Тёмный

Debate with Simon Yu - China vs The West // (含中文字幕) 和Simon Yu一场关于中国与西方的辩论 

Barrett
Подписаться 381 тыс.
Просмотров 72 тыс.
50% 1

A little while ago when we were in Shanghai we met up with Simon Yu, A native Chinese guy who grew up in Shanghai and has a Taiwanese wife. He did a masters degree in the USA and therefore has an interesting perspective on the world and living under very different systems. I (Lee) had a chat with him about lots of different things comparing China with the Western world.
Subscribe to Simon: / @simonyu
If you'd like to support the channel / 如果你想支持我们的频道:
💰 Become a Patron: www.patreon.co...
🧧 WeChat / 微信: prnt.sc/tgyc41
☕ Buy us a coffee: www.buymeacoff...
📺 Other videos that might interest you!
China Doesn't Have Free Speech!: • China Doesn't Have Fre...
0 - 100,000 SUBSCRIBERS IN 11 MONTHS: • 0 - 100,000 SUBSCRIBER...
📹 Oli's RU-vid Channel: / @olibarrett2959
✍️ The course I (Oli) use to study Chinese. I can read short sentences after less than 30 hours of study! (7-day FREE trial & 30-day money-back guarantee): courses.mandar...
🔒 Get 49% off the fastest VPN (30-day money-back guarantee): www.expressvpn....
📖 Get 1 FREE book and 2 FREE Audible originals: amzn.to/36hvEPO
📻 The Barrett Podcast
Apple: podcasts.apple...
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
🐦 Twitter: / barrettyoutube
📷 Instagram: / barrettinst
✌️ As always, until next time!
Contains affiliate links

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,9 тыс.   
@moulion
@moulion 4 года назад
Reading the comments, it seems pretty clear Simon's views don't represent a significant number of Chinese people's views. Still, it is important to bring people with different opinions to hear them out, and challenge your audience for the sake of finding the truth (unlike a few China-bashing RU-vidrs who EXCLUSIVELY make anti-China videos). For that, I applaud this episode! Good work, and keep it up.
@BarrettYT
@BarrettYT 4 года назад
Thank you, I think it's important to engage people with different views.
@sabrinachan1833
@sabrinachan1833 4 года назад
Agree.
@moulion
@moulion 4 года назад
@@BarrettYT Thank you for being fair and objective. As a Chinese immigrant to Germany, I have seen the best and worst of both worlds. But the one thing they all have in common is the formation of "political bubbles", and it's always disappointing to witness wherever it happens. That's why I subscribe to your channel - not because you praise China all the time, but because you try your best to be fair to China and it's people.
@mollydang5827
@mollydang5827 4 года назад
@@moulion Politicians and media keep mindfucking people
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
It would be better to include people who have better understanding rather than a shallow assessment. It's not that Simon Yu is wrong in criticising China, but he doesn't really explain why democracy is better, he just insist that it is without explaining why.
@nxul2454
@nxul2454 4 года назад
身為一個台灣人,非常不認同西方民主代議制度能有效管理一個擁有14億人口的大國,別說大陸了,光看台灣兩黨就可以把台灣玩成這副德性,就知道民主選舉制,尤其領導人,一個掌握國家未來發展生死存亡的大位,竟然是用民粹選出來的,想想都不寒而慄,中央只要不干擾人民生活財產,管理階層是否民主,並不重要。
@张张老师-x4l
@张张老师-x4l 4 года назад
同意。这个傻逼就是恨国党,仗着自己喝了几天洋墨水!和国内方方一样的嘴脸!精美分子!中国不适合民主!这么多人口!这么民族怎么管理,和印度一样吗?中国要和新加坡一样,精英治国!
@davidwan7956
@davidwan7956 4 года назад
身為一個台灣人+1
@李荣-n7s
@李荣-n7s 4 года назад
真正民主,应该是无党制,不能多党制。因为政党免不了要代表部分人利益而忽略其他人利益, 但总统却是所有人的总统。 所有人的总统却仅仅代表部分人利益。。。这是什么情况? 所以要选出好总统,不能多党制。 无党制或一党制在逻辑上更合理
@jackyd1917
@jackyd1917 4 года назад
部分同意,台湾这十几年就一直在党争不断,内政上几乎没干成什么事吧。不过国民党现在要垮了,民进当一家独大,也许接下来几年还能干点事。 不过民众的意见在决策层里得到体现也是很重要的,否则没有监督机制决策层想怎么玩就怎么玩,那腐败的速度也会是非常惊人的。所以大陆也应该需要找到适合自己的民主制度,否则也不可能长久。
@nxul2454
@nxul2454 4 года назад
簡單舉個島內的正在發生例子:新冠爆發至今,都快半年了,目前台灣當局還在為了紓困案喬不定,很多錢嗎,不,才區區幾百億,平均給一個台灣人不過2-3000元,可是卻因為發放消費卷的政策是前朝實行過,是目前執政黨過去強力抨擊按在地上磨擦的,所以目前當局拉不下臉來做,硬要拐個彎,讓人民先花1000元去買3000振興卷,實在脫褲子放屁,就不能直接發2000元卷就好嗎,不行,因為前朝實行過,這就是兩黨制,不管對不對,先吵再說,發錢很困難嗎,不,台灣前陣子"援助"帛琉群島,2億5千萬,吭一下都不用,直接給了,以帛琉總人口21000人計,平均每人12000新台幣。台灣3000元消費卷,還在吵,帛琉爽領12000,這就是民粹台灣。
@Auntie爱种花
@Auntie爱种花 4 года назад
I don't know about Simon Yu. The longer I live in the US, the more I see the homelessness on the streets, the more I appreciate Chinese Culture.
@KizzMyAbs
@KizzMyAbs 4 года назад
Try living in the 80s and 90s China. Or try living there today with their amazing sanitation infrastructure and plumbing 🤣🤣🤣💩💩💩
@alfredchen4579
@alfredchen4579 4 года назад
Yu seems like the type of people majority people don't like because this type if people always favour other countries; this type of people won't be constructive when the homeland has difficulties, but run away, only return to the homeland to enjoy the goods after the difficulties which he doesn't deserve.
@dugang139
@dugang139 4 года назад
@@alfredchen4579 absolutely right
@saminekunis8680
@saminekunis8680 4 года назад
So true
@hangruizhao6321
@hangruizhao6321 4 года назад
U ARE SO NICE.I'm a Chinese and agree on what you say.Welcome to come to China if you like.Get away from CRAZY Trump.太喜欢你了。
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
This person's opinion does not represent the majority of Chinese people, he said that Taiwanese people have better hygiene habits than Chinese people, Chinese people do not have the habit of washing their hands, in fact, in China since primary school teachers tell students to wash their hands frequently and keep clean. He can only represent himself. His claim that China's political system is inferior to the west is rife with western brainwashed prejudices.He said he was trying to get the world to know more about China, I don't know how such a person without his own judgment, blindly worshiped the west and knew nothing about politics, knew nothing about the Chinese cultural system, was full of prejudice against the Chinese government and was extremely self-abased can let the world know about China.
@bunicebear5140
@bunicebear5140 4 года назад
agree with it
@leewie9085
@leewie9085 4 года назад
I think he thinks his hair is blonde and have blue eyes. A Chinese with such naivety. Chinese people says such kind of person eat shit growing up. Tell me which country in these world become like what he thinks so ideally overnight. None. He doesnt even understand his own country let alone make comments which i have seen. A disgrace to his own kind. Makes me puke.
@jurgenangler5294
@jurgenangler5294 4 года назад
If you ask for my analyze that i can tell you, he is taiwan DPP supporter. If you look at his channel there is no anything mentioning about Trumpandemic disaster handling or Ahmaud Arbery cases. Why??? I can answer you that it is inappropriate to make a video criticizing or hardly against your strong supporter, right??? For me it is makes million sense..
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
Jurgen Angler Yes, he said he made the video to let the world know about China, he is a liar
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
他父母让他学英文,就被西方媒体洗脑了。 _His parents let him study English and gotten brainwashed by Western media._
@clementinejustice2541
@clementinejustice2541 4 года назад
I don’t think this guy really understand politics in the west or China, I don’t really think the governments really listen to us the public in the west Ike how he imagined. I don’t think this guy really know the west, even though he studied there, like some of the chinese thinking too highly of the west. He is too innocent, or even stupid he doesn’t really understand the international situation. I think Chinese have more freedom of speech than what he thinks because he is trying to compare with the west, but he doesn’t know the impact of that speech. I heard so much changes was inspired by people’s voice from my friends in china, where in the west, I often found we can complain, but hardly see anything being done . And public don’t really believe reports as much, because opposition parties’ outlet would have different opinions most the time , except anti China. I think you( Barret) have a much better understanding of the world situation than this guy, and this is the first time ever I dislike your video.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Perhaps it would be better to include people who have better understanding rather than a shallow assessment. It's not that Simon Yu is wrong in criticising China, but he doesn't really explain why democracy is better, he just insist that it is without explaining why.
@爆炒蛙蛙真好吃
@爆炒蛙蛙真好吃 4 года назад
I agree with you about the first part ,but I have no feeling about this video because producer should have all different kind of communications. that we can know how many youngman really considering about the difference between Chinese politics and western politics now. it is not a bad thing
@以德服人-q6c
@以德服人-q6c 4 года назад
he is a China hater!
@vincentfu3530
@vincentfu3530 4 года назад
too young too naive
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby Simon Yu said that Chinese people don't wash our hands, but his mother is a doctor and yet she doesn't teach her son how to wash his hands?
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
Oversea Chinese here, I feel be misrepresented by Simon Yu. He tends think once all people get evolved into something(voting), all things can be better solved. Really? ? Look at Donald Trump in the US, Boris Johnson in the UK. Should China get a leader like these two?
@kimkwan4993
@kimkwan4993 4 года назад
surely not ! !
@kwanhochong8191
@kwanhochong8191 4 года назад
Wow at least people have their own choices to choose their leaders. And they know they are fully responsible if they make bad choices.
@johnun7814
@johnun7814 4 года назад
I also agree with you. What kind of involvement he wants? I am a British Chinese, do I feel like I got any involvement in for any decision the government made in the UK? I do like the life in China now, am thinking to go back very soon.
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
@@johnun7814 most time, the majority are just not making the right decisions.大多数人并不理性。讽刺的是,真理只掌握在少数人手中。
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
@@kwanhochong8191 Really, Trump, Hillary(2016) which do you prefer? Trump, Biden (2020) which do you like? Is the Brexit really good for the long term interests of British people?
