Тёмный

Can You Cohabitate Leopard Geckos? A Revision of Leopard Gecko Cohabitation ft. Reptiles & Research 

JTB Reptiles
Подписаться 12 тыс.
Просмотров 23 тыс.
50% 1

Reptile keepers are, for once, almost unanimous in their opinions about something: they don't think that keeping leopard geckos together is in the animals' best interests. However, this notion rests upon the assumption that cohabitation has no beneficial aspects as far as a leopard gecko is concerned, and in this video I aim to illustrate why this is incorrect.
Many of the topics I have covered in previous videos - such as why all reptiles should be offered ultraviolet lighting - have been contentious in that they go against the grain of popular opinion. However, in most of these cases, I have been explaining things about reptile care which are strictly true or false, or at least close to this (we don't have any good reason to suppose that any of the reptiles we keep do not benefit from the right intensity of UVB, to continue my last example). This time, however, there are significant reasons why cohabitation might not be recommended: leopard geckos can fight, can bully each other, and can ultimately kill each other. So what case can really be made in favour of cohabitation?
Put simply, we have to take note of the benefits which are brought (to the lizards) by keeping leopard geckos together. These benefits are not widely recognised, so today we have to take a look at a couple of scientific papers for me to get the point across that naturally, leopard geckos are not the solitary animals people think they are.
Only when we compare the benefits to the costs of introducing leopard geckos to each other are we able to come to a valid conclusion as to whether we should do so or not: it is my view that, if (and only if) sufficient precautions are taken to ensure its success, cohabitation is not only viable but to be recommended.
Papers referred to in the video are:
Natural history and biology of hobbyist choice leopard gecko Eublepharis macularius, Muhammad Sharif Khan - www.researchgate.net/publicat...
Social experience affects territorial and reproductive behaviours in male leopard geckos, Eublepharis macularius, Jon Sakata et al -www.researchgate.net/publicat...
PHEROMONAL DISCRIMINATION OF SEX BY MALE AND FEMALE LEOPARD GECKOS (Eublepharis macularius), Cooper & Steele - www.researchgate.net/publicat...
Visit the official Reptiles & Research RU-vid channel - / @reptilesandresearch
New to my channel? You might want to start here - • Ceramic Heater & Heat ...
Follow nature’s example - ru-vid.com...
Instagram - jtb_reptile...
Facebook - / jtb-reptiles-472487643...
The supplies I use - kit.co/JTB_Reptiles
Advancing Herpetological Husbandry - / advancingherphusbandry
Reptile Lighting Group - / reptilelighting
The Reptile Networks - reptilenetworks.co.uk

Животные

Опубликовано:

 

22 ноя 2020

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 143   
@RuddGerrath
@RuddGerrath 5 месяцев назад
Can we get an update on this? How are your leopard geckos doing after 3 years?
@Alex-fw6ur
@Alex-fw6ur 3 года назад
It’s beautiful to watch them climbing, hunting, socializing, camouflaging into specific parts of environment etc. Their sleeping spots towards the end (the cute “aw sleeping together” moment) was no random ‘just dropped there’ thing, they went to spots that best matched their specific patterning etc. Idk, I just love seeing it. Gives a totally different insight to their more normal world, and as sweet as it is having a human x animal bond with your leo geck with handling etc, it’s so much nicer to see them like this too.
@Garrettito6671
@Garrettito6671 3 года назад
I had a male and two female leopard geckos in a 48x24x24 inch tank growing up. They never had problems because I gave them plenty of space, five hides of different temperatures, and plenty of enrichment (fake plants, climbing logs, rock pile etc). Cohabitation works great when done properly. They’re also super smart animals. One of the females used to glass dance but only when my dog was in the room for what I can only assume the purpose was to get him mad and then she would watch him smash his stupid flat face against the glass. Wouldn’t run. Just sit there and watch and move around when he stopped hitting the glass. Funniest thing I’ve ever seen. That had to be a sense of humor in some form. I’ve never been able to explain it any other way
@ReptilesandResearch
@ReptilesandResearch 3 года назад
Thanks for having me on, such an interesting topic, making me want leopard geckos, their ecology is fascinating!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
A pleasure, Liam! Leopard geckos belong to a truly fascinating species, as common in the pet trade as they are!
@pcuneo4243
@pcuneo4243 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles I find common pet reptiles are often overlooked as being basic or not impressive but really they are only common due to hardyness or for being easy to produce. But really they are often misrepresented and actually far more complex!
@SachiYasui
@SachiYasui 2 года назад
Question for both Reptiles and Research and JTB Reptiles! I love both of your channels! I'm looking into giving a lot of my animals upgrades in the near future. I am in the planning and saving money stage. I have a male and female leopard gecko, each currently in 20 gallon long tanks. I initially had them together in a 48x24x15 and they got along swimmingly, of course I monitored for conflict, but they were happy. However, upon reading about how it is never recommended to keep leopard geckos together, I separated them, and had to put them in smaller enclosures due to lack of space. Now, I have 3 options: get 1 4x2x2 for both of them, get a 2x2x2 for each of them, or get 2 48x24x16s for each of them. If I were to cohab them again, I'd like to get a third leopard gecko, female. Which enclosure configuration do you guys think would be best for them? I've already had them together before and saw them get along for the longest time, but I succumbed to peer pressure and separated them. I don't have a desire to breed them however, but my male has seemed pretty depressed since I separated the two. Any advice?
@3012ftp
@3012ftp 3 года назад
Interesting video on an often discussed topic! . I can tell my experience that i made with cohabing Leopard Geckos: from 2015-2018 i've had 4 females in a 150x60x60cm enclosure (which is a big tank) out of the reason, as you said, i could acquire more than one animal without having to get more enclosures. i would not do it again. they hat a structured background and lots of hides. It worked for a certain amount of time and one day it just didn't anymore. you never know with leopard geckos, because they only tolerate each other they don't bond and they don't cuddle. the most dominant one chased the others around, i could hear it when the lights were out. it was the worst after brumating.. they had moonshaped bitemarks on the head and tail. i saw at the end of the video one of your females has those too. those are not signs of shedding, those are bitemarks, so i would keep an eye out on that. we can't observe our animals 24/7 so we don't get to see all of their interactions and the pressure of the male wanting to mate is not to be underestimated. In my opinion, interaction/stress is what on one side makes the life of wild animals but it also shortens their lifespan. And they have unlimited space to get away from each other what captive animals don't. So i keep my Leopard Geckos separate, less stress for them and less stress for me. for me it's just not worth the risk anymore ;) maybe keeping them together for a certain amount of time and then separating them could be a way to go, to give them social enrichment but also keep them safe. i'm excited to see how your little group works out, i know you're doing your best for them :)
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
I was aware of the marks on my geckos and what they were. They appeared on day one of putting them together and were gone with the next shed, not yet to return - I think it was the results of my male's breeding antics. Separation is definitely the biggest key to long-term success with this, I think. It is, as you say, what makes a huge difference between captivity and the wild: there's only so much space in a box. If we have the ability to separate our animals at a moment's notice (and we pay enough attention to them to know when we might have to intervene), then it would be very unlikely indeed that any long-term harm would come to them. As I argue in the video, for the time that they are living harmoniously, I think it a good bet that they will have a better quality of living than if they were to be alone; and so I think we should at least really consider this before writing off cohabitation entirely. On a slight tangent (which is more a point of speculation than a serious conjecture), your observation with your female leopard geckos matches something I have seen in my lined day geckos when I just had two females together (thinking one was a male). They got on for so long, clearly begrudgingly (I am not aware of lined day geckos being anywhere near as social as leopard geckos, but breeding projects necessitate cohabitation!), until one day the subordinate female kept attacking the dominant one. It was all rather sudden and unexpected. Within not-very-long the dominant female had reasserted her position and business resumed as usual. Still, they would be quite guarding over food and the dominant female would never share basking space with the subordinate. When I learned of the dominant female being, indeed, female and not male, I acquired an actual male, and the females immediately stopped being so aggressive towards each other (and have been calm ever since). The male, being so much larger than the females, is clearly the dominant member of the group. Could it be, then, that all-female groups are more prone to deterioration because the members of such groups are more evenly matched, so there is a potential for any individual to take the top position and therefore they fight for it? Does the presence of an obvious "ruler", a larger male, serve to calm the rest of the group because even the highest-ranking female will still always be below the male in the pecking order? The male never has to assert his dominance; the females would never contest it seriously. Perhaps, then, my mixed-sex leopard gecko group is better set up for long-term success - maybe? (I am ignoring the implications of breeding here, but again, this is more a paragraph of food for thought than anything serious. We shall have to wait and see!)
