Everything Wrong With I Am Legend In 12 Minutes Or Less 

"Fuck you, get another dog that's not stupid" I know Jeremy's a cat person, but damn...

how did you miss the biggest sin of this movie. he goes to bed completely locked down and wakes up with sunlight shinning through the widows as if he never closed the metal doors

The dog dying is double sad because his daughter handed the puppy to him and told the dog to "protect daddy" as they were leaving in the helicopter. It's the last part of his child in a way and now that's been taken from him as well 😭

5:58 You don't tell a dog "I'll be back soon" because the dog understands the words, but because he understands the calming tone. Also being the last human alive for hundreds of miles, it's an understandable trait for the character. Just like rewinding and returning videotapes. It creates a sense of normalcy that helps prevent going insane.

"He expects a dog to have a concept of time. Or understand what he said" That dog was family to him and he'd been alone for 3 years,I'd start talking to an animal like that too

The army destroyed the bridges in the film to isolate the city 😂 it didn’t just happen 3 years have gone… and likes I got from this still tickles me

Its 2020, I thought it had been long enough, but hearing the scene with Will yelling "No no no!!" after his dog, BROKE MY HEART ALL OVER AGAIN I WASNT READY.

Movie Sin 39: He has that dog since it was a baby. You wouldn't just let your dog die that your dead child loved. That's kinda like saying:''your dad or the only living thing that loves you ran away? Just find another one.''

Only sin in this video is Will Smith survived 3 years in new york city , died next day after he met a women.

“Just go find another dog” Tell that to John Wick...

You missed the fact that when he sacrificed himself so the women and boy could stay in the little bunker untill daylight well wouldn’t the zombies still stay in there during the day? Making it impossible to get back out of the bunker without being killed?

You should watch the alternate ending. That will make a lot of sense as the creatures show signs of human like emotions. The zombie he captured was the gf/wife of the alpha zombie. He didn't care about Neville until his gf got kidnapped. The last scene shows Neville giving the girl zombie back to alpha and alpha sparing his life. This alternative ending could've cut more than 10 sin points.

one does not simply "find another dog"

"Just go find another dog" Cinema Sins has DEFINITELY never owned a dog!

The biggest sin is that you keep referring to the creatures as "Zombies" when they are in fact Vampires...hence their aversion and damage from sunlight. It is also referenced in the book that they are in fact Vampires.

I’ve been laughing nonstop at “Here lies our friend Fred. He got shot in the head and now he’s dead.” and “She probably heard about what you did to Fred” for 10 minutes

missed out the biggest flaw, about the ending where he sacrifices himself when he could have just thrown the grenade before crawling into the safe that had plenty of room

when I saw this movie, some teen yelled out "Circle Jerk" when Will's character saw the zombies standing in that room while looking for his dog...

2:20 It's not uncommon for news stations keep recordings of all their broadcasts.

I remember one of the most heartbreaking scenes was when after sam died and he was at the woman’s house he went up to the bathroom and sat in the bathtub the same way he would sit in it to wash sam 😢

4:30 "just get another dog" wow you're getting a sin for that

No, he didnt capture all the NEWS to get clues or something. He watches them do get a sense of normality in his daily routine.

even with Jeremy talking over the dogs death, i cried. Shows just how powerful this movie can be

I liked this movie for a while and liked it even more when I saw the alternate ending, but after hearing what the book was really about, they never explained what the title means. Apparently he is legend amongst the infected, because to them, he is the boogie man he takes them while they sleep. That's such an interesting concept.

I cried when he was talking to that mannequin and said something like "I promised a friend I would talk to you" :(

"Movie predicts Batman V Superman 8 years before its release, but is unable to stop it from happening." Thank you for making me spit my drink all over my phone Cinemasins

"Knock knock." "Who's there?" "SUDDEN LION!"

I'm surprised he didn't sin the sacrificing himself bit. He coulda just thrown the grenade and then hopped in with them

BONUS SINS: In the original book, Neville does a ton more killing than healing (hence the genocide pictures in his basement), and in the final scene (where he blows up the infected with a grenade) instead he is brought into their society and executed by them, showcasing that he was in fact the monster, instead of the infected, and solidifying the name of the movie and book with this final line: "[I am] a new superstition entering the unassailable fortress of forever. I am legend." Neville was supposed to be tradition that ended evolution, and was a commentary on how time marches on, and what was once noble and righteous can become twisted and evil, even if the actions have not changed. This movie not only destroyed that point, but turned Neville into a martyr instead of allowing the audience to understand that even with good intentions, evil can be created Ding.

too many sins for this movie "15 years of testing in 3 years" yea no shit he has nothing else to do. we need a cinemasins on cinemasins

What I found weird was that when they rescanned his wife she was negative for the virus so dosent that mean that many of the other people in line be wrongly scanned?

