Classical Musicians Guess What Instruments Strangers Play 

Underrated comment right here XD

LMAOO

Hands down best comment! 😂

I saw this comment before watching the video and I was like “Oh yeah cause they probably don’t do well.” Now I’m at the end, and can I say, I did not expect them to do THAT poorly... Thank Christ they chose music 😂😂😂

The crime that violin chan is still waiting to be saved 🤣

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA yeah

Based on stereotype, I correctly guessed the pianist. C Major. She gave it away 😂

I kept replaying this part 😂

Claire de Lune one is a really brilliant misdirection! 👏👏👏 I personally love Silencio and sometimes use it to fall asleep, and Claire de Lune is definitely up there in the list beside Silencio 👍

Best comment ever!

The reveal for that one was epic ngl

The fact that this has 2k likes and two replies amazes me

LOL

How?!?

The brass and the harp too...

That was eddy

The subtitle said, trombone, but I heard trumpet

As a Piccolo Player i related to that one

MusicalBasics I do...even when I am just 11 lol

Is that a tenor clef that I see

2:07 Writing a thesis is easyru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uGiR-neokWs.html

Yoooooooo, you watch TwoSet? THAT’S AWESOME! Love your piano - been listening to you since... 2009-2010!!

I just got done watching one of ur videos.....

cool video idea!!!

There is *1 Violist* among us

@@violetneiv lmao yessss

SEND THEM OUT THE AIRLOCK

There is one impostor among us

Lol

This! My reaction was basically: "...?" when they said it, (cuz it seems like a bit of a silly thing to say in any case) and then it turned out that HE dOES iNDeED PlAY THe HaRP Im SCreaMIng. Look where bias can get you. getting all the answers wrong in your own musician quiz xD tsk tsk.

I was screaming because E flat major is such a hint to him being a harpist!

@@katrienktrn why tho? I'm curious, does the position of the strings make it easier to pluck the scale?

@@emalaw1329 E flat major is when the pedals are up and when the strings will sound the most beautiful!

@@katrienktrn got it, INTERESTING! Thanks!

this comment was written by a cultural smart brain. Lmaooooo good oneee

Even as a violinist I can't stand it, TBH.

@@00muinamir Canon in D is very often played almost like a funeral march. It's a lot better in the original tempo. Example: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JvNQLJ1_HQ0.html

@@HerraTohtori its still very overplayed

As a pianist I can't stand it as well lmao. My classmates keep shitting me to play it.

Occasionally*

Omg I laughed so hard at this. Literally what my stereotype was 😂

And not everyone who looks like Toni is a flautist lol

Lmaoooooo

He was giving off cello vibes tho. I've met at least 3 cellists that he reminds me of

Yes 😂

Youre definitely not alone

Ff

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-VfAZnSMzMAU.html 11:55 You can find the violinist play and probably the others too, from the other videos in the channel. He's the second violinist.

Underrated

same here

she*

@@lynnnalee9866 thanks

Her name in the description has no "beat" at all. Unless there is something I missed, Beat is maybe a nickname.

Nominative determinism - the idea that a thing ends up the way it is because of what it's called.

@@tirzakharisma3566 oohhh, that's why Thanks btw

proves: GENDER DOESN'T MATTER

Ppl say I don't look like an oboist cuz I'm a white dude :'D

HAHA the girl thing didn't hurt

🤣

turns out beat is a nickname. the real name is ******* (name hidden to prevent spoilers, check the vid descriptions)

And the brass player😂

Brett would have gotten two of them right if they didn't ask questions (that had misleading answers anyway!)

I know right

eddy was the imposter

@@zahrahxx truu haha

Eddy, the game destroyer hhhh

Brett always guesses right 😂

Ikr Brett needs to back himself more. He’s right most of the time

oh noooo flutecookies

I instantly got the piano vibes from the pianist lmaooo

@@maulyjain same. all the other were difficult but she was so obvious lmao

@@nessa9732 true lmaooo

Which one of them dated a flautist for years? That’s pretty cool

as a beginner, the struggle is real!

