Bill Browder: No oxygen left for any type of dissent against Putin in Russia

Подписаться 7 млн

Просмотров 51 тыс.

50% 1

Last year, pro-democracy opposition member Vladimir Kara-Murza returned to Russia after being very vocal about his disapproval of Vladimir Putin. At that time, he told Ali Velshi he needed to go back to be with his people even if it resulted in personal danger as the “price of freedom.” He was arrested the next day and has since been sentenced to 25 years in prison for speaking out against the Putin regime. Author and Head of the Global Magnitsky Justice Campaign, Bill Browder tells Velshi that his friend and colleague Kara-Murza will likely die in prison. "The person in charge of the prison where [Sergei Magnitsky] was tortured, is now in charge of where Vladimir Kara-Murza is being kept. The person who Kara-Murza would've gotten sanctioned is now in charge of his torture in prison,” says Browder. Kara-Murza “will be a symbol for everything that is not Putin, everything Russia should be instead of what it is right now.”
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersRU-vid
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#Velshi #Putin #Ukraine

Опубликовано:

21 апр 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 269

@Laura-LaFauve Год назад

The heartbreaks of friends. The tears of family. The sacrifices of normal people who become heroes. In sadness and hope and the world continues. It's up to us humans to watch, and to not forget.

@kevinjenner9502 Год назад

Illegal wars, occupations, regime change, and proxy wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen.

@classifieddementiatalibani9619 Год назад

Laura, Don't worry because Biden will continue moving so slowly that Russia 🇷🇺 will win after Ukraine 🇺🇦 has no men left to fight!!!😊

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@classifieddementiatalibani9619 aww, you are scared of putin's draft, aren't you? you should be, future 300. lets send more himars to ukraine🎉

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@kevinjenner9502putin is also doing some crap in chad and central africa, ya know, vlad. he has been instrumental in destabilizing all of the places you mention.

@classifieddementiatalibani9619 Год назад

@@ghostlogan Are you making fun of yourself?? I already told you the way it is and you had to change the subject!!!😊

@jtempleton1465 Год назад

These men are heroes! What a tremendous sacrifice Mr. Kara-Murza is making for the "price of freedom". Thank you, Mr. Browder for your excellent work! 🙏

@maximeprometheas Год назад

I remember watching those interviews with Vladimir Kara-Murza - on MSNBC as well as some other channels - when he talked about how sometimes you need to go back and face the people who want to silence you. So it was difficult for me to believe when news came out when he was arrested after he voluntarily went back to Russia.

@Babyluthi Год назад

Same with Navaldi. I really wish they didn't go back. They could have done so much more from the outside compared with the situation they are both in now.

@luckyluke1503 Год назад

No, he just thought just because he was working for CIA than Russia would not have arrested him but Russians don’t care about that and if you are a traitor than you will be going to jail and it doesn’t matter who you are or who you work for.

@e-spy Год назад

@@Babyluthi saying that just negates everything these two gentlemen knew to be true. With Russia, it is in your face, or nothing is done. And even with that? So friggin' little. But we see what has happened with Putin being charged with crimes against humanity as well as war crimes, and yet not only still free, but his government in the UN Council is president! If nothing else, these two gentlemen have exposed the hypocrisy of the "free" world. I pray for the release of these two men and others. And I pray for justice in the world. Sadly, all I can do is pray.

@maximeprometheas Год назад

@@Babyluthi Fully agree. There's way too much romanticising of the notion of "martyrdom", of "dying for the cause", of becoming political prisoners. It's time that more people like Kara-Murza and Navalni live for the cause. Prisons in Russia aren't Birmingham jails or Robben Island Prison; they're not gonna be able to write letters that change the outside; they're not going to get dignitary visitors of the highest levels to strengthen their cause. In Russian prisons they generally languish and die, just like Putin intends them to. I hope future dissidents keep that in mind before thinking that the braver decision is to submit to authorities, Socrates style. The braver decision is to be a De Gaul and base your fight from outside where you can actually do some real work and change.

