Despite huge PR push, is US plan for Gaza doomed to fail? | The Bottom Line

Подписаться 14 млн

Просмотров 54 тыс.

50% 1

How “permanent” is the US/Israeli plan for a “permanent ceasefire” in Gaza? The intentional vagueness of the proposal to bring a “sustainable period of calm” to the Gaza Strip is the biggest obstacle preventing a deal, argues Michael Hanna of the International Crisis Group.
Hanna tells host Steve Clemons that the governments mediating between Israel and Hamas have given the latter “private assurances” that are not mentioned in writing.
This, coupled with the belligerent public statements of Israeli leaders and epic levels of mistrust among all sides, is ruining chances for an end to the catastrophic war in Gaza, says Hanna.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#palestine #israel #israelhamaswar #aljazeeraenglish #gaza

Опубликовано:

15 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 329

@oceanwave4502 9 дней назад

The US is buying time for Israel to finish its plan. All the dramas, e.g. ceasefire, we have seen are just a show for public.

@lookbovine 9 дней назад

The U.S. government and military knows Israel’s plan (overt and covert) is unachievable.

@jake751 9 дней назад

Do they honestly think that they will be allowed to do that? America is not the super power anymore and hasn't been for years. Just look at joe Biden and he represents what America has become "THE LAUGHING STOCK OF THE WORLD ".

@jgcelliott1 9 дней назад

Hamas has no intention of releasing the hostages. All this talk is certainly a waste of time. Gotta love those crafty word games though. The leaders are soooo clever. .

@mrjojo166 9 дней назад

@@jgcelliott1 what do you think we should invite someone from Austria who was denied admission to solve the problem😂😂

@jgcelliott1 9 дней назад

@@mrjojo166 ... I think if you made any sense, I might have an answer for you. .

@user-vf6nn6hx9x 9 дней назад

They're saying that but recently voted AGAINST a Palestinian state, which is the ONLY way for peace

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

And where would that state be located?

@user-vf6nn6hx9x 9 дней назад

On lands that the Europeans have stolen and occupied

@pattit6530 8 дней назад

@@carrerau7138 for starters isnotreal needs to get completely out of Gaza the Westbank and Jerusalem! Ideally, I think isnotreal needs to go back to Europe, where they came from. They don’t even have the skin for the Middle East.

@abugeorge565 8 дней назад

@@carrerau7138where it always has leave this conversation to the grown ups

@halifaxmoletsane9390 8 дней назад

@carrerau7138 how about you ask your grandparents where did they stole land from Palestinians 😂

@vaclavkubicek2970 9 дней назад

Palestinians need a state recognized by the UN - WITHOUT US VETO

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

Without turning it down u mean. Many times it's been offered

@waheed78666 9 дней назад

No vetoed more then dozen times trice recently even against it. So not sure what offers you speaking of. @@RebeccaPerry-ur9up

@fuckbankers 9 дней назад

Most countries do.

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@RebeccaPerry-ur9up bullshit every time less land !

@halifaxmoletsane9390 8 дней назад

@@RebeccaPerry-ur9up western media condemned ur peanut mind 😂😂

@hassanvlogs3447 9 дней назад

Free Palestine

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

They are free free them from what

@tanjohn3995 9 дней назад

Free from UNRWA Hamas Terrorists organisation oppression

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@RebeccaPerry-ur9up from RACIST TRASH

@abugeorge565 8 дней назад

@@RebeccaPerry-ur9upoccupation silly bat zona genocide supporter

@torvenhartz1002 8 дней назад

Free Palestine from Hamas...

@fuckbankers 9 дней назад

Israel's goal is impossible.

@resurrectedone7463 9 дней назад

Israel's dependence on the United States was stated bluntly by retired IOF Maj. General Yitzehak Brick in an interview: " All of our missiles, the ammunition, the precision-guided bombs, all the airplanes and bombs, it's all from U.S. The minute they turn off the tap, you can't keep fighting. You have no capability, ... Everyone understands that we can't fight this war without the United States. Period"----NOV 27,2023

@DENGODFREY 9 дней назад

We need to turn off the tap- like, yesterday.

