Тёмный

Blaming Atheists for God's Hiddenness 

Prophet of Zod
Подписаться 63 тыс.
Просмотров 77 тыс.
50% 1

The problem of Divine Hiddenness pretty clearly falsifies most Christians' concept of God. There's really no good way to account for why an all-knowing, all-powerful god wants us to know him wouldn't clearly reveal that he exists. So how does Mike Winger address this problem? He goes all in on slandering the intentions of non-believers, then turns around and gaslights them about the fact that he'd just done it. It's bizarre, but it reflects a tactic you may have encountered when being confronted by Christians about your non-belief. If you've ever faced insinuations that you don't sincerely believe and then felt like your accuser was blaming you or otherwise trying to muddy the waters, hopefully seeing it play out in this video will be helpful for you.
MINDSHIFT'S TAKE ON WINGER'S VIDEO - GO CHECK IT OUT! - • Divine Hiddenness: Mik...
MIKE'S ORIGINAL VIDEO: Go ahead and watch it if you feel like it, I guess - • A powerful argument ag...
STUFF ABOUT ME AND WHERE TO FIND ME
My Patreon: / prophetofzod
My Facebook: / prophet-of-zod
My Twitter: / prophet_of_zod
My Email: poz@prophetofzod.com
My mailing address:
PO Box 773024
Eagle River, AK 99577
Website: www.prophetofzod.com (Still under construction, but you can find a little merch and an incomplete set of links to my back library)
MUSIC CREDITS
The metal version of my theme music is by Katy Montgomerie: • Metalcore cover of the...
Original version of the song is "The Game is On" by Ross Bugden: • ♩♫ Epic Movie/TV Intro...

Опубликовано:

 

18 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,7 тыс.   
@DuctTapeJake
@DuctTapeJake Год назад
Mike - "If you seek God you will find him." Me - "I sought and didn't find him." Mike - "Well you must be lying"
@whatwecalllife7034
@whatwecalllife7034 Год назад
😂 yeah that sums it up quite succinctly
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism).
@SUperDEvil137
@SUperDEvil137 Год назад
Every apologist ever
@Jenna_Miles
@Jenna_Miles Год назад
Alternatively, the classic: “Well seek harder!” 😂😂
@katarinatibai8396
@katarinatibai8396 Год назад
​@@Jenna_Miles💯💯💯this
@RobertTaylor
@RobertTaylor Год назад
“You’re bad for asking this question and asking this question disqualifies you from having God reveal himself to you.”
@williamdowling7718
@williamdowling7718 Год назад
Questions are by far the biggest threat to any organized religion. This is why it's so very important for them to "teach" kids when they're young, and then shelter them in a faith bubble where they won't be exposed to hard questions until the indoctrination has had time to cement itself and become part of a person's identity, rather than just something they believe. When something becomes part of your identity, you cling to it and vehemently oppose any challenge to the ideas. Because at that point,questions or criticisms don't feel like questions or criticisms about the idea... They feel like questions or criticisms about YOU. It's been scientifically tested and verified that people cling harder to a central belief when challenged on it. Giving facts or logic to someone who's made an identity their personality doesn't sway them. It makes them dig in even harder. So get em young before they can even imagine the right questions to ask.. so that later in life when the questions inevitably come up, they'll already be in too deep.
@marcomoreno6748
@marcomoreno6748 Год назад
I don't know how good people who happen to be Christians can watch people like Mike Winger and not feel scummy and in need of a hot shower. One of the cracks that started my journey was seeing the qualiyy of the charlatans "defending" my faith.
@marcomoreno6748
@marcomoreno6748 Год назад
Quality* not sure how autocorrect didn't catch that one.
@paulteti
@paulteti Год назад
Outstanding.
@herbdavis9765
@herbdavis9765 Год назад
Hebrews 11:6 ESV And without faith it is impossible to please him, for whoever would draw near to God must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who seek him. It would seem, you Mr. Taylor are correct.
@randolphphillips3104
@randolphphillips3104 Год назад
Ah, the divine hiddeness argument. "If you just brainwash yourself through repetition, it will be evident. If you insist on thinking, he will hide."
@JM74239
@JM74239 Год назад
We have reason and logic to separate us from the daffodils, but the only way to connect with the ostensible creator of brain-bearers and butter-yellow flowers is to not use them. Got it.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@JM74239 True though.
@DartNoobo
@DartNoobo Год назад
If you insist on thininking that God does not exist you will never find him. Plain an simple
@eh9618
@eh9618 Год назад
@@DartNoobo and if you insist on thinking god does exist, you shall find it in places where its not there in the first place. its like pareidolia see faces where there is no face
@DartNoobo
@DartNoobo Год назад
@@eh9618 true, both statements are true. So biases do not help here
@hamobu
@hamobu Год назад
"I don't believe in cops." "That's because you just want to break laws" "If cops exist, then show one to me" "There's one in a police car right over there" "OMG, you were right all along " God should be taking notes on this
@DenisLoubet
@DenisLoubet Год назад
It's interesting to notice that Christians are unlikely to commit an obvious crime right in front of a police officer, yet have no trouble sinning right in the face of a supposedly omnipresent god. Is it because they believe in one, and not the other?
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@DenisLoubet Nah, they know they have a get-out-of-jail-free card with their deity.
@DenisLoubet
@DenisLoubet Год назад
@@lil-al Good point!
@DJ5780
@DJ5780 Год назад
Lol
@hamobu
@hamobu Год назад
@@DenisLoubet The whole "god is always watching and can see your thoughts" must drive some people mad. Imagine your grandma bends over and you accidentally catch a peek down her blouse, and then you are like "GOD PLEASE FORGIVE ME I DIDN'T MEAN IT!"
@christasimon9716
@christasimon9716 Год назад
God _USED_ to show up all over the place. He walked with Adam in the Garden. He parted the Red Sea. He spoke to Moses and the 72 elders, and called to Moses to come up the mountain. He made the sun to stop moving across the sky for a whole day. When Jesus died, He opened graves and allowed famous dead people to walk around and interacted with the living. And...then what? God retired? He got tired of celebrityhood?
@timothy8428
@timothy8428 Год назад
He got game pass.
@sigmascrub
@sigmascrub Год назад
It's almost like those are things that only happened in his book. You know what we call things that only happened in books?
@IanM-id8or
@IanM-id8or 4 месяца назад
Then cameras were invented and people starting wanting pesky evidence ;-)
@Napoleonic_S
@Napoleonic_S 4 месяца назад
Not 100% correct, in ancient days the gods and demons were supposedly everywhere, if someone sneezed someone else would claim pixie dusts caused the other guy to sneeze, every week there were supposedly apparitions of gods, demons, saints, spirits whatever... But as human knowledge and scientific knowledge gained, all of those things gradually disappeared.
@christasimon9716
@christasimon9716 4 месяца назад
@@Napoleonic_S "in ancient days the gods and demons were supposedly everywhere... But as human knowledge and scientific knowledge gained, all of those things gradually disappeared." And that's fine. But I'm using examples from the Bible, which [if true] would be very observable, undeniable events. The questions for people who actually believe the Bible is literal and historical is, where'd He go? @DartNoobo If you insist on thininking that God does not exist you will never find him. Plain an simple Why? Does He scare that easily? If God parts the Red Sea again tomorrow as He did in Exodus, does a single person's disbelief close up the passage? Is God's power really that fragile? I've been told many times that God wants a personal relationship with me. Great. If He's omnipresent, He knows where to find me. AND, being omniscient, He already know what it would take to convince me that He's real.
@MindShift-Brandon
@MindShift-Brandon Год назад
This was fantastic! Also, thank you so much for the shout-out and kind words. That was really kind of you. Lastly, this was really cool for me, because I could compare how I responded to specific points to how you did. I learned a lot!
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
Yo0u both did a fantastic job of exposing Mike's nonsense.
@luigi290
@luigi290 Год назад
I was so excited to hear you get a shout out! Well deserved in my opinion. Your content is top notch and incredibly informative
@waynestanley01
@waynestanley01 Год назад
I saw your show recently, very good.
