Тёмный

Does The Future Exist? 

The Science Asylum
Подписаться 679 тыс.
Просмотров 346 тыс.
50% 1

The concept of a space-time seems to suggest both the past and the future already exist and that the freedom of choice is an illusion. However, a deeper look into cause and effect, locality, light cones, and infinitesimals still leaves an opening for freewill.
________________________________
VIDEO ANNOTATIONS/CARDS
Ultimate Guide to Relativity:
• The Ultimate Guide to ...
How Fast Is Light?
• How Fast Is Light?
Is The Universe Infinite:
• Is The Universe Infinite?
Is Math the Language of the Universe?
• Is Math the Language o...
________________________________
HUGE THANK YOU TO THESE PATRONS
** Daniel Bahr, Ilya Yashin, Drake Dragon (TMDrake), Morgan Williams, Rick Finn, Kevin MacLean, David Bronakowski, Robert J Zapolis, Nicholas Ursa, Evgeny Ivanov **
________________________________
SUPPORT THE SCIENCE ASYLUM
Patreon:
/ scienceasylum
Advanced Theoretical Physics (eBook):
gumroad.com/l/ubSc
Merchandise:
shop.spreadshirt.com/scienceas...
________________________________
LINKS TO COMMENTS
Future Predetermined:
• Why Do Things REALLY F...
• Why Do Things REALLY F...
• Why Do Things REALLY F...
• Why Do Things REALLY F...
Universal Reference Frame:
• The Ultimate Guide to ...
Featured Comments:
• How Fast Is Light?
• How Fast Is Light?
________________________________
IMAGE CREDITS
NASA Big Bang:
• NASA | The Big Bang
RU-vid Silver Play Button:
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...

Опубликовано:

 

2 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.   
@safiya4339
@safiya4339 5 лет назад
This is profound, taking physics into its border zone with spirituality. Younger viewers than me (ie virtually all of you) will not be able to appreciate how lucky you are to live in an age where you can access this so easily. People like Nick may be the true heroes of our age.
@markfuller
@markfuller 2 года назад
I think what this leads to is "mindfulness." Existing in the moment. Thoughts are about the past or future. It has a spiritual tone to it (Eckhart Tolle). But, there are basic principles involved (don't think; exist in the moment. The past & future are constructs. Like a snail remembering something it picked up from its elevated "eyes." It's just a matter of degrees. All that is real is *now*.). That kind of stuff naval-gazing to me in the past. But, it really is like the inverse of waht you said. Taking spirituality (existence) to a border of physics. There's only one moment (now) in the universe. We're the only things stitching past and future into now (snails too, to some lessor extent). What turned me onto this way of thinking was a RU-vid channel mindfulPeace. They had these two videos: "Guided Mindfulness Meditation on the Present Moment. Be Here Now." The other is gone now. They've created a slew of new videos. But, that one (and the one gone now) were very basic. About recognizing your own thoughts as they arise. Differentiating between being in the now vs self-talk, rumination.
@SB-lc2vd
@SB-lc2vd 2 года назад
Exactly! Well said Feroze
@99fulgur
@99fulgur 2 года назад
That's why studying science is amazing, studing how the universe work is looking deep inside of us because we are all part of this thing that we don't know what it is, but we know that it's happening right now but we are not different from chemical reaction or physic forces, we are made of matter and energy the two things that make this universe we are indeed the universe itself, the line that separe our complexity of our body and the rest, is just immaginary.
@Warlord_Megatron
@Warlord_Megatron 2 года назад
Yeah I really appreciate it.
@martinmartin3490
@martinmartin3490 2 года назад
I was born in the 80s in Central America, no electricity, no internet. Im addicted to learn more about the nature of reality and because i dont have the mental capacity neither the education about these kind of stuff i appreaciate these youtubers, Arvin, Nick, Alessandro, Fermilab and PBS. Unfortunetely (most) people born after the year 2000 are more concerned about TikTok, hip hop and pornography, maybe when you grow up with scarcity wondering about God and the universe is a good thing to help you appreaciate the answers your are given so easily driven by your curiosity.
@catalogiccat4206
@catalogiccat4206 3 года назад
I know Nick isn't intentionally motivating us, but I feel very relativistically optimistic at the end.
@miti3369
@miti3369 3 года назад
Pessimistic instead in review 😄😄😄😄😄
@markkennedy9767
@markkennedy9767 4 года назад
I love how you have three characters with three different approaches to any subject: Yourself, the "wow" guy and the nerd guy. Each with their own strengths and weaknesses.
