Тёмный

Coriolis Effect: IDTIMWYTIM 

SciShow
Подписаться 8 млн
Просмотров 1 млн
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

29 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,9 тыс.   
@WoytazThePilot
@WoytazThePilot 10 лет назад
As far as I know, on the Northern Hemisphere winds rotate counter-clockwise, not clockwise as stated in the video (just look up some satellite images of cyclons). Yes, the Coriolis Force will deflect air traveling on the northern hemisphere to the right, however that means that if you stand in such a way that wind is blowing on your back, the area of low pressure will be on your left hand (since the traveling air will be deflected to the right). Because wind will blow from the area of high pressure to the area of low pressure, it will spin counter clockwise (to the left) on the Northern Hemisphere and clockwise (to the right) on the Southern Hemisphere.
@boanthun
@boanthun 5 лет назад
You got it right!! I'm a navigator and this is a correct. Spot on!!
@angelob340
@angelob340 2 года назад
Diving deeper into wind turbines and I got confused by the video. Kowalski, agree
@heylearnthis9355
@heylearnthis9355 Год назад
Yes, areas of Low Pressure in the Northern Hemisphere include winds flowing counter clockwise around them. Winds flow clockwise around Low pressure systems in the Southern Hemisphere. It's the opposite for wind flow around areas of High Pressure: winds flow clockwise around Highs in the N. Hemisphere.
@BunnieGreen
@BunnieGreen 10 лет назад
Does anyone else feel like the equator in this is way too low?
@syystomu
@syystomu 10 лет назад
I think the map is just using a weird projection... which is weird since it's depicting a sphere (or to put it in another way, it's a picture of the globe rather than a map of the globe), you'd think it'd be easy to get it right. Actually it just looks like someone cut up a circle out of a normal Mercator world map (which tends to emphasize the northern hemisphere, making it look huge in comparison to the southern). Edit: I checked and yeah, the equator is correct according to the landmasses but the map itself is distorted so it looks like it's wrong. (And it's wrong on the circle since it should be in the middle.)
@AustinAlmond
@AustinAlmond 10 лет назад
Tuuliska Also there's no Antarctica which throws it off even more.
@ablereason4861
@ablereason4861 10 лет назад
I checked google earth and the equator is correct in this vid. I think it looks weird because I'm used to seeing the equator as it crosses South America and it somehow looks higher when it's got most of the wide part of the continent under it as opposed to having the wide part of Africa on top of it. Just a guess but the brain is funny that way. But it is right as shown here.
@herranton
@herranton 10 лет назад
Actually, the equator is in the right place in relation to the continents, but 60 degrees N is waaay too high. It should cut just about through Stockholm, Sweden; Oslo, Norway; Helsinki, Finland; and St. Petersberg, Russia. Or at least come really close to these cities. On the other side of the "map", 60 degrees N should cut off the Kamchatka Peninsula just a bit south of where it meets the rest of Russia.
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
Yeah, that's some mad Eurocentricism for ya, they need to bump the land masses up where they belong! Bad graphic design perpetuating some bad distortions of who/where is the most important on the globe...
@Jordan-zk2wd
@Jordan-zk2wd 10 лет назад
Dude, I'm not real finicky usually, but your equator is killing me, it's so not middle. Anyone else just hurting deep down when they see this?
@ptroinks
@ptroinks 7 лет назад
YES! That equator IS killing me! Along with the "60 degrees north" line!
@kvnjng
@kvnjng 7 лет назад
I have a question: since time is relative to the velocity at which something moves. Does that mean that people who live in Texas experience time slower compared to let's say a scientist living on the north pole?
@SlyPearTree
@SlyPearTree 7 лет назад
Kevin J Replying mostly because I want the answer and Google just throws maths at me. My own thinking throw one big wrench in the experiment: the gravity vary depending where you are on Earth because it is not a perfectly sphere and it's density is not the same everywhere either. Let say Earth was a perfectly homogeneous sphere not affected by any outside force like the Moon and Sun's gravity, but still spinning on its axis like it does now. In that case I wonder how much the centrifugal force of someone at the equator will lessen the effect of gravity and therefore speedup their time relative to someone at the pole. Will the two effects, speed and lesser gravity, cancel each other?
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
I'm real butt hurt over this. pretty frustrating...
@donutviper1
@donutviper1 7 лет назад
SlyPearTree I would like to know why the coriolis effect doesn't affect hovering helicopters. Even Mr Coriolis might consider scrapping his theory if he did not observe a helicopter waiting for it's destination to rotate to it. 🙀🤦‍♂️🙀🤦‍♂️🙀🤦‍♂️
@AndrewGatt
@AndrewGatt 9 лет назад
Two mistakes in this video. The "circumference" of the Earth at the Equator is 40,076 km, not the diameter. Second, storms in the Northern Hemisphere rotate counter-clockwise, not clockwise. That means that low pressure systems that produce hurricanes or cyclones in the Northern Hemisphere rotate counter-clockwise.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane "Storms rotate which ever way the pressure systems and other variables dictate, a Coriolis effect not being one of them." Nope, wrong. If it was just whatever random set of variables happened to be present at the time that a low pressure weather system developed that determined which way the system rotated, then we should expect to see at least some low pressure weather systems north of the equator rotate clockwise, and occasionally see some low pressure weather systems south of the equator rotate counter-clockwise. However, we never see that. ALL low pressure weather systems north of the equator rotate counter-clockwise, and ALL low pressure weather systems rotate clockwise south of the equator. Only the Coriolis effect explains that duality.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane "The history of Hurricanes show both directions on either side of the equator." Prove it. Give us some details - dates, names and locations - about these hurricanes and typhoons that spun the opposite way that the Coriolis effect predicts. Tornadoes have a more random spin. They are relatively small, short lived phenomena that are less affected by the Coriolis effect and more by the characteristics of the storm that spawns them. However, hurricanes and typhoons always spin counter-clockwise north of the equator, and clockwise south of the equator. Here is a website you can use to track these storms and check them out for yourself. severe.worldweather.wmo.int/
@1372eatapeach
@1372eatapeach 6 лет назад
@Flearther McPlane Amen Bro
@marcadams440
@marcadams440 6 лет назад
@Flearther McPlane what are prevailing winds
@marcadams440
@marcadams440 5 лет назад
@Flearther McPlaneLiterally the exact word for word answer you get when you Google prevailing wind. Why is there prevailing wind. Don't just Google it, show you understand it.
