Тёмный

Did Depp’s Rebuttal Ruffle the Troubled Couple’s Tussle? | Depp/Heard Case Analysis 

Dr. Todd Grande
Подписаться 1,5 млн
Просмотров 149 тыс.
50% 1

This video answers the question: Can I analyze the testimony of Johnny Depp on Day 22 the Johnny Depp / Amber Heard defamation trial?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
References:
• WATCH LIVE: Johnny Dep...

Опубликовано:

 

25 май 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,8 тыс.   
@audralynn7454
@audralynn7454 2 года назад
🔥🔥"Amber wanted to show the world her true self. Unfortunately for her, she was successful." That was the best comment about this situation 😂 Thank you Dr Grande, I needed a laugh!
@alygodsquad
@alygodsquad 2 года назад
haha I agree that is priceless !
@judis3476
@judis3476 2 года назад
Today, it all came down to Amber’s final minute of testimony on cross examination. After lying over and over, trying to cry and not being able to squeeze out a single tear on Direct… she SAID: “That’s why I wrote the Op Ed”. Previously, she said she didn’t write it herself. Then she said it wasn’t about Johnny because he wasn’t named. She messed up on her lies, and the truth will always find a way. Malice. Case closed.
@barbadosantigua1
@barbadosantigua1 2 года назад
I thought at the beginning of this trial I would sympathise with Amber being a survivor of terrible abuse however I' am in shock at Ambers open lies even when proved she will just ntr accept any wrong doing, its shocking behaviour I believe she is a dangerous person able to manipulate any given situation and it will be her downfall
@ddz1375
@ddz1375 2 года назад
No woman who was in a situation of abuse by their partner would ever crap the bed without without having an Escape Route immediately. And even then the fear of retaliation would be paralyzing and one would never even consider to do such an act. We have lived in fear during and surviving the abuse, never allowed the anger and rage the surface until we were safely away and well-hidden. Even then the anger is not within reach under all of that self depreciation and shame
@Ocrilat
@Ocrilat 2 года назад
Same and same. I'm having flashbacks watching the trial.
@Kalleesto
@Kalleesto 2 года назад
@@ddz1375 I am three years out of an abusive relationship that wasn't physical but had all other aspects of DV. I am still scared of him and being angry at him is just not on the table. Like you say, not even within reach. I remember bein shocked at his response to finally going no contact and that was to tell me that he knows I'm angry at him but blah blah blah (one of the last emails I read from him - maybe THE last). I was like "wait, what? I'm not angry with you. I'm terrified of you!" (ofc I never said that to him). I guess that's my long winded way of saying I agree with you. xD
@Kalleesto
@Kalleesto 2 года назад
@@Ocrilat Yeah I think a lot of people are. I think this trial is much more important than it seems on the surface.
@cheriechetyrbok
@cheriechetyrbok 2 года назад
Same. I actually did start believing her I'm ashamed to admit! I guess was too hard to accept someone could be that awful and lie about something so serious as abuse and SA ! Annoyed that I fell for that for even a second! My misplaced empathy. Exploitative manipulator. Such harm to JD legitimate victims. Smh
@cronobactersakazakii5133
@cronobactersakazakii5133 2 года назад
There is no way I can see her as a victim in her attitude. If I was a juror, I would beg her to stop looking at the juror’s bench with all her faces so I can focus on the substance of her answers and not her poor acting performance. I never saw Aquaman and I ain’t certainly not watch it now.
@lisadavis9485
@lisadavis9485 2 года назад
You didn't miss much. The movie was awful.
@sarahallen6420
@sarahallen6420 2 года назад
That’s a harsh narrative to believe women that have traumas are supposed to act a certain way.
@cronobactersakazakii5133
@cronobactersakazakii5133 2 года назад
@@sarahallen6420 I didn’t state she should behave a specific way
@MDGB-ok2se
@MDGB-ok2se 2 года назад
@@sarahallen6420 how do we know she has trauma though and it’s not an act like many people say?
@FlurryJoe
@FlurryJoe 2 года назад
Staring at the jury establishes dominance. It's a social tool to control conversations. Heard's manipulative personality involuntarily revealed itself as the case went. She has no idea how deep the hole she has dug for herself is.
@wolfgangweller1475
@wolfgangweller1475 2 года назад
One can say what one wants, but Depp is the more honest one here (in my opinion) and admitted to some mistakes ("yes very angry") whilst Heard did not admit to any guilt. Not even when caught lying.
@AedanGUnit
@AedanGUnit 2 года назад
Narcissism 101 NEVER admit any wrong doing.
@a33m3a
@a33m3a 2 года назад
And she had the audacity to say “I don’t claim I am the most innocent person” or whatever word vomit it was. She says she is not innocent but also everyone lied and she is a saint
@luisa1473
@luisa1473 2 года назад
What lies? Any issues that were brought up in cross-examination of Amber were circumstantial and not significant.
@jaymike3302
@jaymike3302 2 года назад
Depp ADMITS in texts that he's angry, takes women, doesn't care about repercussions of his behavior, and tried to get Amber fired from Aquaman.
@casedistorted
@casedistorted 2 года назад
That’s why he’s more credible and likeable. He seems like a nice guy who has made mistakes but he admits them at least and takes responsibility for it.
@AedanGUnit
@AedanGUnit 2 года назад
I thought she showed all of us what it’s like dealing with a narcissist. Everyone else is lying, only SHE is telling the truth. It’s crazy making and narcs consistently do this and lie looking you right in the face. Such arrogance from Ms. Heard. Dreadful narcissist.
@davidhollenshead4892
@davidhollenshead4892 2 года назад
I made the mistake of marrying a bunny boiler like Mrs. Heard. She even kicked my blind house cat when she was mad at me and assaulted me with a baseball bat knowing if I had hurt her in any way I would be arrested regardless of my injuries. My diverse took twenty minutes and all her claims were dropped once the judge saw the photos of her vandalism and injuries to my person. Mrs. Heard will continue to abuse others until she dies...
@kjbruch3270
@kjbruch3270 2 года назад
As Chase said in the behavior panel channel, she makes out like she's this Disney princess --who's never done anything wrong in her entire life--who was married to Satan. 🤣
@mobwatch8119
@mobwatch8119 2 года назад
Funny because that's what you all say about her witnesses - that they're all lying. You have no way to verify which side is more credible and who is telling the truth.
@Cristobels-Green-Boots
@Cristobels-Green-Boots 2 года назад
She might have indirectly given some help, in the form of clues, to those involved with a malignant narcissist (including a family member): The victim - man, woman, child - might lack the insight needed to define WTF is going on...why is the victim always to blame...? Dr Grande: ‘Amber Heard wanted to show her true self; unfortunately, she succeeded’ So, there it is - a Masterclass in ‘how to portray a malignant narcissist’: it couldn’t be clearer- ‘love bombing’, ‘bait & switch’, atrocious bullying cowardice & deceit - it’s all there... Some victims will go into denial, believing that to be the safer option: but I hope to high heaven that this psychodrama, this disgusting lack of empathy for others, will cause victims to seek help - & pronto! Is it too much to ask that the help will be there? 🙏🏻💔🙏🏽
@christinecornezcolmenero9356
@christinecornezcolmenero9356 2 года назад
Agree. I'm a little surprised she did not have this diagnosis.
@sarahmayer7026
@sarahmayer7026 2 года назад
The way AH scans the jury immediately after every "emotional outburst", is scary. She goes from allegedly crying as she talks about the alleged abuse to staring at the jurors to see if her "performance" had the intended effect in an instant. And during cross examination she never shows the same emotional response when talking about the alleged abuse, no sign of fear, sadness, pain, no "crying". Not once.
@dearbh1736
@dearbh1736 2 года назад
Yes Sarah, I watched a good video from 'Law and Lumber' who had been in the courtroom specifically to watch how she interacted with the jurors and you are absolutely right based on his reading of things - during the emotional outbursts she would scan to see who was showing an interest and look to the female jurors first and if they weren't buying it she moved around in a certain order which is why her eyes seemed to dart around. The witness stand is evidently very, very close to the jury box and she knew from early on which ones were most sympathetic. Lets hope they were the two alternates lol
@mastiffmom2592
@mastiffmom2592 2 года назад
Did you happen to catch her acting coach saying The Nameless One could not cry if it was acting/faking? I don’t believe she shed 1 tear during the entire trial.