Hahaha when Will says “get your hands of my wife” hahaha

4:30 he’s been alone for a long time and the dogs all that’s keeping him from completely losing it in my opinion it’s reasonable

The bridges were blown up in the flashback he has, it was to stop people from leaving the city because they were infected.

Idk about anyone else, but I could only watch this movie as a kid, before I realized how depressing the situation actually was as an adult

I always thought Fred's head moved to the side when they zoom in on him, 7:20 check it out. Also, "Dammit woman, I told you to drive around until light, they don't know where I live!"

6:58 the soldiers drawing their weapons on eachother is actually a small but genius part of the writing that I believe is there intentionally. It shows the chaos and confusion of duty during a situation like this. One military detail has been assigned to protect Col Neville while the other has been assigned to stop anyone with possible symptoms from going across. Which is why when he tried to pull his wife over, the first soldiers drew their weapons on him and out of their duty to protect Col Neville, his security detail pulled their weapons in response.

When I've finish writing my first Hollywood Movie, Imma give Cinema Sins the script to review first...

"She probably heard what you did to Fred"- LMAO

Will Smith : Survived 3 years with a loyal German Shepherd Dog. Died after a day with a woman.

Uhhh, it's possible Neville had a laboratory downstairs...I mean, wasn't it his house before the whole apocalypse thing. He's a world-famous scentist no? Why can't he have a lab downstairs?

3:14 That was his house before the outbreak Since he’s a scientist it would make sense he has a lab in his basement

You made me remember how awesome this movie is XD It's amazing how hearing the flaws of a film can make you realise how flawless it is.

The covering over the buildings(to contain the virus in the building) is a reflection on how frightened and desperate society would be in the face such a horrific outbreak. The soldiers drew their weapons towatds each other because they were frightened and on edge, because they were torn between duty and a natural desire to desert and go home to their families and friends during a terrifying and unprecedented crisis. The dog hearing the infected outside the house would certainly bark causing the infected to possibly investigate neville's home(a clear plot hole).He doesn't get another dog because like most dog owners he loves her and considers her family and they may not be as common as you think, domestic animals would easy picking for the infected.The bridges and tunnels were destroyed by the military to quarintine the city.(no shit?) The infected sleep standing up, Why? probably to make them even creepier and less human. In "The Omega Man" (1971) the infected were far more sofisticated. The infected set up the trap that caught neville, so the infected are barely human yet still intelligent. When Neville says he's not going to let this happen to anna, he's talking about the total extinction of humanity, he correctly believes there's still time to save our species. Anna believes the colony exists for the similar reasons neville doesn't, she needs it to be there for hope, he needs it not to be there for hope, so he can stay on his purpose in new york to find a cure. If he believed there were a colony of people just a couple of hundred miles away he might be tempted to leave it all behind and go there to join them. Neville talks the infected near the end probably for the same reasons buildings were covered in plastic: fear, desperation, an irrational attempt to fix a horrific problem.

"That dog was awesome!" 3 minutes after explaining how "stupid" she is. Sin

The biggest sin this movie has is not using the original ending,

I don't love how he is saying to just find another dog after his dies...like come on you can't just see your dad die and then say "tHiS iS nO pRobLem i cAn jUsT fiND aNoThEr oNe"

"enter the room where there is only one means of entrance and exit." that's actually a smart move if he took his gun, force them into a choke point and clear out a metric fuck ton of them as they try to get at you...The sin still stands because they DIDN'T go with that...apparently the people who made this never played the buried map of call of duty zombies.

The biggest sin is the ending. The alt ending shows that the zombie Neville captured and 'cured' earlier on is in fact the Alpha female. The alpha male is only trying to get her back, showing that the zombies are not mindless, but are an organised subspecies of humanity. Furthermore, the fact that he has killed hundreds of their kind makes HIM the monster, not the zombies. A brilliant twist, but sadly we had to go for "Zombies are evil, lets kill them indiscriminately."

You should remove at least 5 sins for the superb heartfelt scene of him killing his dog. Smith knocked that out of the park bro. Comon.

Cinema sins: “just go find another dog” John wick: hold my beer

3:13- he probably has a lab because he built it years before the virus, he was apart of the military after all. 4:32- he could find another dog, but that one dog has meaning to him. He was the only other family he had after his wife and daughter died. 8:01- he probably cuddled him because he was feeling scared and sad cause he knew that his dog was pretty much already dead. Yes, he could've found a less painful, more quicker way to kill him, but it makes sense why he cuddled him then killed him.

When I was younger I ALWAYS cried when the dog died.

"How has he been putting down the rats, with a heavy dictionary?" -That was actually pretty funny

4:35, I think you're underestimating how lonely will smith is..