@alexanderl8794
@alexanderl8794 7 лет назад
1:50 Hank says the coriolis effect does affect "bigger, slower moving fluids." The experiment Veritasium and Smarter Every Day conducted proved the same thing
@ReflectedMiles
@ReflectedMiles 4 года назад
Except that a kiddie pool probably was probably still much smaller than the scale that Hank was thinking of and referring to, but it worked with the right conditions of still water and no other effects present. It's just a _very_ small force at that scale.
@vaniadesmonda
@vaniadesmonda 9 лет назад
Veritasium & SmarterEveryday brought me here
@m1a9r8k3
@m1a9r8k3 9 лет назад
Vania Desmonda Gizmodo brought me to the Veritasium & SmarterEveryday video =)
@guisado1002
@guisado1002 9 лет назад
Me to!
@AdityaVenkata123
@AdityaVenkata123 9 лет назад
Vania Desmonda same here!
@zes3813
@zes3813 9 лет назад
wrr
@duustincrawford2945
@duustincrawford2945 7 лет назад
Vania Desmonda THE EARTH IS FLAT
@SineCalvin9
@SineCalvin9 10 лет назад
Scishow! Hey! There is a large misunderstanding of aviation and parachute in the media (weird, right?) and I think it would be cool to do a show on BASE jumping, 'what if the parachute doesn't come out'? which pretty much ever happens, it's more complicated than that. Or 'what if the engine stops?' no, it does't just fall out of the sky, etc. I have a degree in aero, and I am a professional parachutist. If you are interested, I would love to help! PS- I love your show (space, etc) and thank you for being awesome. Communicating science is one of the more important things ever. -Calvin.
@xXSabzyKababzyXx
@xXSabzyKababzyXx 11 лет назад
NO JOKE I NEEDED TO KNOW WHAT THIS WAS THE OTHER DAY. YOUR TIMING IS FREAKING PERFECT OH MYYYYYYY
@katherineswift116
@katherineswift116 8 лет назад
At 52 seconds. Could you not have used any other map projection. The Mercator projection is super unhelpful for globes, or their likenesses. Check out that equator you drew; definitely not in the middle of the circle...
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
+ SRSLY tho
@glurpbot8048
@glurpbot8048 6 лет назад
I love you , I love you, I love you! The Earth Science regents are in 5 days and I'm panicking because I was an idiot and left months of studying to the last minute. And now I have to spend 10 months of lessons into my head in just 5 days. *THANK YOU!!!*
@nobodyspecial3123
@nobodyspecial3123 6 лет назад
I remember a long while back on the Simpsons, they went to Australia over something Bart did and that's where that myth started for me. Thanks for clearing this up.
@TroutOfOrder
@TroutOfOrder 11 лет назад
you know what I love about your channel: you explain so many things that Sheldon says from the Big Bang Theory, and you make it easily understandable.
@tupguz
@tupguz 10 лет назад
Please do an IDTITWYTIM episode on the phrase "scientifically proven". Please!
@rjch0173
@rjch0173 11 лет назад
Wow - talk about timely. I'm an Australian who just happens to have flown over to the US over the weekend and it was literally yesterday that I had exactly the same thought you opened your video with. Now if I just knew why the designs of toilet bowls differed so much from the US to Australia, that would be one less irritating, trivial detail for my brain to lock on to. :)
@Unakanon
@Unakanon 8 лет назад
I would love to see a IDTIMWYTIM on Hypothesis vs. Theory.
@AdilAlsuhaim
@AdilAlsuhaim 4 года назад
I saw videos of experiments from countries on the equator demonstrating that water don't rotate when drained exactly on the equator with smaller basins, clockwise if the basin is moved slightly to the north, and counter-clockwise when drained slightly south of the equator.
@MrAspentree
@MrAspentree 10 лет назад
The map at 0:54 was fucked up, dude. I live on the 62 N latitude, which according to you, is in the middle of the Arctic sea.
@SolveigSkj
@SolveigSkj 10 лет назад
Haha, that's true! The line is even higher than 75 N.
@ValeriePallaoro
@ValeriePallaoro 7 лет назад
And the equator was like a hipsters pants line
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
yeah, straight wrong. Shows a lil' too much bias towards that Northern Hemisphere, eh?
