Тёмный

Episode 19 (August 14, 2023), "I'll make you a STAR!" with David A. Burnett 

Data Over Dogma
Подписаться 16 тыс.
Просмотров 9 тыс.
50% 1

You're not going to want to miss this one!
This week, the Dans are resurrected as star stuff when they interview scholar and friend David A. Burnett. You're not going to want to miss this one, as David connects Paul's ideas of the afterlife with the deposing of the divine council, and a new arrangement in the firmament. Will you make the cut as a celestial body? They'll also dig deep into the scholarship to discover whether monotheism was ever actually a thing in ancient southwest Asia, or if that was an imposition of much later interpreters of the text.
To find more of David Burnett, check out his academia.edu page here:
www.edinburgh....
Or follow him on the socials:
/ dburnett51
/ david.burnett.50
If you want to support our show, please consider becoming a monthly patron at www.patreon.com/DataOverDogma
Also, follow us on the various social media places:
DataOverDogmaPod
data_over_dogma

Опубликовано:

 

9 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 60   
@maxpower2480
@maxpower2480 Год назад
Great Episode! David is an amazing guest. I would still like to encurage Dan to interrupt those nerds even more often to explain stuff that is just obvious to them, but not us, or even read out bible passages (earlier).
@moontrack4625
@moontrack4625 Год назад
DB I’m so glad you ask for meanings of words I can’t possible understand. It’s so NORMAL for the Scholars, they forget it has NO meaning to the listener. That’s how my interest fades, feeling excluded with words from the club. Thanks Dans, LUV you two. 🎉 ❤
@soneedanap
@soneedanap Год назад
This is one of the best episodes so far
@ErictheHalf_bee
@ErictheHalf_bee Год назад
When I first heard Pete Enns describe monolatry, as opposed to monotheism and/or pagan idolatry, it was a mind-bending game changer. The idea that the Hebrews accepted that all the gods exist, but were accountable to their god, was such a helpful construct that made sense of all the supposedly conflicting biblical accounts - the conflict is with our impositions on their world, not their world. Thanks for fleshing out this concept so well.
@Vishanti
@Vishanti Год назад
What a great episode! There is supporting evidence for the idea of resurrected people being like stellar bodies: Daniel 12:3 - "והמשכלים יזהרו כזהר הרקיע ומצדיקי הרבים ככוכבים לעולם ועד" (and the insightful ones will shine like the shinies of the sky, and those who turn many to righteousness/justice like the stars forever and ever."
@Lanarch
@Lanarch Год назад
I love David's enthusiasm.
@elizabethhubble5296
@elizabethhubble5296 11 месяцев назад
I'm a month late to the comments, but this episode was absolutely mind-blowing. Thank you #davidburnett. And thanks to the Dans for having you on.
@DudesSqueakyMarsKink
@DudesSqueakyMarsKink Год назад
Thank you for another great episode!
@scottcamp9266
@scottcamp9266 Год назад
Great Discussion❤
@EAncients
@EAncients Год назад
Absolutely fantastic diacussion! I do ablot of reading about Origen and this makes his theoriea about the life of the stars and Theosis at thw resurreftion make so much more sense.
@david.a.burnett
@david.a.burnett 5 месяцев назад
Exactly. At the close of my argument in my first article, I cite Origen's commentary on Romans as evidence for the reception of these traditions. Thanks, @EAnceints!
@JosephNobles
@JosephNobles Год назад
I found the Fredriksen paper. That's a keeper!
@parleylambert9397
@parleylambert9397 Год назад
My favorite episode so far!
@pererau
@pererau Год назад
At least you left my Seahawks out of it!
@Lmaoh5150
@Lmaoh5150 Год назад
Very interesting episode. One of my favorites so far
@Solom0n2
@Solom0n2 Год назад
Very good episode
@MagickalDistruction
@MagickalDistruction Год назад
I think this also helps explain the temptation story and why the last temptation was about inheritance.
@babystreet44
@babystreet44 Год назад
WOW
@cameronmathews9338
@cameronmathews9338 Год назад
Does anyone have information about where to find new updates to bible scholarship? I'm a hobbyist and don't have any sort of university experience in the field.
@rchristy5767
@rchristy5767 10 месяцев назад
Makes perfect sense, the bible talks about several gods, not a one and only schizophrenic loving revengeful ONE
@user-od5bb8vt2t