@SoCalKevin
@SoCalKevin 2 года назад
It demonstrated how ignorant and child-like her mind works. It was embarrassing and scary at the same time.
@timewoundsallheels4ever
@timewoundsallheels4ever 2 года назад
When Johnny testifies, I see and hear a real life human. When Amber testifies, I see an actress in a badly self-scripted movie.
@hedonismbot3274
@hedonismbot3274 2 года назад
In her uk testimony i don't even see a real person/human tho. Just cold predatory eyes.
@alaynaheinline1921
@alaynaheinline1921 2 года назад
Couldn’t have said it better 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@allthatjazz613
@allthatjazz613 2 года назад
Y’all sound like you’ve never been in an abusive relationship… cause when I hear her speak it fucking sounds just like that.
@alaynaheinline1921
@alaynaheinline1921 2 года назад
@@allthatjazz613 I have been in one, have also known a few that have been as well. She’s clearly lying
@moonstruck562
@moonstruck562 2 года назад
@@allthatjazz613 I have been in a multiple abusive relationships. But I don't get that from her speaking, however I do get it from HIS speaking.
@IsaVarg
@IsaVarg 2 года назад
I want to add that the texts about "I want, I take", that Johnny said he didn't think he'd sent, did say "incoming", meaning they were sent to him, not by him.
@dontmindme633
@dontmindme633 2 года назад
@@Not.Two.nonduality001 whoa! Good catch I didn’t think about that
@auntiesocial3680
@auntiesocial3680 2 года назад
@@Not.Two.nonduality001 They were actually incoming texts from Deuters. They are both labelled as incoming messages (top right of each text). If you compare them to the one he did send to Christian Carino, you will see it says outgoing, and he admits to sending that one. These are data dumps. AHs team also neglected to fully redact the phone numbers. If you watch closely, you can see one of the numbers being greyed out while JD is being asked about them. I doubt the numbers are still in service, but I am sure that they would also verify which phone the messages originated from. It is unfortunate that neither JD nor his legal team noticed.
@onepartyroule
@onepartyroule 2 года назад
@@Not.Two.nonduality001 we don’t know what was intended by molly. There’s zero chance Johnny does not know that molly is drugs slang, that was common knowledge back in the 90’s.
@onepartyroule
@onepartyroule 2 года назад
@@Not.Two.nonduality001 He didnt say what? Can you clarify your statement?
@helenav8108
@helenav8108 2 года назад
That's what I was going to comment as well. It was actually a pretty dirty move by Amber's attorney and JD stood his ground that he never said those words
@julieberry27
@julieberry27 2 года назад
“Amber wanted to show the world her true self, unfortunately she was successful” 🤣😂🤣
@whitneyhesmer6648
@whitneyhesmer6648 2 года назад
She’s incredibly scary… sociopathic.
@prioract2842
@prioract2842 2 года назад
well as Tillet Wright testified, Johnny when not sober and mixing cocaine and alcohol was acting cruel and misogynistic. And was also paranoid. That's quite sociopathic too, if you ask me..
@daisy7066
@daisy7066 2 года назад
@@prioract2842 Don't be ridiculous, sociopaths are completely vindictive, predatory, & aggressive, just like AH. If you're suggesting they have similar characters then you're not watching the same trial.
@prioract2842
@prioract2842 2 года назад
@@daisy7066 you’re right.. I’m watching it grounded from planet Earth, whilst you’re on planet InfatuatedFan. Wish u a nice trip
@idacoetzee
@idacoetzee 2 года назад
Amber was caught in too many lies and provided questionable testimony without evidence- she failed to acknowledge her abusive behavior when she wrote her oped, she did defame Johnny in doing so, the jury should award Johnny a win.
@jaymike3302
@jaymike3302 2 года назад
Depp ADMITS in texts that he's angry, takes women, doesn't care about repercussions of his behavior, and tried to get Amber fired from Aquaman.
@Blissfulnessence
@Blissfulnessence 2 года назад
So much bias.
@livinglie5598
@livinglie5598 2 года назад
@@jaymike3302 yikes, that's a lot of bias right there. how would you like it if someone cut your finger off, take pictures of you sleeping and defecate on your bed? No, you wouldn't like it one bit at all.
@jaymike3302
@jaymike3302 2 года назад
@@Blissfulnessence I know. Depp fans say one of these text messages was incoming or something. Which is ridiculous...what about the hundreds of others? Just vile...like about burning her dead body. But to his fans, that's okay and he deserves lawsuit money from her.
@ThisIsBritt
@ThisIsBritt 2 года назад
@@jaymike3302 I have some thoughts. 1) The text I believe you are referencing was an INCOMING message to Johnny Depp's phone. Meaning, he received it. He did not send it. 2) The president of DC content at WB testified JD never put in a call to get Amber Heard fired. It was her poor chemistry with Jason Momma that led to talks of her getting fired. Telling your sister something in a text is a far cry from calling up WB. 3) Being angry is something every human being is at some time in their life. They have probably also vented to a confidant or two what they feel towards the person making their life a living hell. Finally: From watching the trial it is clear that Amber Heard is most certainly the sinner in this case. Only she is on the record as having admitted to hitting someone. She was also arrested for DV in the past against her ex-partner. AH provided a Photoshopped image to the jury, claiming they were separate images despite being taken at the exact same time, down to the second. She has been caught in so many lies, it is mind boggling. This woman would lie that the sky is blue. ("I wouldn't characterize it that way." 🙄) I hope the jury sees through her. She lied about suffering DV at JD's hands. Therefore, her op-ed is defamatory. End of story.
@carrieallen2047
@carrieallen2047 2 года назад
He admitted almost everything. I think it makes him look more honest when he denies a few things because he has admitted most things including some nasty texts. Also after listening to how she screams and puts him down and abuses him. It would be hard not to get angry with her.
@charamia9402
@charamia9402 2 года назад
He has admitted to just about everything presented to him in court, except abusing Heard and sending two texts. Even the 'global humiliation for the flappy fish market sucking Mollusks d*ck' text he admitted to in a heartbeat.
@frozenrose87
@frozenrose87 2 года назад
@Storytime with Mamabear I think you have that reversed. On the tapes, she is clearly the one taunting and mocking him until he gets upset. He tries to deescalate and leave repeatedly, in multiple instances, which he wouldn't do if he was the aggressor, and she lashes out and calls him a coward for not sticking around to "work it out," even when she's already gotten physical such as by throwing pots and pans. She says that absolutely doesn't matter or have any bearing on whether he should leave (but then tries to use a recording of him slamming cabinets to prove how abusive he could be 🙄🤦‍♀️). He's trying to escape violence that SHE is repeatedly instigating and she says she can't promise she won't get physical with him again. She's the abuser. Point blank.
@ntawvdabneeg9993
@ntawvdabneeg9993 2 года назад
@@frozenrose87 also she refused to turn in her phone. So JD shouldn't have to turn in his phone text message. Also, this new chick Molly, I get what I want when I want.. is incoming text so it couldn't go out from JD's phone and Molly is a drug? I just learned that Molly or Mally is a drug from that text. watch Laywers You May know channel. They explained it. It was something JD's lawyer team didn't catch.
@bonnienelson7373
@bonnienelson7373 2 года назад
Reactive physical AFTER being abused by AH.
@lee5802
@lee5802 2 года назад
@Storytime with Mamabear after his taunting? You've not listened to them intently. They show him trying to leave each argument and her not letting him go. She also admits to physical abuse, that she is the one that starts the physical fights, not him. He not once admits to physical abusing her. He is the victim.
@jennifer97363
@jennifer97363 2 года назад
Re:the lurid texts attributed to JD. She already testified she went into his laptop and saw messages to a woman…do we really think going into his phone, faking these texts is beyond her? Please.
@Grumbless
@Grumbless 2 года назад
the Molly ones say incoming not outgoing. they were sent too johnny not by him. it seems like neither team noticed it,
@luisa1473
@luisa1473 2 года назад
@@Grumbless No, they obviously got the text messages from the person Johnny sent them too. Obviously Johnny deleted his incriminating sent messages.
