight stabilizer before getting the jump kit, if it was there to buy. You are right on the money, Yahtz; I respect you enough to accept crapping on this golden game. Prey 2017 is my BG&E2. I hope you get your hands on some Twiglets and Jaffa Cakes this year.
I will never forget flying through space, freeing the giant space whale from a big chunk of rock, getting a photo of this majestic whale floating through space, so eager to hear what he had to say about it, only to get the generic "okay, I'll add it to the collection" response. Perhaps for a sequel, they could just finish the first game.
Have i mentioned i love the dogs who've replaced the imps? Because i love them. Especially when they are attached to clip art like the little pupper who looked like he was driving a disembodied pair of legs doing the can can.
Always enjoyed Yahtzee’s reviews of older games. It would great to see it become a semi-regular thing on Fully Ramblomatic instead of an intermittent thing like it was on ZP
The music was amazing throughout the game. Visiting the garage, and that funky song kicks in. You just want to stay, goof around, or talk to the bros. The different environments, from the island, to cities. It felt surreal, with the music adding a vibe to everything
Ollayoooolay, Ollayoooolay, bumbadinkabankasha, Ollayoooolay, Ollayoooolay, bumbadinkabankasha That's how i remember that first racing track going. I want MORE of that. If Christophe Héral is still alive, i hope he may one day compose a new such soundtrack. And that other composers will be able to make similar cool stuff.
As someone who lives in the Bay Area and takes the public transport from time to time, I felt that reference. So hard. It's as if they think everyone on the trains/buses are deaf or hard of hearing.
I really liked how things were often not just what they appeared to be at first. The photography is introduced as just getting animal pics for rewards, but then it's already a skill you have when you're asked to be a spy. The racing is fun racing, sure, but it also serves as a secret route into a locked facility. Very enjoyable all throughout.
"The point is not to force users to go down one route or another," he explains. "We offer purchase, we offer subscription, and it's the gamer's preference that is important here. We are seeing some people who buy choosing to subscribe now, but it all works." Is there any rage bait capital G gamers won't go for?
Oh man, that hurt my nostalgic heart. Still a great watch though! I can't wait for him to dive into more of my favorite games from my childhood to dissect and analyze their true quality so I can be reminded of the good old days of video games and why I dont smile outside of someone telling me a joke anymore.
I enjoyed playing it back then on PS2. I also replayed it some years ago on PC and personally I thought it still held up pretty well. Though I do agree a good way to describe the game is "full of untapped potential".
Seeing this in my recommendations felt like Christmas came back for 10 minutes because it forgot it's car keys. I remember getting every single pearl in this game before finally beating it, and I still get a warm feeling when I hear the title screen theme.
One interesting (to me, at least) thing about the game is the original title was supposed to be Between Good and Evil (because that's the choice Jade has to make). It got changed for unknown reasons.
I really loved that game. It's up there with Psychonauts as one of the ones that made the PS2/GC era the glorious time it was. My first playthrough fell victim to the infamous "lost partner" glitch and I had to start over, something that would be an absolute deal breaker for me these days. But at the time I'd never seen a game quite like it and I remember it very fondly. That probably means I shouldn't risk playing it again. 🤣
FINALLY! I've been waiting for you to retro review this great for 17 years now. You've referred to it so many times in other reviews, including your very first review for The Darkness. Glad to see it happened in my lifetime. One of my favorite games of all time.
Went back and played this a couple years ago for the first time, and honestly without the nostalgia I still thought this game was pretty excellent. Janky at times but there were very few points where I wasn't having fun with it.
This was one of those games that existed in the back of my mind as something I wasn't sure was a fever dream or not, thank you for injecting it back into my consciousness.
I started replaying BG&E a few years ago for nostalgia’s sake and reached the same conclusion. We likely hold so much nostalgia for it because there’s so much room for your imagination to flourish and wonder about why some things are what they are, how things work, who people are, and the game never gives you any of it.
I adored this game as a young teen, super surprised to see it pop up today! On a side note, genuinely lol'd at a few moments in Jack's Second Wind merch ad. You guys and gals rock.
All my Christmases came at once it seems! Been waiting for this one a while (drunken stupor email pestering notwithstanding). Still really glad to hear your take on this one, and almost suprised to agree with most of the points you made. As usual amazing job Yahtzee and looking forward to your review of BGE 2 in 2045(not confirmed).
I remember starting Beyond Good & Evil on a Gamecube like 10 years after the game had come out, and then I just stopped playing and never went back to.
YES!!! I've just redownloaded and completed beyond good and evil HD for the xbox 360 (I played the original on the OG xbox too) and never finished it as I never worked out how to kill the priest at the end as the controls flipped in the boss battle. I started the year off by downloading and hundred percent-ing the game at the age of 26 and 20 years after I originally played it! It's an absolute gem. The even better news is that a remake is due early this year too!
I got frustrated with the last boss and just looked up the fight on RU-vid to memorise the attacks he gives you when the inputs are reversed. I was just done with the fight by then.
i somewhat recently (less than two years) tried replaying beyond good and evil -- a game i loved so much in high school i gifted it to greater than or equal to two friends -- and i softlocked one of the times flying the hovercraft after the looters who take your monies. one time as a kid i got extra credit in spanish class playing it in spanish
1:50 having grown up watching Le Manège Enchanté you successfully instantly put that song in my head. Damn you Yahtzee! Tournicoti Tournicoton Tournicoti Tournicoton
DO YOU KNOW HOW LONG AND HARD I'VE TRIED TO FORGET THAT INTRO SONG! Damnit Yahtzee for reminding me about the Magic Roundabout. Now that song is stuck in my head. Curse you!
This flew under my radar when it first released, but I got the HD release around a year ago through the Microsoft store (it's backwards compatible). Great thing is that you can custom remap the controller through the Xbox Series settings so you can just reverse the vertical look without the horizontal. I can see why its charm aged so well. I'm not confident a sequal created now could replicate that. But with Psychonauts 2 recapturing its predecessor's flavor, maybe there is hope.
I found a copy of that game and a gamers guidebook about it which so far the intro alone has more intrigue than most modern games since it gets to the point without breaking pace.
No one will deny that he was a poetical and suggestive thinker; but he was quite the reverse of strong. He was not at all bold. He never put his own meaning before himself in bald abstract words: as did Aristotle and Calvin, and even Karl Marx, the hard, fearless men of thought. Nietzsche always escaped a question by a physical metaphor, like a cheery minor poet. He said, "beyond good and evil," because he had not the courage to say, "more good than good and evil," or, "more evil than good and evil." Had he faced his thought without metaphors, he would have seen that it was nonsense. So, when he describes his hero, he does not dare to say, "the purer man," or "the happier man," or "the sadder man," for all these are ideas; and ideas are alarming. He says "the upper man," or "over man," a physical metaphor from acrobats or alpine climbers. Nietzsche is truly a very timid thinker. He does not really know in the least what sort of man he wants evolution to produce Gk Chesterton
His choice for an image of a time machine reminds me quite a bit of this old book I had as a kid called The Great Kettles. Illustrations were amazing, and it had a time machine that looked suspiciously similar, or at least a derivative of the same design.