@Dina-he1uc
@Dina-he1uc 3 года назад
I have taken calc 1, 2 and 3, and I never understood what dx meant. Now I’m watching this video for fun, and I think you have just explained my whole calculus career. Thank you so much
@its_robbietime1333
@its_robbietime1333 2 года назад
dx means a really really small change in x sometimes written as delta(x)
@Dina-he1uc
@Dina-he1uc 2 года назад
@@its_robbietime1333 I am aware , I knew the definition but this video really put it into perspective and gave me the best visual I have ever seen
@its_robbietime1333
@its_robbietime1333 2 года назад
@@Dina-he1uc oh okay thats greatto hear
@bestopinion9257
@bestopinion9257 2 года назад
You just need to learn things one after another, in order. For sure that info is written somewhere in the beginning.
@wildk5367
@wildk5367 2 года назад
How!? I learned in this in my literal first lesson in high school calculus
@ArifRezaBD
@ArifRezaBD 6 лет назад
I almost closed the window. Then I remembered I didn't press the like button. I reloaded the page and liked. It would be a sin to not like your video.
@abhaysharma966
@abhaysharma966 6 лет назад
I also scrolled up after reading your comment but then i scrolled down to like such a genuine comment for the praise of such an interesting channel and person.
@timhaldane7588
@timhaldane7588 5 лет назад
It would be a cos not to like your comment.
@hrantk6397
@hrantk6397 5 лет назад
Timothy Haldane nice one😂😂😂
@darkseid856
@darkseid856 5 лет назад
Yes ! And the punishment is that you will not get sec
@sjakierulez
@sjakierulez 4 года назад
If you didn't close, then why did you reload?
@FGj-xj7rd
@FGj-xj7rd 6 лет назад
Have no idea you don't have 100K subs yet. You upload some of the best science related videos I have ever seen. Edit: 7:21 Gradient is calling fake news on this one.
@FGj-xj7rd
@FGj-xj7rd 6 лет назад
Probably the greatest video you have done.
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
I'm pretty sure I'll hit the mark this summer... but, if we're being honest, the active and (mostly) positive comment section I get on my videos is more important to me than a sub count. The sub count only matters to the YT algorithm and for gauging how much the channel is worth to sponsors. Those are less important than the connection I make with viewers.
@FGj-xj7rd
@FGj-xj7rd 6 лет назад
Thanks for the reply. It made my day 👍
@semmering1
@semmering1 6 лет назад
There is nothing similar I have ever seen here in Europe - congratulations to you and your team - simply excellent - subscibers +1 ;-)
@ianstephens333
@ianstephens333 6 лет назад
And that's what makes you a true scientist
@badmath9099
@badmath9099 3 года назад
Wow the end of that video was amazing! This entire channel is such a gold mine of information. Thank you very much for having so many beautiful topics that you cover. I can't believe I'm only stumbling upon this channel in 2021!
@midnightdragonfly9707
@midnightdragonfly9707 3 года назад
And I chime in on the gold mine. Aligning all his videos with my knowledge has become a fun and rewarding past time
@suomeaboo
@suomeaboo Год назад
I love the role of Nerd Clone. He's there to remind the viewers that the reality is more complex and that some things are simplified, but for good reason.
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum Год назад
Yep. That's exactly why he's there.
@MrValinterama
@MrValinterama 6 лет назад
Hello Nick! I remember that I read a very interesting and well-written book on physics, which helped me to understand more about tensors and quantum mechanics, when I was studying at university a few years ago. I accidentally discovered your channel surfing the youtube a couple of months ago. By now I think I have watched all of your videos, and I really love them!). What a surprise was for me when I realized, that the book was actually written by you). I couldn^t finish it all at that time, but I^m definitely gonna buy it now. I teach maths and physics to high school students myself, and your videos improved my understanding and answered some of my questions about gravity and relativity. So THANK YOU very much, keep up the good work and I wish you good luck in your future projects and in your life!!!
@peterkokarchev6141
@peterkokarchev6141 6 лет назад
What is the name of the book?
@MrValinterama
@MrValinterama 6 лет назад
Peter Kokarchev The one in the description to this video, Advanced theoretical physics
@seeker869fm2011
@seeker869fm2011 6 лет назад
There's not a suitable "Like" function for this kind of work, in every aspect. Perception, structure, presentation - all of the highest level possible. Nick Lucid, a true genious of our time, dealing with concepts only a few people can and doing so in an innovative, unique way - not copying left and right as we so often see happening on RU-vid - and still managing to let us all get a pretty good idea of what he tries to convey. Just brilliant, absolutely brilliant!