@katenkaren6692
@katenkaren6692 2 года назад
Good catch
@Grumbless
@Grumbless 2 года назад
@@luisa1473 then why would they not say that? The texts also talk very much like a lesbian/bi woman talking about a striaght woman imo "I want to change her understanding of what it's like.." if they did take it from someone else's phone why would they have not mentioned that? Johnny admitted to writing the other and denied this one that was also written completely differently from his other messages. Either the team missed it, or they (or amber from that smirk) lied. There's also an image of amber with a note that has written in it "I need, I want, I take" The messages were also sent in 2017 after their divorce
@charlie.patton
@charlie.patton 2 года назад
@@luisa1473 , no, the txt messages were taken from Johnny’s phone not from someone else’s. One message in particular Johnny acknowledged writing to his friend and for context that was the txt specifically talking about Amber being a guzzler. What was then brought up on cross in regards to the objected messages was that he (Johnny) would often use his staff to txt or call Amber (or whoever) on his behalf when he (Johnny) was unable to do so himself. The problem with this conclusion is that it would have Johnny requesting a staff member to txt on his behalf (so as Johnny himself) to then send a message to himself, then to be read by Johnny himself …🤨?
@Elayzee
@Elayzee 2 года назад
@0:38 She didn’t just imply that it was Johnny Depp, dude. She ADMITTED it today when Amber was confronted about the former TMZ dispatcher who testified that he was alerted about Amber Heard being at the courthouse AND exactly where her “bruise” was on her face. You can literally watch her admit in her response that the op-ed IS about Johnny, and that she DID write the op-ed as well.
@debbrown3760
@debbrown3760 2 года назад
I disagree that Johnny was " punching down" to her lawyer, I think he was angry that he wasnt allowed to properly explain, and this anger came out as an attempt at humour, which I think the public got. So I disagree that it has made him look bad.
@Chalee711
@Chalee711 2 года назад
Johnnys life was on the line as a man of 50yrs of kindness, he doesn't owe nobody anything if he is upset
@veryimportantperson3657
@veryimportantperson3657 2 года назад
yeah the idea that someone on the witness stand is "punching down" when snarking on the opposition's legal counsel is frankly idiotic.
@jonathanisrael9714
@jonathanisrael9714 2 года назад
I apologize for feeling angry with JD when I first heard news reports years ago that claimed he was a wife beater. Now that the truth has come out, I see that he was NOT the wife abuser that I assumed. BEWARE of news media's unprofessional and inaccurate reporting!
@jennifer97363
@jennifer97363 2 года назад
You’re not alone. My husband, who is the most tuned-out-to-celebrities person there is, who knew of JD only by name and because of Johnny’s Cpt JS movies…said “good, he’s a wife beater isn’t he?” when I told him about the trial and the rough time Johnny’s having. That illustrates just how infectious her destructive agenda has been toward him. What a mess. ONE person causing all this chaos! What that must do to her inflated ego!
@denischabriddell986
@denischabriddell986 2 года назад
You are not alone. I was saddened to hear the allegations that he beat his wife. Since watching the trial I now know that is not true. I do believe they were both toxic.
@karenpearson8916
@karenpearson8916 2 года назад
what truth has come out? Jonny Depp is a very very rich man he said he was going to ruin her, he has the money to do this he is also a drunk and a drug addict you dont know if he is a wife beater or not because you are trusting what you see in the news I see a woman that was smitten with a film star and then found herself drawn into drugs and drink
@jennifer97363
@jennifer97363 2 года назад
@@karenpearson8916 No, not what I see in the news, which is zilch, I don’t watch the news. I’ve watched the entire trial on the Law and Crime Channel. Didn’t have a dog in the race, wouldn’t have called myself a JD fan, and had never heard of Heard the actress. I’ve listened to sworn testimony, looked at evidence submitted and used critical thinking. Anyone who thinks he was the main abuser in this relationship has confirmation bias. The number of people who would have to be lying under threat of perjury to allow her to be telling the truth is staggering. She is a very destructive person. Telling,that in the hundreds of comments I’ve read by DV survivors - I’ve seen exactly one who was supportive. Otherwise every single one said AH showed no recognizable signs of being a victim of DV whatsoever. Most went so far as to call her a liar- like millions of other people. That’s not to say that everything out of her mouth was a lie, but every horrible, unsubstantiated claim against JD, as far as I can tell, is a heinous lie. She tried to ruin him first- he has every right to tell his truth to the world. The Uk trial was closed court- we heard nothing directly.
@defaulted9485
@defaulted9485 2 года назад
If you ask me, Johnny did indeed snapped, but it's caused by Amber. More like a staged extortion and perjury than a domestic violence for the sake of unleashing anger. I really hope the jury give Johnny something, because this trial has massive implications for future trials. I hope they definitely give Amber NOTHING, sent her to jail for contempt, let the police handle recidivist case, and then restraining order for her against any other human being. Johnny doesn't need to win, but at least take Amber accountable for a lot of things. Also, I'm sure any jury who sides with Amber is definitely being death stared for literally siding with person who disrespected them in court for 6 weeks. Like bored them to death, lied, biased, fooling them, taking advantage of them, and hurting their sanity for lying so much that her evidences are made of unaccountable excuses they have to check.
@minyah9625
@minyah9625 2 года назад
I’m so much more willing to believe someone who admitted to some failings, then a selfish brat that could see no wrong in anything she did
@Chalee711
@Chalee711 2 года назад
Using facts are always better
@tessapainter3128
@tessapainter3128 2 года назад
The way Amber was smirking when the text messages Johnny “supposedly” sent were read, I immediately suspected Amber texted them when Johnny was “passed out” and he wasn’t aware of them.
@megapint8598
@megapint8598 2 года назад
I saw those smirks too - the smirks of I have you trapped now ..
@ichx8
@ichx8 2 года назад
Passcodes are a thing
@lalalovengun
@lalalovengun 2 года назад
BINGO!!!
@tessapainter3128
@tessapainter3128 2 года назад
@@ichx8 and fingerprint authentication could be done with a passed out persons thumb without their knowledge
@marybodnar4749
@marybodnar4749 2 года назад
The “I want, I need, I take” was Ambers words. And she’s the speed freak, not Johnny.
@BunnyLang
@BunnyLang 2 года назад
I feel since she lied so much and gave herself away on many issues, she got caught and even tho they both were dysfunctional, it was Amber who got the ball rolling with the press. I feel she does deserve to lose this case.
@babs420th9
@babs420th9 2 года назад
Johnny Depp isn't after the truth. He wants revenge. Revenge for his son getting confronted with Ambers article, and for his tanked career. But the truth is that HE HIMSELF cause his career to crash with his boozing and drugs. Man up and take responsibility, Johnny!
@rosiered2357
@rosiered2357 2 года назад
i agree
@chrisyanover1777
@chrisyanover1777 2 года назад
So you believe Johnny Depp's picture perfect memory of events that happened when he was completely trashed on drugs and alcohol?
@DRay4eveZ
@DRay4eveZ 2 года назад
@@chrisyanover1777 I feel like Johnny being addicted to drugs and Amber being an abuser and lying about SA and DV are two completely different issues. Amber does deserve to lose this case. She has defamed him. That is clear.
@rudeboyjim2684
@rudeboyjim2684 2 года назад
@@chrisyanover1777 how does that relate to the demonstrable fabrication of evidence on Amber’s part? She edited AND staged photos.
@lari5875
@lari5875 2 года назад
They missed it, but the texts he denied writing were sent TO, not BY him. It says Incoming in the document.
@BigZebraCom
@BigZebraCom 2 года назад
Dr Grande, how on earth can a Jury keep their sanity after 22 plus days of listening to all of this? How is it that they DON'T run out of the courthouse, pulling out their hair from the roots?
@Vonononie
@Vonononie 2 года назад
Hey hey heeeeeyyyyy! Where’s my reminder you’re just speculating BigZebra?
@bthomson
@bthomson 2 года назад
Yes! We do like our commenters to be true to themselves! BigZebra has a style we exect! The guy who always asks about bitcoin (cryptocurrency), The Grande Groupies who send sweet messages to each other, etc. This is our safe space!
