Complete Pizza Tier List 

Charlie's seriousness about eating expired food leads me to believe he's immortal but expired food is secretly his only Kryptonite

Matt SHOULD have his own tier list on screen. I'm sure we can all agree on that.

The absolute HORROR in Charlies eyes when Matt said the pizza was expired 💀

Matt's tier list absolutely deserves to be up there. He is just as important to these videos as Charlie is.

The fear in Charlie's eyes when he heard the pizza was expired was the purest emotion I've ever seen

Little Caesars is like a dice roll. Sometimes it has no sauce, sometimes it is burnt, and sometimes the cheese is barely hanging on to the pizza. But when you get that perfect pizza man is it good.

4:50 HAD ME DEAD “Is it like cheesy crust?” “Maybe… Its ass” “Oh goodness gracious”

Timestamps : 1. Red Baron - 1:32 - B 2. Tombstone - 2:59 - D 3. Digiorno - 4:24 - A 4. Tacobell - 5:46 - D 5. Hungry Howies - 7:42 - F 6. Little Caesers - 9:27 - F 7. Jet's Pizza -11:03 - A 8. Domino's - 12:09 - S 9. Papa Johns - 13:41 - A 10. Pizza Hut -14:43 - A 11. Marco's - 16:46 - F 12. Blaze Pizza - 18:37 - S 13. Cici's Pizza - 19:59 - B 14. Costco - 21:43 - B 15. Mama Celeste - 24:26 - C

I would love to see a video with Matt and Charlie in two different rooms testing the same pizzas so we can see an actual in real-time comparison. It's been long enough.

In defense of Little Caesars, the dollar to flavor ratio is pretty good I’d say for working with smaller budgets 😂

I will not tolerate this little caesars slander

Charlie's reaction when he heard it was expired makes me realize how much we need him to do a collaborative MRE tier list with Steve1989.

Charlie got stun locked when they said the pizza was expired. The pure shock on his face says it all

The way Charlie’s face changed when they said it was expired but he scientifically realized that it taste better expired and came to a new S+ tier for it has me hysterically laughing

17:01 is the best reaction ive seen to eating bad pizza lmao, just more so like disappointment then actually grossed out

As a GM of a dominos in st.Louis I was genuinely surprised when you gave it an s tier

26:43 The look of fear on Charlies face when Mat said the food was expired

As a Howie's employee, I can confirm that every pizza we've ever sold is a display pizza

I've really gotten into making my own pizzas recently, and my favorite I've found so far is a sort of Mediterranean themed pizza using Pita bread. I topped it with Hummus instead of tomato sauce, caramelized onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese, a sprinkle of mozzerella to hold the toppings together a bit better, and finally a balsamic glaze. Threw it in the oven on a pizza stone for 10 minutes at 375 and it came out PERFECT. Slightly sweet, slightly salty, a bit of tang from the balsamic. Turned out so well i'm making that my dinner for the next couple of weekends. Pretty healthy, too.

26:36 I have never seen someone switch from happy to scared for his life so quickly! Charlie. Do an "Expired food Tier List"

I love the dichotomy of 22:00 where Matt softly lifts the pizza up like it's a sheet of silk, and then in comes Charlie with the "Ah yes, it's missing the vaginal rugae?" and lifts the fucking thing up like a car hood.

I don't care what anyone says, Little Caesar's saved me from many dinnerless nights. For that alone it's legendary

22:07 excellent thank you for that Charlie.

The camera man zooming into their hands struggling to do stuff while they're saying dumb shit in the background is my favorite part of all of these.

I remember the first time I ordered Marco's pizza. I hadn't eaten all day, and it was the best pizza I have ever had. The next time we were ordering pizza, I recommended Marco's. I assured my family it would be good. That was the single worst pizza I have ever had. I have never been more betrayed by pizza company before or since.

If anyone is wondering why Charlie was freaked out about the expired pizza. He made a very personal video about being a severe hypochondriac. This video definitely showcases that. His mood, mannerisms, body language, speech, etc all changed when they said the pizza was expired. He looks like he had a mini panic attack. His friends realized this which is why they assured him that everything is fine and it was frozen. I'm also a hypochondriac and it can be very debilitating. Having friends that can recognize/support is amazing, huge shoutout to them.

We always ordered Dominos at work, a never fail really good pizza. The owner traveled the country and try pizza joints he heard about. His favorite was Buddy’s Pizza in Michigan.