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

From USA? You mean Virginia where Israel signed a 6 billion $ defense bill with!? That part , we don't own that, Israel has bought land here and runs weapons manufacturing here . Those aren't ours , they are there's made in Virginia in Thier own factories

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

Signed in 2019 Feb 3 it's on the state website. It was on the News

@husnasmith3058 9 дней назад

Yes, turn off Israel’s water

@mytboss 9 дней назад

Very true! The US made the GENOCIDE of Palestinians by providing Israel the means to do it.

@yeryuzusessizgokyuzumavi9299 8 дней назад

Standing next to you Palestine

@fuckbankers 9 дней назад

This conflict has been going on for 76 years.

@user-bx1lv3rn5d 9 дней назад

I hope more people can stop this war

@zairamansha5228 9 дней назад

No one is talking about the arrest of Nathanyahu

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

Nazis are talking 24/7 about that.

@helenhenthorn4948 8 дней назад

US put the onus on accepting the deal on Hamas knowing it lacked clarity that Hamas would need to ask for guarantees so they could then blame them for derailing the process. This is an old trick they used in the Oslo peace initiative so they could go on to blame Arafat for rejecting a disingenuous and unreasonable offer.

@HijabigirlBydesign 9 дней назад

15,694 children have been killed and 17,000 are without parents after 8 months of Israel’s war on Gaza, let that sink in

@valentinadivina2229 9 дней назад

It's totally unacceptable and unforgivable! ✊✌️💯

@arnoldcalaway1682 9 дней назад

fake

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@arnoldcalaway1682 F R E A K

@torvenhartz1002 8 дней назад

Oh - seems as if you've counted them in person. I wonder who was shooting when the IDF rescued the last four hostages!? Children and women and parents!? And how about the numbers of killed fighters? Why aren't there any numbers? ... Or is it just the same?

@abdinshahkarami2054 8 дней назад

I belive the IDF WILL FACE THE JUSTICES.

@gertstraatenvander4684 9 дней назад

It's meant to fail and then to be blamed on Hamas.

@historyalwayslie 9 дней назад

“You are what you do, not what you say you'll do.” ― Carl Gustav Jung List* of the countries bombed and/or invaded by the U.S from 1950 to 2020: Korea 1950-53 El Salvador 1980s Bosnia 1994, 1995 Cambodia 1969-70 Congo 1964 Cuba 1959-1961 Afghanistan 1998, 2001- Guatemala 1954, 1960, 1967-69 Indonesia 1958 Laos 1964-73 Grenada 1983 Iraq 1991-2000s, 2015- Iran 1987 Korea 1950-53 Kuwait 1991 Lebanon 1983, 1984 Libya 1986, 2011- Nicaragua 1980s Pakistan 2003, 2006- Palestine 2010 Panama 1989 Peru 1965 Somalia 1993, 2007-08, 2010- Sudan 1998 Syria 2014- Vietnam 1961-73 Yemen 2002, 2009- Yugoslavia 1999 Former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger once remarked. "It may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal," And U.S. has proven him right. Time and again, the U.S. has showed that it is not a reliable ally in global affairs.

@AlirezaDakhteh-pv4mb 8 дней назад

And unfortunately there are many many more.

@user-bw8mu6yg8b 9 дней назад

Eid ul Adha mubarak all of you🇵🇸🇵🇸

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

And that's why there's no cease fire right there,this attitude!

@Harleyhogking1974 9 дней назад

@@RebeccaPerry-ur9up What did he say that was so wrong?

@peterbeavis-go9wr 9 дней назад

It looks like Israel is doing America's bidding. Who IS in control of this situation?

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

The IDF.

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@carrerau7138 international diaper force ! TO THE RESCUE

@Findestemps2430 9 дней назад

How can one negotiate with an opponent that wants your total destruction? That really is a non-starter.

@HughCurranAedh 9 дней назад

Is the "opponent" you are referring to, Israel?

@salikamous6418 9 дней назад

0:35

@user-jz9kw1xt9u 9 дней назад

Was the occupation started by negotiation.