@eyjaremati247
@eyjaremati247 6 лет назад
When I (Australian) was in the US, I was so scared of how high the toilet water gets to notice what way it spins. Your toilets are so full!
@dylanbarbagallo9404
@dylanbarbagallo9404 11 лет назад
Thanks for clearing this misconception up for me. I have thought that toilets were effected by the Coriolis effect for years even before I was taught it in 9th grade science this year. I will let my teacher know.
@oopsy444
@oopsy444 2 года назад
They need to bring back this video series!!
@LM-kc2uw
@LM-kc2uw 8 лет назад
50,000 PEOPLE USED TO LIVE HERE
@TheBL-ZNL
@TheBL-ZNL 6 лет назад
now it is a ghost town
@youssafsu2307
@youssafsu2307 5 лет назад
"Shock and blood loss will do the rest," he said...
@cheesestyx945
@cheesestyx945 4 года назад
@@youssafsu2307 "coriolis effect" he said, I didn't even know what that was
@BrenBawks
@BrenBawks 11 лет назад
Yay! I hope these keep coming. I missed this series!
@NativeExplorer
@NativeExplorer 5 лет назад
What about the “museums” on the equator when you go 10m north the water drain one way and you go 10 south it drains the other way?
@jimbobeire
@jimbobeire 3 года назад
Easily influenced by how the water is poured. I watched a guy do it, and the customers were too busy watching the straws floating in the middle of the bowl, to notice that the guy pouring the water poured it three different ways, aiming slightly left, slightly right or in the middle depending on where he was standing and what he wanted the customers to see. 10 metres is nothing.
@StarOfTomorrow2009
@StarOfTomorrow2009 11 лет назад
I knew this and was trying to explain it a few weeks back to some know it all in one of my classes. She told me I was lying and called me a stupid r-word. I'm going to show her this video; can't wait to see her reaction! :)
@ulfy01
@ulfy01 10 лет назад
I blame Lisa Simpson for all this.
@ilyanzolliani2432
@ilyanzolliani2432 4 года назад
After this video my life wll be totally different. THANK YOU, Greetings from Italy (yes northern hemisphere, Christmas in cold december).
@DottyDotDitto
@DottyDotDitto 9 лет назад
Australian toilets don't even swirl, they tumble. Aussie toilets are typically a dual flushing, water saving affair. I remember the first time I flushed an American toilet, it started to fill with water and I had an "oh shit" moment as I thought it was going to overflow.
@meenadobhal9661
@meenadobhal9661 5 лет назад
Haha lol movement for you
@Kinor7
@Kinor7 11 лет назад
oh wow. That's mindblowing. Is there any video of it?
@DeathsheepFSF
@DeathsheepFSF 10 лет назад
IDTIMWYTIM on the word "Literally" because people seem to use that word wrong a lot nowadays
@laerzzyziz2381
@laerzzyziz2381 10 лет назад
you know whats funny about language is that historically if everyone is wrong then the meaning on whatever they are wrong in will change - simply put if everyone is wrong it's suddenly right.
@MrOuchiez
@MrOuchiez 10 лет назад
Laerz Zyziz Which constantly makes us dumber, communicatively.
@Digiscat
@Digiscat 10 лет назад
MrOuchiez No, actually. That's how the evolution of language works. There's no reason, at all, that it makes us 'dumber'. EDIT: Maybe do a regular scishow over th evolution of language. Don't think that's been done yet, and I think it'd be cool.
@zooh8017
@zooh8017 10 лет назад
If you're going to correct someone on a grammatical infraction, I believe you meant "incorrectly".
@WrathOfMega
@WrathOfMega 10 лет назад
quak :3 Oh god another one. Here, watch this. www.merriam-webster.com/video/0038-literally.html
@Bmambl
@Bmambl 11 лет назад
I second this. You already do quite a bit of this kind of thing anyway, it'd be nice to see it all drawn together and built upon.
@flixmanager
@flixmanager 10 лет назад
Just for fun: if the Coriolis effect was strong enough to affect toilets wouldn't it cause mini whirlpools in your bloodstream? Or make your pee veer off to one side? :)
@brandonma1925
@brandonma1925 9 лет назад
dude i know that u said it for fun, but for blood it is part of a sentient being and moves with it so it wont yeah
@lesunfish4551
@lesunfish4551 5 лет назад
Oh man I really don’t know if that pee thought was necessary
@stamariana
@stamariana 11 лет назад
Actually you can see this with a small amount of water. I live in Ecuador and there's a museum just over the line (measured with a gps) that shows the difference with a sink. They put it a meter to the north and the water flushes to one side, one meter to the south and it goes to the other. But EXACTLY over the line it goes straight down. I've seen it a million times.
@LReBe7
@LReBe7 9 лет назад
I know how it made it into common understanding: THE SIMPSONS STARTED IT, with bart and lisa having a toothpaste race in their sink.
@IMortage
@IMortage 11 лет назад
The equator at 0:53 is drawn CORRECTLY in regards to the continents shown, but INCORRECTLY in regards to the shape of the earth. Which means the landmasses are shifted (northwards) on that globe from where they actually should be.
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
+ Yeah, I worry that it over emphasizes Europe and downplays Africa, makes me nervous...
@MrSaeedAta
@MrSaeedAta 11 лет назад
When I visited the equator with my family we did a little experiment. We took a bucket of water with a hole in the bottom and watched the drainage (using a matchstick to make it easier to observe) we walked about 10 paces north and it spun one way. Then we stopped the motion waked 20 paces south and let it flow again, the matchstick spun in the other direction. So I think that the effect can apply to small scale items.