And are they callused? :-)

@@oxoelfoxo They sure are! After a while, the calluses aren't that visible though, more like hard fingertips.

Yea that’s sAcRiLeGiOuS

@@Max-jf5vu Do violinists get calluses or hardened fingertips, too?

LMAOOO

When they said the first player was an oboe I died 😂

@@heyytheree hahahhahahahhaha true i felt the mini tension

@@benjaminredd8070 So true!

HAHAHA SAMEEEE

Lol 😂

That was a brilliant misdirection, I love it! and Claire De Lune is definitely good for sleep, not wrong about that 🤣

They should have qualified the question as favorite piece "on your instrument"

I also listen to Claire de Lune when i can't sleep😂🤣

@@oxoelfoxo that would have probably broken their rules for questions

But if there are the same amount of labels as there are musicians, then every time they guess 1 wrong, there will be at least one other they also have to get wrong The other way around is not the same. Just because you guess one right, still mean you do not necessarily have all the other right as well. So I think there's a bigger chance of failure than of success

😂😂😂

@@chomo54andbabyaisha97 can you calculate the probabilities to get all right vs all wrong vs 1 right

@@wada-wada I think that is possible, but I only know about logic, I am not good at math. If you are bored because of the corona lock downs, I would start out with the smallest possible sample and then work upwards. I don't remember exactly the rules, but you can start with two labels, then see if it is possible to calculate, and then three and then compare to see if there is a connection of some kind. I am used to truth tables in boolean logic, should be possible to do something similar here. It's just a structured way of listing all possibilities in a table (and it is very good if you're not good at math because you can see all the results visually, it just take a little time).

@@wada-wada ok finally comes to my field of expertise

yes, their deduction is flawless

LOLOLOL so true! I was thinking the same thing!!

yes

personally, im offended

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ApRt35-s5jU.html

I KNOW

Yes, I need that

hope it would mostly be Eddy actually listening to Brett

Azizah Siddiqui He should have cut Brett less. He does that so often in so many videos that I’m getting a bit annoyed.

@@ajchandra7735 I get "Eddy is the youngest child in the family" and "Brett is the oldest child in the family" vibe from them. I mean, *in my opinion*, most of the time, Brett didn't look annoyed (except on this vid when he actually guessed right, and Brett shows it that he is annoyed). But yeah, I agree, there are times when I think Eddy should let Brett talk more.

Yes i think this is a fun theme, maybe some improvement for them 1) make it Brett v/s Eddy and seeing who guess right the most will be more entertaining 2) the video quality 😭

Yeah, like, how does a pianist don't like GOD Beethoven? I don't like Mozart's piano pieces (I like his symphonies), but Beethoven...

@@LucasOliveira-wo9xj Probably a contrarian personality type thing. Kinda relate, ngl.

I just like… don’t understand. Howww? To each their own, of course, but…

I am a pianist and I don't like Beethoven. I like his Kreutzer Sonata and Symphony no.9 and that's all. He is just overhyped. For example, I like Chopin / Liszt / Tchaikovsky / Shostakovich / Rachmaninoff. I admit that Beethoven is a great composer but personally I like Chopin and Rachmaninoff more.

Always need those longer arms...

Not always. Every trombonist in our orchestra is pretty short. Not saying they are good at their instrument either.

I am a 5'3" trombonist. I just tilt my shoulders a bit to get full extension. I will say, most trombonists I know are tall. I am always the shorty in the pack.

I'm 176cm, and my arms are more than long enough to play trombone with comfort (although they are somewhat longer than usual for my height). If your arms are too short, you can also use a 'kwartventiel' (don't know the English name) which is common. You normally only really need the last position for two (less common) notes anyway, only in the low register. The second last position is also only needed for two (more common) notes, they may sound a little too high as a kid.

Yeah I agree

Any sus?