@3012ftp
@3012ftp 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles if those marks didn't appear anymore that's great to hear. i agree with you and i think everyone should decide for themselves and educate themselves before making a decision to cohabite or not. Interesting assumption you're making regarding your observation your daygeckos. I don't have any experience in keeping mixed sex leopard gecko groups so i can't say if this might be true or not. But i'm excited to see how your group is evolving over time and i like that you're very open to proper discuss this topic. That's only one of the reasons i love your channel so much!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
@@3012ftp Discussion is what it's all about! Thank you :)
@ricardosmythe2548
@ricardosmythe2548 3 года назад
I have 2 adult females I cohab, they have been together since a young age. There Viv is huge but they stay close to each other all the time even sharing hides despite them having multiple options. Never seen any issues in regards to feeding. Your video covers everything, people who are totally against cohab with leopard geckos are judging off old outdated information
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks for sharing your experiences!
@Scales13
@Scales13 3 года назад
Brilliant video. Love the background information put into this video on the topic.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks 😁
@lockman3962
@lockman3962 3 года назад
You are professional and extremely informative thanks so much for this video
@peaceupmtown
@peaceupmtown 3 года назад
This video explains exactly what I've been telling people about green iguanas and bearded dragons (yes they compete, but you will always find them in a group in their native habitat). I'm also a big fan of finding a good balance between a naturalistic enviorment and safety. Having parasites and breaking bones is very naturalistic, but we don't want this to happen with our animals. Keep the videos coming!
@joelselph6281
@joelselph6281 3 года назад
Thank you so much for this video!!!!! Very well done!!!! Love your enclosure!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks!
@mantissebastian1122
@mantissebastian1122 3 года назад
You are clearly very intelligent and good at this. Keep it up.
@joelselph6281
@joelselph6281 3 года назад
Thank you for this video. Very well done.
@ScorpionZam
@ScorpionZam 2 года назад
My females have been cohabitated since 2008. I didn't even know it was controversial, I just thought they were friends.
@sameen11Agehnejad
@sameen11Agehnejad Год назад
is it normal for them to fight or bite every once in a while?😊
@ScorpionZam
@ScorpionZam Год назад
@@sameen11Agehnejad no, only happened one time but I think it was an accident. They’re both pretty old now so I don’t think they’d fight anyway
@claytonwhite490
@claytonwhite490 3 года назад
Really enjoyed the video and I was just wondering how things have progressed after 4 months and now that the gecko's are becoming more active? I've read over the same paper and had similar thoughts to yours regarding the potential benefits of cohabitation. Someone has a similar setup but with more females in a larger tank on the AHH facebook page and she'd seen a lot of new behaviours that suggests cohabbing multiple females with a male has its advantages as well. After reading over the comments do you think that it may be beneficial to go larger with tank size in the future? Say a 6ft or 8ft long tank? I feel like it would further mitigate the chances of injuries and negative behaviour because each gecko would essentially have a normal tanks worth of room to spread out in if needed. Or potentially temporarily removing the females for a while whilst the male is being particularly bothersome
@PeterCGM
@PeterCGM 5 месяцев назад
Very intelligent and well-thought out!!
@Wysdrem
@Wysdrem 2 года назад
Hello I was wondering were there any updates on how this turned out? Did you end up with eggs, has anyone gotten hurt? I'm so interested in the studies and would love to know more!
@rdnkenki
@rdnkenki Год назад
I believe it comes down to space, food, enrichment and that Geckos are each individuals, just like humans :) Cohabitation is only for Experienced keepers. No lazy allowed. Monitor them closely
@thesaltangler7978
@thesaltangler7978 Год назад
Thank you so much for this video! You are so right! Everyone who says Leo’s can’t live in groups doesn’t know what they are talking about. You’re a smart guy. Keep up the great work! 🤙🏼
@maureenfinnegan4919
@maureenfinnegan4919 5 месяцев назад
Great video and I love your enclosure. How big is your tank for the group of leo's you have? I have one leopard gecko that looks just like yours but I was told when I got her a year ago absolutely NO cohabitation for leopard geckos. I love her so much and she is really the easiest pet I have ever had. I wish I had gotten some of the other babies at the same time. what kind are yours?
@WildLife_Perspective
@WildLife_Perspective 3 года назад
Wow you definitely brought some good information to the table! Great video!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks 😁
@ArcadiaReptile
@ArcadiaReptile 3 года назад
This is excellent, well done.
@ReptilesandResearch
@ReptilesandResearch 3 года назад
I agree, Joe did well on this!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thank you both! Your contribution was much appreciated, Liam 😁
@mosesp6200
@mosesp6200 3 года назад
Nice video. A video about mixed species cohabitation (with animals that have the same temperature & humidity requirements) would be really interesting too! I heard about and saw people keeping cresties together with croc skinks and cresties with cave geckos (goniurosaurus bawanglingensis). And the zoo in my city has an "australian" enclosure where ackies, beardies, frilled lizards and blue tongue skinks live together for years.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
That is a rather broader topic that I am not yet ready to tackle... but that doesn’t mean I won’t be in time 😉 Thanks for watching!
