Carpio: Agreeing not to repair BRP Sierra Madre like conceding Ayungin Shoal as ship decays | ANC 

Justice Carpio in his analysis is indeed patriotic. PBBM should take his point of view seriously. And maybe since WPS is an exclusive economic zone of the Philippines a military presence such as the navy be always ready to shoot any enemy intruders like what indonesia is doing. They shoot trespassers to their exclusive economic zone without warning. Indonesia doesn't have Mutual Defense Treaty with USA but they don't allow china to bully them.

JUSTICE CARPIO I SUGGEST YOU TO FILE A CANDIDACY FOR SENATOR ,FOR WE LACK BRIGHT SENATORS IN THE SENATE PLEASE TRY TO HELP OUR COUNTRY PHIL.

We need leader like Justice Carpio

We need more Filipinos like retired SC Asso. Justice Antonio Carpio and Antonio Trillanes, III who are truly very vocal about their love to our country and fellow Filipinos. They are the Antonio Lunas of the Modern days. God Bless always.

We don't have.to be talking about what Roque was saying at all he is no longer an official of the gov

Sir Carpio's advise is the right approach kailangan natin pumapalag. Like what happens to Natuna Island of Indonesia. When Pres Widodo brings all his military in the area, and then suddenly all the tsekwa fishing boats and two big coastguard disappear. Tsekwa said it is their traditional fishing grounds pero bakit tumakbo sila? Kailangan natin ipagtanggol ang ating sovereign

JUSTICE CARPIO, PLS. FILE A CANDIDACY FOR SENATOR! WE NEED A BRIGHT, HONEST AND A TRUE PATRIOT LAWMAKER LIKE YOU IN THE SENATE! PLEASE 🙏🙏🙏

Do not agree what ever china or duterte will say. Philippines must repair the ship since it is our territory and inside the EEZ. We can put military over there also. It is our rights.

I agree on what Carpio said. "Put a Lighthouse in Ayungin Shoal".

dapat laging may naka tambay na nagbabantay na coastguard dyan sa Ayungin,at hindi nila iniiwanan yan para malaman ng mga Tsikwa na hindi nila sakop yang ayungin.Kung sakop nila yan bakit naisadsad dyan yung Sierra Madre?Sana noon pa binabantayan na nila yan.Kailan lang sila nag patrulya dyan noong lumago na yung ekonomiya nila at lumakas na yung military nila.

This story needs to develop quick and we’re waiting for a Duterte interview. I hope this story exposes him and gets him into more trouble aside from the ICC trials coming. He better not get a VIP jail cell for what he did to the entire country.

NOT!! A gentlemans agreement, but Its a TRAITORS AGREEMENT.😢😢😢

Sir Carpio you have a mind and heart of a true filipino , i salute you !

Your right Atty. Carpio its a bilateral aggreement between two. In short this gentle aggreement is effectively only during the term of digong after His term is null and void.

Your the best Sir Carpio

It Siera Madre should be repaired. Non of China's business

Kong hindi na puede e repair, maglagay na ng panibagong barko, ok ba yon?

We need this intellegent. pilipino in our government to depend our legal rights in WPS Iwas na tayo sa sikat na walang laman

ATTN. FORMER SC JUSTICES, PLS. HELP US TO KNOW MORE ON POLITICAL DYNASTIES, WE NEED NEW LEADERS, OUR COUNTRY IS SINKING 🙏🙏🙏

I love hon. Carpio in the presence of repairing the ship and put some light house in said area including building of structure to our research personel. Hon. Carpio stand as TUNAY na Pilipino till the end of his journey, mabuhay po kayo hon. Carpio

kung pinapanindigan ng gobyerno na sa Pinas yan, irepair na agad agad,kilos na hanggat di pa tuluyang bumabagsak ang Sierra Madre🇵🇭🙏🙏🙏

the best is while conducting the balikatan we must bring all the nesissary material needed there. and repair it immediately.

Then why you did not suggested that during your incumbency as the chief justice of pres Aquino's administration.

airlift ang dapat gawin pag may resupply mission or magpascort sa u.s warship pag madeliver ng construction supply

Go go go dear president lets do what Justice Carpio said!

very nice & enlightening conversation.

coast guard to accompany beside the Sierra Madre that even water canon will attack the coast the Sierra Madre that was commissioned will automatically included in the water cannon attack.

mraming pilipino ang lumaban sa mga dayuhan pra sting bansa at ngayon ay kinikilala ntin ibalik ntin ang kasaysayan dhil mraming bansa ang kkampi ng pilipinas

Atty CARPIO pwedi ba dagdagan natin ng isang barko para may alalay na isa ang BRP SIERRA MADRE sa ayungin shoal.

Well the mutual defense treaty ang nag sasalba sa atin

Ang kailangan ng “Bansa ay Pangulong may SAPAT na TALINO at PRINSIPYO na KATULAD ni FAJ CARPIO..kahit sa panag inip sana ako’y katulad ninyo.

Digong Sold our SOUL? Yet?

Yes put a huge lighthouse permanently

U are so good Grace Antonio… smart explanation!