@bentoth9555
@bentoth9555 8 лет назад
If you're very careful to put it on a perfectly flat and level surface it can affect the draining of a kiddie pool. I think it was on Veritasium that I saw that one.
@joanmae9741
@joanmae9741 8 лет назад
I'm so confused. I'm in Biology right now and my roommate is an oceanography major, both of our books say that in the north it is counter-clockwise and in the south it is clockwise. I read various resources online and some support this idea while some don't...... please help! Which is right?!
@theartificialsociety3373
@theartificialsociety3373 8 лет назад
Joan Mae in northern hemisphere, the clouds around hurricane rotate counter clockwise around the eye. But the Foucault pendulum in northern hemisphere rotates clockwise. So the standard cliche explanations must need more explanation to account for the motion around the eye of hurricane. I visualized both and that's how I see it. That is they appear to contradict each other.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane " Full Moon in the day time, really?" What do you mean by "day time"? We never see a full moon, for instance, at noon. It simply does not happen. You will see an almost full moon just before sunset, or just before sun rise, but you will never see a 100% full moon in the sky at the same time as the sun.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane "Viewing Venus in the middle of the night. Really?" No, that isn't right either. We never see Venus at midnight, in the "middle of the night". The farthest Venus ever gets from the sun is 45 degrees, so just before sunrise or just after sunset, Venus can be seen halfway between the horizon and directly overhead.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane "Tides on a single coast, 2' in one place and 24' just up the way. 4 tidal changes in one place and 2 in others. Tides do NOT react in any way in accordance with the Lunar body. Never have, never will." More misrepresentation. What do you mean by "just up the way"? The timing and approximate height of a tide can be predicted years in advance by analyzing the positions of the sun and moon. However, the exact height of a tide has more to do with the topography of the coast line than anything else. The highest tides in the world, in the Bay of Fundy in Canada, are caused by the water piling up as it surges into a bay that gets progressively narrower and narrower. The height of the tide in the mouth of the bay is about 10 feet, while the height of the tide at the narrowest point at the north end of the bay can exceed 50 feet. All of the highest tides in the world share the same topography, a long bay with a wide mouth that progressively narrows down. We can precisely predict when a tide will occur anywhere by tracking the positions of the sun and moon, but the exact height of the tide varies by a location's topography.
@rayopeongo
@rayopeongo 6 лет назад
+Flearther McPlane "In fact, if you go outside to observe a lot of things, you'll realize the absurdity of a multitude of misinformation in scholastic text." If you live south of the equator, you only have to spend one evening observing the night sky to know that the earth is not flat. When looking north from north of the equator, all of the stars appear to rotate counter-clockwise around Polaris, in accordance with the flat earth model. However, when looking SOUTH from SOUTH of the equator, you see a completely different set of stars, rotating around a different point in the sky, and rotating in the opposite direction, clockwise around the south celestial pole instead of counter-clockwise around Polaris as the northern stars do. You can't even see Polaris from south of the equator. Flat earth busted.
@mellowfish316
@mellowfish316 11 лет назад
Related to the Coriolis Effect (maybe?) is that if you drop something down the center of a very deep mine shaft it will *not* hit the bottom directly, instead hitting and bouncing down the western side of shaft. They have actually done this for instance in the super deep mines in Russia.
@louisrobitaille5810
@louisrobitaille5810 Год назад
This is more likely related to the fact that the center of gravity of the Earth is NOT the center of the Earth. It's slightly off-center. Idk, might be a combination of both too. Idek where to look for an answer to this 🤷‍♂️. Perhaps a geologist would know?
@StevXtreme
@StevXtreme 8 лет назад
So the Coriolis effect is nothing more than the preservation of inertia inside a system with a GRADIENT of inertia?
@anush7386
@anush7386 7 лет назад
Stefan Badragan is it only inertia of motion simple
@boanthun
@boanthun 5 лет назад
@Flearther McPlane No. You're an idiot. IT's a proven fact. I'll give you a million dollar if you could prove your statement!! They don't blow randomly. Take it from me. I'm a navigator and low pressure systems ALWAYAS blow counter clowckwise in the northern hemisphere and opposite in the south. Also high pressure systems blow clockwise in the northern hemishpere and opposite in the south. However they are not storm systems. Navigators (both pilots and mariners) study oceanography and metrology and this is a fact. Proven science. Go ahead and put this to a test and you'll see that this is true.
@erickbush6097
@erickbush6097 3 года назад
They're right but their explanation was contrary. If the Coriolis can affect hurricanes then it'll affect something even smaller. Basically, while it affects swirel rotation other things can have a far larger influence and thus counter act or reinforce the Coriolis affect.
@zacharytaylor190
@zacharytaylor190 9 лет назад
Could you do an episode on the Doppler effect?
@JTGoran
@JTGoran 11 лет назад
I did know that but had no idea how to explain it to people; thanks!
@Juwanaknow
@Juwanaknow 10 лет назад
He made a mistake at 2:20 and on. He states that weather systems in the Northern Hemisphere rotate clockwise and counterclockwise in the Southern Hemisphere. That's wrong. Weather systems in the Northern Hemisphere rotate counterclockwise and in the Southern Hemisphere they rotate clockwise.
