Emma: "You Left Me?!" (Once Upon A Time S2E14) 

"You left me and let me go to prison because Pinocchio told you to?" Morrison's delivery of this line was really good 👏🏻

Baelfire and Neal being the same person was one of the most satisfying reveals in TV history.

"Maybe something good came from us being together." And I think of a certain browned haired boy by the name of Henry.

Emma: You believe in that??? Neal: considering that I have been to neverland, met captain hook, am about 300 years old, have a dad who is immortal and can't be killed and has awesome magical powers, fell through a magical portal that led me to another world.... yes, yes i do.

Imagine you’re a bar patron and you overhear any part of the conversation “Sweet Jesus how much did I have?”

I am just so blown away by how GOOD Morrison's acting is in this scene! Not trying to knock her on the rest of the show, but she is just so natural here. Maybe because the dialogue feels so organic, so real and she is channeling the damaged, pre-Storybrooke version of Emma Swan that lived life as an orphan and betrayed by the man she has to face once again in Neal. When I re-watch this scene versus so many others, it doesn't even feel like the same show at times. The writing, acting, the everything in this episode was just so Emmy-worthy!

I will never forgive the writers killing off baelfire 😭💔

I do see Neal's side of things. He was trying to fix his father's mess, since Rumple helped Regina set the curse. He wanted Emma to reunite with her family. Yes, it hurt her, but in the end, he did the right thing. Not that I don't see Emma's side as well, I definitely do.

Maybe it was fate. "You believe in that?!" says the woman who's parents are Prince Charming and Snow White.

"Maybe something good came from us being together." "Nope, nothing that I can think of.." Damn Henry, your mom just demoted you to 'nothing good'.

Jennifer Morrison deserves all the awards. I watch this scene over and over again, and it breaks my heart every time again how she says "how?" trying not to cry, trying to keep her walls up in front of the guy who left her. JMo is a damn good actress... and this scene is still as heart-breaking as it was 3 months ago.

Out of context, they sound so insane! "because Pinocchio told you to?"

It’s kinda scary to think about everyone Emma really had a close connection with before she went to storybrook was from the enchanted Forrest. Lily maleficent daughter, Neil is Baelfire, august is Pinocchio, Sarah is Ingrid, Merlin showed up in the theater that one time like no matter what even if Henry was never born Emma couldn’t stop her destiny

Michael Raymond-James was so good in this episode. Loved the way he looks at Emma throughout. He still loves her.

The line about Pinocchio still cracks me up. I never thought about it like that until she said it. It's so funny! LOL!

When emma said that nothing good came out of their relationship I was like, "uh, Henry for starters?"

Personally I would blame Pinocchio/August more than Baelfire/Neal.

Lads I'm looking at this 10 years later and then I see comments form like 9 six years ago wow I still love this scene

This is right after Emma got off the phone with her mother, It is so sweet the way she is gripping the phone as if clinging to her mothers advice.

I'm a Captain Swan shipper, and I never really took to Neal in the short time that we had with him, but I honestly was so upset when they killed him off. I feel like he should have stayed alive for Henry because I really liked their dad/son relationship. I didn't really have enough time to REALLY like Neal because I feel like we didn't get much time with him. I'm not going to bash Neal-I'm not going to bash anybody-but I feel like it would have been cool to see Emma and Neal develop a friendship and raise their son together. Keep in mind: before Neal and before Killian, there was just Emma. There was a character named Emma Swan who was badass without a man and who wasn't in a love triangle that had Swanfire shippers or Captain Swan shippers getting into internet fights over which side was better. There was Emma and Henry and a single message that the show provided-hope, not romance. I'm for Captain Swan, but I'm for Emma Swan's happiness even more.

Am I the only one who's still bothered by what ended up being in the box? I mean, episode after episode they basically hyped it up. What's in the box? what is it? what made Neal change his minds? What's in it tell me?...And then, bam. It's just his typewriter saying "I know you're baefire"... I mean come on? it couldn't have been something else? like something from his childhood?

2:22 she is thinking of Henry

That moment when 'Henry' pops into her mind...

Can we take a minute for the amazing line. “ to remind myself to never trust me again?” My reaction- damb em you go

August Booth. The man who causes all stuff to happen.

