Тёмный

Biology Is for BIGOTS? w/  

Peter Boghossian
Подписаться 204 тыс.
Просмотров 234 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 4 тыс.   
@blackmacs1748
@blackmacs1748 Год назад
Every time Peter does these he inadvertently shows that very few people paid any attention in science classes.
@stvbrsn
@stvbrsn Год назад
And in phys. ed. classes, for that matter.
@southhedge73
@southhedge73 Год назад
Sorry from Australia Peter. Victoria is the home of some of the silliest and nastiest people in Australia. I hope you enjoyed your time here.
@carolynbrightfield8911
@carolynbrightfield8911 Год назад
​@@southhedge73yes, it's totally "off" now. And my 30 years of science teaching feels like it went down the gurgler. What happened to science is about facts, debating new ideas, open discussion and rational thought etc 😢
@xanderytube
@xanderytube Год назад
male loses penis in accident, now he is intersex 🤡
@southhedge73
@southhedge73 Год назад
@@carolynbrightfield8911 This way of 'thinking' conducted by some of these people is obviously anti intellectual but I think it is also anti hierarchical. I once had a guy I knew tell me that his opinion (based off the reading of a magazine article) of a subject was equal to and just as valid as the opinion of someone who had studied that subject for several years. 😐
@johnnybgoode2484
@johnnybgoode2484 Год назад
Sex is not "assigned" at birth. It is simply "observed" or "noted" at birth. If gender is fluid, but biological sex is fixed by nature, why must biological sex be transformed unnaturally to mimic the opposite sex when one's gender identity doesn't match one's biological sex. It seems to make more sense to simply ask society to accept those biological males who are more effeminate than others and those biological females who are more masculine than others. Regarding those who say they "feel like" the gender that is opposite their biological sex, I don't know how this is even possible. In reality, none of us actually know what anyone outside of our own body feels, let alone what those in bodies of the opposite biological sex feels. I know what it feels like to be me, but I can't honestly say that all other biological males experience life as I do. I know that women are different than men, but I've never experienced life as a woman, so I don't know how I would possibly have a clue about how "being a woman" feels. It's nothing more than conjecture, really. And it's unlikely there will ever be a way to change one's chromosomes or DNA. If one puts Ferrari rims on a Chevy, it's still a Chevy. One cannot change their sex. Period. End of story.
@DiogenesNephew
@DiogenesNephew Год назад
You've summed my exact thoughts on this as well. Well done; that was very clear!
@purplemonkey649
@purplemonkey649 Год назад
If genitals don't define sex... Then how does altering them affirm it. -internet meme.
@paulmaloney2383
@paulmaloney2383 Год назад
Your common sense and logical reasoning make sense to most of us but for the select few that experience gender dysphoria they are unable to grasp the reality of their biological sex. Biological sex is one of the most binary things there is in nature, everything else is a continuum. No matter how strong the desire to have the genitals and secondary sexual characteristics of another gender, no amount of self-claiming, hormonal injections or any amount surgery will ever change your fix biological sex.
@johnnybgoode2484
@johnnybgoode2484 Год назад
@@paulmaloney2383 Well-stated. That doctors are so willingly transitioning children will, most certainly, go down in history as one of America's worst crimes.
@Apriluser
@Apriluser Год назад
Actually sex is manifest BEFORE birth and confirmed at birth. It just doesn’t happen at birth. It can be observed with ultra sound.
@ZakJames
@ZakJames Год назад
I do get frustrated when people claim men and women could compete fairly in sports without sex based categories.
@loganmiller4863
@loganmiller4863 Год назад
As do I unless They're talking about archery, darts, shooting, crokinole, or some other skill based competition. But running, jumping, swimming, judo, karate, MMA, cycling? Just no. unfair. Just make an open division for trans people to compete in. Done, fair.
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
Yep. Example: Why can't a female compete against male motocross riders? Because even if she could handle a motorcyle like Jeremy McGrath, it would absolutely destroy her pelvic floor and possibly cause a uterine prolapse. We are different not only outside, but inside.
@Queque2524
@Queque2524 Год назад
@@loganmiller4863 Men do have an advantage in archery due to their upper body strength. I had to look up crokinole.
@murderparker7968
@murderparker7968 Год назад
@@loganmiller4863I believe men even have a competitive edge in some of those “skill based” sports you mentioned. In archery, for example, men consistently score higher than women in competition, but I don’t know the biological reasons for this.
@elizabethwalker7756
@elizabethwalker7756 Год назад
I suspect that any woman who says this has no interest in competitive sports and doesn't see why any woman would. She's prepared to sacrifice what is hugely important to some women simply because she wants to look virtuous. She's also extremely naive if she thinks no man who claims to be a woman is any danger to women.
@hrmIwonder
@hrmIwonder 11 месяцев назад
Just because a male might say they feel like a woman, how do they actually know what it feels like to be a woman?
@Pilcrow23
@Pilcrow23 8 месяцев назад
I'd go one further and say that you can't even know what it is to be any other man. You only have your experience of manhood and you have no way of comparing it with others' experiences. Therefore we should dispense entirely with the argument that feelings mean anything substantive and focus on the real world of biology.
@SlimZany
@SlimZany 8 месяцев назад
They dont. They will never know what it feels like to have excruciating cramps from 11 years old or younger and bleed from a vagina. Then they will never know what it feels like to get pregnant. Period. These Woman are a disgrace to all Women. Disgusts me the brainwashing. Which this type of confusion has destroyed civilizations. History repeats.
@zeenuf00
@zeenuf00 7 месяцев назад
They can't
@ivandankob7112
@ivandankob7112 7 месяцев назад
They want to wear a dress and receive free favors 😂
@danielstruve
@danielstruve 6 месяцев назад
Everything about males and females is different. Our sex organs of course but also our skeletons, our musculature, tendons and ligaments, our brains function differently, our emotions are predictably different. You cannot “feel” like a woman unless you are. You may have a fetish about having a vagina or wearing women’s clothes but you can’t possibly “feel” like a woman unless you are female. That said, it should be a persons choice to wear clothes typically associated with women or makeup or whatever else you feel like donning but you are the sex you are and there is no changing that. You can be whatever type of male you want to be or whatever type of female you want to be but you are in fact that sex and you can’t change it.
@alyssabrugman8479
@alyssabrugman8479 Год назад
Peter, could you start asking people how long they have had these opinions? Because I'm sure these grown adults did not have these beliefs even 5 years ago.
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
Excellent point!
@Bufekana
@Bufekana Год назад
THIS!👍
@gtugland
@gtugland Год назад
My guess is that many would just insist that their opinion on this never changed. But it would be interesting to hear the answers.
@pmcommando
@pmcommando Год назад
Tik tok probably
@Bufekana
@Bufekana Год назад
@@Cancionera40 were you asleep?
@tomcotter4299
@tomcotter4299 Год назад
I love when they’re like: “I agree with this thing that completely obliterates my position, but I still hold my position.”
@OmnipotentJC
@OmnipotentJC Год назад
Lol. Yeah that sums up most of these conversations Peter has with people. It's obvious most people don't work through the logic of their positions until someone else does it for them.
@tomcotter4299
@tomcotter4299 Год назад
@@OmnipotentJC Yeah. In light of all the evidence showing that people do not use rationality to form their values, it’s kind of weird that people in the rationalist community continue advocating for a rationalist approach to politics. Seems to be the rational thing to do would be to accept that most people are by and large irrational in this area of their lives, and to use a more emotional approach to achieve our goals.
@jeffcapes
@jeffcapes Год назад
I think they mostly post rationalise things to fit whatever evidence they like, but its rarely the true reason they hold the beleif to start with, I think it mostly comes from a moral position, "being compassionate to trans people is what good people do, and I want to be a good person", anything that disagrees with that gets thrown by the wayside
@tomcotter4299
@tomcotter4299 Год назад
@@jeffcapes There’s overwhelming evidence that shows this to be the case. That’s why I personally believe reason is a good way of persuading people, but emotional appeals are better.
@marieparker3822
@marieparker3822 Год назад
And these people have a vote.
@shannonochoa7413
@shannonochoa7413 Год назад
The mental gymnastics being performed in the name of tolerance is absolutely mind-numbing. 🤡🌎🤦‍♀️
@imperfectious
@imperfectious Год назад
Changes my position on neuroplasticity for sure.
@fellapal
@fellapal Год назад
Its a merry-go-round of nosence
@justasimpleguy7211
@justasimpleguy7211 Год назад
@@imperfectious Neuroplasticity works in both directions, for the positive and the negative.
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
It's scary how mindlessly they recite the Newspeak nonsense 🤦🏾‍♀️😨
@zacharylane817
@zacharylane817 Год назад
this is a beautiful and perfect way to put it.
@lilyvonshtuup
@lilyvonshtuup Год назад
Watching these 4 adults grapple with understanding and making sense of these questions leads me to the conclusion that this is not a question or decision that we should be giving to children. If adults can’t understand it how on earth do we expect children to. This is a very dangerous experiment that can only lead to mind bending confusion.
@tonyhoffman3309
@tonyhoffman3309 5 месяцев назад
Perhaps "confusion" of children is the goal,
@AndthenthereisCencorship-xc6yi
@AndthenthereisCencorship-xc6yi 4 месяца назад
Very good point!
@jason192
@jason192 26 дней назад
They expect children to be groomed and indoctrinated like they claim the traditional role children are placed. They think that its okay to progressively teach children to become what they aren’t meant to be. That’s how they expect children to understand. Like ABC’s and 123’s. The human mind isnt fully developed until around age 25 so thats plenty of time to mold our nations youth into a nightmare.
@humblemonkm61
@humblemonkm61 26 дней назад
@@lilyvonshtuup that's the problem, children believe what adults tell them, they don't know any better because they haven't had enough life experience to gain a sufficient knowledge base to question what they're being told & if the adult is someone the child admires like a TV celebrity/movie star, online influencer, a trusted caregiver like a parent, teacher, therapist, or doctor they tend to believe these adults. Kids believe Santa & the Easter Bunny is real. Children live in fantasy & have no issues accepting & believing they are dragons, dogs, cats, firefighters, astronauts, boys, girls, the list is endless. This is why pushing this delusional gender ideology onto young minds is criminal. It's taking advantage of their innocence & naivety.
@Dan_Capone
@Dan_Capone Год назад
It amazes me how quickly this pervasive idea that sex is "assigned" at birth has developed. It's like it appeared overnight and every person under a certain age just accepts it as an incontrovertible fact now.
@justasimpleguy7211
@justasimpleguy7211 Год назад
Mind-numbed robots waiting for the next narrative to gobble up and regurgitate ad nauseam.
@margaretcadogan5199
@margaretcadogan5199 Год назад
Because it is pushed down from the top,.systemically. these are mostly normal people trying to conform to what is taught as best practice. Their confusion and discomfort are the goal. How far can we be pushed to assert what we know is not true?
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
Ikr, all the astroturfed linguistic vandalism is like this -- nonsensical, and it has spread insanely rapidly.
@kamwalker6296
@kamwalker6296 Год назад
So easy to reprogram an NPC with BS these days...