@angelbrother1238
@angelbrother1238 Год назад
@@lil-almikes arguments are nonsense but not as bad as the arguments from the religion of atheism . How about we start with the Ancillary evidence and go from there . The Bible says we have a soul and an afterlife right ? Please tell me where does science itself lean towards when it comes to the existence of the soul and the afterlife . This is when atheists start ignoring me :( 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
@angelbrother1238
@angelbrother1238 Год назад
Hey skeptic I’ll give you a shout out also big boy . I know you don’t like this subject but maybe we can discuss a little science :(
@DoloresLehmann
@DoloresLehmann Год назад
I've already watched several reactions to this video of Mike, and none of them addressed what I found most concerning: It's the "there are several ways to poke holes in this argument" statement. That shows what he is about: not about acknowledging the argument, considering its content, thinking it through, seeing if there's any evidential power to it, no, it's all about debunking it from the start. And then he doubts the sincerity of his opponents. Great.
@OneEyed_Jack
@OneEyed_Jack Год назад
That's because he's a lying twat. Right from the start he acknowledges the argument that there can be _people_ that are sincere seekers, but then jumps on doubting the sincerity of _the_ seeker. Singular.
@tripolarmdisorder7696
@tripolarmdisorder7696 Год назад
What else is new? Trying to whitewash the No True Scotsman fallacy in apologetics must be taught the very first day in the class for being a con artist for Jeebus.
@ScientiaHistoria
@ScientiaHistoria Год назад
@doloreslehmann: Koukel entitling his apologists’ book “Tactics” said it all. They’re increasingly pushed to just give their audience tools rather than ideas.
@nagranoth_
@nagranoth_ Год назад
well.. have you ever seen an apologist do anything else? It kind of goes without saying, so... it goes without saying.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
Mike is an apologist, so your expectations were FAR too high.
@Cellidor
@Cellidor Год назад
In my case, I _was_ someone who officially deconverted via searching through prayer. Or more specifically, a prayer ended up being the final 'tipping point' so to speak. I did the prayer alone in my room, ensuring I had privacy and nothing to distract. It went (roughly) as follows: "God, I'm just speaking this prayer to you because I don't know if you actually exist, if there's a different god up there, or more than one, or if I'm just...sitting here by myself, talking to myself. If you've got anything you'd like to talk to me about, or want to help me with this, I'd love to know" I waited. ...Silence. Silence for a good long while. So, after enough time had passed, I decided to finish up the prayer. "Well...I'm always around, if you decide to talk to me. Or, anyone else up there, if there are any. Amen." 20-ish years later, still no contact, still an atheist until such time as that changes. Ball's in the celestial court, so to speak.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
What you lost is the axiom of "My God exists". That's all that changed: you lost that axiom. There are ex-christians who changed to a DIFFERENT God, such as Allah, but they still kept that axiom, merely changing their God to fit their preferences. All you did was lose that axiom. If someone wants to Pascal Wager you, then remember, which will naff God off more when you do something he doesn't like, but you thought was good: "I would do it again" or "I was following your Orders". Which would please God more, doing something he likes and you saying "I would do it again" or "I was following orders"?
@fabianschobinger2765
@fabianschobinger2765 Год назад
Yeah, I think, most of us experienced something like this. Back when I was a Christian, I thought he didn‘t give me a clear message because he didn‘t have anything to say or said it in a different way, more „undercover“. But when you struggle with your believe and you don‘t get any sign from god, then this can really destroy your faith.
@Cellidor
@Cellidor Год назад
@@fabianschobinger2765 The nice part is, it's not a struggle anymore, hasn't been for decades. I live what I see to be a good life, and try to use my judgement to do what I see to be good things. Any god/gods, if they exist, that wished to comment on that work, always welcome for a chat. My door's open, they can come on in anytime that works for them.
@Jack908r
@Jack908r Год назад
Brilliant. For me (despite every other solid argument), if there is a god, why is he so hidden? Why wouldn't he be more clear? The existence of UFO's is honestly more clear. And if you knew people like anyone else on the planet does, god could show himself in the sky with a clear message, and a certain percentage of the population would still not believe. So theres no loss to god doing that. And yet, here we are. We'd honestly be better off worshipping the sun. At least its real.
@ScientiaHistoria
@ScientiaHistoria Год назад
@cellidor: as someone who never believed (raised in “none” family) I found this scene poignant and gave me some sense of what many on these channels have gone through that I have no experience with. Thanks.
@kylas1902
@kylas1902 Год назад
Mike Winger is the epitome of "I'm trying to convince myself this BS is true by convincing others."
@HuxtableK
@HuxtableK Год назад
Thats what an apologist does.
@utubepunk
@utubepunk Год назад
Winger nervous laughter.mp3
@aazhie
@aazhie Год назад
@@utubepunk xDDD oh no I can hear it lol
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
That's the impression he gives me too.
@pansepot1490
@pansepot1490 Год назад
There’s only two options for Mike: either atheists are lying when they say that god is nowhere to be found OR I am delusional. And he ain’t admitting he’s delusional.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
Remember, Mike starts his claim with the idea that "God is hidden" as *GOD* being at fault, but when someone atheist "looks for God and fails to answer", he asserts this is the *ATHEIST* being at fault. No, your perfect all loving omnipotent God is at fault, mike. Remember?
@rembrandt972ify
@rembrandt972ify Год назад
Mike can't remember his own name.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
@@TheCassandra Well why worship a NON-EXISTENT God whose STORIES clearly say he kills kids, etc. That "Why worship a god when it is so clear he kills kids..." is what to ask any christian who believes their God exists to DO those things. Myself I just say God is hidden because it doesn't exist.
@AnathemaMysticalcel
@AnathemaMysticalcel Год назад
I have been wondering... why does everyone start with the premise that if God exists he exists as Omnibenevolent, omnipotent, and omniscient?
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
@@AnathemaMysticalcel It's weirder. They start with "If" but never consider the case the conditional statement doesn't apply. Never "Not". BTW the tri-omni is an inevitable feature of monotheism, a polytheist just has them Celebrity Big Brother against each other (even die, see Zeus' parents and their family), but all a monotheism has is "my god am bester than everyone else's, so mine is the only true one!!!!". But even if it weren't the case, that is what all christians are told to believe (whether trinitarian or not), and so being in a mostly christian led culture, you would hear mostly that God.
@shadesmarerik4112
@shadesmarerik4112 Год назад
@@AnathemaMysticalcel with "everyone" u mean people of monotheistic book religions .. or really everyone? Cuz when Atheist start with that premise, its for the logical reason of disproving the whole god theory by picking up a Theist claim and bring it to the inevitable contradiction. Its just one point of many, but given its a low hanging fruit, it gets taken up quite often.
@bouldersoundguy
@bouldersoundguy Год назад
Why is it even necessary to "sincerely seek" God for him to act on his desire to be known? If I need someone to know I exist, I introduce myself to them, and it has no impact on their free will or anything like that.
@pansepot1490
@pansepot1490 Год назад
It’s all nonsense that only makes sense in the mind of needy people unwilling to give up their psychological crutch. No one needs to sincerely believe or seek gravity in order to experience it. And the same applies to all things that belong to the real world.
@thedarknessthatcomesbefore4279
Absolutely correct.
@antonioscendrategattico2302
@antonioscendrategattico2302 11 месяцев назад
Yep. Still haven't heard any kind of explanation for why telling someone you exist is somehow robbing them of their free will.
@istvansipos9940
@istvansipos9940 10 месяцев назад
yes. the g0d (whatever it is) is once again outcompeted by 3-year-olds. They can say a cute "Hello" when they want to.
@Petticca
@Petticca 27 дней назад
The absurd "free will" response in this context fails for the following reasons: 1) According to the Bible everyone knows God exists - 2) According to professional liars such as Mike Whinger, atheists know God exists 3) According to professional liars such as Ray Comfort, everyone with functional sight can see the undeniable evidence of the God that everyone already know exists. 4) Despite number 1... God instructed people to run around telling everyone about Jesus/God, and failed to mention that it was in any way important or relevant, that they have a care about what anyone they're preaching at, wills or wants/ doesn't want to hear/ know. And given everyone already knows God exists, this is not only a pointless exercise, but even if there was some moronic hand wave offered in an effort to make it not pointless, it would only serve to be evidence that God doesn't give a shit if someone exercises their free will and "chooses" to pretend he doesn't exist, as believers (which is supposedly everyone, no?) are instructed to run around pointlessly telling everyone that God exists and God, as Jesus did that thing, that you already know about, because everyone already knows, in their hearts, and what not. Questions? Thought not.
