Welcome All! Mando season 3 has sunk Star Wars to a new low of stupid. You can find me on Twitter and Instagram. And do the “Like”, “Subscribe” and “Bell” thing so you don’t miss a video. Cheers!
It is amazing how many people qualify themselves as such, still trying to defend the legion of moronic elements in these scripts. Faverau really needs to stick to running the show and directing, and hang up his keyboard. As does most of the LF writing group.
S Rank comedy construction with the Mythosaur butt vs. Mando Helmet Thing as illustration of better writing, you made 2.5-jokes-in-one instead of plain didactic statement! - Correction: "Mythaurosus"!
OMG Lmmfao. In the Multiverse, Star Wars is to Smart for it's own good. And have highly complex story lines running in Parallel. That there is a Video by Captain Midnight That most Hip Hop and International non english speaking ,fans can't Stand Star Wars claiming "to confusing" and in other words. They to dumb to pick up what Normal people that have a vast awareness of Popculture and a Vocabulary deem basic. But edgy. Makes you think. This Star Wars Spoon Feed you like a dummy. Even the more "Andor Political Thriller. Fell Flat. That was not Jason Bourne is Space. Or James Bond in Space?. Hard Pass. And Mando is Ramboo in Space. Trying to Be. But more flat and no real danger in the Galaxy. I want a future where people on Earth can Go on these Adventures in Space. We can Buy a Ship. And conduct our own experience in Space. At tour own Risk.
Neither. He is a prop to sell toys that was obviously not written into the third season until the managers said "put the merchandiser back in the show or your fired"
@@nathank2289 I disagree. He was always supposed to be in the entire show as the secondary character. They just ham-fisted the Jedi training part in to make him more capable faster, retconning the audience into thinking he's gone to score some cheap emotional points. They should have done a training thing way earlier and not made him so incompetent in the first place. You tell me that, even though his species is slow-growing, 50 years of experience around other people, a lot of that actively being schooled, isn't even enough for his brain to start speaking even basic words? Human babies speak at 2 years, and Grogus' species lives about 10 times as long, so even if you extend linearly, he should be able to speak words at least by the age of 20. I'm fine with Grogu if they made him an actual character. Have him speak actual words and do useful things, and not be basically an annoying escort quest NPC. He could have been cute and awesome like Yoda is. Instead, he's just kind of there.
@@DrTheRich That's possible but unlikely. He came back in the middle of an entirely different show AND that part was not in the "previously on" catch up. Now that he is back he has no agency at all. Before he was R2D2, not a main character but still helped out the team. Now he is C3PO, just there so people can talk to him to fill time. That all tells me he was shoehorned into a show that he wasn't expected to be in. I think before Gina got fired and all John's plans went to shit, Grogu would have trained with Luke to return in the "Avengers Assemble" season.
@@nathank2289 Not at all unlikely. The thing they did with the episode in a different show, just shows their incompetence of planning out and managing the show. But it's pretty obvious, the entire show has always been about the adventures of Mando and Grogu. he isn't just a character he eventually runs into, like Gina's character. from very early in the show they became a clan together. Very obvious he's meant to be a core part of the two man team, even if he just took the role of a droid (bad choice imo). He was in the promo material for the start of the show, before his cuteness was even known. (his hand from the floating pod) It's possible they meant to bring him back later in the season, since his training is supposed to have taken a long time changed that plan when things got messed up. because now they were lacking an important other side character. That doesn't mean he was written off the show, and wasn't meant to be there. It's pretty reasonable to assume his going away always had the primary purpose to increase his capabilities to make him a more active character from then on. Not to get rid of him. Yes Disney itself does a lot for merch, but not literarily everything is only ever about merch for the showrunners. It's reasonable to have become cynical, but that doesn't mean your cynicism is always true. You really think the execs were ok with having their cash cow written of the show from the start, but then change their mind half way through the series? You just got duped by the retconning, you have yet to see it. I'll guess we'll hear more about it as more interviews come out from the creators.
How 😂 first reason why it’s not stupid, that woman doesn’t know that the Jedi and mandalorians had a long heated rivalry 2. Grogu (the mandalorians son) was literally a Jedi and has the force
@@darthnotvader Yeah, and just because you don't know someone is Jewish and lost grandparents at Auschwitz, it doesn't mean they might not be pissed off when you Sieg Hiel at them.
I'm baffled that Bo-Katan has been sitting on that chair for who knows how long and never once took the 5 minutes to fly to Mandalore to check if the air is breathable.