@annie4963
@annie4963 4 года назад
Simon didn't answer the key question. He lacks in-depth understanding and perspective
@christinaj334
@christinaj334 4 года назад
​@何Bobby true
@csgs2301
@csgs2301 4 года назад
what a waste of time of listening to his crap.
@sang6281
@sang6281 4 года назад
腦子讀書讀壞了!! 千萬別讓公民普遍參與國家政治與政策制定!!那是制度的倒退,而不是進步!
@李荣-n7s
@李荣-n7s 4 года назад
我觉得可以让大众参与政策制定。因为这不是什么有技术含量的事,更像某种许愿:我想要住大楼,开豪车,想跟马云一样有钱。。。等等等等。 许愿谁不会?所以 让大众许愿不是什么坏事,政府本来就是为人民服务,知道大众的愿望不是可以更好为人民服务吗? 但是。。。 大众可以提政策,但决定采用什么政策,得让专业人士决定;怎么实施政策,让政策成真,也得由专业人士去实行。
@damonyu2999
@damonyu2999 4 года назад
@@李荣-n7s 说实话, 民众只适合吃瓜, 一段时间一个瓜, 多开心, 投票搞政策还是拉鸡巴倒吧
@REDSUN-8
@REDSUN-8 4 года назад
西方资本主义制度的弊端就是IQ普遍达不到100的普通公民却妄想选出一个IQ120以上的国家领导人😂😂, 在美国能出一个特朗普, 就是反映美国人的普遍水准。
@REDSUN-8
@REDSUN-8 4 года назад
@@李荣-n7s 得了, 还是放弃这种想法吧, 瞧瞧香港, 给了这种权力了又怎样??得不到回应照样胡来。人就是这么犯贱, 吃了一个还想吃第二个, 他们贪婪以外没有别的, 最终他们还想骑政府头上撒尿。
@zacheron3244
@zacheron3244 4 года назад
@@李荣-n7s 如果我许愿让地球爆炸,政府要不要帮我实现呢? 仔细想想,所有合理的,该由政府去做的事情,都是确定的,可以用理性去推断的,不用问。让大众参与政策制定,就是骗人的把戏。 这个把戏是怎么骗人的? 大众参与会有什么结果呢? 比如我是开餐馆的,你是搞IT的,他是开公交的。大家的人生经历,专业素养都不一样,不可能在任何问题大家都懂,都保持理性。 这种时候,理性就不是我们的最大公约数。那什么样的决策会获得最多人的支持呢? 台湾关于核电的一系列风波就是最好的例子。有空去了解一下啊
@wzlzd5295
@wzlzd5295 4 года назад
Simon is too young to understand the complexity of political system. No system is perfect and it is a serious choice. If you follow US, you will see the same problem in HK where the capital control everything and ordinary person suffer. In China, the infrastructure is developed and living standards much improved for ordinary ppl because the capitalism cannot control this country.
@astroayumi1752
@astroayumi1752 4 года назад
Very well said !
@ZZ-gw9xn
@ZZ-gw9xn 4 года назад
If every citizen demands an increase in welfare, what is lost is the capital to build the future! This may be the failure of the people's election system! People are selfish!
@mnbr6884
@mnbr6884 4 года назад
I don't think you were listening. He said exactly that no system is perfect and hopefully we can meet in the middle.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
I think Simon Yu's personal background is that while he was living in Shanghai, he *wasn't all that interested* in politics, like most people. His first exposure to politics was probably in West and that's why he adopted the anti-China political stance so common in the West.
@kevinliu2432
@kevinliu2432 4 года назад
I think nobody should touch politics as it can make our minds more narrowed. We shouldn't even watch RU-vid videos to begin with either
@wadeabout1856
@wadeabout1856 4 года назад
Yu cannot represent the Chinese, He is so naive.
@carly9702
@carly9702 4 года назад
@MyChina 1950 He is a banana man
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
This kind of person is yellow skin white heart, so pathetic
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
他父母让他学英文,就被西方媒体洗脑了。 _His parents let him study English, but he gotten brainwashed by Western media._
@erwinlee2842
@erwinlee2842 4 года назад
Eric Li or Professor Wei wei if you want to listen to professional Chinese commentators
@lchmann65
@lchmann65 4 года назад
Simon... he represent taiwan, the majority of which are broods of failed KMT, chased out of mainland China many years ago. KMT is fully sponsored by USnakes all along.
@adgg3168
@adgg3168 4 года назад
Too young, too simple, sometimes naive
@leehk4425
@leehk4425 4 года назад
From the fact that he said he couldn't work as hard as his mother, you know he is either has a West-is-better-for-sure mind or he is just the spoiled second generation abusing the hard work and wealth of their parents. If China has more youth like him, China will surely go a declining trend after 20 years.
@fui5469
@fui5469 4 года назад
对不起,看到我蛤的名言我笑了233333
@TL-fe9si
@TL-fe9si 4 года назад
@cityhunterhf 江大爷很有水平的,不知道怎么搞得就风评被害了
@coreycox2345
@coreycox2345 4 года назад
@@leehk4425 Truth. I have noticed a work ethic. I am two generations removed from my Ukrainian and English immigrant ancestors who came to Canada, and my grandparents and parents worked so hard compared to me. They came from a hard life. I have worked. Things will be harder for my son's age. Do you have an exchange student program for my sons as teenagers? I am already planning to introduce them to the kids from the Chinese Canadian family across the street, who built their parents a new deck in the first weeks of COVID. They take excellent care of the elderly in that family.
@realguy6964
@realguy6964 4 года назад
Maybe young, yes. But he knows how to do something that I’m pretty sure you don’t know how to do. That is, to look at things from a third party perspective.
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
Oversea Chinese here, I feel be misrepresented by Simon Yu. He tends think once all people get evolved into something(voting), all things (like poverty alleviation, etc.) can be magically better solved. Really?? Simple examples. Look at Donald Trump in the US, Boris Johnson in the UK. Should China get a leader like these two?
@asiacuisine4869
@asiacuisine4869 4 года назад
Not forgetting Scott Morrison of Australia. Such disasters so called democracy.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby The OP merely says that he feels misrepresented that's all.
@jorryzhu7382
@jorryzhu7382 4 года назад
@@Shenzhou. this 何Bobby express strange view points everywhere, a real anti-China guy, 高级黑.
@pengfeixu7301
@pengfeixu7301 4 года назад
@何Bobby U need to calm down man, nothing will change for u trying so hard to be deliberately ambiguous.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby Subscriber count or not, all the OP is saying that as overseas Chinese, he feels misrepresented by Simon Yu that's all.
@hongyin2637
@hongyin2637 4 года назад
Interesting Talk. Being in the Us for 15 years, I think Simon’s understanding about the west is superficial, hence the comparison wouldn’t get to the root. I also think because Simon knows a little bit about how the westerns perceive China, so the intention of making a balanced view colored his points as western media machine made. Sorry,for me, he tried too hard. Next time,maybe invite someone who has no western exposure to see what that group of the Chinese (actually they will represent the majority of the Chinese) think of US vs China, at least their view will be pure.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
I think Simon Yu's personal background is that while he was living in Shanghai, he *wasn't all that interested* in politics. His first exposure to politics probably occurred in the West and that's where he adopted the anti-China political stance so common in the West. His political stance consists of Westerners telling him "China is evil, China's system is all wrong," without hearing the Chinese side.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby China is home to *world's largest highspeed railway network,* surpassing even Japan's _Shinkansen_ hi-speed rail in terms of track length. Our high-speed trains are world class, the journeys very smooth and enjoyable. Passengers have even experimented by balanced small objects like coins, stationery and smartphones on their edges in a train traveling at 350 kph, and the objects remain undisturbed (even stagnant water remains still) for long period of time. Prior to the advent of high speed rail, during the Spring Festival, people in China would make the trip back to our home province to spend the new years with family and friends and the journey would often take several days. But thanks to China's high-speed rail, the commuting times have been cut short, from *days to mere hours.* _Countries by high-speed rail lines in operation_ *1. China (38,207 km)* 2. Spain (5,525 km) 3. Germany (4,692 km) 4. France (3,802 km) 5. Japan (3,421 km) 6. Sweden (2,055 km) 7. United Kingdom (1,757 km) ... Source: _Wikipedia: List of high-speed railway lines_ Video: _Watch how long coin can balance on high-speed train traveling at 350 kph_ Link: youtube(dot)com/watch?v=fumYdO9XknE
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby What makes you think allowing ordinary people to participate in political decision-making is a wise idea? Ordinary people are *fickle* and they make poor voters for several reasons: -Ordinary people may not vote responsibly (i.e. They may not turn up to vote, or they submit blank votes) -Ordinary people may base their vote on emotions, not logic (i.e. Many British don't like immigrants, so majority voted for Brexit) -Ordinary people are susceptible to foreign influences (i.e. Russian interference in US elections) -Ordinary people may simply lack awareness of the country's real political situation, to make informed decisions regarding the country's future. There's a host of other problems associated with democracy, so why not let those who know how to govern, govern? That's what China is doing and look at how successful China is.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby The number of wealthy Chinese people has *overtaken* the number of rich Americans for the first time, according to a report by _Credit Suisse._ _The bank’s annual wealth survey found there were _*_100 million_*_ Chinese people among the world’s top 10% of richest people, compared with _*_99 million_*_ in the US._ Source: _China _*_overtakes_*_ US in rankings of world’s richest people_ Link: theguardian(dot)com/business/2019/oct/21/china-overtakes-us-in-rankings-of-worlds-richest-people
@alexy9907
@alexy9907 4 года назад
Agree, invite someone who has no western exposure to see what that group of the Chinese think China and Western.