@trisha2286
@trisha2286 3 года назад
I think u forgot to mention to another drawback of co habing is having a more difficult time keeping track which geckos are eating/pooping or lack of
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
There is definitely something in this, and it is something I could have mentioned, which is that you don't want to be mixing ill leopard geckos together for the simple fact that what ails one could easily spread to another member of the group. For this reason, it is essential to have long quarantine periods prior to mixing stock (which is why I held my females separate from my male from February to August, a full six months in total). It isn't a massive problem to know which geckos are eating what. If I throw six locusts in and see one gecko coming out straight away and catching four of them in quick succession, I'll tong feed next time and give that gecko less than the others. As it happens, the only feeders I let loose for hunting are crickets and locusts - everything else burrows, so I offer these items on tongs anyway. It's really not that difficult to keep track. With regards defaecating, well, if the geckos are outwardly healthy and all the faeces looks normal, I think it is a fairly safe bet that all three are, indeed, healthy. If a small portion of the faces were to look abnormal and all the geckos were still acting the same, I might not know which one of them (or ones of them) have the complaint, but seeing as they all live together anyway, I'd be wanting to get them all seen to by a vet regardless of whether I knew which one had any symptoms. I'd separate them, get faecal tests done for each, and take them all in for a checkup - which is exactly the same as I'd do if just one of them were to be diagnosable. It is true that if one gecko managed to pick something up from somewhere, then it would be more difficult for it to be spread to geckos in separate enclosures than ones in the same enclosure, but if you've done a proper quarantine period then I see no reason why that initial likelihood of contracting disease from somewhere is any higher for a leopard gecko in a group compared to one in isolation. Given how low this likelihood of initially contracting a disease is (assuming proper husbandry), I don't think it represents a real reason not to cohabitate (but it is, quite rightly, something to think about). Thanks for watching
@gaffermulholland9176
@gaffermulholland9176 3 года назад
Very nice presentation here. I appreciate the scientific and eloquent nature of your argument.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thank you 🙂
@EpicAngie101
@EpicAngie101 Год назад
super well spoken and intelligent young men. thank you for sharing this
@markperez8824
@markperez8824 3 года назад
Where did you get the geckos
@dragonnoodles7487
@dragonnoodles7487 3 года назад
It is worth mentioning most gecko species in general seem to be more social than other lizards. Geckos are the most vocal group too, able to produce a variety of sounds, like that infamous "tokai" noise. Yes, some solitary animals also vocalize to communicate but there definitely is a difference between solitary animal vocalization and social animal vocalization, even if the social animal forms loose colonies. I have three female leopard geckos, all co-habing together. Two of them have been living together for about 8 years, the third one about 6 years. I have never seen serious bite marks on them and they share their huts, though the oldest one is very comfortable sleeping/resting right in the open; sometimes they sleep in separate huts. Bite incidents happen extremely rarely and only when I'm feeding them - overexcitement has led to one of them to confuse: 1. a leg for a worm, 2. a tail for a worm. These accidents have never left permanent damage besides the most recent bite mark on a tail that disappeared after a shed. What I would consider a sign of dominance - and/or maybe a lack of spacial awareness - is when they choose to walk over each other to reach their destination. However, they do try to avoid this behaviour and walk around if possible. Like you said, mine also lick each other and I can imagine each one has their own scent/taste that other members of the colony are able to differentiate from the others. A curious behaviour I have observed is a certain fascination when one gecko sees another gecko outside their enclosure when I want to handle them for a while. I wouldn't say it's jealousy, I don't believe they are capable of such a complex emotion, but I would say they are thinking how the gecko got outside the cage. One thing I very often saw as a case against co-habing is sharing the same hut. They make it seem as it's a case of dominance purely that can stress them out. 'Though if you think about how cold it gets in the wild in their natural environment, I would say it's an effort to conserve heat. Besides leopard geckos, other reptiles thought to be shown solitary have completely shattered many expectations. Certain species of rattlesnakes also form social groups.
@joshuarosenblatt
@joshuarosenblatt 3 месяца назад
How are these guys doing now? Any follow up vids??
@Solaxer
@Solaxer Год назад
Any update? How are they faring?
@rdnkenki
@rdnkenki Год назад
I have 2 female babies living together. They have same parents but one baby is a month older. 3 and 4 months old. I give them plenty of hides and food spots. I am disabled so I'm home always and I monitor them very close. So far so good.
@kilIacon
@kilIacon 9 месяцев назад
any updates? im planning on cohabing 2 females in a 48x18x18, trying to see as many successful cohabs as possible before i decide to lol
@rdnkenki
@rdnkenki 9 месяцев назад
@@kilIacon i separated because one was not growing.... Come to find out she's just a micro. Built small but healthy and proportional. The other ended up being a Male anyways so glad I did separate too
@monsterkajiu1912
@monsterkajiu1912 2 года назад
Like your bookshelf and books on it.
@snowymass854
@snowymass854 3 года назад
Interesting and something to think about. I wonder if it'd be possible to set up a sort of connected-habitat setup where each gecko has it's own enclosure it can get away to while having the central socializing chamber and/or moving them into one resting enclosure and then separating them into hunting enclosures manually? I would say you're not out of the woods yet. I've heard horror stories of leos kept together and doing fine until one day snapping and causing injuries. Plus keep in mind that even if this experiment is successful and all three of your geckos live a long happy lifespan of 15-20 years that individual personalities can vary wildly especially in captivity. It'll be interesting to see as this new study enters the herpticulture community and how that changes the care of leopard geckos. I'm always interested to see what reptiles, which are generally solitary animals, benefit from proper cohabitation. If cohabitation is as important as you say it might even bump Leo's off of the recommended starter list, you know accommodating multiple basking spots isn't exactly for beginners. Edit: What do you plan to do with the inevitable babies that are produced?
@hornet_artz4462
@hornet_artz4462 2 года назад
I have two cohabiting and they love each other, they sit on top of one of their rocks together and warm up. They are either side by side or across the tank from each other
@TrailoftheWildWild
@TrailoftheWildWild 3 года назад
Have you ever seen the geckos bite each other? I just saw my geckos do it for the first time ever. But now they are just chill again. What should I do?
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Yes, I’ve witnessed biting a couple of times over food, and it is usually accidental - my male leopard gecko tends to get quite over-excited over food... It has not amounted to anything thus far. Such minor events as these are what we must be prepared for when cohabbing. We must draw a line between letting animals be animals and one animal continually bullying one or several others - in the case of the former, we let them get on with it; in the case of the latter, we move them apart. In essence, long-term success rests upon knowing when it is time to step in, and just as importantly when not to.
@TrailoftheWildWild
@TrailoftheWildWild 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles thanks so much for responding. I am assuming this is a one time thing because they are fine with each other now. Also, they have multiple hides on each side of the tank for separation if they don’t want to be near each other. Have a great rest of your day!
@TrailoftheWildWild
@TrailoftheWildWild 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles I also have 2 setups prepared for the geckos, if anything were serious.
@TrailoftheWildWild
@TrailoftheWildWild 3 года назад
Hello, here is an update on my geckos fighting. I have seen them bite a few more times and have decided to separate them, in the same enclosure. I will have a divider in the tank that lets them both have heating on each side, as well as room for the geckos to explore.
@DarthRaider8180
@DarthRaider8180 3 года назад
Okay I have a question. I got my leopard geckos from my uncle, he had a male and a female together and they are doing just fine, now my other uncle really likes my geckos and wants to get two just like me. But the only thing is, is that he wants to cohabitate them as well. So Is it okay to cohabitate juvenile geckos together?
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Juveniles are more likely to get along than adults; most people that breed keep their juveniles together at some point. Make sure you have a nice-sized enclosure and a spare one available to separate if necessary!
@DarthRaider8180
@DarthRaider8180 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles okay tysm
@PardoNdSchuman
@PardoNdSchuman 3 года назад
Love your videos your very knowledgeable. I am putting togeather a new 48”x18”x16” viv for a leopard gecko. Would love your input. I have a piece of foam I am planning on making a climbing wall out of. Would love to do something more advanced tho like you did here.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thank you! What sort of enclosure is it - wooden or glass?
@PardoNdSchuman
@PardoNdSchuman 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles glass, sliding front opening doors. I have a 3” thick piece of insulation foam to carve something for the background
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
I’ve never done a foam build before, but I have done a cork background in a glass vivarium using just cork, silicone, and sphagnum moss, and it turned out well. The video (a bit dusty now, I must admit!) where I did this is linked below. In a few weeks to a month or so, I will be commencing a new glass build where I will be using the same technique. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xI2gHdFA5iI.html
@PardoNdSchuman
@PardoNdSchuman 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles I kinda want to use the foam so it’s removable. I did just get 15lbs Of corkbark, maybe I should just glue a bunch of it the foam?