@Vonononie
@Vonononie 2 года назад
@@bthomson Grande Groupies, 😂
@BigZebraCom
@BigZebraCom 2 года назад
@@Vonononie Just a reminder that even i need reminders. :)
@BigZebraCom
@BigZebraCom 2 года назад
@@bthomson I like the idea of 'Grande Groupies'
@aMEWzed
@aMEWzed 2 года назад
The texts johnny said were not his allegedly were sent TO him not sent by him. Please review the trial footage to confirm that. It has been an interesting trial. I learned a lot. Your calm assessment is informative & well spoken. Thank you.
@DiegoRamirez-zc7fs
@DiegoRamirez-zc7fs 2 года назад
I can’t understand why the “incoming” wasn’t caught by Johnny’s legal team, unless they plan to use it in the closing argument.
@susanbaker2796
@susanbaker2796 2 года назад
@@DiegoRamirez-zc7fs Same.
@buffsan717
@buffsan717 2 года назад
@@DiegoRamirez-zc7fs I think closing. They might have taken care of it on re- direct if Johnny's reaction hadn't been so emphatic and real. Couple the reaction with the "incoming" and it will be very effective in closing. Adding the impression of AH's team trying to fool the jury and set Johnny up comes as a bonus.
@rars0n
@rars0n 2 года назад
@@DiegoRamirez-zc7fs Because they didn't come from his phone, you idiots. They came from his assistant's phone, they were messages that were sent FROM Johnny's phone. You can't understand why his legal team didn't "catch" it because there was nothing to catch. In case you haven't noticed by now, they're not morons. They actually know what they're doing.
@mobwatch8119
@mobwatch8119 2 года назад
Far worse ones have been confirmed to be written by him, so I'm not sure what the fuss is about. In fact I know - there is an attempt to whitewash his image to the highest degree.
@AbdullahMQureshi
@AbdullahMQureshi 2 года назад
The rebuttal did change my mind from being somewhat on the fence to being supportive of Depp. They literally and effectively challenged almost every single claim by Heard's Team. Regardless of whoever wins, JD is not the monster we have been told he is in the press.
@prioract2842
@prioract2842 2 года назад
Until this morning i was very much on the fence like you.. i start now to really see thru ALTHOUGH… there’s smthg that truly irritates me STILL.. which is the agressiveness and even - bad faith - of many of JD’s fans. They didn’t help, honestly.
@MDGB-ok2se
@MDGB-ok2se 2 года назад
How in the world did it take you that long to side with depp? I’m not a huge fan as far as his movies, but they proved Amber was lying almost immediately.
@AbdullahMQureshi
@AbdullahMQureshi 2 года назад
@@MDGB-ok2se because Amber's defense was simply harrowing. So many heinous allegations, so many pictures showing bruises and everything. It was the rebuttal which ultimately vindicated Depp.
@MDGB-ok2se
@MDGB-ok2se 2 года назад
@@AbdullahMQureshi see that’s the problem I had. I can get a bruise somehow and blame any man I want and ruin his life just because I said he did it? The law doesn’t work that way, or at least didn’t used to. Now people have to prove their innocence instead of guilt. As soon as I learned that all she had were questionable pics of some bruises and a red patch on her face but didn’t have any proof he was the one that did it, I came to an opinion. And all the pics she took but never bothered to take any of her supposed broken nose, or cuts from broken glass. It doesn’t matter that people want to believe a woman who says she’s been abused, it has to proven or else nobody is exempt from having their lives destroyed just by words.
@CourageGraceandKickintheAss
@CourageGraceandKickintheAss 2 года назад
I'm a bit Baffled by some fence sitter's and Genuinely I mean Absolutely No disrespect at All. The 'Abuse' she claims in conjunction with her 'Evidence' isn't possible at All. Being Hit or Even Backhanded with those Rings Messes Your Face Up Horrendously. There's No Way to Hide it and it Takes Weeks to Heal, Ice or Not, Make-up or Not! Oh and Never Trust the Press. If there's an Important Issue of Which this Case Very Much is, I Recommend doing your Own Homework or Research to get to the Truth. Have a Beautiful Weekend 😊
@waelrifai6547
@waelrifai6547 2 года назад
Johnny was hurt thats why he feels angry and vindictive ... She used him abused him and tried to end his career and life of course he is being defensive he waited 6 years to tell his side of the story ... I can imagine how he feels .we all faced an amber in our lives and some of us never saw Justice .... Now with this trial maby watching johnny defend himself and defeat his amber gives us hope to fight our own amber's
@fatucha5621
@fatucha5621 2 года назад
When i saw her testimony... I fell like she is using my suffering. My ex narc still, after more than ten years, sometimes he puts letters on my door telling me how much he "loves" me... Its discusting. He makes me remmember him. Why should have emphaty for these people? What about all the shit we have to suffer?
@sarahspencer1010
@sarahspencer1010 2 года назад
Yup, you are so right. This gives me hope for my own abuse.
@steggopotamus
@steggopotamus 2 года назад
Watching youtube videos about the JD/AH trial, i saw suggested videos by dr. Ramani, about narcissism, which lead me here eventually. So I too, maintain it's a good thing for educating people about narcisissm
@a33m3a
@a33m3a 2 года назад
Yes! I told my boyfriend that if you sent that text to a friend about me, it would be grounds for breaking up but in this case, Johnny sent it in response to all the vindictive things she did to him and all the trauma and violence and cheating so he is 100% justified in sending a nasty text about her to a friend
@a33m3a
@a33m3a 2 года назад
@@fatucha5621 please get a restraining order in him. It is not normal to go to your ex’s house 19 years later. Only shows they have no limits and boundaries and want to continue keeping you on edge.
@flossypark3169
@flossypark3169 2 года назад
The journalists outside of the court actually showed the whole of the message exchange that he was supposed to have written, including the message he denied. Above the messages were either ‘incoming’ or ‘outgoing’. The message Johnny denied was ‘incoming’! That brings credence to the fact that when Johnny intimated that the messages may have been doctored, he was right!
@aina3387
@aina3387 2 года назад
Yeah. He's admitted to some unkind texts, so when these came up and he acted like he didn't remember them at all and they seemed out of character for him, I believe him. Its a dirty trick the other side used.
@LeeDee5
@LeeDee5 2 года назад
Johnny is far off from being the most innocent, angelic person that on Earth but wow… Amber is on another level. She’s an outright menace.
@Chalee711
@Chalee711 2 года назад
His personal issues with substance is none of ur business, they tried so hard to say its the reason she claim dv. Yet it's all bs
@SoCalKevin
@SoCalKevin 2 года назад
This is probably one of the biggest things to come out of this trial. Amber is such a psycho she could make Johnny look like an angel.
@SoCalKevin
@SoCalKevin 2 года назад
This is probably one of the biggest things to come out of this trial. Amber is such a psycho she could make Johnny look like an angel.
@titasantiniE
@titasantiniE 2 года назад
.Very thoughtful analysis. Agree about AH. Sad. I think Johnny is well liked and respected in the industry far and wide. Even if his bad behavior has been outed, he’s not a wife beater. If anything, he’s abused himself: alcohol/drugs. He’s incredibly talented as an artist, but his shy nature doesn’t do well in the life style of the rich and famous. It seems to go against his true nature. Now he’s “loved “ by millions, but can not find genuine, mature, love. I hope he stays sober, goes to counseling, and finds folks who love him for himself and not penthouses.
@bthomson
@bthomson 2 года назад
With so many well-worded good wishes going his way I hope he feels the love!
@stormybleu6054
@stormybleu6054 2 года назад
Nobody deserves lies like the ones I've heard from this woman, they are damaging to anyone's reputation. JD said some ugly things about her but I don't believe he abused her. His substance use has always been known. Recently HEARD she is being investigated for perjury in the UK but have not verified.
@luisa1473
@luisa1473 2 года назад
He is a court-certified wife beater
@sarahr1235
@sarahr1235 2 года назад
Stay warm, friendly and kind, surrounded by kind and loving people. Prays JD gets his career back and stop allowing people , to suck the life out of him financially, mentally, physically emotionally. Be true to yourself and your children which did not deserve this abuse either.
@julieannfaehealing
@julieannfaehealing 2 года назад
So well said Tita
@luvlyval587
@luvlyval587 2 года назад
It will be interesting to see how the jury rules in this case. I'm sure they are exhausted.