I could be wrong, but doesnt she admit that she knew it was breathable however it was cursed in other ways? Like a living reminder of the death caused there. Not disagreeing with you just something
I'm still confused about how EVERY SINGLE Mandalorian who was following her, even though they already knew she couldn't lead them because of......traditions?......left her on that moon/planetoid. She didn't have ONE friend who was willing to watch her back regardless of everyone else leaving? Not one single Mandalorian was like, "Well, our creed says we stick together by our own people. Guess I'll be the one who stays here with Bo Katan." The protocol droid doesn't count. NOT ONE?!
@@cuffss7455 Not sure, you could be right on that point. But what I'm sure of is that multiple times each episode I have a reaction of "What the. This doesn't make sense." And that makes it hard to enjoy the show.
Would be great to have her do sth else like idk, hunting to eat or something. Would explain how she remains sharp on aim skills while having her actually do something different for once.
Dogma and pre-conceived notions can be blinding. If there was a large and flourishing society of diverse mindsets on her planet, then it would be a bit more surprising. One jaded and traumatized Mandalorian can be excused for her shortsightedness, I think.
Bad Robot’s hands are covered in science fiction blood, as well - they’ve slaughtered Star Wars, Star Trek, Aliens, and Westworld. Anyone affiliated with JJ Abrams should never be allowed to work again.
It's all KK dude. Sure, we think Filoni and Favreau are making this, but she changes what they want to do, to make Star Wars stupid, because she has a vendetta against Lucas.
Some "reliable sources" inside Disney have claimed that the first season of The Mandalorian was actually based on a finished screenplay for a separate Boba Fett movie that was never made. This would help explain the rapid decline in quality and consistency since then, sorta like when Game of Thrones ran out of original material and tried to imitate.
I'm of the opinion that Jon Favreau has had his creativity stifled by Kathleen Kennedy, as seen in Book of Boba Fett. Until that stunted slime is out of Jon's sight for good, Mando and all the other projects he's been behind are going to suck ass. We have evidence that KK has thrown monkey wrenches into projects including but not limited to: greenlighting expensive set pieces and props (Vespas) just because it would piss him off, rewriting scripts to include woke propaganda and/or sequel trilogy bullshit, deadlocking creative decisions Jon wants to take, firing actors and other employees marquis to Jon and Dave's success with their shows--and much more. The proof is in the pudding: anything that managed to get by KK's radar (the triumphant return of Luke Skywalker being chief among them) has been so good for the health of the franchise that the influx of viewers literally crashed the Disney+ servers at one point--a problem Disney is likely never to encounter again. I refuse to believe the same guy who gave us hope that Star Wars would be good again, the same guy responsible for jumpstarting the MCU, the same brilliant partner in crime responsible for many of the creative decisions behind Avatar: the Last Airbender--these geniuses would not drop the ball so hard if it weren't for the literal track record behind their boss. Kennedy has, with evidence to back it up, been jealous of the success of others (particularly men), George Lucas, and the overwhelming support of Star Wars projects made by better minds. We've seen pictures of Luke Skywalker's face being crossed out, we've heard soundbytes of her saying that Gina Corano is going to be a problem; we've seen the deconstruction, emasculation, and assassination of the greatest characters in the galaxy far, far away while promoting infinitely-inferior ones. I find it baffling that Jon Favreau could be even accused of making bad media when his track record speaks for himself, whereas Kathleen Kennedy is constantly defending decisions that have torn down the galaxy and divided the fans of the biggest entertainment franchise in human history. She's the ones who approves the stories, she's the one who kiboshes ideas, and she's the one who insists on butting heads with the one competent creator that's made her money. This is all her.
Honestly would make sense, first season felt like they were throwing bones to the old lore they killed while keeping it in the new disneyfiloniverse. I appreciated it as an old starwars fan but then the second season came out and it just started rapidly going downhill. They took the best bits of boba and put them into mando and when the boba show came they didn’t have anything for him and now they don’t have anything for mando. Hurts to see starwars like this and all the younger kids defend it to the death as that’s all they know. All I know is legends never die.
I like how we wasted the first episode trying to get the IG because it was THE ONLY droid he'd use, but then within 3 seconds in this episode he decides any droid works. That was good.