@user-od5bb8vt2t 10 месяцев назад
Impressed with David's insights. When will David Burnett publish his dissertation?
@Darisiabgal7573
@Darisiabgal7573 Год назад
The Broncos of Denver? What are these horse gods you speak of😂. Didn't they use to pray to the Cowboys of Dallas? Did they not challenge their gods and were defeated during the age of old, just after the great flood?
@Darisiabgal7573
@Darisiabgal7573 Год назад
How the define reality in the new age of quantum physics? If you can eat chicken it's real.😂
@susanholder3944
@susanholder3944 Год назад
The concept of many gods seemed to be adopted by the Catholic church with their saints. They are prayed to and shrines are built to
@MrDalisclock
@MrDalisclock 9 месяцев назад
I think you've just been excommunicated for this comment. Which would only bother you if you're actually Catholic and care.
@rchristy5767
@rchristy5767 10 месяцев назад
And that’s why Ostara could very well have been used by some during passover
@eddd123
@eddd123 3 дня назад
Did this conference occur? Where do I watch it?
@francissreckofabian01
@francissreckofabian01 Год назад
Go Da Bears!
@rorybriscoe7769
@rorybriscoe7769 Год назад
I loved the episode and have really been enjoying the podcast. I have a question though, if and when the Bible contradicts itself, how do we try to learn from it?
@beateifarta
@beateifarta Год назад
My answer, not as a scholar but as Bible user: As we learn from people around us. They do not always agree, but you still get insights from them. It is said that the first hundreds of years after the Bible was made, Bible readers did not look for the right interpretation, but the right use of the Bible, and Lectio Divina was one such way - Holy Reading. A kind of meditative way of reading the text slowly, and stopping up when something touches you. Because the aim is to use the text as a medium to communicate with God, and be in His presence.
@QueenAngelCakes
@QueenAngelCakes 6 месяцев назад
Dan's usual answer - and I agree mostly - is that, those differences teach us about the difference between the people who wrote them, and the times and places they lived, that shaped their perspective. It can teach us the history of how these different points of view came to be.
@Darisiabgal7573
@Darisiabgal7573 Год назад
Judges is even more explicit that that. Beth Anath. The secondJudge, Shamgar of Anath. This is not Yahweh's judge. Moreover the song of Deborah was probably calling the names of different gods, but it was later morphed into Yahu, Yahu (Ia, Ea) and later changed again. There is no way to study Judges and not have it completely emmersed in a polytheistic world.
@Darisiabgal7573
@Darisiabgal7573 Год назад
"Arise oh god", in Hebrew its Elohim (plural). Very context dependent. Elohim could mean one of the council, or the council itself, or in hebrew literature just the Yahweh god. You cannot talk about the council rising up , either as a member thereof or the entire council without a context of a council. So if this is meant to be man, not gods, then what is the council, and if its the dead, are they a council in sheol?
@noname4422
@noname4422 7 месяцев назад
The verb “arise” here is conjugated as masculine singular imperative. So it is unambiguously addressing a single listener. “Elohim” can sometimes be ambiguous about whether it refers to God or gods, but not in this case.
@annaclarafenyo8185
@annaclarafenyo8185 Год назад
The reason Jesus is immediately divine is explained by Carrier in "On the Historicity of Jesus". Jesus started out divine and became human, not the other way around.
@TwentySevenist
@TwentySevenist Год назад
Interesting. So I guess Pinocchio got it right. :)
@hillaryfamily
@hillaryfamily 9 месяцев назад
