@@akhandtripathipyz9888 because he never loved her and the Story turned into a romcom because of 14 year old shippers in the last minute (you cant change my mind. Isayama himself stated that Eren sees mikasa as a motherly figure 😂😂😂)
@@invizzyi disagree about that He had also stated that he makes Mikasa prettier in Eren's pov He also stated that Mikasa is the first character he created and wanted her to be the centre piece of the show.didn't he?
They know that their grandchild is the founding titan. As his name has been mentioned a lot! They probably don’t know that they met him. To them he’s just some devil that lives across the sea.
I honestly do feel so bad for the grandparents. Like they were just trying to live their lives and get by. They got caught up in Grisha’s, Zeke’s, and Eren’s stuff
They just accepted Faye's fate that led to Grisha being who he was and the Episode's title was "Sinners" and they were shown in the episode to show that they paid for it
I don’t feel bad for them dying but don’t hate them either. They were to brainwashed and scared and weren’t brave enough to question the marlyeans and fed their children the same propaganda.
It's chilling because they didn't do anything wrong directly. They were only trying to preserve their own survival, so they were obedient to marley. Deep down, they probably agreed with Grisha, but probably didn't have the courage to say it. They are blamed for zeke's betrayal when they had nothing to do with that and were left imprisoned, unlike all other prisoners, probably as a form of judgment as they were the indirect cause for the rumbling
I agree with everything you said, with one large exception---the "they probably agreed with Grisha, but didn't have the courage to say it". No. Dr. and Mrs. Jaeger were very much "good Eldians" brainwashed by Marley into believing that their people were accursed monsters and deserved to suffer. Now, I do think that they certainly downplayed Faye's death to stave off the destruction of their entire family, but everything else was genuine belief via lifelong indoctrination. People who don't really believe the lies wouldn't tell the Marley-sanctioned history with such passion (in the anime, Dr. Jaeger actually does an excited "fist pump" while talking about how the Eldian Empire was destroyed) or spend time indoctrinating their grandson with false history, to the point of doing it even when he explicitly wanted a normal children's story. I don't think they exactly deserved to be crushed under the skinless feet of The Rumbling, and they certainly lived terrible and deprived lives...but they were much more culpable than it might seem on the surface, and I think they knew it too, hence their reaction when The Rumbling came.
@@stargatecommand714 do you expect them to be a rebell like Grisha? And then end up as a titan? How about you blame holocoust surviver for end up in prison? Eren's grandparent just try to survive inside concentration camp, if it mean they have to lick their oppresser boot to survive then they will do it. Stop blaming the victim for their silence, i bet your parent will do the same if it mean your survival.
But eren Yeager did say his name in the path dimension tho, I think they realize it. Eren never got to be with his grandparents and I understand why he choose his friends over them. (His grandparents is just a status of being his relative) the person he really cares about is his friends.
@@rachavinvitayakovit1408doesn't matter if you know someone well or not, family is the most important part of everyone's life. Family always comes first
@@Philthorn it’s like being force to love someone just because of their status. If u have to choose ur best friend or someone u literally just met (walk up to u and show u guys have the same blood) u r gonna choose that stranger?
It’s possible for sure, but it depends on whether Yeager is a common name. Personally if I was them, I’d find it hard to believe that this ‘Eren Yeager’ is the child of my son who was killed by Marley 20 years ago!
@@TurtleQuirk well I’m guessing news about the incident with Grisha and the ship that took them there was known in Marley. So another Yeager popping up would help them connect the dots
@@TurtleQuirk they were imprisoned because of Sieg's betrail, so they knew Sieg was on Paradis and was in direct contact with that so called Eren Yeager, also the grand pa caught and talked to a 20 yo ( yonger then Sieg but not too much ) weirdo/very suspicious guy, using a young boy from the Grace family to send letters literaly a few days before the declaration of war (which had the same haircut as Grisha).
Every single member of the Jaeger family has been through so much pain, including the grandparents. I liked how the anime went into more detail of The Rumbling.
I knew his Grandparents were killed in the rumbling because I knew that they were on the mainland when the rumbling happened. I read the manga, however it never showed Erens grandparents after his talk with his grandfather on the bench so I just logically assumed, cool that they added the scene in the anime to confirm it.