@k3630
@k3630 Год назад
Its like a mind virus
@moonlightray8493
@moonlightray8493 Год назад
It continues to amaze me how many people are completely oblivious to the biological definition of sex as a reproductive role. It's not determined by secondary characteristics like chromosomes or genetalia; sex is determined by an organism's potential to produce either large, immobile gametes (eggs) or small, mobile gametes (sperm). The former individuals are - by definition - female, and the latter are - by definition - male. And unless there is some highly advanced gene editing method that I'm unaware of, there is *no* possible way to change one's sex and start producing the opposite gamete type. As Helen Joyce once put it, it's not just the breasts and vagina and estrogen that makes her a female... *every single cell* of her body carries that reproductive role.
@ruthtodd6022
@ruthtodd6022 Год назад
And the hole they fashion is for penetration only, reducing the vagina to something that simply provides pleasure for others...it's unbelievably offensive.
@lellamas2778
@lellamas2778 Год назад
Boggled my mind. Has basic science class content been altered??? Maybe this is the root cause of the COMPLETE IDIOCY and confusion these people are spouting. They did alter the definition of "vaccine" to include "gene therapy" in 2020. Just goes to show ANYTHING can be changed and you won't even realise till the next generation is talking bullshit in the streets
@Yurkevich22
@Yurkevich22 Год назад
how is this different from chromosomes? Would it be incorrect to say that only a person with XX chromosomes has the potential to produce large, immobile gametes (eggs) ?
@laurenedson7625
@laurenedson7625 Год назад
Do you think they are truly ignorant or consciously lying? Many liberals seem to believe a lie that feels morally virtuous has more value than truth.
@xEvilRaptorx
@xEvilRaptorx Год назад
I was under the impression that sperm is just produced by the testies and eggs are from the ovary. I suppose I never gave the time to think about if it were possible to transplant them into someone else. And if you did transplant it to the opposite sex, would the body know what to do with it?
@faded1to3black
@faded1to3black Год назад
The women were saying some of the most idiotic, reality denial nonsense I've ever heard. Holy crap.
@Winterascent
@Winterascent Год назад
So, women being women?
@scottsherman5262
@scottsherman5262 Год назад
@@Winterascent HIGH FREAKIN' FIVE!!!!!!! COME ON!!!!
@anastasia-fr1gn
@anastasia-fr1gn Год назад
You can tell they’ve never thought deeply about this. It’s just statements they’ve heard. I’m amazed how they don’t realize “gender” is just what liberals of the past used to call “gender roles”. He even briefly mentioned this in the video when he said “sex based stereotypes”. This is what some people call sex based expression. It accounts for people not conforming to gender norms without having to bend reality in a religious belief that we can be born in the wrong bodies therefore must treat a man like a woman and ignore biology.
@LittleMissPyeWacket
@LittleMissPyeWacket Год назад
@@Winterascent Not all women are like this. Try being more insulting.
@Winterascent
@Winterascent Год назад
@@LittleMissPyeWacket "Not all", yet what we see today is exactly the result of women and their behavior. Feelings over reality.
@tidepride86
@tidepride86 11 месяцев назад
Those two women are absolutely terrified when giving an answer to a question that their fellow cult members haven't drilled into them yet. They know if they say one thing that can be even misconstrued as "problematic" they will be heretics and their lives ruined via cancellation or even physically harmed.
@KatMoore-ih6mw
@KatMoore-ih6mw Месяц назад
Exactly, it's just like any other religious group or cult
@stargazerh112
@stargazerh112 Год назад
I can’t stand the term, “assigned at birth”. 🤦‍♂️
@kathymharris2432
@kathymharris2432 Год назад
Yes, I agree. I have heard it described as "ibserved" at birth. This seems more truthful.
@SeaTeaSnow
@SeaTeaSnow Год назад
If anything, it’s “gender identity assigned at birth”. Conceptually, that makes sense to me. The activist types want to focus on sex though, because they want health insurance to pay for sex, reassignment surgery. If the focus were on gender, it has a lot less weight in the healthcare systems.
@stargazerh112
@stargazerh112 Год назад
@@SeaTeaSnow gender identity is made up. It is not assigned at birth. At best you can assert that social constructs play a role in sex/gender stereotypes. This is a far cry from what the gender theory crowd assert.
@geobloxmodels1186
@geobloxmodels1186 Год назад
Agreed. the reason for this term is that trans ideologists picked it so they could push their narrative. Avoid playing on the enemies chosen field of battle. Seriously, all of us fighting this nonsense could stand to reread Art of War.
@davidkennerly
@davidkennerly Год назад
No reasonable, intelligent person can.
@colewilson98
@colewilson98 Год назад
It’s so sad that the young woman has had her notion of what a woman is reduced to if there is a hole between a person’s legs, no matter how it got there
@THXx1138
@THXx1138 Год назад
Women aren't penis-less men.
@khaderlander2429
@khaderlander2429 Год назад
@@THXx1138 sorry brother I'm mourning the death of the definition of women, it got murdered by this pseudo intellectual.
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
I know. It's so disgusting and demeaning. "Bonus hole." It's dehumanizing, like how a serial killer would think.
@dimercamparini
@dimercamparini Год назад
And then they turn back and say "do not objectify me!" :DDDD
@zeenuf00
@zeenuf00 Год назад
​@lovesilk1 a woman is- and can only ever be - an adult human being who was born biologically female. A man can never be a woman - in any way, shape or form.
@ndb232
@ndb232 Год назад
Imagine being this old And still not knowing what a woman is 🙃
@ChollieD
@ChollieD Год назад
Dude has a trans kid that he helped to medicalize, or a dysphoric close friend that he failed to help. There has to be a back-story to generate such anger.
@mrpopo8298
@mrpopo8298 Год назад
There's no fool like an old fool.
@willyboy256
@willyboy256 Год назад
@@mrpopo8298 Actually there is no fool like a fool regardless of age. Old age does not make one a fool.
@Hajrat_ali_imam
@Hajrat_ali_imam Год назад
may be his "birthing parent" was a man , that is why he did not get to know a woman😂
@DJaneSyria
@DJaneSyria Год назад
@@willyboy256you’d expect a bit more sense coming from someone of his age surely?
@turntableable
@turntableable Год назад
The problem is that so many people have never actually thought about it for themselves. That’s why the one lady sounded so confused: because she was trying to explain what she’s been told is “correct” and has never actually thought about whether it actually makes sense or not.
@syloui
@syloui 9 дней назад
That's because people never needed to think about this stuff until institutional activists convinced them that it was possible to change sexes with technology. If they knew what those surgeries actually did they would likely be horrified; but the reality of what they are is too inconceivable to cut through the I inherent disbelief people have when confronted with them. It's a horror that even Lovecraft could not have conceived, and the consequences will be existentially devastating
@leighrevers8397
@leighrevers8397 Год назад
To add to the conversation, I’m a university professor facing dismissal because I once compared a chemical reaction between two inanimate molecules and a non-human hermaphrodite such as an earthworm, and this was taken as insulting to intersex people. It’s hard to comprehend this level of idiocy within our higher educational system.
@ClockworkWyrm
@ClockworkWyrm Год назад
Bloody hell! Good luck with those ridiculous dismissal charges.
@ManicMindTrick
@ManicMindTrick Год назад
In what country is this university?
@stevetennispro
@stevetennispro Год назад
It's my understanding that people with intersex conditions are not true hermaphrodites. (i.e., they are not functionally both female and male.)
@tanchella
@tanchella Год назад
I hope they'll find out in your favour, this is ridiculous!
@josir1994
@josir1994 11 месяцев назад
Hope you can escape hell soon enough
@idkwhattonamethis8593
@idkwhattonamethis8593 Год назад
I really hate how much misinformation has been pumped out on this topic that there are people who actually think, or at least say, that you can change your sex 😒 And what's more concerning is that these people get to vote. I can't have a basic conversation with people who think like this because they are just so misinformed that I have to spend the entire time educating them on basic facts while they stumble through regurgitating the nonsense they heard from some trans activist or in gender/queer studies.
@formulaic78
@formulaic78 Год назад
The way that your average person now thinks that sex is assigned at birth rather than observed, because they've heard the former so many times in recent years but never stopped for a second to think about the meaning of that phrase, is flabbergasting. To the best of my knowledge the phrase sex assigned at birth was coined by John Money when working with intersex patients (because they actually were assigned a sex because they couldn't confirm their sex through observation). That some of those people will then berate you for being transphobic when they don't even understand what transsexualism is is scary.
@SineEyed
@SineEyed Год назад
I kinda think this is the default state humans occupy. Pick anyone out of a crowd, and with the right questions you'll find the bullshit they think is true. And many beliefs are so intertwined with either someone's worldview or their sense of personal identity, that presenting them with facts and logic isn't going to educate them like it would for someone else. That's because they're not taking your information or reasoning onboard to be processed and reflected on as if it was valid. In their conscious reality, truth and bullshit swap places. It's seriously like an acute hyper-local insanity. It can be literally impossible for people to see the truth for what it is, even when perfectly showcased and put right in front of their face. Their brain straight up wont let them see it. This is every human... and we have our evolution to thank for it..😖
@harryricochet8134
@harryricochet8134 Год назад
Indeed, you should try sharing a State with these people who have re-elected Daniel Andrews the criminal tyrant who legislatively imposed teaching this perverted pseudoscientific ideology upon children in our schools as well as enforcing the longest and harshest lockdowns anywhere in the world. This used to be Australia's most conservative state believe it or not. Six months on from the election the State is totally bankrupt, the laughing-stock of the rest of Australia and now the entire British Commonwealth after their totalitarian cult leader cancelled the Commonwealth Games two weeks ago. Sigh of sighs my once beautiful State of Victoria has been utterly destroyed by poisonous wokeness.
@stvbrsn
@stvbrsn Год назад
A minor nitpick to be sure, but don’t fall into the linguistic traps being laid down… there is no such thing as “misinformation.” One can be misinformed, but the word “misinformation” is an invention, just like the term “conspiracy theory” specifically designed to shut down discourse.
@riiidiculoso8697
@riiidiculoso8697 Год назад
@@stvbrsn, the phrase ‘conspiracy theory’, and the word ‘misinformation’, both existed long before they were intentionally imbued with a tone of derisive mockery, in order to discredit believers. Regardless of tone, some conspiracy theories are correct, and misinformation certainly exists - usually spread by those who doth protest it too much.
@babysis6.059
@babysis6.059 Год назад
It's so hard to believe that so many people are this far removed from reality, it's like they make it all up as they go along
@valuedCustomer2929
@valuedCustomer2929 Год назад
And so much of it is based on faith. It is an immitation of religion.
@traviscue2099
@traviscue2099 Год назад
The far left opperates very much religion, they're scared to say what they think since they'll be shunned by the group. They believe it because they're told they have to. Most of the US is removed from reality if you think about how many are religous.
@WaaDoku
@WaaDoku Год назад
@@dansschoolofschool There's no understanding. You really have to be believe in it.
@mahaffer71
@mahaffer71 Год назад
@@dansschoolofschool Which is stereotyping and characterization of a particular sex which is sexist
@matthewgauci7936
@matthewgauci7936 Год назад
In these experiments people definitely choose a line that they arent really sure about and cant back up but spew random tangents to try and prove their point. This for the more outrageous people opting for lines that are the woke answers
@eternity7477
@eternity7477 9 месяцев назад
As a 64 year old woman who were subjected to all the unfair advantage to men, I am astounded that we are expected to give up so much of our wins. Just like that, women sport is back to extreme discrimination. Any fool knows that a man is stronger/faster than a woman physically. All a man now has to do is to say they identify as a woman and they are guaranteed to win with far less effort and talent. Plus they win the financial benefits in prizes. That a young woman would think that is a good move, sickens me. We have lost the plot as humanity. I hope this is a temporary condition. If not, we are screwed.