@pengfu8608
@pengfu8608 4 года назад
American Chinese here! Born in China and moved to California and now back to China. Yikes, USA is not doing well, man. The core issue is actually exactly what this Chinese guy admires. Perhaps the "perfect democratic" system that he admires so much is all empty talks and bullying. I have much more freedom in China. Better foods, safety, progress, creating large infrastructure to benefit everyone at the expense of pissing a smaller percentage off. Sure, much better than regime change and sanctioning people like changing underware. I never wanted that and attended anti war protests. The government never listens to me! My pay was stuck at the same level forever and my government holds hands with corporations to suck my blood and I complained, they never listen to me. China stopped dead of the COVID and USA let it become air freshener.....I never approved that. What freedom? By the time I paid off all my expenses (not even spending disposable income), I got nothing left. No money no honey and no honey then no freedom. So what freedom? I want that damn fast trains built between L.A. and S.F., and L.A. and Vegas. Talked talked talked and even began some construction but price kept going up and some nice grandma selling tamale complained so the government switched to build F35s, which we already have a lot. They did not listen to me. And why are we always so scared, and poor? Ugly cities and ugly infrastructure with ugly around people who think they are the best but they have never been outside of Los Angeles. Freedom of speech? Yea, I have been shouting about dumb ass gun laws and merciless killings of citizens, particularly African Americans, yet it fucking happens ALL THE TIMES. Now if it does not happen something is really wrong. Human rightS? I saw a doctor once out of the 25 years in the U.S., and countless times in Shanghai, without purchasing expat health insurance, mind you. USA pulled out the UN Human Rights Council, so USA should not even be fxcking talking about human rights. Freedom of Press.....If you up the extremes of punishments and accountabilities, then there is no need to publish goofy things corrupt officials. In China, if you went over the board, chop chop. No stupid 29 years debates between two retarded "parties" and mountain of lawyer fees. That ass lick Colin Powell with the fake powder is having a really nice steak now. Dickie Cheney is fingering his wifes. Tony "devoted" Blair Flair farts a gallon of Middle Easter people's blood but still thinks he did the right thing. If the punishment from Geneva (Fancy boring self contradictory white place) international criminal court really does what it says, then both Saddam and Tony would be friendly cellmates. The whole "yes, pick a name from the list that you like because he looks smart, not traditional, charismatic, check it and toss it into this little plastic Box" election game is the most ridiculous! Every four years or less we will find out who is the real slut with attention deficit disorder who won't follow simple tasks such as mask wearing instructions. While I do not have any power to get rid of him but am told I have all the power to do so......Go vote more, find some loopholes, yes, you said it, no I didn't I misspoke. When impeachment is about to happen, some super rich daddies will fly in with hooked nose to bail me out.... Go Lee, great example of India! Even my India friends don't have much faith in India. I am just so sick and tired of being jerked around like a damn fool to believe that the West is the Best. NOOOOOOO, BOOO HOOO. And there lies so much problems because Hong Kong and Taiwan's educational system are controlled by anti China history twisters: China bad, West Good, China Bad, West Good, China Bad, West Good. I still remember that several years ago the queen of England complained about the Chinese visitors being rude. HeeeHeee, that bitch's castles were built by human bones, her crown is a Lego piece made up of all the jewels of countless countries like India that were rich before.....Just look at her stupid dogs that have a better lives than average Brits and she is so selfish and would not drop dead to give power to other people....."Pardon me......Pardon me.....Is that the world's biggest diamond? Oh dear, oh dear, it is mine now. " Here, I just bought some multi purpose dildos. Yea, the government knows.......So? They are super flexible high quality silicon made in China product and I am trying to help lift the country out of recession. What do Americans and the British and the goofy Kiwis and Kangarooreans down South have to hide? What? Hitler is still alive and JFK and Mao had intimate oral sex? What? The Earth is flat?
@clementinejustice2541
@clementinejustice2541 4 года назад
I wish this Simon guy will your comment. Learn from it.
@cchysp4261
@cchysp4261 4 года назад
现阶段还是绝对不能开放油桶,绝对会导致重大的问题,国内的精美 精日 ,甚至 印吹 越吹 都多得很,觉对会搞处很多麻烦事儿。 有限度的开放VPN 让相对有判断力 有认识能力的人可以自由在油桶等平台发声就够了 ,油桶永远都是别人家的舆论主场,我们影响不了啥。
@likang3842
@likang3842 2 года назад
对的,光是国内媒体都容易被洗脑别说翻墙了,他们根本就没有独立思考的能力。要是开方油管很容易被西方洗脑,只要会造成社会不安
@aghs2169
@aghs2169 4 года назад
用中文说吧。很多年前我在上海混的时候,接到过政府某部门的调查问卷,当时忙着工作,并不上心。去年我住在一个三四线小城市,因为住的地方附近正在大开发,很多路面被大车压坏了,坑坑洼洼,导致我的驾车体验很差,于是试着拨打市长热线投诉。结果第二天深夜(第三天凌晨)回家时就看到有工人在施工了,而且当时是周末。周一早上去上班,路面改善了很多。其实也不是最近才这样,十多年前,我家附近十字路口,路边新建的草地挡住了斑马线,导致你要么绕过去、要么踩草坪,我妈说这太蠢了,于是打电话给电视台,结果电视台真报道了,然后市政部门立刻过来整改了。 中国很多地方的政府对问题的响应都非常及时,官员会主动下到基层,也会搞很多走访调查。老百姓有什么要抱怨的,也有很多有效的渠道。像上面说的我的经历,对于身边的小问题,你可以打12345、可以找媒体,对于大一点的问题,你可以找社区反映,再大一点的问题,根据其性质,可以找人大或政协帮你,对于腐败问题,可以找纪委匿名检举……如果这些都不管用,还有信访的渠道给你压轴。 很多被西方洗脑的人,想问题真的太肤浅,天真的以为手里有票、能选人就是民主,以为有选票才有权利。其实,重要的不是“那个人是你、是大家选出来的”,而是“那个人听你的声音,帮你、帮大家做事”,否则,你觉得“那个人是选上去的,结果他只帮资本家做事”这样算不算民主?
@kiyu414
@kiyu414 4 года назад
When he is talking about people always want more, and he thought in the west people get to involve to make decision for the government.. ... Oh my god.... I want to debate with him ...
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby As the world's most populous country, China has (statistically speaking) the most *brainpower* to come up with plans and ideas, as well as the most *manpower* to implement said plans and turn ideas into reality. Larger populations have more geniuses, and since China's population is 4x that of USA, there should be at least 4 Chinese geniuses to every 1 American genius. _Consider two standard bell curves, say one with 1.4 billion people and one with 326 million. The number of average people in China is very close to 4.3 times the number of average people in the U.S. That is also true for those in the top 2% say, which produces scientists, the best business and government people, and the most competent computer programmers. Even there, China would have a 4.3 to 1 advantage, which would be quite an advantage, everything else being equal._ Source: _China's Statistical Advantage: Large populations have more geniuses_ Link: iiipublishing(dot)com/blog/2018/06/blog_06_07_2018.html
@spotato
@spotato 4 года назад
@何Bobby As the world's most populous country, China has (statistically speaking) the most brainpower to come up with plans and ideas, as well as the most manpower to implement said plans and turn ideas into reality. Larger populations have more geniuses, and since China's population is 4x that of USA, there should be at least 4 Chinese geniuses to every 1 American genius. Consider two standard bell curves, say one with 1.4 billion people and one with 326 million. The number of average people in China is very close to 4.3 times the number of average people in the U.S. That is also true for those in the top 2% say, which produces scientists, the best business and government people, and the most competent computer programmers. Even there, China would have a 4.3 to 1 advantage, which would be quite an advantage, everything else being equal. Source: China's Statistical Advantage: Large populations have more geniuses Link: iiipublishing(dot)com/blog/2018/06/blog_06_07_2018.html
@cilngenois6496
@cilngenois6496 4 года назад
I have similar background with Simon: I got my master degree in US, and now working in China. I saw the changes in China, but have great confidence with Chinese political system.
@godvinkevin1554
@godvinkevin1554 4 года назад
l will say simon knows nothing about Chinese government
@monkeylias7404
@monkeylias7404 4 года назад
And American gov
@JohnDoe-gi7ty
@JohnDoe-gi7ty 4 года назад
Unfortunately it is true, He may not know much about the Chinese government , and most of average people does not know the government well in China. so do western people, they do not know their government well either. I grew up and educated in China, and I worked for the government for short period of time after college graduation before I came to USA. The Chinese government is not perfect by any mean, but the Chinese government is the best system for this period of time. The longer I stay in US, I am more strongly believing that the CCP is right for China. Of course there are plenty of room for improvement, for example, expanding more people involved in local government decision making process.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Probably during Simon Yu's upbringing in Shanghai, he *wasn't all that interested* in politics, like most people. His first exposure to politics was probably in the West, and being bombarded with Westerners constantly telling him his country's political system is wrong, is going to influence his political stance to be anti-China.
@朽下清吹
@朽下清吹 4 года назад
This simon is banana guy,no doubt.
@christinaj334
@christinaj334 4 года назад
yes
@obsidianstatue
@obsidianstatue 4 года назад
I've watched a handful of SImon's video, as a Chinese myself, his version of China portrayed in youtube is still presented through a westerner's view of China, the only difference is he's a native Chinese speaker, his understanding of China or at least his portrayal of China is still skin deep. his ultimate view still rest on "The West is right and China should be more like the West because they are right" as to why he thinks a western model is right for China or even objectively the right way, he never mentions why.
@bennychen9330
@bennychen9330 4 года назад
Yes, I think there is nothing wrong with criticising China but at least have something to back your arguments instead of hinging them upon the view that "freedom and democracy" represent perfection.
@ProCelestialEmpire
@ProCelestialEmpire 4 года назад
What I saw from this video is he's making his arguments based on facts and reasoning, while what you said is basically claiming him to be shallow or wrong in the first place, which is groundless.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
China should not be under pressure to adopt Western Liberal Democracy. China should follow our path to success, keeping policies that work, abandoning policies that don't, and adopting good points of other policies after they have shown to be successful.
@hongyin2637
@hongyin2637 4 года назад
obsidianstatue completely agree!
@obsidianstatue
@obsidianstatue 4 года назад
@@ProCelestialEmpire "facts and reasoning" from which perspective? I said his understanding or at least his portrayal of China is skin deep, I even refrained from concluding that he had a skin deep understanding of China, he may very well knows a lot about China but chose to represent it a certain way, which to me is very shallow and more importantly eurocentric. I've also acknowledge that he's a native Chinese speaker, so he can use that position of authority regarding the Chinese social media, and present it however he like, because most of his viewers can't fact check him, thus in absence of a clear understanding of China's social-political-economic structure, I deemed his view/ portrayal of China, as skin deep. NOW, if you want to discuss about China's historic preferences for centralized autocracy based in Confucianism and Legalism and how it relates to modern day Chinese socialism and CPC governance, you're welcome to start that discussion, you won't find that in Simon's channel. because his views are based on reading Chinese comments and his own feelings, nothing wrong with that, but as I said, it's skin deep.
@janezh6041
@janezh6041 4 года назад
12:05 Simon, if you want to involve in making decisions for the country, then you should fight for the opportunity. No one in China was born to have the power of making decisions for China. If you want that power, then you should serve your people to become a representative first. If your people like you, trust you, and elect you to be their representative, then you can involve in making decisions for the country.
@clementinejustice2541
@clementinejustice2541 4 года назад
I don’t think he is qualified, he is not intelligent enough to be A CCP member. China would be better without people Like him to be In CCP
@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863
@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863 4 года назад
@@clementinejustice2541 if he do get into ccp he will be the first to be executed for corruption and being a US running dog
@tc7662
@tc7662 3 года назад
And you cant let any random dumb person or most manipulative persons make decisions for you.