He did Actually. He used every last ability of attack titan to gain the strongest being in the verse aside Ymir and then also changed peoples views beacuse of his actions and made his friends look like world savers
But at cost of mass genocide which he already saw earlier with his abilities but instead he could have figured a different way out when he already know the future. It looked more like a POSSESSION OF FATE THAT IS INEVITABLE
@@nibirh_Vlogs he said it himself to armin that he saw every possible future that could have happened while he kissed historias hand and the only way to save Paradise was to start rumbling and military of parade were gonna betray and take his titans from him to begin with so he had no time either
@@_ORION1 i guess i forgot that part, watched it along time ago, still there was no other alter way though to fight against a large no. Of military people , the Rumbling was the best way out ..
To think eren killed his mother ate his father abandoned his friends used his newly found brother killed his stepmom and grandparents just to make rumbling happen. That's some dedication
Pretty sure he never abandoned his friends. Eren is that guy who can sacrifice the world but not his friends and they were portrayed like heroes in front of the world at end of manga because of him too
@@badmanjosh6091 why would he try to change it when he wanted to only save the paradise from the beginning. Marley brought it up on them and the pot was full of sins from the beginning anyways. The whole world wanted war with the island and even didn't considered them human so eren just did what a monster would do.
@@badmanjosh6091 well that just means you haven't watched isayamas interview and read the monologue or manga once again. If you still think he did all that for nothing that is
Well you can argue they were to far gone. Trying to rescue those with generation cases of Stockholm syndrome are a lost cause. Even if they were rescued, they would only resent Paradis and do whatever they can to sabotage them.
When I rewatched s4, I realised that HE DID talk to his grandparents. At first, I didn't know it was him and just ignored it and when I found out, there were so many things happening that him talking to his grandparent just slid away which I noticed after rewatching. Man, the fact that they died without even knowing that it was him...
Eren just casually killing his whole family. He ate his dad, had his mom eaten, stepped in his grandparents, and had zeke killed in the process of rumbling.
Eren killed his mom Eren killed his father (In order to acquire his powers) Eren trampled both of his grandparents Eren killed himself (basically allowed himself to be killed by Mikasa) Bro literally game-ended nearly his entire bloodline, only Zeke escaped, and even he still got something (trapped, betrayed and then used)
lol its nothing when you realise eren killed another one of his family member in the end of the series to achieve freedom and that too was the one eren loved the most and started killing titan from season 1
@@kyledeguzman165 right. But he facilitated her death. His dad was a renowned doctor to royalty. Eren couldn't tell Grisha to move his family inwards to the wall or at least tell Grisha to get his mom to be on the other side of the wall before the chaos happens?
@@alexkurowski1159Your brain is too limited to understand reality.Jean, Armin, and others kill thousand of people. Paradise is a fasciat Nation, and Eren has murdered million of Eldian people. There are more Eldian outside the wall
That’s because the guy didn’t start the video correctly. He said “part 3 of AoT” But the informative gave was “Season 4 (part III)” causing anyone currently in season 3 to see this video as safe. -season 4 has 4 parts.-
Isayama want to makesure to let the reader know who is the main character of AOT. The plot armour titan. Jesus even his fried family survive, while everyone else die
Eren: kills dad, mum, grandfather, and grandmother Eren: I just need to kill mikasa now Edit: this made me think: Eren: I've always hated you, mikasa Meanwhile mikasa: has saved eren's life multiple times
The thing is that eren in this story is neither the hero, nor is he the villain. He is just a victim of hatred within the world and someone who fought for freedom no matter the cost of that freedom. The rumbling was that cost, and it had to be done and it was already written as he had visibly ‘seen’ the unchangeable future.
@@stargatecommand714 Eren is not a hero he confirms this himself, the main reason for the Rumbling is for his own freedom and the safety of Paradis Island is only a benefit. Eren does not end the power of the titans he uses it to murder the innocent and not so innocent world because he proves that he is a devil
Because they wouldn’t do a thing any way, them talking to Eren wasn’t going to do a thing considering what he saw them let marleyan soldiers and civilians do to his aunt
@@kyledeguzman165 what I meant is, they can't run away like the other Eldians. Since they were in the jail cell. All they can do is sit there waiting for death to arrive
In the manga, it’s not known if they died or not (though they probably did), so their deaths in the anime are probably a way to abridge the story a bit.
Eldians who live in the luxury of other continents don't deserve Eren's " salvation " . Eren understood this but has no choice . Any Eldian who lived outside the walls will have to bear the consequence to be crushed by their own blood race whom they alienated from . And again sorry for being talking religious stuff . Think of it as a rapture . Christians who stayed faithful to God are taken and the unbelievers or major unforgiven sinners stay to suffer the consequences .