@maximeprometheas Год назад

@@Babyluthi Also, just by the by, it's "Navalni"...

@gilbertgamasr.1600 Год назад

A very cool video Ali and Bill.

@jeffbguarino Год назад

They should use someone else than Ali. He is the guy who promulgated so much fake news. The culmination was the "no riot going on here " video, with huge flames in the background. The guy is not a journalist. I remember from our Canadian news before he jumped ship for south of the border. He will say or do anything MSNBC tells him to do and MSNBC is one of the worst networks. MSNBC is above FOX but below CNN for the fake news booby prize.

@MarshaBlackburnTrump.In.A.Wig. Год назад

Trump's little "genius" is getting clowned on the battlefield.

@ID30394 Год назад

Seven to one ratio in deaths.

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@ID30394 russia is doing worse than that at this point

@shane5898 Год назад

@gregoryvadnais4284 7 to 1 and Russia still can't take Bakmut after 9 months of trying. That's even more pathetic

@jimperkins6073 Год назад

Stop lying in public

@telebubba5527 Год назад

@@jimperkins6073 You have problems with the truth, just like Putin?

@davidgregory5716 Год назад

Trump-GOP goal. Crush freedom.

@sandiharris5906 Год назад

silly

@archieclement2977 Год назад

Freedom? We don't even get to pick our own president. Saddam Hussain had more valid elections than we do.

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@sandiharris5906cowardly filthy russian

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@archieclement2977russians abduct Ukrainian children for p€d0 putin

@jimperkins6073 Год назад

Good, freedom is over rated.

@Joseph-zd2ru Год назад

NYC Mayor Adams said his city is a sanctuary and will accept all asylum seekers. Says come to New York City.

@Norman.638 Год назад

I rather have Brandon than putin and his puppet in the white house.

@b.t.2795 Год назад

Trump loved being Putin's first lady. 💓

@Ted.Fart.Nugentt5656 Год назад

I like this new Winston Smith.😂

@ID30394 Год назад

Got out of a brain trauma unit three years ago. Thank goodness I can still see through some of the MIC propaganda. Keep money laundering to cannonfodder Ukrainian citizens.

@DarthSailorMoo Год назад

I like this new Winston. The other one was boring with believing in fairy tale fantasies.

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@ID30394 aww, butthurt russian troll? my favorite❤ you won't be 300 soon enough🎉

@danieljames1852 Год назад

Pick your battles as a lawyer friend once said.. some are not winnable! And she never lost a case 😉

@kevinjenner9502 Год назад

US invasion of Iraq declared illegal by UN Secretary General Kofi Annan on 9/15/2004

@RUTHLESSambition5 Год назад

He will be forgotten about in a week😆😆 The things people do for clout. 75% of the world hasn't sanctioned Russia. The world is rooting for Russia against the west. I know I'm rooting for them

@henryhudson1297 Год назад

Irrelevant.

@tomsmith5488 Год назад

@Affluent BIG Slime you are probably a russian troll

@suehowie152 Год назад

Brave men..

@tatianalong4085 Год назад

Red Notice and Freezing Order are great books by Browder that show the real nature of the regime.

@paulanderson7796 Год назад

Don't fall for that. Browder is not to be trusted.

@ragingmonk6080 Год назад

This was ignorance on his part. He should have used his contacts from abroad to mount a movement that would meet him at the airport when he arrived. Stepping off the plane as one man is just suicide.

@tolrem Год назад

Kara-Murza bears a striking similarity to Lenin IMO.

@matsfrommusic Год назад

The world does not do enough.

@anitaarnell3274 Год назад

I am so sad that he went back to Russia and the Dictator Mr. Putin. It is amazing how words can be so frightening. Pse let us know if there’s possibilities to write were he is held/ adress to prisson?

@tomsmith5488 Год назад

I agree. Tragic for his family, but i suppose they discussed it, and they are prepared to pay such a high price. Very sad.