@chrismcgarry3160
@chrismcgarry3160 3 года назад
1:11 I dunno how many Subs you had back then, but grats on your 100k-sub prediction! See ya in the 1M-Sub timeline! 2:21 I also have that nerd-voice in my head that tries to think in 4D when I watch vids about spacetime XD 6:14 That "CalculUs" joke! I almost spit my tea at the end of the rhyme XD 7:09 Nice ending there! Made me feel all warm & fuzzy inside, just after giving me anxiety XD
@JavierArveloCruzSantana
@JavierArveloCruzSantana 5 лет назад
Not only do I come in for the videos, Nick, but I always read at least the first 100 comments every time! I. LOVE. THIS. CHANNEL. AND. I. LOVE. YOUR. FOLLOWING. CRAZIES!
@paule.2687
@paule.2687 6 лет назад
wow this is the best free will explanation I've seen on youtube, thank you Nick, I'll be recommending your channel to my friends fast fast!
@KeithCooper-Albuquerque
@KeithCooper-Albuquerque 6 лет назад
Nick: Another great video! Your videos are starting to get through my thick skull! Please keep them coming!!!
@kamranzamanifarahani3306
@kamranzamanifarahani3306 5 лет назад
You are brilliant. The way you expand, delve and explain is unique...
@thestragequack3598
@thestragequack3598 2 года назад
I had always tried to understand what the heck is the light cone, watched dozens of videos, consulted many teachers but just couldn't get it. You did that in a mere minute. You're just awesome!😙
@peteranthonydaniel
@peteranthonydaniel 6 лет назад
Fantastic work 'again' nick.. ..'FANTASTIC'!!. Every time i watch your work, a whole load of fuzzy misconceptions i might have half learned from outer sources are clarified and then fall instantly into place! ..wonderful.. ..simply wonderful!
@georgiosringos3286
@georgiosringos3286 3 года назад
Exactly
@nachannachle2706
@nachannachle2706 6 лет назад
This is so nicely done! I didn't expect you to develop this question into the realm of freewill and determinism, but now that I saw it, it seems the most natural progression of the reflection. That Calculus jingle was an epic moment: I totally loved it! :)
@terigopula
@terigopula 5 лет назад
Loved the complete video, but loved the last two lines the most! "You have a choice about what kind of person you are here and now. Make that a good one". NAILED IT...
@someshyv
@someshyv 5 лет назад
This is probably the best channel I have discovered lately. The poynting vector video blew my mind
@plastichamster365
@plastichamster365 6 лет назад
Your videos are great, I show my friends and I hope they like it too :)
@trippinluv
@trippinluv 6 лет назад
Another excellent video. Loved the way you ended it. So many of us carry stuff from our past around and let it color every aspect of our lives, but it literally doesn’t exist. We only exist in the here and now and always have the option of being a good person and doing good things (like chipping in on patreon so you can keep making these sweet vids). FastFast!
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
Thanks for the support! And yeah... sometimes people have experiences (or disorders) that make certain choices _much_ more difficult than they are for others, but there's always a choice.
@thorstenwestheiderphotogra7722
@thorstenwestheiderphotogra7722 4 года назад
Awesome, just awesome. Going to share your videos, your deserve a bigger audience!
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 4 года назад
Thanks!
@devinuzumaki9032
@devinuzumaki9032 2 года назад
This is one of the few RU-vid videos I consider to be 10/10 from editing to break down. Love the content 🤝
@JuergenNoll
@JuergenNoll 6 лет назад
I so desperately want a 100-thumbs-up-button for this channel and this video in particular. Great explanation of a physically and philosophically tricky subject!
@tsuchan
@tsuchan 6 лет назад
"You always have a choice about what kind of person you are here and now" We certainly don't know that. Although living "as if" may be a good precept.
@yoso585
@yoso585 5 лет назад
tsuchan1 Oh but even that would be just wishful thinking.
@VedanthB9
@VedanthB9 4 года назад
“Fake it till you make it”. The mantra works.
@VedanthB9
@VedanthB9 4 года назад
Yoso If the _intention_ is genuine, then it won’t be wishful thinking.
@SSMLivingPictures
@SSMLivingPictures 9 месяцев назад
Best part of the vid is Nicks prediction of a 100,000 play button. Big congrats to the success of your channel thus far Nick and I wish you nothing but exponentially greater success to come.