@hollykappert8200
@hollykappert8200 8 месяцев назад
We as women are losing the ground we gained. It's disgusting our fellow woman are cheering it on.
@mwfmtnman
@mwfmtnman 4 месяца назад
Thank you ladies for.beimg sane.
@user-nj9ru4ef2w
@user-nj9ru4ef2w 3 месяца назад
its so depressing that the only women who are against toxic trans ideology are actually just misandry sexists.
@pinklilyblossom
@pinklilyblossom Месяц назад
Clearly these women have never been athletes.
@KatMoore-ih6mw
@KatMoore-ih6mw Месяц назад
Exactly! Women fought for single sex bathrooms to be added at work because there was so much sexual assault in shared bathrooms, women were just holding it for 12 hours which was physically damaging. Young women these days act like it's no big deal to just let some men back into those spaces, like they've forgotten the suffering of our ancestors 😢
@fintinryan7678
@fintinryan7678 Год назад
I’m shocked how much these women are willing to dumb themselves down on the bases of “be kind”. They know their lying to themselves.
@justmy2cents652
@justmy2cents652 Год назад
Exactly. That girl absolutely knows that her boyfriend could easily overpower her but still denies it to be "kind". It wouldn't even matter to her if all womens sports would collapse. Maybe bc she hadn't done a situp in the last 5 years. 🤔
@fintinryan7678
@fintinryan7678 Год назад
@@justmy2cents652 while their “being kind” biological males are destroying the hopes & dreams (also safety & fairness ) of young girls (biological females) in sports alone. Where I live we have biological males in prison for very very serious crimes with with who didn’t pay their TV license. Sometimes their lick up for 23 hours a day for “their safety” This ideology is a danger to women & children. Especially gender non conforming kids.
@Dan_Capone
@Dan_Capone Год назад
@@justmy2cents652 The problem is that when we talk about "women's sports" we're usually talking about "men's sports done by women" in which men will naturally outperform any woman. In actual women's sports like synchronized swimming there isn't even a men's category in the Olympics and I don't see anyone crying about it because men are clearly inferior at it. I tend to think that getting rid of sex categories in professional sports would actually improve women's sports and new ones would emerge.
@ollie6502
@ollie6502 Год назад
Not just kind. If you're caught on video saying "transphobic things"...
@justmy2cents652
@justmy2cents652 Год назад
@@Dan_Capone I'm guessing every woman who is active in sports which you would call "men's sports" would disagree. And I think it is misogynistic nonsense to limit women to activities like gymnastics and synchronized swimming. Why is it so hard to accept/understand that in some spaces it is just a nobrainer to seperate via sex? Now we should forbid women to do certain sports bc men have an advantage in those? Seriously?!
@rachelbassett4942
@rachelbassett4942 Год назад
I'm so impressed of how patient Peter is with the ridiculousness of some people's explanations.
@Hindu9054
@Hindu9054 Год назад
u r seeing editied videos. obviously youtubers wont show their bad clips. it happenns worldwide and for both conservative, libral, centrist, political parties, celebreities etc
@quantum_ocean
@quantum_ocean Год назад
If you want to have better conversations and be more like Peter, be more open-minded and stop thinking other people’s perspectives are “ridiculous “
@arebee9024
@arebee9024 Год назад
unfortunately, in clown world there are a lot of ridiculous positions, that would have landed you in the loony bin not too long ago.@@quantum_ocean
@user-vu5dp2wm4e
@user-vu5dp2wm4e 11 месяцев назад
​@@wheelie642they are different based on newly adapted definition, but it doesn't mean they are not very closely connected.
@simonmcintosh6565
@simonmcintosh6565 10 месяцев назад
@@Hindu9054 so you think doesn't show patience? And they only show him being patient? You can check many hours of long form podcasts with him. There is nothing to suggest he loses his patience with these loons.
@davegrimm9091
@davegrimm9091 Год назад
Your doing good work Peter, Thank You for bringing us these conversations
@drpeterboghossian
@drpeterboghossian Год назад
Thanks for listening
@TheWorldTeacher
@TheWorldTeacher Год назад
@@drpeterboghossian, it seems that you conflate "gender" and "sex", Peter?
@theycallme_bruce
@theycallme_bruce Год назад
@@TheWorldTeacheror… it could be that you folk just want to redefine everything to fit your emotions. Is language a social construct? Sure. And said language is how we communicate and therefore become civilized. And that only works if it has rules. Otherwise, any gibberish would constitute language yet would provide no communication. If words don’t have a meaning, what’s the point? We should all just go back to grunting and hope there’s no misunderstanding?
@frosksdeadteeth5163
@frosksdeadteeth5163 Год назад
​​@@theycallme_brucewho are "you folk"? Gender is a language construct, masculine, feminine, neuter in some languages. Sex is male/female. Language evolves over time and meanings change. This is why the "progressives" want to change it deliberately, 1984-style. We only ever confused sex and gender due to prudish modesty about using the word "sex".
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
​@@TheWorldTeacherWTF, did you even watch this video?? 😂
@w1cked001
@w1cked001 5 месяцев назад
This is absolutely insane. THe man with the billboard has a ton of patience.
@Crewboy17
@Crewboy17 Год назад
The mental gymnastics these women are willing to go through to cling to their opinions in the face of logical arguments is mind boggling.
@corsairsofnarshaddaa
@corsairsofnarshaddaa Год назад
Logical? Sure. But even biological arguments. They started off defining sex accurately ("biologically a male or female") and then spent the rest of the discussion controverting their own definition by equivocating.
@HistoritorJimaldus
@HistoritorJimaldus Год назад
What about CAIS people?
@polaristrans
@polaristrans Год назад
Sex is not "assigned" at birth. It is observed at birth or even earlier.
@scottsherman5262
@scottsherman5262 Год назад
Ya, observed by bigots, unless they switch the sex to trans, which is the only morally decent sex one can be. You should try it, it's never too late or too early to go full trans & then boom, you're elevated to the highest of high positions from which you may ASSIGN (see what I did there??) all others as bigots.
@stvbrsn
@stvbrsn Год назад
It was pretty funny how she tripped herself up on that one. She said sex isn’t observed, it’s “assigned.” Then immediately goes on to say it’s “assigned” based on what the doctors see… smh.
@stevetennispro
@stevetennispro Год назад
Agreed. They are confusing assigned with signed, i.e. registered. Assigning is a matter of choice.
@oo7tease
@oo7tease 7 месяцев назад
sex is determined at the moment of fertilization and it is the sperm that provides the sex chromosome determining M/F. sex can be determined pre implantation IVF or between 6 to 10 weeks into pregnancy depending on the method. This assigned sex at birth concept is rubbish HORMONE LEVELS DO NOT DETERMINE SEX!!!!
@thefourthwritedjentleman3643
@thefourthwritedjentleman3643 5 месяцев назад
Assigned at conception- confirmed at birth
@nf6386
@nf6386 Год назад
00:37:00 “On average, are men stronger than women?” *Loooooong pause* “Are we talking… like…strength?” 😢 It’s amazing how the women with conviction that biological men should be able to play women’s sport clearly don’t play competitive sport.
@PowderedToastMan661
@PowderedToastMan661 Год назад
Isn’t it amazing that the “success” of “trans” athletes only goes in one direction? Where are the “trans men” dashing records in men’s sports?
@nf6386
@nf6386 Год назад
@@PowderedToastMan661 it’s quite wrong to assume that biological men always have the advantage in women’s sports. I mean, look at that Finnish figure skater 😂
@PowderedToastMan661
@PowderedToastMan661 Год назад
@@nf6386 That was a disaster 🤣
@LuckysLair
@LuckysLair Год назад
@@nf6386 That was hilarious
@alexgibson8999
@alexgibson8999 Год назад
Interestingly, the one participant contradicts herself moments later. Turned to the other participant and said 'we're just different'. Also, notice her grimace when Peter asks 'on average are men stronger than women'.
@lellamas2778
@lellamas2778 Год назад
The girl with the sunglasses - is in DENIAL. She can't admit her FAILED LOGIC. Just really shameful. If she's telling the truth - i'm REALLY afraid for the future.
@chrisalmendra4370
@chrisalmendra4370 Год назад
and she just said a penis is what makes you a man xD this is fucking bizarre, what a time to be alive
@ForeverMe543
@ForeverMe543 Год назад
She INFURIATED ME!! With her argument that you could actually change your sex and no empathy for a man in a car accident or questioning a botched surgery (WHICH HAPPENS ALL THE TIME)
@MarkMeraji
@MarkMeraji Год назад
You can honestly hear her realize how terrible her stance is as it’s torn to shit further along in the video …but she reduces to admit defeat while the timidness in her voice exposes her failed logic. It’s kind of funny.
@krymz1
@krymz1 Год назад
@@MarkMeraji most people don't change their opinion on the spot. Hopefully she's going to challenge her stances and come to a new idea, but she might just get stuck in her bubble and double down after that.
@Saylor_On_Shore
@Saylor_On_Shore Год назад
The hope is that she will realize later the foolishness and inconsistency of her statements. It’s very hard to rewire one’s worldview within a single conversation. Never give up on people. Build golden bridges.
@jknowstheway1462
@jknowstheway1462 Год назад
When you are not allowed to challenge an idea, you know the strength of the idea.
@nopenoway9875
@nopenoway9875 Год назад
This particular ideology is very dangerous in my opinion
@ponygirl1716
@ponygirl1716 Год назад
Well, you know the strength of those who support the idea, that's for sure. This particular idea is incredibly weak and incoherent, yet so many self-professed liberals are perfectly willing to overlook the vicious, even violent, suppression of free speech in order to protect the idea from any real scrutiny. It's absolutely mind-boggling.
@jknowstheway1462
@jknowstheway1462 Год назад
@@ponygirl1716 sunlight is not the best disinfectant. Its the only disinfectant. If you cant talk about something, theres a reason.
@IsomerSoma
@IsomerSoma 9 месяцев назад
It can be an indication, but your statement is surely false how its stated.
@reddirtwalker8041
@reddirtwalker8041 Год назад
These 2 women are all over the place. Sex matters, then it doesn't, it can be tested, but it doesn't matter. I mean do they even have a standard they would adhere to?
@sebastiansirvas1530
@sebastiansirvas1530 Год назад
No, because, knowingly or not, they have fallen for Queer Theory nonsense.
@EarlHayward
@EarlHayward Год назад
My favorite was … “If you have a hole” … It is sad how people lack the ability to make an argument with logic and reason…
@dogwklr
@dogwklr Год назад
Leftist drones adjust as the conversation goes, what is true from one moment to the next constantly changes as needed. Nothing is stable (especially their mental state) and nothing is consistent, their entire existence is based on subjective delusional reality.
@ollie6502
@ollie6502 Год назад
The standard they adhere to is that that nothing can prevent a man becoming a woman, and that if there is this thing called female and only some women can have it, that is unacceptable. Therefore the meaning of "female" has to change. And then we are forced to use terms like AMAB in situations where the truth is still needed. The truth is so stigmatized that it has to be relegated to the status of an embarrassing mistake.
@SN00PICUS
@SN00PICUS Год назад
They just want to live in a world where whatever they imagine, is the truth.