I thought of that too

Count me in, Imma use all the things TwoSetV taught me to trick them into thinking I practice 69 hrs a day, & go threaten them using violin-chan as hostage. *lol*

Impos TOR not impos TER

Maybe a singer

Same I was so happy to se an oboe!! we love the small bits of representation we get

@@Kesthechicken fr!!

Oboe unite - ppl don't think I'm an oboist cuz I'm a white dude :'D

@@Yello96486dang stereotypes, am I right? what do they think you play lol

@@Simplyabandkid trumpet 😭

Brett has crazy people intuition lol

he actually initially got 2 (or 3?) guessed right.

Yea I saw that vibe as well. He was right on the spot.

@@rabbitsonblue he definitely does! Must be the ENFP in him while Eddy was overthinking 😅

@@melaniescarlet01 good catch!! I also notices that when you are in a conversation with ENFPs they tend to steer it to talk about you (instead of themselves), I wonder if Brett is like that too

I play viola and I don't know how to do that either, but it sounds fun! ^^; (Another viola game that just came to my mind: listen to viola pieces and try to guess who's the composer.)

Nah, they'd just figure it out in like 5 seconds

There is 1 imposter among us

among us vibesss

The Violist probably once played the Violin, so he or she probably knows how to fake his "Violinist" side.

Brett had a better gut feeling but went with the flow. Next time, Eddy please leave Brett to his instincts. xDD

@@maboleth in other games I notice that too, it's just that he have trust issues with himself 😅 Brett, be more confident coz you're actually smart :))

They should both interview everyone separately instead of together, that way we could see if Brett is actually better

Hi

My best friend is a violinist hahah

@@natalialecce7111 hahah my best friend is a violist

i also do not know on why they didn't think it's piano when they have made skits and video reactions of piano accompanying violin

Me, a pianist: looks at my 5 violin player friends and 1 bassist

I'm not an instrumentalist, but I have sung a lot and socialised with orchestral players. The brass and percussion sections are always the most fun!

percussionist here. agree

Trombone player here, i have never read a bigger truth

@@Noodle-hd8sn I well remember a production of "The Desert Song" where my character, Pierre, had to react to a trumpet fanfare. At random intervals, the trumpeter would insert different variants designed to trip me up... including Rimsky's "Scheherazade", "William Tell", the "Pink Panther" theme and, on the last night of the run, "The Stripper". Much mirth would ensue over drinks afterwards :)

That’s so true XD I do like hanging out with drum section

Intonation🤣🤣🤣

There was an Adam Neely Q+A with a question about brass players having notoriously bad rhythm, but they were trying to decide between violin and flute so who knows what they were thinking

AHHHH SAME IKR

how?

It was the fact that she had all violin friends for me. Immediately wondered if she was an accompanist for them.

i felt the same way, but isn't the same for all instruments?

@@yanas9871 I always found piano easy to practice in the sense that all is required to start is to just... sit at the piano. You can always get up and do sth else if you feel like it 😂 You don't have the extra hussle to open your case, put the shoulder rest on, tune and warm up (I guess as a violinist I have to warm up more than pianists). And when I decide I'm finished, I have to be serious - I have to loosen my bow, clean the strings, rosin my bow, take off the shoulder rest and close the case. It's like when a pianist is not in the mood it's much easier to stop practicing after only an hour. Disclaimer I'm not a pianist and I can be completely wrong, also I'm not suggesting in any way that piano is an easier instrument. Lots of love to piano gang! ♥️

I even prefer the piano version

It's beautiful, but it's so uncomfortable to play. The original was for 2 pianos btw

I play the harp. I'm not surprised that he loves Ravel.

@@nycgingercat lots of gliss?

@@rocketcrazy3467 Speaking of Ravel and two pianos. Bolero. Oh my. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE---_XLAsXupk.html

Wow! That is some observation-amazing!

i think we have different definitions of "easy"

That’s so cool. You should work in criminal justice and they should make a tv series about you!