@einarvasvik1507
@einarvasvik1507 5 лет назад
Just wanted to say thanks for all your videos. At times it goes way over my head, but I still enjoy it and learn a lot!
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 5 лет назад
I'm glad you enjoy them :-) I've been doing really tough topics this year. I'll be taking a break from that over the next few months to cover electricity.
@jaikumar848
@jaikumar848 6 лет назад
1:10 wish you best of luck Nick! 👍you really deserve 100000 subscribers...effort that you put for us in explaining complex things simply is really amazing..
@bseduarda
@bseduarda 6 лет назад
I love your videos!!! You make physics seem so simple! Thank you for explaining to us!
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
You're welcome. Glad you like them :-)
@toddborstad504
@toddborstad504 4 года назад
Love your video, little complicate with all the numbers but your points are well made and you're hilarious. Keep up the good videos!
@vrealitygaming7088
@vrealitygaming7088 5 лет назад
Wow amazing! Ending was on point.
@dakicdanilo
@dakicdanilo 6 лет назад
I think your videos are fantastic! And the way you explain everything. Brilliant.
@NavalKishoreS
@NavalKishoreS 6 лет назад
Was watching a movie, got notification you uploaded a video. Jumped right here...
@nadavdanieli
@nadavdanieli 6 лет назад
I am watching a movie I receive notification, I am jumping right here.
@joeycook6526
@joeycook6526 5 лет назад
To all those out there with the same question as Nitesh Kumar: stick with it, and keep watching this guy. Your lightbulb will eventually flip on; that moment is extremely rewarding.
@fundacjawega
@fundacjawega 2 года назад
OMG, what a great channel, I am so glad I have found it! 🙂
@adityakelkar6860
@adityakelkar6860 6 лет назад
You, kind sir, deserve way way more subscribers. Keep up the good work!!
@philipberthiaume2314
@philipberthiaume2314 6 лет назад
Again a brilliant video Nick, causality ensures the future but the future doesn't exist without the now. Now is all that there is. What an amazing concept.
@joelcurtis562
@joelcurtis562 4 года назад
These are terrific videos. Funny and engaging but also offering quite a bit of actual substance in the physics. Hard balance to strike. Well done.
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 4 года назад
Thanks! 😊
@onedayaftermonday3915
@onedayaftermonday3915 2 года назад
You are Awesome keep doing what you are doing!! Thank you Sir.
@suyashverma15
@suyashverma15 6 лет назад
And about that 100k subs. I am trying my best by sharing your phenomenal science videos to my science crazy friends like me, here in India, so that your supposed future event may reach you in the very near future, and you honestly deserves more than that!!
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
I'll be at VidCon in a few weeks. That should help.
@Rugbystu14
@Rugbystu14 6 лет назад
Your videos are always so unique. It's just amazing!
@davesobo2331
@davesobo2331 5 лет назад
You make it so simple and enjoyable. Thanks for making this information painless. 🤙
@user-uu7sk8bz5l
@user-uu7sk8bz5l 3 года назад
Wish You a bright future Sir.Your knowledge is unimaginable
@ShellShocks14
@ShellShocks14 6 лет назад
RU-vid continues to teach me calculus concepts in ways I can understand, yet my university could not. Thank you
@medexamtoolsdotcom
@medexamtoolsdotcom 5 лет назад
You went to college without already understanding calculus? Could you read yet? It makes me angry that people like you exist. Detritus clogging up the system and ultimately stealing the career opportunities from those with actual ability.
@TheCimbrianBull
@TheCimbrianBull 6 лет назад
Your silver play button will soon be coming fast fast! 😀
@RamsFan93
@RamsFan93 5 лет назад
@Hugoj Sim racing dont go anywhere
@PinkeySuavo
@PinkeySuavo 3 года назад
He already over doubled that amount of subs
@praveenb9048
@praveenb9048 3 года назад
@@PinkeySuavo the silver play button is now in his past light cone.
@petslittleworld
@petslittleworld 5 лет назад
I had watched this video in my past and knew I will be watching it again in my future, I watched it again today and it was my 'present'. Nice video Mr. Lucid.
@bryanbowen4193
@bryanbowen4193 5 лет назад
Even though your information isn't the best, your presentation is awesome. Great work.
@archagoras
@archagoras 6 лет назад
Thank you this video was informative and entertaining. I learn a lot from you.
@adityadhardwivedi634
@adityadhardwivedi634 6 лет назад
I appreciate your explanation by this video and I came to know that your explanation really matches with the explanation of time as done in the book, The fabric of the Cosmos. Thanks for this. Your hard work would sure let your channel to reach 100k or more subscribers in future.