@prof.scheere6933 Год назад

Putin made Vladimir Kara-Murza's name live for ever

@IAm-NotHear Год назад

BB's book Red Notice - gripping

@ziziroberts8041 Год назад

India headed in the same direction? Please discuss this. Thank you.

@jeffbguarino Год назад

The only problem with these guys going to prison to make a point is that the Russian public doesn't even know they are in prison. If it were me I would have stayed in Germany and UK. Do your work from outside of Russia and it would make more of an impact.

@travkin8842 Год назад

Российская "общественность" жалеет что у нас мораторий на смертную казнь.....

@jeffbguarino Год назад

@@travkin8842 Я думаю, что мораторий тоже надо снять, чтобы Путина повесили, после того, как прихватят малютку. А еще лучше, он, вероятно, будет тащиться за грузовиком до конца года.

@francisponz2109 Год назад

Question: is Russia doing to detractors the same that USA does or is Assange different?

@williamwells1862 Год назад

What a story.

@angeline12345 Год назад

❤

@dianehartung5954 Год назад

Get this man out........

@mrkiplingreallywasanexceed8311 Год назад

Whilst shameless plugs normally leave me feeling rather bilious, my enormous respect for Bill Browder easily prevails - along with the understanding that if he were not personally rich and powerful, he would not have been able to advance to such a great extent, his noble causes such as the Magnitsky Act - and indeed his current ruffling of Russian feathers regarding both the Wall Street journalist recently detained and the subject of this interview. Asides from which, one imagines the royalties from the books are minimal compared to his main activities so again, I feel this time the publicity is fully justified....

@michaellynnblockermutt946 Год назад

I honestly haven't gotten my money or my bmw

@ericlovelace6502 Год назад

So when are they giving Julian Assange a release date?

@ghostlogan Год назад

nobody cares he's a spy and one of putin's useful idiots

@ericlovelace6502 Год назад

@@ghostlogan Lol. What like this guy that you and Browder are currently crying over. Your own cia boy is getting the Assange treatment Russian-style and you don't like it. Total hypocrites.

@droughttolerant9334 Год назад

Putin had invoked Mr Browder’s name in response to a question from a US reporter, who’d asked whether he’d consider allowing 12 Russians who’d been indicted for interfering in the 2016 US election to be extradited to America for trial. He said he’d allow the 12 Russians - all military intelligence officers - to be questioned by US officials if he could have his own people question Mr Browder in kind

@vwwaa Год назад

Assa is victim of free press of which they promote

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@droughttolerant9334 spam elsewhere, vlad YT is American

@tabithan2978 Год назад

Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya is doing more for Belarus from exile than from prison. Navalny and Kara-Murza were foolish to go back. They will probably die in prison like Magnitsky.

@paulanderson7796 Год назад

World class Putin bashing. Well done Browdercunt.

@radwulfeboraci7504 Год назад

That's cuz Putin hasn't run out of 10th-floor windows yet.

@LuciferMornStar Год назад

I remember watching him say why he was going home! Told my neighbor that he would be Navalney cell mate. And only way they would ever see daylight again is if putin was terminated! And maybe not then!

@deepakgeorge5871 Год назад

Wise men think do not take stupid decisions.. Did this individual think he will be welcome and get red carpet experience.. Vain sacrifice.. be real.. unfortunately this individual is doing disservice to democratic fight in Russia..

@leninha5549 Год назад

I would like to know if this book also is available in the russian language... I really think, that a russian friend of mine need to read that book about Russia URGENTLY .. while he is STILL!! a putin fan (unbelievable but true..!)

@ziziroberts8041 Год назад

Are you saying that Putin is a dictator? 🙄

@jaygibson5057 Год назад

Douglass Mackey

@daveharvey5764 Год назад

I love the reporting out of America. Absolutely no idea but gonna say it anyways.

