It's ridiculous for a country with a space station to learn technology from a Middle Eastern country. Do you really think this plane has any technological content
@@sunxc9446if its not why they copy that chines gj11drone is copy of iranian rq170.most of Chinese technology arent realy work they just have face like buy su35 from russia but dont use your owen j20 figher(no one ever seen jet realy work).
@@sunxc9446 silly of you to underestimate Iran or any other Middle Eastern country. After all, China is still a developing country, so why wouldn't China want to learn from other global players?
you have misunderstood. It is just an unofficial trade fair. Any private seller or buyer can display it and it does not include China's official military factories. This low-end model of drone is no more than manufacturing children's toys in China. My nephew made something similar to Shahed 136 for his summer science homework. Control servos, communication modules, and simple flight control software can all be purchased at very low prices on Taobao, then print a PCB and assemble it with a soldering iron under my guidance. . . In the face of the super supply chain, high-tech things that appear to Iran are as easy as buying potato chips in China , so much so that they can do it in their rural backyards and Organize production. Chinese military looks down on these gadgets and has no intention of large-scale production. However, the Chinese government is indeed happy to see private companies producing these gadgets and exporting them to Russia, yes! The general export of small commodities for civilian use, unrelated to CCP, is simply perfect, and the international community can't even find a reason for sanctions.
Haha China is the big country when it comes to drones! Don't use Iran to confuse China! Iran is such a shit, selling oil but not asking for dollars! As long as China has arms and transferred technology, can it make chips? Aircraft carrier? space shuttle? fighter? Nuclear submarine? Satellite weapons? Everyone knows that China’s DJI drones are powerful!
I am from Iran, and I approve of China using our design to make and improve the Shahed Drone. And I love the the name "Sun Flower" . Glory to China and Russia from Iran
Brother, why did your country attack Pakistan? It shocked all Pak population as we never considered Iran an enemy country. Thanks God sanity prevailed and things got settled soon without further escalation.
In the coming Third World War, this munition delivery system will dominate the battlefield in what is fast becoming a Crowd-Designed Weapon. Tanks are Vulnerable. Trenches are Vulnerable. Military Conferences are Vulnerable. There is a reason that Field Uniforms have low-contrast shoulder patches to deny snipers and spotters a ready target.
I can tell you that despite decades of sanctions, Iran has become very powerful from a military point of view. The important point is that it makes most of its own weapons and is not dependen
They have some of the best computer programers in the world. When you are used to working with 2 cans & string you get good at it! They haven't had the luxury of being able to write bloatware.
The reason why this drone is also great is because the missile used to shoot it down may cost more than the drone itself, so at the minimum you are making your opponent use up more resources even if they can defend against it.
Taiwan’s 2014 Sunflower Movement unleashed a wave of youthful activism that has profoundly reshaped the island’s political landscape, showing how activists can effect change through elections.
@@vlhc4642 Since they have open elections one would assume if "most now regret it", they'd simply elect to be annexed by China, yet that is not the case.
In addition to China, Russia has also copied the Iranian Shahed-136 kamikaze drone, recently inventing the Geran-2 kamikaze drone and the even more modern KYB kamikaze drone. But we must not forget that Iran has also modernized the Shahed-136 by equipping it with a turbojet instead of a piston MD550. Now, it no longer buzzes like a scooter, Iran has also produced the Shahed-238 kamikaze drone, much more modern, silent and powerful than the Shahed-136. Iran also produced the Arash-2 kamikaze drone.
Haha China is the big country when it comes to drones! Don't use Iran to confuse China! Iran is such a shit, selling oil but not asking for dollars! As long as China has arms and transferred technology, can it make chips? Aircraft carrier? space shuttle? fighter? Nuclear submarine? Satellite weapons? Everyone knows that China’s DJI drones are powerful!
Does China imitate Iranian drones? This is the dumbest ignorant news I've ever heard! More than 70% of the world's most advanced drones are produced in China, not to mention top international giants like China's DIJ. China has the most complete industrial chain of humanity, from chips to space stations and aircraft carriers. China can manufacture 100% entirely by itself. That's why the United States and its allies launched a trade war against China, sanctioning over 2000 high-tech Chinese companies. No one will tell you that most of Iran's drone parts are imported from China.
ایران فقط ۵ مدل پهباد انتحاری رادار گریز دارد این پهباد ها بیش از صد بار از تمام رادار های پیشرفته امریکا و اسرایل عبور کردن و ب هدف رسیدند پهباد شاهد ۱۳۶ برای ۷ سال پیش است
Well considering the entire west is supplying Ukraine can you blame Russia for sourcing weapons where they can? The US has given just about everything they can including man power!