@@roxtechs Oh yeah right ! I think I missed out the point . And yeah even though he has a relative outside the walls , he doesn't treat them as such . His grandparents are just relative by his family name . But the real family he has are the people of Paradis whom they look up to him and friends he fought alongside with . At the end , Eren dies being slain by his own people ( his own people are Mikasa , Armin , Jean , and Connie ) . I didn't count the warriors since they fight for the world which they believe Eren's actions is wrong . And Eren is against the world that would potentially wipe out their island if left untreated . I see Eren Yeager as Andres Bonifacio . The father of the Philippine Revolution who died betrayed by his own country he fought for . Eren is the true father of Eldian Revolution .
@@ErenYeager-zf3td yeah correct killed his own mother to achieve his freedom what a great freedom fighter lol killed 80% of population of earth killed innonect people little children babies what has they did to eren have they oppose him and what to killed the paradise no they just got trample just halil and ramzi those poor children 😥😥😔
Is this even a question, of course he did. Eren killed his own fully innocent and loving mother to achieve his ends. Of course he killed his grandparents without a second thought.
Technically no it was Reiner, its Eren's fault that Dina was the one to do it rather than some other Titan. Carla was screwed from the beginning... manipulating means you are responsible for a lot of things most of which you won't be aware of until the following events unfolds completely.
@@joetad1956 no saving his mother could make things worse. Changing time even a little has dire consequences but all Eren does is little changes here and there which has major ramifications anyway. An example of what happens when you save your mother from death would be The Flash screwing with time is never advised even when you know what you are doing.
@@zenithxabyss8023 da fuq you smoking, Carla legs were broken any other titan would have killed her if not Dina her surviving is as believable as Mikasa walking to Paradis from Marley with Eren's head. Nobody went back to Shiganshina so how would she not be dead. Dina would be alive but not sure why that is a worse out come according to Isayama unless she would get eaten by another pure titan.
I think they knew. Before the rumbling, Eren was public enemy #1. At the declaration of war I’m sure his grandfather or grandfather heard about him or Zeke told them about him.
I have a question, in 138 how did mikasa know that eren was in the mouth? Did she know the whole time? If so then the whole battle on eren could’ve been prevented if they just all went to his mouth from the start
IMO we can’t blame them that much, they were just trying to protect him. If Grisha had believed the Marlyean propaganda like they wanted, then he would’ve had a *much* more quiet life 🤣
Eren was once an innocent boy who had witnessed his mom dying, in that moment he already lost his hopes and dreams everything after that was him pushing past that.
that's why I love this anime it doesnt give stupid fan service it's like writer mind = anime but nowadays it's like fan like = anime and that give a pressure on writer to write something own.. aot was masterpiece whole :)
@@mewthecutest2536 I am not reading manga And I dont about it I just know the writer was right .. And eren also and if not then what? Its just anime For entertainment Why people take entertainment things so seriously Answer : illiterate and stupid!!
@@SGRADECURSE correctly that what i am saying to this eren worshiper lol it just an anime no need to taking this seriously but this stupid poeple think eren was right like killing innocent children like halil and ramzi they were just living there shitty life until eren just killed all of them
One of the points of AoT is showing how conflicts and their consequences impact everyone and that in the end everyone is insignificant in the grand scheme of things.
Considering the name "Eren Yeagar, the enemy of the world" was used many times, I think its fair to believe they at least had some idea they were related to Eren. Remember there was someone on the island with the same surname as Reiner. They were not brothers but were probably linked through same ancestors closer than others were
Yes, but Grampa Yeager didn’t realize he was talking to him in the beginning of Season 4. Though, I think Zeke told them that Grisha started a new family in Paradis.
That part wasn't in the Manga and I ever wonder what happened to them (even though I had a feeling they were dead), still tho it's nice to get some confirmation in the Anime.
He’s grandpa was in the stands after he ate that dude on stage and rush to the stands where his grandpa just looked at him without knowing who he was before war hammer appeared
He also made Dina kill his mother. Dina was supposed to eat Bertholt when they attacked Shinganshina, but Eren steered her away towards his mom, to get the future he wanted. You’ll hear it when he talks with Armin right before he dies.
That's something I didn't understand. Why did he have to trample Marley? The King gave half of his subjects to Marley to save himself. He couldn't have his Rumbling go past Marley and destroy everything else?
I mean they probably know Eren is their grandson. They've definitely heard his name before and Zeke could've told them about him as well since Zeke seemed to be relatively close with them.
So does Zeke actually care about his grandparent? Since he planned on betraying Marley why can't he arrange for his grandparent to be extradited too? Does he not care about them?
