I remember when I watch this video when it first came out back in the day. I remember how the image genuinely scared me. After rewatching it as a 17 year old it still sends a chill down my spine. And the music that you edited in definitely helps in that. Overall good video
A defining channel of my childhood. Love whenever I get reminded of you Mullet Mike. I miss getting home from school to sit down and listen to your videos to the point of checking my back every 10 minutes.
Goldenbucket Dang, u had balls. I was a pretty brave kid, watched a ton of horror and exploitation movies by the age of 13 or so, and that picture still lowkey freaks me out to this day. Idk, somethin bout it
@@DomOfSin666 bro same. I’m 13 rn and I love horror movies. I also have the courage to do a few things, like eating spicy stuff (cause I like spicy stuff but a wimp when it comes to it)
Thank god this series got reuploaded. I remember binge watching those videos back in 2014-16. Thank you Mike for being a big part of my childhood with this series, and properly kicking me into the world of creepypastas.
he probably got so fucking scared he bought every single lamp or nightlight he could fit in his house, and immediately bought three german shepherds, installed high priced security systems, proceeds to rent two rooms for two priest to move in free of charge, and put a months worth of savings into salt, crosses, crucifixes and quiet possibly went on ebay to buy a full fucking set of crusade armor, and once again putting almost 6 months of savings into to every fucking gun he can get his hands on, that or either getting so fucking paranoid, he puts long and pointless effort trying to find out where in the blue fuck that image originated from, (i know it was used on 4chan, but the true origin,) until he starts going insane and fucking snaps and gets checked in at a hospital.
9:12 “What in the bloody teetotaling blue hell on an ice cream fuck bar and shit stick sundae is this all about?” best question ever XD. Fun fact: that scary face is actually a girl doing a cosplay from a guy called "Kyo". This guy is a vocalist group from a Japanese band called "Dir En Grey" a band that was famous back 1990s. Many believed that was a photoshopped mango. The unedited image was discovered on september of 2023.
I'm thinking that maybe this was an unfinished ROM hack, and one that was going to be horror-themed, hence the quite unsettling feel and the whole victim description thing. It could have just been a test or a demo for a much larger, more extensive horror-themed hack, but it was just never finished, so instead, it's left an unsettling, empty game only for the victim bit and the image to come straight out of nowhere. That's just my speculation, though. I'm just glad the video's back!
Mullet Mike, you give me a lot of nostalgia with these videos.. Also I would like to know the song at 9:42 - I want to use it for a D&D session with some friends as they delve deep into a haunted house or cave
AFTER YEARS OF LOOKING FOR YOU BECAUSE I WATCHED YOUR CREEPY GAMING SERIES, AND I MEAN YEARS, I FINALLY FOUND YOU MULLET MIKE You have been a childhood favorite of mine. Thank you so much for bringing the series back!
there is no fucking way thats corey, slipknot does creepy shit, but they are usually self explanatory, i did a investigation on the image itself, didnt get far
One of the greatest moments in Creepy Gaming history was that image being displayed with super creepy sound effects for a few seconds before Mike loses his absolute shit
I use to binge these videos when i first got on youtube- I remember this was around the time that Mark was still playing Gmod horror maps- I remember these videos being creepy to me, but also that the dude's voice made a lot of it less scary. Now everytime i think about creepypasta's in general, i think of Mullet Mike's voice and it makes me chuckle- I just like his voice
Ah, the episode that introduced me to Creepy Gaming. I would rewatch it whenever I was feeling down, just to laugh when you “release the beast”. Of course, this is also the episode that got me to scream(and please pardon my language here) “WHAT THE FUCKING HELL IS THAT THING?!” when I first saw it. My brother still hasn’t let me live that down.
I watched this when it first came out god knows how long ago ... I was like 13 or 14... And I'm now 21 .... And to this day, this video still gives me genuine fear... I really don't know why. The static sound Mike gives us when he shows the "victim," ... Or the creepy pasta it's self.. Just, everytime I watch this, it instills fear into me and I just can't explain. Frankly, this is a PRIME example as to why I love you Mike, and I love your series. I'm not scared by much anymore. I've been shot at lol. It's rare to hear me say this, seriously, I wish I could ever explain this to you or anyone who reads this but I just can't... Unless you grew up poor in the ghetto and have also experienced shootouts on your block. Yet this... This video some how scares me more than a literal life or death scenario. I just don't know why or how. Yet the amount of horror this used to give me when I was young, signified my love of being a horror fan, and my love of you Mike, and your series Creepy Gaming. I've been up to date with you to. I know I'm a little late saying all this, But I'm so happy with where you're going with your life and I still wish the best for you and pray everything goes good for you, the same way I've been doing the second I heard about how much you've been struggling. You deserve it Mike. Thank you for the nostalgia, the memories, the horror frankly ... And I really want and wish the best for you.