@davebcf1231
@davebcf1231 Год назад
Still waiting for a single apologist to realize that it's not Christianity vs. atheism. It's Christianity vs. every other belief system on the planet. They constantly make videos directed at atheists while ignoring the billions of people who are members of other religions that also don't believe in the Christian god.
@aisaacp
@aisaacp Год назад
Oh no we definitely believe the Christian world view opposes both atheism and every other world religion. Every other world religion is about working your way to God, but Christianity is about God making a way and doing the work on your behalf.
@nagranoth_
@nagranoth_ Год назад
you're kind of missing the point. These are American Christians worrying about christians becoming atheists. They want to keep the remaining christians in line, maybe accidentally convince an atheist of a god again and they assume that'll be the christian one of course. They don't care about other religions, they know they won't convert loads of people, they're just trying to keep the ark from sinking, and failing.
@pansepot1490
@pansepot1490 Год назад
@@aisaacp “words, words, words” _Shakespeare_
@aisaacp
@aisaacp Год назад
@@pansepot1490 well hello there 👋🏼 your second reply to me yet…much love to you my friend. I hope one day you’ll consider the words of God :) Romans 6:23 For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.
@trashaimgamer7822
@trashaimgamer7822 Год назад
​@@aisaacpI'll consider the words of a god if one day a god decides to actually speak with me in person. I won't however consider the words of a random dude on the internet quoting a random paragraph from a random book.
@JM74239
@JM74239 Год назад
Yeah, I'll worry about whether God is good or loves me after I have any decent reason to believe he exists. Mike Winger seems quite confused as to what the problem is. I can also save him the condescending inquiry as to my sincerity in my search for God --- there isn't one. I'm sincerely not looking for God, precisely because there's no reason to think he exists.
@WetDoggo
@WetDoggo Год назад
Seems like you will know after your death... or rather won't know, since as far as we can possibly know, death is the end.
@dross4207
@dross4207 Год назад
@@WetDoggoHaving to wait until we die is just another excuse why they can’t give any evidence for their claims. You didn’t look; you don’t want to see; you’ll find out when you’re dead….just excuse after excuse.
@JM74239
@JM74239 Год назад
@@WetDoggo Yep. And to be fair, it's another convenient non-search. No strain necessary as there's no decent evidence to worry that consciousness survives the body.
@WetDoggo
@WetDoggo Год назад
@@dross4207 exactly
@zugabdu1
@zugabdu1 Год назад
I wonder how much searching for Xenu Mike Winger did before he came to the conclusion that Scientology wasn't true.
@01Aigul
@01Aigul Год назад
I would think that if an omnipotent God wanted to be known, there should be absolutely no question whether that God exists. It shouldn't come down to "oh, this slightly unusual internal state I achieved after hours of works must be God", it should be completely undeniable.
@01Aigul
@01Aigul Год назад
Like, my mother is not omnipotent, and loves me much less than God does (according to Christians). She's also not going to torture me forever if I fail to believe in her. However, her existence is completely indisputable. I would think that God should provide at least as much evidence of his existence, given what Christians claim about him.
@bobmudge4836
@bobmudge4836 Год назад
If I’m a lost child of this all-loving, all-powerful, all-knowing god, why doesn’t he just reach out to me in a way he knows would convince me of his existence? Unless ….
@iluvtacos1231
@iluvtacos1231 Год назад
Because ~reasons~
@sypherthe297th2
@sypherthe297th2 Год назад
For reasons perfectly sufficient for God. Also known as "I don't have a leg to stand on and never did."
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
FREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE WIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
@bobmudge447
@bobmudge447 Год назад
@@lil-al If only it were compatible with an all-knowing god. Bummer, huh.
@butter__boi703
@butter__boi703 Год назад
Many wouldn’t follow him anyways. Look to the isrealites, a people who witnessed pillars of fire, water burst from rocks; a sea part in front of them, many plagues etc and they still turned away. It’s a heart issue generally
@SmolJordan
@SmolJordan Год назад
One of the worst instances of this I've seen was the debate between Alex O'Connor and Jonathan McLatchie. One of Alex's primary arguments was an incredibly strong case for divine hiddenness and when Jonathan finally responds to it, he just has no other way to deal with the argument other than to say 'well you must be doing it wrong' or 'you must not be sincere enough'. It's so frustrating
@sypherthe297th2
@sypherthe297th2 Год назад
Johnathan McClatchie is one of the most immature apologists out there. . . out of an absurdly large group of primarily middle-aged/elderly immature men with a sadly emotional attachment to their favorite fairy tale. Hes so easily dismantled and then becomes a petulant toddler when he's stuck. Oh, and he likes to go into the RU-vid comments of videos reviewing his nonsense and ruin his reputation further.
@DenisLoubet
@DenisLoubet Год назад
Can this be called a reverse of the sharpshooter fallacy? No matter where your shot lands, the target is moved so you always miss.
@pjaworek6793
@pjaworek6793 Год назад
Or MacLatchie suspects "disconfirmation bias" and/or that maybe god doesn't love Alex. 6:15
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
But what other option did McLatchie have?? They all know God is completely hidden, if not nonexistent, but they supress the truth in unrighteousness.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@DenisLoubet This.
@DHPersonal
@DHPersonal Год назад
How can a test of divine hiddenness be valid when it returns a positive result but invalid when it returns the opposite? That doesn’t seem to be an appropriate way to conduct a test.
@dross4207
@dross4207 Год назад
Cherry-picking to support a confirmation bias. It’s that simple.
@fred_derf
@fred_derf Год назад
Obviously, the test is only valid if it gives the answer he wants. That's how tests work, right?
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
A test of divine hiddenness is valid when it returns the result that Mike Wingnut wants. Otherwise it's YOUR FAULT.
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism)
@nitehawk86
@nitehawk86 Год назад
Why do apologists think its ok to straight up lie to to prove their point? Most people making a casual bad argument aren't doing it on purpose, but guys like Winger definitely thought through this crap and decided to lie anyhow.
@OneEyed_Jack
@OneEyed_Jack Год назад
Because it makes them money, and they know the people that they intend this crap for won't think about it too hard because they _want_ to believe. Any that do call him out just become part of the out-crowd as "never _true_ believers." Edited for autocorrect 🙄
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
Lying for Jesus is ok.
@tos100returns
@tos100returns Год назад
It's called "lying in service to the lord." That is, they can tell lies all day long to promote Jesus and belief, and that is fine, because in the end it got them what they wanted. They got it with lies, but they don't care. Between this and the fact that Christians believe they have unconditional, never-ending forgiveness, I cannot EVER trust ANYTHING that a Christian has to say. This is why they lie so effortlessly. They are not to be trusted. When someone tells me they're a Christian, they're also telling me they're a perpetual liar.
@IanM-id8or
@IanM-id8or 4 месяца назад
Lying is tin the name. After all, they call themselves "apologists" but - rest assured - they aren't sorry at all. Mr Deity calls them "excusists". I'm gonna go with that
@EmissaryOfStuff
@EmissaryOfStuff Год назад
Winger also adds a few unnecessary caveats from the outset to fuel his gaslighting, namely the "sincere searching" part. Isn't it the Christian claim that God wants to have a Relationship with all humans? All Humans should be made aware of his existence, regardless of how sincere they are or if they're even searching at all, because that is the starting point of a Relationship. The very concept of searching for God should be nonsense, as if searching for the Sun.
@TK-yz3wt
@TK-yz3wt Год назад
George Carlin did say that if he worshipped anything, it would the sun. He could see the sun except at night and it provided heat, light, and skin cancer yet asked foe nothing in return.
@dross4207
@dross4207 Год назад
Exactly!! When my girlfriend says that she doesn’t have a boyfriend, I keep showing up at her dinner dates so she knows that I’m real. If I can make myself evident to someone that says that I don’t exist, a god could do the same.
@trishayamada807
@trishayamada807 Год назад
That whole sincerity bull$hit is their excuse for when you don’t find god, they will just claim you weren’t sincere. It along the same lines as, you never really believed, you have hardened your heart, etc.