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Having not used foam before, I don’t know how well that will work... If it’s not all silicones to the back of the vivarium, is it not likely to fall forwards? You might be better asking in the Facebook group “Building Reptile Cages”. It’s quite a new group but a promising one. Joe Monahan is admin.
@PhonixxTheArtist
@PhonixxTheArtist Год назад
My two girls live together for over 10 years now they snuggle sometimes
@est95ny
@est95ny 3 года назад
Did you say the size of the large enclosure?
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
They’re in a 3x2x2’ at the moment 🙂
@kenjiro2676
@kenjiro2676 3 года назад
I don't have geckos, I did find a species that can act as a substitute for leopard geckos if one wishes to house them communally. Those are banded geckos, they can readily be housed with one another as long as the male and female ratio is correct. Another species would be mourning geckos, which are parthenogenetic.
@tbone198786
@tbone198786 2 года назад
I recently purchased 1 male and 1 female hardwicki leopard geckos. They came in a pair and have lived together since babies. Currently around 6 months old. There is not much research on these types and there care. I'm going to co habit these 2 to see how things go. If it doesn't go well I will separate. I also read that there care is much different then your typical leopard gecko.
@davidoakley7618
@davidoakley7618 3 года назад
Quality JTB!
@fizbiz115
@fizbiz115 Год назад
Ive had my male and female in the same enclosure for the last three months. They get along perfectly fine. As a matter fact they sleep together and bask together.
@LetsTalkHerps
@LetsTalkHerps 3 года назад
I have to pause when you say that eliminating all risks in our captive animals can lead to negative behavior. “What’s the point in living? And you give the example of a tiger pacing it’s cage. Despite the glaring flaw that tiger husbandry and reptile husbandry are not equal, it should be noted that captive reptiles enjoy a much longer life span than wild ones. This is due to risk elimination. It’s an interesting concept you’re exploring, but I’m not convinced that cohabiting leopard geckos eliminates any kind of social deficiency or promotes such positive enrichment that would validate promoting cohabitation of this species. I understand that it can be done, and would make for a more true to nature exhibit. But I don’t see the advantage for a keeper to do this at home. I’ll continue to watch to see if my opinion changes, but I’m not understanding the benefit here. Just that it’s not as dire a situation as it’s made out to be.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Whether the specifics of caring for different animals are different or not, the fact that animals (or at least vertebrates - I’m not well-up on invertebrate keeping) demonstrate “negative” (how this is defined, again, I don’t know, but you will see an intuitive “negativeness” in all the analogies I am about to make) behaviours when they are unable to live naturally is regardless of where in the family tree they fit. Several years ago we were moving house, and we were setting up a pond for my goldfish which had previously been together in a tank indoors. Rather than dumping all the fish into the newly-cycled (fishkeeping jargon which you may or may not be familiar with - basically, if a tank or pond is properly “cycled”, you can safely keep fish in it) pond, we put just two in to start with. Both fish sat on the bottom and were reluctant to feed. We could not find any issues with the setup, however, and had to move the other fish in anyway because time was pressing on. Lo and behold, when six goldfish were present, they all swam round and came for food. I may be right or I may be wrong, but it would seem to me that the fish had been lonely in one way or another, yet I doubt many people would ascribe such a feeling to a goldfish! Most of the time, goldfish kept in solitude do not seem bothered by it. Nor do leopard geckos. Perhaps it was because my goldfish had been together for so long beforehand that the split caused such a change in their behaviour. Maybe it was just the change, not necessarily tied in to anything to do with social living. The possibility still remains. How, indeed, do we know that the possibility does not remain in leopard geckos? They DO live together in the wild - because we struggle (find it damn near impossible) to interpret their thoughts, can we really be so certain that they do not suffer in some way from solitude? It is certainly something to think about. With regards longevity, I disagree that a long life and a good life are the same thing. A budgerigar kept indoors in a small cage, alone, is likely to live twice as long as one in a group in an aviary, seemingly because flying round just takes its toll on their little bodies. For this, an animal which would naturally spend its life flying in enormous flocks across the Australian outback, does solitary confinement in a cage seem like a better life than life in a spacious aviary? Another example: returning to big cats, I have seen cheetah in an enclosure in a zoo (quite a prestigious zoo which I won’t name) pacing round. And I don’t just mean a bit: both of them were taking such a perfect track around the enclosure that there was a trail round the perimeter about four inches across where the grass hadn’t grown. They were literally taking the same steps over that thin line, over and over again, stopping the grass from springing up there. Yet, I bet they’ll outlive most wild cheetahs - veterinary care, no threat from starvation, no lions to kill them when they become weak... Is this really a better life than one in the wild? The optimum is to provide the creatures with the things which are clearly not “negative” (disease, starvation, predators etc) but still to give them everything else. Where does social interaction fall on this spectrum for leopard geckos? If we can ensure that the negative aspects will not come into play - bullying and so forth - by tailoring our enclosures and always having a spare to hand, then what argument is there not to cohabitate given what we know (and perhaps more importantly, what we don’t know) about the social nature of leopard geckos? I do not know of one, so I keep my leopard geckos together.
@LetsTalkHerps
@LetsTalkHerps 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles c’mon. Fish? Cheetahs? I don’t need an analogy to understand the concept. I get the concept. Unless you’re comparing behavior to a burrowing reptilian insectivore it’s just a completely pointless comparison. Your logo before the video suggests you’re peer reviewed (by Facebook groups?) so I’m holding you to a scientific standard. But let’s take your analogy at its face value and you’ve shown that social animals falter in isolation. What negative effects are geckos showing in your solution? I would argue that your male was doing awesome in that beautiful enclosure. And what are the negatives? You said it yourself in the video. They fought over food already for you. In the study you cited he says the live in the burrow together but forage separately. I could make a case using the (incredibly vague) animal welfare act to argue that you’re not allowing them to perform their natural behavior of foraging individually!! I also think promoting cohabitation runs the risk of encouraging someone less experienced who thinks they’re ready for “advanced husbandry,” who ends up with injured geckos. I just don’t see the rewards outweighing the risks. Now, I should say I think your setup is phenomenal. I would rather see this video framed as a defense of your own experiment as I’m not buying the justification that cohabitation is inherently beneficial. The science just isn’t there yet.
@user-ks7tx2wb7y
@user-ks7tx2wb7y 3 года назад
Surly the inability to express social behaviours in what has been shown is a social species is detrimental to the animal mentally? Who are we as keepers to determine that an entire array of behaviours that have evolved over the course of thousands of years not be required for that animal to truly thrive. Surly or atleast in my opinion the introduction of an appropriate tank mate(s) into an appropriate exhibit can only benifit to create a far more complex and mentally engaging existence.
