Can we guess these TOP 10 Cy Young Pitchers ONLY by their Stats?! 

I want Passan to be here forever he’s great

Johan Santana in an Orioles hat is a cursed photo. Where did you guys even find that?

Tim Lincecum was an absolute streak of lightning and i miss watching him pitch so badly.

1. Passan getting medium because of how is amazing. 2. I did NOT have Millwood in Colorado.

Hope they always include Passan

I can't believe only one person got Randy Johnson lol. I was gonna scream if no one got him.😂

The breadth of Dalton's knowledge never fails to impress me. Passan is also a gem! I'm not a fan of sports pundits, but he has so much credibility b/c of reasonability, extensive knowledge of the game, and dedication to his craft. He's one of my all-time favorites.

I love Chris Carpenter to start it as EZ

I love Ervin Santana. That 2008 teams was one of my favorite with weaver and lackey

Knew Santana from that Braves year. He had received a qualifying offer and didn't find what he wanted on the market, ultimately signing with the Braves on a one year deal during spring training, after they had Medlen and Beachy get injured just days apart. This was before a player couldn't receive more than one QO, so the Braves offered him one again, and ultimately drafted Michael Soroka with the comp pick they got.

So when i was 12 we won the little league championship that year, why that's important is because chris carpenter was there to watch and hand us our trophies. His dad owned the business that was our sponsor. This would of been 2000-2001 so it was before he blew up but i remember him being sooooo cool. He stayed and took pictures with everyone and with us as a team and sat and talked to us about baseball. It was super cool.

Everyone: "I don't remember Ervin Santana with the Braves" Me, the Braves fan: "I only know this because of the Braves year." Shared a rotation that year with fellow Braves legend Aaron Harang

Passan should just join JM full time

Passan's energy is so fun. Great guest. 👍

Just when you think Sales Lucas has done it all, he does even more.

I watched Kevin's no hitter with the Phillies vs the giants as a kid. And that's the only way I knew that one 😂

Missed the last one but I'm just glad I got Ervin Santana immediately.

Not only did Carpenter miss 1.5 seasons after TJ, he missed almost all of 2007 and 2008 and came back dealing.

Ervin Santana was also in an episode of Nitro Circus back in the day throwing tomatoes at the guys at full speed.

Absolutely love the Passan content

I get so hyped when I go 3 for 3 on these. I started watching baseball the same time y’all did so these are so nostalgic for me

14:43 Santana with the Baltimore cap is a strange error.

I have not thought about Kevin Millwood in over a decade and I don't know who I channelled to say his name on that, amazed myself. Got 8/10, missed Halladay and Johan while thinking Felix and Price got a 2nd

Wow I can’t believe that none of them got Randy except Jolly he was the first guy I thought of

For the 3rd one, anytime I think of pitchers who played in Atlanta and Colorado I go right to Mike Hampton - but I knew it wasn't him, and couldn't remember his name anyway. The closest I got was "Mike Hailwood" (the motorcycle racer), but some fun word association got me to the right guy.

Can't believe it took me as long as it did to get medium, yet hard was 5 seconds. 🤦🏼‍♂️

the 5 complete games and 3 shutouts for Philly in '03 was the giveaway for me. really good set players this episode.

So cool to see Ervin Santana, I can't exactly put my finder on why, but I absolutely loved him with the twins

Oooooo more Jeff passion content W

I blindly got easy; I’m too young to remember him ever being in Toronto. Got medium instantly because he was one of the better arms for that era of Angels teams. Hard was a wild guess but I somehow got it.

I always remember Ervin Santana on the Braves, strictly because of the Adrelton Simmons defensive highlights.

Anybody who only had basic cable in the late 90s and therefore watched every Braves game on TBS should remember Kevin Millwood. Denny Neagle was another guy who magically got good for a season just by pitching with the Three Braves Aces.

What's the music at the start of the video it's so FLAMES

Ervin “magic” Santana Never cheered so loud and wanted to punch my TV more in the same season then watching this dude

That Chris carpenter one really threw me off glad I got it. Had no idea he was a blue jay since I only started following baseball closely around 05

That’s a dope hat that Dan has. 🔥

11:50 darn it! Couldn’t get Millwood before the first correct guess😂

Outro was delightful

Jeff Passan is too good! Potential Future Theme: Rule 5 Draftees?

Passan is awesome on these.

I was saying the exact same thing about wainwright and carpenter being the same person in my brain 😂😂

Jeff Passan is a machine

For the longest time I thought Toronto and St Louis Chris Carpenter were two different players.

Damn Jeff Passan winning RefGuess and filling MLB Connect in 12 seconds

Passan looking like a Mormon missionary and dropping F-Bombs is hilarious.

Cardinals won multiple world series on carps back. Most clutch pitcher they have had in a long long time.

Many years of sporcle quizzes helped me get the bonus question haha

3 for 3 today. I'm hyped

Okay. Passan is actually the best. Nice!!

Listening to passan curse while he's got a suit and tie on with the pretty boy hair makes me lose it.😂😂

Hell yeah 2012 Kevin Millwood! Got that Co-No hitter because he got hurt and had to leave the game after like 5 innings lol

The first two I blanked on but got Millwood immediately. Crazy

Oh man starting pitchers. This is straight in my wheelhouse. I was able to maxmannis the first three, and got the trivia without much difficulties. Hooray for keeping track of the wins statistic every year since 2005.