@Brandonsniffskids Год назад

It’s just leftist propaganda

@ghostlogan Год назад

sure, brokeback vlad better get ready for that money shot😂 we have a kamikaze drone for you❤ mwah🎉

@selah71 Год назад

So, Dave, how do you get your reporting? From homing pigeons, smoke signals, and banging drums? But, hey, thank you for commenting on this channel. It helps the algorithm. Every. Single. Time. 😘✌️

@vwwaa Год назад

What do expect from CNN, NBC, msbc one side story. Russian is loosing the war. America can win this. You economy will go done. Wake up. Proxy war is difficult. You are just feeding Ukraine. As long as you feed them they are happy. you will go down with them.

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@vwwaa I see you hail from the 4th world RF. how's borat?😂 learn english, vanya.

@eltinmccarthy2469 Год назад

All Russian police and the Judiciary involved in breeching Russian peoples rights to protest will be swapping places with these innocent people rotting in jail. That message needs to be clearly sent out.

@Joseph-zd2ru Год назад

NYC Mayor Adams said he now understands how a Texas town of 36,000 was devastated by 35,000 illegals in a week.

@williamwells1862 Год назад

Take exhile.

@dt8762 Год назад

Joe is a fill in for Joe.

@RaNiaNameste Год назад

If 45 gets back in office again, this is where our nation will be not long from now. He has said it himself repeatedly.

@AlbertInSanAntonio Год назад

Ohhh nooo how terrifying 😮 ..

@waggsish Год назад

Give up that fantasy, not happening.

@paulanderson7796 Год назад

Browdertard. Browderpuppet.

@ericlovelace6502 Год назад

At least he's got his release date - unlike Julian Assange who is locked up forever. So much for the free West. Lol.

@eliyasalisho348 Год назад

🤔

@darploin5071 Год назад

Is there anyway we can start a civil war cause of the collapse in maybe armed Russian dissidents with heavy duty weapons.

@anthonyhousley8040 5 месяцев назад

Shouldn't have thought it was a good idea to go to war with him woth my money should have júst paid me 😈😂🖕🏻

@vwwaa Год назад

Mandela, king please don't compare him to great men. You just bitter.

@pikayell Год назад

Putin needs to be terminated.

@jimperkins6073 Год назад

Nope

@telebubba5527 Год назад

@@jimperkins6073 Yep!

@wileycoyotegenius1 Год назад

Hahahaaa! Democratic my foot.

@Brandonsniffskids Год назад

Msnbc: slob on Ukraine 😂😂😂😂

@paulkern7229 Год назад

oh, Boris...

@BIBIWCICC Год назад

How can we criticise Russian courts when the UK courts still have a reporter of war crimes in jail?

@telebubba5527 Год назад

Assange is a war crime, not a reporter, but a traitor. Therefore he belongs in jail and we can freely discuss Russian courts as we please.

@AlbertInSanAntonio Год назад

@@telebubba5527 when telling the truth becomes a crime and lying makes you a hero .. you are sick sick man !

@Brandonsniffskids Год назад

Welcome to Joe Biden’s America folks😂😂😂

@ghostlogan Год назад

I ❤ my country. seethe more, vlad. you'll never be accepted in russia🌈

@voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 Год назад

Read freezing order by bill browder so you know what's going on.

@sandiharris5906 Год назад

Sure the U.S. is better than Russia, but is it as good as Japan or Switzerland? Plenty of room for doubts

@ghostlogan Год назад

svetlana, your sberbank account will never have a ruble ❤ disgusting russians

@telebubba5527 Год назад

Well at least it's not at the bottom of the list.

@hisomebodytrackingmuch1309 Год назад

Praying for this beautiful freedom fighter

@saml8967 Год назад

😴

@jackkozlowski5201 Год назад

The anchors always have to sell the guests book. Is this a new broadcast or an infomercial? They might as well say... "with the purchase of a novel You get a free coffee travel mug."

@stellangios Год назад

They're good, relevant books though and they came out a while ago so it's not like it's a promotional tour, the mention is more of a courtesy and credential, as well as info on where you can read more on the subject being discussed. Also we still have libraries so it's not like you have to buy them

@hmmcinerney Год назад

I got Freezing Order from the library riveting book.