@LetsTalkHerps
@LetsTalkHerps 3 года назад
@@user-ks7tx2wb7y I’m not convinced by the evidence shown in this video that these animals show any sort of social behavior that is beneficial. I don’t believe that we should simply recreate the wild at all levels without assessing the risk. And the risk of food fights is very present and already observed by JTB. Who are we to decide? We’re the person tasked with the survival and wellbeing of this animal. I think this particular setup and keeper are wonderful, but it can go wrong quickly, and should not be recommended as quality care for leopard gecko keepers. There’s merit to being cautious.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
"But let’s take your analogy at its face value and you’ve shown that social animals falter in isolation. What negative effects are geckos showing in your solution?" The point of my analogy includes your first sentence, but is broader than that. I am attempting to illustrate that any vertebrate species can be expected to, as you say, "falter" when it is unable to perform natural behaviours. (I don't know what "falter", "suffer", etc. would be defined as, but I think all readers will accept that it is a fairly intuitive concept). This observation has no intrinsic association to social behaviours - you will see that the cheetahs were (probably) pacing around because they are nomadic by nature and enclosure therefore does not allow them to fulfil their desire for movement, not because they were socially dissatisfied. No, specific social behaviours are mostly incomparable between taxa, even closely related ones. (I could infer that humans are solitary creatures by assessing orangutans and be completely off the mark, for example.) Being social versus solitary has proven too plastic throughout the course of evolution for solid assumptions. It would be entirely inappropriate for me to look at a bird, a teleost fish, and a mammal to decide whether a reptile is social or not! But that is not what I am doing. Given, then, that we cannot make good guesses as to the social nature of leopard geckos by looking at other species, we have to look at the information we have about this species in particular to find out what would be its natural state. As it happens, we find that they are "gregarious" by nature, as Khan writes. Once again, this does not mean that they will necessarily suffer from an inability to perform social behaviours - indeed, do they? You're right in asserting that we don't see any specific behaviours - like pacing, feather-plucking, enhanced aggression, or whatever else we might see in other species - which result from their solitude. But there are a couple of issues with this line of thought (it occurred to me a long time ago, and I thought about it quite a bit before dismissing it as cause not to cohabitate). Firstly, what exactly would you expect a lonely leopard gecko to start doing? They aren't the most emotive of animals, as far as the human observer is concerned. Maybe solitary leopard geckos ARE exhibiting unique behaviours in frustration at their situation, but we are too oblivious to notice. It wouldn't surprise me. Secondly, I think that the notion that there must be an unnatural behaviour to replace the natural one(s) is false. You will agree that a lone, caged budgie probably has lower welfare than if it were to be flying round in a flock in an aviary - yet it might live longer and I, for one, will say that budgies never seem particularly depressive! What is wrong with that state of living, then? It is the absence of the natural behaviour that is the issue: the bird is NOT flying or chattering to its companions; if it were, it would be better off than it is in its cage, but the being alone in the cage does not promote unnatural behaviour. The bird might well not be bothered about being alone and caged, but it would much prefer not to be. Likewise, a leopard gecko may not be particularly bothered about living alone, but it may well much PREFER being able to interact with conspecifics. (This might be a rather subtle extension and change of view from what I have posed earlier, so I hope I have explained it properly.) Thinking of all of the above, we have an animal which would naturally live communally and, in doing so, performs a whole range of natural behaviours which do not fall into that category of "obviously harmful" like tail autotomy. There are, of course, downsides to cohabitation, but if we limit these in the ways described in the video (with the method of limitation of highest importance being the option of separation), then is it not the best conclusion that social interaction will benefit leopard geckos? I think so, or I wouldn't have put my leopard geckos together, and I wouldn't have made this video about it. (Before you right off the peer review as being done by Facebook know-alls, by the way, I recommend having a look in the groups and seeing the list of names in the review panel.) I thank you for your caution here. You've obviously got your thinking hat on, which makes a nice change!
@angelcotto3383
@angelcotto3383 Год назад
I have cohabitated two pairs for two years now, and it also in my personal experience depends on the personality of the animal. For example, my two males can't be more different from each other in personality and physicality , Kristoff my supersnow male is very laidback and quite literally let's his "mate" lay on top of him from time to time, so in their case I don't need any special means of separation for the sake of the female as of yet, on the other hand Olaf my leucistic albino male is considerably larger in proportion than the female and when it's breeding season he is incessantly pushy and in that case I've provided the female a hide in which she can hide where he can't follow because of his massive head. I'm no expert and definitely enjoy these kinds of videos, I love learning more about my leos.
@speedymadr6
@speedymadr6 3 года назад
Interesting and thought provoking topic as always. It always amazes me on some groups when someone takes in a pair of Leo’s that have cohabited for a long time, everyone is quick to point out they must be separated. At first i thought that was what you are supposed to do but if you sit back and think, these animals have been together with no apparent issues, surely it is more stressful to the animals by separating them rather than keeping them together. I have read a lot in the rabbit world that it should be made law that if you sell rabbits you should make sure that you sell a pair or at least the buyer has a rabbit already. They develop incredibly strong bonds, our two are brother and sister and the bond they have is so special. I’m not saying that Leo’s are like rabbits but if they live in groups in the wild then why should we not allow them to create that habitat in captivity? I can’t wait to see how they interact with one another over the coming months and years.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
It’s all about taking responsibility. Yes, the animals might not get along - but by keeping them together, does that mean you aren’t prepared to separate them? As I explain in the video, the likelihood of having to separate them can be made low indeed if you set things up properly, but even then, you’ve still got to be ready to move the animals apart if needed. I think much of the controversy comes from the fact that people think you either keep them together permanently, or not at all: there’s no recognition of the keeper being able to step in during a worst-case scenario. As you say with rabbits, I should imagine that rabbits are perfectly capable of giving each other as much of a beating as any other animal. Yet, it is noted how much they benefit from companionship, so they are kept in pairs or groups whilst recognising that the keeper may have to intervene if they do not get along. With reptiles, of course, we have not only to prove that this is the case - common sense though it may seem - but also to prove that, in the right measures for the right species, social interaction can indeed be a positive thing. The latter is perhaps the most difficult point to get across, so I hope the video has done so adequately! Thank you for watching and your feedback 😁
@speedymadr6
@speedymadr6 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles Absolutely, we have to break the rabbits up every now and again as they both have their moments to show their dominance to the other. It all ends fine and they snuggle up to one another. As you say common sense and an enclosures that allows space if needed.
@rdnkenki
@rdnkenki Год назад
Thank you
@jadesjungle
@jadesjungle 3 года назад
Thoroughly enjoyed this video. I find it very interesting that you challenge the popular care guides with scientific literature and come up with a strong case for why you do what you do. It is something I always try to do and reflect on, so seeing videos like this gets my brain into gear reflecting on common practices and questioning certain things. A recent example for me, completely unrelated mind and probably not that interesting to you haha, is that I had a giant slug and a giant snail. Always been told they can not cohabitate because of toxic slime but never found any evidence for where this had started? I looked into scientific papers on the slime and could not find anything expect for the fact that it does wonders for human skin apparently, used in a lot of beauty products, not something I would ever intend to purchase personally. Given the fact that there has been deep research because of the beauty industry, that pays hell of a lot more than the pet industry for research like that, it was helpful on deciding if the slime was toxic. As you can guess, no evidence still found, so decided to try cohabitate. The benefit for me would be the fact that I did not have to purchase a second large tank, decor and enrichment, and heating equipment/ thermostat, for a single small slug. I know we all like to make the point that our pets deserve the world and if you cant provide what they need, then don't get. Realistically, who wants to spend hundreds on a slug if they don't have to, right? There are also some papers out there on detrivores working together on a forest floor to break down different things and nutrients, so not a direct benefit for social needs or anything but I did figure the bioactivity of their tank may very well be improved at the least. Theres also the argument of aggregation occurring in snails and slugs where they can retain humidity and warmth for longer under a prime spot, which is why you always find a ton under slabs or plant pots. I have species which are not predatory, many are, which would mean they aren't suitable to co-habitate and is worth pointing out. It's been working fab for months now, both thriving very happy in the set-up. People still make a point to tell me off about it, I even had someone make posts in a load of Facebook groups moaning about me and asking them to start a thread of evidence for points against, so I would listen. The drama man, over a happy lil slug! I couldn't imagine the backlash you get putting out controversial videos such as this for something like a reptile which im sure many more people have passion over than slugs lol. It gives me confidence too, if I have looked into it myself, why should I back down from peer pressure when no contradictory papers have been provided to me, whilst I am providing my own evidence. A thread with points for against, kind of seems like they couldn't think of a good reason themselves but refused to let go of the 'rule' that it shouldn't be done... Anyway sorry for the long ramble, could talk for ages about my opinions and care cultures! Great video!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
What you describe - what one may call “folklore husbandry” - seems to be rife in all the sectors of petkeeping I’ve ever dipped my toes into. “Such-a-body says something, means it’s true, ‘nuff said.” I can’t comment on gastropod care, but it sounds to be much the same from how you describe it. Keeping animals in the private home has expanded enormously in recent years, and it is time we took responsibility by doing actual research rather than carrying out long-held traditions in faith that they will always work!