@MaruskaStarshaya
@MaruskaStarshaya 2 года назад
1:12 - the most smart suggestion to subscribe - you've got it
@physicsphilosophy2492
@physicsphilosophy2492 4 года назад
You're a gem ♥️ Keep it up so that one day everyone will know you👏👏👏👍♥️
@dreamer-bh1xt
@dreamer-bh1xt 6 лет назад
Hey nick! your channel is growing! :) It makes me happy.
@pronounjow
@pronounjow 6 лет назад
Well, I'm psychic and I can see a silver play button in your near future. :)
@beaconblaster33
@beaconblaster33 3 года назад
In the when?
@pronounjow
@pronounjow 3 года назад
@@beaconblaster33 He should have it by now. Lol That was 2 years ago.
@nateblack972
@nateblack972 5 лет назад
This was awesome!
@xpkareem
@xpkareem 4 года назад
It's two years later and I'm here to tell you that this time exists.
@darkages9507
@darkages9507 2 года назад
Sorry, no more...
@jagrathty2743
@jagrathty2743 2 года назад
@@darkages9507 yes... No more
@eaaslee
@eaaslee 2 года назад
Your two years in the future is now in my past
@tweedy151
@tweedy151 2 года назад
you just saw the video and wrote that comment in different 'nows' which are really the same now.
@MikeMotif
@MikeMotif 4 года назад
Calculus and...philosophy. :) I like it. We need more teachers like you.
@evrimagaci
@evrimagaci Год назад
Can you explain what type of transformation would bring the two events shown at 03:50 to reverse order? I can't think of a transformation of axes/tilt to reverse the relative positions of those two objects (your head and yellow face). How can your head become "lower" (or "before") than the yellow face by just changing the perspective? Why does the light cone of yellow face not move with the transformation?
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum Год назад
You don't seem to have relaxed your concept of "up" and "down." The screen doesn't determine that. The axes do. If you can rotate the axes so that the space axis is between the observers, then you've made them switch... even if they don't move on the screen.
@Mysoi123
@Mysoi123 Год назад
Q: Why does the light cone of yellow face not move with the transformation? A: *Because the speed of light is constant for all observers, and the center of the cone is defaultly located at the cause event.* Q: How can your head become "lower" (or "before") than the yellow face by just changing the perspective? A: *When two events are separated by such a long distance that light cannot travel between them in the time it takes for them to occur, they are considered non-causally connected. This means that different observers may disagree on the order in which the events occurred since there is no causal relationship between them. The reason for this is that nothing can travel faster than light, so the events cannot influence each other.* Q: Can you explain what type of transformation would bring the two events shown at 03:50 to reverse order? A : *the type of transformation for (t,x) to (t',x') is called the Lorentz transformation*
@xrete
@xrete 7 месяцев назад
​@@Mysoi123take my like
@oceaneuropa1117
@oceaneuropa1117 5 лет назад
...Make that choice a good one... Well said! Thank you.
@MrTommy4000
@MrTommy4000 5 лет назад
Very nice job. I was able to digest, while others have left me scratching my head, and howling like a chimp. Thanks for sharing light to the calculused and logarithmically challenged.
@osvillb
@osvillb 6 лет назад
this comment is part of your past
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
I just made it part of my present by interacting with it.
@-_Nuke_-
@-_Nuke_- 6 лет назад
What about plank time? Could that be considered the present? As it might be the smallest chunk of time? Could that be the "infinitesimal" value that we are adding?
@paule.2687
@paule.2687 6 лет назад
I just influenced your future somehow by writing a comment that you've read
@Ni999
@Ni999 6 лет назад
If you think that got past me, you're mistaken.
@Lucky10279
@Lucky10279 6 лет назад
NUKE Maybe. The problem is that we don't know if plank units actually are the smallest ones possible. We don't even know if there ARE smallest units. Its entirely possible, even plausible (at least as far as I know) that both time and space are infinitely divisible. No one has figured it out yet though. There's probably a Nobel prize in science and/mathematics for whoever figures it out either way.
@Chiaros
@Chiaros 5 лет назад
Nick casually dropping some deep philosophical advice at the end of a physics video. Cheers man, you're one of the good guys.
@w.c.orielly9059
@w.c.orielly9059 5 лет назад
That was cool, well presented, a lil humor, not over the top, well done... I'm subbing...✌️🍺 cheers
@gswovoka6286
@gswovoka6286 5 лет назад
Nicely done!