This is exactly why I loved Andor so much. Unlike this season of mando, it trusts the viewer to pay attention and understand what is going on. This just treats you like you're an idiot with short term memory loss
@@GeeTrieste I don't think any of it is implied. It's presented in a very natural way that relies on assuming that the viewer is following along and remembering the events that have previously taken place. Something that it does very well is cause and effect, because every plot point that happens can be easily traced back to a decision or event from earlier. If it appeared as an overly intricate plot like you say, you might have just missed a few pieces. I don't remember having any issue following along and connecting the events back to their cause
@@GeeTrieste Andor was unfortunate because the audience is in the apathy stage at this point. Almost nobody cares enough to watch it and those very few who do acknowledge that although it's a diamond in the rough, it can't make up for the mountains of horseshit that Kennedyfilm has been shovelling down the audience's throats for the last 8 years.
it's like one of these modern games in which the playable character will never shut up whenever they find a puzzle and think the player is a fucking retarded idiot
How about in the premier they put the helmet on the kid and it makes the “air sealing sound” but the kids hair is sticking out the bottom of the helmet. What the hell is that?
I tried to point out on reddit (my first mistake) how Grogu's rescue doesn't make actual sense in the universe. I was astounded at how many downvotes I got, to the point where they wouldn't even register and someone reported me for suffering mental distress. Guys, we don't have to accept garbage, even in a story that we enjoy.
The sooner you turn your back on Reddit, the better. There are good posts here and there, especially from 5-10 years back, but you won't find anything worthwhile on any of the bigger mainstream boards like "StarWars", "Music", "Movies" or any of the "circlejerk" boards. The format of the site had potential, but the users ruined everything. Being a "Redditor" is not a good thing. You can pick out these insufferable people in a crowd. All they know is to consoom, get excited for the next thing, consoom some more, and hit downvote at the first sight of a comment they disagree with.
@@Dousch There's some good subreddits on there that are much more cynical and critical in nature for several franchises. They're not all just astroturfed echo chambers of forced positivity and corporate propaganda. I recommend r/Saltierthancrait for starters, they have an endless supply of good memes and blunt discussions about all things Disney Star Wars; I think you'll find their takes on Mandalorian, Kenobi, BoBF etc. *far* more authentic and nuanced than something like r/StarWars and the like.
I think that the perfect "show dont tell" is when anikin was staring in to the window to padme in revenge of the sith, it is pure silent but there is so much story telling going on
Yes, and on the Disney+ version they added a Palpatine VoiceOver to that scene which ruined the moment and once again shows disney thinks their audience are idiots.
The worst part about her complaining about mandalorians killing each other is that she literally dedicated her life and betrayed her sister to do the exact thing she complained about
Truth. The b*tch who got her sister killed is now acting around as the wronged princess. God! There was not even a mention of Satine and her peacekeeping ways. The entire monologue in ep2 was such BS
@@ggt47 Continuity Error. Disney doesn't care enough about being consistent to really bother a proper retcon... plus, we all know they'll reverse this "new continuity" soon enough.
Which she should remember, not just because she did it, but because every character has watched all the previous Star Wars movies and meta-games the shit out of their role in the galaxy.
@@nephicus339 I can’t tell if this is disagreeing or agreeing with my comment but if it’s disagreeing it’s dumb because she was only in rebels(I think and if she was only like 2 episodes) and clone wars for like 8 combined episodes and the depiction of her character is literally the mandalorian culture of being warriors which causes her to rage a war against her own sister to go back to fighting instead of peace and her statement in mando show is just infuriating cause the writer wrote that part in the clone wars and should know this
I did just to watch Clone Wars S7 and for pirates of the caribbean in english, basically i spend €8 for weekend never watched anything else and i will never renewed it
I will never ever get over how short sighted the costume director is. This character with the frizzy hair and messed up mouth clearly looks like some sort of mechanic but her clothing looks like its fresh out of the laundry. On a desert planet but no dust or discoloration. Clothes look brand new...almost like they're a prop more than the outfit they wear every day.
Most of the costuming on that entire show is terrible. Everybody looks like they belong in a theme park. Everything looks fresh, and clean, and never been worn before.
@@Luthiart bro the other mandalorians are the absolute worst. Mismatched armor colors and ill fitting helmets and everything. Like fuck. Don’t they have spray paint in the Star Wars universe?
@Jacob I'm a little more forgiving of that. Since the Mandalorians have been forced to eek out an existence on the fringes of society, and are low on resources, it kind of makes sense for their armor to look scavenged and cobbled together (not to mention; I'm sure Mandalorians care more about function than fashion). It would be less believable if they all had shiny, new armor that looked like they just bought it yesterday (like all the rest of the costumes on that show).