@janezh6041
@janezh6041 3 года назад
@@tc7662 Exactly!
@蔡日文-k2w
@蔡日文-k2w 4 года назад
SImon。在中国被看作是一个小公知。他一方面享受着国家的进步,尤其是在上海。一边又在羡慕西方的政治体制的个人权利。但问题是你想要西方式的个人权利,你就得不到你现有的物质基础的具大进步。印度就是个很好的例子。
@chenjan8305
@chenjan8305 4 года назад
之前看过他的视频!就一公知
@kevintin3739
@kevintin3739 4 года назад
搞笑的是一个英国人在引导规劝一个中国人相信中国政府,不要做键盘侠。
@廣東捕蛙狂魔
@廣東捕蛙狂魔 4 года назад
@@kevintin3739 这才是最骚的
@Moonlights_scented
@Moonlights_scented 4 года назад
一个在美国喝了半瓶洋墨水的上海人,找了个台湾媳妇,生活在一个中国地域歧视最严重的地区....觉得自己很了解东西方的政治文化.... 是吧
@keqing77
@keqing77 4 года назад
的确,金灿荣老师说过:这些公知说的话永远是对的,但永远没提出解决方法,总是盯着中国不好的
@linc7075
@linc7075 4 года назад
Lol if you wana compare political systems, you have to compare country economy, growth, happiness index, infrastructure, technology, stability, security etc. The result is the proof whether the political system is working. My own opinion is China is doing great
@drandersjiang
@drandersjiang 4 года назад
Or as Marx called it, Historical Materialism.
@zesawyer1449
@zesawyer1449 4 года назад
How about having the ability to call your president "Winnie the Pooh" without going to jail? Does that count?
@DrSAM69
@DrSAM69 3 года назад
So is taiwan, japan and south korea
@bitesizemandarin4911
@bitesizemandarin4911 4 года назад
I don't agree with the political system part. In the global pandemic, we have witnessed the strength and determination of Chinese government. It shows the advantages of its political system. On the other hand, we also witnessed how the western political system coped with the covid 19.
@王俊-v4s
@王俊-v4s 4 года назад
@何,可惜最后还是把你射了出来
@spotato
@spotato 4 года назад
@何Bobby As the world's most populous country, China has (statistically speaking) the most brainpower to come up with plans and ideas, as well as the most manpower to implement said plans and turn ideas into reality. Larger populations have more geniuses, and since China's population is 4x that of USA, there should be at least 4 Chinese geniuses to every 1 American genius. Consider two standard bell curves, say one with 1.4 billion people and one with 326 million. The number of average people in China is very close to 4.3 times the number of average people in the U.S. That is also true for those in the top 2% say, which produces scientists, the best business and government people, and the most competent computer programmers. Even there, China would have a 4.3 to 1 advantage, which would be quite an advantage, everything else being equal. Source: China's Statistical Advantage: Large populations have more geniuses Link: iiipublishing(dot)com/blog/2018/06/blog_06_07_2018.html
@zesawyer1449
@zesawyer1449 4 года назад
"Western political system" includes New Zealand and Australia, both of the countries did a good job fighting Covid. Dont try to justify communism and suppression of freedoms by cherry picking.
@JERRYGOODE
@JERRYGOODE 4 года назад
This is a great video! Awesome points made Lee. Best video ever from the Barrett boys! The shots was so cool and super crisp. Color graden is off the charts.
@yogalau9832
@yogalau9832 4 года назад
作为一个中国90后,我个人认为中国的的政治体制并不比西方的差,我觉得这个中国人压根就没真正的理解政治
@hmhuang7461
@hmhuang7461 4 года назад
至少西方没有把1,400,000,000中国人当作人质好让中共胡作非为,这也就是为什么美国到现在还没有制裁中共,因为他不想伤及1,400,000,000中国老百姓。中共就利用了川普的仁慈,去不断挑衅他的底线,这次新型冠状病毒实际上就是中共病毒。中共在武汉P4实验室,研制了此病毒,让其他国家分心,尤其是五眼联盟,让自己晚点灭党,因为他们知道其他国家联合起来的实力绝对可以干掉中共。不但如此, 1997年说的一国两制,看看现在变成什么样了,曾经香港引以为傲的自由言论、个人财产不可侵犯全部没有了。现在又出来个港版国安法,就是中共在香港为非作歹的理由。只要你上街游行,就把你抓起来,说你感染了新冠病毒。之所以设墙,就是没法让你看到外面的新闻,这样中共说什么你就信什么让你以为全世界都处在水深火热之中,而此时中国将行使大国的责任出来帮助全世界,研制疫苗,拯救全世界。而真正研制出疫苗的,却是美国。中共手上沾了多少血,我们数都数不过来,还每天一口一个中国梦,所谓中国梦就是噩梦。这就是你所谓的好的政治体系?
@wongjacky4891
@wongjacky4891 4 года назад
@@hmhuang7461你是否忘記了食藥? 我覺得你需要見一見精神科醫生
@grantzhu6731
@grantzhu6731 4 года назад
@@hmhuang7461 你这病不轻啊,建议吃多点安眠药
@大熊-u3d
@大熊-u3d 4 года назад
柯浩哲 玩你妈蛋去
@贝樱
@贝樱 4 года назад
30 柯浩哲 你他妈是川普射出来的吧还仁慈
@jxde287pjto2
@jxde287pjto2 4 года назад
Lee has a good assessment of Western and China (live in China for more than 17yrs) and can give a better comparisons. Simon is still young...too naive.
@jxde287pjto2
@jxde287pjto2 4 года назад
@何Bobby Nonsense
@zhanyuxie7869
@zhanyuxie7869 3 года назад
kinda agree with ya,
@helenc1051
@helenc1051 4 года назад
I can tell you that the wrong person you are interviewing... simply he is 輪子as Chinese people will call him.
@asiacuisine4869
@asiacuisine4869 4 года назад
Agree. Barrett, u interviewed the wrong person. He is not worthy of attention. like serpentza and laowhy.
@shannon9121
@shannon9121 4 года назад
@何Bobby I don't agree with your comment, believe me, we all know China and Chinese have defaults and flaws which they need to improve; however, it's definitely not the one-party system, having only one small group of elites to govern its citizens is actually the beauty of China, and the reason why China come back strong again.
@davidtan3353
@davidtan3353 4 года назад
I don't think it's a wrong person Barrett interviewed, let him be 輪子, reading comments here we can see many people have clear mind, compare to simon, Barrett have better understanding in most field, simon just sound "not clever" "brain washed" "frog under the well"
@YuffieAogiri
@YuffieAogiri 4 года назад
I can tell he knows nothing about western democratic systems
@yz233
@yz233 4 года назад
this yu is just using other big youtubers to grow his own account by agreeing people like SerpentZA. Simon yu was disgusting when SerpentZA recommended his video(content) to every China hahers.
@bz1138
@bz1138 4 года назад
subscribed his youtube for two days and just unsubscibed. Waste of time.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Maybe Simon Yu is collaborating with serpentza from behind the scenes?
@astroayumi1752
@astroayumi1752 4 года назад
maybe he is being brainwash by his taiwanese wife !
@bz1138
@bz1138 4 года назад
@@astroayumi1752 if she is taiwanese, then he should be shanghainese. If he claim he is chinese, then she should be chinese too.
@mnbr6884
@mnbr6884 4 года назад
I'll have to watch his videos to confirm because based on this interview, he seems a very well-balanced person.
@thevanchung7568
@thevanchung7568 4 года назад
Mr Barrat, I have been enjoying your videos. Simon always said about Huawei transparency, but how about Apple, Face Book?
@台灣三害AITKMTDPP
@台灣三害AITKMTDPP 4 года назад
CIA and NED love this guy 😂
@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863
@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863 4 года назад
@Ben Louis NED are the ones created the riots in HK, they funded, supported and trained those rioters and bring in rioters from ukraine riots
@蓝盾-h9c
@蓝盾-h9c 4 года назад
这上海哥们还是太年轻,对治国的理解有点浅薄。。。14亿人,你代表不了所有人,那么多人连温饱都还是问题,如果把他的出身放到山区农村,你可以问问他想吃饱饭还是想治国。。。
@LinSiCatXXX
@LinSiCatXXX 4 года назад
国家层面的战略决策或者是经济决定本就不是一般人参与做决策的,难道你要一位普通上班族去参与货币政策的制定???
@AmelieZh
@AmelieZh 4 года назад
Lucas Lim 👏🏻👏🏻
@LinSiCatXXX
@LinSiCatXXX 4 года назад
@@AmelieZh 之前貌似看过他的在RU-vid发的视频,没记错是娶了一个台湾老婆,之前有段时间是在台湾发视频
@eric_panshengmou
@eric_panshengmou 4 года назад
没毛病。
@liunoe5966
@liunoe5966 4 года назад
本来不同的民众的诉求都不同,利益可能还是相冲的。大的国家方针,本来就是要长期有利,短期无法避免的有人利益受损。所以可能出现短期的国进民退,但是长远来看,人人都是获利者。要是民生就是人人都参与做决策,那要不内部因为意见分歧崩盘, 要么被几个最大利益既得者的资本团体通过资本手段(媒体控制)玩的团团转。所以普选,选票都是很虚无的东西,人们只看得到“作秀”,我拿什么去信任一个天天出现在媒体上的一张口和一幕场景,就默认觉得他能为我带来改变?很多事情并不能通过改变一个国家领导人就能改变一切,甚至换个人什么也改变不了,选举需要资本,那么他就无法摆脱资本,说到底竞选者也只是个维护资本主要利益的买办而已,他和他们各取所需。
@廣東捕蛙狂魔
@廣東捕蛙狂魔 4 года назад
凭什么公民屁事不懂去参与政府决策,那个家伙竟然还对西方这种虚伪的制度存在幻想,太天真了,政治那么专业的东西给普通人去玩只有等死的份
@mollydang5827
@mollydang5827 4 года назад
Any political regimes have flaws and people will always complain about the governments because governmental decisions and policies can't benefit everyone equally per se. The universal function of government is to sustain social order. Schooling is instrumentalized by the government to construct "model citizens" who show obedience to certain rules and norms. It is implausible to force China to fully implement the exact same Eurocentric model of liberal democracy because it just won't work for China's unique situation. Undoubtedly, more Chinese people are aware of Western democracy due to globalization. Likewise, more Chinese people do realize cons of one-party state, such as limited freedom of expression, censorship and so forth. However, they also clearly know that infusion of Western democracy will merely stir more social chaos and the society will end up being highly divided, what's worse, it can lead to barbarism again. China can spend time figuring out whatever works best for their people at each stage. There are more important issues China need to resolve before buying into the Eurocentric idea of democracy and freedom. For instance, education and juridical systems also need to be transformed more progressively as well. US politicians and media keep downplaying China, demonizing one-party regime and twisting factual information because they might not be able to boss around or "bully" other countries so they deliberately conjure up the doctrine that China's communist ideology will also "invade" the whole world as the economy keeps growing. In fact, they are afraid of impairing the "legitimacy" of white hegemony and post-colonial power structure. Some people denounce China's CCP for a lack of human rights or humanity. Are the rights of African Americans are protected fairly? There is no perfect political regime. In China, CCP has the most power to decide what benefit the nation and people the most. In US, affluent groups use their power to pick the party that can represent their interests the most. Yes, both of them sorta suck, but that's the reality. Some people gain, some people lose and some even sacrifice themselves. Nowadays, human rights, democracy and freedom seem to serve certain political ends.