@Krikenemp18
@Krikenemp18 Год назад
I'm sure he would bring up the free will excuse, as if me having evidence that Mike exists means I have no choice but to be in a relationship with him. Utterly ridiculous.
@infosecrogue8883
@infosecrogue8883 Год назад
Mike is the high-interest used car salesman of apologetics. He has a way of smuggling extra things in his arguments and this was a prime example.
@aisaacp
@aisaacp Год назад
Just because he opposes a hopeless world view doesn't make him bad person.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@aisaacp His IS the hopeless world view!! He doesn't care about this life, it's all about the nebulous afterlife for him. His gaslighting, lying and wilful ignorance make him a bad person. He is truly revolting.
@pansepot1490
@pansepot1490 Год назад
@@aisaacp nowhere the OP said Mike is a bad person. YOU are implying used car salesmen are bad persons.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@pansepot1490 At least they admit the used-car-salesman part.
@mrk4022
@mrk4022 Год назад
@@aisaacp I think he is a bad person. Because of his lying and obnoxious behavior. His views are truly laughable but they per se don't make him bad. They just reveal that he's not very bright.
@fred_derf
@fred_derf Год назад
"and then felt like your accuser was blaming you" It's a common tactic of abusers, authoritarians, and tyrants; it's called *Blaming the Victim.*
@ZenWithKen
@ZenWithKen Год назад
You're the reason I hit you and I hit you because I love you.
@ferretfather2000
@ferretfather2000 Год назад
ie Gods whole shtick
@joegame4576
@joegame4576 Год назад
victim of what exactly?
@ZenWithKen
@ZenWithKen Год назад
@@joegame4576 Gods version of love. I'm sending you to hell because I love you.
@ferretfather2000
@ferretfather2000 Год назад
@@joegame4576 victim of abuse. the abuser blames his victim as an excuse to keep abusing them. "you know this is your fault right?"
@JayMaverick
@JayMaverick Год назад
Well spoken. Winger is the worst manipulator and gaslighter because he seems so friendly.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
The Con in conman is for confidence. They have to be "A nice guy" to succeed in the scam business. I become more convinced Mike Winger does not sincerely believe but is just in the Jesus Business. No slur or lie to great in service of his income.
@PrometheanRising
@PrometheanRising Год назад
He's like a Kent Hovind upgrade with the new fake sincerity module.
@katarinatibai8396
@katarinatibai8396 5 месяцев назад
​@@PrometheanRising💯💯💯🎯this - you hit the nail on its head 🏆👍
@katarinatibai8396
@katarinatibai8396 5 месяцев назад
This are the worst narcissists. The "friendly" ones. This are the real wolfes in sheep's skin.
@isk3397
@isk3397 Год назад
So, if you reduce his whole argument to its most distilled form... he's essentially arguing that you need to fake it till you make it. If you havn't made it yet, fake it harder. There's really nothing more to it, at its most basic level, and what's there is really weak.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
Worse than that. You have to make it to HIS version of God. Doesn't count if you make it to belief in Allah or whatever.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@markhackett2302 Or even an ever-so-slightly different version of the christian deity.
@not_a_theist
@not_a_theist Год назад
I’m so glad to see you promoting MindShift… I discovered his channel a few weeks ago and think he deserves to be boosted by larger creators. Thanks!
@andresvillarreal9271
@andresvillarreal9271 Год назад
You cannot be unknowingly deceitful. With this Freudian slip, Mike Winger is suggesting that he is being deceitful himself.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
I become more convinced Mike Winger does not sincerely believe but is just in the Jesus Business. No slur or lie to great in service of his income.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@stultusvenator3233 For sure. He is vile.
@katarinatibai8396
@katarinatibai8396 5 месяцев назад
​@@stultusvenator3233💯💯💯🎯this
@coruscanta
@coruscanta 16 дней назад
I remember as a kid being obsessed with the difference between being deceitful and sincerely mistaken. Ugh, I wish my fear of quicksand had been the one to be more relevant in my adult life. At least that would have some adventure to it and wouldn’t just involve gaslighting anyone who disagrees. 🙄
@bradfordjr9905
@bradfordjr9905 Год назад
Yes, Mindshift is a great channel. I hope everyone checks it out. Thanks POZ for your great videos!
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism). What you realised that Etheism is just an empty cult? That Have nothing to offer to you, or to the humanity? It leads to nowhere? To the Obsession for God? For Christianity? That there is not comfort on it??? And that live and die as an alone godless person is not the best you can have? Just as have the idea that once you die you will be Nothing (and Nothing you are now, as you become what you think you will be once death) is not the best for your mental and psychological stability? Or have sacred things (as other people have) and you do not (such God) is so idiot that you are rething about everything and start to believe that Atheism is not but a BS, and a trap you are in?????!!!!
@TheHiddenMarty
@TheHiddenMarty Год назад
Bro, imagine hiding your existence from your child because they don't try hard enough to find you. Bro, that's so F-ing evil.
@karenlankford8558
@karenlankford8558 Год назад
The basic argument for divine hiddenness goes like this: "If the god you describe actually existed, why does the world look exactly like what you would expect if he/she/it did not exist?"
@butter__boi703
@butter__boi703 Год назад
The answer, it doesn’t. It looks very very different than if there was no God. Your presupposing a lot of things to get to that conclusion
@just_some_guy_on_the_internet
@@butter__boi703 such as what? That seems like an assumption on your part all on its own.
@antonioscendrategattico2302
@antonioscendrategattico2302 11 месяцев назад
@@butter__boi703 No, actually the world looks exactly as it would if the god of the Bible didn't exist. Like, say, the fact that we don't have him going around healing the blind and turning water into wine anymore.
@coruscanta
@coruscanta 16 дней назад
@@butter__boi703​​⁠nah. It’s not presupposing all those things. The Divine Hiddenness argument specifically comes up *after* someone has *concluded* those things for various reasons. If you want to say that you disagree with that conclusion, that’s fine. But to say those conclusions are being presupposed shows that you’re largely unfamiliar with how the conversation actually goes.
@cygnusustus
@cygnusustus Год назад
As a rule, youtube apologists are shamelessly dishonest.
@rembrandt972ify
@rembrandt972ify Год назад
You have a penchant for the understatement.
@williamdowling7718
@williamdowling7718 Год назад
It's not exclusive to RU-vid. Apologists MUST be dishonest. Their entire job is to invent explanations to cover the inadequacies of a supposedly perfect book. If the bible was written/inspired by a perfect god, there would be no room for confusion and thus no need for someone to jump in and explain.
@cygnusustus
@cygnusustus Год назад
@@rembrandt972ify I have a penchant for staying within the youtube posting rules!
@rembrandt972ify
@rembrandt972ify Год назад
@@cygnusustus 😝
@Cat_Woods
@Cat_Woods Год назад
They obviously don't believe in an absolute morality where lying is always wrong.
@DirtPoorWargamer
@DirtPoorWargamer Год назад
_"I have to either agree with you or call you a liar, and agreeing with you means I'm wrong. Liar it is."_ And that's why you'll never get through to these people; they're in a perpetual state of denial.
@coruscanta
@coruscanta 16 дней назад
I don’t really want to be anti-theistic, but it’s principles like that from Christianity that make it hard not to be. It poisons any conversations it’s adherents ever have with someone who disagrees with them - because they fundamentally don’t believe any disagreement is actually being had, just deception. Anyone who inherently enters conversations assuming everyone else either agrees with them before the conversation starts or will be necessarily deceitful just shouldn’t be allowed in civilized conversations.
@charlesyates8228
@charlesyates8228 Год назад
I’ve never looked for God. But then my parents were atheists. I figure if God wants a relationship with me, God knows where to find me (part of being omniscient).
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
That's how it should work, but apparently Yahweh wants to blame it all on everyone else.
@tos100returns
@tos100returns Год назад
I never looked for one either. Never knew what my dad believed, and he's been dead for 20 years. When I was 43, found out that my mother considers herself to be Catholic. They just never brought up religion.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@tos100returns Which is how it should be. If you must be superstitious, keep it to yourself thanks.
