Also not meant to diss ShadX video, I just personally disagree with many of the takes and believe it to be too generic and in line with the community’s general consensus.
If Godfrey (prime) brandished the Elden ring wouldn’t the same apply to placidusax who was Elden Lord before Godfrey and by extension also brandish the Elden ring?
@@CausalViewer23 I did mention that, but the era before the Golden Order is a little iffy so I presented it as just a possibility. If he did have it I’d place him in third.
@@Chillblackcat idt that really means much, the only real threat he’s faced to our knowledge up to this point is a rotted Radahn who isn’t the most impressive. And I think that can be also attributed to the powers of the Fire Giant in its second phase where it channels the Fell God, which is an actual God, so it makes sense in a literal sense to compare it to a God, even if that doesn’t inherently mean it’s like an absurdly powerful being
OK but shouldn't upscaling that version of Radahn still make fire giant Mohg level since Radahn was stronger than Okina in the festival. Especially since Marika tasked the fire giant to gaurd the flame of ruin presumably because of how resilient the fire giant proved himself to be by surviving Godfreys genocide campaign against the fire giants. Albeit that last one could have been done purely out of spite, because Marika lol.
@@Chillblackcat I don’t think Mohg is really below Okina and I don’t think anyone could in full confidence say he is, all we know of their fight is that Okina landed a hit and Mohg found him impressive enough to recruit. And I was presenting Alexander’s experiences as like a possible interpretation in which there are multiple, not as like what I’m arguing is the true reason as to why Alexander compares it to a God. And for the ending one yeah I’m sure it’s either out of spite or to just make sure to not leave it untended as it can burn the Erdtree (or both, they aren’t really mutually exclusive)
Malenia goddes of rot ranks just below malikekh and radagon, on par with miquella and his you know what, these are the only ones who reached godhood. Prime radahn ranks equal to malenia blade of miquella, above all the demigods (except the one we face in shadow of erdtree)
@@sedplayz the Elden Beast and Marika were Gods as well, and we can assume Ranni rose similarly in her ending. Prime Radahn is not equal to Malenia and is not above all other demigods, the statements are ass and he’s fighting a Malenia that’s confirmed to have been fatigued, while Radahn has no such confirmation
Destined death does not make someone the strongest why do we know this because the first person to have it was killed by maliketh therefore there is a lot of maliketh d riding. Radahn fight was only a stalemate because Melania nuked calid radhan could’ve kept fighting not to Mention he held the stars. Morgot over radahn is crazy.
Destined Death doesn’t immediately mean strongest character in the verse, but it’s absolutely one of the most broken abilities and as you just said Maliketh was even capable of beating it beforehand, and I gave more reasons for him. I provided a scan outright stating it was a stalemate UNTIL she bloomed and I explained how most of the debunks to Radahn’s shit are in my Morgott vs Radahn video