Disney: How about a planet in Outer rim gets attacked, warns Captain Teva, which is traveling throughout the entire galaxy to the inner rim for a burocracy meeting which fails, so he moves to the outer rim/mid rim to convince mandalorians, which will hold a evening TED talk, to start preparing and starting the next day :D
Thing I love about this channel is that you actually learn why the show is bad, robot head doesn't just sit there crying like most channels, he rips it apart scene by scene
@@nathank2289 Yeah, most just cry "bad because woke" when Robot Head and the Drinker explain why EXACTLY this EXACT bullshit is bad. It's a lot more entertaining.
@@wellendowedplatypus9024 yet ultimately it’s bad because it’s woke 😂 so y’all’s cognitive dissonance seems to prefer one telling over the other apparently 🤔 the bucktooth scavenger we keep visiting is there why again? Bo Katan is a girl boss while mando is clumsy why again? Where’s Gina again? Etc etc
Another reason Baby Yoda is still in the show is because he's the only toy that sells. Disney is still trying to get their money back on those Sequel toys that didn't sell.
The baby Yoda fad is over. Anyone who wanted to buy the merchandise has already done so by now. Chainmail and round disk thing versions of baby yoda toy aren't going to make them buy another.
@@RoboticPope mhmm. It's reflective in this season's ratings. Baby Yoda doing pointless shit ain't drawing anyone in anymore and people are realizing how boring the show really is.
I can't believe how small scale they have made the Star Wars galaxy in this show. Essentially Mando had no life prior to season 1 episode 1 and now he is in continual contact with the people he has since met. Oh, except for Cara Dune who is now noticeably absent when you see everyone else constantly returning.
I feel like the sequels had the opposite problem: it felt like the galaxy was a conveyor belt of new planets full of the dozen new aliens they thought each movie needs.
It's actually amusing how fast they were able to destroy Mandalorian. It kicked off so strong, at least in my opinion. A western vibe. Unexpected father-child bond. Exploring culture of mandalorians for the first time. Taking a look at post Episode VI Star Wars for the first time (Sequels are not canon as far as I'm concerned). And then suddenly, everything is pointless. Grogu was supposed to stay with Luke. That was the whole grand quest. But now he is back with Mando, as if there was no Season 2. Moff Gideon was supposed to be dead. Mando was tracking him down for countless episodes leading to a final showdown. But now he is back, as if there was no Season 2. The cult of Din's Mandalorians were supposed to be basically extinct. But now there is more of them then there was in Season 1. As if there was no Season 2 (and 1). It suddenly became apparent to me, that this show is about nothing. Whatever happens, can be just undone next season. Whatever the goal of the quest is, it's probably not gonna matter in a few episodes. They are just gonna milk this show until it's worse than Rebels, and then it'll come to an awkward resolution. It's sad to say really, but Mandalorian should've ended with Season 2. It was a satisfying conclusion of the series. There was no reason for Din and Grogu to ever meet again other then to just milk the show. It finally became obvious to me.
I agree with your points. Not only that Grogu was supposed to stay with Luke, they had to do the Mandalorian show dirty by reuniting Grogu with Din in the Book of Boba Fett show. IMO, the Mandalorian Season 1 & 2 are really good, while The Book of Boba Fett was mediocre at best, and that's why they make an episode about Grogu's reunion with Din there to make people watch and get invested in the show because the two characters that we like and care about show up in there.
Friend of mine and I constantly chat about movies and stories and come up with better ideas for them. Boba Fetts show should have been him deciding to become a mandolorian warlord following what his father taught him, becoming and opposing force to Bo Katan and the Cult. All three of which should be building their forces and trying to convince Mando to join their side, turning it into a large political military situation. Which then ends with an empire remnant group showing up and they call a truce to destroy them. Mando ends up uniting them as one people with different clans and they start the restoration of Mandolore. I threw in that an interesting end would be that due to Mandos relationship with Grogu and the other jedi that they make peace and the Mandolorians assist the Jedi by going with them for exploration and peace keeping. Now, this isn't the best story that could be done, but we came up with it in like 10 minutes and ita waaaaay more interesting than what we've got since season 2
How naive we were in season one when we thought we would be exploring the vast galaxy and infinite possibilities. Mando literally only meets the people he has met in previous seasons. It's even the same Republic police officers who keep meeting up with him.
@@johndodo2062 FR, the first season was half nostalgiabation with endless "references" breaking up the story. The parts that were actually new were pretty good. But that's maybe 30% of the show.