@Hitchens1949
@Hitchens1949 2 месяца назад
“Sorry, you didn’t try to find god without any evidence to justify your search. You’ll be going to heck for eternity. Should’ve tried harder!” -typical apologist.
@writer4life724
@writer4life724 Год назад
Mike seems to forget many atheists in America were once Christian in some form or fashion and genuinely fought to stay in the faith. But the idea of a "true believer" losing their faith seems to scare him, so he paints generalities of atheists to keep himself planted in his faith. That's what I get from this video.
@marcomoreno6748
@marcomoreno6748 Год назад
It's the most pathetic, weakest, cowardly, and defensive tactic to accuse deconverts of insincerity.
@AnathemaMysticalcel
@AnathemaMysticalcel Год назад
Isn't that the "no true scottsman" fallacy?
@ianmacfarlane1241
@ianmacfarlane1241 Год назад
​@@AnathemaMysticalcel*Scotsman. And yes, it is.
@Simon.the.Likeable
@Simon.the.Likeable Год назад
God = porridge
@lucidragon5260
@lucidragon5260 Год назад
I remember in one video, Mike says that when he encounters a difficult question about Christianity, he chooses to trust God rather than his own logic. Then he is usually able to find an answer later, but even if he can't, he'll trust God. When I was a Christian this made perfect sense. After all, God knows so much more than we do. But now that I'm thinking about it, this just amplifies confirmation bias to the max.
@lurch666
@lurch666 Год назад
Wouldn't it be better for a deity to reveal himself to skeptics who are just 'looking for him to prove he doesn't exist' than to reveal himself to people who were bought up in that religion?
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
FREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE WIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
@lurch666
@lurch666 Год назад
@@lil-al Yep but free will only for the skeptics,none for people predisposed to believe. Funny that!
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@lurch666 Pleasae don't try and poke holes in the only defence for divine hiddenness that they have.
@butter__boi703
@butter__boi703 Год назад
He does, one of two things often happens 1: NO THAT WAS A COINCIDENCE GOD ISNT REAL!!! 2: They turn to Fait
@lurch666
@lurch666 Год назад
@@butter__boi703 So why does this deity only reveal itself to certain people and not everyone?
@stevenfeduk4833
@stevenfeduk4833 Год назад
Zod, I'm embarrassed that I haven't been subscribed. I've been watching since you started out the channel. You're an amazing, inspiring, compassionate, resilient person. You've made a profoundly positive impact on many lives. Thank you.
@martifingers
@martifingers Год назад
All that for sure... smart too.
@pythondrink
@pythondrink 4 месяца назад
How did you unsubscribed for years? That's surprising, considering that it's easy to forget a YT channel exists since YT doesn't show videos from a channel on your home feed.
@stevenfeduk4833
@stevenfeduk4833 4 месяца назад
Boy, I hope YT is RU-vid and not Youth Television. Getting’ old. I’ve believe I’ve watch Zod ‘s videos since he started producing RU-vid videos. I have never been subscribed to Zod’s channel until recently. Better double check that again now! I don’t know what you mean by, no videos in my home feed. I don’t like of favourite many videos. Is that what you mean? I think if the amount of RU-vid videos I watch showed up in a list, the list might be called: Time for a break!
@pythondrink
@pythondrink 4 месяца назад
@@stevenfeduk4833 yes, by YT I meant RU-vid. Your home feed is the page you land when you open YT that contains videos that YT thinks you'll like. My point earlier on is that if you're not subbed to a YT channel, that means no post notifications. So you'd have to depend on two things: search out videos from that channel yourself and get a video from that channel in your home feed. Since you've been watching fod years, either or both of those should have kept happening throughout the years, which seems rly unlikely to me.
@ferragusslackwyrm
@ferragusslackwyrm Год назад
Thanks for covering this, Zod. I know Mike likes to masquerade as some kind of compassionate Christian Intelligentsia. Meanwhile, he spouts shite like that. Morally dubious bankrupt ideas and other repackaged dimestore apologetics. I would like to say, "It's a wonder he continues to get away with it. " Then I remember who his audience consists of.
@JasonHenderson
@JasonHenderson Год назад
I thoroughly enjoy mindshift.
@andysims9184
@andysims9184 Год назад
I just found Mindshifts channel yesterday and I've reall enjoyed his content. I definitely recommend his channel as well
@graladue
@graladue Год назад
Is god being powerless in the face of the non believer *again*? God needs to up his game. Although we do have an awful lot of iron (steel anyways) chariots nowadays.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
Remember, mike starts off claiming "God is hidden" is a claim God has failed, but then wants to make it the ATHEIST who failed when God hides. So he's saying God is powerless, only humans have power, and can beat God at everything. Personally, I'd just say to this kind of christian "There is no God, and a non-existent God can't talk to you, so it wasn't God you heard, it was the same fiction internal voice that every other non-christian religion hears.".
@rimbusjift7575
@rimbusjift7575 Год назад
It always fun when they leave a logical loophole in step one.
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
@@markhackett2302 Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism). What you realised that Etheism is just an empty cult? That Have nothing to offer to you, or to the humanity? It leads to nowhere? To the Obsession for God? For Christianity? That there is not comfort on it??? And that live and die as an alone godless person is not the best you can have? Just as have the idea that once you die you will be Nothing (and Nothing you are now, as you become what you think you will be once death) is not the best for your mental and psychological stability? Or have sacred things (as other people have) and you do not (such God) is so idiot that you are rething about everything and start to believe that Atheism is not but a BS, and a trap you are in?????!!!
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
@@markhackett2302 Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism). What you realised that Etheism is just an empty cult? That Have nothing to offer to you, or to the humanity? It leads to nowhere? To the Obsession for God? For Christianity? That there is not comfort on it??? And that live and die as an alone godless person is not the best you can have? Just as have the idea that once you die you will be Nothing (and Nothing you are now, as you become what you think you will be once death) is not the best for your mental and psychological stability? Or have sacred things (as other people have) and you do not (such God) is so idiot that you are rething about everything and start to believe that Atheism is not but a BS, and a trap you are in?????!!!
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
@@rimbusjift7575 Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism). What you realised that Etheism is just an empty cult? That Have nothing to offer to you, or to the humanity? It leads to nowhere? To the Obsession for God? For Christianity? That there is not comfort on it??? And that live and die as an alone godless person is not the best you can have? Just as have the idea that once you die you will be Nothing (and Nothing you are now, as you become what you think you will be once death) is not the best for your mental and psychological stability? Or have sacred things (as other people have) and you do not (such God) is so idiot that you are rething about everything and start to believe that Atheism is not but a BS, and a trap you are in?????!!!!
@not_enough_space
@not_enough_space Год назад
Mike likes to keep the issue limited to one particular person making a claim. It's somewhat easy to question the sincerity of one single person. But the divine hiddenness argument isn't about that one particular person, and questioning that one person's sincerity doesn't save God. The idea is that a nonresistant nonbeliever should be impossible, given certain common claims about God. That is, there should be exactly zero in the entire history of the world. He's got to question the sincerity of every single one there has ever been. And at that point Mike's strategy passes right through implausible and settles down in absurd.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
The only way Mike can comfort himself on this (and many, actually) issue, is to invent an atheist with invented questions/problems. If he actually engaged with atheists (he does not) he might be able to refine his arguments, or, shock horror, abandon them.
@whatwecalllife7034
@whatwecalllife7034 Год назад
Mike seems to "solve" this problem by assuming that such people do not exist.
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism)..
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
@@whatwecalllife7034 Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism)...
@PrometheanRising
@PrometheanRising Год назад
In spite of his insistence that he doesn't mean for his argument to apply to everyone, there is no way to give this sort of presentation without the expectation that the people that see it as ammunition will use it against every atheist that they meet.
@adrielschmunck9054
@adrielschmunck9054 Год назад
The clasic "im right and if you don't arrive at the same conclusion, you are wrong and/or lying" response. It seams like a lot of apolegetics boils down to that
@grapeshot
@grapeshot Год назад
Yes the invisible sky wizard loves hiding in other dimensions.
@letsomethingshine
@letsomethingshine Год назад
It’s for your free will that His non-biological eternal maleness hides, but here’s his signature bibliolatry! On the other hand, your real friends keep pushing everything on you by merely existing physically and don’t ever write you a one-way book (single version of many versions/canons) or say contradicting things to different people unless they feel it convenient among themselves to finally agree on one issue or another.