@kevinhornbuckle
@kevinhornbuckle 2 года назад
They are tired of being lied to.
@dontmindme633
@dontmindme633 2 года назад
Do you have a prediction on how they will rule?
@em-jaytaylor6743
@em-jaytaylor6743 2 года назад
I think they’ll find for Depp for the headline about sexual abuse but I doubt they’ll be able to find for the other two claims as the law is not on his side for that. I doubt the counter case will win anything. Then again, the jury may have been so put off by AH behaviour on the stand and in the audio that they find for JD for £7 million in a kind of poetic justice
@dontmindme633
@dontmindme633 2 года назад
@@em-jaytaylor6743 what confuses me is, her team saying if there was ever any abuse of any kind including verbal, she’s innocent, and then Johnny’s team saying the opposite. It seems to me the slander was about physical and sexual abuse. But if it’s confined to the op ed and she didn’t make those claims in the op ed….
@Sadtoday
@Sadtoday 2 года назад
They should offer counseling the other doors afterwards because there’s a lot
@CuriousNanna
@CuriousNanna 2 года назад
Although I tend to agree wholeheartedly with most of your opinions, I must say I disagree on one thing. Those gross text messages were not from JD, and I’m surprised no one noticed and mentioned, but those were incoming messages, not outgoing.
@Blissfulnessence
@Blissfulnessence 2 года назад
Incoming to whom? Did it show received by Johnny? (Serious question btw) Sometimes the use of texts in court are those on both or either party's phone. Ie: you send me a text then delete it on your phone, yet i retain it on mine - entered into court it shows as incoming because mine is the phone it was retained on. It seems if it wasn't a text from Johnny his lawyers would've argued it.
@CuriousNanna
@CuriousNanna 2 года назад
Why would JD send a text message to himself? You can’t receive and send a text message at the same time.
@rars0n
@rars0n 2 года назад
Why are there so many people repeating this nonsense? Did ANY of you pay attention during the trial? The texts were NOT taken from Johnny's phone, they were taken from his assistant's phone. Those texts were sent FROM Johnny's phone. THAT'S WHY NOBODY IS MENTIONING IT.
@rars0n
@rars0n 2 года назад
@@CuriousNanna "You can’t receive and send a text message at the mail X act same time." I don't know what this means, but you can absolutely send yourself a text message. I do it sometimes if I want to quickly write something down on my phone. But that has nothing to do with the texts presented during trial.
@bevmacdonald9008
@bevmacdonald9008 2 года назад
That's right. The texts were suddenly submitted without warning, Johnny's team were blindsided, while dealing with a full slate. Although Amber had this data all along, they suddenly submitted it and Depp's team did not have a chance to properly examine the evidence. They didn't notice the "incoming" label. That was according to Team Heard's plan. They know it is about mdma. That is why they didn't ask questions to try to discover the identity of Molly, because they also knew it wasn't about a woman. I hope the jury members notice they were incoming messages, at least upon their evidence review.
@ThatGuy-Official
@ThatGuy-Official 2 года назад
The text messages were labeled "Incoming" which suggests that Amber's team made a mistake and confused texts that were received by Depp with ones that he sent. If that is the case then he definitely did not write those texts and was being honest.
@needfoolthings
@needfoolthings 2 года назад
The mistake lies with Depp's team as they didn't seem to notice and didn't bring this to attention.
@charamia9402
@charamia9402 2 года назад
Ah, a 'mistake'.
@rars0n
@rars0n 2 года назад
No, actually it suggests that you paid zero attention to what was going on during the trial and didn't understand the evidence being presented.
@rars0n
@rars0n 2 года назад
@@needfoolthings Yeah, they just mysteriously turned full retard during that particular instance. That aligns perfectly with how thorough they've been during the rest of the trial. Yep, your logic is infallible.
@charamia9402
@charamia9402 2 года назад
@@Truthseeker-kc8rd How do you know?
@razor84
@razor84 2 года назад
Her most frightening entity described as "not being the center of attention" cracked me up good, also it appears to be true. Thank you for the laughs as well as your insights on the case updates!
@ellobo1326
@ellobo1326 2 года назад
A H testimony was a litany of lies, partial truths, and exaggerations.
@maryannanderson2213
@maryannanderson2213 2 года назад
When Amber was giving her deposition, she was sophisticated and arrogant and blasé and carefree, but now that she is on trial, she is SAD and scared and sad and exhausted and sad and terrified and sad, and she is sending out Barbie Baptist vibes. The liquor was Johnny's. (She didn't even want it in her refrigerator... not that she knows what it was... all she knows is that it was Johnny's devil brew), the drug box was Johnny's (though she knew exactly what was in it,) the lines of coke were Johnny's (though there were FOUR lines laid out). Johnny was the one using the language that sweet little ole Amber just can hardly bring herself to repeat, though of course the tape recording has HER using the same language. I am weary of her trying to portray herself as Nancy Nazarene and Johnny as the Devil Incarnate.
@theprofeshio
@theprofeshio 2 года назад
She's scared , but scared that Camille is going to expose her
@CaroleLynnK
@CaroleLynnK 2 года назад
She thought she needed the restraining order to change the locks on HIS penthouses
@charlie.patton
@charlie.patton 2 года назад
Also Amber: I never EVER would do drugs with Johnny… and I also hate drugs which is why I took this picture of his coke after he left for work, which clearly, Camille, you don’t know the *correct* way to snort coke and not leave a residue! Which uhh duh, is through a tampon applicator which can also be seen right there in this picture!! 🙄🙄🙄 ……… 👀 (turns to look at jury)…. *ahem* but I only know that because I was there when my coke head sister taught Johnny because uh, I don’t do drugs like I said, I just like watching others snort them through tampon applicators. I mean I’ve had my fair share of A LOT of pills, which by that I mean 2 because 2 is a lot for me….but basically I’m a free spirit and am very chill on drugs because my main vibe is cuddle puddles and who can say cuddle puddle and be a an evil abusive liar? So like I said, I don’t do drugs, I never have … 👀 (jury check) … and also, 🤧 Johnny abused me so bad and then we went on a walk and my dog stepped on a bee! 🥴
@YaakovEzraAmiChi
@YaakovEzraAmiChi 2 года назад
@@charlie.patton 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@michellegoldsmith
@michellegoldsmith 2 года назад
You forgot about the 2 bottles of very expensive red wine she scoffed down every day and the copious amounts of drugs she also consumed. And JD covered the bill for her and her parasite friends for YEARS.
@barb_eh
@barb_eh 2 года назад
"Amber wanted to show the world her true self. Unfortunately for her, she was successful." Pure gold, Dr. Grande. 🌵🪙📀
@autumn.melody1715
@autumn.melody1715 2 года назад
Listening to Amber ranting made me want to lock myself in the bathroom.
@joelgarcia3907
@joelgarcia3907 2 года назад
Attorneys just doing their job? They took a case they knew was false. They did a very unethical move with the Molly text. They know that was not about a woman
@kevinhornbuckle
@kevinhornbuckle 2 года назад
Elaine Bredehoft knowingly attempted to deceive the court, jury, and public. Elaine debased herself by adopting narcissistic strategies to intimidate witnesses and bullshit witnesses. They reproduced narcissistic abuse because their client did not bring facts or honesty to the trial.
@awkwardautistic
@awkwardautistic 2 года назад
You don't know much about attorneys do you?
@ravenanbu5708
@ravenanbu5708 2 года назад
Dude no it wasn't even his tect it was incoming to his phone he received the test not sent it and her lawyers and she used one picture for different even so this whole trial they have been forging evidence and lying
@gd3551
@gd3551 2 года назад
Everyone is entitled to a defense and attorneys are obligated to represent their clients vigorously. Even the worst people are entitled equal justice.
@aerynstormcrow
@aerynstormcrow 2 года назад
@@awkwardautistic of course he does. Everyone does. Saying it out loud doesn’t mean he doesn’t know lawyers are bloodsuckers.
@stubstunner
@stubstunner 2 года назад
I’m sure he did ruffle feathers. This went both ways but the predominant issue is that the severity of her BS was far greater.
@nitasheehan2704
@nitasheehan2704 2 года назад
Well stated.