Jar Jar was actually important to the story, he guided Qui Gon and Obi-Wan to Oto GunGan (the underwater city) and in Attack of the Clones, his vote was the one that put Palpatine as The Senate.
Plus, JarJar was a secret Sith Master. If he wasn't, then there's no particular reason he is coincidentally present for the events. It could just be terrible storytelling, but, JarJar is present for these events inexplicably. He shouldn't necessarily be there. And if he were Force Sensitive, it would have been obvious to at least 3 other Jedi in the same room. Especially around his later role as senator. After all, episode 2, when the transport ship is attacked, Senator Binks steps in quickly as a backup for the former Queen.
@@theunknowncommenter725 that was the point though- the fool/trickster archetype - he was meant to be Lucas’s *Keyser Söze* Fooling everyone but pulling the puppet strings all along.
Why not? Idiots are the common denominator. It's why intelligent films and other works of art are ignored by the masses while Marvel movies make up a significant percent of the box office market. If you make your product consumable and attractive to morons, you're going to make more money. It's my theory on why woke ideology and leftism as a whole exists despite meteoric business failures across the board. Companies think it's easy money; they think losing a few "close-minded" individuals will net them success, when in reality it's the people with SUCCESS and MONEY who pay their bills.
@@darrellpowell6042 That was the intention, not the result. Literally every age group enjoys SW and that intention disappeared with Empire Strikes Back anyway.
This has been evident since Force Awakens. With the forced, slapstick "humour", the cheapening of moments that are meant to carry huge emotional weight behind them by simply retconning them in the next scene, or their inability to string together stories with anything other than thinly veiled, easy-to-see-coming-twists.
Is this the Marvel-ifying of Star Wars you're describing? Not sure if they're trying to emulate their initial success, or if the writers just occupy the same incestuous intellectual gene pool.
@@darrellpowell6042 True, but going back to ANH then, compare that to the Force Awakens and tell me they're both the same in terms of one being more or less directed to kids? I'd say TFA has taken the "being for kids" thing to the extreme. The originals were intended for children, but they didn't spoon feed everything to them.
@@darrellpowell6042 And you have to remember children's media are done by respecting the imagination and intelligence of children so as to appeal to all ages. The Phantom Menace is a children's movie because of the stand-in Jar Jar, but it's just as much a children's movie with the Senate and political intrigue. Pull the children up, not talk down to them.
Am I the only one who wishes they could go to bed one night and wake up the next morning to learn that the entire experience of Disney Star Wars was just a bad dream?
I was really hoping Bo Katan was going to team up with Mof Gideon to defeat their common enemy: Din Djarin. He has the dark Saber which Bo wants and Grogu which Gideon wants. What an epic twist that would be.
There was once a genre of films in Mexican cinema, the masked wrestler movie. They weren't heavy on plot, or even action, and the directors often padded out screen time by *showing* the hero driving his car from point A to point B. I haven't watched any of this Diswarz dreck, but what I just saw here seems to use that same technique, and for much the same purpose. ='[.]'=
I was amazed how bad the writing was in Book of Boba,the guy tackled Black Krrsantan and went straight into a guilottine from him,even tho its established that even weaker wookies such as Chewbacca can rip arms of people with ease,yet he survived without a scratch (again 0 sense) and was fine 2 minutes after he got punched in the head with spiked knuckles that Black K had (even tho a regular punch should be enough to kill him) Then Black K bear hugged him and they played a back braking sound followed by comically looking face,because a second later there was no damage to Boba at all Also Boba going into the Sarlacc pit with his ship at such close range,was idiotic af,since his armor is unbreakable,he could just bomb the sarlac and then enter the cavity/body,to get his armor,but no he had to look str8 into the sarlac from 2 ft.with his whole ship,and they almost blew themselves up I wont mention the comically slow speeder chase scene it was str8 out of Scary Movie or Harold and Kuumar or some shi,the mos espa street gang was laughable and didnt fit the SW universe at all,they looked more like something out of Cyberpunk and not Star Wars Anyways i think mandalorian has been good for the first 2 seasons,and dont dislike the 3rd one as much as everyone else,but i can see a drop in quality of writting Like why would they train on this planet where they get jumped by huge ass creatures and murdered all the time,no sense at all
Wait… so the whole grogu lassie moment was taking place as they were fighting? So…. There was no in between showing a concurrent battle? Or mando really well hidden?