Who cares about blame, Russia has invaded Ukraine and is desperate having dug themselves down in trenches hoping to outlast US political will or gamble that Trump wins the election and helps Putin.
The US has given Ukraine manpower? You're claiming US troops are fighting in Ukraine? Hilarious! You have been nominated for the most ridiculous statement troll award. Bagdad Bob has nothing on you! 🤣🤣🤣
@sandybennett_itsme yes they have given manpower! Intelligence from pilots, men on the ground directing fire, trainers, and my tax dollars which I never got to vote on!! I'm glad actually ecstatic Russia is winning and will win. I am suspecting our dirty president is being blackmailed by ukriane and is willing to sink our country to save his arese!! Ukraine has zero value to America and is a complete waste of our time and 500,000 dead ukraians would likely agree with me!! Wakeup and tell me why are our men again risking their lives for yet another war? I am sick to death of our crap government getting involved in another war but this one could end all life on earth for what?
That tip modification is very interesting. If it has a camera and a remote guidance capability, then the drone can actually be retargeted in flight beyond just Beitou guidence. This can become more like a long range, large warhead version of the Lancet.
@@Hainan海南岛he is talking about the spread and scale and Chinese manufacturing, what’s wrong with that especially since you said China has paid for the design from Israel?
They have even much more and the US government is playing recently with fire. It is a miracle that the US never learned about fighting far away from its shore like Vietnam - IRAQ - Syria or Afghanistan.
Bro, i got to say. Many do underestimate China a lot. Think about it. China is the birth place of DJI, the world undoubted No.1 on drones design and production. China must've created tons of different military design. Look on youtube for the Barrage Swarm Drone Laucher. It is by far the most dominating drone-related weapon so far. and yet China is doing tons more when come up with anti-Drones.
Haha China is the big country when it comes to drones! Don't use Iran to confuse China! Iran is such a shit, selling oil but not asking for dollars! As long as China has arms and transferred technology, can it make chips? Aircraft carrier? space shuttle? fighter? Nuclear submarine? Satellite weapons? Everyone knows that China’s DJI drones are powerful!哈哈
Amazing search string, bro. I've been trying to hook up to produce cheap attack drones in the USA but the profit model is based on huge projects where corruption and waste can easily be hidden instead of being serious about National Defense. "Bringing an Abrams to a Kamikaze Drone Fight"
In the Russian campaign of the 2nd world war, the German advanced Tiger and Leopard tanks, eventually could not hold their own against the cheap, and inferior Russian tanks., mainly due to the shear superiority in numbers of the Russian hardware. No matter how advanced an air defence system, it can become ' saturated ' and ' spent ' if the enemy launches a massive attack by cheap but plentiful drones or aircraft. This Shahed 136 was designed from the outset to overwhelm enemy air defences, and it looks as though, Iranians have achieved their design goal.
Does China imitate Iranian drones? This is the dumbest ignorant news I've ever heard! More than 70% of the world's most advanced drones are produced in China, not to mention top international giants like China's DIJ. China has the most complete industrial chain of humanity, from chips to space stations and aircraft carriers. China can manufacture 100% entirely by itself. That's why the United States and its allies launched a trade war against China, sanctioning over 2000 high-tech Chinese companies. No one will tell you that most of Iran's drone parts are imported from China. check
Haha China is the big country when it comes to drones! Don't use Iran to confuse China! Iran is such a shit, selling oil but not asking for dollars! As long as China has arms and transferred technology, can it make chips? Aircraft carrier? space shuttle? fighter? Nuclear submarine? Satellite weapons? Everyone knows that China’s DJI drones are powerful!
Shahed-136 is more than you know. China may replicate something with similar shape but it is not the same. This clip missed the electronic warfare system of it and only mentioned it is autonomous which means a lot
@@TheGhurabah sha-hid (شاهد) means ''witness'' in Arabic too... the word martyr is Sha-heed (شهيد). Semetic languages are just confusing big ways, I assume Persian too as many Arabic words in it.
shahed means martyr in farsi,arabic and turkish, which is more suitable since these drones are suicide drones, but yea shahed can also mean "watch" not witness. here's how they're written watch: شاهد martyr: شهيد (the name of the drone, shahed)
trying to teach me my own language :l what is witness in Arabic and farsi?? شاهد : can mean Watch! as order or Watched in past tense too. But what did they name the drone? I want the spelling in Farsi! @@enceladus4900
to defeat the iron dome, missiles should be bundled in a single big missile vector that liberate several smaller missiles before the impact of a counter missile.