@LexBravary
@LexBravary 10 месяцев назад
I wouldn't be surprised to learn the guy who interrupted is either a tenured professor or works in government.
@33greenleaf
@33greenleaf 3 месяца назад
He’s a party member employed at the Ministry of Truth. INGSOC
@cvanunen
@cvanunen Год назад
OMG! She said if a guy lost his bits in an accident he automatically becomes intersex. You really can’t make this stuff up. 😂
@jmass4207
@jmass4207 11 месяцев назад
Interestingly she allowed the person who, after experiencing an accident undergoing genital surgery, to "choose". But the cis guy who underwent a random tragic accident is irrevocably now intersex...
@neetpride5919
@neetpride5919 10 месяцев назад
She's right. If you lose your dick, you're no longer a man... But you're not a woman either. Hence intersex
@lilnymphtress
@lilnymphtress 10 месяцев назад
She is a freaking idiot.
@lisam4503
@lisam4503 9 месяцев назад
Technically they become intersex or a eunuch. They no longer produce testosterone. That is itself basic biological reality. I think castration complex or fear falls into this for some people. They simply can't accept that it could happen to them and it would change them physically externally and internally. If you aren't producing testosterone it will also effect you mentally and you will be more emotional.
@Zach-mi6to
@Zach-mi6to 9 месяцев назад
Humans have 2 arms, by her logic if I lost an arm I'm no longer human.
@rickwyant
@rickwyant Год назад
That old guy is so embarrassing. He knows the truth but wants to be relevant to the younger crowd. We all know that men can't be women and women can't be men. It's a facade, a delusion.
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
My dad is like this guy 😮‍💨 He's a "moderate" living in Portland, OR.
@antimonycup7066
@antimonycup7066 Год назад
It's not my job to accuse someone who says they're convinced (of something) of being secretly unconvinced, that sounds too much like evangelicals saying atheists actually _do_ believe in god, but just 'deny his existence' because 'they want to sin'.
@avengemybreath3084
@avengemybreath3084 Год назад
Asking people what they think is not “embarrassing.” Young people are “brainwashed ideologues.”
@DoublespeakNPC
@DoublespeakNPC Год назад
Putting my neck out here, but check that guys hard drive.
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
​@@DoublespeakNPC I agree. He's the kind of guy I'd cross the street to avoid, and NOT because of his physical appearance, but because of his frenetic attitude. "Methinks he doth protest too much" about his alleged inability to differentiate men from women. 😳🙇🏾‍♀️😖
@RVMTube
@RVMTube Год назад
You know what the problem is... there people didn't come to those conclusions by themselves. They are using language made up by ideologues and are repeating the talking points of the ideology. Basically they have a religious stance, based on beliefs and not backed by evidence.
@afuzzycreature8387
@afuzzycreature8387 Год назад
you think you don't do that all day long on many multitude of common things such as the definition of "cheese"
@ludlowworthington697
@ludlowworthington697 Год назад
@afuzzycreature8387 Sure, to some extent definition & categories are used all day without examination, but my gut sense there’s a difference between a definition of cheese based on a long history of real world experience and a movement that, at its core I believe, is gaslighting people to believe the opposite of reality: “This IS that. Silence IS violence. Trns women ARE women. Freedom IS slavery.”
@AndyJarman
@AndyJarman Год назад
​@@afuzzycreature8387yes, but we haven't accepted ideas without utility. When you come across euphemisms you know it's emphasising a narrower frame of reference, or it's a gambit to change the definition/epistemology of common parlance. This is being done for an ulterior motive, that is evidence of ideology and not empirical objectivity.
@christopherkucia1071
@christopherkucia1071 Год назад
No worse, because it’s not backed up by research, years and centuries, sources, and also cross verified by its opposer…. Science is religions opposer and as far as I can tell the belief in religion is backed by scripture, dates, CENTURIES of passing on stories and knowledge, and religions own opposer even verifies some dates and artifacts and what not, or even has natural explanations for some of the supernatural things described in religion…… Literally the only evidence this whole movement has is that people sometimes are attracted to just about anything, and also will make themselves appear and act in any way they deem fit…. So a man can love a man, but there’s still a MAN (and a woman) like, I can put on a wig and stuff my shirt and make myself appear “more like a woman” but that doesn’t make me not man or even something else or inbetween….. it’s so funny this whole ideology. All the different sun categories of rainbow people also in fight and make claims that “debunk” or “erase” the “truth” and and legitimacy and the experience of other rainbow groups…. Hell it seems even gender dysphoria and trans people genuinely seem to go through hell and have no idea what’s even going on with THEMSELVES. How can you even claim that you can claim to be something? Last time I checked your identity was based on how OTHERS view you…. Identity is negotiated with society….. you can’t identify as something that others refuse you are EVEN if those others are LYING! Think about it, someone could lie about your identity and even though it’s not true, because that person is lying, others might think it’s true and that can effect you LIKE it’s true! Got ‘em there too! Literally I can’t imagine the mental pain/gymnastics these wackos must put themselves through….. like, gay people exist, people who claim they are the OPPOSITE sex exist, people claim to be all sorts of thing, do all sorts of things too. But at the end of the day, you are what you are. The harder you try to pretend your not-the harder your life will be and the harder you make it for ALL those around you. What’s with the PUSH for all this crap? Last time I checked, gay people and trans people just are gay or trans and find that out on their own and make all the changes themselves without being told how to do it or what they should do….. don’t need the propaganda because the propaganda will only confuse CONFUSED and SUSCEPTIBLE people. The real gays and trans find a way to be gay and trans lol…. If everyone knows what gender they feel like even as a CHILD then surely we don’t have to talk about it at ALL no?
@SineEyed
@SineEyed Год назад
Humans being humans, basically..
@Crackpot_Astronaut
@Crackpot_Astronaut 10 месяцев назад
The girls start out by saying that sex and gender are different, and then spend the entire time arguing that sex and gender are the exact same thing. They don't seem to understand what they believe at all.
@33greenleaf
@33greenleaf 3 месяца назад
Nobody understands what they believe. It’s incomprehensible.
@katfart939
@katfart939 Год назад
These women are very confused and are arguing against their best interests. Very sad to see
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
Yeah, and the fact that they lack the reasoning tools (despite seeming reasonably intelligent/educated) to understand exactly how FLAWED their logic is is very concerning. Lots of people just don't know HOW to think anymore.
@teelurizzo8542
@teelurizzo8542 Год назад
Very sad indeed.
@dessalinesankara3464
@dessalinesankara3464 Год назад
Yea! She's a Parrot that lacks critical thinking
@harryricochet8134
@harryricochet8134 Год назад
Yes, like two naughty monkeys who have found a saw and are now avidly taking turns enthusiastically sawing away at the very branch they're standing upon while a lion sits calmly basking in the sun at the foot of the tree awaiting the delivery of his midday meal that will be the sole inevitable outcome of such ill-conceived adventurism. Survival of the fittest in slow-motion.
@Dan_Capone
@Dan_Capone Год назад
Do you think the conservatives that have taken the opposite side are actually fighting for women's rights? When historically they haven't cared about them or they have directly fought against them? I only see people latching onto arguments to further their agenda making it look more positive.
@jellybiscuit
@jellybiscuit Год назад
Every time I hear someone say biological male/female I lose a few more brain cells. Same with sex "assigned at birth"
@khaderlander2429
@khaderlander2429 Год назад
It's a mantra you supposed to repeat it until it becomes reality. Indoctrination is on full swing, the rest of us need to get on board. If you don't agree with that then you are label as a bigot and dismissed.
@anonymousAJ
@anonymousAJ Год назад
Yes, sex is only a biological category
@angelawest9759
@angelawest9759 Год назад
Bigot. 😂
@EquippedwithStrength
@EquippedwithStrength Год назад
Same
@guillaumest-jacques5935
@guillaumest-jacques5935 Год назад
💯💯💯💯
@amandakish5828
@amandakish5828 Год назад
You cannot change your sex, you can only charge your aesthetic.
@neglectfulsausage7689
@neglectfulsausage7689 Год назад
calm down vaush. Just because you can use aesthetic and other unusual words doesnt mean it applies. Most adult MtFs or FtMs are VERY UNaesthetic.
@ErgoProxy12345
@ErgoProxy12345 Год назад
real vaginas dont need daily dialation to keep them from welding themselves shut.
@noroomforsquares4483
@noroomforsquares4483 9 месяцев назад
Got 6 minutes in and had to bail out. The stupidity was too painful.
@joannejohnson85
@joannejohnson85 2 дня назад
Cant belive I managed to stay the whole time. I am in an eternal state of bewilderment though
@bowler3329
@bowler3329 Год назад
Your body is not simply a penis or vagina, the male and female bodies have many other differences other than sex organs, therefore you can not change your sex IMO.
@nynoah
@nynoah Год назад
Never ending cognitive dissonance and thought ending cliches
@bluegregory6239
@bluegregory6239 Год назад
Well-said.
@jsharp9735
@jsharp9735 Год назад
YES, its painful.
@John.T.
@John.T. Год назад
It’s actually doublethink: Cognitive dissonance brought on by political indoctrination as opposed to being a natural phenomenon of their psychology. Nobody holds these beliefs naturally.
@antimonycup7066
@antimonycup7066 Год назад
If I were born intersex I'd be pissed at being used as a beard by trans activists, and a man that loses his junk in a car accident *definitely* shouldn't be classed as intersex. If you insist on over-simplifying, intersex means *at least* both types of genitals in some measure, not one less. You might argue losing your junk makes you (more) androgynous but that's something else altogether.
@DDR99999
@DDR99999 Год назад
Even if I had gender dysphoria, I wouldn't want to be associated with woke college kids with pink hair and nose piercings.
@antimonycup7066
@antimonycup7066 Год назад
@@DDR99999 I only object to the 'woke' in your summation. I used to be quite cool in the 90s with the pink haired and the nose pierced.