This has gone exactly as expected. Boca Raton shows up and is immediately elevated. Saving the day left and right. Every time I turn around she's getting bestowed some form of "the highest honor". She swoops in and is immediately appointed tactical leader over all these hardened Manolorians. Oh, and btw, she no longer has to wear her helmet because she's so much better than the rest of you.
that robot creature took it from mando, bo katan took it from that robo and wrecked it. so actually making a big thing of it at the end of the season would be a unnecessary failure because she already owns the darksaber again, right? :D
@@DG-sj7hz Mandalorians have some kind of relics fetish To rule them you Need a particolar mcGuffin (the saber or a maks, depend from the era) and without It they Will shatter their society in less than 10 seconds😂
"Did you think your dad was the only mandalorian?" There is literally no reason for Bo Katan to say this to Grogu. Other example: Mandolorians running out of fuel right when they need to save the kid.
And when they run out of fuel they mention how this keeps on happening, which makes the whole bit about not shooting it down to save the kid moot. As far as they are concerned the kid is as good as dead as soon as he's snatched. Also if this keeps happening, why haven't they already gone and killed it? They seem to be content with letting the dragon keep snatching and eating their kids... then there's the fact that they some how get to the nest before it gets there, that whole section was one stupid thing after another.
@@Impulse_GuyI was like when they arrived at the nest...why sleep the night, when the chances of the childs survival comes costs any second before it's too late???
Writing and visual arts in film are like dance partners. Both are equally important as they move together in harmony, one always complimenting the other. Something seriously lacking when it comes to Disney. They are ruining everything they touch and the sad part is there are plenty of dullards out there to lap it up.
Your story about getting stuck in a Mythosaur's ass and all he had to do to save himself was to take off his helmet was absolutely perfect! I can't stop laughing. That's good story telling for sure! 😂 Love it!
Episode 3 is a sucker punch to anyone who thinks this show may remotely stray for even the slightest bit from connecting to the hot garbage of the last trilogy. Disney wrote off so many books and comics as not cannon. Stories that are far superior that what they’ve made just so then can give us something “fresh”. My 10yr old self back in the day would be crying at the horror if he knew the future of Star Wars.
Thank you Robot Head for being the first reviewer to notice that those monsters looked exactly like the Morlocks from the Time Machine,I’ve made that comment on other reviewer’s post not one has acknowledged this. Oh well I guess they never saw the Time Machine movies by HG Wells
Pretty sure Bo Katan literally names them "Moroks"! It's only one letter off! In fact I'm gonna say that it was just straight up plagiarism so they didn't have to come up with a new design.
Here's an arc that'd be far more interesting for the character. Din having never been to Mandalore could've been the setup for some good stories and interactions as his cult had always prided themselves on being "true" Mandalorians, but when he arrives he realizes that everything he knows about the planet from his tribe is all wrong and he's treated like an outsider by the residents of the planet because he's essentially the Star Wars version of a foreign weeb going to Japan and thinking its gonna be exactly like anime.
This is what happens when you hire someone based upon their declared identity to write and direct existing intellectual property programming and movies. These people outright say that they hate the fanbase and they have no knowledge of the source material. How or why Disney think that's a sustainable model is beyond me.
Amazing! In school when we learn to write, they teach you that if you show a cow on screen, there is no necessity to explain through dialogue that you are showing a cow. Their writing is so bad. It's like failing at 2+2.
Just realised mando goes to bo katan saying hes gonna go to mandalore and asks about the mines in the same system as mandaolore then goes to the outer rim where tatoonie is to get the driod then goes back to the mandolore system 😂😂
Apparently Coruscant is protected by about 2 TIE fighters and Bo Katan's Palace has no shields, ground defences or air support. The Mandalorians all live in one cave next to a lake of giant monsters. No defences. They all train in the open, despite being 'in hiding'. This has fallen apart faster than a cardboard sledgehammer.
It has always been a bit overhyped but it was still some watchable entertainment especially in comparison to what else has gotten released these years. It just dropped to the same levels as those now.
Jeez, how quickly does Mando fall to the bottom of that lake/pool thing? Bo-Katan has to use her jets to get down there, but she jumps in literally seconds after Mando falls. On the way back up it looks like hundreds of feet… That makes no sense - much like everything else in this once-promising show.
There was nothing to imply that he was pulled under. And he would have known if he had been grabbed down. No, they just don't know how water buoyancy works.
That's scary. Mandalorian is just a government prop. They need to put women in charge of the show in order to get women pumped to join the military via DRAFT. Our military has been shrinking for 50 years it's smaller than ever. DUE TO ALL THINGS SCIENCE nuclear war should be happening anytime now and they need to draft women and lgbtqa like they do in Israel...It's that simple. The government has had their hands in the Superman comics and more since the beginning- using it as WWII propaganda. That's what's happening. I just didn't know it was so effective...