How the fuck did Charlie burn frozen pizza, literally 10 minutes in the oven

I didn't realize we needed a larger pizza teir list until I saw this 👀

Time stampsss Frozen: Red baron 1:32 Tombstone 3:00 Digiorno 4:23 Fresh out the oven: Taco bell 5:46 Hungry Howies 7:42 Little Caesars 9:27 Jet’s 11:00 Dominos 12:09 Papa Johns 13:42 Pizza Hut 14:41 Marcos 16:45 Lebron James (Blaze pizza) 18:37 CiCi’s 19:59 Costco’s (THE G.O.A.T) 21:44 Mama Celeste 24:26

19:13 best reaction, came in like a blaze of glory 22:04 Charlie outta nowhere, Matt was not ready to hear that 25:17 this is like when your friend says it's good and you have to question yourself like, why do they like this, is there something wrong with my taste because it's not good to me

I'm gonna give you two Papa John's pizza hacks that will change your life: 1. order from a clean location that will not give you food poisoning 2. ask for both garlic butter and their special seasoning packets when you order, then when you get the pizza home, have the oven preheated to 425 F. brush the garlic butter over the crust, and then sprinkle the special seasoning + a little kosher salt over the crust only. place it in the preheated oven about 5 minutes. that will be the best Papa John's pizza you've ever had in your life. it's literally Papa John's pizza with Dominos crust. you're welcome.

Hes got good people around him. People are laughing at him pancing when he heard the pizza is expired but being a hypochondriac and suffering from panic attacks is no joke. His friends debunked the situation and told him its okay its frozen and Matt uplifted the mood and took a bite to make him feel better. Keep them close Charlie friends like that are hard to come by. i bet you he googled this later to make sure he was okay cause its the same thing i would of done.

little caesars is definitely a per-location experience. the one we have goes insane with the sauce

The thing about the Mexican pizza is that if you don’t eat it as soon as it comes out fresh, it gets soggy…. It’s really good if you get it fresh and you eat it right away but if you try to drive home with it by the time you get home, it’ll be a bowl basically.

As someone who has and will always love Cici's Pizza, I'm glad you guys liked it

It'll be cool to have Matt's own tierlist too

26:42 The look on Charile's Face and fast reaction he had when Mat said that the Pizza was expired was absolutely Hilarious. 🤣

Don’t know if this has been said, but Jet’s makes their own ranch dressing from scratch and it is AH MAZING.

If you’re ever up in Long Island you NEED to go to Labistros and get some pizza and their pasta purses. You don’t even need to rank either of those but it’s the best pizza you can get.

Charlie’s ability to compare some of these pizzas to things that shouldn’t be compared to pizza is wild

As someone who worked in the Costco Food court I will say the pizza has changed the last 2/3 years. They've gone with cheaper dough and cheese to keep up with the low prices they offer. So though it's still ok I can definitely tell the difference. Imiss the old pizza I'd tear it up.

When I was plant based I used to love blaze pizza, they have vegan options for toppings, I'm not vegan but I still order it that way, that's how good it was

Oh man. It would've been cool for them to make their own custom pizza and rate each other's. Missed opportunity

The look of dread on Charlie's face about the expiration date 🤣🤣🤣

Finally, the sequel we've all waited for

I agree with Matt we need scores, a matt score and a Charlie score for the tier list videos

I absolutely agree with Charlie. The Celeste pizza kicks ass. Though I never microwave it. To get the best out of it, you need to make it in the oven. I usually make it in my small Black & Decker counter oven/toaster and it absolutely slaps every single time.

it really is incredible how much better dominos has become. i remember having dominos for the first time in 2016 and thinking it was revolting. i heard they changed up their ingredients shortly after but never had the courage to try it again until very recently. the pizza was legitimately great. what a franchise turn around

As a college student, Jack's Supreme Pizza for $4 is an absolute steal

7:06 it’s literally an open face quesadilla

Is it bad? I’m actually relying on Charlie and Matt to give me a good tier list of pizza because I don’t know what I should get right now

26:40 That look on Charlie’s face when Mat said that the pizza was expired🤣

Charlie’s face at the end with Celeste’s pizza expiration date is gold 😂

They should individually try each place and find the best type of pizza from each place to know for sure which is the best of the best

I literally had Matt tearing open the little ceasers on my screen when I was interrupted by a little ceasers ad.

As an employee at a Jet’s pizza I appreciate Charlie putting our pizza at A tier

Watching two men discover the beauty of Jet’s pizza crust was truly amazing 😮❤😂

I'm impressed they managed to make a tombstone soft, that takes some real skill cuz that crust is always hella crispy

I was surprised by your reaction to Marcos, maybe its where you order from. Marcos was my familys favorite pizza back in the day. I miss it so much after moving to the west

I physically shook my head when they misconstrued that Chuck-e-Cheese's gave them the icing

As soon as they put Taco Bell's in D, there was from then on the potential to be "worse than beans on bread pretending to be pizza "

I imagine the people delivering it had a duel on who has the best pizza

8:01 Actually Charlie was right, I just re-watched the first pizza tier list, and indeed it was Hungry Howie's that included the icing. I'm not sure why they were so quick to "correct" him on that, but they were wrong.