@petslittleworld
@petslittleworld 6 лет назад
Wow!! That was crazy... And the quote at the end was deep ... Keep 'em videos coming I am sure craziness lies in my future light cone.
@Lucky10279
@Lucky10279 6 лет назад
I just added a pledge on patreon. I've never done that before, but your channel deserves it. Its really impressive that you do this all yourself. One thing I really like is that you're really good at anticipating questions/objections and immediately addressing them. I love your channel and I hope it grows enough so you can make videos more often. 😀
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
Thank you so much for supporting! Your questions always keep me on my toes, which is a good thing.
@DudeWhoSaysDeez
@DudeWhoSaysDeez 6 лет назад
He preemptively answers the questions that most people have
@Lucky10279
@Lucky10279 6 лет назад
No this is Patrick Exactly.
@XEinstein
@XEinstein 5 лет назад
He doesn't do this all by himself! He has an army of clones helping him.
@Lucky10279
@Lucky10279 5 лет назад
@@XEinstein lol. I love his clone stwick
@mehrdadmohajer3847
@mehrdadmohajer3847 4 года назад
Good job. Well done🌷
@tmdrake
@tmdrake 4 года назад
Luv this channel!
@barryretmanski4763
@barryretmanski4763 6 лет назад
I predict that in my future I will watch your next video! Awesome as always! How do you only have 74k subs? 0.o
@joeycook6526
@joeycook6526 6 лет назад
I know you don't have the time, but I would watch your videos as often as you could make them. Your channel deserves SciShow viewership *at least.* The Science Asylum is definitely one of the best out there. P.S.: the Hank Green pedantic remark just made him look like a pedant. Keep up the good work.
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 6 лет назад
If I can get this channel to a place where I can hire help, I might be able to make more.
@Hitngan
@Hitngan 4 года назад
Most excellent, your best vid yet.
@you_are_soul
@you_are_soul 4 года назад
Always make the best decision you can in any given moment. Excellent advice.
@kombasanpracka
@kombasanpracka 6 лет назад
After 18 years from highschool I unintentionally found out the true meaning of "dx". Thank you for providing us always some HQ stuff. PS: As EN is not my native language I have some difficulties to understand when you speak that nerdy spitty voice. Besides that thanks for this great channel :)
@Minty4141
@Minty4141 6 лет назад
This gave me a minor existential crisis, that fairly rare for me, good job.
@stanmakrushin
@stanmakrushin 5 лет назад
Really thought-provoking video👍 The idea of non-existent past and future and the only existent “now” is kinda scary😅
@philjamieson5572
@philjamieson5572 4 года назад
Beautifully simplified. Thanks again.
@Xcalator35
@Xcalator35 6 лет назад
Oh you deserve WAY MORE than a simple silver play button!!!
@garyaubin8016
@garyaubin8016 6 лет назад
Xcalator35 c fuck off. Idiots guide to science by and idiot!
@radhekrishna5863
@radhekrishna5863 3 года назад
@@garyaubin8016 who are you to judge anyone
@artdonovandesign
@artdonovandesign 3 года назад
@Xcalculator: Ain't that the truth!
@RayDrouillard
@RayDrouillard 5 лет назад
Relativity rule #6: Cause happens before effect. Except for the quantum eraser experiment. But that's quantum mechanics, which is hard to mix with relativity.
@erwinhun
@erwinhun 4 года назад
I note that the QEE surprised those who believe that the future is not causally linked to the present and the past (the ones who believe in free will) while determinists saw nothing strange about it.
@Ying-yang6969
@Ying-yang6969 5 лет назад
That was a clever way to say to subscribe and not getting off topic.
@subbannar7319
@subbannar7319 4 года назад
Really good, thank you
@chriswehlen3534
@chriswehlen3534 6 лет назад
Best science based content creator on RU-vid. Thank You. Would like to see more stuff on relatively and time dilation
@pete2375
@pete2375 6 лет назад
The silver play button will be yours ... oh yes ... it will be yours!
@kennyhuggins5216
@kennyhuggins5216 2 года назад
I really enjoy your videos they are informative and entertaining so keep up the good work and looking forward to more content from you..
@peteypoodles358
@peteypoodles358 5 лет назад
What a great video!!
@hankseda
@hankseda 6 лет назад
A very "Lucid" presentation! With an excellent video!
@eugenes9751
@eugenes9751 6 лет назад
You should do a video about the Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser. It suggests that cause and effect might sometimes work backwards and the past can be rewritten based on future events.