It’s like the show doesn’t understand that Bo Katan is already a well established and liked character in Star Wars. It’s tearing down Din to make Bo look better by comparison in a bad attempt to make us like her an I’m just like “STOP I ALREADY DO LIKE HER!” All this will do is make people dislike her now.
How does the suit we have been told they CAN NEVER REMOVE while flying through space and taking jobs that can take them to literally ANY planet in any solar system not have something that analyzes the atmosphere?!?
I was so happy when Grogu left with Luke. I felt that story was over and it was time for mando to move on and go on other adventures. And this entire helmet thing is driving me crazy especially the we all eat separately scene. Thanksgiving must be a joy at a Mando’s house.
I think having Din remove his helmet TWICE killed something for me, it makes the whole helmet thing pointless now. Should never have had his face reveal at all ever.
“Killing each other… made us weak” Umm how? Is she saying that weak mandalorians killed all the strong ones? Because that, like most everything in neostarwars, makes no sense.
The irony of video game dialogue being in Mandalorian making it bad is that Respawns Jedi Fallen order and Survicor games have been everything we've wanted in a Star Wars story. How is it an actual video game has better writing than a show with a big budget?
Mando really has just become an open world videogame where everyone just sits and waits for the hero (Grogu) to have the time to come back and help move the plot along. Which is good I guess because most people would die from having 6 tubes draining your blood in the time it takes to travel between planets.
Crazy how this thing Obi Wan once said to Luke eventually turned out to be a universal phrase known and used by any good character, jedi or not, of any era in SW... so fucking dumb...
Here is what I don't understand about Mondolorian. They said it was Pedro Pascal, then we find out "well it's not always him in the suit," then we find out "well it's only him in the suit when you see his face, he's actually just voicing it," but to me it doesn't even sound like him. So WTF was the point of having Pedro Pascal?
I feel the same way. It's like watching an entirely different show right now that is excruciatingly bad.. or was I just imagining the others were good?
Sounds like you are becoming more critically aware. That's good; you've taken your first step into a larger world...where there are fewer and fewer quality films and programmes.
@@KeldorDAntrell Not so much that ( I always have been critical as I'm an eternal cynic!). Mando is essentially a TV show made up fetch quests, and I hate fetch quests as they get boring fast. It's a show made up of filler content and no substance. I have no desire to watch even the two episodes that were good again, so even they weren't exactly good either. One positive I feel that has come from the pandemic, is people watched a lot of older movies, TV etc, and noticed a serious decline in quality and have since checked out. Story telling and character growth have simply been replaced by 'the message' and cut and paste levels of creativity. I never really watched TJ Hooker when I was a kid, but I'm loving it at 49! Not great, but o so much better. But it still pales in comparison to Miami Vice. Or at least the first two seasons.
One was good, not amazing, just solid. It was surrounded so by so much Star Wars rubbish it was a shinning light that the universe was getting better so the fans supported it. Sadly as soon as it was successful it think it lost its independence and all the hacks jumped in.
Mandalorians pre disney: warrior culture with brutal initations rituals, love of the hunt and battle and in ancient times newely conquered the galaxy and barely lost against the entite military of the old republic, a splinter faction of jedi and the at the time galaxies greatest taction. Mandalorians in disney era: abunch of clowns with a silly rule about armor and babysit product placement.
I needed this. I couldn't put my finger on what had changed or why I wasn't enjoying the show anymore, even though I was kind of happy about Bo Katan's part in the story. I could feel myself wincing so many times without stopping to ask myself why. (In robot voice: "THIS IS MANDO. THIS IS GOOD. MUST LIKE MANDO") With my legs cut off, my body on fire, and me yelling "I HATE YOU!!!" I will claw my way to Asoka barely clinging to Star Wars life. Just maybe Paps will save me and put some armor on my burns and bring me back to life. NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Another perfect example is in Saving Private Ryan, where Ryan mentions that he has trouble remembering his brothers' faces, and Miller tells him to not just remember them as people in and of themselves, but to remember a context that's important. For Miller, he mentions that he doesn't just think of his wife, but rather how he would watch her gardening happily in the yard, and the specific pair of gloves she wore. Then we get Matt Damon ad-libbing the hilarious story about how two of his brothers played a prank on the third while he was about to lose his virginity. Damon does a perfect job with delivering the story beats, plenty of fitting emotion, and paints a clear mental picture for the audience, so we can enjoy the same context that's important when delivering that kind of storytelling/expository dialogue.