@jeffreyfiegen1538
@jeffreyfiegen1538 Год назад
When I was trying to find God during my journey out of religion (that's what I call it), I didn't just go to church and pray in public like Winger said, I prayed silently and/or behind closed doors, like the bible said to do.
@ianmacfarlane1241
@ianmacfarlane1241 Год назад
No worship songs? That's why you never found Gawd - you need to break out the acoustic guitar. See, you weren't trying hard enough.😂
@jeffreyfiegen1538
@jeffreyfiegen1538 Год назад
@ianmacfarlane1241 I unironically read the first part like the "So no head?" vine.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
I hear, many now Ex-Christians during their early doubts and waking up, prayed and groveled and begged God to do something. Of course, a not existent being can't do anything. So they with much pain did get out of the cult and retrospectively realized they had been fooled and brainwashed.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@stultusvenator3233 Mike does NOT want to hear this. It does not fit with his narrative.
@donaldnumbskull9745
@donaldnumbskull9745 Год назад
In the sense that Mike Winger's god is Mike Winger, I have heard from him.
@silverharloe
@silverharloe Год назад
My landlord wants rent, so I spend all my time trying to prove he doesn't exist and that he can't evict me.
@stephanklein257
@stephanklein257 Год назад
Na-ah - fixing the analogy for you: Random people tell you the house you're living in has a landlord, who wants 10% of your money, has obscure rules to follow, loves you, and will torture you if you don't love him back. When you ask to see the guy, he is completely incommunicado - so you decide he's fake, and you stop handing over the "rent" to his "emissaries" and demand to see the guy or else go f' themselves and their landlord along with them. And this is still a bad analogy, bcs we know houses are built and have owners, renting appartments is a thing etc.
@suziwolf4830
@suziwolf4830 Год назад
People like Mike are the reason I refer to myself as a seeker of *FACTS* and couldn't care less about Truth.
@halthammerzeit
@halthammerzeit Год назад
Like old Jew joke: Two Jews go to Rabbi with their dispute. He hears them and says to the one of them: - You're right. Other one says his arguments, and Rabbi says- You're right too. Third guy was listening to their dispute and said- but Rabbi, they can't be both right! - And you're right too!
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@halthammerzeit Except that, in every case, Mike is wrong.
@tos100returns
@tos100returns Год назад
Christians aren't seeking anything, as they proclaim to have found everything already.
@probablynotmyname8521
@probablynotmyname8521 Год назад
The problem with winger is that if a muslim put these idiotic arguments to him he would reject them, he really is a poor thinker.
@Venaloid
@Venaloid Год назад
Damn, not pulling any punches with the lead in, well done.
@rataflechera
@rataflechera Год назад
Your video on the issue was also well done
@Eric_01
@Eric_01 Год назад
As for me, and I think there are more like this than aren't, I came out of Christianity. Born into it, raised in it, believed in it, experienced all of the anxiety and fear that packages with it, and later actually stepped out of the bubble long enough to get the real answers. That's about as sincere as one can possibly be.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
I hear, many now Ex-Christians during their early doubts and waking up, prayed and groveled and begged God to do something. Of course, a not existent being can't do anything. So they with much pain did get out of the cult and retrospectively realized they had been fooled and brainwashed.
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@stultusvenator3233 Yes, in spite of what the likes of Mike Wingnut would have us believe, many of us did not want to lose our faith, but allowed truth to prevail anyway.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
@@lil-al Which I think takes a lot of courage and honesty. I hope as for me it was so worth it and opened the door to so much interesting knowledge, kindness and joy.
@ThisguySL
@ThisguySL Год назад
Nah. Must be lying. You didn't agree with what christian apologists said as soon as it left their mouth just because they said it, after all. /s
@lil-al
@lil-al Год назад
@@stultusvenator3233 Absolutely!!
@MatthewCaunsfield
@MatthewCaunsfield Год назад
That opening section is a glorious piece of editing. Speaks for itself and says it well.
@lawrenceshadai4966
@lawrenceshadai4966 Год назад
Ok, the sincerity of Atheists is to be questioned, but Christians are sincere. Double standards.
@reenie6738
@reenie6738 Год назад
You can absolutely question the sincerity of Christians. I don’t see why not.
@lawrenceshadai4966
@lawrenceshadai4966 Год назад
@@reenie6738 I was pointing out the double standard. I see attacking sincerity as a waste of time myself. But you are right in that if it works one way, it works the other.
@filipe.sm31
@filipe.sm31 Год назад
Sincerity shouldn't even be an issue. I could sincerely want to not believe that the sun is real, but that doesn't mean that I could deny the obvious fact that the sun exists. If God was as real and evident as the sun, there would not be a problem of "sincerity".
@filipe.sm31
@filipe.sm31 Год назад
Or even better, I can sincerely choose not to worship the sun, but I can't will myself to believe it doesn't exists
@mariolis
@mariolis Год назад
in September - October 2022 I started visiting churches of various denominations , going through the motions and pretending to pray, and partaking in communion not becausr i wanted to "try" it but because i never really went to church back when I was still a christian and i guess i wanted to try church out of curiosity ... a curiosity that was quickly fullfilled ... going to church all those sundays was a waste of time and it would have been much better if i had stayed home and sleeped in... i wasnt trying to go back to jesus or try to prove christianity wrong though... i guess what i got from this experiment was a bit interesting , so i dont actually regret trying it , but lets just say i dont plan on trying it again anytime soon
@ViiOlet810
@ViiOlet810 Год назад
It's so nice that you gave Mind Shift a shout-out 😊 thanks for another great video. A lot of people have been replying to Mike and it has been interesting to hear all the different takes
@absolutearcher3137
@absolutearcher3137 Год назад
like always for these people, the only sincere atheist isn't one.
@kevinfancher3512
@kevinfancher3512 Год назад
Winger seems to have an issue with a "philosophical" argument against the existence of god, yet all he has to support the existence of god is exactly that, philosophical. Also, Mike, dude, pay attention, atheists are not arguing that god has done a poor job of showing itself, we're saying that in places and at times one would expect to detect god we do not, therefore we have no reason as yet to believe the claim that god exists.
@DannyS177
@DannyS177 Год назад
I'm a fan of Mindshift! He makes really good videos.
@davidleedougherty6478
@davidleedougherty6478 Год назад
Being an Open Thinker is so rewarding, and such a relief in general. Truly more valuable than fame and fortune, mikey boy Also, just got my PoZ shirts in the mail. Sir Sic didn't offer tall sizes so i went with my other favorite content creator, and they fit, and look cool af!
@dross4207
@dross4207 Год назад
That’s okay, Sir Sic’s children can go without food for a couple of days. 😢
@marcomoreno6748
@marcomoreno6748 Год назад
​@@dross4207and by "children" you mean gullet, and by "food" you mean whiskey.
@garryfounds3737
@garryfounds3737 Год назад
It’s interesting that he thinks atheists feel like their sincerity is being attacked and that this makes the attack personal to them. I think that he sees atheists’ disbelief as an attack on his livelihood, and he takes THAT personally, which explains his utterly offensive and irrational behavior.
@sypherthe297th2
@sypherthe297th2 Год назад
Well money is the primary interest for these people so yeah.
@stultusvenator3233
@stultusvenator3233 Год назад
The Jesus Business.!!
@sypherthe297th2
@sypherthe297th2 Год назад
@@stultusvenator3233 Ah yes. . . the Jesus Corporation - "Our business is eternal life itself." Internally, however, it makes use of a different motto - "Obedience Breeds Discipline, Discipline Breeds Unity, Unity Breeds Power, Power is Life." At the beginning of the 21st century, the Jesus Corporation had become the largest commercial entity in the United States. Nine out of every ten homes contain one of its members. Its political and financial influence is felt everywhere. In public, its the world's leading purveyor of "love," "morality," and "charity." Unknown, even to its own members, its massive profits are generated by spreading hatred, fear, and ignorance as well as attempts to subvert democratic governance.
@christobotha7848
@christobotha7848 Год назад
Why would Mike tell you the argument without quotes from actual atheist instead use a ambiguous "a atheist"? Right, that would be too honest.