@nadavdanieli
@nadavdanieli 6 лет назад
It suggest scientists like fairy tales, time machines, warm holes, warp drives, just like little kids. Time is reversible, but there is no point to talk about cause and effect if they were already pre-determined, they are just now.
@eugenes9751
@eugenes9751 6 лет назад
+Chike, what? Scientists like fairy tales? What it shows is that there is no predetermined time, a quantum action in the future can go back and rewrite the past circumstances. Time is pliable, and rewritable. You can't destroy information, but you can cause the information to have never existed in the first place. Secondarily, warm holes and warp drives are completely within the limits of reality, and would in fact act like a time machine if we could get the negative energy necessary to keep them stable. Going faster than light would in fact take you backwards into time (from your perspective). Now, FTL travel might not be possible, but we haven't conclusively proven that just yet. Quantum entanglement shows us that it is possible for certain things (entangled particle pair information) to travel at effectively infinite speed, we probably can't transmit anything useful through it, but it does demonstrate that the quantum world doesn't necessarily give a crap about the time dimension.
@nadavdanieli
@nadavdanieli 6 лет назад
Why do you say re-write, have you seen it change? Like I said time is reversible, the *sequence* of events does not change. How do warm hole settle with the sequence of events? Events travel at the speed of light. Say you have seen an event on earth and went through a worm hole someplace far, you will now see it again *buzz* ! not possible, you can see an event at a specific time and location only and no other time but that time, you can see it at the same time and location how many times u wish, but only at a certain now and where. And what about preservation laws? No, I know the eraser experiment, and the photons on screen look the same either way, what it show is you can predict where a certain photon will hit, no better than you do with 2 slits anyway.
@eugenes9751
@eugenes9751 6 лет назад
+Chike, "Re-write", because based on where the particle is detected, it's past could only have had a single timeline out of 2 possible states, wave or particle. The final state's measurement forces the initial state (future re-writes the past). How did you determine that wormhole travel is impossible other than saying that it might cause an apparent paradox? But the paradox doesn't exist when you consider just your timeline. Even if a time traveler went and changed the past, you wouldn't notice, since your brain is in its current configuration and can only witness what it records. The fact that you're limited to your time slice doesn't mean that the rest of the universe is. Preservation laws can be broken, time symmetry was shown to be broken not too long ago in a special particle. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-yArprk0q9eE.html Based on your last paragraph, I believe you may not understand the delayed choice quantum eraser experiment. It's not about where a photon hits, it's about whether an object is it's in a wave or particle state and that the final measured result is what forces it into the particle or wave state. The future measurement affects the particle's past solution, here: How the Quantum Eraser Rewrites the Past: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8ORLN_KwAgs.html
@nadavdanieli
@nadavdanieli 6 лет назад
Like I have said, I know the experiment, watch it again closely, there are never 2 lines you would have expect if you try to detect which slit they went through, you simply cant say anything about the photons when you examine them against a and b detectors, but you observe interference pattern with C and D detectors, and you still do not know which slit which photon went through. All you can say is that photons detected at C will create different pattern than those detected by D, any other interpretation is bogus, you have no idea of why this happen not it help you to understand it. Either you accept information travel to be the speed limit that we would never be able to reach or not, you must make up your mind, if it is you cannot see the same event twice, if it does not, we can argue. There are no paradoxes in the universe, nor any conservation law is broken, not in my theory. Make it rule #7, if it creates a paradox it is false. Tell me, what is this "wall" between the slits for a gravitational wave? Would you get the same pattern if it was made of neutrons with no electrons circling around them interacting with the gravitational wave, caused by the particle, no space between them (or much less space between them) to allo the wave to continu? Don't take what science tell you as granted, ask tough questions, and keep asking until there the answer is satisfying (one that does not raise another question or more) Quantum theory rejects relativity, so it bring back a question that had already been answered. Still it use it to make other predictions (Hawking radiation/Unruh effect) that have yet to be proven right.
@derrick211000
@derrick211000 Год назад
oh man this was a good look at the same concept from a different perspective that gave me a better understanding of light travel and far off distant objects.
@psyclotronxx3083
@psyclotronxx3083 5 лет назад
Your videos are the best. I absolutely love them.
@bjjthaiboxing
@bjjthaiboxing 2 года назад
I absolutely love this channel! I truly hope this style of teaching set's a trend, world wide! Thus effectively impacting our culture in a positive way, for everyone to enjoy. Had I been exposed to someone this creative in my younger days, my understanding of science and physics would be next level!