"Virus somehow destroys Bridges!" Later in the movie: *Haha A-10 go BRTTT*

Should’ve taken off a sin or two for the “Will Smith impersonates Eddie Murphy” bit, it was legitimately funny😂

HE BETTER NOT SAY ANYTHING ABOUT THE SHREK

i like this guys humor and choice of words ths why im subing

How did he not have any other type of emergency defense against the zombies (I’ll just call them that since it’s easier to remember) he had a little more than 3 years to prepare and try to prevent the zombies from getting into his house I also just realized how smart the movie is the creatures are nocturnal so that’s why will smith only goes out during the day and fortifies his house at night

The military blew up the bridges in the beginning

When the dog died, I died.

The shrek scene is my favorite. Also the helicoptor scene in the flashback... This was a great movie one of will smiths top 5

I literally screamed and then laughed at the pet where you said F all jumpscares 4ever

1 sin for calling it a hot water heater. Why would you heat up hot water? *ding*

I always figured the house he was living in was his house from before. The lab in the basement was already there before the outbreak because he is a scientist.

7:46 according to what I could find the average human can hang upside down for 5-10 minutes before death. So either mans has really low blood pressure or he managed to get right side up in his unconscious state assumingely then same way he got from the tub to his bed

That Knicks winning streak looking real glossy after this year

When a human dies in a movie: meh When a dog dies in a movie: you monster!

HE BETTER NOT SAY ANYTHING BAD ABOUT THE DOG

This movie was good and made sense literally until another human came on screen

Sometimes I start these, realize how good the movie was, and watch it again.

I'm adding an extra like 10 sins because the alternate ending of the movie was better than the regular ending

I cried so hard when the dog dies because she looked just like my dog. She has passed away now. Rest in peace Lucy. (I don't mean to upset anyone) She was a lovely dog, born on the same day as me and was the exact age as me, she was like a sister.

I feel like Neville underestimates the zombies a little. When he captures the female for testing, the male shows a clear emotional reaction which I think is just overlooked as a primal rage. They're still a lot more human than he's prepared to acknowledge.

1:01 - That looks like clear tarp. Probably from a construction/remodeling project on that building. 1:24 - He could've moved the cars himself for access.

You can tell this guy has never owned a dog. I’d do anything to save my dog if that happened.

1:39 you add a sin for the dog not barking, then add one because it was barking. Seems a little harsh but ok...

“Dogs aren’t picky” My dog: I’m about to end this dude’s career.

Many sins did this movie make, yet it is stellarly re-watchable. I love it!

I'm pretty sure in the movie they blew up the bridges to prevent the spread of the virus. Am I wrong?

What I dont get is when that girl shows up in his house EATS HIS BACON and pulls a gun on him...like BRO he was saving that bacon

3:55 *sighs in 2022 😔

4:00 Gas is now about $7.00... Sh## has officially hit the fan.

Pretty sure they are supposed to be vampires, not zombies

+1 sin to Jeremy for not adding 400 points to the sin total when the sentence was a nuke power up.

8:19 i love how i cried so fucking hard during this scene and cinema sins is like "mAnEqUiN fLiRtIn"

Glad you left out the scene of cutting himself down from the trap, that fall and landing makes me feel sympathetic pain.

CinemaSins missed one sin... The woman used his bacon... HE WAS SAVING THAT BACON... HE WAS SAVING IT...

They blew the bridges out in an attempt to quarantine

So I'm late on seeing this video but the mannequin scene, from my guess, is to act like social interaction so he doesn't go crazy. Also could be to give him hope of finding/saving whoever is left cuz he sees them and thinks about replacing them with real ppl

Immediate like when I saw he was laughing at the knicks winning streak🤣🤣🤣🤣

Plus 100 sins for changing the original ending

You know...I think that in a couple more movies and you could start saying "will smith working out cliche".

7:09 wait, this guy is an actor at The Onion, right? He's in their older videos, never noticed he played in that movie, nice!

“Viral zombie outbreak somehow destroyed three of the biggest bridges in the world” I think he forgot about the fact that the military shot down those bridges to quarantine off the city. -1 for CinemaSins.

The biggest sin is that they changed the movie so much from the book that the title doesn't even make sense anymore. In the book, Neville goes through the city systematically killing the zombies on purpose until they catch him, at which point he realizes that they fear him, like a boogeyman. He will be their legend forever. They will tell their children, "Be good, stay in bed, or Robert Neville will get you."

lol your sins for his dog was bs...lmao the dog is pt of him...the dog is family...you can't just go around and finding another dog...he had that dog for yrs

Dog dying still breaks my heart

I love this channel and to my recollection have never criticized you guys once. But to the sin where you called Sam stupid, I say: How dare you? Lol