@IamGrimalkin
@IamGrimalkin 9 лет назад
Doesn't it depend if it is a high or low pressure system?
@fordfiveohh
@fordfiveohh 9 лет назад
IamGrimalkin NO... the type of system makes NO difference as to the direction of rotation. At the equator, there is little to no rotation and creates an area called the doldrums where really no cyclones (neither hurricanes nor tornadoes) exist. Source: I have a BS in Geography.. A high pressure systems act like a "hill" , low pressure systems act ,like a "valley", moisture will move into low pressure systems and away from high pressure systems. So, if I have high pressure in the west, and low pressure in the east, the system will have a vector of moving from west to east. The magnitude of the vector is dictated by the isobars(measures pressure gradients) distance from each other. If the isobars are close together, the force is strong, if the isobars are further apart, the force is weaker. The isobars dictate the rate of change of pressure. This vector is also ADDED to the vector that is the "general circulation of the atmosphere" , which he began to explain in speaking about how stuff moves back and forth from the poles to the equator, this would be the predominant movement but for the Coriolis effect, which causes a curve when the rotational vector and the vertical vectors combine. There are many things at play in weather patterns but it's mostly the general circulation of the atmosphere, the tilt of the earth and it's angle of incidence of the suns rays with the earth, and the thermal/pressure gradients that result from the pressure/temperature differentials caused by where the suns rays are and are not hitting. It also has to do with the density of the atmosphere, the size of the particles the light is passing through, the albeto effect... it goes on and on. It's not a simple answer in the nitty gritty of it.
@IamGrimalkin
@IamGrimalkin 9 лет назад
fordfiveohh Yeah, air does move away from high pressure systems and towards low pressure systems. And the Coriolis force curves things to the right in the northern hemisphere and the left in the southern hemisphere. When air is moving outwards, "to the left" is anticlockwise, whereas when it is moving inwards, "to the left" is clockwise.
@melissaanderson5376
@melissaanderson5376 7 лет назад
Counterclockwise in north!
@eKriZZLe
@eKriZZLe 7 лет назад
According to weather maps, it most definitely DOES matter the type of system. earth.nullschool.net/
@khindall8044
@khindall8044 5 лет назад
I don't know if you read comments on videos this old, but I'd like to suggest that you do an IDTIMWYTIM on "life expectancy." I just saw a documentary that said that almost no one lived past their thirties in the Middle Ages because the average life expectancy was late thirties. Or maybe just a video on what "average" means would do the trick!
@teamnevergraduate
@teamnevergraduate 8 лет назад
Doesn't it spin counter clockwise in the northern hemisphere and vice versa?
@brandonhernandez371
@brandonhernandez371 6 лет назад
Captain Deadpool did you not watch the video
@boanthun
@boanthun 5 лет назад
@@brandonhernandez371 Captain Deadpool was right. The low pressure systems ALWAYS rotate counter clockwise in the northern hemisphere and opposite in the south. Similarly the high pressure systems blow clockwise in the north and counter clockwise in the southern hemisphere. This fact is known to all navigators in the air and on the sea. We rely on this fact to determine where to best go in case we have to stear away from the systems. THIS IS A FACT and I know this because I'm a navigator. Check out the next weather report on your local tv station and you'll see it. I will give 1.000.000 USD to the one who can disprove this fact!! I dare you!!!! Heck. I double dare you :)
@neonether
@neonether 5 лет назад
@@boanthun Yeah what kind of credentials does this guy with a crappy channel name have? I bet his credentials don't mean what he thinks they mean...doh!
@boanthun
@boanthun 5 лет назад
@@neonether What you said......
@BapanSarkar880
@BapanSarkar880 4 года назад
Superb explanation sir I'm from India.
@paulflute
@paulflute 11 лет назад
so I have a couple of friends who have tried the water flushing different ways across the equator and report it as 'a thing' that happens.... (one of said friends has a science PhD from cambridge and used to do it regularly as a demonstration).. not to mention the numerous youtube demonstrations.. So.. If you say that this is not because of the Coriolis effect then i say fine.. but if you say this is 'bunk' but offer nothing more than I have to question you hank.. clearly there is something going on here..? or is everybody else simply mass hallucinating..?
@ColinBewley
@ColinBewley 10 лет назад
I can assure you that it is entirely down to the shape of the toilet or basin. If you had the exact same toilet on either side of the equator, they will flush the same way. I learned about this during my Physics Masters when studying what effects the Earth's rotation has on everyday life.
@paulflute
@paulflute 10 лет назад
Colin Bewley thanks for your comments. I remain unconvinced.. You write... " I learned about this during my Physics Masters when studying what effects the Earth's rotation has on everyday life." So maybe the effect in question is not as a result of the earths rotation...? I believe you are well intentioned but you are not known to me and you offer 'assurance' based on limited study and no personal experience.. I have already stated that two trusted friends have direct experience of this phenomenon.. one of them performing it repeatedly and possessing a higher qualification than you.. and there are numerous videos of the effect here on youtube.. In short.. for all the videos to be faked and all the people in them lying and my friends to be repeatedly confused I need more assurance than a stranger claiming to have sat a particular physics class.. As of yet I await any contradictory evidence.. any links you could suggest..?