@jadesjungle
@jadesjungle 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles Funny story about that actually, my replies when they mentioned that it’s bad and shouldn’t be done because more experienced people than me tell us not to, I said that I do not follow folklore husbandry and will go by papers mostly, if they had any. They said that it was ironic to bring that up, as in that case I am starting folklaw husbandry for unsafe practices if people watch me. Interesting twist in the argument there 😂
@AnimalsatHomePodcast
@AnimalsatHomePodcast 3 года назад
Nice job, gents!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks Dillon!
@basicbaroque
@basicbaroque 3 года назад
A lot of keepers cohab females together in Sweden. I wonder if cohabitation works better here because the requirements are much larger? The legal size for 2 adults would be 4x2x2ft, and for three, 6x2x2ft (dimensions can vary as long as it's the same floorspace, these are just examples). They have also been offering UVB lighting for a very long time here too. I was also surprised... People keep leopard geckos on sand here too. Which, I wouldn't do personally, but I found it interesting being from USA and always hearing they should be on tile or paper towel. This of course varies for some keepers, but the majority I've seen keep them on sand, or divide the enclosure in two sections with sand and a different substrate for them to choose from. I always find it interesting how opinions and style of keeping differ between countries.
@duncanmcintyre2670
@duncanmcintyre2670 3 года назад
4x2x2 is quite small for 2 leopard geckos tbh, I have that for a single gecko,
@KeeperoftheKnife
@KeeperoftheKnife 8 месяцев назад
I've kept several females together for decades. The oldest pair lived together for 13 years without issue. Currently have four females together.
@fistfullofsquid4200
@fistfullofsquid4200 3 года назад
Great video. It will be interesting to see how the leopard gecko keepers react to this video. Just avoid any controversial tortoise keeping topics or else you'll probably be hunted down by a group of 60 something year old women and beaten to death. Throwing handfuls of Werthers Originals may buy you enough time to escape their clutches.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thanks - the confectionary arsenal is ready for action! Joking aside, I must point out that I hope any disagreement can be put towards constructive conversation rather than combat, be it involving toffees or otherwise. We will only progress if we can learn to listen as well as put our own thoughts across! Thanks for watching 🙂
@ReptilesandResearch
@ReptilesandResearch 3 года назад
Dead 😂
@jenniferlong7560
@jenniferlong7560 6 месяцев назад
Thank you for your research and sharing this information! I’m currently doing research on leopard geckos cohabitation, and I have to say 9/10 of the pairs I have use a communal area to deposit waste. And the 10th, one gecko is blind. Love to pick your brain if you have time!
@danielrobison4755
@danielrobison4755 Год назад
I have a male and female together in a 20 long for three years. Not a single problem. They like each other and always together
@owentice3261
@owentice3261 3 года назад
Super interesting topic that I've been wanting to know more about for a while. I really appreciate a well reasoned and structured argument as opposed to the usual: "ALL leopard geckos are solitary, and they should NEVER be housed together." A lot of what I've seen in this hobby is black and white (ex. sand should never be used), but we're dealing with live animals. There is no black and white. Only we, as keepers, know what's best for our animals. I don't think some random person on the internet will be able to accurately predict how your animal will behave in certain situations. As far as cohabitation goes, I think it can be beneficial in some cases. I don't, however, think that it will ever be an essential part of basic care. Again, I really appreciate your factual evidence and open mind! We need a lot more people like you in this hobby 🙌🙌
@fishinggamingandexploringc4296
@fishinggamingandexploringc4296 2 года назад
I've kept 2 females for 3 years
@lizard1533
@lizard1533 3 года назад
I have mixed feelings about this video, I'll be interested to see how your geckos do in the future! Have you got any updates since time of recording? Have you found multiple papers which validate these claims or is it just the 1? What are your opinions on breeding of leopard geckos? Don't you think that this could cause a influx of leopard geckos on the market and couldn't that lead to more leopard geckos being kept in poor standards? even if you freeze the eggs for example you still run the risk of egg binding and such, breeding causes lots of stress for females. I enjoy your videos and appreciate what you do!
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Thus far I have nothing to report, which I suppose can be taken as good news, although to be fair the geckos have been in full hibernation since November and were being cooled down through October, so I wouldn't expect much activity anyway. We'll have to wait for the spring to find out. If people go throwing their leopard geckos together willy-nilly, then yes, that would produce an influx of the things, and there will be some viewers that take this video as me confirming that just putting leopard geckos together, regardless of the situation, is OK. I can't stop that; I've tried my very best to make a coherent argument, and if people want to pick and choose quotations to alter what I've said to support their actions, I can't stop that. I don't think it is the right thing just to sit quiet about it all, though. With regards female health, I am led to believe that egg binding is more of an issue when the eggs are infertile. Adult female leopard geckos will lay eggs once they're a few years old whether they breed or they don't; in nature these eggs will almost always be fertile, so it follows that they probably haven't evolved to cope with laying slugs as they have nice pearly whites. I presume that mated females will lay more regularly than unmated ones, though, so maybe it does require more of their bodily resources in the long term. There are a lot of unknowns here. A further one to add into the mix is that where overbreeding has occurred in the past in the hobby, it has almost always involved geckos in unlit plastic boxes: you can see that the health of the geckos in these surroundings is incomparable with that of those in well set up vivaria, so the effort of egg laying will be a lot greater. In summary, then, I cannot say whether being in a mixed sex group in a proper vivarium actually would leave a female any worse off than not being bred at all - it's another one we'll have to wait and see. In any case, there's nothing stopping a female being temporarily pulled out from the group for a break. Thank you for watching, and thank you also for sharing your concerns! It's always good to be revisiting and thinking about things.
@hawkjeff
@hawkjeff 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles are you expecting that they will breed? will you be removing any eggs if they do? Unwanted babies would be my biggest concern with this approach.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
Yes, I will raise the babies on. If there turns out not to be much demand for them, I will simply feed off any future eggs to my corn snake.
@hawkjeff
@hawkjeff 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles - great excuse to get a snake! I do think for me, and probably for many, this critical piece would be a real stumbling block to this approach. I was seriously considering two females together, but having read that some people here have had long term problems with that, I'm reconsidering.