@Evan-wd7xw
@Evan-wd7xw 4 года назад
👍👍👍
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
China today is currently *at peace and not at war* with any country, since our last major conflict in 1979. Instead of making war, China is building infrastructure like _roads, railways, highways, bridges, tunnels, powerstations, dams, ports, airports,_ etc and investing in developing countries like Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and also African countries like Nigeria, Kenya, Chad, Sudan, Ghana, Mozambique, Tanzania, etc. Whereas the United States is *warmonger* being involved in Gulf War, Iraq War, Afghan War, Libyan War, Syrian War, Yemen War, etc, even in the 21st century. USA is bombing in those Middle Eastern countries and enacting regime change by cutting off their "heads" (Saddam Hussein, Muammar Gaddafi, etc) and then installing their own US puppet governments in place.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby About military spending, China today is currently *at peace and not at war* with any country, since our last major conflict in 1979. Instead of making war, China is building infrastructure like _roads, railways, highways, bridges, tunnels, powerstations, dams, ports, airports,_ etc and investing in developing countries like Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and also African countries like Nigeria, Kenya, Chad, Sudan, Ghana, Mozambique, Tanzania, etc. Whereas the United States is *warmonger* being involved in Gulf War, Iraq War, Afghan War, Libyan War, Syrian War, Yemen War, etc, even in the 21st century. USA is bombing in those Middle Eastern countries and enacting regime change by cutting off their "heads" (Saddam Hussein, Muammar Gaddafi, etc) and then installing their own US puppet governments in place.
@あきやまゆきな
@あきやまゆきな 4 года назад
I would like to be more frank and say that this young man has gradually separated from the Chinese model, which is very bad. This interview absolutely does not represent the views of most Chinese people.
@vincentfu3530
@vincentfu3530 4 года назад
On the contrary, I think this is what most Chinese young people think,because my friends and I agree with most of his opinions,im 40s old by the way.
@徐成-u1r
@徐成-u1r 4 года назад
@@vincentfu3530 我20岁,圈子不同,不认同你。我觉得港独、台独是汉奸,方方是卖国贼。中国走的路是正确的,敬佩习主席!
@3yexQSx
@3yexQSx 4 года назад
I don't like this Simon Yu guy, blocked his video several month before
@wadeabout1856
@wadeabout1856 4 года назад
Me too
@astroayumi1752
@astroayumi1752 4 года назад
may he is too stupid !
@talkfacts100
@talkfacts100 4 года назад
He deletes neutral comments with intention of open discussions in his videos, only leaving comments supporting his views and opinion, pathetic.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Simon Yu claims Chinese people don't wash our hands, but his mother is a doctor yet she doesn't teach her son to wash hands?
@rhubirose2939
@rhubirose2939 4 года назад
Same 😐
@lycorixl2353
@lycorixl2353 4 года назад
不是我地图炮,但是上海这种立场奇奇怪怪的人真的很多,我公司(国企)里,尤其体制内,还是党员,立场特别歪。我想了想,可能越是精致的利己主义者越是入党,然后又把西方那一套学得淋漓尽致吧……
@yuhongli6786
@yuhongli6786 4 года назад
党内很多坏人,投机取巧的人,把党的名声搞臭了。党的建设工作还要努力哦。
@jeromee.crawford6044
@jeromee.crawford6044 4 года назад
Simon, you should remember that China was never a democracy for all its time. If you want to vote or have your so-called"White System" go back to the US. You are a little too young to comprehend the in-depth of your country system. Every country got issues with its system of government but putting the people wellbeing is more beneficial. The current system for China works for them! Thanks for the initiative Lee, even though he's too young to understand.🙂
@rivenmk6871
@rivenmk6871 4 года назад
Fully agree, he should go to Western country to promote his RU-vidr
@danielledumont2349
@danielledumont2349 4 года назад
I don’t think this guy understands China deep enough, it has nothing to do with age to be honest. He’s just traveling too much all around the world instead of domestically. He needs to see more about this country, it’s way wider than the eastern prosperous corner.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Exactly, China has 5000 years of history and is among the world's oldest "continuous" civilization still alive today, whereas other ancient civilizations like Mesopotamia, Rome and Egypt have since succumbed to history. China has witnessed the birth and death of various other nations, the rise and fall of numerous other empires, yet China has survived the violent passage of time to modern times relatively intact, whereas even Rome eventually crumbled. China has always been under the authoritarian rule (and we still are today) of emperors and the imperial court, because that's how China has been successfully governed for millennia. Not all countries have to adopt Western democracy to be successful and China is living proof of this.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@@dawei666 Chinese invented the _Four Great Inventions_ (四大发明) which have greatly influenced the world through their respective areas. _Paper_ and _Printing_ made the transcribing and transmission of knowledge easier. The _Compass_ made navigation easier and dangerous journeys safer and more reliable. And _Gunpowder_ has changed the way modern wars are fought. Yet Westerners made use of Chinese inventions and Chinese don't complain about it.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby Toilet paper (which is in high demand all over the world today) was invented in China. With Chinese invention of paper, came inventions like paper lanterns, paper umbrellas and paper banknote (which made business transactions easier since merchants need not carry around lots of metal coinage and precious stones) Mankind's first aviation was in the form of paper kite, and even hot air balloons were invented in China, and were known as _Sky Lanterns_ (天灯) or _Kongming Lanterns_ (孔明灯) Here is beautiful video of _RISE Lantern Festival_ in Las Vegas, celebrated with Chinese Sky Lanterns. (Suggestion: Watch in HD Fullscreen for best experience) Link: youtube(dot)com/watch?v=SNtwlBbBdb4&t=10
@mengli8432
@mengli8432 4 года назад
I hope to see more Chinese youtubers, but not the ones like Simon. He seems to talk in an adult way, but with a childish mind. He was simplifying the situations in China. Shanghai is one of the most developed part of China, and he was living in the best conditions in China. The development of China is far from enough, and it is very dangerous if any mistakes were made for this country during development. Importantly, very few people know the country enough to make decisions for the people. If he thought that his decision is really important for the country, try to work for the goverment and understand how each decision was made there before judging. Bad decisions were made everywhere, a lot of them were made here in demoncratic countries. In China, you may complain the goverment, and goverment must take the responsibility and improve themselves. In west, as voters, you must take the concequences by yourselves, like what happened in Brexit.
@wisdomcai2925
@wisdomcai2925 4 года назад
Exactly!
@5小-d3z
@5小-d3z 4 года назад
Agree
@asiacuisine4869
@asiacuisine4869 4 года назад
The fact that he is on youtube, despite being Chinese, shows he has his agenda.
@jorryzhu7382
@jorryzhu7382 4 года назад
​@何Bobby You talk in quite odd way. The naive is common in China, the government is more and more confident with the political system, which makes arrest unnecessary.
@jorryzhu7382
@jorryzhu7382 4 года назад
Highly agree with you.
@patrickwong6572
@patrickwong6572 4 года назад
Hey Simon, may i ask a question? Iran is more democratic than Saudi Arabia, why was the former, rather than the later, got sanction from US?
@asiacuisine4869
@asiacuisine4869 4 года назад
Venezuela too. Not to mention Iraq invasion, and countless others in middle-east.
@xelkim9666
@xelkim9666 4 года назад
Anyone who dares to stand in the way of the American hegemony is sanctioned. Iran is the perfect example. Unfortunately not many people understand the reason of it.
@chenbz9795
@chenbz9795 4 года назад
Simon is too stupid to answer you
@m.0829
@m.0829 4 года назад
Watched a couple of his vlogs. Came across as a person very easily influenced like those H.K. youths. Also noticed some of the commenters that patted him like a dog whenever his opinions supported their negative views of China. He's the kind that can be had by those CIA working now in H.K. controlling those young kids.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Simon Yu said that Chinese don't wash our hands, but his mother is a doctor yet she don't teach her son how to wash hands?
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby It's not that Simon Yu criticising China is wrong, its just that he doesn't explain how exactly is democracy better, he just insist that it is without explaining why.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby He needs to explain why he thinks allowing ordinary people to participate in political decision-making is a good idea. Ordinary people are fickle and they make poor voters for several reasons: -Ordinary people may not vote responsibly (i.e. They may not turn up to vote, or they submit blank votes) -Ordinary people may base their vote on emotions, not logic (i.e. Many British don't like immigrants, so majority voted for Brexit) -Ordinary people are susceptible to foreign influences (i.e. Russian interference in US elections) -Ordinary people may simply lack awareness of the country's real political situation, to make informed decisions regarding the country's future. There's a host of other problems associated with democracy, so why not let those who know how to govern, govern? That's what China is doing and look at how successful China is.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby China is home to *world's largest highspeed railway network,* surpassing even Japan's _Shinkansen_ hi-speed rail in terms of track length. Our high-speed trains are world class, the journeys very smooth and enjoyable. Passengers have even experimented by balanced small objects like coins, stationery and smartphones on their edges in a train traveling at 350 kph, and the objects remain undisturbed (even stagnant water remains still) for long period of time. Video: _Watch how long coin can balance on high-speed train traveling at 350 kph_ Link: youtube(dot)/watch?v=fumYdO9XknE Prior to the advent of high speed rail, during the Spring Festival, people in China would make the trip back to our home province to spend the new years with family and friends and the journey would often take several days. But thanks to China's high-speed rail, the commuting times have been cut short, from *days to mere hours.* _Countries by high-speed rail lines in operation_ *1. China (38,207 km)* 2. Spain (5,525 km) 3. Germany (4,692 km) 4. France (3,802 km) 5. Japan (3,421 km) 6. Sweden (2,055 km) 7. United Kingdom (1,757 km) ... Source: _Wikipedia List of high-speed railway lines_
@vivien622
@vivien622 4 года назад
maybe he's shitting on china for the adcents. Being anti- china on youtube will definitely earn you a lot more money than saying positive things about China.
