Arthur can beat Tommy and the Pinhead like nothing, and take on 40 npcs at once. Arthur/John could easily beat the living Hell out of her if she didn't have that damn plot armor.
@@KangarooMonkey No, it's probably more than 40, actually. I once was literally fighting those guys for like 30 mins straight and they just kept coming. It's like a bell goes off in every black guy's head in Saint Denis when one of their boys is fighting.
@@VioletPistols I mean at once. If it was one at a time I might be able to do that too. But either way that’s pretty impressive, but I don’t think it makes sense story wise. Just like how a bullet in a cutscene will kill a character but in gameplay mode it just hurts. So she is better than him, but the game can’t account for player skill.
I was fighting her and I was dodging so many shots and landing so many significant strikes on her I manage to knock her down and I kicked her down again she got up I went up to her close she pushed me and I collapsed and woke up outside 😑
I did too. I lost few times before quite easily but 1 minutes ago I dropped her 3 times and did touch couples of times I still lost against her but hardly. I fought her as a John. In Epilogue 2. She's the strongest character in game when comes to fight in brute strength.
Dude, I just kept dodging and laying haymakers on her for a solid 9-10 minutes and she still just pushed me and I woke up outside!!! Like wtf! Arthur gave tommie brain damage and after knocking this woman’s lights out multiple times… she just pushed me and I flop like a fish…
@@lookatstephwardellcurryman397 Well I did this at Chapter 2 before he even got TB from Mr. Downes and lost only 10% of my health, yet I still got knocked out -.-
It would have been nice if you were able to beat her yeah. I think it could have been a funny moment if she saw you in the crowd if you beat her and then she rematches you but, sadly this I’ll never happen
It's a design feature. It's the attack she uses at the end, it's designed to one hit ko you. It gives the illusion of of it being a random blow, but it's always that blow to the jawline. If you can back off that somehow you're good, but if I know game devs, there's one of 2 options they used. Either that move represents she's hit the condition to prompt it, which it is possible that it's health based and thus, only happens when she's low health. Or she's just a punching bag with no real stats, just moves to make.
@@drapplebees409 Quite literally unbeatable. Not one singular player has ever beaten her. If you somehow dodge all her attacks and hit her a lot, she will punch you once no matter once and instantly knock you out.
@@mikeshrout2870when you see the climb on stage button press it and quickly press RT but shoot her immediately cause when the fight starts the game puts your gun away
Its pretty annoying they made her unbeatable. If they had just made her really difficult to beat it would've been fair, but giving her unlimited life and unblockable attacks is cheap.
@@RealAstroWhale she's invincible though so what is your point.. Also Trevor is only invincible during his ability when it runs out then she will definitely kill her.
She looks really cool! It would be like fighting the She-hulk! Awesome, she might be strongest character in the game but truth be told i didn't knew about this, i need to go to the theatre more often! Although she would be nothing compared to Sasquatch from Cyberpunk.
People are so mad in the comments 😂 as if it’s a real debate. “Arthur could easily beat her if it wasn’t for plot armor” Just like Arthur beats everyone he comes across because of plot armor lol it just goes to show Hortensia is a stud of an Athlete, and she deserves her title as world strongest women. Beating a large over 6 foot enforcer of a gunslinger in a fair fist fight is impressive. It’s what she does for a living. I like hortensia even before I fought her and lost. I cheer her on everytime I see her because she’s not a fraud or a fake. Just like Benjamin Lazarus. They’re the two stage entertainers that I actually enjoy watching because they actually let members of the audience put their worth on the line.
@@TheBlarggle No we are not, because we are only responding to attacks these so called SJWs are pathetically attempting to do. If they didn't shit on us we wouldn't fucked with them in the first place, BITCH.
Yeah I find it stupid that she's unbeatable. Seems like you could originally beat her but they didn't really wanna cause controversy so they just decided to maker her unbeatable
@@themanfromthesouth8697 i did in chapter 2 when Arthur was in his prime keep in mind Arthur gave Tommy brain damage beat the big guy who tortured him also Arthur is pretty big strong guy who can lift a wagon weel and throw a full grown buck over his shoulder pretty dumb that he cant beat her in chapter 2 even when i knocked her to the floor 8 times.
She's quite possibly the strongest character in the RDR series, maybe behind Strange Man because they're unaffected by bullets and I swear is some kind of spirit. I'd like to see a fight between her and Charles, while on a technical standpoint she'd win due to mechanics, it would be cool to see them fight since both are described as being super strong.
She’s probably the strongest in red dead. It’s never confirmed if Charles or Arthur is the better fighter. Charles is more muscular but Arthur has beaten bigger foes. Since she is scripted to knock Arthur out I think it’s safe to say she’s the best.
@@nitrix6033 yeah they should have just made her super hard to beat so that only few people could and given some sort of hidden cutscene or they should’ve made it so that in the fight she throws Arthur off stage and Arthur gets up saying he’s not done yet and the show man stops him from carrying on and closes the curtains resulting in a no contest. Would’ve been much better than simply watching her get her ass handed to her by Arthur just for her to KO him in one uppercut. Looks like lazy writing to me.
For me i cheated by spawning the machine gun turret and bam dead and the show continued and i'm happy that she is dead even Benjamin Lazarus who hung himself
“You’re dying Black Lung” *piano music starts playing* _Hortensia proceeds to beat the absolute living goddamn helluva fucking shit out of Micah and breaks his neck on her knee_
Dodge all her attacks, only using counters and controlled strikes. Spent 10 minutes fighting her instead. She has infinite health and literally can’t die, so you’re just meant to lose, which is total bullcrap imho. R* should have made it so that she can 1-hit KO you, but at the same time she can still be defeated for players skilled and careful enough to dodge all her attacks. Feminisms BS shouldn’t allow me to NOT be able to beat an NPC that I am playing well against. The fact that I can’t beat her is totally stupid and I’m saying this as a woman.
I lost quite easily few times before but 1 minutes ago I lost again but hardly even I dropped her 3 times and did touch couples of times and did blocked her punches couples of times. She got hit from me more than she managed to land punches.
I got knocked out LOL I beat the heck out of her for a long time too I didn't even know it's possible to beat her I thought it was scripted or something because I beat on the lady for like 40 minutes it seemed like