So much truth and insight here but missing the appropriate meaning of “creation” and the animals and gods etc. The creation is of the covenant world, not the material world. The sun, moon and stars are the people who have the power and authority, and “heaven” is the position of power and a “god” is a ruler. The covenant creation is the creation of the political and social world. This creation is centred on the covenant people, the covenant man. This covenant creation is passed down to Israel. Israel is the heaven and the earth and her priests and authorities are her sun, moon and stars that govern light to the covenant land. But that world, that creation, and its light-giving bodies in its heaven was to be destroyed and replaced with the new heaven and the new earth. The new covenant world, the new creation. That new creation is what we see in Revelation 21-22 when there is no more summer and winter, no more sun, moon and stars, no more sea, no night, when the tree of life gives its fruits 12 months a year. The Lord taught that the sun, moon and stars would fall from heaven and be destroyed at the fall of Israel, at the fall of the Second Temple, in his own generation. That would be the passing away of the old heaven and the old earth. That would be the end, that is the end of the old age of Moses and the Law, the old age of Adam, the man of dust. The world of flesh and blood, that will not inherit the kingdom of God. Paul is teaching the same thing in 1 Cor. 15. The glory of the old covenant world would be surpassed by the glory of the new covenant world. The rulers of the old world of Israel would be totally shattered, as Dan. 12 states, when the Abomination of Desolation is set up in the Second Temple when its sacrifices are stopped. That is when the righteous rise as stars, when the wicked who controlled Israel by rebellion are destroyed along with the power of the holy people.
@JosilyneTwigg
@JosilyneTwigg 7 месяцев назад
They talk about this in the episode "Lilith Unfair" This episode doesn't go super indepth of the creation, that one and other episodes do Hopefully this helps
@LeislSchutte-jb2yu
@LeislSchutte-jb2yu 5 месяцев назад
Have we figured out how professional theater will work if we do that… well we know that if they don’t get tortured to create craft that they don’t need to make new art for therapy… well… ok but what kind of material are they drawing from to make art? We maybe we will see if that - internal only * Octavia of Trecrew certifies this message is ‘divinely and scientifically 😂 uninspiring!’
@raydunn8262
@raydunn8262 Год назад
This narrative is similar to Joseph Smith's later 'prophecy'. It claimed that God said for mens' salvation, men needed to marry more than two wives. And if they do, they will become gods themselves in the afterlife, ruling over planets. If they didn't, they would have little power. Scholars believe Joseph concocted this up so his wife, Emma, would accept him beconing a biganist.
@REALGODJESUS
@REALGODJESUS Год назад
Some in the evangelical Christian community are not going to want to completely give up their faith in God and Jesus Christ. With Dan’s work and others’-relating to biblical inerrancy, diversity of voices in the Bible about all sorts of different issues, like there being many gods, definition of marriage-those evangelicals are probably going to be attracted to some form of Mormonism
@Bridan-Art
@Bridan-Art Год назад
First comment???
@JosephNobles
@JosephNobles Год назад
Another term for this event: the Rapture? 😂
@JosephNobles
@JosephNobles Год назад
Seriously, however, when Paul talks in Galatians 4:3 about being enslaved to the elemental spirits of the world, is he equating the law, the disciplinarian, to the gods of other countries? IOW, that the law is an Adonai-approved graven image?
@davehorner8126
@davehorner8126 Год назад
Why the refusal to use the name "Yahweh" ? No disrespect but it reminds me of "He who shall not be named " in Harry Potter.
@karmachameleon326
@karmachameleon326 Год назад
Out of respect to the Jewish tradition of not saying the “name” of god.
@neuroshima
@neuroshima Год назад
besides, it is not known how the ancient Israelites pronounced YHWH. Yahweh is an academic reconstruction, not without its problems
@davehorner8126
@davehorner8126 Год назад
Thank you for explaining this to me. Makes total sense now.@@karmachameleon326
@lisaboban
@lisaboban Год назад
Dan's explicit goal is to make this level of scholarship accessible to everyone. And not just Christians. If an observant Jew were to tune in, the speaking of the Tetragrammaton would make this video unwatchable.
@davehorner8126
@davehorner8126 Год назад
Thank you, Lisa. Much appreciated and a good learning experience.@@lisaboban
Далее
Мама знает где все документы
00:21
Has the Church Replaced Israel?
5:05
Просмотров 20 тыс.
N.T. Wright Reviews Heiser and The Unseen Realm
17:06
Episode 18 (August 7, 2023), "The Devil Made Us Do It"
57:58
Episode 1 (April 8, 2023), "In the Beginning"
1:07:02
Просмотров 21 тыс.