Not efficient & not effective,junk ,read report of Pak army, bangladesh army, Nigerian army & Myanmar air force who had bought & suffered due to poor quality & technology of chinese weapons & jets
The most probable outcome, is that the target will be destroyed. Even the most heavily defended US aircraft carrier strike groups will not likely have anywhere near 1000+ missile interceptors available, and the Phalanx CIWS guns have rather short range, such that they would not be able to engage a very large number of the drones (compared to a swarm of 1000+), in the time that it takes for the swarm to transition from out of firing range, to hitting the target. The Shahed-136 drones fly rather slowly, which makes them vulnerable to getting shot down by airplanes with Gatling guns, but the US does not have anywhere near enough gun equipped fighters available to scramble quickly enough to shoot down a swarm of 1000+ drones at a time. Essentially, a swarm that large is pretty much guaranteed to saturate/deplete/overwhelm the best defenses that the US has available to it. In other words, US military doctrine is fundamentally flawed. A US aircraft carrier costs more than $10 billion USD, and is probably closer to $20 billion, when combined with the value of the other things on board (ex: airplanes, crew, munitions, etc.). However, the Shahed-136 is estimated to only cost $20,000 each, and if China is starting production of a new variant, it is likely that the price will fall, perhaps substantially. However, an attack made with a 1000x swarm of Shahed-136 guided long range munitions at $20,000 each, is only $20 million USD, which is 1/1000 of the value of the US aircraft carrier. In other words, if Russia, China, or Iran can sink a US aircraft carrier using a 1000x swarm of Shahed-136 style drones, which they probably can, they will basically win the battle in a large way, by a financial factor of 1000x. The US likes to think of itself as a "wealthy" nation, but the US economy is not 1000x bigger than China + Russia + Iran. The total US economy is somewhat smaller than China's economy, and the US is much less efficient at manufacturing things. Consequently, the US cannot realistically win a non-nuclear war of attrition against any reasonably sized nation that decides to mass produce cheap, but accurate, long range guided munitions, like the Shahed-136. A potentially realistic way for the US to try to win in such a scenario, is to adapt and become capable of manufacturing an even larger quantity of interceptors and their own attack drones, at a price cheaper than the adversary (or rather adversaries plural, since Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea all appear to be effectively allied against the US at this point). Realistically, such is not likely to happen, since the US government has not even recognized its own vulnerabilities and weaknesses, and the US is not flexible or efficient when it comes to building factories quickly and mass producing things cheaply. Each missile interceptor that the US expends shooting down Shahed-136 style drones usually costs the taxpayer around $1-2 million USD each. The Shahed-136 has a large enough warhead to be dangerous and thus the US does need to shoot them down if it wants to win a battle, but at the same time, they cost too much for the US to actually shoot any significant quantity of them down. Every time the US shoots down a Shahed-136 style drone, using a $1 million dollar missile interceptor, the adversary effectively still wins, since they successfully destroyed a $1 million USD target, for a drastically lower price of $20,000.
Iran helped it allies while. Israel didn't help anyone until now the Israeli weapons are not seen or deployed in Ukraine and i wonder 🤔 why hmmmm ?! Anyway not bad for drone 👍😊😉
Iranian drone🇮🇷😎♥️ Because it is the original, and the rest of the drones are a copy of it And of course, the Iranian drone has demonstrated its capabilities in a real war, but not the Chinese drone!
China can make better engines than Iran, leading to lower weight and higher range - for same payload. More importantly, China can mass produce these drones, in far greater numbers than Iran.
You see the invention of this weapon from the country's geniuses who were and are under the most severe arms, equipment, economic and political embargoes! Unlike other countries that are full of international deals and large arms purchases from superpowers, here a superpower that you always buy weapons from is asking Iran to sell the technology of a weapon to Chinese!
And China can make them cheap. And China is Iran's biggest trading partner, with Iran having a trade surplus with China so they have plenty of RMB to buy Chinese products. I think we're going somewhere here.
There is no need for a data link at all. The desired goal and mission is determined beforehand, and once the drone starts its mission, it will not return. The drone detects the location of the target with a GPS sensor and the target itself with a camera installed and processed by artificial intelligence and moves towards it at maximum speed.
Chinese drones with computer vision and AI can be more deadly in the battlefield. These loitering bombs can become fire and forget weapons - which will seek and destroy enemy autonomously.