I remember seeing this video and it made me terrified when the eyeless person picture appeared along with the audio that made it have a more unsettling tone to it, I'm still young and will still be scared but I'm glad I get to see this again
The mystery of the "victim" face has always fascinated me, the eye area actually looks like it has dark spikes going through. I always thought it was odd at first that the number combination said "notepad", I figured it would have said "killed" or "murder" or something more ominous. But "notepad" obviously points to the file that says "find me", all is to reveal the face. Thing is, I could actually see this happening and in a way it saddens me. Why I can imagine Mario doing horrible things does hurt my childhood image of him as this lovable nice man. But that's the joy of creepypastas I guess. XD 9:23 "fuck....THIS" and the scary image is zoomed in on. Always makes me laugh. I have to point out again.........9:42.......that epic music. Does anyone out there know what it's title is called or who made it? Mike, do you know? That music is just so awesome and chilling, I absolutely love it.
I remember way back when this vid was new, (10 years at the time) I would look at Mike as some badass because of his reaction to the Victim1 photo. Such a nostalgia trip rewatching this. You know how a lot of people look up to games as like "omg that was my childhood"? well, you were certainly part of mine when it came to creepypasta videos.
I remember watching this for the first time when I was twelve, and being absolutely terrified of that image. I kept thinking that thing was following me around. I'm not as scared as I was back then, but I still can't quite bring myself to look at that image. It gives me the creeps.
I watched this when I was young. Like 13 or 14. I'm 25 now and I always think back to the breaking point moment and die laughing. Miss your videos man. Keep it up.
So that creepy face actually was revealed recently to just be a woman who had eye makeup and fake nails rubbing her face. The contrast was just boosted wayyy up. Crazy to think my nightmares was caused by a emo chick
The music reminded me of your Squall is dead video. When you showed us that faceless Squall picture, it was the same music wasn't it? The same music you used when you showed us that creepy picture.
Came back to this after god, I think 7 years now? I used to watch you religiously, thought you were the funniest dude on the internet. I was only 11 at the time but god damn if you weren’t a big part of my childhood and my introduction into horror. I still remember your intro word for word lmao. I’m 17 now and I’m turning 18 in September but I wanted to say thank you for everything, Mullet Mike
The image is actually from a irl murder victim in Japan because the castle blowing up scene had the text saying victim found dead on the car Pat with eye on the ground and said cause of death was unknown.
Glad you finally reuploaded this! This was one of my favorite Creepy Gaming episodes! Also, did anyone ever find out the origin of the image or "Victim #1"?
I honestly think it's just a highly edited image of the person who am delighted the creepypasta or some other person, I don't know how they made that image but I know however they did noones sleeping when they it
I remember back when I first saw the notification for this episode when it uploaded. It's sad to see the channel I grew up with become different but I'm glad that no ill will or any of that negative stuff has happened! Keep it sticky, stay creepy and you're welcome for me watching! Peace Mullet Mike
Yooo, I'm so glad you've re uploaded these original episodes, they popped up in my recommended and omg the nostalgia, id watch these when I was 10 after school on my gradads iPad before going home and the time I spent watching these creepypasta videos were the highlights of the afternoon, thanks for the awesome memories
If my job was pluming, and I get to go on a Cross country adventure to rescue the princess all while collecting rare stars and golden coins and riding a dinosaur with superpowers like fireballs and flying Yeah it's hard for me to complain
Yo anyone know what that scratchy violin sound affect he used is called? Btw, I have been watching your videos from the beginning, god this was such a wild ride, I felt so horrible and sad finding out all the events happening in your life, it adds a little touch of reality to this channel, but we were all happy to hear that you opened up to us about what happened in real life, I am so sorry for your loss, I am deeply sorry about everything you went through, you were a huge part of my childhood, I still come back just for the freaky nostalgia you give me, and this video used to give me nightmares, and I still see that face when I close my eyes, but you, Mullet Mike, are gonna be one of Creepy Gaming's Legends, not these videos, not the creepypastas, you, you are the highlight and The Undertaker of Creepy Gaming. Much love.
Man. This hit hard :( i played this game when i was very young and I remember always asking my uncle to help me get through the ghost houses and difficult levels. I will always love that game.
The mystery of Victim #1 in the Mario creepypasta revolves around the eerie and unexplained occurrences within the game. Creepypasta is a term for short horror stories that get shared around the internet, often involving popular culture icons such as video game characters. In this particular Mario creepypasta, Victim #1 is a character who is said to have been killed or disappeared under strange circumstances within the game, sparking rumors and theories about supernatural elements affecting the gameplay. Players and fans of the Mario series have speculated on the true identity of Victim #1, with some suggesting it could be a reference to a lost or forgotten character in the franchise. Others believe that the creepy events surrounding Victim #1 are the result of a haunted or cursed game cartridge. The mystery continues to intrigue and terrify gamers who come across the chilling tale of Victim #1 in the Mario creepypasta.
So fucking weird going through these again and seeing how damn cheesy they are. Can’t believe younger me was so scared and her so obsessed with this scary shit.
I remember watched this as a teen and I always thought you wrr a famous youtuber. When I refund your channel I was expecting to cringe since I watched weird stuff as a kid but you have so much charisma and great editing. I can now see you are CRIIMINALLY underrated