@hawkjeff
@hawkjeff 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles - please keep us updated. I'm fascinated by this. I understand people's concerns and also understand why you'd be willing to take the risk. I hope you'll give us some honest assessments of how it goes.
@ninakoncilja1448
@ninakoncilja1448 2 года назад
I have cohab 3females leopard gecko, they are doing so fine, i was afreid at first but now i see there are no problem. I gave them a big tank and lots of hideouts and they seem happy😊
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
Length of Ur tank in feet?
@Toobluejzs147
@Toobluejzs147 2 года назад
The lady i got my geckos from keeps 1 males and 2 females together, and she has about 50 geckos, so i fill like people have opinions on cohabbing that i is so bad, but iam not convinced
@bookworm28427
@bookworm28427 2 года назад
I was going to get a leo but I then decided on a beardie so I know some about Leopard geckos but not a whole lot I was talking to someone at my school and they were saying they had 2 leopard geckos from petco (and a beardie, that died of MBD, tail rot and scale rot Rest In Peace) but he said he had his 2 geckos together (didn't say tank size, I'm assuming 20gal) I was like oh I don't think they can live together. He replied with "they were brother and sister and were siblings and raised together. Besides, they didn't really go near each other, the female liked the warm side and male the cool side" I kept trying to say I don't think they can be cohabed when he said they both died (didn't tell me how) I'm assuming MBD or each other....am I right or no?
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
Nah the guys an idiot you only want to house sisters together
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
Also is his Viv filthy or something living animal rotting wtf.
@bookworm28427
@bookworm28427 5 месяцев назад
@Hood_mf I have no idea bc this was like 3 years ago. I do know that they all died and he didn't get anymore. So.fucked up...he was shocked my beardie lived to 2 😳
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
​@@bookworm28427 crazy
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
Also I don't know if it posted but I said two sisters probably would've been alright
@AggroAggron
@AggroAggron Год назад
Ive just begun cohabitating my two female geckos because I want to hopefully enrich their lives in a bioactive terrarium and Im hoping they do well.
@Hood_mf
@Hood_mf 5 месяцев назад
Is it bad to say I'm the fucture id like to do it but the main reason is that it's just cool lol
@rdnkenki
@rdnkenki Год назад
Definitely not brumating mine*****edit****.... My one decided for me. She didn't eat from November to almost March. Ate her sheds though. Lost a little weight but not bad.
@gardian1701
@gardian1701 Год назад
💥 I just got 2 females, hatched together, 1 year old. I just caught them fighting like cats during the night on my infra red camera! No, they didn't fight at all during the day. I had them both in a 4x2x2 Viv. 💥
@CelestialScribbler
@CelestialScribbler 3 года назад
I appreciate the deep dive into the topic but I can't help but feel your overlooking the fact that in the wild they spend the vast majority of their waking hours intentionally alone. Unless it's vastly large, even a cage with enough room to theoretically separate will never be the same as living freely and will inevitably end up with much more daily social interaction then they would experience naturally. That doesn't mean it must be harmful to force more interaction then they may otherwise choose, but it seems like a jump to say it must be beneficial enrichment to live together in captivity just because they often sleep in groups in the wild.
@duncanmcintyre2670
@duncanmcintyre2670 3 года назад
Another advantage of sleeping together in groups in the wild is that they're more focused on predators, so that they won't have 'time' to fight with each other. The same can't be said for captive species, that could explain why there is often a breaking point as opposed to an instant reaction when cohabitating leopard geckos, crested geckos etc.
@LeesInTheD
@LeesInTheD 3 года назад
There are multiple explanations for this behavior, including the fact that food is more spread out in the wild so they must forage further than in a captive environment. So it's not necessarily that they can't stand each other and scatter but rather the demands of finding food. Yes, the space will be smaller, but that's an argument for more space, not solitary confinement.
@themotions5967
@themotions5967 3 года назад
@@LeesInTheD I don’t know if the loose pseudo social dynamics leopard geckos have with each other constitutes the phrase “solitary confinement” when they are not provided long term. Don’t get me wrong the enrichment benefits female leopard geckos in particular seem to get from properly done cohabitation is substantial enough for more advanced keepers of this species to consider There are just a lot of things that make me think that the social interactions we see between wild leopard geckos are like the neutral interaction between many species of reptile we consider for all intensive purposes to be “solitary animals”. I mean there are factors that also play a role into what are called leopard gecko “colonies” Firstly this behavior has been recorded as more frequent during times of breeding which means at least part of this grouping behavior is likely due to some form of sexually based competition. Also note these animals seem to have a preference for a specific type of landscape, cover, and natural structures to make burrows and residences out of. In areas that have less of these options the colonies seem to be larger, with more fierce completion. while in cover heavy or arid semi forested habitats which have more cover options the colonies seem to be smaller in number. This makes me think that part of the formation of this social dynamic is a mutual interest in a preferred safe hiding space, and pockets of suitable habitat. There is also the fact that in most cases in the wild these animals will spend most of their active time alone and seemingly come back to a shared burrow to sleep and stay safe. Also while they do have some minor communicative capabilities with each other they seem to be limited to “hey back off”, “hey I’m excited/interested in seeing you”, and “hey I’m scared/angry”. These also seem to be consistently seen expressed by leopard geckos in a group setting. What makes me think though is all species even strictly solitary species can express these same messages to each other. I think a good example to relate to leopard geckos when it comes to social structure is oddly enough crocodilians. The groups initially forms due to animals simultaneously seeking out the same optimal habitat and resources (in the case of the geckos being hiding opportunities, and food), and the convenient large number of females sparks a breeding response in males, and competition and sexual selection influences the evolution of competitive, and harem behavior which leads to males fighting over dominance of the conveniently gathered groups of females and resources. That’s why they are at their root solitary as even though they can be commonly observed in a group they are not in a group for the direct benefit of social interaction or a group dynamic, not do they seem to have noticeable behaviors or health based signs of stress when they are living solitary. they are simply there because they were communally drawn to local resources, and the opportunity to mate. Essentially while they are not technically solitary in the literal terms of being alone all of the time, they aren’t really interacting with each other beyond what we see from other solitary species “ie mating, competing for resources” which means besides mating there really isn’t a substantial beneficial reason these animals are in these groups.
@themotions5967
@themotions5967 3 года назад
@@LeesInTheD social animals are social at their core because it provides benefits to their survival, leopard geckos don’t Share resources, they don’t coordinate with each other, they don’t use each other for protection, and if anything colonies seem to be a source of enrichment that comes with minor long term stress which is only tolerated as I said because of resources and breeding. That’s why I don’t think solitary confinement is a proper term as that implies that the animal requires social interaction, when this species simply uses interaction to avoid direct competition for habitat and resources, and for access to mates.
@jackiekearney
@jackiekearney 3 года назад
I love to put 2 females and a male but probably I will put them in at least 4 feet long tank.
@crow5673
@crow5673 Год назад
Btw your geckos are beautiful
@apss5736
@apss5736 2 года назад
i both agree and disagree with this video i dont think that most and i say most not all leos benefit from cohabitation and certain individuals can benefit from it but it can in some cases work however this should not be advised for newbies and beginners and even though in the wild leos can be in groups the average enclosure is not large enough and if i were to personally do this i would do a 4 but ideally a 6-8 foot tank with lots of hides,plants,rocks,uvb and basking spots where they can be away from each other if they want and a group of 4 or 5 to disperse aggression. for most reptiles cohabitation can be done in an large enough setup but like with pure sand it can be done but better safe than sorry . i keep bettas and although cohabitation can be done in large naturalistic setups with multiple males and females i personally dont do it and i prefer to stay away from it . dont forget that wild leos have endless space and can move away from others if need be . nevertheless this is a good topic and a controversial one. another thing noted with bettas is that wild individuals live in harems and colonies but after generations in captivity some individuals are more aggressive. i believe this is similar with leos in the fact that some individuals are far better with cohabitation and it can work but it can end badly too
@CodyB_Fitness
@CodyB_Fitness 11 месяцев назад
Tommyinnit?
