Crosby, Stills & Nash - Helplessly Hoping - 10/7/1973 - Winterland (Official) 

i choked on hello and tripped on goodbye.

Stills best ever

Crosby had the ears and the voice. Harmonies were his LIFE

RIP David Crosby for bringing us these incredible harmonies.

I was a drummer in a rock band back then and we tried to play several of their songs, my opinion the band was never the same the day Young left. " Best Music Ever "

Its 2024 and I saw the original the first time :-c I love this music!

Whenever I can join in with the harmonies, my soul soars...what a blessing to join in..

Those harmonies, magical! RIP David.

Legends.

I was 19, great memories.

Croz is the one who brings the two dominant voices together

Splendid...once in a lifetime harmony perfected!

Brilliant to say the very least

Thanks for your artistry, fellas. I lived and breathed this album in my teen years. It enriched my life immeasurably. Good Vibrations

Simply is the best !!!

Gorgeous! & that smile from Croz at the end...priceless!

A favourite of mine ❤

Why wasn't Crosby also pictured, harmonizing with his band mates in this video

I was at that show. The big rumor was that Neil Young was gonna show up. Kinda glad he didn't.

I want to be this good... ♥️😎

This was a Manassas concert which was clearly Stills' best band ever.

Best harmonizers in the business!!

I wonder what the cameraman made ignore Davids singing, so he was just focusing on Stephen and Graham?

Groovy

Helplessly hoping her harlequin hovers nearby Awaiting a word Gasping at glimpses of gentle true spirit, he runs Wishing he could fly Only to trip at the sound of goodbye Wordlessly watching, he waits by the window and wonders At the empty place inside Heartlessly helping himself to her bad dreams, he worries Did he hear a goodbye? Or even hello? They are one person They are two alone They are three together They are for each other Stand by the stairway, you'll see something certain to tell you Confusion has its cost Love isn't lying, it's loose in a lady who lingers Saying she is lost And choking on hello They are one person They are two alone They are three together They are for each other

Stephen's Lambchops are WORLD CLASS here ...

#wishiwasthere

Damn….that’s all I can say. Damn.

❤❤❤

Even Stephen Still had tuning problems, and he didn't have a tuner, had to tune it by ear. Then he kicked it off too fast. Even the big boys had problems. LOL

They are three together... so why don't we see Crosby ?? 😅

Graham's voice is pure magic 2:19

this is sick as fuck

Easier to separate out the individual parts in this recording. On the album it’s much harder cuz they’re so damn tight & seamless.

Weird that Crosby was cut out of the video during the singing.

Can someone that understand a bit of human voice explain to us exactly which mode each are using? It sounds simple yet i can't take one apart from the other ig stills is using head voice and the other two are using the upper parts of the same register (falsetto) [btw if there's anything wrong bare in mind I'm here to learn so any mistakes just let me know]

The sound is made by stills and nash. Where is -crosby?

Professionalism in motion....

Crosby given middle child treatment by the camera editor.

You need a roadie 3

Soundtrack movie of annhillation..

Please see how Crosby recognizes the out of tune guitar before they start. Graham and Steven both check and Crosby tells Stills the E string. A hell of a lot of bad things could be said about Crosby but his ear was never one of those.

Your opinion and am happy to respect it. But I disagree. Those harmonies, as others have pointed out, are damn good. There was a reason those popularity continued after NY’s departure.

born i the wrong generation

Sucks when you can't hear the note and you're the one playing the fucking guitar, Steven