"You made a deal with him? Emma you don't have to do that, tell him you lost me." What I hate about that, is he *knows* what happenes to people who break deals with his father.... (in this scene) if he really cared for her he wouldn't have said to break the deal. (Yes, I know he did follow up to seal the deal, but still)

I think I read it on Twitter. Either it was an interview with Jennifer Morrison or in a press release for an upcoming episode..I can't remember which one. Anyway, it was said that Emma would not ask Neal to be in her life romantically, but wanted Henry to know his Father. It's in this conversation, that the engagement is revealed. I think 'Tamara'(new character) may be his fiancée.

You can tell their filming in Canada... There's hockey on the tv

I just want to point out as well that Emma gave birth to Henry in jail - and giving birth in jail, from what I have heard, is really traumatic. They chain you to a bed in the hospital so you don't run (which they're actually not allowed to do; but they do it anyway), you often have to wait ages with no painkillers during labour before anyone will take notice of you, etc. I heard a story from one woman who had to wait for shift change while in labour, because the guard on duty didn't want to deal with it. There was another story where a woman just gave birth alone in her cell because no one would help her. Oh also, giving him up for adoption might not have been a choice - because you don't get to take your baby in with you most of the time. If you're lucky, you have to get family to care for the child. Emma had no family, which means she may have been forced to give him up. That's a thing - if you don't have anyone to care for the baby, and you don't get lucky with one of the prisons/jails that does let you bring the baby back inside, the baby automatically goes into the system. Emma probably adopted him out to avoid THAT, having been someone who also grew up in the system. So she has even more reason to be upset with him than the show addresses.

August was incredibly selfish anyway. If they had to break up fine. but didn’t have to send Emma to jail though and steal her money. If it was seriously a thing where Emma had to break the curse. Break it off and leave don’t call the cops and bounce. Gave me confused feelings about Neal

When Emma says she's over it and him it's obvious it's a LIE if she was over him and what happened, she wouldn't have brought it up. She brought it up because of two likely reasons 1.) She needs to understand what happened, because she still has questions, and thinks about it a lot consciously or unconsciously. 2.) She wants to know that it hurt him to do that to her, and she needs closure but can't find it on her own because she's still pining away for him.

Am I the only one who's curious about how August knew that Neil was Baelfire or how he knew that Rumpelstiltskin even had a son? I hope the show explains how and it eventually turns him back into a man. As for Emma and Neal, I'm not sure I want them to be endgame, but I'd rather see them end up together in the end of the show, than her and hook.

Great scene. One of my favorite episodes.

Emma has the right to be mad

what's cute is they both still have the things they gave each neal the dream catcher emma the necklace I think that when august told him to move he was doing just that but he's still in love with her she is to but right now it's an emotional blow I understand her not getting back together now but give it time maybe next season it will hit

i also keep remembering how it was neal who asked her to settle down...he only ran away cuz he freaked when he found out who she was...melodramatic in the greatest way ever!

Emma was really hurt and I think it hurt so badly bc she still in some way cared about him. She might’ve even loved the idea of him but still, that counts for something right because when your idea of someone is ruined, everything hurts. Jeniffer Morrison executed and delivered this perfectly I think.

Neal: You know there's not much I remember about my father that doesn't suck. Boy, your father loved you. He broke his leg so you wouldn't be without a father, he became the dark one so you wouldn't be forced to fight and after he made the mistake of letting you go he spent every moment trying to get to you and you can't even bring yourself to remember the man he was before he was corrupted by power. All those years he devoted his life for you. He may have let you go that one time but that has been his biggest regret for his whole life and I will fight anyone that has the nerve to say Rumpletilskin is not a loving father.

This is just one of my all-time favourite episodes

"Maybe something good came out of it" We all know who that is

The reason they met was so that Henry would be born. The seer told Rumble a boy would lead him to his son....Henry did when he travled with his mom and Rumple

“Call it fate, call it destiny” Call it the Author?

He didn't leave cause he wanted to, he wanted to stay with her but her fate got in the way, but i think that if he had known that Emma was pregnat then things might have been different, but if he hadn't left her then she probably wouldn't have found her parents

Couldn't just Neal have broken up with Emma instead of sending her to prison

Okay, this has been bothering me since forever. They all act like Neal leaving Emma set her back on the path to being the saviour. I mean, what, she couldn't break the curse if she was happy and had a family?????