Nice idea sir

Paano? Hindi nga makapagdala ng mga construction supply, dapat escorted by foriegn militiray!

I agee to Justice Carpio 100%. A true Filipino in mind and spirit. Mabuhay po kayo Sir. Pbbm should learn this and take immediate action.

ilagay ang lahat ng pera ng bansa para gumawa mga gamit pang agriculture. pagawa ng barko. at wag ibigay bilang ayuda .ginagawa ng mga politiko para mas malaki ang kurakot nila dahil wala ng accouting. lalo silang yayaman. ang mahirap lalong hihirap. we need a job for every pilipino. wag ayuda dahil aasa na lang sa ayuda...

Dapat kailangan natin mabuti si justice antonio carpio para matulungan ang ating bansa ineed him to be our next president by 2028

Bakit pa ipaparepare ang Sierra MADRE. Bakit hindi nalang Gamitin ang taxes ng bayan sa pagpapatayo ng maraming sari saring FACTORY tulad ng pagawaan ng malalaking fishing vessel! Wag asahan ang mga banka ng ating mga mangingisda. Pagawaan ng mga airplane, heavy industrial machineries, Tractor, harvester for agricultural use para sa mga magsasaka. Wag ninyong asa hang pang habang buhay ang KALABAW, in this case it will create millions of millions of job. Don’t push the citizens to build its own private local industry, pagawaan ng tuyo, tsinelas, Bakya..instead support our local product by pouring billions of pesos assistance..ITIGIL ANG PAMIMIGAY NG AYUDA THIS CREATE LAZY CITIZENS AND THIS ONLY GIVE CHANCES TO GOVERNMENT IN POWER RAMPAMT CORRUPTION AND MANIPULATING OUR HUNGRY POOR PILIPINO. PILIPINOS NEED PERMANENT JOB TO HAVE FOOD IN EVERY TABLE OF FAMILIES. AYUDA IS ONLY WAY OF MANIPULATING THE POOR TO REMAIN POOR FOREVER. GOVERNMENT IN POWER TOOK THE MORE MONEY OUT OF PEOPLES HARD EARN TAXES.. You in the government wants PILIPINOS to remain poor you make AYUDA AS AN EXCUSE for all politician TO CONTINUE corrupting peoples taxes, AYUDA MAKES ALL politicians RICHER AND RICHER THEY takes more bigger SHARE than what they give..

Well, I agree with ex SCJ Carpio, Why China dictate our own decisions if what to do to delapilapidated Sierra Madre which is in our own territory, China have no right stopping us repairing Sierra Madre, If we followed the ideas of Roque, well its just were giving up our right in Ayungin shoals. 😂😂

Carpio mabuhay , binigyan mo Ng linaw Ang issue Ng west Philippine sea

Former CJ A Carpio is right in his narrative that whenever back down we lose our rights in our EEZ😢😢😢

Nasaan ang OUTRAGE ng Both Houses MEMBERS.

Roque is a spoke person of China.He defend the interest of China.

Mababaw na dahilan.... agreement malinaw na pina paboran talaga nito ang tsikwa....

Sana ang mga etchas ng mga sundalo sa Siera Madre ay si Carpio ang mag dispose sa mainland PH!

Yes agree with you hope our leaders see u as an exemplary adviser people need you our salute

Dear God. 🙏🙏Pls give wisdom like that of king Solomon for people who really love n protect our nation. Bless our nation because you are the God who does the impossible. In Jesus name we pray. Amen🙏🙏

Let us do whatever we like in Ayungin its ours build quarters build everything

A "gentlemen's agreement" is a private agreement between two or more gentlemen. It is only binding on those particular gentlemen who are parties to the agreement. It is not an official agreement of any sort. An official agreement between the government of the Philippines and another state must pass through the approval of Congress and be officially documented. The "Duterte-China gentlemen's agreement" was a private agreement made by Duterte and not an official agreement authorized by the Philippine government. Therefore, it doesn't bind the Philippine government to that agreement, whatever that was. And China knows that very well. But China's biggest miscalculation probably was that it falsely assumed that more Filipinos would be pushovers like Duterte, which proved to be awfully wrong, and that it could bully its way to lawlessness in the international waters of the South China Sea and within the Philippine EEZ indefinitely, which was another grave miscalculation by China.

™️AJ Carpio's arguments are superior to all regarding WPS issues

Tama van po yan na Hindi nila sakop ang Ayungin Shoal.

Good thinking justice salute you for that..

Tama ka Justice Carpio na hindi na kailangan erepair ang nabubulok na BRP SIRRA MADRE kasi subra nang serasera. Ang sugestion ko kung puede palitan nalang ng Retired US Aircraft carrier of the US navy. Puede nsman ang AFP bumili o manghingi sa USAF ng mga retired US AIR CRAFT Carrier. Mas igagalang pa ng Tsina at malaki puede gawing kampo ng maramira raming sundalo. Puede pa maglanding ang small military plane and helecopter at anytime.

Yes, it would do well if we put up a lighthouse in Ayungin shoal to give notice to the world that is within our EEZ. Agree!!!