@hayuseen6683
@hayuseen6683 Год назад
7/10 athiests say they hate god, 3/10 lie about not hating god - 7/5 chrispians say
@christobotha7848
@christobotha7848 Год назад
@@hayuseen6683 🤣
@Liverpoolfc9karim
@Liverpoolfc9karim Год назад
@@hayuseen6683 9 out of 10 dentist agree with you !
@davidtaylor6663
@davidtaylor6663 Год назад
Prophet of Zod you nail it every time. I wish everyone listened to you
@Wehwehweh
@Wehwehweh Год назад
It is weird that "trying to find god" is even a requisite. Most things we know exist don't even want us to have a personal relationship with them and we found them even by accident. It seems if someone so powerful and willing to be known existed, we would know it no matter if we were trying to find it or not.
@pythondrink
@pythondrink 4 месяца назад
I agree
@coruscanta
@coruscanta 16 дней назад
This has been my biggest hang up for a while. If any other being wanted a relationship with me, step one is interacting with me in such a way that I’ll know it exists. But supposedly I’m failing step two or three or something by not following/loving a being that I haven’t even gotten through step one with. It’s all back asswards.
@shockbladezed2352
@shockbladezed2352 7 месяцев назад
The fact, that they dismiss atheist accounts for finding nothing where god should be, but assume personal experiences are a good argument, tells me enough about apologists.
@BaronVonSTFU
@BaronVonSTFU Год назад
I think this kind of reasoning can be flipped around on Christians. If we wanted to make broad sweeping statements about all believers we could say, "if Christians were REALLY honest about their pursuit of truth then more of them would lose their faith". I mean, I didn't have my whole life and network wrapped up in the church, but even to this day I still occasionally fear the mob boss god lurking in the shadows saying "Love me, or else....." I think they think atheists are dishonest about seeking the truth because they are looking at "our truth" as the death of everything in their lives that they might hold dear. Not to mention eternal torment. They think we are as dishonest as they are.
@domecrack
@domecrack Год назад
Hey algorithm - if there's anyone on earth I'd gladly swap personalities with, it's POZ.
@Captain-Cosmo
@Captain-Cosmo Год назад
I recently had someone tell me that the reason I did not see the outward evidence for God is because of my unwillingness to look inward for him. I didn't want to straw man his argument, so I asked again. Sure enough, he insisted, you won't see the evidence on the outside until you first see the evidence on the inside. And that, he said, is how you meet God halfway. Huh???
@lnsflare1
@lnsflare1 Год назад
Is Mike still sincerely seeking Shiva?
@paulteti
@paulteti Год назад
or The Great Green Arkleseizure.
@imaginativeskydadytm1389
@imaginativeskydadytm1389 Год назад
Is Mike sincerely seeking Lisa the Rainbow Giraffe?
@pythondrink
@pythondrink 4 месяца назад
​@@imaginativeskydadytm1389 this is blasphemy. You can't refer to the goddess that way. Address her this way: Lisa the Rainbow Giraffe (LBUH)
@0nlyThis
@0nlyThis Год назад
Why do the gospel writers have Jesus teaching his disciples in Greek? Why didn't Jesus leave us writings of his own? Didn't he consider his teachings worth the trouble? Was he illiterate?
@donaldnumbskull9745
@donaldnumbskull9745 Год назад
Palestinians in Jesus's time spoke Greek and Aramaic. His name, Yeshua, is Aramaic, but it's likely that he spoke Greek also. Literacy in any language was rare everywhere - maybe 3% - so he and his disciples were almost certainly illiterate. By the time the Gospels were written (c. 70-110 CE) Christianity had spread through the empire, so Greek, the international language, was the logical choice, but it was probably the best choice for circulation in Palestine, too. Hope this helps.
@travis1240
@travis1240 Год назад
Yes, apparently Jesus was both illiterate and thought the world was going to end in his lifetime anyway, so no point in writing anything down.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
@@donaldnumbskull9745 No, they didn't. SOME did, but very VERY few. It is very likely he didn't exist.
@marcomoreno6748
@marcomoreno6748 Год назад
Because, to grossly simplify, the NT was written by elite greeks as fan fiction of poor people in the Levant. Bilbo Baggins didn't write The Hobbit. (Audience gasps)
@0nlyThis
@0nlyThis Год назад
@@travis1240 So. Jesus was in error? Heavens to Murgatroyd!
@darrynreid4500
@darrynreid4500 Год назад
I am again led to the question of just how the hell do these people think everyone else owes them to try out their cult first, before concluding it consists of claims that are incoherent, untestable and demonstrably false.
@torquemadatheapostate8768
@torquemadatheapostate8768 Год назад
The mental gymnastics apologists go thru to try and justify magic and make believe never ceases to to amaze and disappoint.
@asagoldsmith3328
@asagoldsmith3328 Год назад
Always comes back to "how do you know reality is real"
@ancientflames
@ancientflames Год назад
@@asagoldsmith3328and yet their entire faith is based on their own or others mystical experiences. All rooted in reality. 😅😅
@asagoldsmith3328
@asagoldsmith3328 Год назад
@@ancientflames "I only trust reality because I have a basis of faith in a god that I only believe in because I heard about it from other people" moment
@fudgesauce
@fudgesauce Год назад
One thing that rubs me a bit raw is the demand that I be a sincere seeker. If I suggested to Winger that he should sincerely seek out Zeus, or any of the thousands of other Gods, I guarantee he'd be unwilling to spend even a moment. But having grown up in a Christian household, going to mass weekly, making offerings, praying before meals and nightly ... the fault is mine for not being sincere enough that I ended up a non-believer. What Winger and his kind mean by "sincere seeker" is really that they want me to seek *his* conception of God, to live as *his* type of Christian, to try it on for a while and see if I grow to like it. For instance, if Winger if I had really tried to find God and I said, "Yes, I read the Koran from cover to cover," he would say, "Of course you won't find God there." Had I said, "I spent six months in an ashram," he would again say, "of course you won't find God there." In fact, I strongly suspect if I said I attended Catholic mass daily for a year he'd also say, "Of course you won't find God there."
@fudgesauce
@fudgesauce Год назад
... and of course, just after sending this, I continued watching the video and Zod addressed some of these same points.
@Leith_Crowther
@Leith_Crowther Год назад
If theists are talking about God’s morality, attributes, or process before establishing their existence, they’re putting the money before the goods before the cart before the horse.
@Mar-dk3mp
@Mar-dk3mp Год назад
Why godless alone people are obsessed with God?? and talk about him more then a believer? Well for many reason.... 1) About that BS called atheism there is not much things to say, no value, no sacred things and and it leads to nothing. 2 And then because they know they are so many godless alone people that will run to kiss their ass... 3 they do that so this cult can be alive, otherwise is destined to vanish, exactly from the nothing it comes... because is nothing but a cult that has nothing to offer to us and neither to the godless alone people who belonged to 4 And finally this cult will be vanished without those videos and those godless alone people will be just alone. And who said the opposite is a godless alone hypocrite. This cult called atheism is so empty... And those godless alone people really have nothing to offer to themselves. They have less sacred things then us... what an idiots they are for that too. Let's hope in a better generation because this is so lost. You are into an empty cult that leads you nowhere... No respect for you, godless ass kisser.... You really left God to put BS and emptiness in your miserable Life. No Pity for you. (God is always you do not know)..... We need to move to a better generation, and Hope godless alone people like you will not exist anymore in the future (you are worthless your cult called atheism). What you realised that Etheism is just an empty cult? That Have nothing to offer to you, or to the humanity? It leads to nowhere? To the Obsession for God? For Christianity? That there is not comfort on it??? And that live and die as an alone godless person is not the best you can have? Just as have the idea that once you die you will be Nothing (and Nothing you are now, as you become what you think you will be once death) is not the best for your mental and psychological stability? Or have sacred things (as other people have) and you do not (such God) is so idiot that you are rething about everything and start to believe that Atheism is not but a BS, and a trap you are in?????!!!
@ScientiaHistoria
@ScientiaHistoria Год назад
The fatal weakness of Mike’s spiel was never addressing the question of why god would hide from (not just refrain from contacting) the supposedly insincere. (zod notes this.)