@deanc91
@deanc91 10 лет назад
paulflute Your personal and unverified anecdotal evidence is about as good as anyone else's youtube anecdotal evidence. As for videos found on youtube, there's also plenty of videos, even ones where they pull out a GPS to verify their location, where they test multiple sinks and toilets, with water draining the opposite of what you'd expect if there was a Coriolis effect on the water, to just going straight down the drain. It's all based on a shape of the basin and a few other forces, like movement of a drain plug or new water coming down at an angle.
@MrOuchiez
@MrOuchiez 10 лет назад
paulflute My best suggestion is to merely look at the "thumbs up" on your comment, and see how its being drowned out by the contrary. Also, I am baffled to learn that Cambridge, IN has an online PhD course at all!! I respect your fight, but this is an instance of "pick your battles"... Cheers, and thanks for the conversation!
@ArchAngelSlayer1
@ArchAngelSlayer1 10 лет назад
Colin Bewley So why are all toilet's and sinks etc, made in a different way in the southern hemisphere, just to fuck with us?
@poneill6
@poneill6 10 лет назад
Thank you. I've been living with that particular misconception for many years. Once again, I discover I am full of ----- it.
@aqwhawater
@aqwhawater 8 лет назад
i came here becauese of captain mc mallian from cod 4
@goldofficial6057
@goldofficial6057 7 лет назад
IabuseTheM16 _ MISSION FAILED WILL GET EM NEXT TIME oops wrong game
@jackcarter1382
@jackcarter1382 5 лет назад
AqWha Water at this distance, you’ll have to take the coriolis effect into consideration
@cheesestyx945
@cheesestyx945 4 года назад
@@jackcarter1382 why didn't McMillan take that shot he seems way more qualified than the person who had to be trained how to snipe on the very same mission.
@Haydenny
@Haydenny 4 года назад
@@cheesestyx945 because video game logic😂
@sheldendowden3096
@sheldendowden3096 11 лет назад
You should make an IDTIMWYTIM on cancer. I've heard so many ridiculous and surprisingly common misconceptions, like how cancer is actually many, many, MANY different things, not just one super evil little goblin virus and so forth.
@diggity1039
@diggity1039 8 лет назад
That equator looked a little low.
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
+ Redix
@christinepage5025
@christinepage5025 11 лет назад
You guys should do a psychology unit, like talking about disorders. For example, I'd love to hear you talk about trichotillomania. Not enough people know about it.
@MilitanT07
@MilitanT07 10 лет назад
The Simpsons brought me here
@lennyellis1011
@lennyellis1011 6 лет назад
Aha same here lol
@princestory26
@princestory26 11 лет назад
Very useful since I am learning this in Geography now...
@DiminutiveFlower
@DiminutiveFlower 10 лет назад
The word "theory". Please make a vid on this (unless you already did with biology.
@Shabboi
@Shabboi 10 лет назад
This. The scientific term, "Theory," is like one step short of being the opposite of the colloquial, "Theory" (the complete opposite, I guess, being, "Fact").
@Edgewalker001
@Edgewalker001 7 лет назад
And facts are basically just really, really persistent theories. People always use the word "theory" when they mean "hypothesis" and it always pisses me off.
@Delathers2651
@Delathers2651 9 лет назад
Here's an idea for IDTIMWYTIM, emotions vs. reason. I feel like there is some confusion in popular culture with star trek and Vulcans and such. It could be an interesting episode.
@samliedtke578
@samliedtke578 8 лет назад
The equator at 0:52 is anything but along the middle of the earth, I don't know if this is addressed later on in the video, but it bothered me so much that I had to pause it to point it out. Ugh.
@danhill5694
@danhill5694 8 лет назад
It's more or less where it's supposed to be in relation to Africa (though it does look a little hastily placed). It looks like they just made a circle out of a Mercator projection, notice that Antarctica isn't pictured. Also, Russia/Siberia looks nearly twice the size of Africa, which it certainly is not. So the map is actually worse than the equator placement.
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
+ Yeah, map is bad, ttly showing a Northern Hemisphere preference...
@chelleross5132
@chelleross5132 3 года назад
My University is making me watch Hank Green for my Atmospheric Science class? I'm excited. I'll actually learn something!
@RevMet
@RevMet 11 лет назад
"Hey, Australian people" OOH OOH THAT'S ME! HI HANK!!
@trevormoomaw
@trevormoomaw 11 лет назад
I knew it! My 9th grade Earth science teacher taught me that and it always bugged me. Thanks Hank!!!
@Jakathera
@Jakathera 10 лет назад
My fiancee and i just had a 10 min convo about the pic at 0:41. :)
@MCAndyT
@MCAndyT 7 лет назад
Yeah, SRSLY tho, wildy inaccurate
@jklocport
@jklocport 11 лет назад
In a similar subject to this one, you should do a video on foucault pendulums: how they work and what they tell us about the world.
@davedavid5983
@davedavid5983 9 лет назад
You were wrong!! Proved by Veritasium and SmarterEveryday
@blitzwaffe
@blitzwaffe 9 лет назад
Dave David Well he was right about the toilets and sinks :3
@24NEWS-d8l
@24NEWS-d8l 9 лет назад
Dave David He wasn't wrong at all... re-watch the video. The videos corroborate each other...
@davedavid5983
@davedavid5983 9 лет назад
Eagles13 But he said it will only have an effect on weather patterns?