As a british guy who barely is able to see baseball outside of youtube and games I think I did rather well with the final, 8/10 missed DeGrom and Halladay (worst bit I'd even said Halladay out loud but thought his 1st Cy Young came before 2000) I mean I even said Kluber as a neutral isn't half bad

DAMN. How did I not get Millwood? I'm sorry Kevin you had a good career, should have got it

Shoutout to Dalton for actually pronouncing Toronto right! Us canadians dont pronounce the second T

Ervin Santana followed me on twitter too at the time he was my only follower 😂😂

I'll absolutely never forget Ervin Santana's no hitter against Cleveland. He gave up a run and we couldn't do shit

2:27 The 1954 Indians. had 3 HOF pitchers and were swept by the Giants.

I’m so bad at this but today I actually got the first two!!

As a Cards guy I couldn't not get the first one, but somehow I'd completely forgotten he came up with the Blue Jays. Had no hope on the other two, my brain couldn't get past Jered Weaver even though I knew Weaver didn't pitch in 2021. Was proud of myself for getting 7 out of 10 of the multiple Cy Young - I knew Pedro was wrong, but I missed Kluber, Santana, and Big Time Timmy Jim. The one I was most confident with only to be wrong was I was sure Grienke had two, and my other guesses were Keuchel and Maddux but I knew they were wrong.

Disappointed I only got 4/10 on the final. COMPLETELY forgot about how dominant Lincecum and Kluber were.

The only one I blanked on for the 10 cy young winners was Kluber, I have no recollection of him winning two 😂

God I love Passan

Not getting kevin millwood drove me nuts i used to love that guy on the braves

Fun fact: Chris Carpenter was the pitcher that gave up the Manny Ramirez shot that went into the fifth deck of the SkyDome

I did good. This is fun! I need to do this with some friends.

I love Jolly and not just because he's a Mets fan

I'm usually pretty good at Ref guess, but I completely bombed on the second one. Completely forgot about Ervin Santana...

Idea: Players who played on the two teams farthest apart geographically: Mariners and Marlins. Easy: Ichiro or Jean Segura, Medium: Dee Strange-Gordon or Miguel Olivo, Hard: Logan Morrison or Arthur Rhodes

I got hard so quick and struggled so hard for medium until the Yankee/Twin WC game was brought up

I am a little shocked at how similar the team profiles of Kevin Millwood and Bruce Chen are: ATL, PHI, BAL, and TEX all in common.

Brandon Webb fucked me up good for the trivia game. I was never as sure as anything in my life as him having 2, turns out he had a win then two straight 2nd place finishes from '06-'08...

Have we ever seen Jeff passan & hoodie Allen in the same place?

i'm not sure what ethnicity jolly is but he's absolutely gunning for jake's title of italian stallion

they ain’t kiddin when they say ervin follows way too many people on twitter. he follows me 😂

I got Milwood right away because as a little kid I was at his no hitter

Not gonna lie I was drawing a blank on the second one until someone mentioned he started the 2017 WC game and then it clicked immediately, imma give myself the pass on that one

Haha, the only one I knew was Kevin Millwood!

I wanna see a max manis Jeff Passan head to head duel

Didn’t know Passan was with Jomboy Media

I think using the back of a baseball card for the stats would be a cool twist on this

4:16 Ervin Santana

Jolly got the same 8 I could think of

Thought that Millwood was Denny Neagle for a hot second

"Oh now I remember him. I was on a bus and breaking the news he was signing a new contract" Rest of the panel will have trouble matching stories like that.

Millwood 9:40

seeing degrom in the rangers hat still breaks my heart

“Crazy you said Barry Zito”

Damn I only got easy this week 😂

Jolly should do players who won the ASG MVP

Jake said “Maxwell Scherzer”, but his first name is actually Maximum

Passan looks like Hoodie Allen's uncle

Dan, from seconds 40-55; you are speaking exactly what I was thinking. When I paused and thought about who this could be. “You’re not wainwright. Who the fuck are you”. DAN, you are him, and you are the man.! Fax

where do you get off using the orioles johan photo and not the twinkies

Imagine my shock when I answered Chris sale for the trivia round and found out he has ZERO cy young’s

Has there ever been a player who played for all 3 bird teams?

I have to join everyone else and give Passan His Love Due The More He’s on The Merry Also, I can not believe how quick y’all can pull some of these out Let alone at all I completely forgot about Kevin Millwood , Like ever even existing Same with Santana until You said His name I totally remember Him even with Braves for a sec & He was 1 I couldn’t believe I didn’t get But Millwood , Man He was Good I can’t beLive he deleted from My brain until this I got Carpenter off Cuff I couldn’t remember His last name for a minute. Lol I said “ Chris Singleton or something like that 🤔 No… That dude played CF …. Chris… CARP! Duhh. “ 😁

Sometimes I feel like the mediums are harder than the hards lol

I didn't even watch baseball in 2003 and I knew Kevin Millwood's no hitter, lowkey Phillies legend