What's important in the battlefield is A weapon East to use cost effective and have huge impact Iran is the best on this matter right now Using a multi million kamikaze drone to destroy a million dollar vehicule is a failure in the army war standards It's not always the case we're the most expensive stuff with high tech is the best If the easy cheap one do the same job why spending money you can make multiple ones rather then one I know that every expert in the field will understand what I say Russia can make drones but they choosed the Iranians ones because of this matter You can use your multi million drone I have thousands of cheap one that do the same job
@@frankfleming1103به دانشش رسیدیم به لطف تریحم های آمریکا و غرب به دانش موشکهای نقطه زن و هایپر سونیک هم رسیدیم البته جنگ خوب نیست ضعیف بودن هم خوب نیست به کشورهای ضعیف نگاه کن همیشه مورد تهاجم وغارت ابر قدرتها هستن نظم دنیا نیاز به پاکسازی عقاید استعمارگرانه دارد نظمی عادلانه و برابر برای همه هیچ کسی از دیگری برتر نیست
R u kidding me? Who copy Who? The original design was from Isreal in 1980s, then China copied it in 1990s. then lots of countries copied after 2000s including Iran
It’s a very effective weapon because it is accurate, even if slow, and carries a huge warhead. So the threat of the drone has to be honoured and air defence HAS to engage them, often using interceptors that cost 10X as much. Beyond a combat weapon it is an economic one. I think radar-layed ADA SPAAGs like the German Gepard are going to become MUCH, MUCH more popular. Only economical way that these weapons can be intercepted is with guns like this.
Back in 2014 i designed one with an RC motor and i told people it would great to be used as one way attack drones for antitsnk use and people called me stupid... Well
@@abdulshariff00 Wood or fiberglass structure with fuel bladders, 50 Hp motor, wood propeller. Control surface services. Glonass motherboard, payload. Bill of material estimate? Rest is labor. These tech is very disruptive.
هزینه هرسه تأمینی روسی ایرانی که دراصل ایران درروسیه برایشان میسازدویاحدعقلدرنسخه یروسی نخبگان ایرانی هم وجودداردکه بانمک همدیگربهترش راتولیدکنندهمیانطورکه درچین داریم
صورة المسيرة الفي الفيديو ده حطام المسيرات الهاجمت شندي اليوم ولا صورة ساي من طرف محشورة في الفيديو؟؟ لأنه لو دي صورة المسيرات المهاجمة دي صورة المسيرة الصينية زهرة الشمس ٢٠٠ ودي مداها في حدود ١٢٠٠ الى ١٥٠٠ كيلومتر وده معناها في تطور نوعي في قدرة الدعم السريع على استهداف مناطق بعيدة جدا عن اماكن سيطرتهم. تبقى المعضلة هل في كادر مدرب بالشكل الكافي لاستخدام هذه المسيرات وما نوع الاتصال بين المتحكم والطائرة الانتحارية
This is definitely not made in China. China only provides drawings and parts. You can buy them and assemble them yourself. Like some special DJI accessory.
@@j4genius961 bro they copy everything. Gun powder is just one but they copy American military weapons, American/European automobiles and everyday essential products.
After 40 years sanctions, an indipendese country that needs nobody, design and sell it like other goods, defenatly Iranian have more surprises that dont wañt to show off or sell them
أصبحت الدول العظمى روسيا والصين وامريكا تقلد الدرون الإيرانية شاهد لما لها من سهولة التكاليف وأداء عالي جدأ في دقتها وإصابة الاهداف وهي تعتبر قديمة نوعأ ما بالنسبة للصناعات العسكرية الإيرانية التي تتطورأ بشكل كبير تضاهي الدول الكبرى وتفوقها احيانا
Iran's drones are in fact copies of Israel's IAI Harpy drones, which are used for anti-radar purposes, whereas Iran, due to its backward electronics industry, produces Shahed 136 drones that can only strike stationary targets and are not very accurate. And in fact, Iran's drone uses a lot of Chinese civilian drone parts and Western electronic equipment. So to say that China has copied the Shahed 136 is patently inaccurate. China already had a Harpy drone in 1994, and a modified ASN-301 anti-radiation drone went into mass production in 2007.
Not just a copy but exact clone of the drone. The only difference i see is that it had a bigger warhead and one piece frame compared to Iranian shahed drone
If something works, someone somewhere will copy it, and make it better. Anyway, the Iranian drones looked so simple even peasants in china can do it with off the shelf components.
开局一张图，内容全靠编。那个车间图片一看就是私人小工厂，把它跟军方强行联系起来编故事就他妈的无耻。 The opening picture is entirely made up. The picture of that workshop looks like a small private factory. To forcibly connect it with the military and create a story is fucking shameless.
dude, china is the no1 drone manufactor and design fecilitie, have you heard the company called DJI? thats a Chinese compamy, have you thought about the relationship between China and Iran, mayby its the other way around.....