@userBBB
@userBBB 5 лет назад
If something happen in my future, which is someone's past that mean... it has to be out of my influence so it must be some information that have already made which I can't change so-called existed future means information made by others (info out of your influence) that you can learn in the future but my future which is within my influence, is not yet made into information, to be in someone's future so... my future is not predetermined you can make new information and decide your reactions to predetermined information
@artdonovandesign
@artdonovandesign 3 года назад
This was a tough one for me to get my head around. Watched it a few times and I'll continue to do so until that "light bulb" goes on. Best regards and thank you, Nick. 😊
@ipsumquaerere6927
@ipsumquaerere6927 6 лет назад
MIND BLOWN! Would I say if I weren't crazy!
@Lucky10279
@Lucky10279 6 лет назад
Lol
@amberflame8682
@amberflame8682 6 лет назад
i just noticed that if you had a time machine you could never go to the future, because when you go to the future it then becomes the present and your origin time is the past. (kanshpyracie)
@vijayanand8077
@vijayanand8077 5 лет назад
Amber Flame beautiful
@amberflame8682
@amberflame8682 5 лет назад
why did i just say kanshpyracie?
@amberflame8682
@amberflame8682 5 лет назад
OH I MEANT CONSPIRACY
@hanseldsilva2393
@hanseldsilva2393 4 года назад
I loved the final minutes where you wrap it all up while spicing it with some personal philosophy. 10/10 upload more pls
@stefaniasmanio859
@stefaniasmanio859 4 года назад
Very philosophical video.... anyway Thank you for being in our present!! Hope you will be in our future for a very long time!!!
@johnbonahoom3972
@johnbonahoom3972 3 года назад
Very well done Nick
@ScienceAsylum
@ScienceAsylum 3 года назад
Thanks!
@CockneyBiker
@CockneyBiker 6 лет назад
I'm popping out of my cone for a second.. see you all yesterday..
@MouseGoat
@MouseGoat 5 лет назад
Well Seems like you over shoot that by 6 months and 30 days ^^ at least according to my point of spacetime reference.
@SNK1995
@SNK1995 5 лет назад
@@MouseGoat , He must be in some short of loop already.. some paradox you know?
@MouseGoat
@MouseGoat 5 лет назад
@@SNK1995 I dont think space-time alows for paradoxes, so no i must say i dont really understand what you getting at here. :O He said he would be here yesterday, but now its 10 months ago, now normally you would say that is because i have moved 10 months forward in time, from the point of him writing that comment. but from my spacetime reference, its him moving backwards in time, noting paradoxical in that.
@SNK1995
@SNK1995 5 лет назад
@@MouseGoat, aha... Now i got it, thanks for the explanation. 😁
@SNK1995
@SNK1995 5 лет назад
When i read "see you all yesterday" in his comment i suddenly thought of time travel, and then came the thought of paradox. 😂
@bjm6275
@bjm6275 6 лет назад
Excellent scientific explanation of the past, present and future. I often hear questions about time travel. Your video clearly explains how it is not possible in reality. We should learn from the past and live responsibly in our present to experience a more satifying future. Thanks to you! Three thumbs up!!!
@kevtherev8194
@kevtherev8194 5 лет назад
You persuaded me - SUBSCRIBED
@meows_and_woof
@meows_and_woof 4 года назад
I just found your channel and I love it
@Fixundfertig1
@Fixundfertig1 6 лет назад
This ends the discussion about time travel, you can't because future or past, don't exist. Masterpiece 👏
@stonecoldranblesfan862
@stonecoldranblesfan862 3 года назад
You can go to a place where time ticks slower or faster or speed yourself up significantly to change your time but it will always be your now.
Далее
Relativity & Gravity - The Complete History
10:35
Просмотров 217 тыс.
Here are 3 ways a Multiverse could exist.
19:15
Просмотров 213 тыс.
What the HECK is Time?! (in Einstein’s Relativity)
11:50
How does Hawking Radiation REALLY work?
13:40
Просмотров 428 тыс.
Time Does Not Exist. Let me explain with a graph.
16:07
Photons, Entanglement, and the Quantum Eraser
11:49
Просмотров 304 тыс.
What is NOT Random?
10:00
Просмотров 7 млн
How Elastic is the Fabric of the Universe?
9:42
Просмотров 213 тыс.
Does the future already exist? (Andromeda Paradox)
19:21
Is The Universe Infinite?
10:21
Просмотров 355 тыс.