@DDR99999
@DDR99999 Год назад
​@@antimonycup7066 I meant it in a funny way, I get it that trans activists stole that look 😅
@antimonycup7066
@antimonycup7066 Год назад
@@DDR99999 That's fine, for me personally the subject is serious enough to choose my words precisely, especially on one of Peter's videos. I was crass enough to quote from NWA's Fat Girl on an Aba and Preach video an hour ago, _in a funny way._ 🙂
@TheVeganVicar
@TheVeganVicar Год назад
​@@antimonycup7066 sex: the state of being either male or female in most species of metazoans. In humans, each cell nucleus contains 23 pairs of chromosomes, a total of 46 chromosomes. The first 22 pairs are called autosomes. Autosomes are homologous chromosomes, that is, chromosomes that contain the same genes (regions of DNA) in the same order along their chromosomal arms. The 23rd pair of chromosomes are called allosomes (sex chromosomes). These consist of two X chromosomes in most all females, and an X chromosome and a Y chromosome in most all males. Females, therefore, have 23 homologous chromosome pairs, while males have 22. The X and Y chromosomes have small regions of homology called pseudoautosomal regions. The X chromosome is always present as the 23rd chromosome in the ovum, while either an X or Y chromosome may be present in an individual spermatozoon cell gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either (anatomical) hermaphrodites or of indeterminate sex (or to be more accurate, disordered sex). That does not negate the incontrovertible FACT that there are but two sexes/genders. In order for reproduction to take place, there is the requirement of a female ovum and a male sperm to unite, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division of most species of animals is to enable procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the individual in question. There is no third gamete. Cf. “gender”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). If the reader is curious to know the reason for this term being included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because, in recent times, LEFTISTS have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the words “sex” and “gender”, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, immoral ideologies, especially by promoting the nonsensical idea that a person is able to transition from one gender to the other. gender: the state of being either male or female, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division in most species of animal life is to facilitate procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the person in question. There is no extant third gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either “intersex” (typically referring to those who are anatomical hermaphrodites) or of indeterminate gender (that is, not easily determined by a cursory inspection of the external genitalia), but that does not negate the incontrovertible scientific fact that there are only two genders. As far as we know, there has never existed a single human being with the ability to BOTH conceive a child in his/her womb and, simultaneously, successfully inseminate a woman (or in more disturbing terms, for a hermaphrodite to inseminate him/herself). And even if such an individual has existed, that person would be a combination of BOTH male and female, and not some imaginary, novel third gender. In those rare cases in which a human is born without gonads, the other characteristics of sex/gender would be taken into consideration - firstly, the allosomes (sex chromosomes) found in the DNA of every cell, and then, any extant genitalia, since even those females who have experienced the misfortune of being born without ovaries, for instance, usually have their remaining sex organs intact). Cf. “sex”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). So, essentially, the only significant distinction between the two terms is that the etymology of “gender” pertains to the beginning of things, as can be plainly seen by the other English words that originate from "genus", such as “generic”, “genetic”, and “generate”, whilst “sex” is a scrupulously-literal translation of the Latin cognate “sexus”. The mere fact that the word “genitals” (referring to reproductive organs) is very closely related to the Latin “genus” is further evidence of the assertion that the term “gender” refers to the binary division of human (and of course, many non-human) sexual identity, and NOT to any taxonomy based on emotion, feelings, psychology, or any other non-biological categorization schema. If the reader is curious to know why this term is included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because leftists have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the word in recent times, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, sinful, objectively-immoral ideologies. Until relatively recently, the word “gender” has ALWAYS been used in the etymologically-accurate sense of the term, and even in the former case, predominantly where leftist ideologues comprise a significant proportion of the population. See also “leftism”. If you are truly wise and intelligent, you would surely have recognized several amazing secrets contained within the body of this treatise, “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”. However, perhaps the most secretive secret, shall forthwith be revealed: It is IMPOSSIBLE for a human being to change his or her sex/gender! (You are implored to keep this secret - do not tell a soul!!!) For example, a man who castrates himself and wears a skirt or a dress is simply a mutilated, transvestinal male - not a woman or a female. Similarly, a woman who attaches an appendage resembling a phallus to her crotch and dons a pair of pantaloons, is merely a transvestinal woman with a fake penis between her thighs, and not a man, nor a male, in any accurate sense of the terms. Actually, I would contend that any “man” who excises his reproductive organs was ALWAYS a dickless “man”, metaphorically speaking. 🤪
@damonreitmeier4539
@damonreitmeier4539 7 месяцев назад
He knows their material better than they do. And good on him for keeping calm and polite the whole time.
@ReasonAboveEverything
@ReasonAboveEverything Год назад
That salute had no business swinging out so naturally Lmao.
@____uncompetative
@____uncompetative Год назад
TRANSEVANGELISTECOSOCIALISTCRYPTOFASCISTS
@theinnerlight8016
@theinnerlight8016 Год назад
As a German I laughed my ass off 😂
@slaapliedje
@slaapliedje Год назад
Was he old enough to have been....
@saiello2061
@saiello2061 Год назад
Yeah! That seemed a bit TOO natural... 😂
@ForestG
@ForestG Год назад
​@slaapliedje not an OG
@Syzyro
@Syzyro Год назад
Funny how people say “sex is assigned at birth”, whilst I remember my fiancée’s ultrasound @20 weeks we were told by the midwife, “it’s a girl”. Sex _might be_ “assigned” at birth, but the chromosomal structure of our genus is determined in prophase. I am not a biologist, but I would assume this occurs hours or perhaps days after conception.
@scottsherman5262
@scottsherman5262 Год назад
Well, I am a biologist (in New Jersey) & I say you'd better raise that baby as a boy, or you & your lovely fiancé are racist. I'm pretty sure that's how that works, but again, I'm only recognized as a biologist in New Jersey, so...
@ryanchou2846
@ryanchou2846 Год назад
​@@scottsherman5262😂😂😂
@anastasia-fr1gn
@anastasia-fr1gn Год назад
These people must hate gender reveal parties 🫢
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@anastasia-fr1gn Sex reveal parties...
@cameronlapworth2284
@cameronlapworth2284 Год назад
Genus is a whole other catagory. By sex is determined the moment a sperm with either an x or y enters the egg.
@kronk2294
@kronk2294 Год назад
😆This was incredible. "Sex & gender are different, except they are both made up and determined by what I feel like..."
@hankhooper1637
@hankhooper1637 Год назад
And it's really really important that you agree with whatever fantasy I have created for myself or you are a bigot.
@bobjohnson1633
@bobjohnson1633 Год назад
That's why you never let women vote or have any power. Men should be required to protect them. Not letting them vote or have power is our responsibility to protect them from themselves.
@nomadichomebody4230
@nomadichomebody4230 8 месяцев назад
i majored in biology, we never spoke about this 20 years ago while i was at university. wouldn't have even been a debate.
@07Dsach
@07Dsach Год назад
It’s sad to see an old man with such little control of his emotions that he literally heils out of frustration
@rijntje73
@rijntje73 6 месяцев назад
He's indoctrinated and feels socially pressured to lose his temper and sieg heil to attack and 'out' the guy with the boarding. Ironically, I feel that this old geezer has the predisposition and personality to have been one of the first to fanatically get behind the Nazi movement back in pre-WW2 Germany and feel proud and vindicated to be part of that.
@user-nj9ru4ef2w
@user-nj9ru4ef2w 3 месяца назад
most western woke cultists are like that. and then they accuse you of being hateful and angry.
@kenweide6083
@kenweide6083 Год назад
Yikes...these women are CLUELESS about men and women's sports.
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
Exactly..like have they ever even PLAYED sports? I have, and Lord knows I wouldn't want a dude swinging a field hockey stick at my head or hurling a 90mph softball in the general area of my reproductive organs. 😮
@elizabethwalker7756
@elizabethwalker7756 Год назад
They clearly have no interest or idea how much some women and girls invest in sport just to have all their efforts trashed by cheating men.
@zeusthecat6295
@zeusthecat6295 Год назад
I love how Hitler Claus is just standing there for half the video waiting for his moment to pounce.
@josmclove4426
@josmclove4426 Год назад
🤣🤣🤣
@nicolepeltz8992
@nicolepeltz8992 5 месяцев назад
As a woman myself, I must say I am embarrassed for these two young women.
@mdhen4
@mdhen4 Год назад
You have the genitals you have, yet are somehow "assigned". When we finally get over this lunacy, there is going to be a lot of denial and cringe when people look back at how irrational the human psyche can be.
@rclooper2843
@rclooper2843 Год назад
Non stop gaslighting about this for sure
@user-bg6qr9mh3i
@user-bg6qr9mh3i Год назад
Then they’d have to admit they were wrong… it’ll never happen, people will only double down
@gratefulpipeandcigar3239
@gratefulpipeandcigar3239 Год назад
The guy wearing the posterboard is a saint. He’s doing everything he can to make those girls feel validated when it’s time for him to pretend to change his mind. They literally have no argument Other than people can do whatever they want. They literally don’t have the ability to think about the differences between men and women.
@floydisnutz8443
@floydisnutz8443 Год назад
Guy tried so hard to be kind, like talking to kids.
@quantum_ocean
@quantum_ocean Год назад
He was often rather long-winded. I think he tries so hard to be kind and respectful that he became less clear and convincing
@gratefulpipeandcigar3239
@gratefulpipeandcigar3239 Год назад
@@quantum_ocean I agree
@HistoritorJimaldus
@HistoritorJimaldus Год назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5Zro0neuVeY.html
@fiasco2003
@fiasco2003 Год назад
It seems likely that they simply don’t have the ability to think. About anything.
@marieparker3822
@marieparker3822 Год назад
Gender expression is personality. Gender presentation is fashion. Anyone who believes they are in the wrong body is psychologically unwell, and needs psychological help You cannot cure a mental illness with surgery.
@xJMAN92x
@xJMAN92x Год назад
Right, and then many of those post-op commit suicide: bc they realize the grass isn’t greener on the other side and now they CANNOT go back to what they were born as… So even the “successful” trans highlight the very points of their ideological opponent … But the crazy libs blame that phenomenon on those ideological opponents: that those who have “trans” people avoid survey are responsible (“killing”) the trans that were successful in having surgery but then decided to kill themselves…. Put shortly, those leading the horse to toxic water blame those telling the horse not to go when the horse dies after drinking the poison water. That’s gaslighting.
@Varil92
@Varil92 Год назад
That's the point. They are forcing this idea now that gender dysphoria is not a disorder, but an "identity".
@ryoriotwow
@ryoriotwow Год назад
"You cannot cure a mental illness with surgery." Don't be so sure. The mental is somehow a result of the physical, although we do not fully understand this yet and even if we did we probably could not simulate any more than we can climatical models. But by fiat of being an emersive property of some physical construction, there is a physical - surgical or medisinal - solution to any mental or psychological illment. I'm not saying we have that solution, or that "sexual reassignment"-surgery is healthy. And fixing one bolt might just unscrew another. Who knows, maybe every single individual must have something mentally wrong with them. But your statement seems a bit too absolutist.
@jeremyashcraft2053
@jeremyashcraft2053 Год назад
and the same people who claim its possible to be "born in the wrong body" will get very upset if you ask them if it is possible to be a black man born in a white man's body.
@madnezz1961
@madnezz1961 Год назад
actually it's proven that unlike the help modalities used lets say for annorexia, Gender Affirming care and social acceptance and support are proven to help Transgender folks. The treatments are totally different
@CraigJS91
@CraigJS91 Год назад
You can hear the lack of conviction in their voice as they defend their shaky position. It's almost like they understand what they are spouting doesn't make sense and falls apart under the simplest questioning but are scared to say the wrong thing and offending people. Also I lost it at "it's a hole", way to boil down a whole subset of humanity to such a flippant definition.
@briannabanks1659
@briannabanks1659 11 месяцев назад
These are what are called liberal feminists, and liberal feminism is the cancer of feminism, they believe in this gender nonsense, “fat positivity”, the idea that “sex work”(their sterilized politically correct word for prostitution) is empowering for women, and a bunch of other nonsense. It’s misogyny sold as feminism.
@pjevans1830
@pjevans1830 6 месяцев назад
That's the point, they don't believe it. They're just afraid of offending someone. By extension it gives everyone an excuse to do anything they want. I support your crazy ideas so now you have to support my crazy ideas. What's coming is the normalization of pedophilia.
@norcalmack
@norcalmack 5 месяцев назад
I think they had a false sense of confidence because they heard terms like “assigned at birth” on repeat in class and on tv. I doubt they ever had any challenge on the beliefs that were served to them and that’s why they had no idea about the holes in their logic regarding the holes between their legs.
@joannejohnson85
@joannejohnson85 2 дня назад
Yeah. I cringed at tht statement.
@TW-rr6qb
@TW-rr6qb Год назад
These people are lying, and they know they are lying. They want their social credit points...that is it.