@cbs63 9 дней назад

@@user-jz9kw1xt9u when exactly do you think an occupation took place. So many people are parroting something that does not exist.

@Keepthepeacesharethelove 9 дней назад

@@cbs63your are in denial. Every international organisations stated there is an illegal occupation for decades.

@jaypie8 9 дней назад

Project Izzy is over .... Facing the truth is the only way to grow as a person

@user-jz9kw1xt9u 9 дней назад

The occupation still pursuing with its economic plan for Gaza. Real Estate. Google Gaza 2035. Build the Ben Gurion canal and port on Gaza land the alternative route to the Suez canal. Produce oil and gas from Gaza land. Google, Gaza oil and gas.

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

Google it's always been this way. Google when governments do the right thing, it's not possible

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

Yea well palistine people be destroying things they can stay wherever but not USA

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

Why not a big parking lot?

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

1/2 TRILLION off the coast of G A Z A

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@carrerau7138 pave paradise

@user-gk3jm5pr8b 9 дней назад

All these things is basic American foreign secretary Blinken doesn't want to end these conflict as we knows his first trip to Israeli he said I'm not came Israel as American foreign secretary i came here as a Jewish person. So he is the part of the problem.

@user-sc5fy2cw8r 9 дней назад

People are starting to see what happens

@jamiemoj597 9 дней назад

Problem is this is just like the One China Policy and the Minsk Accords where the US boasted about buying time after the event.

@user-bw8mu6yg8b 9 дней назад

Free Free palastine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

@United_Anti-Terrorism_Group 9 дней назад

Who Is Palpatine? Why He Should Be Free? And Why Palpatine Is Jailed?

@tanjohn3995 9 дней назад

Free Palestinians from UNRWA Hamas Terrorists organisation oppression

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@United_Anti-Terrorism_Group what a nerd

@redherring9497 8 дней назад

@@United_Anti-Terrorism_Groupkid brain ⬆️

@user-xb1ep6bs3c 8 дней назад

People all over the world have a common desire, which is to yearn for peace

@jarosawbielski2301 9 дней назад

Don't speak into the ears of a fool, for he will despise the wisdom of your words.

@am-zo5dz 8 дней назад

Words speaks louder than actions

@garysantos7053 9 дней назад

“Useless, confusing, and rambling unintelligible explanation of the facts.”

@zionismisterrorism8716 9 дней назад

BDS!

@user-bx1lv3rn5d 7 дней назад

A terrible war is doomed to no good

@user-kt8bv4bs4y 7 дней назад

War brings great trauma to people.

@rashidbagewadi1006 8 дней назад

Who trusts on great satan's tongue. The world knows the double standards.

@jaypie8 9 дней назад

Historical Palestines freedom fighters... Basically God's children 🙏

@MusiciansWithVision 8 дней назад

When was the last time USA got international policy right? You have your answer!

@user-jz9kw1xt9u 9 дней назад

Palestine existed before Judea and Samaria. David 921 killed Goliath Jalut Palestine King and occupied Palestine. Nebuchadnezzar liberated Palestine. Google, who was Goliath.

@gertstraatenvander4684 9 дней назад

Nope. You do it. Also: bullshit to the max.

@Baci302 9 дней назад

@@gertstraatenvander4684It certainly wasn’t an Israel.

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

😂

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@gertstraatenvander4684 CANAAN DNA FROG

@SannaMcclaren 7 дней назад

America is a panic maker.

@The-Man-Right-Chea 9 дней назад

😢 😮 😢 🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥Does anyone else find it interesting that you cannot spell Israel without the letters L-I-A-R-S 🤔 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

@United_Anti-Terrorism_Group 9 дней назад

Cry For It

@The-Man-Right-Chea 9 дней назад

@Vanussy. Can U or someone please explain to me again why no European nation including the US wanted these people in their country before during and after WWII????? What did they know that we are now finding out???? 🤔

@Keepthepeacesharethelove 9 дней назад

@@United_Anti-Terrorism_GroupCope with it and live with it.