As a person who believes in the power of fate. From what I've seen throughout the show, fate plays an important role in the lives of these characters.. So, it's seemed like fate took a surprising turn for Emma.. She wasn't expecting fate to be so cruel... Why him? But maybe it seems that fate was giving Henry waht he always needed... Always questioned about.. Neal had spent most of his life trying to get his father back. To bring the man who was good, who was kind back into his life but as his father grew more obsessed with power, he only saw the dark side of it.. Only trapped in a word of dark magic instead of light.. Probably because all his other family members have turned to dark magic. Pan, Fiona, Rumple..it probably runs in the family.. How this fear of rejection, of the future, of losing everything we have can lead them making the terrible of decisions.. In a way Pan, Rumple and even Neal abandoned their love ones, a child.. This scene shows just how much this trust between them has broken. Neal failed to overcome his fear. His struggle between magic and how it affects him. And yet he wants a future with her but after the years of pain, mistrust and broken emotions... This is not the time for this. She placed her ways that he can't break... As for August.. He was selfish.. But in a world that you don't know at a young age, the world is filled with temptations.. Bad temptations.. So couldn't resist. He was a child.. And it became a habit. That why he turned back into wood.. He thought by setting Emma back on the right path he was going to get out of his situation but he it didn't.. He has finally forgiven himself. And has learnt to be forgive from others.. Plus, maybe fate had other plans for Neal. His relationship with his father, to me was more important than his relationship with Emma. Fate only gave Emma to Neal so he could finally face his father after all these years of pain and hate.. Emma was just that reason..

I was about to say, “um you don’t think Henry is a good thing to come from your relationship?” Then I remembered that he didn’t know he existed yet and she didn’t want him to know.

at 2;24 he has the look of hope in his eyes. he loves her you can totally tell and when he asks about the keychain damn fiance of his neal get rid of her

Some of the best actors are on Television right now

Without Henry the story never would’ve gone anywhere

I think it's only a matter of time and Swan-Thief will reunite. I like their chemistry...Emma & Neal are a lot fun to watch! I enjoy the funny banter between them.

emma calling her mamma after this is precious shows how close theve become

You know...I'm a confirmed Rumbellers and they are my number 1 ship, but I have to say that I'm REALLY liking Neal and Emma! They are funny and heartbreaking at the same time. I loved how Neal said, 'No the bar is better, but don't worry, you can keep yelling at me when we get there!' Since this episode I have become a Swan-Thief shipper as well.

Fate, destiny.....a horse?

Maybe they didn't let the 'thing' with Sheriff Graham go too far because they ( the creators/writers) knew Bae would be reintroduced back into the story. Jennifer Morrison has said, that she has known from the beginning who Henry's Father was...I'm sure she also knew that he would also be Baelfire. If fans had seriously started to ship Graham and Emma, that may have complicated things when they wanted to introduce Neal/Bae.

"You left me & you let me go to prison because Pinnoccio told you too". LOL :)

I totally believe destiny has plans for us that we just don’t get

Every time I see Neal, I just think of his (Michaels ) character on True Blood.. It makes it hard to trust him. Lol.

This episode was so mind-blowing....

It appears that Neal is engaged, but I don't think he ever expected to bump into Emma again...now that has...it may change things. When Neal saw that she still wore the key chain he gave her, he looked hopeful that it meant she still cared for him.

you left me?! because Pinocchio told you?! She says that in a dramatic way that makes you wanna cry... but when I think about it, I can´t take it seriously, Pinocchio isn´t just a serious word.

"If I had I wouldn't come near you". For me this is the proof that Neal does not truly understand Emma and how the whole thing as affected her. Emma needs a man that will stay by her side, regardless her being a savior or not. Neal is too insecure about himself.

I miss Baelfire😔 😔 😩 😫 😖

Fate, destiny, writers, whatever you want to call it :3

I remember a time when this revelation was as big a deal to me as R+L = J (which I guess also came true).

Because “Pinocchio” told you to?!?!?!?!

Neal getting killed off was the biggest mistake the show made.

Isn’t it funny how it always happens to her, she’s always involved (Emma) lol 😂

August is so overdramatic with that typewriter reveal. I can't believe there were so many theories wondering what was in the box, thinking it was something like a little fairy maybe. Turns out it's a stupid typewriter paper with that message lol 😆

This is some real heartfelt deep emotion on both sides in this scene. There is seems to be a wealth of heartfelt emotion between Neal and Emma in their interactions good and bad. That I just don't see with either Hook or Emma, I mostly see flirty lightness between those two. Nothing deep though. But who knows as the story progress how that would change.

yes, but what happens when he finds out that she has magic..neal is pretty adamant about not being involved with that --can't wait to see it unfold.