Your observations were really nice. Thank you for sharing!

Detective Conan here XD Good job.

He is just curious lol🤣🤣

then they give her the violin anyway

@@beyondviolet Didn’t they give her flute?

As a vocalist, can confirm

Job security and an edifying hobby is one hell of a combo.

I am happy for you! My grown children came over for all of their old sheet music,after isolating at home and working remotely for months. Old hobbies and pastimes are being given new attention .

i’m so proud of you! keep going mate, you got this!

It is reassuring to know that for some people 2020 was a memorable year for good reasons.

Lol eddy flexing his perfect pitch as always 🤣

Surely less chance. Intonation is far easier on a piano

They nearly guessed correct, then said pianists don't like white keys. 😆

@@huaiwei higher level pianists dislike keys like c major because it's more difficult to play technically hard pieces on white keys

Time?

It's also extremely Southern. I didn't even notice it was weird lol.

@Scott Horton, yeah I was gonna say, we say it in America too!

And in the UK!

what i meant was "in a twoset's video"...aside from the scissors paper rock, this too is the most australian thing

@@user-gk5ob4lp4q yeah but they could've checked her calluses

or a lesbian

This is such a stereotype. I've been biting my nails since I'm 8. Nothing to do with the fact I've started piano 4 years ago.

@@CadenzaPiano true, but it's really uncomfortable to play piano with long nails so one wouldn't be wrong in assuming that from a group of musicians, a person with clipped nails is likely a pianist

@@ratsalad178 a lot of musical instruments are hard to play with long nails so I disagree. The only things I agree is to say that if she has long nails, she is probably not a pianist. But if she had short nails, I cant know what instrument she is playing

I agree with you 😌

*she is indeed :)

@@Jorinde123 it's a guy though?

@@nitya404 nope. A girl. Check her Facebook profile

@@Jorinde123 Shugo was a guy (was marked cello), Beat was a girl

ayy piano and clarinet gang

@@kitcatwafers ^ ♪～(´ε｀ )

@@kitcatwafers yes!

Oboe gang - ppl don't think I'm an oboist cuz I'm a generic white dude :'D

They didn't know the harp. It was misleading for me too: I first thought trombone (if you play it in C), in a concert band as trombone it's quite common to have some flats in the key. Since trombone is in nature a Bb instrument, most of the times played in C, then Eb is close to 'normal'.

Yeah, Eb is my favorite key to play in as a trombonist. Simply for ease purposes

Ahh that make sense

Depends, from personal motives could be. From difficulty in some pieces to from being burnt out. I like Beethoven, but I could understand if a pianist hate it. I like some pieces from him, but some are just so overplayed I don't feel the joy.

I think most pianists don't hate Beethoven. I play the piano but Beethoven is just not my favourite.

I can understand her not liking Beethoven, just like I don't really like Mozart.

@@lucist3048 this is shocking to me 😂😂. Like i think all the pianists i know have a common goal to play pieces by mozart or beethoven and thats what drove them for most of their journey as a pianist. Not liking either of these comes as a shock but then again people are different so fair enough.

@@lucist3048 this is shocking to me 😂😂. Like i think all the pianists i know have a common goal to play pieces by mozart or beethoven and thats what drove them for most of their journey as a pianist. Not liking either of these comes as a shock but then again people are different so fair enough.

Actually who is he?

@@KeishaPritaAngrijanata I just looked on wikipedia and just read few words so I can say: 1. he's playing flute (of course) 2. one who's said like charmeleon (can try to match a style of music composition...not about genre though) 3. becomes a principal for flutist on FBO (no idea what that stands for) here's the wikipedia for general reviews of him en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emmanuel_Pahud

And here are the videos of him ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-RNjroFNi7mA.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-fW1Xn_ZX1fI.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-z8X4AtE5c2k.html

I thought she was a flauist coz she made the hand gesture of playing the flute out of instinct.

@@KeishaPritaAngrijanata He’s a legendary flautist, he’s amazing!