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
Ikr, they're simply reciting their cult dogma. The same sort of reality-denial as the Soviet saying "You did not see graphite on the ground" because Soviet reactors "can't" explode. 🙄
@33greenleaf
@33greenleaf 3 месяца назад
They know they are lying. We know they are lying. They know that we know they are lying. We know that they know that we know they are lying. THEY LIE ANYWAY!
@merkazoidduff7651
@merkazoidduff7651 Год назад
My favorite quote from a previous video is ‘there are only two sexes and sometimes it matters’. That’s the entire debate in a nutshell.
@johnking6067
@johnking6067 Год назад
Love that quote
@thisguy3032
@thisguy3032 Год назад
Exactly, sounds stupid to have to say this but, it matters where it matters.(ie. sports, law, bathrooms, medicine)
@nforne
@nforne Год назад
Is that a Helen Joyce quote?
@merkazoidduff7651
@merkazoidduff7651 Год назад
@@nforne That’s correct. Guess I was too lazy to verify earlier.
@gtugland
@gtugland Год назад
I feel really sorry for the imaginary guy that lost his wiener in a car accident and then apparently automatically would become female with no regard (all of a sudden) for his own views on the matter. Solid reasoning right there.
@lisam4503
@lisam4503 9 месяцев назад
No one said he instantly became a women. They said he became intersex. Seriously they are no longer physically or biologically 100% functionally male. That is reality.
@DaveIrish66
@DaveIrish66 8 месяцев назад
😂😂😂
@MT-tg2xr
@MT-tg2xr 8 месяцев назад
😂😂😂
@mourlyvold64
@mourlyvold64 6 месяцев назад
Strongly agree.
@liverpooljft9623
@liverpooljft9623 6 месяцев назад
Not female, just intersex 😂. These "women" shouldn't be allowed to express an opinion, they're too stupid.
@rgii8060
@rgii8060 Год назад
The level of mental gymnastics the 2 women are doing is astounding.
@ollyb7570
@ollyb7570 Год назад
Putting aside that intersex people are still either male or female (there is no third gamete), I don’t see what relevance they have regarding transgenderism. Trans people are rarely if ever intersex. A transwoman, for example, is usually a complete male with XY chromosomes, a prostate, male genitalia and the physiology which produces small mobile gametes (sperm).
@DDR99999
@DDR99999 Год назад
Yep, trans people are usually born with 0.0 reproductive organs of the opposite sex. Even after surgeries, the trans males have zero functional female organs.
@swifty64
@swifty64 Год назад
This was just painful to watch. Them girls having their ideology ripped apart infront of them but just refusing to even acknowledge their opinions are just wrong. The cognitive dissonance was off the scale
@mothertoad560
@mothertoad560 Год назад
It's insane that people actually believe that men can become women 😅 it's all so crazy
@Sal3600
@Sal3600 Год назад
They're basically black facing women.
@annab704
@annab704 Год назад
You just need a dress and a wig
@kalig.4982
@kalig.4982 Год назад
And "blackfacing" men. Since most transitioners today are female. (But since we live in a gynocentric societies only the wellbeing and safety of women matter. And that has deep and necessary biological roots.)
@nf6386
@nf6386 Год назад
@@kalig.4982but it seems that many of the f2m transitioners are primarily rejecting being a woman rather than seeking to become a man.
@oliverhug3
@oliverhug3 Год назад
@@nf6386 , not true, TIFs are just as annoying as TIMs.
@ruthhorowitz7625
@ruthhorowitz7625 Год назад
I have never met a trans woman who actually knows what it means to be a woman. They think it's about wearing makeup, heels and dresses. I never wear those things but I am a woman. Every trans woman I have met still acts, talks, and moves like a man.
@zeldagoblin
@zeldagoblin 6 месяцев назад
It's a feeling, an essence, an energy. It's the way they see themselves and interact with the world. That's how I've heard them talk. Menno calls it "gender woo. "
@ruthhorowitz7625
@ruthhorowitz7625 6 месяцев назад
@zeldagoblin my essence and feeling are that I am 7'2", and am a star basketball player. I should sue the NBA for not hiring me 😂
@zeldagoblin
@zeldagoblin 6 месяцев назад
@@ruthhorowitz7625 Those bigots! Sue them into next century!
@jasonlee-os1qi
@jasonlee-os1qi Год назад
Nicely done Peter! Keep asking the questions - somebody has to do it ;-)
@drpeterboghossian
@drpeterboghossian Год назад
That's the plan!
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
"Whether I agree or not, that is actually what happens" (on how hospitals observe ("assign") M or F at birth) - what an ASTOUNDING statement
@natasharostova5186
@natasharostova5186 Год назад
hospitals dont assign M or F at birth- they acknowledge M or F. M or F gets assigned in the womb.
@tracyaf6084
@tracyaf6084 Год назад
I hate when they say we assign it. We don’t. We observe and record it.
@tupacalypse88
@tupacalypse88 Год назад
​@@tracyaf6084You don't flip a coin?🤔🤔🤔
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
@@tracyaf6084 TRUE. Will edit to reflect, thank you!
@tracyaf6084
@tracyaf6084 Год назад
@@tupacalypse88 that’s what it makes it sound like 😂 I’ve been attending deliveries for almost 2 decades as a nurse and I’ve never assigned anything. I’ve observed and happily told families what they have. Most of them nowadays know before delivery.
@kathymharris2432
@kathymharris2432 Год назад
I would like to see if these women would agree when a man who says he is a woman invades their space in the way we have been seeing happen in the media.
@PaisleyMarie80
@PaisleyMarie80 9 месяцев назад
LMAO this first guy just punked himself out, as a Nazi 😅😅😅 GOLD😅🤡
@Lee-hq6tf
@Lee-hq6tf Год назад
If stupidity were a publicly traded stock, I'd invest in it!
@zxyatiywariii8
@zxyatiywariii8 Год назад
Same!
@THETANKGINGER
@THETANKGINGER Год назад
I want to get in on one of these because the debate is so simple. On a cellular level men and women are different and that cannot be changed. Mutilating your body will not change you from man to woman or vice versa.
@justinstone2188
@justinstone2188 Год назад
Completely agree. Change all u want. U will never have sperm or eggs. So u will still be what u were born as. 😂
@bobjohnson1633
@bobjohnson1633 Год назад
Science and facts are racist, sexist, trans-phobia, and far right.
@PatstarDeluxe
@PatstarDeluxe Год назад
"Are men on average stronger?" You can literally see her mind doing gymnastics to figure out how NOT to admit defeat
@therealalexmilani
@therealalexmilani 8 месяцев назад
"Do you understand more now than when we started playing?" "No" The smartest thing she said all video 😅
@evieblessed
@evieblessed Год назад
I have tried to remain kind for the past 10 years, ever since we started having this strange discussion; you know, before we forgot what a man and a woman are, but I have to conclude that some people really just are not that bright.
@jenniferterry6775
@jenniferterry6775 Год назад
Every time one of these women makes the argument that they would be perfectly happy and feel perfectly safe allowing biological males into their locker rooms, changing rooms and especially shelters, I just wish the next follow-up question to them would be "Have you ever been punched in the face by a man?" I am guessing the answer is no.
@dax2005
@dax2005 Год назад
Same here! I also would like to know if they have ever thought why women might need a female shelter...
@WaaDoku
@WaaDoku Год назад
I think they believe in the good of people so strongly that they just can't fathom what could ever go wrong if there were no separate spaces for men and women in restrooms, changing rooms, sports competitions, abuse shelters, etc. ESPECIALLY for children and pubescent teens
@bobjohnson1633
@bobjohnson1633 Год назад
I feel perfectly safe letting rapists and murderers into female locker rooms. People who are right wing get their own locker rooms where these people aren't allowed.
@ncorp2668
@ncorp2668 Год назад
I would also like to.know if they believe we should have the right to fmle only things or if they agree with the T movement making it illegal to exist via "discrimination"
@HistoritorJimaldus
@HistoritorJimaldus Год назад
Why would you assume a trans woman in a women’s restroom would be punching people? Silly argument
@drpeterboghossian
@drpeterboghossian Год назад
Despite the interruption, this was a great, respectful conversation with diverse viewpoints. Check out Richard from Common Ground Conversations, who participated in this conversation. commongroundconversations.co/
@TheWorldTeacher
@TheWorldTeacher Год назад
Great and lowly are RELATIVE, Pete. ;) Incidentally, are you VEGAN?
@tharkun21280
@tharkun21280 Год назад
I often marvel at the amount of patience you display.
@MrsRitchieBlackmore
@MrsRitchieBlackmore Год назад
@@tharkun21280 As a former Portlander, I can only imagine being a professor at PSU cultivated that saintlike patience! Phew.
@FrankMattew
@FrankMattew Год назад
1:37 Is that your copy?
@jswets5007
@jswets5007 Год назад
At first that young woman seemed so rational. Until it became clear that she had no regard for factual information and apparently rationalizes everything through emotion.
@Amethyst_Friend
@Amethyst_Friend Год назад
It’s great you facilitated a civil discussion. Respect to the three participants
@drpeterboghossian
@drpeterboghossian Год назад
Thank you. That’s the goal!
@derekconn9950
@derekconn9950 10 месяцев назад
After you finish the discussion, you really should bombard them with facts as to how absurd they are with this nonsense
@CoreSystemDev
@CoreSystemDev 9 месяцев назад
@@derekconn9950 I think he probably doesn't do that to allow for the participants to do their own research in order for them to reach their own conclusions which are therefore more "robust" since they thought of them "themselves" (even though they needed A LOT of help).
@NoLefTurnUnStoned.
@NoLefTurnUnStoned. 6 месяцев назад
@@derekconn9950 That would completely undo the whole point of the exercise.
@shoestringfries3418
@shoestringfries3418 Год назад
50 minutes of mostly peaceful conversation? 50 minutes of Peter Boghossian’s street epistemology? What a great day this turned out to be!
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
Yes, mostly peaceful. Don't know what ponytail man had stuck up his arse.
@danielh3668
@danielh3668 Год назад
Peaceful until you reach the thumbnail 😂
@shoestringfries3418
@shoestringfries3418 Год назад
@@danielh3668 mostly ;) just enough conflict to go with the discussion imo
@MichelleMikey-el6pb
@MichelleMikey-el6pb Год назад
Minority, please leave us alone. STOP stop making the majority 97 3% suffer from the minority 0.3% behaviors and actions. #1) Only a tiny few transgirl males and transwomen males invade, disrupt, and compete against females in sports. This MINORITY destroys the female MAJORITY. #2) Only a few transmen females pumped full of testosterone and have mental illnesses and LGBTQIA + mental illness people will commit rape, pedophiles, child molesters, groomers, and mass shootings at Christian Schools to commit HATE CRIMES killing Christian kids and teachers. Once again, the MINORITY is destroying the MAJORITY ( Christian kids). #3) Gun laws and the 2nd amendment rights are risk of being taken away from the MAJORITY of responsible gun owners because the MINORITY with mental ilnesses like psychotic, LGBTQIA +are committing massive school shootings and most of the crimes against nature, but NOT THE MAJORITY. #4") However, the gun rights are taken away from the MAJORITY because the MINORITY won't follow the gun laws. #5) Freedom of speech is being destroyed by the MINORITY and LGBTQIA + activits because anyone who expresses a different opion gets xensored, canceled, fired from jobs and beatvup at rallies by the MINORITY ewgo are do powerful from corporations and Hollywood and left wing liberals. The MINORITY has destroyed free speech by declaring every opinion from the MAJORITY that is different from theirs is HATE SPEECH, BIGOTRY, TRANSPHOBIC, HOMOPHOBICs, DISCRIMINATION AND HATERS. #6) Freedom of religion of the MAJORITY has been destroyed by the MINORITY who are Aetheist, Satanists and BELIEVERS in Transgender Ideology as their new religion. #7) When the MAJORITY read Bible scriptures aoud at protests rallies, the MINORITY calls this hate speech and the MAJORITY is arrested by cops GO TO JAIL. #7) The MINORITY celebrates gay pride month and can't reproduce their own children because TWO EGGS or two sperms CAN'T MAKE BABIES, the MAJORITY who procreate all the babies and children are MANDATED to celebrate pride month, drag queen story hour, frag queen explicit sex shows for kids, name men shaking their junk in ftontbof kids at pride parades, which goes against the MAJORITY right to Freedom of theirvown expressions nitvto engage in pride month celebrations
@LittleMissPyeWacket
@LittleMissPyeWacket Год назад
The young woman could have been offered any facts and she would have reputed it. The very fact she wouldn't acknowledge the strength difference shows this. For the older lady, as she was placing so much on hormones I wish it had been pointed out that regardless of that adjustment there are other male attributes that give an advantage. Such as size of lungs, bone density, arm length, overall height etc. You might pose the question to the younger lady whether she would be happy to go in a boxing ring with Mike Tyson once he puts a wig on and states he feels like a woman.