I think that Neal understands how the whole thing affected Emma. He just said that he would've stayed away from her because he had a lot of bad experiences with magic. He went after Tamara because he figured that magic would tear him and Emma apart like it did before. Now I think that he's willing to take that risk. after season 3 I want Hook to go off the show and I want to see Emma and Neal make an effort to makes things work between them.

I'm convinced that Neal is either Peter Pan or one of the lost boys after I saw the CTV preview for QID. Plus the "more years than you could know" line in this episode definetly threw me off.

Baelfire : " Maybe we met for a reason. Maybe something good came from us being together". Me: Yeah, your son.

At this point, Neal is still paranoid about magic. After all, it did drop him from his home to another horrible realm... twice.

OMG YESS everytime i watch that part i shout HENRY!!!

She didn't want to tell him about Henry. For obvious reasons...

Now if you excuse me I must find the whole episode and make some popcorn later dearies ^.^

Henry foo! Something good came from it

You let me go to prison because Pinocchio told you to 😂😂 favourite quote to date

I wonder how Emma was able to get a job as a bail bondswoman if she has a criminal record? Did the police figure out Emma never stole the watches in the first place and cleared her records? I heard if people have pasts with the law then getting a job will be difficult if not impossible. Why didn’t the police try to find Neal before Emma found him again? Even if Neal had sold the stolen property would he have still been arrested for robbery in the first place?

2:15, *falls out of chair* hehehe, & he doesn't even know yet.

Emma+ neal belong together i hope they get married at the end of season 3

To me the biggest question is how the fuck did august know about baelfire?! That was WAY before his time and honestly, as a little kid who got turned human from a wooden doll he sure does know a lot. Maybe that apprentice got to him like he sis lilu

That reveal of the typewriter was so convoluted. Why didn’t he just say “I know you're Baelfire”? Of course the reason is because the audience could hear that but a camera could be positioned so Neil sees something the audience doesn’t. It should have been a drawing of the dagger or something.

like a kid runs to her parent after getting hurt so cute

Who else hates Neal? He just assumed Emma was still in love with him and that he was giving her her best chance. You know what her best chance is? Letting her make her own decisions and just being there for her and listening to her.

I know a lot of people like Emma and Killian, but I was always hoping Emma and Neal would get together, up until his death.

Even though Neal had a good reason it was still wrong to leave a woman who you say you love to take the Fall for something that you did !

Couldn’t have been a picture of Bae with his mother or something? Or a drawing of the dark one dagger

You’ll think before rumple found out that Henry was related to him and that Neal and Emma knew each other_ u think that he would of do that prick of that world glob thing and it said that Neal was in Maine but it was really Henry and he didn’t know at that time,but rumple did had some part of Neal in SB and that part of Neal was Henry AND they knew each other for 10 years. But if rumple knew that Henry was from Snow and charming daughter aka Emma, that he could of knew that there was another part of that DNA in Henry and it’s his own son aka NEAL.. but although I still LOVVVEE the show

I Love Neil! He and Emma are meant for each other!

Geez, Disney has really been taking down a lot of OUAT videos lately. But not all. So weird. I love this scene.

Neal is my favorite character I think he should have stayed on the show longer tho at least for Henry because Henry never got to see his dad again after Regina had to destroy the curse.

Being with Neal just reminds Emma of her past and brings her pain. He moved on with someone else, which shows he didn't truly love Emma. In fact, if his fiance wouldn't have told me she was working against him, he would've stayed with her and had no romantic interest with Emma whatsoever.

Anyone else think Pinocchio/August is at fault for what happen to Emma and Neal?

Oh my god. This scene was beautiful, Emma and Neal need to get together! :D

i call that angst and very much like snowing in season one. im guessing since neal thought breaking the curse meant emma would go back to ftl he thought there was no hope. plus new podcast has the creators confirming he still lloves her so i'm excited

His death was fucken depressing but Hook is a good lover too just saying

To be fair, Neal did chose to do the right thing, but he could've chosen an even better way to do it. Instead of leaving Emma to face this all alone, or keeping her from breaking the curse, which he knew had been given to Regina by his dad, he could've decided to finally face his dad and his past and go with Emma to storybrooke to break the curse. He was gonna have to face his dad eventually, I mean, the man precipitated a series of events centuries in the making just so one bad witch would use his mom's curse which he could use to hitch a ride to the realm he was sent too, it was only a matter of time before he was gonna find him.