@alanakafang6143 Год назад

How do you think they get paid to lie and read out their scripted BS?

@hmmcinerney Год назад

@@alanakafang6143 Oh dear, someone sounds bitter and twisted

@alanakafang6143 Год назад

@@hmmcinerney hardly buddy, just stated an obvious fact. Obviously it touched a nerve to prompt your baseless response.

@letsgorandall9848 Год назад

Who cares

@ghostlogan Год назад

lets send more himars to ukraine🎉

@petrtiler645 Год назад

Lajf self fax imejl nikdy no tiler petr Jonovy 😢

@droughttolerant9334 Год назад

Putin wants his back taxes bill.

@droughttolerant9334 Год назад

Isnt Brower still a wanted man in russia?

@ghostlogan Год назад

nah but there is an ICC warrant out for Putin😂

@droughttolerant9334 Год назад

@@ghostlogantrump was considering trading the dude for 12 Russians indited for interference in the 2016 election. No wonder dude is scared of Trump. Dude owes huge taxes to Russia.

@ghostlogan Год назад

@@droughttolerant9334 we took out Putin's TR45H Browder owes you people nothing. its amazing he was able to get back all of the money you russians stole from his company, heritage investments, was it? nah vlad, I am pro Browder. he tried to help your country become a democracy and enter the free market. enjoy being the new north korea❤

@ghostlogan Год назад

filthy russian cowards are despicable.

@irresistablejewel Год назад

The Russian government confiscated around $230 Million from Browder (claiming his hedge fund didn't pay tax on $1.5 Billion); he employed a Russian lawyer, who later died in prison. A better description might be that Russia doesn't want him. He has a sentence of 9 years if he returns to Russia. It should be mentioned that amassing that amount of money in Russia (early 90's) strongly suggests corruption of some sort; the Russian oligarchs had connections to government and mafia and were allowed to leave (if they didn't get into politics) but Browder isn't Russian. While he takes the lawyers name for "The Magnitsky Act" (2016), used to sanction Russian individuals (which doesn't really) work, I would say he hung his lawyer out to dry. There are other matters surrounding this man that cast doubt on him being an honest broker; but after changing nationality he is saying what some American politicians clearly and dearly want to hear; his story sells books, but Germany and Russia (& I) don't accept his version of events. To amass assets of $4.5 Billion in a country like Russia (1990's) where $200/month is a good wage; is indeed remarkable. He reminds me of Frank Abagnale. Best avoided!

@andrewjacobson556 Год назад

These brave courageous men can't do anything behind bars, they can't expand there movement or be a voice for there people!! Reconsider returning to Russia!!!!

@AlbertInSanAntonio Год назад

Yes glory to Russia 🇷🇺💪 Glory to the motherland

@AlbertInSanAntonio Год назад

Yes glory to Russia 🇷🇺💪 Glory to the motherland

@cruisemissile2873 Год назад

Putin better than Biden

@LeftIsFascist Год назад

Its that way for Ukraine here in America

@ghostlogan Год назад

lets send more himars to ukraine🎉

@archieclement2977 Год назад

Russia is at war. Why should they brook attempts to undermine their efforts by people who are giving aid and comfort to their enemies?

@robertbirch5676 Год назад

Brandon is losing his war

@shane5898 Год назад

Is he though? Trump called Putin a genius and Putin and his "mighty" army have been getting clowned in Ukraine. Biden spent just 5% of our annual military budget and 0 US troops to help cripple Russia. Looks like Biden won this one.

@voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 Год назад

Brandon's your sock puppet?

@enochcushite496 Год назад

Lol And there is room for deceit in America? Really? Trump Jan 6th, Black Nationalist They are free? Really?

@AlbertInSanAntonio Год назад

I am shocked to see how misinformed all of your viewers are .. but then I realize this station is nothing more than state run media and now it makes sense