@jayvaughnwhatley5752
@jayvaughnwhatley5752 3 года назад
I Cohabit my leopard geckos I have 3 I want to add 2 more
@erikdahlstrom3561
@erikdahlstrom3561 2 года назад
how big is the tank what is their sex?
@eagle7757
@eagle7757 6 месяцев назад
For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. John 3:16 KJV, Ephesians 2:8-9, Jesus Christ is the only way.....
@duncanmcintyre2670
@duncanmcintyre2670 3 года назад
I was worried about this video and after watching - i still am. This is a dangerous, irresponsible video to promote. Inexperienced keepers will use this video to fight against responsible owners. You may cohab, but it isn't the best option. Also, that paper mentions wild leopard geckos - who have space to disperse if they need. So even if leopard geckos are sociable animals, they still aren't stuck together in a confined space for years upon years.
@JTBReptiles
@JTBReptiles 3 года назад
And what if everything I have said in this video is right? If more evidence accumulates to suggest that social interaction improves the welfare of leopard geckos, what then? Would this video be "dangerous" and "irresponsible"? If, having taken all of the information onboard that I have shared in this video, a person acts with the result that their animals have a better quality of living, am I in the wrong? I do not believe for one second that just because a few people will ignore the majority of the video (and the description, and the discussions in the comments) and simply look for an excuse to keep some leopard geckos together, regardless of the husbandry they offer or how experienced they are with the species, that this is a good enough reason to stay silent. Those people will cram their leopard geckos together in a shoe box whether they can conjure up a go-ahead from me or they can't; they'll hunt around the internet until they find someone else who says they can do it. I, for one, will not bury my head in the sand because people don't have the patience to listen to the full story. Maybe if the people who have a real voice on this platform (not me with a couple of thousand subscribers - the people with tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, millions of keepers looking to them for guidance) were to do a better job at getting across the basics of proper husbandry, like having large enclosures, proper lighting rigs, providing mental and physical stimulation beyond feeding, and so on, the average beginner would not be so likely to run into problems with cohabitation. If you shove three leopard geckos into an unlit plastic box with a dish of water, one hiding place, and one bowl full of mealworms, and they begin to squabble - well, I'd ask, "what did you expect?" No, the thing that is wrong - what is "dangerous" and "irresponsible" - is just following what the good ol' Internet guru says is right and not questioning it. If only people would sit back and think about what is laid out before them - if only! - then I could make videos like this (which actively invite discussion, I should hope) and get more feedback than "no, DON'T do that, I heard it was the wrong thing to do!" (As it happens, the comments section here is mostly good discussion, which I am glad about. The comments around where it has been posted to Facebook - less so.) Such-a-body with 100k subscribers says "you can keep leopard geckos in racks, they'll thrive in this environment", and people believe it. There's no debate about it, no querying - nothing of the sort. Is that what I have done here? Told people that they can keep leopard geckos in groups without further explanation? Well I bloody well hope that's not how it comes across, because I've spent too many years trying not to do exactly that sort of thing to learn that I'm as bad at it as everyone else. I start out the video with an overview of where I am heading. I then give the orthodox opinion first, so that anyone watching who has no further idea about the topic can know what the majority of people hold to be correct. I then refer to several scientific papers to illustrate why I do not think that the orthodox view is entirely correct, and I discuss how we can take action to mitigate the issues associated with cohabitation (having attempted to define what sorts of behaviour we actually want our animals to perform, if any). I show the introduction between my leopard geckos and tell people about the (incredibly minor) scuffles I have witnessed over food - anyone is free to judge these observations as they will. I then round of the video by summarising the points made and telling people that if they are new to leopard geckos, they should give it a few years before thinking about cohabbing. All of this has been peer reviewed by a panel of five who I will not name but are surely five of the best people I could want to check over this video for me. They spent a week talking over it before they got back to me and I made changes to the video so that it formed a clearer argument. If someone comes along, sees two leopard geckos in the thumbnail and takes that as enough evidence that they can bung a couple of their own together... Good luck to them. I have tried my best. Now, with regards space, this is a real issue. Let us accept for one second, with absolute clarity and certainty, whether this is actually right or it isn't, that leopard geckos do benefit from social interaction, even if they do need to get away from each other at times. Then what would be worse: them never making contact with conspecifics because they are housed alone, or them not being able to remain separate for more than a couple of hours? If the geckos are fairly harmonious in the enclosure, i.e. one isn't being chased around by the others (which, if it were to continue, I would say was cause to split the group, if only for a while - the option of separation is the biggest factor pushing cohabitation towards long-term feasibility in my mind), then even though they cannot be as separate as they would be in the wild, they can at least be away from each other (sleeping in a different hide; at the other end of the enclosure; up the background). If you keep just one gecko on its own, then no matter how hard it tried it would never find company. You can have a communally housed leopard gecko which is basically alone (because it has moved away from the others, contingent on a proper enclosure design), but you cannot have a singly housed leopard gecko which can interact socially. I have argued in the video that I think the assumption made at the start of this paragraph is well-founded; therefore, I think that communal housing is the lesser of two evils. Evil it is nonetheless, because it is not as good as the ideal where the geckos have the option of complete solitude, but in all practical situations this optimum will never be attained. One is left wondering whether captivity is excusable at all, and I do sit back and think about it often.
@ojinga
@ojinga 3 года назад
I think many of the points in this video are correct, but what IM worried about is the badly informed reptile keepers looking for an excuse to keep their Leo’s together in a small tank, like the commenter said.HOWEVER, this is not really a fault of the video. And I believe that with the instructions in the video and a large enclosure it can be done and can be beneficial.
@duncanmcintyre2670
@duncanmcintyre2670 3 года назад
@@JTBReptiles I agree with you for the most part, however, i believe this video will be used by inexperienced owners to excuse housing leopard geckos together and I believe that's a really dangerous thing for the hobby.
@6strings735
@6strings735 3 года назад
California kingsnakes are similar. In their preferred habitat, they can occur in small groups, likely related. Could be seasonal, not sure. At any rate duplicating social behavior like this in captivity would be next level. It has been done actually by a few many years ago.
Далее
Housing Leopard Geckos Together?? Responding To YOU
15:59
How to Safely Handle a Leopard Gecko
5:07
Просмотров 208 тыс.
What turned out better to repeat? #tiktok
00:16
Просмотров 4,5 млн
🤯 #funny
00:20
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Leopard Gecko Care 2022
16:30
Просмотров 7 тыс.
SHE DROPPED HER TAIL :'(
7:16
Просмотров 307 тыс.
African Fat Tail Gecko Care Guide
25:37
Просмотров 2,5 тыс.
Do Reptiles NEED Lighting? NO! But...
8:46
Просмотров 3,1 тыс.
Общение с ровесниками:
0:23
Просмотров 205 тыс.
Дени разносит квартиру🙈
0:40
Просмотров 482 тыс.
Милая мебель для котов
0:27
Просмотров 2,3 млн