"Mandalorians fighting eachother for reasons no one understands" Its weird hearing that from her of all people. Didnt she herself start a war against Mandalore, for the not-at-all hard to understand reason of taking over the planet for herself in season 7 of TCW?
To be honest with you, I've thought every season of every Disney Star Wars show has been written poorly. It varies from film student amateur to absolutely God awful.
Same here. They are like fan videos at best. A few minutes of brilliance like the ATST chase or Luke crushing the dark trooper. But most of it is a fetch quest in a videogame with barely passable writing to remind you what they are doing.
@@lukem726 No it wasn't, it had a good speech or two but it was a 5/10 show at best. Fans are just starved for anything that isn't Last Jedi levels of crap. Kotor 2 was good writing, X-wing: Rouge Squadron was good writing, Empire Strikes Back was good writing; Andor was "Revenge of the Sith was better than Phantom Menace at least" writing.
they have to be trolling at this point. what is this red head female character?? what even is she? it's like they're trying to troll us by introducing a character that can only be described as "space karen" headband and all
@@basteagui Clone Wars is before Disney fucked up Star Wars. It's worth watching (you can skip season 1 though) if only because it helps the prequels not suck. Rebels sucked but the last episode is an epilogue to CW.
we need to stop letting these big companies get away with making horrible to mediocre content for us, we deserve better movies and shows and they deserve less praise.
This season feels like a fever dream. I loved season 1 and wasn't as keen on season 2 but still enjoyed it. This though? This is written like the phantom menace.
Once they let Boba Fett air, I knew we were in trouble for this season. That shit should have been shelved for the good of the brand. No balls, no leadership and no creativity left.
i finished season 1 and although some episodes were good most were subpar. the mandalorian is regarded as the biggest badass in the universe but in almost every episode he stumble bumed thru a fight only not getting killed by shear luck or happenstance. watched 2 ep of the 2nd season and gave up on it. now im getting far more entertainment watching reviwes of season 3 and laughing my ass off. we had made a grave error trusting in Jon Favreau. star wars is dead.
@@Eviscerator03 shit! i forgot about andor. i really enjoyed it. felt weird watching a quality star wars show. everything else is crap. looking forward to the 2nd and final season. how did kennedy not detroy it!
... I should thank Disney/Favreau for giving us The Scribbles of Fredo Fett. It killed any interest I had for future Star Wars projects from them, so it's nice I'm happy I gave this a hard pass.
I never bothered with the spin offs, it was Movies or nothing for me after reading "Han Solo at Stars End".* So I enjoyed Boba Fett as I had no expectations of it. But from what I've found out after about Boba's character prior to that, it makes me wonder if the show was planned as The Mandalorian season 3 storyline - Mando freeing Navarro from corruption, Grogu getting brassed off with Luke, last minute reunion and off for season 4. Maybe they changed it after Gina Carano's sacking. Using Boba & Fennec instead of Mando and Cara. Just a thought. * I don't know if that makes me a true fan, a non-fan or just a fartabout fan.
@@zacmumblethunder7466 BOBF completely shattered my care for future Star Wars and Disney Plus shows. Or at least Disney Star Wars. Andor was the exception. This 6 episode act structure does not work for every character.
This season is so bad that I'm going to rewatch the previous 2 seasons and pretend anything afterwards is just bobafett having a dream in the bacta tank.
Disney is convinced that they can package turds with a Star Wars sticker and still make a buck. Sad part is, they're right. People just line up for this shit.
Bringing baby yoda back has killed the show, they could have done something interesting without him but Disney would rather sell merch than tell a good story. Plus mando isn’t the main character in his own show.
To have Bo Katan save Mando twice in one episode is the point at which I dropped the series. They made Mando a weakling just like they did Boba Fett. I want to watch Mando be heroic and cool, not Bo Katan. It's now garbage for me and I don't plan on watching further.
What Disney has done to Star Wars is a whole new level of failure. If this were archery, a normal failure would be snapping the bow string or missing the target. Disney found a way to shoot themselves right in the ass with the bow, which is an achievement that blows my mind.
They make an episode in THE MANDALORIAN where Boba Fett steals the whole episode, then Mando steals 3 episodes in THE BOBA FETT SHOW and lastly Bo Katan steals the whole MANDALORIAN show. What's next? Star trek stealing the star wars as a whole?