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@United_Anti-Terrorism_Group Vpussy we would never cry for you

@mustansirangoothiwala8656 6 дней назад

Very true

@TrTurkiyeTravel 9 дней назад

Qatar talking about PR stunts is top level Hypocrisy.

@debbieretzlaff2912 День назад

8 days later…nothing has happened!

@back6450 8 дней назад

END THE OCCUPATION AND GET OUT OF GAZA !!!

@buddadavid480 9 дней назад

Free Free Palestine land's 🇵🇸 ♥️ 🙏

@AceZeddex 8 дней назад

Yes.

@GPWGXO 8 дней назад

May world peace never end in war

@snaaz5450 9 дней назад

Hello 🖐️ Steve sir

@jhcsharif85 9 дней назад

First View, Like & Comment.. I Watching from Bangladesh🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩

@geraldmantel4955 9 дней назад

Amerika .... DUH!

@ungratefulninja4535 6 дней назад

Israel has lost the PR war.

@lukasbudiman9116 8 дней назад

🤲🏼 salam from AL QURTHUBI & ATH THABARI 🙏🏼 happy eid adha 😊 .

@JjjYyyy-xl5so 8 дней назад

Несёт ответственность по соседству только Израиль

@anindohassan8498 9 дней назад

2 sovereign state is only solution

@user-xw7tp8jz7k 9 дней назад

Free palastine☝🤲🤲

@bobbythisisgreatthankgodpl5039 9 дней назад

PLEASE STOP 'THIS MAD MAN KILLINGS OF ALL THE IN HOLY FATHER HOLY LAND IN JESUS HOLY NAME JESUS SAVE'S 😢

@Hlth-cn4fh 9 дней назад

Ok, ok, class settle down. Today's word of the day is obedience. Yours. Israel has spoken.

@julio-iz3sk 9 дней назад

wait, is it me or you guys have a problem with semantics? prisoner and hostages to me are different situations. according to Al Jazeera, what is a prisoner and what is a hostage?

@karenshaikh3744 9 дней назад

No hostages POWs is a better term. How many of the captives are Israeli military active or reservists?

@julio-iz3sk 9 дней назад

@karenshaikh3744 POW to me is an enemy combatant of an other army, civilian law. POW is anyone with or without uniform of any age of any religion or non religion that is under Islamic law, this excepts gays, they don’t even make it to prison. A nation of Hope vs a Nation of Martyrs, that is the menu, pick your rooster. since we got a QandA here, what does it mean peace to you?

@gertstraatenvander4684 9 дней назад

Someone who is held without charge is NOT a 'prisoner'. It's either a hostage or a kidnappee.

@julio-iz3sk 9 дней назад

@@gertstraatenvander4684 that is true, everywhere. hostages or kidnapped by the state is a crime. hostages or kidnapped by a religion/state is just the law, right? let’s call them guests

@julio-iz3sk 9 дней назад

@@karenshaikh3744 POW is an enemy combatant, an army, its civilian law. unless, is Islamic Law, everyone is a POW, if you want to put it nicely, let’s call them guests.

@user-ew3mq3jy4y 8 дней назад

❤กลิ่น❤❤มาดาม❤

@masterpassacademy 9 дней назад

🐱

@sagarjeevan9434 9 дней назад

What happened next isral plan iam scared

@user-wq9eg3nm4c 9 дней назад

Me too

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

All Nazis are.

@alienhawkq4690 9 дней назад

In fairness, every plan in the last 1000 years has failed.

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

They have Egypt to ho to they have tunnels being used no one is forced to stay because they can't leave

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

liar !

@uzaukee 8 дней назад

Clueless and ignorant or just plain delusional comment.

@AlirezaDakhteh-pv4mb 8 дней назад

That was Bibis plan all along but it didn’t work so by being stupid he shot him in the foot. And unfortunate for both sides he is stubborn like a mull he won’t move an inch unless it benefits him personally.