If you've never had Celeste Pizza before " it's like having pizza on a cracker" is about as accurate as you can get.

Today's Fact: In 2001, a man named Richard Jewell was falsely accused of planting a bomb at the Olympic Games in Atlanta; years earlier, he had been involved in a controversy over his work as a security guard at a university.

I also love Little Ceasars! They saved me when i was broke, hungry & homeless. Especially love the thin & crispy & the pretzel crust.

Charlie just nonchalantly saying "oh theres no vaginal rugae?" got me so good, godlike comedic timing

Following up a Red Baron with a Tombstone is like following a shot of vodka with sewage.

Blaze Pizza is good because there’s technically no limit in toppings. My BYO pizza has like 20 different toppings and 4 different cheeses all for $8.

Obviously Lil Caesar's has a massive quality consistency problem cuz my local branch puts on a solid sauce layer that has a very well balanced profile and its always cut well. I will say the crust is often times a bit too tough, especially the edge crust, but it has a good bread texture if you can get through the tougher shell.

I would like to thank charlie for making a sequel. Everytime I eat pizza I watch the original video and I’ve watched it Atleast 15 times now, I will now wait to complete this video till I’m eating pizza

Shoutout to Matt for knowing how to use an oven and a timer, a genius we all must marvel at quite frankly.

Would be so curios to see these results with a blind taste test. That's how my friend's and I did it and I was shocked by the results.

Charlie and Matt are like a pack of wolves, Everyone eats after them

Petition to have Matt's rankings on the screen as well as Charlie's, ie. After Charlie's go up another screen with just Matt's goes up after

Used to work at a Little Caesar's and some of the stuff with them is kinda crazy. Dough (at least at the location I worked at) is made fresh every morning and typically thrown out the next day if not used, recipe calls for a shit ton of sauce for some reason, and somehow was the best uncooked mozzarella I've ever eaten. I still genuinely don't understand how combining it all together makes dogshit. Cool little sidenote with it, I always made my own pizzas custom and this was the dream combo I found. Regular crust, Cheese sauce (the one for the pretzel), Cheese, Beef, Sausage, Cheese balls for the one promo scattered on it, and a light topping of cheese I brought from home (hand shredded Muenster).

Add this to your their list playlist Charlie you goof ball

it's so sad to see these old videos with Matt having no tier list

Charlie is the only Mukbang youtuber I would watch

S/o to everyone reassuring Charlie that it was ok 😭 I could see how worried it made him and I understand he is a hypochondriac and it’s so important to have people around who know how to support that and make things better for charlie

Im not sure if anyone has pointed this out, I think its important to note that papa johns pizza comes with garlic butter. If you use this with the crust, its amazing! 14:20

You should have done these tierlists by writing down each of your ratings on paper then revealing them at the same time and splitting the diff. more interesting and also removes peer bias

Charlie, please do a sour candy tier list. I think it would be very entertaining.

There needs to be two Tier lists for sure. Matt's voice needs to be heard lmao

I remember rushing to the cafeteria in school to get Papa John's pizza on pizza day. If you were late, it would be gone almost immediately.

Little Ceasars is top-tier. Reliable, tasty, cheap. Everything great about a jack-of-all-trades.

Little Ceasers being severely underrated once again, little ceasers was always there for us

24:26 I always get spooked when there’s any actual editing in these videos

Hungry Howies was absolutely the one that gave you the icing the last round lol 8:04

the best part of the pizza is the air bubble. if the pizza doesn't have the air bubble, it's not s tier

The little Cesar’s disrespect is outlandish 😭

I really think the funniest thing in this whole video is the fact that the "bumpiness" of the pizza is called "docking" the dough. You use a plastic roller thingy with spikes on it to push the air out of the dough, so it doesn't have holes or bubbles. Charlie prolly would have lost his shit knowing that 😂 I've worked at both Pizza Hut and Domino's, and Domino's I ate almost every day I worked, Pizza Hut, not so much

Little ceasers is so good when you get it fresh theirs look like it was left out for like 30 minutes

Good god, the bromance between Charlie and Matt is STRONG 😅

Not sure if Charlie just got unlucky but I've actually had pretty good experiences with Marco's Pizza in my area. Their Deluxe and All-Meat pizzas are really good. Next time, Charlie should make a tier list using pizza from some of his local Italian restaurants.

Little Caesar's seems to be quite a bit different here in Canada, and it's usually pretty decent. More sauce, better overall quality just from the looks of things.

Chelsea’s favorite cereal is probably stale Wheaties.

This is the only take I’ve ever heard from you, chuck. Lil Caesar’s is a classic. Hail Caesar.

Fun fact: Dominos and many other chains pizza joints have plastic trays for the dough that can get brittle after a while. I.e. when you scrape off the dough sometimes a little piece a plastic (generally the size of rice) will get stuck and baked into the crust at 400° F