@noahsuo5071
@noahsuo5071 4 года назад
It was Socrates who was voted to death. The people at the bottom simply do not have the capacity to make decisions for the country. The most powerful person in China is the National People's Congress, not the Chinese Communist Party. The National People's Congress has the right to consider government reports, amend the Constitution, appoint and remove the President of the State, etc.
@myfirstmylastusa
@myfirstmylastusa 4 года назад
“The people at the bottom simply do not have the capacity to make the decisions for the country”. So dictatorship is what every country in the world needs? People at the bottom rung of the society deserve to be ignored?
@moulion
@moulion 4 года назад
@@myfirstmylastusa Not dictatorship. Also not politicians who make empty promises to voters. But educated representatives of the people.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@@myfirstmylastusa About people at the bottom, what makes you think ordinary people participating in political decision-making is a wise idea? Ordinary people are fickle and they make *poor voters* for several reasons: -Ordinary people may not vote responsibly (i.e. They may not turn up to vote, or they submit blank votes) -Ordinary people may base their vote on emotions, not logic (i.e. Many British don't like immigrants, so majority voted for Brexit) -Ordinary people are susceptible to foreign influences (i.e. Russian interference in US elections) -Ordinary people may simply lack awareness of the country's real political situation, to make informed decisions regarding the country's future. There's a host of other problems associated with democracy, so why not let those who know how to govern, govern? That's what China is doing and look at how successful China is.
@lchmann65
@lchmann65 4 года назад
@@myfirstmylastusa The bottom rung of society is equally represented via their provincial governors. Btw they are serveral opposition parties within the congress!
@myfirstmylastusa
@myfirstmylastusa 4 года назад
@YodaGrammar l how do you decide who is eligible to get their voices heard? Don’t citizens of a country all have equal rights to be heard?
@sinas8414
@sinas8414 4 года назад
This guy Simon Yu is the sort as SerpentZA, he does not represent us Chinese. Out of all people you picked this guy, I give a thumb down.
@xTMagnumPi
@xTMagnumPi 4 года назад
They're friends. Serpent sent his idiot watchers to this guy's channel a few months ago.
@jyashin
@jyashin 4 года назад
@@xTMagnumPi Months? It was at least a year ago. When Simon first started his channel his comment section was FILLED with people saying "Found your video off Serpentza, love it!" yadda yadda.
@kevintin3739
@kevintin3739 4 года назад
This buddy lives in his imagination of Western society. Even in the current epidemic situation sweeping the world, he still has not given up his illusion of Western democratic society. Perhaps his Taiwanese girlfriend has a great influence.
@wujianzhu7881
@wujianzhu7881 4 года назад
But when I see those interviews of those Taiwan youths they are verry ignorant about China they are verry misinformed
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Taiwan had been under authoritarian single-party KMT rule for *more than half its life.* For decades the KMT ruled Taiwan with iron fist and Chiang kai-shek was a dictator who jailed and executed dissidents and political rivals (whether real or perceived) in a period known as _White Terror_ (白色恐怖) and imposed martial law on Taiwan for more than *38 years,* which was qualified as "the longest imposition of martial law by a regime anywhere in the world" at that time. Source: _Wikipedia: White Terror (Taiwan)_ But under authoritarian single-party KMT rule, Taiwan actually flourished and prospered, in what's known as the _Taiwan Miracle_ (台湾奇迹). Between 1952 - 1982, Taiwan's economic growth was on average 8.7%, and between 1983 - 1986 at 6.9%. Taiwan GDP grew by 360% between 1965 - 1986. The percentage of global exports was over 2% in 1986, over other recently industrialized countries, and the global industrial production output grew a further 680% between 1965 - 1986. And its all been achieved under KMT leadership. Source: _Taiwan Miracle_ Only in the late 1990s, when democracy was introduced (because USA threatened to cut off weapons sales to Taiwan) did Taiwan's economic growth became more modest. Since Taiwan was doing well under authoritarian KMT rule, why switch to democracy then?
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby If you look at democracy, democracy has a *long history of failure.* Athenian democracy failed, Spartans democracy failed, Greek democracy failed, even Republic of Rome eventually failed. These proto-democracies weren't successful and democracy wasn't even popular outside of Greece among ancient countries. Modern Western liberal democracy only has about 100-200 years of history and is not guaranteed to be successful in the long run. Historically, most of the world adopted some form of authoritarian/oligarchic political system, in which political power is not in the hands of many, but in the hands of the few elites like nobles (aristocracy), priests (theocracy) or kings and emperors (monarchy). Such political systems were dominant because they were stable and simply because they worked. The elites were often well-educated enough to make political decisions that influence the country's future, while the ignorant masses were kept far away from politics. History is telling us that democracy is an abnormality, that human society has actually been authoritarian for much of history.
@yuglu4055
@yuglu4055 4 года назад
中国在发展, 但是我不管,我就是要投票我就是要参政。 考公务员啊,沙雕! 不然就用好自己的基础票。
@美帝国主义
@美帝国主义 4 года назад
参政有啥好的,无丝竹之乱耳,无案牍之劳形不好么
@caocao8000
@caocao8000 4 года назад
@@美帝国主义 每次看到这些说法,他们要求选票,但是选票的价值问题没人谈过,说实话,术业有专攻,你让一个画画的去投票科研建设方向,我觉得这票就完全没有体现它的价值,不应该让专业的人来解决专业的事嘛?人民负责监督,而不是让所有人都去投票,投那些自己一辈子可能都接触不到的专业领域决策。就像美国人大部分人不了解中国,让他们投票选出一个针对中国政府的领导,他们真的知道自己做了什么嘛?
@dimelo3027
@dimelo3027 4 года назад
​@@caocao8000 强奸犯的一票=诺贝尔奖得主的一票。你可以说很公平,也可以说很不公平。公不公平也好,绝对是不合乎常理。应该说不合乎物理。
@yuhongli6786
@yuhongli6786 4 года назад
可以投票的,每当选举的时候,社区到处找人作选民登记。体制外的人参加的人少,大家都相信政府。
@shuzhenzhou2119
@shuzhenzhou2119 3 года назад
说到政治议题大部分广东人都不感兴趣他们只关心今天能不能挣钱,那里流行一句话…早三两,晩三两不管谁来当首长。意思就是不管谁来管理只要你能让我们过上好生活有钱挣就行。九十年代曾经来了个省委书记不了解广东情况,来了今天不准这个明天不准那个搞得大家烦死了,最后齐心协力给他上了点眼药沒过多久上面把他收回去了😂😂
@junessch
@junessch 4 года назад
Simon Yu understanding of the west is simply superficial, completely wasting of time listening to him lol
@leehk4425
@leehk4425 4 года назад
Can't agree more. This Simon Yu is simply a fan of hypocrites. He is proud of his English oral ability more than his identity. What a pity.
@csgs2301
@csgs2301 4 года назад
strongly agree
@floydhuang220
@floydhuang220 4 года назад
Totally agree with you.
@LinSiCatXXX
@LinSiCatXXX 4 года назад
无语,如果要去参与到中华振兴的进程,Simon你可以去考公务员呀,可以去参政呀,不忘初心去完成你想要改变的东西呀,别跟我说这太难了,如果你有这样的想法,我鄙视你
@mori1894
@mori1894 4 года назад
就是啥都想要啥都不想付出。他不是在双标吗,要那样说不定中国都没了。
@LinSiCatXXX
@LinSiCatXXX 4 года назад
@@mori1894 这个应该就是缺乏独立思考的年轻人,只想耍嘴炮,不想干点实事
@张张老师-x4l
@张张老师-x4l 4 года назад
人家吧妈有钱啊!平常人没谈都为柴米油盐奔波!哪有时间管那些!典型的公知!什么都不懂!只看表面!深
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
他哪有那个能力,和他老婆回诈骗岛投奔菜菜子anti china倒是可以
@chenbz9795
@chenbz9795 4 года назад
只想通过油管赚钱的一个大傻逼,和香港的废青差不多了
@huangsam598
@huangsam598 4 года назад
Hope we can talk next time, I am located in shenzhen, I travel many places in the world than this guy! I have total different opinions with this guy!
@BarrettYT
@BarrettYT 4 года назад
Okay, Great, Please get in touch, our email is leejbchina "at" outlook.com
@likang3842
@likang3842 2 года назад
@@BarrettYT hi you can interview more people on this topic so u can get different view
@talkfacts100
@talkfacts100 4 года назад
Now everyone finally sees how ppl see Simon, on his comment section in his own channel he leaves most comments with pro Simons view and deletes most neutral and most, if not all anti Simon point of view comments. I hope Simon grows up and stops censoring his comment section.
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby China is home to *world's largest highspeed railway network,* surpassing even Japan's _Shinkansen_ hi-speed rail in terms of track length. Our high-speed trains are world class, the journeys very smooth and enjoyable. Passengers have even experimented by balanced small objects like coins, stationery and smartphones on their edges in a train traveling at 350 kph, and the objects remain undisturbed (even stagnant water remains still) for long period of time. Prior to the advent of high speed rail, during the Spring Festival, people in China would make the trip back to our home province to spend the new years with family and friends and the journey would often take several days. But thanks to China's high-speed rail, the commuting times have been cut short, from *days to mere hours.* _Countries by high-speed rail lines in operation_ *1. China (38,207 km)* 2. Spain (5,525 km) 3. Germany (4,692 km) 4. France (3,802 km) 5. Japan (3,421 km) 6. Sweden (2,055 km) 7. United Kingdom (1,757 km) ... Source: _Wikipedia: List of high-speed railway lines_ Video: _Watch how long coin can balance on high-speed train traveling at 350 kph_ Link: youtube(dot)com/watch?v=fumYdO9XknE
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
@何Bobby Huawei has unveiled its new Kirin 990 chipset, the *world's first 5G-integrated chipset,* at the IFA (Internationale Funkausstellung Berlin) 2019 in Berlin. _The Kirin 990 series includes two models, the Kirin 990 and the Kirin 990 5G. The Kirin 990 5G is the smallest and one of the most energy-efficient 5G mobile phone chips in the industry._ Video: _Huawei introduces Kirin 990, the world's first 5G-integrated chipset_ Link: youtube(dot)com/watch?v=TNKtG3t22Po
@sabinereynaudsf
@sabinereynaudsf 2 года назад
Speak for yourself. Sounds like only the wumaos get to use VPN's. And they are so busy here shooting down the slightest criticism of the regime. Why aren't you more grown up and start being able to look at things honestly.