THANK YOU 🙏 MAAM KAREN DAVILA !!! MABUHAY PO KAYO

For any given situation between countries..talking is a very important weapon /way to prevent misunderstanding or war between countries 😂😂

My own suggestion is to bring all the goods needed to repair the brp Sierra madre with the help of navy and coast guard no more question

Very well said Mr 20% of ex Chief Justice of Supreme court.

Carin you have to interview the president bbm tell him you must get Mr Carpio to joint in your cabinet and assign him in WPS

An American's opinion...dont trade the military presence there for a civilian presence. Simply add the civilian presence. It seems to me you can even add to both a civilian and military presence there, no? I hope you do not surrender your sovereign rights in the shoal and i hope my country never lets you down there again. Mabuhay ang Pilipinas Ne'er shall invaders trample thy sacred shores In thine embrace tis rapture to lie. And it is glory ever when thou art wronged.... I stand by the Philippines no matter what happens and as i watch your civilians in small wooden boats face China's much bigger iron ships, I am so proud of your courage and integrity in the face of this big bully. I bet your courage is noted also by the chinese people on the ships harrassing you. I am sure they must hide some respect for that.

In the realms of Ph interest no one among Filipinos may take sides but one-Ph side en perpetoum...❤

Brilliant, Sir!!!🎉

Good job sir justice Carpio. Please continue to teach us our rights to our territory. Specialy WPS. May GOD in heaven bless you always!

Put a Military outpost besides BRP Sierra Madre and at the same time repair it.

SIR TAKBO KA PLS FOR SENATOR OR ANY POSITION IKAW KAYLANGAN ANG TAONG BAYAN NAPAKA LINAW ANG YONG PALIWANAG THANK YOU SIR

I hope the President see and listen to this.

Pbbm must get Mr Carpio and assign him in WPS he is very good maybe he can solve the problem in WPS

We need leader like Justice Antonio Carpio and Antonio Trillanes to their patriotic principle.

Good point atty.carpio go go informed th e people run for senate i think this time you have a chance

To put a lighthouse is need a budget, our congress wont even file a bill to do that very simple and easy solutions to assert our EEZ

Instead of bringing in construction materials to Siera Madre ship ,why not considered bringing in Portalets it could make China happier because ob viously yoour soldiers releasing their waste directly in the sea like your onformal setlers in Manila!

If better to replace a new ship or more ship

Well explained, Justice Carpio , Sir. I know as I oftened heard it that you are already giving your recommandations . views and opinions of what to do and not to do regarding problems on WPS , only , the president at that was not listening. Good job...

" VOTE FOR CARPIO AND GIBO TEODORO IN 2028 "

Every President has different approach & strategy in dealing with WPS issue. That is why they are the chief architect of the country's foreign policy. It doesn't mean that they are already surrendering our sovereignty. If Carpio wants to be heard then run for president and be the chief architect foreign policy and that if you can win.

Those who agreed with China on conditions on how to maintain the outpost in ayungin shoal has little understanding on what he is doing.

Carpio you go to pbbm tell him what you are talking in your interview with Carin

Why not tell PBBM what you want to happen in Ayungin Shoal?

You deserve a seat in the Philippine senate. Please consider

My salute sir Justice Antonio Carpio mabuhay ka.

Yes, Justice Carpio. You're correct.

Pwede siguro humingi tayo ng condemned warship sa US o ibang bansa as donation kesa pina palubog lang nila tapos i dagdag na lang natin sa sierra Madre para madagdagan mga sundalo dyan

The President who agree not to repair the military post in ayungin shoal is really joking.

Watch out for politicians / media personalities who is a modern "makapilis" 😒🧐

dapat kasi na ang mga nanalong pulitiko di lang basta matapang at matalino dapat umaaksyon din🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🙏

Basta yong atin malaya tayo huwag ng pansinin ang intsik, tulad ng mga ibang bansa sa ginawa nila

No need to listen to china as long as Philipines was doing in accordance by International Law and within Philippines territory

Carpio is totally correct in his suggestions.

Please repair the Sierra Madre

Its impossible to repair BRP Sierra Madre , wake up!

Sir Justice Carpio please run for Senator

It's nice to repair the #BRPWithUSAMuseumForAllTheTorriests! #BadDutarte. Get all the Oil and all the Richness in Philippines Seas! #4April2024. #PoorTitoIsladsScaringThemResidentsThere!$ #WithArtifecialChinaIslandsIsElegalInThePhilippinesWater!$ 🇵🇭⭐️🇺🇸🚢⛽️

why repair,bat di na lang palitan ng mas malaking barko

Ang galing talaga ni Sir Carpio.

its a transistion issue from brp to davao del sur marine vessel they know the power of the tomhawk torpedo semi nukes weapons sank the davao del sur vessel

We don't have to talk with china what we like to do inside our EEZ.If we want to drill for oil inside our EEZ, we just have to make USA as partners of this project and go ahead with this plan.

Gibo Teodoro for President...Zubiri for Vice President. Antonio Carpio is the best Presidential Adviser. Gusto kong ang maghahawak ng Pilipinas ay may utak at pusong Pinoy. Ayoko ng dinadaan sa popularity vote ating mga kandidato.

yes. we need Carpio as VP