@TommyGunz327
@TommyGunz327 Год назад
They are delusional. There are over 10,000 biological differences between men and women
@Jopacob
@Jopacob Год назад
great points but that would have scared them off. Facts are hate speech for some people so it was a fantastic step just to get them to engage.
@sebetc7
@sebetc7 Год назад
I can never understand how women become footsoldiers for gender ideology
@fatmonkey4716
@fatmonkey4716 Год назад
Women's compassion comes before logic.
@mysticmouse7261
@mysticmouse7261 11 месяцев назад
Just append 'phobia' to the opposite position and you're done. No thought required
@nicholasmudrinic4464
@nicholasmudrinic4464 Год назад
Feelings have made a lot of ground in their war against facts.
@BasedYoga
@BasedYoga Год назад
What I find interesting is that whether this topic is broached in Australia, the USA or the UK etc, you will get very similar responses from people, they even use the same words/ phrases/tag lines! Like " *assigned male at birth* " , "gender is a social construct" , "a woman is someone who identifies as a woman" etc and they ALWAYS bring up intersex!!! Every single time!! If you ask two people to talk about astrology, for example, especially if they are in different localities/ countries/ continents - no two people would explain their understanding of astrology in the same way, using the same language and bring up the same points!! I find it fascinating that people seem to have a set narritive and certain talking points with this topic but their argument quickly falls apart when questioned further. It's completely hollow. This ideology is not something that has evolved naturally from within communities, in the same time period, on opposite sides of the world. This ideology is something that seems to have infiltrated every western society, which is why the same talking points are used everywhere. Thank you Peter! This was great. The man (i can't remember his name) was excellent at finding common ground and articulating his arguments.
@nf6386
@nf6386 Год назад
Enough people commenting on the mental contortions by the ladies, let me instead note that this is the most reasonable man wearing a billboard that I have ever observed.
@lech.dutkiewicz
@lech.dutkiewicz Год назад
This is the comment I was looking for. I also really appreciate him trying to explain what he understands from their statements. He was using words very precisely to ensure everyone understood him, while also not being rude.
@SarcasticPlotRecaps
@SarcasticPlotRecaps 8 месяцев назад
**Billboard Chris has entered the chat**
@percyp4274
@percyp4274 5 месяцев назад
The “lose genitalia in an accident” question was everything I needed to hear . She has a materialistic view of the word
@Nick-bh5bk
@Nick-bh5bk Год назад
Based on all of the responses I have seen from these video's, there are two types of people that push this gender ideology: the type that simply do not want to offend anyone and the type that actually believe people can magically change sexes.
@dax2005
@dax2005 Год назад
@@dansschoolofschool also, by the end, while he accepted that the discussion helped him understand their position, the women still claimed they didn't understand his - they were obviously not engaging their brain.....
@AnthonyConnelly-ir4tl
@AnthonyConnelly-ir4tl Год назад
Exactly. These people are not even aware that they aren't even thinking. They are only concerned with social appeasement regardless of the realities involved. They are basically NPCs who are programmed to woke.
@anthonyhiscox
@anthonyhiscox Год назад
​@@dax2005 very common. More conservative people tend to understand more left wing positions far better than the inverse. I say "more" in each direction because I'm aware liberals exist that break this paradigm and obviously there are ignorant conservatives.
@Zeburaman2005
@Zeburaman2005 Год назад
@@dax2005 The most telling moment to me was when the younger of the two was asked to provide an argument to help the billboard man move closer to her position, yet all she could muster up was "sex can be changed by way of surgery and hormone treatment", which was nothing more than the exact same misconception of confusing superficial sexual characteristics (appearance) with the whole of what sex is actually comprised of (chromosomes, anatomy, functional organs both internal and external, etc.) that she had been repeating the whole time. Then, a little while later, she just shrugged and said that "it [was] the most basic argument she [could] think of", proving that she didn't even grasp that to convince an opponent in a debate one has to provide the best possible argument, one that is susceptible to actually motivate the other person to reconsider their position. Now that tells me a lot on how much thought she may have given to the topic prior to Peter's friendly "ambush".
@ncorp2668
@ncorp2668 Год назад
Mmm...I don't buy the "don't want to offend anyone" or "being polite". They're not taking a neutral position. They're certainly oppositional and seem to have no problem sacrificing women, like most liberals on this topic. So the politeness only works in one direction, and it also happens to be on behalf of the side that is advocating (with active vlence) against prior civil rights legislation for W.
@horseluv7315
@horseluv7315 Год назад
Thank you for the laughs! The ignorance is astounding in those two women.
@gtwatton
@gtwatton Год назад
When Peter asked about the botched surgery and the women said,” is there a hole?” I lost it
@nondescriptnyc
@nondescriptnyc Год назад
Bonus hole!!!
@nf6386
@nf6386 Год назад
It’s just about the genitals you have, except when the recreated genitals are poorly constructed to the point of being unrecognisable, then it’s about intent, but if a man unintentionally loses his genitals, then it’s about the absence of alternative genitals, and if there’s no surgery at all, then it’s about mental conviction, not genitals. This reminds me of Sacha Baron Cohen trolling vapid fashionistas as Bruno, leading them to agree to completely contradictory statements back to back, then asking “…and do you think consistency is important?”
@zacharylane817
@zacharylane817 Год назад
@@nf6386 this is great! and you're exactly right, there is zero consistency in their reasoning, or lack thereof.
@netpunk5890
@netpunk5890 Год назад
That made me so sad for her. Does she see her own vagina as nothing but a “hole”?
@jemand8462
@jemand8462 Год назад
Lol, exactly. Women always complain that men are sexualizing and objectifying women while they are the ones thinking all that defines a woman is a “hole”
@davidtomasi
@davidtomasi 7 месяцев назад
4:56 Is the single best argument for the fact that gender and say are not the same thing. I used to believe in the sex binary, but the gentleman in yellow finally convinced me otherwise.
@ericnunnally7186
@ericnunnally7186 Год назад
I like the part where the feminist boils down a woman as a "hole"😂 priceless
@bobjohnson1633
@bobjohnson1633 Год назад
That's why they should never be allowed to vote or have power.
@Cyllene1203
@Cyllene1203 Год назад
@@bobjohnson1633 As a woman, I understand your sentiment although I don't agree with it. Really disappointed at women who so carelessly throw away opportunities for our daughters. On the other hand, the older gentleman railing against the conversation as being transphobic makes a case in the opposite direction. it's a strange, strange world.
@sterlingw3611
@sterlingw3611 Год назад
I have a hole in my penis so I should have the right to use the women's changing room./s
@ncorp2668
@ncorp2668 Год назад
​@@Cyllene1203Don't pretend to understand the sentiments of a man that says he wants to end wmns suffrage (which is a real and growing movement) because she said something stupid about wmn. How does that logically make sense...at all? He's literally agreeing with her premise while simultaneously using it as a fail against her?
@neetpride5919
@neetpride5919 10 месяцев назад
The fact is, the downfall of western civilization tracks extremely well with giving women the vote. Same thing happened before the Roman empire collapsed as well.
@tomcollins4266
@tomcollins4266 Год назад
When I first saw this channel, I thought it was a way to get one person's (or group's) views across, but I took the time to watch a few more videos and see this as a great way to communicate across the board. It made me think critically about how I view open discussion. Just because the questions are difficult (at times), it's FAR better to talk it through and visualize where we are at on a scale versus seeing ourselves and others in extremes. Sure, there are definitely extremes but that just proves how Peter's scale and open communication among the different opinions works. The people who seem to get mad or try to disrupt the conversations are the ones who don't have the skills to think critically, but once they are introduced to it (and open to CHOOSE to listen to other viewpoints) it's a step in the right direction. Thank you, Peter, for asking the difficult questions in our society so we can understand the people around us. This might reduce violence and open up civility in our culture even on a small scale.
@ktrigg2
@ktrigg2 Год назад
That woman literally reduced women down to holes. Hahaha!
@the3sounds
@the3sounds Год назад
Yeah, I noted that too. I was thinking of a funny comment about it, but you beat me to pointing it out :-)
@evrebop
@evrebop Год назад
I’m really interested to see attitudes across different countries- I hope Peter travels and tests this out in lots of places
@MustardSkaven
@MustardSkaven Год назад
How we condition the genders is largely based on sex based behaviours, so it is very much rooted in biology. If you subscribe to the idea that gender is a "social construct" then it logically follows you can't choose your own gender but that society defines your gender. Sigh, of course they brought up intersex. Well if that's a separate sex, can she show us what an intersex organ looks like? Cause to my knowledge, intersex people have male and female organs, cause those are the sexes.
