It's 2019 and I did not watch any of the talent shows back then but from me watching the show's season here on youtube in 2019 , Elliot should have won for sure , I can not believe he didn't ?
Tbh I thought this was a cruel way to have Elliott leave the show, this is right before the finale and they just show his name when they say who got the least amount of votes. Normally Ryan would send one person to the finale and then announce the next person in the finale which would lead to the third person leaving
sboudreaux27 but Taylor picked the group he thought was safe when the thing you should do is not pick either group like David Archuleta & Melinda Doolittle did. And Taylor just cheered for joy when he won & that just screamed arrogance. Chris should’ve won and him & Katharine should’ve been the top 2
Actually in the first 4 seasons before that he would just announce the eliminated person without addressing either of the other two first. He didn’t start announcing the top 2 one at a time until season 6,
i wish Elliott and one of the two would have won =( But, given that night, considering overall Taylor had three strong performances, and Kat had SOTR, he was a goner
I still think Chris & Katharine should’ve been the top 2 with Chris winning but after Chris left I was hoping that Elliott would be in the finale with Katherine with her winning. Taylor shouldn’t have won
@@Snide01 taylor shined for his stage presence and energy. People liked his connection with the audience and his personality, but in terms of voice it was elliot or Katherine.
First season I watched, I actually got on board with Kellie early and stuck with her. Loved Chris. But Elliott was clearly robbed. Kat was often shrill, and Taylor was a fucking clown. But the best rarely wins Idol.
