It feels like any version that's not Roger Waters singing is unbearable. While I att the same time know this IS a great performance, but my love for the song and Pink Floyd is manipulating my brain to react condescending. :S
Ouch, this is really, really bad. Come on. I thought there was a law by the UN that Pink Floyd songs are forbidden to be covered... But then... maybe they wanted to punish Gilmore for not being there that night.
This rendition of one of the greatest songs ever written and recorded is absolute rubbish. I'd be embarrassed performing this low-quality version. If Dave Gilmour isn't on his strat slow jamming leading to that masterful solo at the end it's not even worth playing.