@chonshinlim6668
@chonshinlim6668 4 года назад
The more this Yu babble on, the more we see the contrast of experience and wisdom between him and the much matured and well-seasoned Barrett.
@tommylow9293
@tommylow9293 4 года назад
I had seen Simon's video before and I don't enjoy it a little bit. If you listen to his comments here, you see he have got a very narrow view and he sees things in a linear perspective in terms of how the world should progress, ie: he sees the West defined as the 'progressive' 'developed' ones while China and the rest are not as good yet. He don't think that maybe, perhaps, there are 2 ways of doing things....never did it crosses his mind that perhaps, the Western way of managing a country, isn't the best... Many times you see Lee have a differing views and he says he agree that China have good infrastructure, improve no more thieves or whatever, but in the end, he still sees that Western ways is better. It totally makes no sense to say he agrees China have no more thieves and things improves, while in UK there are thieves (which I had personally seen one stealing things in a Pret a Manger before), and yet in Simon's view UK have a better system and it is a developed country and China should become like the UK. Makes no sense at all. And then the last part, about Huawei, you see, Simon was counter by Lee that all those things he talks about how Huawei not transparent and it's causing anxiety to the West, but it never crosses his mind that the West are being hypocrite. Instead he was kinda like saying....yea, I know the west do that (spying by tech company) too, but you know, it was different, it was the West. West should be entitled to do that, you know, they spy for the good, China spying (even though there weren't any proven) is bad, bad for people, because it's China, we are no good, we have not reach the West standards yet so our spying is bad. He might be the victim of western media, and I have absolutely no interest to hear Western CIA propaganda being repeated in my ears. So I'm not following Simon's channel.
@elodiet6953
@elodiet6953 4 года назад
You found the wrong guy to discuss this topic! You should get someone having more knowledge and macro observation like Zhang Weiwei
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
Professor Zhang Weiwei is the one of the best spokesperson for China's political system. He's been to many democracies all over the world and observed it's effects. It's a real pleasure to listen Prof Zhang express his views.
@elsawang3470
@elsawang3470 4 года назад
Agreed, You found the wrong guy!
@tuskinekinase
@tuskinekinase 4 года назад
Then there's probably no debate anymore, because "great minds think alike"!
@Moonlights_scented
@Moonlights_scented 4 года назад
They don’t have the connection to find Professor Zhang.
@lchmann65
@lchmann65 4 года назад
No. He actually found the right guy... exposing Simon's mis-information from western propaganda. Good work! Thanks for the exposure!
@MrWiwen
@MrWiwen 4 года назад
I was young before, young guys actually are not aware that their thinking is not mature enough, they do want to be heroes and dream about decision power over everything without any fear of fail! But when u reach the age around 40 , u will know that you are not that excellent to take those responsibilities with the consequences. Giving the political power to amateur people is a crime.
@asiacuisine4869
@asiacuisine4869 4 года назад
Agree. Same here. Our political views are mostly idealistic and not realistic, until one reaches abt 40.
@spotato
@spotato 4 года назад
四十而不惑!
@eugenechin2863
@eugenechin2863 4 года назад
@Jacob Mwlic LoL so true. When you young you think you know everything and think you are a pro in everything. Once you get older, experience more stuff, you will then know what you are really capable off. A lot of it is also due to maturity in your thinking. I do feel much smarter now than when i was younger..lol
@ericchen5678
@ericchen5678 4 года назад
I don't like this person,what he said is too one-sided,he doesn't understand China and western countries At all.
@davidwong3652
@davidwong3652 4 года назад
This video clearly show people in China can criticize and point out flaws in their government, without being arrested or disappear.
@crzer07
@crzer07 4 года назад
Simon Yu the most objective/neutral Chinese person because he also talk about the bad of China. If so, why his target audience mostly anti-Chinese?
@mantapdjiwa9768
@mantapdjiwa9768 4 года назад
He is anti-china
@Jeffreyuk
@Jeffreyuk 4 года назад
Not necessarily. He might sincerely hope China gets better in all ways but his view has been significantly influenced/brainwashed by the west. What I can see from him is innocent and naive but not evil unless he performed so well lol
@jyashin
@jyashin 4 года назад
@@Jeffreyuk If he hopes China gets better, he's certainly doing it is a VERY strange way. If he's truly pro-China, he should understand fully just how rampant the gongzhi had their way back in the 2000s. He should understand fully how bad the anti-China rhetoric is outside the Chinese firewall. Veteran Leon (a Shanghai youtuber) explained it best. "With my knowledge of the PAP, if I wanted to talk smack about China do you think it would be hard for me to get over 140,000 subscribers? Even Cat-eyes, who just regurgitates the same information we see all the time from the Gongzhi, has 70,000 subscribers." I truly doubt Simon actually wants China to get better.
@qinyin9147
@qinyin9147 3 года назад
他看事情太表面 太浅
@eric_panshengmou
@eric_panshengmou 4 года назад
Unfortunately, this young man's perspective on the problem is not comprehensive enough. Like the young people who marched on Tiananmen Square in 1989, he did not make judgments based on China's actual conditions.
@liunoe5966
@liunoe5966 4 года назад
@Hayley Rule haha
@hefeiyang9452
@hefeiyang9452 4 года назад
@Hayley Rule Another difference is, Simon didn't hang any PLA and burning them alive.
@mori1894
@mori1894 4 года назад
Simon just have it in mind that all aspects of the US is advanced. He wants to live a life that the US recognized as 'good'.
@mori1894
@mori1894 4 года назад
我想说Simon的想法完全就是老一套被灌输的那种,他很多回答不用看都知道他会怎么说,就是标准的西式答案。 给我的感觉像是他用西方的报纸和他所能(只想)接触到的资料,没有额外的思考,像做题一样只揣摩出题人的意图得到出题人想要的答案。
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
@@mori1894 真实。
@mori1894
@mori1894 4 года назад
而且他说的话也没有支撑,就是标准的西方刻板印象。什么是对什么是错,当然是西方说什么就是什么了。先问是不是,再看要不要改。
@hongyin2637
@hongyin2637 4 года назад
CLV Jesse 完全就是你说的这样。不知道,这是他被洗脑了(真的坚信就是这样),还是不自信(想说一个取悦于西方主流思想的答案,以免露怯)。
@weichia8456
@weichia8456 4 года назад
Before sustaining most of people’s lives and transiting from poverty to wealth, it’s waste of time to talk about democracy, more precisely, it’s voting right for each individual. Look at the surrounding countries, India , Philippines...voting power doesn’t guarantee you essential needs of life, disallocation of resource results in bigger economical gap between people, the richer get richer, the poorer get poorer. For pushing massive infrastructures nation wide, a strong one -party government has better advantage. Bipartisan countries have so much conflicts and interest involved, most plans would be delayed, postponed for years as political parties fight each other’s. These issues simply cannot be solved by voting rights from people. It’s tricky to liberate your political involvement or to liberate your economy to enhance your quality of life.
@realdeal7530
@realdeal7530 4 года назад
Wei Chia ... True. India and the Philippines have big problems, but some of China's other neighbours such as Japan, South Korea and Taiwan have done incredibly well under democratic systems. They are fully developed democracies where a large percentage of citizens can earn salaries comparable to the west. In fact the average salary in Japan is higher than in some western countries. The average annual salary in both Japan and South Korea is around 37,800 US dollars ... Japan has the strongest passport in the world, and 90% of Japanese people are considered to be middle class. It is an incredibly successful democratic country with world class infrastructure. ... Yes, democracy can fail (India, Philippines), but it can also be very successful (Japan, South Korea) ... One party systems can also fail (North Korea, Vietnam), but they can also be successful (China). It's easy for us to point fingers at a particular style of political system as the reason for its success or failure, but a country's performance is more closely related to the competence, or otherwise, of its leaders ... and of course the work ethic of its citizens.
@jacqtang1933
@jacqtang1933 4 года назад
😂😂😂This Chinese guy made me thinking of the brainwashed protesters & rioters in hk...west is always the best, the superior. He got potential to be one of those so called HKers😏
@hendrayutub
@hendrayutub 4 года назад
Naive, I kinda waste my time watching this 😑
@August-hc9ke
@August-hc9ke 4 года назад
Simon Yu, he tends to think once all people get evolved into something(voting), all things can be better solved. Really?? Look at Donald Trump in the US, Boris Johnson in the UK.
@AmelieZh
@AmelieZh 4 года назад
A N just look at Tsai . Enough said!!!!
@hendrayutub
@hendrayutub 4 года назад
@@August-hc9ke there's no perfect system in this world. US have democracy but lack meritocracy, China have meritocracy but lack democracy. Country that can adapt its political system to cater its people's needs is always the best that's why in general people live happily in China than in America. America is evolving too but unfortunately it cater only its top 1% need that's why in essence America's political system is no longer democracy but Plutocracy. Simon Yu due to his young age lacks geopolitical comprehension that's why many of his comments are naive. Given time, he will be better.
@楊錦嫦
@楊錦嫦 4 года назад
Simon Yu can you imagine if everyone in China have a voice in deciding how government should run , I think if you are interested you should go work in the government.
@liunoe5966
@liunoe5966 4 года назад
他能力不够,就嘴巴行。这些人很多
@mollydang5827
@mollydang5827 4 года назад
I think he is not familiar with the tricks in Western politics lol
@mnbr6884
@mnbr6884 4 года назад
I don't think you understand how constitutional democracies work.
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
Obviously he has no ability to work for the government. Maybe he can go to Taiwan with his wife. DPP likes banana man
@Shenzhou.
@Shenzhou. 4 года назад
他父母让他学英文,就被西方媒体洗脑了。 _His parents let him study English, but he gotten brainwashed by Western media._
@donecheung6104
@donecheung6104 4 года назад
😅CIA需要这个yellow guy
@AmelieZh
@AmelieZh 4 года назад
done cheung 然后光复中国吗?哈哈
@zhanyuxie7869
@zhanyuxie7869 3 года назад
我也不知道是不是看了视频的中国人里面只有我这么想,反正这个Simon我怎么听怎么觉着哪不对劲,我以前在ins上看到他有一个post说什么很多中国人包括他自己的一些长辈都不想要民主(英文如果直接翻译过来差不多这意思)然后看他后面说的 感觉他对民主的理解是比较狭隘,
@jillkoop5682
@jillkoop5682 4 года назад
Very good discussion/interview. I really love Simon Yu. I think I found him because he did a video with SerpentZA back a while ago. Simon, to me, is a very smart young man wise beyond his years! I hope he goes far in the youtube world and he is, most definitely, a credit to his country and his generation.❤ Good luck, Simon. I feel a bit smarter after subscribing to your channel! I am more than just a little impressed!!!