@TheVeganVicar
@TheVeganVicar Год назад
sex: the state of being either male or female in most species of metazoans. In humans, each cell nucleus contains 23 pairs of chromosomes, a total of 46 chromosomes. The first 22 pairs are called autosomes. Autosomes are homologous chromosomes, that is, chromosomes that contain the same genes (regions of DNA) in the same order along their chromosomal arms. The 23rd pair of chromosomes are called allosomes (sex chromosomes). These consist of two X chromosomes in most all females, and an X chromosome and a Y chromosome in most all males. Females, therefore, have 23 homologous chromosome pairs, while males have 22. The X and Y chromosomes have small regions of homology called pseudoautosomal regions. The X chromosome is always present as the 23rd chromosome in the ovum, while either an X or Y chromosome may be present in an individual spermatozoon cell gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either (anatomical) hermaphrodites or of indeterminate sex (or to be more accurate, disordered sex). That does not negate the incontrovertible FACT that there are but two sexes/genders. In order for reproduction to take place, there is the requirement of a female ovum and a male sperm to unite, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division of most species of animals is to enable procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the individual in question. There is no third gamete. Cf. “gender”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). If the reader is curious to know the reason for this term being included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because, in recent times, LEFTISTS have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the words “sex” and “gender”, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, immoral ideologies, especially by promoting the nonsensical idea that a person is able to transition from one gender to the other. gender: the state of being either male or female, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division in most species of animal life is to facilitate procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the person in question. There is no extant third gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either “intersex” (typically referring to those who are anatomical hermaphrodites) or of indeterminate gender (that is, not easily determined by a cursory inspection of the external genitalia), but that does not negate the incontrovertible scientific fact that there are only two genders. As far as we know, there has never existed a single human being with the ability to BOTH conceive a child in his/her womb and, simultaneously, successfully inseminate a woman (or in more disturbing terms, for a hermaphrodite to inseminate him/herself). And even if such an individual has existed, that person would be a combination of BOTH male and female, and not some imaginary, novel third gender. In those rare cases in which a human is born without gonads, the other characteristics of sex/gender would be taken into consideration - firstly, the allosomes (sex chromosomes) found in the DNA of every cell, and then, any extant genitalia, since even those females who have experienced the misfortune of being born without ovaries, for instance, usually have their remaining sex organs intact). Cf. “sex”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). So, essentially, the only significant distinction between the two terms is that the etymology of “gender” pertains to the beginning of things, as can be plainly seen by the other English words that originate from "genus", such as “generic”, “genetic”, and “generate”, whilst “sex” is a scrupulously-literal translation of the Latin cognate “sexus”. The mere fact that the word “genitals” (referring to reproductive organs) is very closely related to the Latin “genus” is further evidence of the assertion that the term “gender” refers to the binary division of human (and of course, many non-human) sexual identity, and NOT to any taxonomy based on emotion, feelings, psychology, or any other non-biological categorization schema. If the reader is curious to know why this term is included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because leftists have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the word in recent times, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, sinful, objectively-immoral ideologies. Until relatively recently, the word “gender” has ALWAYS been used in the etymologically-accurate sense of the term, and even in the former case, predominantly where leftist ideologues comprise a significant proportion of the population. See also “leftism”. If you are truly wise and intelligent, you would surely have recognized several amazing secrets contained within the body of this treatise, “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”. However, perhaps the most secretive secret, shall forthwith be revealed: It is IMPOSSIBLE for a human being to change his or her sex/gender! (You are implored to keep this secret - do not tell a soul!!!) For example, a man who castrates himself and wears a skirt or a dress is simply a mutilated, transvestinal male - not a woman or a female. Similarly, a woman who attaches an appendage resembling a phallus to her crotch and dons a pair of pantaloons, is merely a transvestinal woman with a fake penis between her thighs, and not a man, nor a male, in any accurate sense of the terms. Actually, I would contend that any “man” who excises his reproductive organs was ALWAYS a dickless “man”, metaphorically speaking. 🤪
@BasedYoga
@BasedYoga Год назад
They never fail to bring up intersex. Every single time.
@freddieoblivion6122
@freddieoblivion6122 Год назад
@@BasedYoga Their whole trans ideology depends on it.
@freddieoblivion6122
@freddieoblivion6122 Год назад
@@TheVeganVicar Recently Benjamin Boyce had a discussion with 2 feminists regarding porn and whether it was destructive: one pornstar, and one journalist. What blew my mind was that they both divorced their sexuality from the idea / purpose of procreation. The exposure the iphone has bestowed upon women has destroyed them - especially the pretty ones.
@GreatSageSunWukong
@GreatSageSunWukong Год назад
they are not sex based behaviours they are based in controlling peoples place in society, you should read the book Misogyny the worlds oldest prejudice, it gives an overview of how successive civilizations and religions have tried to tie women to their reproductive role and use that to control, likening them to cattle, there are other cultures with different gender roles, and plenty of evidence of that in antiquity.
@dack482
@dack482 Год назад
60 years living in Australia I have never used the term gender until now. Sex is better
@TheVeganVicar
@TheVeganVicar Год назад
sex: the state of being either male or female in most species of metazoans. In humans, each cell nucleus contains 23 pairs of chromosomes, a total of 46 chromosomes. The first 22 pairs are called autosomes. Autosomes are homologous chromosomes, that is, chromosomes that contain the same genes (regions of DNA) in the same order along their chromosomal arms. The 23rd pair of chromosomes are called allosomes (sex chromosomes). These consist of two X chromosomes in most all females, and an X chromosome and a Y chromosome in most all males. Females, therefore, have 23 homologous chromosome pairs, while males have 22. The X and Y chromosomes have small regions of homology called pseudoautosomal regions. The X chromosome is always present as the 23rd chromosome in the ovum, while either an X or Y chromosome may be present in an individual spermatozoon cell gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either (anatomical) hermaphrodites or of indeterminate sex (or to be more accurate, disordered sex). That does not negate the incontrovertible FACT that there are but two sexes/genders. In order for reproduction to take place, there is the requirement of a female ovum and a male sperm to unite, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division of most species of animals is to enable procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the individual in question. There is no third gamete. Cf. “gender”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). If the reader is curious to know the reason for this term being included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because, in recent times, LEFTISTS have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the words “sex” and “gender”, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, immoral ideologies, especially by promoting the nonsensical idea that a person is able to transition from one gender to the other. gender: the state of being either male or female, and because the entire purpose of the gender/sex division in most species of animal life is to facilitate procreation, the sexual identity of an individual is best classified according to the gametes produced by the person in question. There is no extant third gamete. An extremely minute percentage of humans are either “intersex” (typically referring to those who are anatomical hermaphrodites) or of indeterminate gender (that is, not easily determined by a cursory inspection of the external genitalia), but that does not negate the incontrovertible scientific fact that there are only two genders. As far as we know, there has never existed a single human being with the ability to BOTH conceive a child in his/her womb and, simultaneously, successfully inseminate a woman (or in more disturbing terms, for a hermaphrodite to inseminate him/herself). And even if such an individual has existed, that person would be a combination of BOTH male and female, and not some imaginary, novel third gender. In those rare cases in which a human is born without gonads, the other characteristics of sex/gender would be taken into consideration - firstly, the allosomes (sex chromosomes) found in the DNA of every cell, and then, any extant genitalia, since even those females who have experienced the misfortune of being born without ovaries, for instance, usually have their remaining sex organs intact). Cf. “sex”. Both terms (“gender” and “sex”) originate from Latin words: “genus” (meaning “begin”; “birth”; “kind”; “race”; “gender”) and “sexus” (meaning “sex”; “division”; “gender”). So, essentially, the only significant distinction between the two terms is that the etymology of “gender” pertains to the beginning of things, as can be plainly seen by the other English words that originate from "genus", such as “generic”, “genetic”, and “generate”, whilst “sex” is a scrupulously-literal translation of the Latin cognate “sexus”. The mere fact that the word “genitals” (referring to reproductive organs) is very closely related to the Latin “genus” is further evidence of the assertion that the term “gender” refers to the binary division of human (and of course, many non-human) sexual identity, and NOT to any taxonomy based on emotion, feelings, psychology, or any other non-biological categorization schema. If the reader is curious to know why this term is included in the glossary of “F.I.S.H” (apart from the fact that it is actually used in a handful of chapters), it is because leftists have been desperately trying to change the meaning of the word in recent times, in order to serve their immensely-perverse agenda to destroy civil society with their hateful, wicked, sinful, objectively-immoral ideologies. Until relatively recently, the word “gender” has ALWAYS been used in the etymologically-accurate sense of the term, and even in the former case, predominantly where leftist ideologues comprise a significant proportion of the population. See also “leftism”. If you are truly wise and intelligent, you would surely have recognized several amazing secrets contained within the body of this treatise, “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”. However, perhaps the most secretive secret, shall forthwith be revealed: It is IMPOSSIBLE for a human being to change his or her sex/gender! (You are implored to keep this secret - do not tell a soul!!!) For example, a man who castrates himself and wears a skirt or a dress is simply a mutilated, transvestinal male - not a woman or a female. Similarly, a woman who attaches an appendage resembling a phallus to her crotch and dons a pair of pantaloons, is merely a transvestinal woman with a fake penis between her thighs, and not a man, nor a male, in any accurate sense of the terms. Actually, I would contend that any “man” who excises his reproductive organs was ALWAYS a dickless “man”, metaphorically speaking. 🤪
@aperson_1852
@aperson_1852 Год назад
Agreed. Gender is a pretty useless word just meaning infinite personalities based on stereotypes
@itzkhaos9643
@itzkhaos9643 Год назад
@@TheVeganVicarhell nah bro asked chatgpt what gender and sex means ☠️ and it’s still wrong 😂
@pamelasloan1664
@pamelasloan1664 Год назад
​@@itzkhaos9643Ai is still feed information by a human being when created
@johnnixon4085
@johnnixon4085 Год назад
I'm the same age in the US, and I can remember when gender and sex were the same thing, the equipment you were born with and what you wanted to do with that equipment was your sexuality.
@alexandragrace8164
@alexandragrace8164 Год назад
Thank you so much Peter for coming to my country. It’s very sad to know that the women and men who understand the truth (there are two sexes, sex is determined at conception and immutable throughout life) are probably too scared to be on camera and say what the think for fear of losing their jobs! I know that’s the case for me.
@brucemai1429
@brucemai1429 10 месяцев назад
A very good, rational conversation. The guy who interrrupted is a reflection of the intolerant ones who will brook no argument that does not fall in line with their doctrine. They want to silence even the questioning of what they believe. THEY are the dangerous ones. Also, notice, the ladies' opinions quickly fell back on feelings. This is always what it goes back to - feelings trump science in this day and age, because people want to be compassionate and empathetic. They don't want practical considerations of fairness to interfere.
@milton7763
@milton7763 Год назад
So interesting: the two women started off claiming sex and gender were two different things but then claim that sex is only assigned at birth in a way that at least seemed to imply they think it is some indicating imposition by a system that can be wrong. But then, if the penis is not a good sign to go on to say “this is a boy” where did that difference between gender and sex go?
@ny3683syr
@ny3683syr Год назад
Complete idiots.
@HistoritorJimaldus
@HistoritorJimaldus Год назад
You don’t check for a penis to decide if someone you see on the street is a boy or girl do you?
@brendadarling7743
@brendadarling7743 Год назад
I do hope both those women read the comments here and really think about the things they said.
@WaaDoku
@WaaDoku Год назад
Love these conversations. Keep them coming, Peter. You're showing everyone how to speak with each other instead of screaming at each other.
@joeJoe-pb3su
@joeJoe-pb3su Год назад
Conditioning...? That's a scary word.🤯 that's like forcing someone to do something they don't agree to do.
@masonzuleger
@masonzuleger Год назад
I hate when people focus so much on hormone levels... the differences go beyond that. Bone structure, muscle fiber type, center of gravity... even the male brain is different enough that it is cause for consideration.
@formless4541
@formless4541 Год назад
Exactly. Nervous system too. Many things that don't rely on strength, and even strength doesn't rely totally on mass
Далее
Genders, Rights and Freedom of Speech
54:59
Просмотров 11 млн
Bike Challenge
00:20
Просмотров 12 млн
ПРИКОЛЫ НАД БРАТОМ #shorts
00:23
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Fake watermelon by Secret Vlog
00:16
Просмотров 3,8 млн
Do Transwomen Pose a THREAT to Women’s Sports?
34:38
Просмотров 247 тыс.
HEATED Exchange: Trans Women in Women's Sports
39:45
Просмотров 1,5 млн
80 Year Olds Share Their BIGGEST Mistakes
10:44
Просмотров 6 млн
Bike Challenge
00:20
Просмотров 12 млн