@lionheartmerrill1069
@lionheartmerrill1069 2 года назад
Lie detector tests.
@caterinascarcella
@caterinascarcella 2 года назад
I feel he was more reactive to her hostility, well according to the video imo.
@kimessex4011
@kimessex4011 2 года назад
AMEN AMEN HALLELUJAH BROTHER 🤘👍
@ripley4155
@ripley4155 2 года назад
Yes. JD saying nasty things in the heat of the moment to the person he wants to divorce is not on the same level as AH staging abuse and faking a violent sexual assault.
@thelocalmaladroit8873
@thelocalmaladroit8873 2 года назад
Oh Doctor, have you ever seen or experienced a couple quite like this? I can’t imagine living with the drugs, alcohol, hitting, punching, screaming! I’d rather peel boiled eggs all day than live like this! Meanwhile, the birds are making a nest on my front porch-hopefully they will be more agreeable than these two! Thank you, and have a lovely evening 🌷.
@mezaminmezamin6846
@mezaminmezamin6846 2 года назад
Much More Productive & Healthy! Good Thoughtful Post.
@theworldofjuniperthecat1307
@theworldofjuniperthecat1307 2 года назад
Agreed.
@retriever19golden55
@retriever19golden55 2 года назад
It's a damn shame these two ever met. Definition of toxic relationship.
@reneaguilar3471
@reneaguilar3471 2 года назад
The eyes of a narcissist is the most powerful weapon after his her words . Johnny knows that and that’s why he denied amber the right to let her look into his eyes . The spell of a narcissist it’s in the eyes . A wounded look from a narcissist melts peoples hearts from love or compassion . Amber is a master of manipulation . I don’t agree with dr grande about they were competing about being ugly to each other . You don’t run away from a competition . Johnny tried to run away and she would keep abusing him
@karenpearson8916
@karenpearson8916 2 года назад
lol you are so sad
@PoM-MoM
@PoM-MoM 2 года назад
Remember! Amber's problem with Australia was AU wouldn't let Amber's dogs return a 2nd time after the first incident of Amber illegally "smuggling" her 2 dogs, who did not have adequate vaccinations, into AU on their first trip together in 2015.
@careip
@careip 2 года назад
Shes obviously never had consequences for her actions.
@a33m3a
@a33m3a 2 года назад
@@careip and when she is faces consequences for her actions and lies, she calls it people are hating on her 🤣
@stormybleu6054
@stormybleu6054 2 года назад
@@EarnestWilliamsGeofferic As they all should be.
@LeopardJoy
@LeopardJoy 2 года назад
@@EarnestWilliamsGeofferic Oh so committing perjury is a common theme for her.
@PoM-MoM
@PoM-MoM 2 года назад
@@EarnestWilliamsGeofferic Yes, The Aquaman set in AU was abandoned because of Amber and yes, it was/IS about the dogs !
@peejthompson
@peejthompson 2 года назад
I hoped to view the trial with an open mind, but, if I am honest, I was more prepared to believe Amber. It is very difficult for people experiencing IPV to stand up, and more women than men are victims. Of course, male victims suffer terribly too. My view of Amber Heard has completely changed, and I think it is clear that she is manipulative and abusive, but worse still, a liar who has misrepresented awful arguments as IPV, in an attempt to destroy Johnny Depp. She should have let go and gone on to enjoy fame and her child.
@polishgrlinvegas
@polishgrlinvegas 2 года назад
Glad you are not claiming anymore this is “ sad and unnecessary “ trial, when in fact- this is very IMPORTANT trial, that will raise questions about gender and DV stereotypes , fabricating DV and staging PR stunts that manipulate public opinion via mainstream media.
@AleksLazar
@AleksLazar 2 года назад
Johnny’s no perfect guy or husband, but I’m glad he’s doing this. For all the dudes out there who’ve been abused by psychos, but had to take it because they’re ‘a man’
@kellinicole1983
@kellinicole1983 2 года назад
You are having too much fun with these titles 😂❤️. Love it. And bless their hearts 🙄
@jeffersonott4357
@jeffersonott4357 2 года назад
I love it!
@meganbos55
@meganbos55 2 года назад
Yes! Lol they keep getting better and better!
@Taffi0623
@Taffi0623 2 года назад
100% agreed!! These titles are hilarious. And as always, the analysis is dead on.
@katarina1852
@katarina1852 2 года назад
You know, it wouldn’t surprise me if Amber didn’t use Johnny’s phone to write nasty texts to herself to bolster her campaign against Johnny. She took photos and made recordings to use against him, why not fake some messages as well. It’s certainly possible.
@enigmag9538
@enigmag9538 2 года назад
I'm still mad that I haven't heard any recognition of the actual "bruise kit"- like what is used by actors to CREATE bruises which explains the lack of swelling. That was a slip by Amber. Also the audio when she sounded absolutely annihilated!.
@blumenkraft2275
@blumenkraft2275 2 года назад
hmmm… me too. in the photo she took of JD sleeping with ice cream spilled on him- you can see a purse with what appears to be a Ben Nye square palette bruise kit.
@suemount6042
@suemount6042 2 года назад
Especially as the bruise kit is in the Bottom left corner of the icecream photo
@vega1349
@vega1349 2 года назад
I think it would be a distraction from the more important testimony, seeing as Amber's own makeup artist also used the word "bruise kit" to describe creating bruises. If they challenged it, it would be too easy to brush off as a slip of the tongue and they wouldn't gain anything more than they already have.
@TheGladeGirl
@TheGladeGirl 2 года назад
Johnny handed in his phone as requested , however Amber has not handed in her phone. She has a lot to hide.
@sarahm3991
@sarahm3991 2 года назад
Those dramatic text messages were incoming. "I need I want I take" He received them. He owned up to everything he did. He never lied.
@mapachemaldito
@mapachemaldito 2 года назад
On redirection, when his lawyer was questioning him he literally admitted they're his texts. How are people this dense? They were admitted as evidence, from his team, they have obviously been checked.
@charamia9402
@charamia9402 2 года назад
@@mapachemaldito If you go look at the picture of the messages admitted to evidence, it literally says 'incoming'.
@bevmacdonald9008
@bevmacdonald9008 2 года назад
@@mapachemaldito that is not accurate. I watched his testimony, we saw him admit to the long one but we did not see him admit to the shorter ones , not even during redirect.
@mapachemaldito
@mapachemaldito 2 года назад
@@charamia9402 It's admitted into evidence, obviously scrutinized and vetted by his lawyers. It's incoming because he has many phones from which he writes his disgusting texts. Wake up.
@Kryptic_Karma
@Kryptic_Karma 2 года назад
@@bevmacdonald9008 Yeah... yet other people are the dense ones.. Also, just because something was admitted into evidence doesn't mean it's representitive of reality or even unaltered as shown by Amber's "unedited" photos.
@user-cs1un6sp1wRennata
@user-cs1un6sp1wRennata 2 года назад
"From this mindset, anything they did was permissible" Excellent analysis Dr. Grande! Thank you for your coverage of this trial. 🖤
@katieflaxbeard1019
@katieflaxbeard1019 2 года назад
Dr. Grande I just want to point out Johnny took accountability for every awful test he wrote that Rottenborn hit him with in his first cross examination. This gives me confidence that if Johnny denies one single text out of all he took responsibility for I believe him. Can’t wait to hear your thoughts on Ambers final testimony
@268marley
@268marley 2 года назад
He didn't say that the photo depicting an apparent black eye before the train ride was photoshopped - he said that it was a shadow caused by the lighting. The photo he said was altered was one that the Orient Express posted on their Facebook page, which made him appear as though he had no black eye. Aide by side, their photo does look altered to me.
@orangemangas2465
@orangemangas2465 2 года назад
My favorite part was when Johnny said 'Mr.Rotten...Born"
@heavenrains2432
@heavenrains2432 2 года назад
Dr Grande I totally respect your opinion and respect the fact that you had to watch the trial word for word ugh 😩 I can’t imagine 🙄 Great job Dr Grande 👍🏻
@interstitialist4227
@interstitialist4227 2 года назад
Dr. Grande watches this circus so we don't have to. THANK YOU!
@rafaelamariaorozco-newton5199
@rafaelamariaorozco-newton5199 2 года назад
As to Johnny's circuitous route to answering questions, I think that is ADHD. I have ADHD and often find myself doing the same thing.