@michaellaw3732
@michaellaw3732 4 года назад
Simon have a master degree from US and returned to China. He think his education background is better than the government local officials. His limited experience restricted his scope of thinking. This happened for all young generation. People don't aware that many government officials studied abroad or trained by Howard University professors.
@stephwliu
@stephwliu 4 года назад
Harvard university?
@Jeffreyuk
@Jeffreyuk 4 года назад
Don't usually comment here but I have to say I am really happy to see that Simon joined to the talk although I have largely opposite opinion about his view. It's vital to communicate with people with different options and background who may get information in different sources and view the world very different from you. No matter if you agree with each other or not the more communication both ways, the better world.
@freedomofriot5006
@freedomofriot5006 4 года назад
simon yu is no differnt from serpentza and laowy86.
@wadeabout1856
@wadeabout1856 4 года назад
Agree!
@erwinlee2842
@erwinlee2842 4 года назад
Different, Simon is Chinese. Serpentza is not.
@lloydglyn6831
@lloydglyn6831 4 года назад
A great video a really interesting perspective thanks to your friend wishbhim well.
@兰花豆-d2y
@兰花豆-d2y 4 года назад
视频开头我感觉好像见过这个人,有一点印象。慢慢想起我曾经看过Simon Yu的视频,后来我把他的频道拉黑了,因为我非常不认同他的看法
@Sophia-0502
@Sophia-0502 3 года назад
非常棒的交流。大家都尽量客观的表达对方方面面事物的看法。希望多点这样的视频哦。点赞!
@qiupengzheng1056
@qiupengzheng1056 4 года назад
I think Simon is ignorance. I was born in a very poor village of north China. I have to say that China has improved a lot in both politics and economy. By working hard, I have a chance to go to the University and buy an apartment in Shanghai. Shanghai gives me great opportunities to do what I to do regardless where I came from. That is true freedom. But Simon seem to hold a dangerous perspective, if Chinese do as Westerns do, Westerns will appreciate us. That indeed put cart before the horse. In this pandemic, even after the lockdown of Wuhan, Westerns still hold the opinion that it is not transparent in China. Incapable Trump government doesn’t think he should take any responsibility. In China, we don’t have so bad government like Trump government. Even after 10,000 people died in America, Trump pretend to care about Hong kong. I believe Chinese can earn other respects by doing our work well. Westerns only respect us because what we accomplish.
@ddng.private
@ddng.private 4 года назад
I won't comment on Simon's perspective because he has right to think in his way. But I will praise Barrett. You definitely made many thorough research to see the advantages and disadvantages of two systems. I appreciate it
@landingba4604
@landingba4604 4 года назад
People can't help government to make the decisions unless most people have high level education!!!!!!! So this Chinese guy wants to take part in the government work is understandable! But it's not now! In other word, if he wants to be a member of government, he could take part in the exam! Don't complain! I don't want to see some stupid people vote for some important things
@hehexie5092
@hehexie5092 4 года назад
中国的公务员考试太难了,几千个人竞争一个职位,笔试面试下来都得脱层皮
@michaelking7641
@michaelking7641 4 года назад
hehe xie That is why it is necessary: chose the best candidate to run the country, right?
@anson1l
@anson1l 4 года назад
@@hehexie5092 hard doesn't mean impossible. Or do you just want to enjoy free lunch? Sorry, you are not lucky enough.
@raychoi33
@raychoi33 4 года назад
Barrett, so glad to have western friend like you who knows and appreciate China better then a local Chinese . China has its problems just like many other countries but lifting millions out of extreme poverty is a significant achievement for the humankind . Young Simon should have a bit of appreciation to his motherland
@sheah1239
@sheah1239 4 года назад
He is too subjective, apparently influenced by western media and his Taiwanese wife. He yearned for freedom, but he did not realize that there was no such thing as absolute freedom. Look at the way the police treated protesters in "free" America.
@westni9611
@westni9611 4 года назад
Simon is like other guys who think they know so much, but in reality, their knowledge is quite limited. Just like Simon, he thought too high himself. He has no idea at all how Chinese governments make decisions. There are public surveys, local representatives meetings, public hearings for all major decisions. He just didn't do his research how to be part of it, just too lazy to do more studies. There are numerous channels to give opinions to the government, if you are really passionate about public governance, just do it. Don't be lazy, especially if you want to give valuable suggestions to the government, you can't be lazy, you need to study in so many aspects to give one suggestion. Public governance is a serious business, OK? Not kiddy game.
@helenc1051
@helenc1051 4 года назад
Please don’t pick up the wrong person to interview, I love your program don’t let them damage it ... Best regards from Australia and if I am in Shanghai also you & your son I love to taking you both for dining out 😊🙏🏻👌
@johnhuan1
@johnhuan1 3 года назад
This is a proper intellectual discussion. Very informative. Thank you both!
@asahiglass
@asahiglass 4 года назад
WTH, Chinese doing only RU-vid not doing any Chinese platform, that show what is Simon target audiences are!! To be honest I never watch him, but by the 1st minute of this interview I kinda know what his content are.... feel free to correct me, but I don’t think I’m gonna give his channel a try!!
@kitchau2380
@kitchau2380 4 года назад
Your guest seems to understand China and the West very well pointing out the advantages and disadvantages of both systems. Very good interview! 👍👍👍
@yipcheong
@yipcheong 4 года назад
This dude should migrate to the west since he loves freedom to talk in the west but I just wonder why he comes back to China?
@jorryzhu7382
@jorryzhu7382 4 года назад
He should move with his wife to Taiwan.
@realdeal7530
@realdeal7530 4 года назад
He obviously chose to live in China as he prefers it. If he loved the US so much, I'm sure he would've stayed there. He has a masters degree and can speak English, so he would've found opportunities to stay in the US, or even move to Taiwan with his wife, but it seems he prefers Shanghai ... Sure he has some criticisms of China, but he is certainly no Joshua Wong or Jimmy Lai.
@bejantabani5635
@bejantabani5635 4 года назад
This is one of the best interview l have seen in my whole 50 years of life. I am an African living in the Netherlands. Keep up the good work man. The world is watching !!
@TAIWAN_PROVINCE_CHINA
@TAIWAN_PROVINCE_CHINA 4 года назад
他是Serpentza 的关门弟子,南非蛇在诋毁完中国大陆,献媚完台湾后,极力推荐了他。称他这种人才是中国的未来!
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
At the beginning of the video, he said he made the video to let the world know about China and that he was a liar. Taiwan is an island of swindle, where swindlers marry swindlers
@trekpac2
@trekpac2 4 года назад
Wow, two of my favorite guys doing a video together. This was very informative and I much appreciate it. You fellows are doing a great job in helping people around the world understand the real China.
@janzhao7974
@janzhao7974 4 года назад
This guy can not represent the views of the Chinese people
@leechee5580
@leechee5580 4 года назад
Wow this is a so well-made video. We need more like this instead of videos spreading rumor, bias and hate to get more clicks. thank you barret.
@BarrettYT
@BarrettYT 4 года назад
Thank you, appreciate that..
@baorichard4345
@baorichard4345 4 года назад
We still have red book today, but now it's an app called 小红书 .lol
@ismaelmasso6662
@ismaelmasso6662 4 года назад
Very sensible conversation about topics we heard about in a manipulated and subjective way in the Western Media. I believe the media seeks for impactful stories that creates sides and separation, so they use any country that does not follow a Western style democracy to elaborate messages of condemnation that promote narrow-mindness. We must understand that different cultures evolve differently, respect, and accept each nation's developmental stages, instead of falling into unfounded petty criticism. Keep making these videos, I am addicted now!
@ciusingwong3258
@ciusingwong3258 4 года назад
If you ask me to participate in national policy making, then I would say it is just like you are asking a bus driver to teach high school student math knowledge,
@SophiaLegro
@SophiaLegro 3 года назад
One year is a long time. So many things changed completely!
@tommyj6289
@tommyj6289 4 года назад
Simon Yu is a friend of serpentza. He always share this guys video
@trevorphillips5786
@trevorphillips5786 4 года назад
A balanced interview without political dogma. Very good
@siyuanzuo3750
@siyuanzuo3750 4 года назад
Thank you for exposing him.
@AmelieZh
@AmelieZh 4 года назад
Siyuan zuo lol。I like this word
@Sanii3845
@Sanii3845 3 года назад
I love it when you do collaboration videos
@unifieddynasty
@unifieddynasty 4 года назад
Simon represents the upper-middle-class neoliberal demographic in China. Like upper-middle-class neoliberals in any country, they are a small but vocal demographic. As much as SImon may be accurate to varying extents on the various issues discussed, his views are nonetheless not representative of the "average" Chinese person.
@unifieddynasty
@unifieddynasty 4 года назад
That said, I probably agree more with Simon than I disagree with him, and this was an excellent conversation.
@jennifercjensen
@jennifercjensen 4 года назад
It was a very interesting debate to hear both sides.
@小米媽媽
@小米媽媽 4 года назад
This Mr. Simon's wife is Taiwanese! !
@yokaxi1011
@yokaxi1011 4 года назад
he is a liar. Taiwan is an island of swindle, where swindlers marry swindlers
@namelessbutalive6903
@namelessbutalive6903 4 года назад
Hi! I’ve been watching your videos for a while now, thanks for the quality content you’re bringing us. If you see this comment, do you think it’s possible to make a video in future about the anti-China RU-vidrs like laowhy86? What do you think about them and their views? Thank you and keep up the great work!
@BlissBliss123
@BlissBliss123 4 года назад
Simon's view in the US is apparently in the honeymoon period. Not a fan of his view at all.
@stonetrouble5053
@stonetrouble5053 4 года назад
The RU-vid post is the new standard of freedom in Western Liberal Democracy. Few of its Eastern admirers notice Western Democracy’s scorn for the truth, its gerrymandered elections, its voter suppression, its mass incarceration, its endless wars, its total disinterest in you, your future, anything about you, anything about your country, or any concern for the survival of humankind. Simon, you only think of one word “freedom” and imagine, “My wonderful voice will be heard! Then the world will change!” The voice of the hero! The ignornt disconnected savior. Simon, this is not democracy, but narcissism. It will change nothing.
Далее
skibidi toilet multiverse 042 Trailer
01:57
Просмотров 2,8 млн
The 'Game On' Debate | The West Wing
9:16
Просмотров 486 тыс.
Kubernetes 101 workshop - complete hands-on
3:56:03
Просмотров 1,6 млн