@seanfagan8490 8 дней назад

Maybe you should leave and stop being complicit in war crimes

@user-hk2xv5fs4b 9 дней назад

This is what war does

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

not a war , goon a war is between two countries with armies not 4 or 5 countries against a walled in prison population ! BOY BOY

@user-jz4tr5df4v 9 дней назад

We want LGBTQ+ rights in Bangladesh. 🇧🇩🏳️‍🌈🇧🇩

@sheikmuhammad3894 9 дней назад

How about no?

@carrerau7138 9 дней назад

Queers for Palestine?

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@sheikmuhammad3894 get gay !

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@carrerau7138 EFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF YAH

@hiroshi138 9 дней назад

What does the international community not understand about "not negotiating with Hamas"?

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

the world is against israel ! MUTANT

@YvonneKennedy-lu2uc 8 дней назад

What we understand is Israelis are duplicitous,liars,, evil and are occupation force murdering women and children because they want what they are trying to hang onto. But US of Israel want for themselves.

@davidboi4025 9 дней назад

12 Views after 30 min, aljazeera fell off

@cheryllines4106 9 дней назад

Because it's infested with IZ BOTS!!

@Hlth-cn4fh 9 дней назад

@@cheryllines4106 Israel has spoken.

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@Hlth-cn4fh to deaf ears ! FROG

@Hlth-cn4fh 9 дней назад

You were told now you weep. Israel has spoken. Obey and you will be OK.

@petergiaschi35 9 дней назад

"Obey" Who the f**k do you think you are? "Obey"...FU.

@Hlth-cn4fh 9 дней назад

@@petergiaschi35 You were told. Israel has spoken.

@uzaukee 8 дней назад

Troll

@AlirezaDakhteh-pv4mb 8 дней назад

Wow Isn’t this what hitter was saying? Where is all this arrogance coming from? You know you just said the quit part out loud. I don’t blame you because when you live in your own bubble you get to believe your own lies.

@talksmoke1190 9 дней назад

Does this reporter have any hostages in his home

@lookbovine 9 дней назад

Does he look Palestinian? Homes are bombed nonstop so Israel is killing its own hostages…if they’re still in them and not underground at this point. Basically your comment is lame and out of date. Stop posting it.

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

do you freak

@talksmoke1190 8 дней назад

@@lookbovine those so called 300 palestinians were done by the friendly civilians in that neighbourhood. Keep on commenting

@talksmoke1190 8 дней назад

@@roystonmason9125 youre hurting my feelings. I know thats not your intention

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

@@talksmoke1190 no i like being lied to by my government time and time again trillions spent killing millions over YELLOW CAKE WEAPONS of MASS DESTRACTION millions of injured americans and now this PALESTINE Has 25 sq miles left ---------------------------with 1/2 TRILLION is GAS reserves off the gaza shore ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------BILLIONS MORE and we have no healthcare no higher education .......................but arab countries and I S R A E L DO while we live in FILTH

@Hlth-cn4fh 9 дней назад

Israel has spoken.

@rickmartin4886 9 дней назад

It sure has! 🇮🇱 flag will wave free from the Jordan to the Sea.

@AOk-by4pi 9 дней назад

💩🇮🇱💩

@DorothyGoodwin-ug2qo 9 дней назад

dont think so at all it will be 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

@rickmartin4886 9 дней назад

@@DorothyGoodwin-ug2qo

@philipjfry4465 9 дней назад

🤡🤡🤡

@jfern6673 9 дней назад

Hamas did not like the terms of the ceasefire so they rejected it.. No pressure, they can go another 8 months before another try thats fine..

@gertstraatenvander4684 9 дней назад

No. 'Israel' rejectted it, Hamas did not. Biden is gaslighting us.

@user-pw9cx1rd9t 9 дней назад

They would be nuts to settle without a full ceasefire and no one in their right mind would not agree with them based on Israel’s history!!!

@roystonmason9125 8 дней назад

BULLSHIT DWEEB

@RebeccaPerry-ur9up 9 дней назад

Gaza better make a deal before trump gets bk in office

@AlirezaDakhteh-pv4mb 8 дней назад

Bring me one example where trump actually honored a deal even the one that he signed him self. Never is the answer. So you don’t have a winning argument.