@ashleykuvet6075
@ashleykuvet6075 2 года назад
I also have adhd, and I answer questions directly. Although, if too many are asked in a row, I might forget one due to working memory issues. 🤷🏻‍♀️
@maragretmcdonald-cavangah3473
@maragretmcdonald-cavangah3473 2 года назад
me as well...along with the stuttering..my son does it as well
@DottieMinerva
@DottieMinerva 2 года назад
I don’t envy the jurors. This case is exhausting and there’s so many details, many of which seem irrelevant from my point of view.
@tinaandtheworld
@tinaandtheworld 2 года назад
Johnnie has ADHD. It takes him a few minutes to form his thoughts and then speak them.
@tinaandtheworld
@tinaandtheworld 2 года назад
@@mrsjprich I get it, and that's why I mentioned it, but many people didn't and do not know - there was limited, brief mention with no context. I am very aware of it because members of my immediate family struggle both in speech and with mental disabilities; as this is something that is very personal to me, I bring it to the attention so there is no misunderstanding. Many people are under the false impression because of his manner of speech, but the truth is that it's because he has ADHD. Someone familiar or even unfamiliar with the film industry or the performing arts might assume that it's done for a "dramatic" effect. Even more so, because of her personality and overacting, they make a false comparison when she is telling events her speech entails is such an exaggeration or lies altogether because of the perceptions she needs others to have of her. Her attempts to look down on others and be so theatrical or histrionic, etc., the fact that they are a "Hollywood pair" has the potential to offer a misleading image of his speech and mannerisms if you've ever been through it yourself or someone who is close you will recognize it. I think her mannerisms and the fact that they are actors could lead him to the conclusion he had. if they had been in any other situation or line of work because of the focus I think he would have because of his area of expertise instead of Drama but we know because we may have experienced both as you mention. but Dr. Grande I believe is a counselor, not a psychiatrist or psychologist. " Forgive me Dr. Grande if I am mistaken that was what I understood."
@ayaa.1351
@ayaa.1351 2 года назад
Her lawyers were rude, unorganized, condescending. It's no wonder he was fed up. Wtf
@a__13511
@a__13511 2 года назад
I really enjoyed your analysis at the end and how you unpacked their behavior against each other. It is so interesting to dissect how a relationship can fall apart in such an intricate way due to idealism. Well done! Thanks for staying as impartial as you could.
@celinescrappassion2184
@celinescrappassion2184 2 года назад
thi is a very good analysis! No matter what AH does, she does not come accross as a nice person. She says she is being threatened by people outside the court, and they are mean to her, but this is not because of comments from Adam walder, this is because of her and how unlikable she is. It is unfortunate.
@paulinekononovich5398
@paulinekononovich5398 2 года назад
I don't think she lying about all the abuse. Johnny lied as well. He has a serious drug problem and that alone can cause him to be violent. I agree no one should win I. This battle. They both got this out now they can move on.
@LunaSea-000
@LunaSea-000 2 года назад
Serious drug problems do not equal violence!
@CourageGraceandKickintheAss
@CourageGraceandKickintheAss 2 года назад
She couldn't go to Australia because she was under investigation there. Charges were dropped but are now active and the FBI is Involved. That's why.
@silverstuff182
@silverstuff182 2 года назад
People like this are not a couple. They are two disturbed people who pitted themselves together.
@franknbeans
@franknbeans 2 года назад
Please please read this the text messages indicate 1. The first text message calling Amber names, you can see it was outgoing. The other 2 messages indicate incoming. That’s why he said he didn’t recognize them
@senmafugu
@senmafugu 2 года назад
@@anjou6497 you actually believe and support Amber Heard?
@TheT3rr0rMask
@TheT3rr0rMask 2 года назад
Nobody's denying what Johny did but one fact shows the clear societal bias we have: John does bad things upon accusation w/no evidence: career gone. Amber has evidence against her as well as family and friends claiming she is indeed toxic: still in a prestigious role and will always have a career.
@darrellspencer1809
@darrellspencer1809 2 года назад
I'm not sure she will have much of a career after this. Her biggest problem was dragging WB into this. What studio is going to want to sign someone willing to do that?
@janealveyharris2433
@janealveyharris2433 2 года назад
“Unfortunately for her, she was successful.” Well said.
@josephmitchell204
@josephmitchell204 2 года назад
I always enjoy your concise, no frills approach, always presented without bias. Your countenance is soothing and your content is always insightful, to me. So, thanks.
@Dgyhjigtjm
@Dgyhjigtjm 2 года назад
She blames everyone else even the poor little dog who can't dipende himself. She is saying everyone is lying and she is sweet pure little victim. Can't stand her!!!!
@rosg1746
@rosg1746 2 года назад
The dogs were tiny! How on earth would a pocket size dog get up onto a huge bed unaided?
@Vonononie
@Vonononie 2 года назад
I think every dog owner looked at that picture and knew it wasn’t from a 4lb dog! Probably the only truly innocent party in all of this is the doggo
@kellilee4287
@kellilee4287 2 года назад
Me Either!! Narcissistic B word
@careip
@careip 2 года назад
How dare you hate Amber! You just added to her abuse. She will never regain her voice now. 😆
@BubbleoniaRising
@BubbleoniaRising 2 года назад
I love your style, doc. I think you nailed this, aside from the texts as there is a question as to why Johnny's incoming and outgoing text markers in exhibit documents were inconsistent. I think it's likely he write one and not the other, because he received it and not because a rep wrote it for him. Great video and thank you!
@dkirk5814
@dkirk5814 2 года назад
He's virtually her only source of relevance and she's clinging onto it.
@The_night_Sun
@The_night_Sun 2 года назад
Ahhhhhh! The titles! They get me everytime! I frigging LOVE them! Also the stoic delivery when you toss an occasional insult makes me laugh harder than any Netflix comedy special ever has. It's the sparsity that makes them so special.
@punkyfeathers1639
@punkyfeathers1639 2 года назад
I’m loving the poetic titles!
@gailremp8389
@gailremp8389 2 года назад
Have you noticed when you're talking with patients, that no matter how well spoken they can be, when they are trying to say something that is difficult for them they often will have a tendency to stutter a few words? I've noticed that about myself and around others over the years working in law. I mean even in the break room with other secretaries and lawyers. So I don't know if he was slow in speaking and deliberate or nervous and not so much wanting to not screw up but wanting to speak so that it was more precise. That was just kind of my question and thought. Thanks... Gail in Central Florida Thursday, May 26, 2022. Peace. Be safe. We need you.
@katherinekemick3666
@katherinekemick3666 2 года назад
I so appreciate how you summarized six weeks, six years in such concise bullet points, with clear professional observations, yet revealing the truth on both AH and JD. It was a tangled mess of sorrows, addictions and deep wounds. Very soothing voice and understandable language. Thank you Dr. Grande. new subscriber now.
@dianabritoart
@dianabritoart 2 года назад
I was on the fence from the get go with both, but I am 💯 with JD on this one. I can't I watch the lies.
@patrickkish6662
@patrickkish6662 2 года назад
Can't wait for us all to be released from the witness stand in this trial.
@crystald8465
@crystald8465 2 года назад
🤣🤣🤣 so true!
@kimseiberling5263
@kimseiberling5263 2 года назад
I know, I’ve been glued to the tv everyday after work.
@Taluta394
@Taluta394 2 года назад
My phone playing all day in my office 🤣
@readygi
@readygi 2 года назад
I low key love the people who testified. So many interesting/weird people and great display of characters.
@freshlimejuice
@freshlimejuice 2 года назад
Hi Dr. Grande! Thanks for keeping us up to date and watching all the content for us. You always deliver a top notch assessment in an unbiased informative package.
@jejunamja
@jejunamja 2 года назад
Well said ...thank you for your analysis. I honestly didn't know who Amber was and I didn't know there was a UK trial before this trial at first. Johnny is definitely no saint he's got some problems especially with the drinking and the drugs but that doesn't make him a wife beater that makes him a man that probably needs to go to into rehab and deal with some childhood issues. After watching the court case and watching many videos like yours I think like most people we've come to view Amber as the aggressor and probably the violent one in this relationship. she has a history and Johnny's ex's all say he was never violent. Also she continues to lie throughout the case and it's obvious to all of us. I think she even lies about things that aren't important it's very hard to believe anything she says because she points out or likes to say everybody else is lying and that's just not possible.