@bobvail1000
@bobvail1000 4 месяца назад
Your clarification of "your god failed" vs "your argument failed" was GREATLY appreciated because your knowledge of subjects such as logic and rhetoric are much better than mine and you have such a fine ability to communicate that knowledge. I couldn't put into words my dissatisfaction with being painted into the corner of "blaming God". I was past my emotional stage of achieving atheism. I have no emotion invested in God not existing.
@phantomofkrankor3665
@phantomofkrankor3665 Год назад
The chestnut that you will believe in god if you try hard enough has two major problems. First, let’s say you try really hard but still don’t believe. Well you didn’t try hard enough - moving the goalposts. And second I don’t wanna. This is their crap, not mine😊. Love your videos!
@davidofoakland2363
@davidofoakland2363 Год назад
Still crushing it, Prophet of God! Keep it up and I hope to see you on one of those call in shows soon.
@WetDoggo
@WetDoggo Год назад
There's definitely a lot going on in a humans heart, it pumps blood around the body and even itself.
@IvyLeather13
@IvyLeather13 Год назад
In the words of Jason Hudson: It's not about truth, it's about who you choose to believe.
@Erik-hi
@Erik-hi Год назад
The problem with a lot of his arguments is I can use them to defend other religions the same way and his argument falls apart. For example when he says an atheist not finding his god is them being insincere. I can say the same thing about him not experiencing Allah, Odin, Vishnu, etc.
@stevenbolin7688
@stevenbolin7688 5 месяцев назад
Thanks for promoting Mind shift, Brandon is really good at this for being new. Love both of your shows because of the truth in the information and your calm demeanor 😊.
@matt2027
@matt2027 Год назад
12:14 I never did that, and never would, but when I was in college a classmate of mine did. They went to a Catholic mass, received communion, and seemed a bit proud to state how they didn't get anything out of it.
@kevinstewart1878
@kevinstewart1878 Год назад
I have to say, I do enjoy this format, and your approach, and all as it is now. But, man...!, I really enjoyed your earlier cartoon format, and would love to see new ones, just putting the suggestion out there.
@_specialneeds
@_specialneeds Год назад
Yeah I love that attitude about how you just have to try enough and you can hear from God. So a purely omnipotent being still needs us to take up the slack? So why doesn't God blow my mind from the get-go and be done with it.?
@bodricpriest8816
@bodricpriest8816 Год назад
That intro was pretty damn fine Zod, clear and powerful with clearly specific evidence behind your position.
@darwinskeeper421
@darwinskeeper421 Год назад
I'm a little confused about Mike's argument. Is he saying that the Christian God only appears to people he believes are sincerely seeking him (and hides from the rest of us) or that he clearly reveals himself to all, and some people refuse to notice?
@sanaltdelete
@sanaltdelete Год назад
Teachings like this contributed to my deconversion because it contributed to my OCD. I had a couple of doubts and changed my mind about some parts of the bible, these kids of teachings made me feel like those things were a sin and moral failure so I ended up in a downward spiral of me trying to make me unconvinced of evidence I couldn’t unsee, which when it failed made me feel I had no faith at all, which made me seek God on my knees 24/7 for years, putting him first over work and family. I fasted continually and became a complete emotional and psychological wreck. At some point I couldn’t psychologically take it anymore and ran to the other side, researching all the things I felt like I couldn’t research before. Now I have stabilized a little bit (but not fully) and am an agnostic, which is a very painful position sometimes.
@petersullivan9559
@petersullivan9559 Год назад
Maybe I'm missing something, but why would I need to look sincerely in order for an all-powerful entity to make itself known? I find things I'm not looking for all the time.
@SegaMSE
@SegaMSE Год назад
Usually I watch videos to the end before writing a comment but dude, awesome intro!
@brandongruber7835
@brandongruber7835 Год назад
Gotta love a guy who projects. Let me attack the sincerity of others in an insincere way myself.
@BillGarrett
@BillGarrett Год назад
I'm finding it more and more useful to talk about God's attributes in terms of a stack of priorities. For example, if we talk about what God wants, we can get answers like "for humans to have free will" or "for a universe where there is no sin" or "for everyone to know him". Then we can present claims and ask questions about what those claims say about which of those priorities God favors. In my limited experience with this method, the contradictions become evident pretty quickly.
@therealzilch
@therealzilch Год назад
I just found God. He was hiding behind the sofa all the time.
@lyndislegion287
@lyndislegion287 Год назад
I found mine in the fridge. Guess I accidentally left him there while looking for snacks
@adcaptandumvulgus4252
@adcaptandumvulgus4252 Год назад
The poz end credit thing like PBS used to do is great brought back lots of nostalgia
@MarkLeBay
@MarkLeBay Год назад
17:45 - why is it so hard to find a resourceful god who wants to found?
@WillPhil290
@WillPhil290 4 месяца назад
This was very well done. What baffles me is that, I think Mike Winger is a pretty smart guy. Listening to intelligent people go In circles trying to defend indefensible positions and disqualify the lived experiences of other people who think differently, makes me sad. I feel like this guy was completely robbed of his ability to think critically in this aspect. You pointed out how any change in ones thinking could be considered a failure, that made so much sense. I think for him, he's pretty terrified of that, by my summation...
@pwoods100
@pwoods100 Год назад
If there was a god who could keep Mike Winger hidden, I would be a follower......lol.
@kimlowe705
@kimlowe705 Год назад
Of course! That makes sense. The more the atheist looks for God, the better he conceals himself. It’s exactly the same with unicorns, leprechauns, the Easter Bunny and the Fairies at the bottom of the garden! Yep, that’s logical (I think)!
@TK-yz3wt
@TK-yz3wt Год назад
It's the same with claims of aliens visiting Earth. When asked for evidence about these visitations on Earth, the response is something along the lines of having stealth technology to conceal themselves. I guess the aliens must hiding near Uranus.
@markhackett2302
@markhackett2302 Год назад
@@TK-yz3wt Read up in the Original Cosmos. The best evidence was an alien abduction that took away someone's unborn baby. One radio show host, years later, asked "So were you pregnant at the time?" She said "No, of course not!". There's a disconnect.
@thing1thing2themediamaniac43
As a Former Christian I completely understand the position of the viewer/caller calling into Mike Winger's Podcast. I used to ask my parents and pastors questions just like the reason for God's Divine Hiddenous. When Christians ask these questions they want reassurrance to take away their doubts.
@jonathanaarhus224
@jonathanaarhus224 9 месяцев назад
One of the things I've noticed is that its not enough for apologists to merely believe that God exists. They need to believe that God is also good and loves them, otherwise it would defeat the purpose.
@JosephKano
@JosephKano Год назад
WHy do I have to look for these gods?
@herbevans2727
@herbevans2727 Год назад
That sequence at the start re gaslighting was very revealing of Mike's approach....still smiling!
@JoyfulArtist21
@JoyfulArtist21 Год назад
This is part of why I don't like Mike. He tries to come across as a decent, kind person. But when you actually listen to what he says, it reveals more of his character and how he sees people different from them. It's nastiness smothered in perfume to try and make it seem nicer than it actually is. And I honestly don't care if Mike or anyone else thinks I wasn't sincere in my search for god. If their god does exist and he's able to read minds, then he would know I was being sincere. And that would be the only person who mattered in that regard. I couldn't care less what a random Christian thinks about my personal search. And a good chunk of those of us who are now atheists were Christians trying to get a better relationship with god. I thought I was a "lukewarm" Christian and was trying to find a way to be closer to god. It sure did backfire.
Далее
When Christians Say Atheists Just "Deny God"
27:40
Просмотров 61 тыс.
ВЛАД А4 СКАТИЛСЯ
09:34
Просмотров 519 тыс.
How Christians Roleplay Being Free Thinkers
21:02
Просмотров 84 тыс.
Why so judgmental?
12:44
Просмотров 561
How Christians Deduce Atheists Must Be Depressed
23:21
Why Christianity Can't Understand Other Religions
22:33
Confusianity: The Struggle To Understand Salvation
37:00
How to Smugly Misunderstand Atheism
21:39
Просмотров 96 тыс.
6 Proofs for God's Existence
26:03
Просмотров 110 тыс.