@BeautifulFreakful
@BeautifulFreakful 9 лет назад
No he wasn't wrong. 'Not a big enough deal to influence toilets flushing out'. That's basicly the same conclusion than that of Veritasium and Smartereveryday
@VakuzaV47
@VakuzaV47 9 лет назад
Dave David To quote Hank "It ( the coriolis effect ) isn't a big enough deal to affect a toilet which drains in 5 seconds, but it is enough to affect bigger and slower moving fluids". Now Veritasium & SmarterEveryday used a large and much much much slower moving fluid than in a toilet. I feel like they've misrepresented Hank since what they did only serves to prove his point, sinks and toilets are inconsistent; only if you minimize the variables to a small degree do you get the effect showing.
@redpawn2
@redpawn2 11 лет назад
I too have seen the exact thing the person above mentioned (note: I have never met or talked to this person). They put a few small leaves in the water so the flow can be seen better. The rotation of the water was much more than if they had directed the water when pulling the plug.
@Danketydankdrummer
@Danketydankdrummer 11 лет назад
Understandable on the sleep dep. Hank does another channel called crash course, their biology section might help you. Like I said there are other videos on this channel as well. He does a pretty excellent job of explaining it.
@maosw
@maosw 11 лет назад
Actually, depending on where you are on the planet, it does matter for (very) long range shots - read the Wikipedia article about external ballistics if you want to know why and remember that the bullets flight time at those distances might be up to 6 seconds. Of course we're talking about shifting the point of impact something like 5 cm at 1 km, but when your target is out +1000 meters and you've to hit with your first shots... being off 5-15 cm may be the difference between life and death.
@Dyslexic-Artist-Theory-on-Time
@Dyslexic-Artist-Theory-on-Time 11 лет назад
Interesting video! This is a suggestion why don’t you make a video about the other theories on RU-vid? There are many theories on RU-vid that are not part of the mainstream of science it would be interesting to know what you think of them as part of mainstream science, Theories like Quantum Atom Theory an artist theory of the physics or ‘time’ as a physical process!
@Kinor7
@Kinor7 11 лет назад
Sorry to disappoint you, but it's just a trick. First they see to it that they pour the water straight into the sink and giving it some time to settle. Then they carefully pull the plug straight up. That way there's little to no rotation. Then they move it to the southern end of the equator, but now they pour the water in such a fashion that the water rotates clockwise. When the plug is pulled, the water continues to rotate clockwise down the drain. And then they do just the opposite.
@newmanhiding2314
@newmanhiding2314 Год назад
2:16 This picture seems to imply that hurricanes rotate clockwise in the northern hemisphere, but isn’t it the opposite?
@mandrael
@mandrael 8 лет назад
2:15 - it's the other way round and not that simple. Cyclones have a low pressure center. The air moves toward this center, on the northern hemisphere the outer area near the equator is deflected to the right, which leads to a counter clockwise spin.
@jackmunnery2408
@jackmunnery2408 7 лет назад
Exactly what I thought Michael. Does that mean this video is inaccurate at the end?
@Brian-fu9um
@Brian-fu9um 6 лет назад
Michael is exactly right - I think this guy just mispoke at the end when he said the opposite.
@Neuralatrophy
@Neuralatrophy 11 лет назад
Lets bump that to the whole list of thermodynamic laws and have ourselves a series like he did for the forces !!
@banterblack
@banterblack 11 лет назад
Thank you. That was very helpful and it made it much easier for me to picture in my head. I'm still a bit confused on the part where Hank said that the Coriolis Effect creates weather systems that rotate clockwise in the northern hemisphere and counter-clockwise in the southern hemisphere. Maybe I'm being hard headed today but I think that is where the mistake is. Large weather systems such as hurricanes like hurricane katrina rotate counter-clockwise in the northern hemisphere.
@daveachuk
@daveachuk 3 года назад
You got the direction of hurricanes backwards. Northern hemisphere is counter/anti-clockwise. Southern hemisphere is clockwise. This is tricky to remember, because the Coriolis effect itself causes deflection "to the right" in the northern hemisphere, which viewed from above means clockwise. To understand this, consider that wind rushes towards a low pressure system from all directions, and in all those directions the wind is deflected to the right in the northern hemisphere-- if you imagine a giant area surrounded by eddies of clockwise-rotating wind, then to match the wind direction and speed at the edge of those eddies, the main storm in the middle will itself have to be rotating counter-clockwise. This is like gears meshing -- one giant gear in the middle is the storm, surrounded by many gears around the outside. The outside gears turn clockwise because of the coriolis effect on the approaching wind, forcing the central gear to rotate in the opposite direction: counter-clockwise.
@muemelification
@muemelification 11 лет назад
The two effects have are related but not quite the same: both are caused by the earth's rotation. While Foucault's pendulum is based solely on the earth moving below the (fixed) pendulum plane, coriolis effect is a combination of that and the conservation of angular momentum
@camb06
@camb06 11 лет назад
The ball would travel at the speed you threw it minus the speed you are running, plus a few other factors like friction, wind resistance and whether or not you've sprained your ankle today. Relativity comes in with your point of view, and most speed measurements are made relative to the ground. So with the same throw in both directions, the ball is traveling the same speed. The only thing gravity affects is pulling it to the ground. Measure from a fixed point in space, though, then yes.
@narisabcd
@narisabcd 11 лет назад
I LOVE YOU GREEN BROTHERS! You guys really help me through my education :'D
@brycepatties
@brycepatties 11 лет назад
the coriolis effect is more than just a weather phenomenon. you see it whenever you have a rotating reference frame. roll a ball across a merry go round, and you will see the same thing happen. long range artillery also has to take this into consideration.