@jayt9608
@jayt9608 2 года назад
If Amber Heard published lies that damaged Johnny Depps career, he should be able to claim defamation, because that is the cold reality. Further, you claimed that Johnny Depp hurt himself and "punched down" in his interactions with her lawyers. However, I quite disagree. The lawyers representing Amber Heard bave spent the better part of a month attempting to slander and discredit him at the behest of their client and often in ways that even the judge had to repudiate. The possible differences in their respective wealth is not an issue when he is on the stand, as he is at their mercy with little room to respond. Everyone in thar courtroom knew that the attorney had nade a bad objection that was destined for an overturning. Johnny may not have been right to say, "You'll be ok." but it did not hurt him.
@kevinlaleau5107
@kevinlaleau5107 2 года назад
Anyone watch Amber's testimony today and how she went from playing the victim when her lawyer was asking questions then switching when to angry ,defensive, aggressive attitude when cross examined by Johnny's lawyer ,Camille Vasquez
@vasudhabhandari8431
@vasudhabhandari8431 2 года назад
No one but remoras care about that sort of emotional range but a lot of people like you will regret supporting a wife beater 😂
@gretchenmae9279
@gretchenmae9279 2 года назад
Absolutely
@blakewin8167
@blakewin8167 2 года назад
I don't feel like Amber actually maliciously "lied" about the Kate Moss claim. She said she "heard about the story". From what I understood it was a big rumor in the 90's
@eadweard.
@eadweard. 2 года назад
Well we only have her word that it was a rumour in the 90s.
@vickyaugust1598
@vickyaugust1598 2 года назад
Johnny told AH about Kate Moss slipping and falling, she knew the true story.
@georgiagem7689
@georgiagem7689 2 года назад
She's the only one he told the story to. Connect the dots.
@TK-fm5ud
@TK-fm5ud 2 года назад
Thank you for providing a balanced commentary. I’d like to hear your take on why people seem to be splitting so severely over this case.
@bjmcacc2304
@bjmcacc2304 2 года назад
A 58 yr old man shouldn't be sharing his drugs period, much less with a group of young people that he's old enough to be a father to.
@jp-a1a729
@jp-a1a729 2 года назад
I feel so bad for AH’s little girl! There’s no way that poor child will grow up without trauma caused by her “mother”.
@kevinhornbuckle
@kevinhornbuckle 2 года назад
Watch Mommie Dearest vs ABBA.
@stuartzimmermann4180
@stuartzimmermann4180 2 года назад
specially in the 2 to 10 year old stages they can be very trying
@GiftSparks
@GiftSparks 2 года назад
My guess is that she will just dump the kid with her sister, who has her own child. Maybe her sister will do a better job.
@juancana457
@juancana457 2 года назад
Both my parents, I believe, shouldn't have been parents given their NPD behavior. I caused myself a cascade of misery in an effort to salve hurt and disregard, thank God I was directed towards maturity and discrimination. A painful, worthy journey.
@kevinhornbuckle
@kevinhornbuckle 2 года назад
@@juancana457 Blessings, Juan. Watch some videos by Crappy Childhood Fairy.
@elizabethwutzke9040
@elizabethwutzke9040 2 года назад
Wow, I never thought I'd say you are so very mistaken about JD. It's too bad you don't know him like so many ppl do. He's helped many people who are much less fortunate than he is...very kind and generous man.
@clearwatercounselingmt
@clearwatercounselingmt 2 года назад
Did you hear his texts about drowning burning and defiling her dead body? Uhhh…. Did your impressions not change?
@amandagrobe6149
@amandagrobe6149 2 года назад
Yes he did do all those generous things, no one can ever take that away from him. However several not so nice things have also come out about him, which he admitted to and said he was embarrassed or ashamed of. He admits to being far from perfect, so people can't act as if he is and just disregard this stuff...if he himself can admit to this then his fans should be able to as well. It's his ability to admit to this that makes him more credable as opposed to AH lying or trying to portray herself as completely innocent.
@fluxaeternal
@fluxaeternal 2 года назад
Ok Dr. Grande I think you're the only content creator who has made me do a spit-take, on multiple occasions, from your video titles alone 😂 bravo, well done, so glad we have your humor and whip-smart analyses in this mad world we are living in 🕵️‍♂️
@sarahspencer1010
@sarahspencer1010 2 года назад
Your analysis was very informative. We can always count on you to give a calm and unbiased assessment. And usually with great humor at points.
@mandychadwick6823
@mandychadwick6823 2 года назад
Amber has a cold heart and is hauty, arrogant and accuses every witness of being a liar 🤥 she comes across as a liar. I am glad JD is going through with this. He admits his faults but he seems a genuine damaged person with his struggles but his heart shines through.
@stephmini4656
@stephmini4656 2 года назад
It’s refreshing how Dr. Grande takes a neutral approach to this case, especially given all of the biased and highly emotional hot takes going around the internet. He acknowledges that both parties had an unrealistic and idealized view of the relationship which then turned sour and abusive, with Amber being the primary aggressor. I think is probably the closest theory to the truth. Attempts to paint Johnny or Amber as a blameless victim are reductionist and ignore the facts of the case. Glad Dr. Grande hasn’t felt bullied by the comment section to take one side or another, but simply based his analysis on the available information. Yay for well-reasoned takes on highly polarized/publicized cases!
@kevinhornbuckle
@kevinhornbuckle 2 года назад
The evidence that Amber Heard is a malignant narcissist has been publicly available for a long time. Even now, when a credible forensic psychologist, Dr. Curry, has diagnosed Heard with borderline and histrionic personality disorders, Dr. Grande cannot bring himself to say so in the current video. So he does not base his analysis on the available information.
@stormybleu6054
@stormybleu6054 2 года назад
He acknowledged the errors of both parties and called it just the way it is going down. Best of all, he called out the lies and I agree that JD's words have the ring of truth to them.
@SaguaroBlossom
@SaguaroBlossom 2 года назад
"Amber just wanted to show the world her true self. Unfortunately for her, she was successful." Excellent summary!
@liev3057
@liev3057 2 года назад
The text message he didn't recognize says "INCOMING", while the others shown say "OUTGOING".
@NinaNina-ry8fn
@NinaNina-ry8fn 2 года назад
The abtrusive text messages were send to Johnny, he never wrote them. I hope his lawyers will clarify that in court. # justice for johnny Depp
@Americans4Israel4Ever
@Americans4Israel4Ever 2 года назад
Good for you Dr grande. You're raking it in on these Johnny Depp Amber Heard videos. 😂
@KateEleanor
@KateEleanor 2 года назад
Dr. Grande...lost for words...you hit every theme here 100%. Am currently asking the universe to have your insight to translate difficult topics in this way in the next life. Best wishes from the UK ( Johnny..so sorry our judicial system let you down)
@chrism2383
@chrism2383 2 года назад
The fact that the trial is televised and people are making videos about it, show how far our society has fallen.
@trishg8852
@trishg8852 2 года назад
Thank you Dr. Grande! I always appreciate your perspective. I would love to hear your analysis of todays closing arguments? Thank you! 😙
@nyreekrikorian
@nyreekrikorian 2 года назад
I was thinking how easy it would have been for Amber Turd to use his phone to send a text one of those times when he was passed out
@stephanieg6507
@stephanieg6507 2 года назад
These alliteration headlines have given me a little chuckle which has been much needed, thank you Dr Grande
@skylove1336
@skylove1336 2 года назад
Dr. Grande you are killing it the video titles related to this trial
Далее
СПРАВКА ДЛЯ УНИВЕРА
00:44
Просмотров 238 тыс.
Penalty: Portugali - Slloveni
02:03
Просмотров 1,3 млн
Prince Andrew BBC Interview Analysis
10:29
Просмотров 508 тыс.
They forgot something BIG | Asiana Flight 214
31:23
Просмотров 231 тыс.
Prince Andrew Loses Titles | Duke of York Case Analysis
12:52
СПРАВКА ДЛЯ УНИВЕРА
00:44
Просмотров 238 тыс.