@MrBardache
@MrBardache 11 лет назад
Love this segment.
@Beanedict_C
@Beanedict_C 11 лет назад
I was also confused about this for a bit, until I though of it this way. Instead of a solid globe, picture several conveyor belts, with the fastest at the equator. If you throw a ball north from the fastest conveyor belt, the ball will travel north as well a bit to the east (because it was thrown from a belt moving east). However, the conveyor belt it's now over is also moving east, just at a slower speed. So it can't catch up to the eastward movement of the ball. Therefore, the ball moves east.
@jazzy6121
@jazzy6121 11 лет назад
Hank, Thanx a lot for doing this video. Though I dont understand mathematics behind Coriolis but I always doubted it being associated with my tiolet. It was very helpful
@isnerdy
@isnerdy 11 лет назад
I guess this explains why I never noticed the water swirl direction thingy happening during either of my two trips to South America.
@Thornarg
@Thornarg 11 лет назад
The effect on low pressure systems can be tricky to visualize. Think of the low as pressure gradient with the lines of force pointing directly toward the center. Initially still air starts to move directly inward from all directions, however air moving toward the equator is also getting farther from the Earth's rotational axis and must slow its rotation, while air moving toward the poles must increase its angular velocity around the Earth's rotational axis.
@rkb12222
@rkb12222 11 лет назад
thats actually true, a maximum range shot with a high power rifle needs to take in account every variable, you just keep adding a constant in for every factor( wind air pressure temp etc) the coriolis) to the integrals, and then you will get your bullet drop on the x and y axis.
@ogarcia515
@ogarcia515 6 лет назад
Thanks. That explains why the water in my toilet drained clockwise when I visited Australia, thus disproving the myth.
@SharksShade
@SharksShade 11 лет назад
I'd like a IDTIMWYTIM about the Doppler effect (for my science teacher) thanks!
@pushpalathadilipkumar3874
@pushpalathadilipkumar3874 7 лет назад
I think u r the best teacher
@Thornarg
@Thornarg 11 лет назад
Here's an interesting experiment to consider: A stream of water falling without any forces other than gravity and the rotation of the Earth coming into play should be deflected slightly eastward by the amount necessary to maintain its angular momentum as it shortens its distance to the Earth's rotation axis. An adjacent plumb bob should show the difference. Calculating the vertical distance required at the equator to observe a deflection of 1cm is left as an exercise to the reader.
@frosTmarine13
@frosTmarine13 11 лет назад
For those of you talking about how it effects bullets, this effect puts major drift on a round flying past a range of about 1000 yards. Until then it reaches it's target to fast to let the rotation of the earth to mess with it. But at a mile (1760 yards) at some points I've seen a round miss by 2 feet which is a huge deal when your a sniper trying to hit just center mass on your first shot
@Kelli1632
@Kelli1632 10 лет назад
The last diagram of the winds turning should have the arrows drawn from the poles to the equator to maintain consistency with the idea that winds blow from high to low pressure.
@Kinor7
@Kinor7 11 лет назад
Ok, now I get it. There were some videos and some comments about it. It's all about how you pour the water into the sink.
@Gribbo9999
@Gribbo9999 11 лет назад
The Coriolis force is included as a factor when working out the trajectory of large long range artillery shells.
@serubyne57
@serubyne57 7 лет назад
"At this distance you will have to take the Coriolis effect into account." "Dude, what the fuck is the Coriolis effect?" -Me, 9 years ago _Searches 9 years later to see what that was_
@h1llf1gga37
@h1llf1gga37 5 лет назад
ReDleGiThacK 11 years later I’m now a n your shoes
@Kinor7
@Kinor7 11 лет назад
Yeah I know how it looks. I've seen the videos. It's not just about pulling the plug the right way. It's also about how they pour the water into the sink. You can clearly see that the water's rotating the way they want it to before they pull the plug. That's because they pour it in such an angle to create the wanted rotation.
@gpportela
@gpportela 11 лет назад
It is also believed that the coriolis effect may have influence in the mantle magmatic movement, there are researches that shows that patterns on some hydrothermal ore deposits are caused by this effect, very interesting as well.
@aaronwilliamson1720
@aaronwilliamson1720 6 лет назад
This video helped a lot! Thanks!
@321seb
@321seb 11 лет назад
please do an IDTIMWYTIM episode about the second law of thermo-dynamics
@ElectricPandemic
@ElectricPandemic 11 лет назад
I was just wondering if anyone had mentioned that! It was really putting me off how far south that line was of the actual equator...
@muemelification
@muemelification 11 лет назад
It depends on where it is (try it at the poles), how large it is and how calm the water has been. An ocean-sized aquarium would work ;) I don't know what Shamu's tank is, but if it rotates in itself, it will create coriolis Effect itself and not rely on that created by earth's rotation.
@JenMsumbaMusic
@JenMsumbaMusic 11 лет назад
More like this one please!!
@Bith29
@Bith29 11 лет назад
Damn good point. Too few realize this. I've seen enough Nerdfighters zealously agreeing with John Green about things they know absolutely nothing about to make me uncomfortable. (Don't mistake me; John seems sensible enough. I'm just bothered by the unquestioning, uncomprehending agreement I sometimes see.) Illogically, I hadn't considered that the same is occurring here, under the guise of science. Thank you.